Western Style Kirtan , Do you like it or not ?
Kulwinder Singh · 30 Jan 2005
Western Style Kirtan , Do you like it or not ? [%sig%]
Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton
ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥
Kulwinder Singh · 30 Jan 2005
Western Style Kirtan , Do you like it or not ? [%sig%]? · 30 Jan 2005
What is Western STyle Kirtan?gurupanthkadaas · 30 Jan 2005
I like many western-style keertanees like Bibi Snatam Kaur Ji and Bibi Waheguru Kaur Ji however it really annoys me when "Yogi Bhajan Mantras" are mixed into keertan. Otherwise the "western-style" keertan is beautiful.Kulwinder Singh · 30 Jan 2005
shabads sang with guitar and Violin in western tunes rather then with harmonium and tabla.sahajdhari · 30 Jan 2005
if your refering to the filmy tunes, then no i dont like itKulwinder Singh · 30 Jan 2005
No Dear Sahajdhari Ji it is not filmy tues. try for your self on the sikhnet look for Mataminder Singh Ji and I recommed kirtan of " Sochai Soch na Hovee" shabad it is mega nice.sahajdhari · 30 Jan 2005
will do veer ji....btw im old skool, raag fanGupt Singh · 31 Jan 2005
I think it's great to see the White/Black/Hispanic Sikhs doing kirtan in whatever style they know best. It's a boosting sight.JGSK · 31 Jan 2005
RAAG VIDIYA FOR LIFE!! :PAmar Singh · 31 Jan 2005
Guru Ji uniquely put almost every single shabad into raag, and in some cases even states the beats to be used. Only Guru Granth Sahi Ji is written to music in this way, with raags which reflect spiritual moods etc. I think people should stick with the set raags defined and added by Guru Ji himself rather than making their own tunes. Our Guru Ji is not short sighted and new that different tunes will exist etc. However Guru Ji specifically set raags which we should respect and follow if we really consider ourselves to the Students (Sikhs) of the Guru. I personally have heard beautiful Gurbani being sung in the most aggressive and wrong styles at numerous Rainsebhai’s by people who wear bana and consider themselves to the Tat Sikhs, but can’t be bothered to do kirtan in the style specified by the Guru.Manpreet Kaur · 31 Jan 2005
I wanna hear some of this?!??!!Redwhiteandblue Kaur · 31 Jan 2005
Kulwinder ji, You mean like "Song of the Khalsa" ? Ahhhhh....not really. I'm not in to the whole "Age of Aquarius" thing at all. I just don't like yoga or yogic things. When I hear something that sounds like a hippie-sing-along...it just doesn't move me, spiritually. I don't mind hearing shabads sung on guitar or when guitar and violin is mixed in with harmonium and tabla. So...for me, it's kind of a balance. I respect Yogi Bhajan and the 3HO community with all my heart, but at the same time, I like my Sikhi without the yoga, please.yo · 31 Jan 2005
is it ok to do yoga for health purposes?Kulwinder Singh · 31 Jan 2005
Well anything you do for health is ok, Why do you feel the need to ask this question ???? · 01 Feb 2005
Undoubtedly one of the best renditions of a Shabad in the western style has to be Snatam Kaur's singing of Aad Guray Nameh. We recently used it for a Sikh camp at our local gurudwara. The effect on the kids was amazing. They all absolutely loved it. Check it out on Sikhnet.erm · 01 Feb 2005
Gurmat Sangeet - Raag Vidiya!!!Hmm... · 01 Feb 2005
Raag is the best. Classic and devotional keertan is good. Western Keertan- it's alright.. my personal favorite would be the one by Dya Singh singing to it.. and his daughters.... They were singing to tu mera pita, tu hai mera mata, tu mera bhandap, tu mera prata.......Kulwinder Singh · 01 Feb 2005
Vir Amar Singh Ji, Yes Rag is good, but most of (nearly 95%) of people doing kirtan from Professionals to non professionals do not do kirtan in Rag. I am not saying we should not make efforts to learn Ragas. But any body who love God can sing his praise in what ever fashion they like, to me if they singing the Shabad in any style I am ready to give a chance to be impressed. I must say Some of the Western Style Shabad Singers have touched my heart and soul. Don't be dismissive of things just because we have our Punjabi way of doing things, which is fine but some time it is the expression of love in one’s presentation is so deep that it just take you with it. My recommendation: Sanatam Kaur and Mataminder Singh Ji http://www.snatamkaur.com/ Check the sikhnet for their Kirtan Open your heart and it will touch you I am 100% sure. and Dear Redwhiteandblue Kaur Yoga could be good for keeping fit altough I don't do it .Redwhiteandblue Kaur · 01 Feb 2005
