Forum
Sarabloh Fanatic Brahmin of Sikhs ?
Sarabloh Fanatic Brahmin of Sikhs ?
Kulwinder Singh · 30 Jan 2005
People who say they are not going to eat anything which is not cocked or presented in Sarbloh, Do these people think their actions are superior then others, or they have personal passport for Akal Purkh ‘s home ?
Re: Sarabloh Fanatic Brahmin of Sikhs ?
Mkhalsa · 30 Jan 2005
Singh Jee, I dont beleive you have been with this forum long and you most likely have no read up on bibek. I used to think this way, but you need to learn what sarbloh bibek is really about before you can say anything. I suggest you click on the Gurmat link at the top of this site and go to the sarbloh bibek article and read it.
Then you will understand.
It has NOTHING to do with brahminism. This topic has been discussed many many times on akj.org, sikhsangat.com and this website. Please do some searches and do your own research before posting something that will create controversy.
Re: Sarabloh Fanatic Brahmin of Sikhs ?
1 · 30 Jan 2005
like not eating ne thing at all thats not cooked in sarbloh is just hog wash, but trying ur best to eat, and when u can't u can't kinda thing is coo.
cause sarbloh is not gonna increase ur spiruatlity, but it will increase ur iron in ur blood, guru ji wuz all knowing thats why he gave us such tings.
Re: Sarabloh Fanatic Brahmin of Sikhs ?
an opinion · 30 Jan 2005
I, myself, do not follow the sarbloh 'rehit' because, well, I'm not convinced it is an rehit laid down by our Gurus; however, I do respect the right of those who wish to follow the sarbloh protocol.
If they are getting something out of it, why does it bother you? More importantly, even if they aren't getting anything out of it, why should it bother you?
Do your own bhagti and forget about how someone else is doing their bhagti. If you think you get something out of using sarbloh, use it; if you don't think you get anything from it, don't use it. No one is forcing you to do anything Kulwinder Singh.
Kulwinder Singh wrote:
> People who say they are not going to eat anything which is not
> cocked or presented in Sarbloh, Do these people think their
> actions are superior then others, or they have personal
> passport for Akal Purkh ‘s home ?
Re: Sarabloh Fanatic Brahmin of Sikhs ?
JGSK · 31 Jan 2005
WJKKWJKP JI!
Those who keep Bibek are only practising Gursikhi to the fullest. It would not be a problem if everyone was Amritdhari and kept Sarbloh Bibek themselves then these Gursikhs would eat from everyone and anyone. But because some of us do not have the ability to carry out such a regimentd way of life like Guroo Sahib instructed we seem to point the finger and calling these Gursikhs "Fanatics" or "Egotistical" as they think they are better than others. This is not the case, they simply want to follow Rehat as prescribed by Guroo Maharaj.
Who are we to even look at these Guroo Ka Sikhs in a bad light?! Are we so perfect that we are at the level where we can see bad in people??
I dont think so....
WJKKWJKP JI!
Re: Sarabloh Fanatic Brahmin of Sikhs ?
Jarnail Singh Gyani · 31 Jan 2005
so are you suggesting we eat from the hand of every tom dick and harry...macdonalds, kfc, kenny rogers, kazi pir mohammed's take away..i think not..because your other posts are very commonsense.
so lets tackle this Brahmin - superior feeling - better than others..personal passport from Akal Purakh.
A SIKH is a"brahmin" of sorts because He is NIARA from everybody else..so he must have different habits, food, dress etc.
"Superior feeling"..if any Sikh has this it is WRONG and Sinful because it breeds HAUMAII..
Same goes for better than others,..... GURU NANAK says Hum NAHIN Changeeh BURA NAHIN koi.....also Neechaan under neech jaat....Hum Kookar tere Darbar....etc etc so if we "feel" we are "better" than others in any way just for haumaii's sake then we contradict Gurbani right there fair and square.
Passport from Akal Purakh....GURU GOBIND SINGH JI gave this Passport to every Khalsa Ji that Chhaks Amrit of the Punj...YES this Passport is Straight for Akal Purakh and is PERSONAL. The VISA is of course the REHAT you keep..IF you Chaak Amrit you have it and I also have it.
BTW I am NO FANATIC..of any sort...I am NOT AKJ, I am NOT Damdami taksaal ( or any other taksaal for that matter)...and if you think the AKJ, DT, other Taksaals are Fanatics..you are dead wrong too...they just do things differently.....from you and me..BUT there are FANATICS out there..you will recognise them from the FLAMES coming out of their mouths... ..they think they have a passport to Brahmgian...given them by their Baba Ji. These people cleverly "mix and match" outfits....like they wont eat MEAT ( AKJ)..because DT supports eating non-hallal meat as per srm, on Mool Mantar they take it LONGer to Nanak Hosee Bhee Sach (DT ) becasue AKJ support MOOlmantar up to Gurparsaad..they beleive in the all powerful BABAS/SANTS (DT) becasue again AKJ doesnt go that far on Babas..this mix and match works perfectly and without embarassment ( One baba Ji patron says Moolmantar is up to Gurparsaad, another Baba Ji patron says NO it is up to Nanak hosee bhee sach...they Take BOTH patrons..wise..very wise..butter ones bread on BOTH sides...
Jarnail Singh....
NOTE: this is why mere mention of my name alone causes a frenzy of hate mails, name calling, accusations and what not causing Admin to close off the topic prematurely... OTHER sites controlled by these people just take the easy way out... I get a notice saying..."Your Password is unavilable/invalid..please supply a new one" type of thing to me..so i know immedautely MY PASSPORT is NOT VALID for travelling to that Site. I NEVER visit them again...so to them I may be "fanatic" as well.
Re: Sarabloh Fanatic Brahmin of Sikhs ?
volvic · 31 Jan 2005
Jarnail Singh Gyani wrote:
NOTE: this is why mere mention of my name alone causes a frenzy of hate mails, name calling, accusations and what not causing Admin to close off the topic prematurely... OTHER sites controlled by these people just take the easy way out... I get a notice saying..."Your Password is unavilable/invalid..please supply a new one" type of thing to me..so i know immedautely MY PASSPORT is NOT VALID for travelling to that Site. I NEVER visit them again...so to them I may be "fanatic" as well.
--
Erm, just so you know, there are some sites that I visit on a regualar basis and they require that passwords are changed every so often.. Its simply a case of security. Its a shame that you should stop visiting forums for reasons that 'may' not be valid.
[%sig%]
Re: Sarabloh Fanatic Brahmin of Sikhs ?
Manpreet Kaur · 31 Jan 2005
what does NIARA mean? different?
Re: Sarabloh Fanatic Brahmin of Sikhs ?
BirRaas Singh · 31 Jan 2005
niara means distinct
Re: Sarabloh Fanatic Brahmin of Sikhs ?
singhnee · 31 Jan 2005
check these links.
Author: Singh
Date: 09-09-04 18:18
here are some threads on sarbloh bibek:
http://www.tapoban.org/phorum/read.php?f=1&i=9715&t=9290#reply_9715 (some really good tips in this one - 4th post)
http://www.tapoban.org/phorum/read.php?f=1&i=9162&t=9035#reply_9162 (rehitnamas on bibek)
http://www.tapoban.org/phorum/read.php?f=1&i=7544&t=7368#reply_7544 (more tips - sarbloh bibek practically)
http://www.tapoban.org/phorum/read.php?f=1&i=4455&t=4220#reply_4455 (purpose of bibek thread)
http://www.tapoban.org/phorum/read.php?f=1&i=1236&t=1154#reply_1236
http://www.tapoban.org/phorum/read.php?f=1&i=825&t=433#reply_82 (is it difficult to keep bibek?... quote from this thread: If you live in Toronto then Tapoban Sahib can help you get sarabloh baattay and other stuff. Visit Tapoban Sahib any Sunday morning and get baattay from there. There is a Chinese store on Spadina Road in Toronto where you can get sarabloh frypans, kaRaahees, kaRchhees and khurchanay at good price. If you are from BC then you can get all sarabloh bartan from khalsa school. )
http://www.tapoban.org/phorum/read.php?f=1&i=12833&t=12709#reply_12833
http://www.tapoban.org/phorum/read.php?f=1&i=12028&t=11188#reply_12028
http://www.tapoban.org/phorum/read.php?f=1&i=11691&t=11572#reply_11691
http://www.tapoban.org/phorum/read.php?f=1&i=10779&t=10731#reply_10779
http://www.tapoban.org/phorum/read.php?f=1&i=10680&t=9884#reply_10680
that's all i found just by typing in "bibek"... as you can see this has been discussed a gazillion times before :) make sure you read the "really good tips" ones
Re: Sarabloh Fanatic Brahmin of Sikhs ?
