Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Singhani Leaders

Singhani Leaders

......................... · 28 Jan 2005

i have been thinking recently all the bad publicity the play beazziti causing to sikh name. Instead of old men can we have women speaking up as chair spokespersons and while we are on that is there any way we can get a female amritdhari proper singhani to become a president of khalistan in exile? rather than old boyz. This would serve as a brilliant rode model. give us good publicity globally where plays and media make out orthodox sikhs are sexist. give women respect. and i also believe women can handle political, and media gruelling a lot better than a guy can. A guys reaction after a wind up would be do what his instinct says but a woman will think more.

Re: Singhani Leaders

Mandeep Singh · 28 Jan 2005

wjkk wjkf Firstly, yes a woman can attain ANY position a man can whether in Sikhi or outside (if there is anything outside sikhi!). However, i will leave myself to be attacked/educated/both, i dont personally believe women can become one of the 5 beloved ones though this is an area i need to get a lot more education on etc... BUT this thread isnt for that! Secondly, I TOTALLY DISAGREE with the fact that women are ANY superior to men when it comes to politics...we are equals and though the way we approach and solve problems may be slightly different they are both advantageous. I wont say i know a lot more than you on this subject, but i know this due being a student (well GAP year!) and studying law....where advocacy is a skill and i honestly at the moment find men to be better at this skill than women whilst women are better at researching etc... then delivering their verdict (the delivery is the weak point!). On the whole, females are equally allowed to go for any office as men are and both are as good as each other. Bhul chuk maaf karni, daas, Mandeep Singh

Re: Singhani Leaders

GKD · 28 Jan 2005

word [%sig%]

Re: Singhani Leaders

Manpreet Kaur · 28 Jan 2005

>>>>and i also believe women can handle political, and media gruelling a lot better than a guy can. A guys reaction after a wind up would be do what his instinct says but a woman will think more.<<<< WHY DO YOU THINK THIS??

Re: Singhani Leaders

Jasvir kaur · 29 Jan 2005

YES we can....Guru Ji gave us the Right.. jasvir kaur

Re: Singhani Leaders

101 · 29 Jan 2005

margaret thatcher, indira gandhi were both nation leaders, but despised by many in their nations. I think more young women should come forward, only young ones, not more pindo ones, there are too many already with men. But above example shows no one is better, we are all same, in good ways and bad ways.

Re: Singhani Leaders

Mandeep Singh · 29 Jan 2005

wjkk wjkf yes guru ji gave u the right (so why ask the question in the first place) and where if anywhere did Guru ji say that you can handle political etc... questioning better than men.....? ANSWER: NO WHERE! But i will still be interested to know WHY you think women can do a better job than men. I have given my reasons as to why i believe men are better advocates (and equally lauded women) and so you must provide yours. Please base your arguments on fact or opinion which is presented intellectually or in a reasoned manner. Bhul chuk maaf karni, daas, Mandeep Singh

Re: Singhani Leaders

......................... · 30 Jan 2005

mandeep singh thank you for your first post but the last seemed a bit direct i am the one who raised the questions here so hands up! i am neither an intelectual, a proffesional debater and just for the record i am a munda MALE. i have no facts, research, posh words, or high mannerismz i am your pendu of penduz no sharmz! sometimes what u wana say doesnt always come out right, going back to my starter post perhaps my question was mistaken or i may have said it wrong. What i was trying to ask was can we have singhanis rising up to positions as spokespersons NOT in the context of are we allowed but as in can we implement something like that? (in event of issues that surround sikhs in media ie beazziti play, gender issues, etc). Gun me for my choice of words bro. this is a good forum, i can ask if i want provided within bounds. Now did i say any of our Guru Jots say that women can handle better than men?NOOOO. Perhaps i should have rephrased that to "i personally believe from my experiences". This is turning into a debate, you do not know what a persons intention is, please dont judge, but i will take my choice of wordings into account first and understand you may have mistaken them. I spoke from what i have seen, but everything i will say some one will come back with their debating skills to take a little stab at it and hence more debating which was not the point of starting this thread. Before i get accused of anything else, i just wanted to see women at top positions for the reasons i stated in my first post. All the men i see representing us get hot headed, and like me try to get the message across but has less effect. I wana see singhanis at the front on tv, not some 50 year old man when they talk about beazzti and covering violations in india it would be far more effective for a singhani to represent us and tell the world what happened post 1984 especially how women were violated. If a man speaks on that gorey now view us as sinister people with things to hide thats why we blocked the play?, white man culture percieve us akin to muslim culture now, but when woman stands up different effect. Its no contest between man and woman its just what i see women can handle things a lot better than men can when it comes to getting grilled. Dont ask me for essays or harvard research you might have a different opinion. Sorry if you took the women part offensive. I got loads of stuff in my brain but its like a washing machine spinning around, when i feel better i will come back right now its sunday let me go eat my gobi pronteh with full fat butter and desi chaa. catch you in a bit.

Re: Singhani Leaders

......................... · 30 Jan 2005

back from my munch! On something else; There is a topic also started on sikhsangat about womens rights , panj, and equality. Singhanis are being told there by one mister singh that females were not given equality but they were however respected and should sit at home and do simran instead of kicking up a fuss every few weeks. Now we have respect for our panth sisters, imagine being a gurl bought up to believe that the religion itself gives them equality, but then some smart sakandar comes along and says you have it all wrong heres why in such a way that it can convince some gurls ( it has already with one) and she will be telling her female sikh friends shes had it wrong all along. It will not take long for other kuris to piece things up; female feotocide, wife killings, treat the brother better than the sister in her most important growing years and so on, celebrate son birth not daughter, lt the boy do anything. Now the sister believe that their religion did not give them equal status. Purleeeeeease Dont tell me thats not the religion i KNOW THAT! I do not want more sisters to leave sikhism in favour for others because we do not put into practice what we say. expecting some more gunning but thats life

Re: Singhani Leaders

Mandeep Singh · 30 Jan 2005

wjkk wjkf I will humbly give my apology...yes my response was a direct one and for that i am wrong. To complement, the post above is very well reasoned but I am now actually thinking that in the context of the Behziti (however you spell it!) play it would have been BETTER to have a young woman give press interviews rather than a 50 year old man as it would have (in this context) proved to the media and viewers that we are modern (?) outgoing, equal etc... and also it would dispel a lot of people's negative perceptions of Sikhi. I think equally the youth (whether male or female) should be given a chance but knowing Indian/Apna etc... culture that isnt likely to happen anytime soon as there is always the elders talking/watering down the youngers (even if they are highly qualified to do so - im not talking only academics here). I think that to highlight the effect of having a 50 yr old man can be seen when the BBC invited Dr Jasdev Singh Rai (Human Rights Activist UK) to talk and give the Sikh side of the argument. No offence to him, but he was crap and made Sikhs seem worse (mumbling and not directly answering ALL questions and responding accordingly to the other interviewer who was advocating free speech etc...! I do apologise. Bhul chuk maaf karni, daas, Mandeep Singh