bhai nand lal ji
khaira · 27 Jan 2005
wahe guru ji ka khalsa. wahe guru ji fateh could someone clarify .....was bhai nandlal ji (goya) amritdhari ?
Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton
ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥
khaira · 27 Jan 2005
wahe guru ji ka khalsa. wahe guru ji fateh could someone clarify .....was bhai nandlal ji (goya) amritdhari ?Singh · 27 Jan 2005
Bhai Nand Lal Singh Jee clearly stated that the first rehat of a sikh is khaday battay dee pahul. Hard to imagine that he would write this and then not shuk himself.respect to bhai nand lal singh · 28 Jan 2005
in guru jee's kavi darbar there were three poets with the name "nand". therefore, the most logical conclusion would be that to avoid confusion amongst the three "nand"s, bhai nand lal singh goya multani's name was popularily known as nand lal and not nand singh. it is really impossible that he did not partake of the guru's amrit. he is the author of the Tankhanama for god's sake which is addressed to the khalsa... so that would be more than a little hypocritical. that and his descendants, (or people who claimed to be his descendants at least) all had the name singh and bhai ganda singh's record of bhai nand lal singh's geneolagy bhai sahib's sons were singhs which make it again even more impossible to think he was not a singh. also because bhai nand lal singh jee was famous before he became a sikh, as the tutor of the future bahadur shah, and was obviously the most prominent of the guru's kavi's, that his early pre-amrit name stuck. the same thing is thought to be true of sainapat, another famous kavi of guru gobind singh sahib jee who wrote the first history of the guru, "sri gur shoba" in 1711. one old copy of sri gur shoba has the word's "khalsa vaach" at the begining where "kavi vaach" would usually be and there is evidence his name was actually saina singh. but the early pre-amrit name of sainapati stuck. this is also true of one of the bhai mani's. there were two bhai mani ram's. one is famous as the writer of the guru granth sahib and for being shaheed joint by joint. his name used to be mani ram and later he became mani singh. there was another mani ram, who was a sikh from the time guru harkrishan. it is said that bhai mani ram's five sons came to guru jee and took amrit. unlikely that he didnt as well. what is likely is that to avoid confusion later with the other bhai mani singh, this other great sikh was known by his old name as mani ram. so, most likely bhai nand lal singh's name was kept as bhai nand lal to a. avoid confusion b. because he was famous before he took amrit as well and was better known by his old name c. inaccurate historians that took the name and then jumped to the conclusion that bhai sahib was not amrithdharee. say something enough times and people believe it. this is a huge problem in sikh history, where lack of information leads to wrong conclusions that are later on seen as concrete fact. gurfatehGupt Singh · 28 Jan 2005
Why is he always refered to as Bhai Nand Lal ?asdf · 28 Jan 2005
I think all singhs with Guru Gobind Singh took amrit, just like all sikhs before that took charn-amrit.Anon Singh · 28 Jan 2005
Banda Singh Bahadur is often referred to as Banda Bahadur but multiple Persian accounts make it abundantly clear he took Khanda Da Amrit. This is referenced in Ganda Singhs wonderful book on Banda Singh Bahadur. In the same way just because the name Singh is not usually associated with Bhai Nand Lal does not mean he was not Amritdhari. There is no historical literature explicitly stating he did not take Amrit. BTW whether or not Tanakhahnama can actually be attributed to this same Bhai Nand Lal is a completely different story....Jasvir kaur · 29 Jan 2005
waht is so "ompossible" about it ?? There is a very famous Bhai (DR.)...Lal in Canada..and he is World famous giving lectures on Sikhi/Gurmat..even represents Sikhs at world meets UNO etc..BUT he is NOT an AMRITDHAREE.. 100 years on people may be asking the same question... this Bhai DR..lal..Not an Amrtidahree ?? Impossible ?man .. he wrote..this and that for god's sake ?? He was rep of SIKHS at the UNited Nations..man ?? how cna he be Not an amritdharee ?? Get my point ?? Some people just cnat take the PLUNGE into Amrti..in spite of being so near to it ?? jasvir KaurMkhalsa · 29 Jan 2005
Jee, this is entirely different.. Bhai Nand Lal Jee wrote bani, he wrote rehatnamas, he wrote thankhanamas. To say he wasnt amritdhari would mean he was histories biggest hypocrite. It makes no sense to beleive that he was not amritdhari.Bani khoji · 05 Apr 2005
Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa. Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh! Sangat jee, pls inform of online sources (other than SikhitotheMax) for Bhai Nand Lal Ji's bani. I have previously heard/ read that there's some set apart from the Bhagat Bani included in Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji maharaaj? Please shed some light to this ignorant murakh. Das was also specifically looking for the translation of this shabad (very nicely rendoured by Bhai Daljit Singh Jee: http://www.sikhifm.net/AUDIO/2004/kirtani/daljitsingh/taksal_aagaisamajh.mp3 Looking forward to your ready responses.... Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa. Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh!