Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Accepting Blood

Accepting Blood

Singh jee · 02 Oct 2004

Are we allowed to donate or accept blood? What does Sikhi have to say about it? What if the donor is a smoker or otherwise a sinner of cardinal sins prohibited in Sikhi? Can we accept blood from them, if required?

Re: Accepting Blood

Singh · 02 Oct 2004

donating blood seems fine. Accepting blood seems problematic for me. If someone has been smoking or drinking or eats meat, all that is going to be found in the blood. If they can't touch or cook food for an amritdhari, I doubt they can give blood too. I know that Bhai Joginder Singh Talwara had refused blood transfusions. I'm not sure Sikhi has a firm stand on the issue, but personally I don't think I would want just anybody's blood.

Re: Accepting Blood

_ · 02 Oct 2004

blood donation is an act of paroupkar. It is giving up a part of yourself in order to help someone else. There could be a small kid involved in an incident where he lost a lot of blood. In situations like this blood Donation can save lives. http://www.bloodservices.ca/centreapps/internet/uw_v502_mainengine.nsf/page/Home?OpenDocument

Re: Accepting Blood

gkd · 02 Oct 2004

yah blood contains no sin.......... give at ur hearts content and if in need take it also butu guru kirpa never happen

Re: Accepting Blood

Kesdari · 02 Oct 2004

hmmm, i dont think the blood tansfution wale accept jsut any blood, from anny smoker or druger...

Re: Accepting Blood

Jarnail Singh Arshi Gyani · 03 Oct 2004

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki fateh. IMHO, BLOOD is BLOOD. Why are we so "egotistical" that anyone else ( for example smoker, womaniser, paapi, drugaddict, prostitute etc etc ) would be willing to "accept" an "amrtidharees' vegetarian blood"...some of these people may also very well REJECT that kind of blood.. WE eat VEGETABLES...BUT our BODY in the Infinite Wisdom of WAHEGURU turns all that into BLOOD, MIJH, BONE, MAAS.... so who is to say "my blood" is BETTER/PURER than say the blood of a womaniser/Paapi/smoker/ etc GIVING BLOOD is an act of sacrifice and love. Lets leave it at that. Dont "judge" people by their "blood" ??? dass jarnail singh.

Re: Accepting Blood

Niranjan Singh · 03 Oct 2004

>>> Dont "judge" people by their "blood" ??? Don't you mean to say don't judge BLOOD by their PEOPLE ?

Re: Accepting Blood

Jarnail Singh Arshi Gyani · 03 Oct 2004

niranjan singh ji: YES. ALL blood is RED and except for diseased persons, its composition is the same. That is why only blood of diseased persons is rejected by the blood banks. jarnail singh.

Re: Accepting Blood

... · 04 Oct 2004

How can you say ...give blood but don't accept it if you need it because that is a sin... is your blood that much better than everyone elses?? why are we creating these artificial classes where anybody who has shakked amrit is better than everyone else, and treats all others as being beneath them?? is this how you expect to bring people into the fold of Sikhi?

Re: Accepting Blood

Bundha · 04 Oct 2004

Guys, you seem to be missing the point. It is not that Amritdharis are saying that they are better or they are pure then other people. The issue is that if a person is in maryadha and he/she does not do meat/alcohol/smoking/drugs etc then should that person accept blood from some one who does? This is not that same as saying that an amridhari is egotistical, he/she is just trying to keep within the maryadha set by Guru Ji. If an amridhari cannot eat the jhoot of a meat/alcohol/smoking/druggy person then how can he/she take his blood ? Having said that meat/alcohol/smoking/druggys are a bunch of ****admin cut**** anyway! (only kidding).

Re: Accepting Blood

... · 04 Oct 2004

So then why share the same air as people who do not follow the same maryada as you?? Do you go swimming?? Not allowed any more either, or you might swallow Jootha water?? Where do you draw the line??

Re: Accepting Blood

shotgun · 04 Oct 2004

"..." are you saying that by accepting blood from a person who consumes narcotics, eats maas, commits other sins will help bring people "into the fold of Sikhi"? That's just ridiculous. No one is creating classes. What most individuals would agree on is that blood with Amrit flowing through it should not be polluted with blood that has narcotic's/alcohol/maas flowing through it. Just as clean water doesn't seem right to be contaminated by chemicals and pollutants. That is very simple to understand, just as an gursikh wouldn't consume anything given to them with narcotics/alcohol/maas in it. To understand this you need to understand that Amrit is no ordinary thing, its power is forever with us. There is a story related to this of how a guy went to get peshed for something in an amrit sinchaar, but ended up getting mixed up in the abhilakhee's, the panj were able to tell that this man was given Amrit before without him telling them that he was there for his peshee and not for Amrit as an abhilakhee (I don't remember the exact story, if someone does please share the details with us - I believe it was on this forum a while back). But whether or not blood with Amrit flowing through it is better is up to you to decide.

Re: Accepting Blood

Archie Bunker · 04 Oct 2004

we should not accept blood from......JEWS....NATIVES...CHINESE... .... REPUBLICANS...THE IRISH........PEOPLE WITH BIG ELBOWS.... AND ESPECIALLY LIGHT AND DARK SKINNED BLACKS that's how most of you come off with your "maryada" argument. Archie Bunker

Re: Accepting Blood

Bundha · 06 Oct 2004

People seem to be getting a bit hysterical. Maryadha says that an amritdhari should not take in Alcohol, meat, grugs and smoking. That is the maryadha set down by Guru sahib Ji, whether you like it or not. Alcohol - When a person has drunk himself silly what is it that the police check ? To make absolutely sure they want a BLOOD test. Meat - The nutrients from maas enters the BLOOD stream to reach all parts of the body. Drugs - A fix is injected into the BLOOD stream to get a high. Smoking - The nicotine and all the other crap enters the BLOOD stream. So how can an amridhari take this blood? Stuff the rest of the world, an amditdhari must, and will, stay true to his Guru!

Re: Accepting Blood

sikh · 06 Oct 2004

bundha ji - thats a good point jarnail singh ji please explain would you accept a blood transfusion from an alcoholic? taking amrit and following rehit enables us to clean ourselves physically and mentally, the alcoholic is still an alcoholic! and then we have the issue of joot as well? what we think in our brains is fused right through our bodys! i'm sorry but accoridng to gurmat i think its wrong - but please correct me if i am wrong no point in rehit if we dont even follow certain basic principles?

Re: Accepting Blood

jss · 06 Oct 2004

PEOPLE........ i think it would help resolve this issue if you all just took a BASIC course in human biology.... you would REALIZE that all the alcohol and other unwanted substances are filtered out of the blood by the liver... so the blood donated is okay to use....also....having worked with the Canadian Blood services...they put all collected blood through rigorous testing before it is approved for use... ALSO...even to donate blood you have to fill out a bunch of forms and give them a lot of information...and have an interview....not anyone can just go in and donate blood....

Re: Accepting Blood

Archie Bunker · 06 Oct 2004

just let me know plain and simple...... would you let your mother die or give her the blood transfusion. Archie Bunker

Re: Accepting Blood

Jarnail Singh Arshi Gyani · 07 Oct 2004

Jss has answered the question put to me. The Blood collection Services simply DO NOT accept tainted blood. An alcoholic ( drunk) would not be able to donate blood under any circumstances. Dass jarnail singh.

Re: Accepting Blood

Bundha · 07 Oct 2004

Archie Bunker, that is a moral point and it is left to everyones own consience. But the basic principle is wrong for an amridhari, how far one is willing to take this is up to oneself .