Redwhiteandblue Kaur · 31 Jan 2005
If I may humbly paraphrase, please point my feet to a kitchen where God is not there.
Re: Sarabloh Fanatic Brahmin of Sikhs ?
Kulbir Singh · 31 Jan 2005
-------------
If I may humbly paraphrase, please point my feet to a kitchen where God is not there.
--------------
Bhain jeeo, I know where you are taking us but there is a huge difference between what Siri Guru Nanak Dev jee did at Mecca and what you are talking about.
For a gursikh, the ultimate truth is what is written in Gurbani and no Sikh can question the hukams of Gurbani. Please ponder upon the following pankiti:
Kabir, Santan kee jhungiyaa bhalee, bhath kushthee gaahon||
Aag lagai tis dhaulhar, jih naahi Har ko Naayon||
(O Kabir, blessed is the small hut of Gursikhs who japp Naam and cursed is the whole village of a person who does not japp Naam (recite Naam). May such palaces burn in which Naam is not japped (recited).)
There are several such pankities in Gurbani that prove that without bhagtee (reciting Naam) homes are like haunted homes. Only such homes where Naam is japped and Gurbani is recited are worthy of living.
There may be God in every kitchen but every rasoyee does not have Naam. Without the presence of Naam no rasoyee (kitchen) can be worthy of making food for Gursikhs. If we use the argument that every kitchen has God in there so we should eat from there, then one can say that since God is present in tobacco too, therefore, we should be allowed to consume tobacco too.
Daas,
Kulbir Singh
Re: Sarabloh Fanatic Brahmin of Sikhs ?
Kulbir Singh · 31 Jan 2005
--------------
People who say they are not going to eat anything which is not cocked or presented in Sarbloh, Do these people think their actions are superior then others, or they have personal passport for Akal Purkh ‘s home
------------
Veer jeeo, we (Sarblohis) don’t claim to have any passport to Akal Purakh, nor do we claim to be superior to others because of this rehit. The reason why we eat from Sarbloh is not because we consider ourselves superior to others but because we consider it Guru Sahib’s rehit to eat food cooked in Sarbloh. We follow the Sarbloh Rehit only and only because it is Guru Sahib’s rehit.
A gursikh always strives to stay as dust of everyone. There is no question of considering oneself superior to others.
As for Brahmanism, a Gursikh who follows the rehit of Guru Sahib and japps Naam as per hukam of Guru Sahib is the real Brahmin. Such person who controls his mind through Naam is the real Pandit. The fake Brahmins and Pandits who consider themselves so because they took birth in a so-called Brahmin caste (The Sharmas, Misras, Trivedis, Mukerjees, Benerjees etc) are destinedc to go to hell. A Sikh is the true Brahmin because he japps Naam and does the karma required to qualify to be a Brahmin.
A Sikh alone is the true Kshatriya because he alone fights while japping Naam and does only righteous fight. Everyday in the morning he or she battles the evil forces of 5 Bikaars. Such Gursikh is the true Kshatriyaas. The fake Kshatriyaas (Rajputs, Thakurs etc) who think they are Kshatriyaas just because they were born into these castes are destined to waste their life.
A Gursikh is the true Vaish (the third caste division). They alone do the true trade. They are the real traders or merchants. They trade Naam for their swaas. Their investment or the principal that they bring along with them (swaas) when coming to this world yields them so much profit that they can not only be successful merchants themselves but can also help numerous others reap benefits from their earnings. The fake Vaishs (Vermas, baniyaas, Kraars etc) who waste their life in doing only worldly trade are destined to get crushed by Jammdoots of Dharam Rai.
A true Gursikh alone is the true Dalit or shudra. The fake Dalits serve the world as they are forced such life but the true Dalit – a Gursikh too serves the world but because of his or her passion for humanity. Bhagat Pooran Singh jee used to clean human excretion (waste) of many patients under his care. He did the work destined for Shudras but he did it out of love for humanity and ultimately for Guru Sahib. The true Dalit – Gursikh of Guru Nanak Dev jee cleans his mind everyday with the help of Naam and Gurbani. He not only cleans his own heart but also cleans numerous other gursikhs who come in contact with him. Above all such Dalit Gursikh does not charge any money for this neither does he complain for cleaning other people’s garbage of hearts as fake Dalits do when they are forced by destiny to do demeaning work by the society.
So Veer Kulwinder Singh jee, yes we are Brahmins but we are Brahmins by Karma and not by birth. Gurbani has several references to this:
SO PANDIT, JO MANN PARBODHAY||
RAAM NAAM AATAM MEH SODHAY||
(He alone is the true Pandit, who keeps his mind in check. He uses Vaheguru Naam to keep his heart pure).
KAHO KABIR, JO BRAHM BICHAARAE||
SO BRAHMIN KAHEEYAT HAI HAMAARAY||
(Siri Kabir jee says that such person who ponders on Brahm i.e. Japps Vaheguru is the true Brahmin in his eyes).
BRAHM BINDAY, SO BRAHMIN KAHEEYE, ANDIN HAR LIV LAAYE||
(So is the true Brahmin, one who understand Vaheguru and day-night meditates on his Naam).
Daas,
Kulbir Singh
Re: Sarabloh Fanatic Brahmin of Sikhs ?
Redwhiteandblue Kaur · 31 Jan 2005
Bhai Kulbir Singh ji,
Thank you so much for responding and for your explanation.
I am still struggling with this though.
I don't see what tobacco has to do with anything, because Gurbani is very explicit about tobacco.
I accept that no Gursikh can question the hukams of Gurbani. And I accept without question what St. Kabir says about homes with and without bhagtee. It is our duty to recite Naam in our homes.
Now, here is where my knowledge of Gurbani may stumble. Please correct me.
In Sikhi, we live our life without attachment and without ritual.
I do not believe in any sort of attachment or sanctification to a kitchen, or to the percentage of elemental iron in its cookware.
I find it to be very unlikely that someone that snubs another's cooking strictly because of the iron content is a person that follows a ritual that means every single thing is cooked in iron.
No iron means:
- no dairy - no milk, no yogurt, no cheese, no cream (dairy products are heat-pasturized with equipment that is not iron)
- no microwaves (you can't any kind of metal in a microwave)
- no teakettles or heating of water of any kind except in an iron pot
- no steel cookware (88% iron is not enough iron)
- no non-stick cookware
- no pizza, or any kind of baked foods, unless the foods were specifically baked in iron
- no open-fire cooking, because that is cooking in fire, not in iron
- no commercially prepared foods of any kind...packaged or restaurant...unless such preparation was proven to only be with iron
- no commercially prepared drinks of any kind...packaged or restaurant...unless such preparation was proven to only be with iron.
Am I correct? Or wrong? I'm not trying to flame, just trying to learn.
Re: Sarabloh Fanatic Brahmin of Sikhs ?
ms · 31 Jan 2005
i believe in 1 with his point how Guru Jee gave us the idea of sarbloh for health purposes to get more iron and i've believed that all my life, but one think 1 jee where you are wrong is you never should joke about the rehit because sarbloh is part of rehit...everyone should take it seriously
Re: Sarabloh Fanatic Brahmin of Sikhs ?
singhnee · 31 Jan 2005
Waheguru jee kaa khalsa!
Waheguru jee kee fateh!
Bhainjee, Redwhiteandblue Kaur jee: food you have mentioned above plus all other you forgot to mention are possible to cook, bake and made at home using sarabloh utencils and trays etc. You name any kind of food, sweet dishes or snacks which are available in stores or restaurants, could be prepared in our own kitchen in sarabloh except cereals for which I don't have equipment and recipes yet.
In Indian Restourants they use same karchies for non-veg and veg foods. A partner/worker which was my mom's cousin gave us first hand information about that. After that our family stoped eating and buying food(sweets, smossas etc.) from outside even we were not aware of bibek at that time. You can imagine about other non- Indian Restaurants or bakeries. They don't even have concept of jooth. We think in bakeries, they are very strict about washing workers hands etc but all workers dont follow all rules we all know that. How can we eat food which is touched by smokers, meat eaters, drugies and many others who do every thing against gurmat. With same hands they scratch their heads and other parts of body which is not even washed daily, they clean their nose and with same hands they touch food items at restaurants and bakeries.
All rehats of Guru Sahib jee have worldly and spirtual meanings. It's easy to explain and understand worldly meanings but spirtual benifits are felt only when we practice those rehats otherwise who wants to give themselves hard time by keeping bibek, sarabloh and wearing kakaars? We follow rehat and get something SPECIAL in return.
Rest in next gotta go now.
Bhul chuk dee muaafi jee.
Re: Sarabloh Fanatic Brahmin of Sikhs ?
Anon Singh · 31 Jan 2005
If you believe it to be absolutely 100% Gurmat to eat fizzy drinks and pizza then could you visualise Sri Guru Gobind Singh Ji Maharaj tucking into a Pizza Hut pizza or sipping Fanta Fruit Twist?
We do Bibek (discerning wisdom/discrimination) between good and bad all the time. We see the mouldy fruit and the good fruit, we reject the mouldy fruit because it is not good for our physical state (mouldy fruit will make you ill). We see innappropriate material on TV and we change the channel (or if we are really strict we do not watch TV at all).
Same way Bibek is for spiritual state. Not just the Bibek of the mouth - Bibek of ears is not listening to slander, etc.
Bani tells us if we keep bad Sangat all the time then it will have an effect on us. There is no "scientific" explanation for it. If we keep the company of a Pakhandhee even if he does not outwardly appear bad, then our Sikhi will be affected. If we keep the company of a Gurmukh 24/7 our Sikhi is improved. There is no scientific basis to this. So why do we always seek Sadh Sangat?
When you take amrit Naam is put into the water by the Panj Pyare. Amrit is not just water and sugar. It is not just a ritual but when you take Amrit you are drinking the elixir of immortal life. This is because the Naam has been implanted in the water by the recitation of the Amrit Bani by the Panj.
In the same way doing heavy simran and Paath whilst preparing food will do exactly the same thing. Gurmat principles can be applied to everything. In old Rehatnamas it says to keep Japping Naam when cooking the Langar, and it also gives stringent guidelines for what a Singh should do in his kitchen. If you want quotes I Will get them for you. I know offhand that Bhai Daya Singh mentions Sarbloh Bibek and Bhai Nand Lal mentions Satkaar for Sarbloh. I also know Macauliffe made a special mention of Sarbloh Bibek with respect to Hajur Sahib Maryada and possibly Cunningham but I am not at all sure about the last one.
In those days Bibek was easy because all Singhs would stick together and all batte were Sarbloh. Nowadays because Bibek becomes so much harder in modern environment we make excuses of how its not a real Rehat and we don't need to follow it just because it doesnt suit us. Just like people wear tiny karas, tiny kachere, because it doesnt "suit them", or Singhnian remove facial hair because it is "too difficult" in the West.
Sikhism is not a religion to change to suit you. You have to change for Sikhi. You do not take Amrit, Amrit takes you!
I personally am unable to get my head around the fact that people cannot see the difference spiritually between a simple food of roti and daal, prepared lovingly by a Gurmukh who has been japping naam throughout its preparation, to a McDonalds meal where the gora making it was krodhi, kaami and full of negative energy.
Many such as myself are not Bibeki but I accept it as a weakness in myself and do not take to questioning the Rehat because I do not myself follow it.
Re: Sarabloh Fanatic Brahmin of Sikhs ?
Redwhiteandblue Kaur · 31 Jan 2005
Anon Singh...quotes would be welcome and much appreciated.
Daas,
RWBK
Re: Sarabloh Fanatic Brahmin of Sikhs ?
Kulwinder Singh · 31 Jan 2005
Dear MKhalsa Ji,
First thing I did not say it is wrong to use sarbloh, I said being a Fanatic about it does raise questions.
And yes it has Brahmin element in it I will explain below.
For Dear 1 Ji
Second thing: Eating in sarbloh can increase iron in body ?
Strange !
====================================================
Between the lines information is only for Iron deficiency it is for help to be honest
not to have dig at anybody
Have a look at the site
http://www.irondeficiency.org/
Which states: some help for people who have some deficiency of iron.
Another site
http://www.mothernature.com/Library/Ency/Index.cfm/id/1225002
This is just for helping purpose.
===================================================
There is nothing wrong in following sarbloh usage if it helps you what is wrong is to think non sarbloh user are some how bit less in sikhi then those who follow it.
Dear an Opinion Ji
You are saying why should it bother me ?
It bothers me because it create a divisions in the sikhi I love All Guru Sikhs those who follow sarbloh or who do not follow sarbloh but I want all of them to be close like one Deshmesh Pita Ji’s family so we can eat together come and go to each other house without any thing making difficult which should not be their. But it does make difficult.
Dear JGSK
You have written
“Those who keep Bibek are only practising Gursikhi to the fullest. It would not be a problem if everyone was Amritdhari and kept Sarbloh Bibek themselves then these Gursikhs would eat from everyone and anyone.”
If I remember history, then Even Guru Gobind Singh Ji went to Chamkur Di Gari, I am not sure that the owner of the Chamkur di Gari was Amritdhari Sikh, and Guru Ji must had his food made with love and affection, Guru Gobind Singh Ji also Stayed in Muslims Shardalu’s homes during his life time, and he must had eaten food prepared (of course Vegetarian ) from these families.
Pir Budhu Saha gave his sons to Guru ji as soldiers to fight against Cruel Muslim Rulers, you think if Guru Ji passed his house and he had offered something Suitable to Guru Ji to eat then Guru Ji would have objected.
Also the bit “ practising Gursikhi to the fullest “
I think if you go back to the history then every guru Sikh should have a horse too.
What you think of that ?
I am not saying that any body is bad for having sarbloh I feel like broken record but It has to be said, I only have issue where sarbloh become a barrier between relationships and create obstruction, Guru Ji has made us free of all the JanJal (stupid rituals), Guru Love when we have Eka (unity), things which obstruct for the hell of it does bother me.
Dear Jarnail Singh Ji ,
First of all I love you for your contribution to the form, I am new but Salute to your contribution and I respect all Sikh . we can have positive discussion and differences but still love each other. yes you got It I feel bad to be in disagreement with somebody like you and S.Kulbir Singh Ji.
Dear Jarnail Singh Ji you say
“so are you suggesting we eat from the hand of every tom dick and Harry “ Well Tom dick and Harry was fine for Guru Nanak as he always loved, talked and eat with common people who are not necessarily Sikhs.
You also say “A SIKH is a"brahmin" of sorts because He is NIARA from everybody else..so he must have different habits, food, dress etc.”
I think it is Niara mean loveable different( very lovingly every body want to associate with ) rather then different ( hell of difference between two). As Lungar is Niara, loved by everybody but very different then anything seen anywhere in the world apart from Sikh temple.
Kirpan is Niaree ( I am not saying Talwar) as Kirpan is symbol of Kirpa ( Kindness ) rather then Talwar which is symbol of power ( could be negative or positive ).
I can carry on giving examples,
You are saying “Passport from Akal Purakh” and referring to Amrit and Rehat which I agree but we was debating on sarbloh.
You also saying “if you think the AKJ, DT, other Taksaals are Fanatics.”
My God I never said any thing like that, how come whole of some Jatha is Fanatic,
Contary to you I believe I belong to all the Jathes as they belong to my real father Deshmesh Pita Ji. And I equally love them all.
Dear Jarnail Singh Ji Idea of Sikhi is not only for Just Punjabis, It is for the whole world for people who live in Alska, to Desert of Africa, from South American Natives who live in Jungles to Nasa Scientist, from Arab to Hindustani, from Chinese to German and Even for the intelligent life which we do not even know yet.
So try to bring people together like Guru Nanak and Guru Gobind Singh Ji did making uninion of humanity for the betterment of humanity is the real goal of Sikhism as it indeed believe in the
Dear Kulbir Singh Ji
I am no way near to anybody’s nam Kami but have to say what I feel and understand. No disrespect to you or any other gurusikh or human being.
You are saying “without bhagtee (reciting Naam) homes are like haunted homes “ I think in Bani when Guru Ji Says home what he mean is human body.
You also saying “here may be God in every kitchen but every rasoyee does not have Naam. Without the presence of Naam no rasoyee (kitchen) can be worthy of making food for Gursikhs. If we use the argument that every kitchen has God in there so we should eat from there, then one can say that since God is present in tobacco too, therefore, we should be allowed to consume tobacco too.”
What kind of argument is that ? I would not dream of you presenting this kind of argument, you must have been in hurry to write this. Not well thought at all so I am going to ignore this.
You say “We follow the Sarbloh Rehit only and only because it is Guru Sahib’s rehit. “
how about having a horse too. That was very crucial to puratan singhs ?
you also saying “As for Brahmanism, a Gursikh who follows the rehit of Guru Sahib and japps Naam as per hukam of Guru Sahib is the real Brahmin.”
I my opinion wrong, Real Brahmin is the one who think about the god and analysis him and try to understand his hukam rather then just being stuck to words as words.
Even you have mentioned
KAHO KABIR, JO BRAHM BICHAARAE||
SO BRAHMIN KAHEEYAT HAI HAMAARAY||
Amaze me how come you still have these opinions!
You also saying “yes we are Brahmins but we are Brahmins by Karma”
Guru Nanak say
Dharm Karm Pakand Jo Disha Tin Jam Jagai lootay!
It is Brhaminwad of Suuch and Juudth, That I am not eating anything which is not prepared in the pure kitchen in sarbloh.
Think my dear Khalsa Ji do we reflect similarities with Brahmin that I am not going to eat hear or their for the reason of purity.
What is purity, earning with truthfulness and working for what you earn and being good law obeying citizen of Good contries is purity. Being helpful is purity, being humble is purity, standing against oppression is purity.
Accepting others as equal is purity.
eaek vasath boojhehi thaa hovehi paak ||
bin boojhae thoo(n) sadhaa naapaak ||4||
The purity which is just belong to some crockery is purity you think that is how Guru Gobind Singh Ji think ?
Sound very strange to me.
Dear Ms Ji
just look up at sites dealing with iron deficiency as mentioned above.
Above all my point was no way to say that I dislike or criticise the people who use sarbloh for themselves it is for those who think it is some how very crucial to sikhi and believe that those who do not practice sarbloh some how bit lacking in sikhi, inferior in status, do not really understand sikhi, do not follow the rehat properly.
To me Guru Gobind Singh Ji gave one Amrit to all so we can be all Sings and Kaurs and belong to one family if a member of family have his kitten separate from the others then it does not reflect the unity specially when this barriers are just rituals and a Sikh should be well aware of what is right and what is ritual.
My intention is to bring everybody close in love as we all love our Guru that is the strongest glue in the known and unknown world.
Thanks
Forgive me if I have offended anybody that is my last intention
Bhul Chuk Maf Ji.
Re: Sarabloh Fanatic Brahmin of Sikhs ?
Jasvir kaur · 31 Jan 2005
waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh.
In this "department" i am as "naive" as the next in line....so sorry if i cant write much.....i mean my naam kamaii is not that high, my sarb loh rehat is a beginner stage..and my gurbani quotes are also a little skimpy..
BUT i THANK VEER KULWINDER SINGH for bringing this up...why ? Because I LEARNT so much...from Kulbir Singh to Mkhalsa.....to Redwhite and blue Kaur Bhen Ji.
This effectively debunks the call by some to "go read up past forum topics...enough has been said....etc etc. imho we must keep on asking ( even if it has been asked a thousand times before) because the same question may evoke some new answers, some new poster may have something to contribute ( i have read all the older messages...but somehow it is not exciting reading old messages as reading new responses)
Thank You all for a really refreshing read. Keep those posts coming..everybody gets a fair chance on this forum. As a beginner i also enjoy kulwinder singh's posts.
Jasvir Kaur.
NB. please note that in a previous message i had done some cut and paste from "Jxxxxxx Sxxxx" post from another Forum to explain a point but due to some computer glitch only the name of the writer appeared and a part of my message was left out. Sorry if this caused a Tsunami of sorts. Beleive me something perfectly innocent.. Will definitley be more careful next time ( didnt realise some people are so super sensitive Bhul Chuk maaf)
Re: Sarabloh Fanatic Brahmin of Sikhs ?
Mkhalsa · 31 Jan 2005
Kulwinder singh..
>>There is nothing wrong in following sarbloh usage if it helps you what is wrong is to think non sarbloh user are some how bit less in sikhi then those who follow it.<<
nobody said this at all! where did you get this from. In fact I am much worse than you. look at my weak stomach, it cannot handle eating out or even eating foods from cans. What a bad person I am that is so sensitive to who cooks food and how it is prepared. Shame on me. I wish I had such strength to endure negative energy and foods that could harm my mind.
(The above is not meant to be sarcastic, but serious).
I have said this many times before. Again, kulwinder singh, read past posts...
>>>It bothers me because it create a divisions in the sikhi I love All Guru Sikhs those who follow sarbloh or who do not follow sarbloh but I want all of them to be close like one Deshmesh Pita Ji’s family so we can eat together come and go to each other house without any thing making difficult which should not be their. But it does make difficult.<<<
Veer jee, again, it is you who make it difficult. If all gursikhs followed guru sahibs rehat (Again I can tell you did not read the article in the gurmat section as requested) what problem would there be? unfortunately so many people have forgotten rehat or ridicule rehat that they no longer care for singhs or rehat and make it difficult for those who do.
I never ask for special treatment, if someone has made food, I just tell them I am not hungry for their food or that I have eaten or that I have food at home etc. I know for a fact I have never hurt anyone's feelings on this matter and all gursikhs in such position should be careful not to. I would much rather go hungry though.
>>>If I remember history, then Even Guru Gobind Singh Ji went to Chamkur Di Gari, I am not sure that the owner of the Chamkur di Gari was Amritdhari Sikh, and Guru Ji must had his food made with love and affection, Guru Gobind Singh Ji also Stayed in Muslims Shardalu’s homes during his life time, and he must had eaten food prepared (of course Vegetarian ) from these families.
Pir Budhu Saha gave his sons to Guru ji as soldiers to fight against Cruel Muslim Rulers, you think if Guru Ji passed his house and he had offered something Suitable to Guru Ji to eat then Guru Ji would have objected.<<<
There is more than enough proof that Guru Gobind Singh Jee and indeed all of the Guru sahibs followed bibek. There is not one documented case that you can show that proves guru sahib did not follow bibek. In fact, I know a Singh that has a peice of Guru Hargobind Sahibs Karahee. Also, How do you explain signs that are at many old gurudwara sahibs saying that only amritdharis can do seva in the kitchen? How do you explain that all of the pots and pans etc at old gurudwaras are sarbloh?
Again, Guru Nanak Sahib Jee started bibek. Do you know the Sakhi of malik bhago? Guru sahib showed that eating food of sakats or those who have no faith in god or do not follow any true path is like drinking blood or eating poison, but the food of gurmukhs (guru sahibs sikh) is the true food and is as sweet as milk. Guru sahib himself has given us so many examples as to why food bibek (merely one of many forms of bibek) is important.
>>I think if you go back to the history then every guru Sikh should have a horse too. <<<
Actually, there are a few rehatnamas that say every gursikh must know how to ride a horse. I do, do you? I am a bit rusty I will admit.
Anyway, I think today, motorcycles are a good equivalent, I have yet to learn.
>>>>I only have issue where sarbloh become a barrier between relationships and create obstruction,<<<<
Jee, open up your mind!!!!!!!
Sarbloh or bibek have NEVER been a barrier for me, in fact it has been a way for me to share very intimate moments with other gursikhs. I have a lot of family that is mona, radhasoami or hindu. Again, It has never been a barrier, I still love my family as my family and have never had any problems.
>>>Guru Ji has made us free of all the JanJal (stupid rituals), <<<
Yes he has, if you can keep sarbloh with full devotion (while keeping strict amritvela) for a month and tell me afterwards it is a stupid ritual, I will touch your feet. You do not know the power of sarbloh nor have you witnessed the power of sarbloh, how can you call it a stupid ritual? why do you think guru sahib chose to create a marayda that AMRIT must be made in sarbloh and NEVER anything else? that DEGH must be made in SARBLOH and nothing else, and LANGAR must be made in sarbloh and nothing else.
There is a special quality of sarbloh that no other material has. I have kind of explored some scientific reasons on my website: http://www.mkhalsa.com (under articles). If you are truly here to learn, I suggest you read that and read the articles in the gurmat section of this website (Tapoban.org).
>>Well Tom dick and Harry was fine for Guru Nanak as he always loved, talked and eat with common people who are not necessarily Sikhs.<<
again prove to me that guru nanak sahib jee ever ate from any non sikhs? you cant. you are mistaken here bhai sahib. There is no historical evidence. We are all brainwashed into this modernist interpretation of sikhi where kaur=princess and women wear chunnis and we all do bhangra or something, thats not sikhi, I suggest you restudy your history with more scrutiny.
>>I think in Bani when Guru Ji Says home what he mean is human body.<<
again, modernist interpretations. Guru sahib didnt write some flowery metaphor filled stuff. He wrote gurbani with straightforward language for the masses. if it says HOME, it means HOME! DUH!!!!
>>It is Brhaminwad of Suuch and Juudth, That I am not eating anything which is not prepared in the pure kitchen in sarbloh. <<
Again, you are entirely mistaken and prove that you know nothing of proper rehats or history.
all panj pyare tell us to keep sucha. you know rehatnamas tell us that even to drink water given to us by a smoker is like drinking alcohol? keeping sucham is important as we do not get "bad vibes" from other peoples bad karms. Even gorae have it right when they say, you are what you eat.
Brahminvaad has to do with castes and birth, whereas ANYONE can become a gursikh and gain guru sahibs priveledge. Are you next going to tell me its brahminvad that the panj pyare need to be amritdhari? that is a useless ritual as well right, somehow they get this special position. NO! they EARN IT. Just as guru sahib tell us in this life we must earn our gursikhi. It is not given to us on a platter. Unlike brahmins who are given it at birth.
Do you understand the difference yet between a brahmin hindu and a gursikh?
Do some studying, read up on it properly, then start a debate. Debating over things that have been said a MILLION TIMES on this forum and others and that we have gone over so many times will not teach you anything. If you are here to learn, then learn, we are telling you resources, if you are not here to learn but rather to fight, I suggest you leave right now--I say this with love. I am trying to open your mind to the possibilities.
I used to think like you and rant and rave about brahmin sarblohi pundit hindus that are making up rehats--I can prove it to you in posts. But then guru sahib did kirpa and showed me what a true rehat it is.
Re: Sarabloh Fanatic Brahmin of Sikhs ?
JKPS · 01 Feb 2005
Interesting read Mkhalsa. Got me thinking.....
At the end of the day 'Sucham' is such a big part of the Sikh Rehat. I don't practice bibeki, but do see the logic behind it.
As they say it's all about 'Jeeb Da Swad'. If we can control our hunger and eat simple then we can be bibekis. If our tummy rumbles when we are out and about and we feel the need to eat from others than you can never grasp the concept of bibek. Bibek is a good discipline.
Re: Sarabloh Fanatic Brahmin of Sikhs ?
Tony Singhprano · 01 Feb 2005
ding !!! ... ding !!! ..... round 1 has just ended
great come back post by kulwinder singh... well structured and thoughtout
i liked the fact that he stuck to the sarbloh debate and didn't turn it into a personal attack.
mkhalsa.... you sound quite flustered in your last post.
Tony Singhprano
Re: Sarabloh Fanatic Brahmin of Sikhs ?
Anon Singh · 01 Feb 2005
This is with regard to references for Bibek.
With regards to the Sarbloh Bibek reference in JD Cunningham's book, "History of the Sikhs" I cannot provide you a reference or guarantee where it is. I seem to vaguely remember it's mention in the appendix section around where Cunningham describes Sikh women (he incidentally describes them with a jurra on the top of their head, covered with "some sort of dress").
On this very website there are a number of references I can give you.
The Rehitnama Hazooree by Chaupa Singh says "Guru kaa Sikh...apaNy langar rasoee vich Sikh rakhey. Hukaie, Topeeaa, BhaadNee, chor, yaar, jooaybaaz, kurehiteeyaa na rakhai" meaining "A Guru ka Sikh...should keep only a Sikh in his langar and kitchen. Smokers, hat-wearers, shaven people, theieves, gamblers, kurehitees should not be kept" (Padam, 85).
Piara Singh Padam has this in his book. I can furthermore quote verses 84, 86, 105 and 298 of McLeod's Chaupa Singh translation to reference this further, if "Rehatnamae" was not enough.
Desa Singh I believe also makes mention of a type of Bibek. About 3/4 the way through the Rehatnama Desa Singh makes specific prohibition of those who take Bhang or Tobacco being allowed in the cooking square. Just prior to this Desa Singh says "He will keep his cooking arrangements unpolluted and he will not permit others who cause pollution to enter his cooking square". It is also said (Verse 100) "As you destribute the food, let not your mind dwell on wicked thoughts"
In Daya Singh Rehatnama Sarbloh is mentioned. Since this Rehatnama is written in pose it is not possible to reference a verse but the mention occurs in the description of an Akali towards the end of the Rehatnama. The Akali is described in detail - he wears blue garments, does not pierce his body, he wears a kirpan in a gatra. He avoids the women who wear makeup and attempt to beautify themselves. He talks of white kachereh, a blue dastar and protecting the hair all over his body. Just before the mention of the kachere it is said the Akali eats from an "iron vessel" and eats only from food cooked over wood (rather than dung).
Again Sarbloh is mentioned, after mentioning Satguru showing the Akali mention, Daya Singh writes "he eats from an iron vessel, his garments coloured blue and yellow. The ornaments he bears are all of iron". A grisht jeevan is also mentioned, and finally it is mentioned that Guru Gobind Singh considers one who follows the above Rehat in "my likeness" and there is "no difference between us".
What is important is the mention of respect for Sarbloh in Tanakhahnama. Many people will claim the reverence to Sarbloh in Sikhi as Brahminvaad and Hindu influence. They will cite Rehatnamas as "corrupt". But the earliest copy of Tanakhahnama we still have, (attributed to Bhai Nand Lal) dates to pre 1720 (1718 or 1719).
Tanakhahnama says in verse 15, One who touches iron with his foot, is greatly punished. In the context of the verse it is placed on the same level as accepting a Mughal as your own master.
In Sau Sakhi (Sakhi 8) it states, "Recognise him as the Guru's Sikh who does not eat the food of the Mona". Damdami Taksal and Nihang Jathebandia will probably acknowledge these as the words of Guru Gobind Singh themselves whilst others may be cynical of the attribution of Sau Sakhi as an authentic part of Dasam Granth; nevertheless this is still a Rehatnama that has to be taken into account.
Finally on this very site a mention of Macaullife's visit to the Sikhs of Hajur Singh is documented. You can read this in full in the "Gurmat" section of this site. Read his book, "The Sikh Religion under Banda and its Present Condition"
In all my examination of Rehatnamas I have never read a single text that states it is acceptable to eat the food of a Mona or irreligious person. No one has ever told me a line of Gurbani which does this either.
Re: Sarabloh Fanatic Brahmin of Sikhs ?
It will help · 01 Feb 2005
Some of us are lazy to chech Gurmat section.
........................................................................................................................
Guru Ka Langar & Bibek
by Bh. Manmohan Singh LA (with minor editing and note by Toronto Sangat)
It is an established truth that the food one eats does not only affect the body's health but also influences one 5 mind and thinking. That is why Sahib Sri Guru Nanak Dcv Ji has forbidden eating food which makes the body writhe in pain and fill the mind with evil. That is why he refused to accept the most nourishing and dainty dishes prepared in the house of Malik Bhago but preferred the simple dry food prepared by the so called low-caste carpenter, Bhai Lalo. Similarly, Sahib Sri Guru Gobind Singh Ji refused to drink water brought by a young man who had never done any service to anyone in his life. Thus, in the Gursikh way of life it is not only the nutrient value of the food that matters but, more importantly, who has prepared it and who serves it. Guru-Ka-Langar, whether prepared in the Gurdwara or in the household of a Sikh can be called Guru-Ka-Langar only if it is prepared by Guru-Ke-Sikhs. This may be the one reason why Sahib Sri Guru Gobind Singh Ji asked the recipients of the holy Amrit to share food among themselves in the same plate, but forbade them to do so with non-Amritdharis. One of the edicts given at the Baptismal ceremony is:
Gursikh di roti beti di saanjh Gursikh naal.
The Gursikhs have to share food and establish marital relationships with Gursikhs only
This edict is enjoined upon all the baptized Sikhs at the Baptismal ceremony at every Amrit Sanchar in the Panth irrespective of organizations or Jathas arranging it. It is further supported by the following quotation from Rahitnamaa:
Jay Kurahtieye Jag Darsaawat.
Pahul Peeay Kukaram Kamaavat.
Tin So Vartan Nahe Milaawey.
Rahey Nirlep Param Sukh Paavey.
(Rahitnamaa Bhai Desa Singh Ji)
Gursikhs are not to socialize or associate with those who have become apostates. Only then will they lead unaffected and happy lives.
Incidently, the above quotation brings out another important point; that even one who has taken Amrit once can become a non-Amritdhari if he commits any of the four Cardinal Sins or big Don'ts.
It is, therefore, clear from the above that if a Sikh is to strictly follow the commandments or Code of Conduct enunciated at the time of partaking of Amrit, he has to share food and keep relationships with Gursikhs (i.e., Amritdharis) only. There is no 'elitism' or 'communalism' in it. In fact, it is a practice ordained by Guru Sahib himself. It does not reek of Hinduism or Brahminism, as some people say. In the case of Brahminism, the low-caste people remain untouchable throughout their lives simply because of the accident of their birth, and there is no means by which they can be upgraded and made acceptable, with respect to sharing food with them. In Sikhism, all people, irrespective of their caste, religion, race, country, etc., are welcome to the Khalsa fold. Once they become Khalsa after taking Amrit, they are then an integral part of the Khalsa Panth, and it is always a privilege to share food and contract marital relationship with them, whatever may have been their original faith, race, etc. In fact, this is the holy way employed by the Satguru for the uplift of humanity.
Much fuss is made on this point because at the congregations of the Akhand Kirtani Jatha, the Guru-Ka-Langar is generally prepared by Guru-Ke-Sikhs (Amritdharis) only. Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh followed this rule strictly and, in addition, had his food prepared in All-carbon Steel vessels. This practice is referred to as Bibek in Sikhism. This tradition of being an All-carbon Steel Bibeki is not an innovation of Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh or any other person. It has been in vogue right from the time of Sahib Sri Guru Gobind Singh ii, who himself set this precept by using all-carbon steel vessels and Khanda for the preparation of the Holy Amrit given to the original Panj Pyaras at the time of the Birth of the Khalsa on Baisakhi of 1699 AD. Since then, certain sections of devout Singhs have been following this principle until even today, not simply for preparing Amrit, but also for preparing food.
***[NOTE: proof for the tradition of Bibekee Singhs can be found in the historical records of M.A. Macauliffe who writes "..so amid the general corruption of the religion of Gobind there are to be found about one hundred Sikhs at Naderh in the Dakhan, who are said to have up to the present time preserved intact the faith and ceremonies of Guru Gobind. They have kept aloof from the contact of Brahmins. Brahmin ministrations are not permitted either at their births, their marriages, or their obsequies. Whether they be Brahmin or Sudras who receive the sacramental pahul, all are by this fact admitted within a pale of social and religious equality. Brahmin weds Sudra and Sudra weds Brahmin. No need, therefore, to put their infant daughters to death through fear of not obtaining for them husbands of their own social status, as is the custom among such a large section of the Sikhs of Punjab. And widow marriages, reprobated by Hindus and now consequently by the Sikhs of the Punjab are habitually solemnised with the clearest conscience among the Sikhs of Naderh...At Patna, as at Naderh, the Sikhs pay the strictest attention to the Injunctions of Guru Gobind. Sleeping or waking, they are never without the habiliments known as the "five Ks." So strong is the aversion of the more orthodox among them to Hindus, that they will not even partake of food cooked by their hands. This is carrying orthodoxy a long way, but still further is it carried when they will not partake of food cooked even by a Sikh who has not on his person all the ‘five Ks’" (Macauliffe in "The Sikh Religion under Banda and its Present Condition")
Various Puraatan rehitnamas also make clear the importance of Bibek for a Sikh. Bhai Daya Singh rehitnaama contains the following bachans: "Bhojanaad Moundit naal chhakey, Tankhaiyaa" or One who eats food with a Mona/non-Sikh, is guilty of a breach of conduct (Piara Singh Padam’s Rehitnamay pg. 72); also "Patr sarb loh kay, bhougtay asan souaad....loh patr mai chhakai," meaning: using utensils of sarbloh, one eats tasty food...one should eat in sarb loh utensils" (Padam, 75)
The Rehitnama Hazooree by Chaupa Singh says "Guru kaa Sikh...apaNy langar rasoee vich Sikh rakhey. Hukaie, Topeeaa, BhaadNee, chor, yaar, jooaybaaz, kurehiteeyaa na rakhai" meaining "A Guru ka Sikh...should keep only a Sikh in his langar and kitchen. Smokers, hat-wearers, shaven people, theieves, gamblers, kurehitees should not be kept" (Padam, 85).
In Sau Sakhee, sakhee #8’s rehitnama it says clearly "So Sikh gur ka janeeay, Monay ann na khai" meaning: such is a Sikh of The Guru who does not eat the food of Monay/Non-Sikhs. [End-Note]***
Who is a Bibeki Singh? Bhai Sahib Kahan Singh of Nabha, in his Encyclopedia of Sikh Literature on page 863 defines Bibeki as "...a Sikh who is strict and steadfast in following the principles of Sikh Dharma." The terms Bibek and Vivek are synonymous and have the same meaning i.e. 'sense of discrimination.' In Gurmat, it implies the unquestionable adherence to the command of the Satguru.
Satgur Bachan Kamaaveney, Sachaa Eho Vichaar (ang 52)
Practice of the True Guru's commands is the only true philosophy.
Thus, in Sikhism, a Bibeki is a person who adheres strictly to and regulates his life in accordance with the Guru's commandments.
Generally, people do not grasp the true meaning of the terms Amritdhari and nonAmritdhari Sikhs. The phrase non-Amritdhari Sikhs is meaningless. One cannot make a comparison between them. There is only one class of Sikhs and that class is the SIKH (Khalsa). Thus, one is either a Sikh or not a Sikh. Who is a Sikh? The literal meaning of the word Sikh is a 'disciple.' A Sikh is one who is a disciple of the Satguru. To be a disciple of the Satguru, one must completely surrender one's will and wisdom to the Will and Wisdom of the Satguru. Only then, the Satguru admits one is in his fold as a 'Sikh' and blesses him with the holy Naam. This initiation ceremony was previously referred to as the deekhya or charan pahul and has been prevalent right from the time of Sahib Sri Guru Nanak Dcv Ji, as supported by Bhai Gurdas Ji:
Gur Deekhya Lai Sikh, Sikh Sadaayaa. (Var3,Pauri 11)
One is called a Sikh only after he has been blessed with 'deekhya.'
Charan Dhoe Rehraas Kar Charnamrit Gursikhaan Pilaaayaa (Var 1, Pauri 23)
(Guru Nanak) followed the system of washing the Guru's Feet and blessing the Gursikhs with the Charanamrit (Charan-Pahul).
Sahib Sri Guru Gobind Singh Ji prescribed specific rules and regulations which must be unconditionally accepted by the candidates before they can be admitted as disciples (Sikhs). The ceremony by which the Panj Pyaras are authorized by the Satguru to admit such persons in the fold of Sikhism is partaking Khande-ki-Pahul or Amrit. Therefore, according to the Commandment of the Satguru, one can become a Sikh of the Guru only by taking Amrit. Such a person is also called an Amritdhari because he has been blessed with the holy Amrit and has, thus, become a Sikh. It is further explicit from the following couplet from Rahitnamaa of Bhai Desa Singh Ji:
Pratham Rahit Yeh Jaan, Khande-ki-Pahul Chhakey.
Soee Sikh Sujaan, Avar Naa Pahul Jo Lai.
The primary Rahit for a Sikh is to take Khande-ki-Pahul. Only he is sagacious Sikh.
Now consider this point from another angle. If someone belonging to other faiths like Christianity, Islam, Judaism, Hinduism, etc., wishes conversion into Sikhism, what is he required to do? Does he become a Sikh by merely refraining from cutting his hair and wearing a turban as Sikhs do? Obviously not. (There are a number of such people with long hair, and even wearing turbans, belonging to faiths other than Sikhism). He has necessarily to partake the holy Amrit to become a Sikh. How can, then, one become a Sikh simply because of accident of birth, without being baptized? This point has also been explicitly made clear by the Satguru himself as:
So Sikh Sakhaa Bandhap Hai Bhai, Jay Gur Ke Bhaaney Vich Avey
Aapney Bhaaney Jo Chaley Bhai, Vichharr Chotaan Khaavey. (pg 601)
Only that person is a Sikh and he is my near and dear one, who comes under the total allegiance of the Guru. As against this, one who owes allegiance only to is personal will, always remains in separation and will suffer.
Even in the booklet entitled Sikh Rahit Maryada published by the S.G.P.C., a Sikh has been defined as under:
"...Dashmesh ji dey Amrit utay nischa rakhadu hai atey
kisey hor dharam nu nahin manadaa, oh Sikh hai."
"...and has full faith in the Amrit of the Tenth Guru and does not believe in any other faith, is a Sikh."
Clearly, therefore, being a non-Amritdhari means that one, has not yet declared his total allegiance and obedience to Sahib Sri Guru Nanak Dev Ji I Sri Guru Gobind Singh Ji I Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji as his Guru. Nor has he been blessed with the Gurmantra or Naam which is given ONLY at the time of baptism by Guru Sahib himself through the Panj Pyaras. Sahib Sri Guru Gobind Singh Ji himself put a seal on this point by bowing before the Panj Pyaras for his own baptism. Are these so-called non-Amritdhari "Sikhs" greater than even Sahib Sri Guru Gobind Singh Ji, that they call themselves full-fledged Sikhs without being baptized?
It is thus, abundantly clear that the non-Amritdharls, even though they may claim to be Sikhs, and are also considered Sikhs politically and socially, are not Sikhs in the true sense and in the eyes of the Satguru. In Gurbani, they are referred to as (a) Nigurey; (b) Gumantar heenus; (c) Sakat; (d) Manmukhs or Vemukh, and (e) Vedeen (Faithless), etc. howsoever prominent or outstanding they may be in the social and public life of the community.
Gurbani defines such terms as under:
a. Nigurey: one who has not become disciple of the Guru.
Nigurey Ko Gat Kaaee Naahee.
Avgann Muthhey, Chotaan Khahee. (pg 361)
For him who is without the Guru, there is no liberation.
Deluded by evil propensities, he suffers.
Satgur Bajhon Gur Nahi Koee Nigurey Kaa Hal Naao Bura. (ang 435)
Without the True Guru (i.e. Guru Nanak), there is not another Guru.
And one without the Guru has a cursed name.
b. Gurmantar-heenus: One who has not been blessed with the Gurmantra (Naani).
Gumantar-Heenus Jo Praani Dhrigant Janam Bharashtneh.
Kookreh Sookreh Gardbeh Kaakeh Sarpaneh Tul Khaleh (ang 1356-1357)
One who is without the Gurmantra, is the most accursed, and contaminated is his life. He is like a dog, a swine, an ass, a crow a snake, and a fool.
c. Saakat: Infidel
Saakat Suaan Kaheeyey Baho lobhee, Baho Durmat Mael Bhareejey. (ang1326)
The dog like infidel is said to be very avaricious and is full to the brim of evil thoughts.
Saakat Besuva Poot Ninaam (ang1239)
The infidel is nameless like a prostitute's son.
Santan kaa daanaa rookha so sarab nidhaan. Saakat nar chhatee parkaar, tay bikhoo smaaan (ang, 811)
The food of the saints/gursikhs is dry but it is equal to all treasures. The 36 types of tasty food of the infidel/saakat are equal to poision.
d. Manmukh: One who follows his own will; the egocentric.
Manmukh Oodha Kowl Hai, Na Tis Bhagat Na Naao. (ang 511)
The egocentric person (i.e. Manmukh) is like a reversed lotus and possesses neither devotion nor God's name.
Manmukh Seti Sang Karey, Muh Kalakh Daag Lagaaey (ang 1417)
Whosoever associates with a manmukh, blackens and stains his own face.
Manmukh Naam Na Jannani, Vinn Naavey Pat Jaaey...
Vishta Kay Keerray Pavey Wich Vishta
Se Vishta Mahe Samaaye. (ang 28)
The manmukhs know not the Naam, and without Naam lose their honor...
They are worms of excrement, fall in excrement, and get absorbed in excrement
e. Vedeen: The faithless; the irreligious.
Choraan, Jaaran, Randiaan, Kuttaneeya Di Baan.
Vedinaa Ki Dosti Vedinaa Ka Khaann
Sifti Saar Naa Jannani, Sada Vasey Shaitaan. (ang 790)
It is the habit of thieves, adulterers, prostitutes, and pimps that they contract friendship with the irreligious or faithless and eat their food; they know not the worth of God's praise and Satan ever abides within them.
The above are only a few of the numerous quotations from Gurbani and are self-explanatory and need no further comment. Evidently then, the Sikhs of the Satguru have to avoid the food prepared and served by them whether in the Gurdwaras or in their social gatherings, in the interest of the upliftment of their souls and the enjoyment of the Bliss of Naam Simran. This practice is not confined to the Akhand Kirtani Jatha alone. Even in the Langar premises of Sri Harimandir Sahib (Golden Temple) at Amritsar, a notice painted in bold letters in Punjabi, hangs prominently near the kitchen stating that the "SEWA OF THE PREPARATION OF LANGAR BE DONE BY THE AMRITDHARI SIKHS - MEN AND WOMEN. NON-AMRITDHARIS MAY DO THE SEWA OF CLEANING OF UTENSILS, KITCHEN, HALL, ETC."
Thus in trying to follow this practice, the AKJ is simply trying to follow the edict of Gurmat in respect of food and not out of any superiority complex or hatred for others.
Re: Sarabloh Fanatic Brahmin of Sikhs ?
J Singh · 01 Feb 2005
It's really sad to see that we try to act as authorities on subjects we know a very little about. Same old arguments. Why amrit is prepared in sarbloh? Why degh is made in sarbloh? How does that really prove anything? Why do we live in heated and air-conditioned houses with tons of luxuries while puratan singhs slept in jungles on horsebacks?!!? The fact of the matter is that Guru ji did not make sarbloh compulsory to become an amritdhari sikh. Guru ji de mehar is on all gursikhs, sarhlohi and non-sarblohi alike. If an amritdhari gursikh wouldn't want to have "roti-beti de sanjh" with another amritdhari gursikh (unless he fully complies with the sarbloh bebiki and full 16th century baana rehit), who will!! Really;-(
Just ask any old gursikh from Punjab how makkan (butter) is extracted from dahin (yogurt) and you will have your answer to strict sarbloh. Daals have been cooked in clay pots for centuries, tandoors (clay ovens) have been used to cook rotian, etc.. etc.. Go couple of generations back and you will find pittal utensils being used all over sikh houses, thaals, glasses, channey, etc.. etc...
VGKK VGKF
Re: Sarabloh Fanatic Brahmin of Sikhs ?
Tony Singhprano · 01 Feb 2005
in regards to sakhee #8 within the sau sakhee
in my collection of books on sikh literature, i have a 1st. edition 1873 english translation of the Sau Sakhee (translated by sirdar attar singh), i believe it's translated from the original sau sakhee manuscript.
translation of sakhee #8
#60 - That Seikh who does not eat food of a Mona, is a special favorite of the Gooroo
* mona, a person not belonging to Seikh religion and not wearing long hairs on his head ( from 1873 edition)
Tony Singhprano
Re: Sarabloh Fanatic Brahmin of Sikhs ?
???? · 01 Feb 2005
J Singh jee why sikhs wear same old kirpans in this new modren world of advanced guns which are more practical(according to modren viewers) ? Why sikhs cant wear gold kaRaas instead of sarabloh if sarabloh is not mandatory and if its old fashioned?
According to your post patkas and chunnies should too be ok to replace dastaars. You meet old ladies most of them wear chunny not dastaar. Does that mean dastaar was not mandatory for ladies from Guru sahib's time?
It's very very very easy to go down BUT it's really really really hard to go up. This is the reality of those hidden puraatan rehats.
Singhs used to live in jungles and slept on horsebacks not only in puraatan times but same history was repeated again in India in 80s. Singhs used to sleep in farms of gunnaas, they had to hide at many places which were possible/available to hide at that time. singhs had to hide because they were not allowed or it was not safe to live in villages/houses. They didnt choose to do so and it is not hukam of Gurru sahib jee to live in jungles and sleep on horsebacks. It doesnt make any point and I dont understand how we can compare oranges with nuts.
