Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Canada’s same-sex bill is Punjab’s hot debate now

Canada’s same-sex bill is Punjab’s hot debate now

Indian Express · 27 Jan 2005

Canada’s same-sex bill is Punjab’s hot debate now Akal Takht issues directive, says won’t allow it in gurdwaras, asks Canadian Sikh MPs to oppose move MANRAJ GREWAL CHANDIGARH, JANUARY 27: Given the large number of Punjabis in Canada, it’s only natural that when Canada sneezes, Punjab catches a cold. But this time, it seems to have caught pneumonia. The heated debate over same-sex marriages in Canada only got hotter last week when Jathedar Joginder Singh Vedanti, head priest of the Akal Takht, the highest temporal seat of the Sikhs, issued a stinging edict against it. Coming two days before the visit of Canadian Prime Minister Paul Martin, the harshly-worded directive urged the Sikhs to stop such ‘‘anti-human tendencies,’’ saying ‘‘the idea of same-sex marriages originates from sick minds.’’ The Takht also asked Canada’s six Sikh MPs (four Liberals and two Conservatives) to ‘‘take a stand against same-sex marriage.’’ Little wonder the Premier, who’s been spearheading the legislation, cancelled his visit to the Golden Temple at the last minute even though Canadian Health Minister Ujjal Dosanjh, who was accompanying him, was at pains to blame it on the tsunami. While agreeing that the cancellation could have been a fallout of his edict, Vedanti says he did not time it to coincide with Martin’s visit. ‘‘I issued the directive after reading about the Bill in newspapers. I thought it was my duty to warn the Sikh sangat against any such union. It is unnatural, even birds and animals don’t indulge in it. We will certainly not allow it in gurdwaras.’’ But he is quick to clarify that his message was for the Sikhs, not the Canadian government. P S Sandhu, his personal assistant, says the Takht also received a rash of mails from Sikhs in Canada who were concerned about the Bill, which will be tabled in the country’s Parliament next week. Bibi Jagir Kaur, chief of the SGPC, is more direct in her attack on the legislation. ‘‘People of the same sex should be allowed to live together, but their relationship should not be termed as marriage. And why make a law on it?’’ But not all Sikhs in Canada second her views. Navdeep Singh Bains and Gurbax Singh Malhi, both Liberal MPs, hold diametrically opposite views on it with Malhi saying he will oppose it on grounds of his religion, and Bains choosing to support it. Even Dosanjh has come out openly in its support, while MP Ruby Dhalla has gone on record to say that she will not impose her religious views on anyone. This Monday, Malhi met the jathedar at the Golden Temple and asked him not to give siropas to MPs favouring the Bill. Prof D S Cheema, spokesperson of the Shiromani Akali Dal (B), said all the units of the party here and in Canada will abide by the edict, and work against the legislation. But there are many like Bhai Ashok Singh Bagrian of the Institute of Sikh Studies, who feel it’s a social and ethical issue that should not be given a religious tinge. Calling it a hypothetical issue, Gurpreet Singh, a broadcaster with Radio India in Canada, who is here on vacation, said to date, no such couple had approached any gurdwara. ‘‘The Bill has divided all the parties and communities, Sikhs are no different,’’ he said, adding that even the supreme court, which had asked the government to redefine marriage, had also ruled that no religious institution can be forced to give sanction to such a union. But the Takht may have been alarmed by the same-sex marriage of two Sikh girls in Ajnala, near Amritsar, in December last year. The girls, one a Jat Sikh and the other a Balmiki, had tied the knot at a temple in Delhi, and had refused to annul the marriage despite opposition from their parents who even approached the court. Meanwhile, in Canada, Justice Minister Irwin Cotler announced on Wednesday that draft legislation on same-sex marriage will be introduced next week. He clarified that it will in no way curb religious freedom of those who choose not to perform same-sex ceremonies. But back home, the debate rages on.

Re: Canada’s same-sex bill is Punjab’s hot debate now

Amanpreet Singh Bal · 28 Jan 2005

Read the story in on-line edition of The Globe and Mail at following link; http://www.theglobeandmail.com/servlet/story/RTGAM.20050127.wcomment0128/BNStory/Front/?query=sikh

Re: Canada’s same-sex bill is Punjab’s hot debate now

Jasvir kaur · 29 Jan 2005

AND GUESS WHAT ?? SGPC has given a SIROPA to the Singh ji member of canadian parliament that SUPPORTS this Bill...surprised ?? This si the dirty politics they play....Vedanti CONDEMNS..Bibi jagiro give out SIROPAS..the right hand doesnt know what the left hand is doing..or do they want to know ?? Jasvir Kaur

Re: Canada’s same-sex bill is Punjab’s hot debate now

theorist · 30 Jan 2005

That write up in the GLoe is just terrible. What I do not understand is, how we as sikhs can sit here and try to decide whether we should listen to the hukamnama from Akhal Takht Sahib or not. If you guys do not know yet, Sri Akal Takht Sahib is the CENTR OF TEMPORAL AUTHORITY of all Sikhs, and if many high avastha Singhs in the past did not dare question its hukams, how can we. Just the simple fact that there has been a hukam given to us from there should be enough for us, what do you think we are implying about the power of Akal Takht Sahib when we do not accept its hukam?