Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

2 Takhts, Sant Samaj hold parallel function

2 Takhts, Sant Samaj hold parallel function

Kulbir Singh · 16 Sep 2004

Sant Samaj held a flop samagam in Amritsar and sangat gave only a “lukewarm” response to their call to celebrate Gurgaddi Diwas against the date suggested by Siri Akal Takhat Sahib. Sant Samaj must be stopped. Sangat needs to rise up against them. Daas, Kulbir Singh 2 Takhts, Sant Samaj hold parallel function Quadricentennial celebrations of installation of Guru Granth Sahib Varinder Walia Tribune News Service Amritsar, September 15 In an apparent attempt to challenge the authority of Akal Takht, two Takhts – Patna Sahib and Hazoor Sahib, a section of Sant Samaj and the All-India Shiromani Akali Dal today held parallel quadricentennial celebrations of installation of Guru Granth Sahib, as per the old Bikrami calendar. The celebrations were held in gross violation of the Nanakshahi calendar, approved by the SGPC and Akal Takht. Mr Mohinderpal Singh Dhillon, general secretary, Takht Patna Sahib gurdwara committee, said the five Sikh high priests, including Giani Iqbal Singh, Jathedar Patna Sahib, participated in the ‘Nagar Kirtan’ today. He claimed that similar celebrations were held at Takht Hazoor Sahib as per the traditional calendar. Earlier, Jathedar Iqbal Singh had alleged that Jathedar Akal Takht had not visited Patna Sahib and Hazoor Sahib to remove discrepancies in the Nanakshahi Jantri (calendar) as per the wishes of local sangat there. However, the ‘parallel function’ organised by Gurmat Sidhantak Sant Samaj, headed by Baba Sarbjot Singh Bedi and the All-India Shiromani Akali Dal evoked lukewarm response from the local Sangat. Unlike the functions organised by the SGPC, Akal Takht and Shiromani Akali Dal here on September 1 when a large number of Sikhs from different parts of world thronged the Golden Temple, there was poor response from different quarters. Giani Joginder Singh Vedanti, Jathedar Akal Takht, described the parallel function as ‘anti-Panthic’. Jathedar Vedanti said that he would invite leaders of Sant Samaj and Panthak Morcha to reach a consensus on the Nanakshahi calendar to avoid any division in the Sikh Panth. However, Baba Sarbjot Singh Bedi, president of Sant Samaj claimed that the actual date for the quadricentennial celebrations fell on September 15. He said the Sant Samaj had constituted a seven-member committee to remove certain discrepancies in the Nanakshahi calendar. However, neither the SGPC nor the Sikh clergy had responded to the request so far. Mr Ravi Inder Singh, president, All-India Shiromani Akali Dal, said the Gurus themselves had celebrated all the occasions as per the Bikrami calendar. He said the solar calendar was also prevalent during the time of the Gurus but they never accepted the same. Mr Ravi Inder Singh criticised Mr Parkash Singh Badal for requesting Dhirmalias for handing over the ‘Adi Granth’. He said Guru Teg Bahadur himself had given back the ‘Bir’ to Dhirmalias and hence there was no point in getting the same back. He also flayed the action of Mr Badal in entering in the ‘rath’ (chariot) along with his ‘patit’ (apostate) security personnel which was meant for Guru Granth Sahib and Sikh high priests. On the denial of ‘siropa’ to the Chief Minister, Mr Ravi Inder Singh said while the person who had taken a bold stand on inter-state water dispute was given step-motherly treatment, the great honour was given to his Haryana counterpart, Mr Om Parkash Chautala, who wanted to grab Punjab’s water by getting the SYL completed. Earlier, the Sant Samaj honoured certain personalities who had made great contribution in the religious field. However, the Sikh high priests did not turn up for getting the ‘siropa’. The ‘granthi who conducted the religious duties at Manji Sahib was given ‘siropa’ on behalf of the Sikh high priests. However, many religious processions taken out from different parts of the state reached here yesterday evening.

Re: 2 Takhts, Sant Samaj hold parallel function

Jarnail Singh Arshi gyani · 18 Sep 2004

Waheguru Ji ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh. YES I totally and unequivocally agree with veer Ji Kulbeer Singh ji that the SANT SAMAJ must be STOPPED ( I call it the KU-SANT samaaj...a MAFIA GANG of corrupt self serving individuals totally anti gurmatt and anti sikhi using Guru granth and Gurbani as "parchaar" to hoodwink gullible sikhs to further thir individaul deras and ammasss proporties...) The "TRUE" sants MUST immeduately disassociate themsleves from this body if anyone is to have any faith in them. IF they dont..... then they are same kurlee they wacchheh THIS STUNT is an attempt ot undermine the authority of the AKAL TAKHAT and nothing else. dass jarnail singh