Dear Kulwinder Singh ji, I don't have a problem with someone doing yoga if they are doing it solely to keep fit. Some practices of yoga to me really seem vedic, though...and just seem as if there is more to it than the physical exercise. I understand that some of the folks in the 3HO sangat have overcome some tremendous personal difficulties, and with many, the tremendous turnaround that they have done...and KEPT...is from the physical discipline for self-control has come by yoga. I have heard others say that yoga gets you in better shape for simran and meditation. But, there are some folks that evangelize yoga, and it seems like every week I see the same thing from at least one person. Someone pushes a yoga class on me. I politely decline. The person's face falls, and then that person doesn't talk to me at all. I mean...puleeeeeze...this is nothing personal. I just don't like yoga! I think exercise is a good thing, I like to swim, myself. But I never felt personally very comfortable with yoga...even from a child, there was something there that really bothered me. And as an adult, I get the same uncomfortable feeling. So, I don't do it, period.anon · 02 Feb 2005
red and white blue kaur, i no this is completely off the topic. but how can u go swimming? do u wear swimming costume or some leotard thing? cos im assuming u dont shave?Singh · 02 Feb 2005
Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fetah Its sad but true that most people nowadays do not use raag, although the first thing Guru Ji tells us in almost every shabad is what raag to use. This is obviously important as if it didn’t matter Guru Ji would not have wasted time specifically setting a raag to each shabad, and placing it at the top for all to see before they even read the main shabad. There are only a hand full of Gurmuckh who live up to this Tat Maryada and respect the Guru’s choice of Raag, after all Guru is the master and we are supposed to be the students and hence should not impose our own ideals over the Guru and change things. The truth is raag is difficult to learn and its far easier to use bhangra tunes and bash a tabla like at most Rainsebais. But than again Sikhi is difficult but making changes to it because its too hard does not justify changing the Guru’s ways. I think at least Gurbani should be sung respectfully which most 3HO do, and not in an excited aggressive way, with mixes and matches from different shabads etc.Anon Singh · 02 Feb 2005
The Prem and Pyaar behind the words is what is most important. If the words are sung without true Love for Satguru then the Keertan starts to lose its meaning and the Keertanee is doing Pakhand. Raag, AKJ, "Normal" Professional, 3HO styles of Keertan can all fall victim to the above. The best style of Keertan is the style of Pyaar.Strange? · 02 Feb 2005
hey anon !!!!!! your right ! "i no this is completely off the topic."Redwhiteandblue Kaur · 02 Feb 2005
>> red and white blue kaur, i no this is completely off the topic. but how can u go swimming? << Oh...ya know...ya jump in one edge of the pool and make a bunch of vigorous motions along with some controlled breathing and it somehow propells you to the other end of the pool. That is swimming LOLOLOL!!! Sorry! I couldn't resist! ;-) I have a set of ordinary, 1-piece women's bathing suits and use silicone racing caps to protect my kes. I have had the same set since before I discovered Sikhi, although one suit is about worn out from the chlorine. I have been a swimmer (not a particularly good swimmer, but still a swimmer) for far longer than I have been a Sikh. No, I do not shave. I am not ashamed of my roop, and I keep my head covered.Singh · 03 Feb 2005
Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fetah "The best style of Keertan is the style of Pyaar." The above is indeed correct, as without pyaar there is no Kirtan (Praise). However it is too simplistic too simply say all you need is pyaar. This is exactly the same excuse used by people who do not want to keep Kesh and take Amrit. Guru Ji has specified certain things and as SIkhs we must follow them and stop making excuses like all you really need is pyaar. If Raag can be overlooked by using the excuse that whats in your heart is important your basically saying that we know more than our Guru and although Guru Ji specifically sets raags etc it is meaningless and can be overlooked. Kistan without pyaar is packhand, but not following Guru Ji's updesh becouse its too difficuilt is falling short of being a SIkh. Wouldn't true pyaar be manifest in living up to what the Guru has specified rather than making excuses and trying to change it. The best Kirtan is done as specified by the Guru ie in Guru Ji's own set raags, AND done with full pyaar. The two go hand in hand. Just like taking Amrit and having pyaar for Sikhi, both are a part of each other and one without the other is not being a complete SIkh. Strange how complain about people changing Sikhi but we ourselves tend to ignore how we overlook the Guru and do things our own way becouse its easier.kuldeep singh · 04 Sep 2005
i like so much. i enjoy the true spirit behind it.Redwhiteandblue Kaur wrote: .