Re: 2 Takhts, Sant Samaj hold parallel function

gkd · 19 Sep 2004

word

Re: 2 Takhts, Sant Samaj hold parallel function

indy · 19 Sep 2004

vaheguru ji ka khalsa vaheguru ji ki fateh lets see u stop Baba Tharkur Singh ji and the jatha??? , the calandar has divided the Panth not united it?? so carry on dishing the ppl who are keeping to the partaan calander. i get to celebrate twice as much this year. and it all about quality not quantity veerji, yea their is bad sants as their are bad sikhs but we never hear anyone say sikhi is bad or this jatha is bad becus someone did some thing wrong?? any way wasting time replying on here. loads to be done Guru ji is the uk is being taken to halls and clubs but all we do it chat about what devides us and not what will unite us Guru jis Satkar (respect) take care indy

Re: 2 Takhts, Sant Samaj hold parallel function

Singh · 19 Sep 2004

I am not pro or against - in fact - of saint smarj but i find it had to understand why those following bikrami must be stopped. As far as i am aware nankshai calendar was dropped on the panth with no prior consultation or thought process behind it. The only exuse i hear is that it was to break us away from the pandits who set the dates. But what stopps the sikhs setting the dates themselves based on the lunar calendar? Why are we adopting dates based on a western calender which was not even used during the times of the Guru's? Even in the west there was a different calendar which is why some orthodox chritstans celebrate x-mas in Jan. I think we need to stop and think about this whole nankshai calendar issue before adopting it wholesale. I myself celebrated the parkash ustav on Wed.

Re: 2 Takhts, Sant Samaj hold parallel function

Harpartap Singh · 20 Sep 2004

I'm with bhaji, "Singh"... Sarbat Khalsa should be the proper forum for altering such matters IF need be...

Re: 2 Takhts, Sant Samaj hold parallel function

Kulbir Singh · 20 Sep 2004

It took 10 years and consultations with almost every organisation before implementing the Nanakshahi Calender. All gursikhs should read the reasons why it was needed to start this calender. Why don't you want us to get released from the clutches of Brahmin? For dates and Gurpurabs, we were totally dependant on the Brahmins of Kanshi and Hardwar. They used to determine the dates of our Gurpurabs. Sikhi is an independant faith. Why did it have to depend on the Hindus for dates for their Gurpurabs? The Sant Samaj is hell-bent on keeping the Sikhs under the clutches of Hindus. The samagam by Sant Samaj was a total flop. No one attended it. I hope, the Sant Samaj learns from it and stops this nonsense. SGPC needs to take control of Takhat Hazoor Sahib and Takhat Patna Sahib. We must free these Takhats from the control of Hindu-minded Mahants. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: 2 Takhts, Sant Samaj hold parallel function

M. Singh · 20 Sep 2004

Indy and Singh Ji, I also agree with you. Arshi Ji should not say SANT SAMAJ as KU-SANT because AKALI DAL is no more AKALI. Nanak Shahi, calendar to me, seems as en effort as to measure weight by Nanak Shahi kilogram and length by Nanak Shahi meters. I say, We did not need it ( if they say we needed it urgently.) Sikhs used to celebrate 10 th GURU'S BIRTH DAY , on a different day as proposed by new calendar. Guru accepted this practice himself. So this date & measurement (accepted by GURU) becomes more emotional to me, than that proposed by Purewal Ji. No problem, if it comes twice according to Christian Calendar.

Re: 2 Takhts, Sant Samaj hold parallel function

Jagjitsingh · 20 Sep 2004

waheguru ji ke khalsa, waheguru ji ke fateh Pyare jio, my understanding of the nanakshai calenders implementation was to rid the Panth of reliance on Brahminsitic rituals. To help shape its separate indentity with the idealogue it already has. Ritualism in the form of pooranmaishis, etc, would be eradicated. However the compromise that has brought it in, seems to have forgotten this. I still think there is a need for it, it just needs to be further developed according to Gurmat. Rejection of it, seems nothing but the usually, I do not agree scenario, so forget it. Those who disagree with it should present before The Panth reasoned argument, discrepencies, and proposed solutions. That seems a more mature way of dealing with the situation. waheguru ji ke khalsa, waheguru ji ke fateh

Re: 2 Takhts, Sant Samaj hold parallel function

indy · 20 Sep 2004

vaheguru ji ka khalsa vaheguru ji ki fateh a mature way wud have been to ask all jathabandys about it first, take into account Gurmat. the Damdami Taksaals views where not taken on plus if want to break away from bhramins then we sud not support the sgpc and akali dals as they have sold sikhi to the RSS. The Taksaal states its not against a sikh calander its in favour of it but based on Gurmat not on one mans wims. how about the clever ploy to move the Shaheedi of Guru Arjan Dev ji Maharaaj away from the attack on Sri Darbar Sahib so that generations top come will not now that the attacked was planed on at the same time of the attack. sangat it theirs a lot behind the secens plus if we let them have their way they will change Guru ji and will attack the basics off sikhi ie Guruji Dasam Granth etc BEWARE and dnt fall into jatha politics indy

Re: 2 Takhts, Sant Samaj hold parallel function

x · 20 Sep 2004

Kulbir Singh, no samagam is a flop when Guru Granth Sahib Ji is present, is a samagam only a success based on how many people attend or how many do Jaikaraey? Please don't be so childish, this is not a bollywood film ratings issue. Also, you dont agree with Sant Samaj over sooo many issues because you're so panthic, yet you have your own different rehat in complete contradiction to the rehat decided by the akal takhat, isnt this hypocrisy?