Re: Sarabloh Fanatic Brahmin of Sikhs ?
Anon Singh · 01 Feb 2005
Tony Singhprano, from my limited knowledge, the original Sau Sakhi manuscript, as allegedly written by Ram Kuir Randhava, does not exist. I am personally rather curious as to the original origins of this work perhaps you could tell us a little bit more about it. Wasn't Attar Singh commissioned by the British to translate it, because they were concerned of its contents which may have undermined the British Raj? From what I know I believe he dates Sau Sakhi as written in 1834.
Although it is a little off top I would be greatly interested if you could enlighten the Sangat on the relatively unknown area of Sau Sakhi. I am aware Nihangs and Namdharis in particular hold it in high regard.
Anyhow, from what I can see there appears to be no difference in the meaning of the Attar Singh translation and the one given by Tapoban/my post. Although your translation of 'Mona' is slightly different. If we take it as non-Sikh, why would it be ok to eat from what could be described as Sehajdhari, but not from a non Sikh?
Re: Sarabloh Fanatic Brahmin of Sikhs ?
Kulwinder Singh · 01 Feb 2005
Just forgive them, people make mistakes because they do not have know the results, some time in weakness’, some time in anger some time for other wrong reasons.
you are wise girl make positive contribution is your character and hurt is sometime unavoidable. but stay positive in your actions for yourself.
Best thing forgive them and learn from it.
Hard thing to do but then life is full of challenges.
Listen to any Shabad which appeal to you , it will uplift you and give you strength to do the right thing.
Re: Sarabloh Fanatic Brahmin of Sikhs ?
Dogma · 01 Feb 2005
">>I think in Bani when Guru Ji Says home what he mean is human body.<<
again, modernist interpretations. Guru sahib didnt write some flowery metaphor filled stuff. He wrote gurbani with straightforward language for the masses. if it says HOME, it means HOME! DUH!!!!"
Es Greh Meh Koee Jagath Rahai.
Rare are those that stay awake in this home.
Mkhalsa Jee,
Do you really believe that Guru Sahib was talking about "home" as in my duplex or someone else's two storey condo? How does me staying awake in my house Gurmat related in ANYWAY? In my humble opinion, I think you are mistaken veerji, Gurbani is not as straightforward as you would like it to be. I know you're smarter than this. You know that some Gursikhs spend YEARS studying Gurbani and it's meanings. Please do not DEGRADE Gurbani into "if it says ____, it means _____." Gurbani is DEEP. The depths of which no one but our Guru Sahibaan know.
I agree that Gurbani is written in a straightforward LANGUAGE.
but it does NOT have a straightforward MEANING.
Gurbani is not Shakespeare where you can find the meanings by reading Coles Notes. It must be felt..lived.....
I understand your passionate about your belief in Sarbloh Bibek, but please answer other people's criticisms with SOLID arguments. Don't twist things that you KNOW not be true to prove your point.
You're a smart man.....use that university brain of yours! :)
Waheguru Jee Ka Khalsa
Waheguru Jee Kee Fateh!
Re: Sarabloh Fanatic Brahmin of Sikhs ?
Kulwinder Singh · 01 Feb 2005
Sorry above message was for some other Topic please ignore it .
Re: Sarabloh Fanatic Brahmin of Sikhs ?
Kulwinder Singh · 01 Feb 2005
Dear MK Khalsa Ji you are saying
“ so many people have forgotten rehat or ridicule rehat that they no longer care for singhs or rehat and make it difficult for those who do “
you think I am ridiculing the rehat ? that is could not be any more far from the truth, I am saying people who Behave in fanatical way are wrong. Please read the topic clearly and understand what exactly I am saying then you can argue more effectively and I do want other people to criticise me effectively, I will be delighted to accept that I am wrong by listening to Guru Sikhs like Vir Kulbir Singh Ji , Giani Jarnail Singh Ji who have very wide knowledge on the wide range of issue but I am genuinely trying to bring issues up and learn from them and bring Eka, but I feel if I have something to say then I should say as long as my intentions are clean rather then dirty. I am new, naughty stupid and moorakh but even moorakh can ask questions or give statement. You do not have to accept what I say but we can have debate.
You have written “Do you know the Sakhi of malik bhago? Guru sahib showed that eating food of sakats or those who have no faith in god or do not follow any true path “
Guru Nanak Dev Ji rejected Malik Bhago because he was exploiter of people, to the contrary he pretended to be very religious.
You also written.
“ there are a few rehatnamas that say every gursikh must know how to ride a horse. I do, do you? I am a bit rusty I will admit. “
First I do not have a horse, You obliviously do, so If you do not ride it regularly for your travelling then why you keeping it ? you said you do have so I am assuming it is your personal horse.
You proceed by saying “Anyway, I think today, motorcycles are a good equivalent, I have yet to learn.”
That is what modern Capitalist Evil Kalyug does to Singhs ? – ( yes I am being scarstic on the above line )
You also saying “Yes he has, if you can keep sarbloh with full devotion (while keeping strict amritvela) for a month and tell me afterwards it is a stupid ritual, I will touch your feet. You do not know the power of sarbloh nor have you witnessed the power of sarbloh, how can you call it a stupid ritual? why do you think guru sahib chose to create a marayda that AMRIT must be made in sarbloh and NEVER anything else? that DEGH must be made in SARBLOH and nothing else, and LANGAR must be made in sarbloh and nothing else.”
First thing you do not have to touch my feets for sure I am papi and moorakh. I do not know if all the things you are saying are fact or not, But I must say I am attempted to do the trail for it. I do not promise anything as I said I am Papi and Moorakh. But your suggestion is truly well received for doing a trail for at least one month.
You also saying “again prove to me that Guru Nanak Dev Sahib jee ever ate from any non Sikhs? you cant. you are mistaken here bhai sahib. There is no historical evidence. We are all brainwashed into this modernist interpretation of sikhi where kaur=princess and women wear chunnis and we all do bhangra or something”
I think if you pause for one minute then thin Guru Nanak Dev Ji did more travelling on feet then anybody else in the universe I believe, and he did not convert everybody he went to chat or see that was never his intention. You think a Guru who was so advance in his thinking that he dismissed all sort of ritual and loved everybody would have made fuss that he will only eat at his Sikh’s house ? In his own life time he was more interested in awaking people rather then converting them to be his Sikhs. People became his Sikhs because they wanted to not because Guru Nanak felt shortage of Sikhs at any time. For many years Mardana Stayed with Guru Nanak Dev Ji he was never pressured to convert to Sikhi, he indeed died as Guru Nanak’ Sikh so Guru Nanak Dev Ji and Mardana eaten together life time even when Mardana was not declared Sikh.
How about Gangu Brahmin who worked in the Kithen of Guru Ghar there is no reference where Gangu Became Singh ?
Up to very the start of last century there were some ragis in the Golden Temple who were Muslims who use to sing in Raag, but they were kicked out by Singh Sabha for very good reasons.
You have said “Brahminvaad has to do with castes and birth “
Wrong : Wrong: Wrong: Wrong: Wrong:
Brahminvaad has far more to do with putting people on the rituals and keeping them busy in wasting time and money. Dividing the community and segregation. Making people Karm Kandi (Ritual Busy) rather then religious in true sense. Brhaminvaad is keeping the power in the hand of people who think they are superior and others are inferiors and they are the real agents of God nobody else.
Caste and birth does serve a very good tool for their aims.
You saying “Do you understand the difference yet between a brahmin hindu and a gursikh? “
Brahmin in terms of Hinduism is Prime, Top, Intelligent, Superior, Key holder of everything in the world
Brahmin in Indian Term: a Fraud
Brahmin in Sikhi Term: then one who try to understand the nature of GOD, the one who analysis HIM, the one who is wise to understand HIS will.
Hindu have many definitions I can write many different versions, Indian, Aryan, Snatan, RSS Version, Islamic version, Sikh version and so on..
Gurusikh : Just a Sikh of Guru and the only Guru is Shri Guru Granth Sahib Ji.
You also saying
“If you are here to learn, then learn, we are telling you resources, if you are not here to learn but rather to fight, I suggest you leave right now--I say this with love.”
First I am not hear to fight I love my Guru and his Sikhs. I am sorry if you feel that my intention could be these but you are 100% Wrong. I am debating it because there are many Karniwale Singh who can debate and probably will make me change my mind, and I will be delighted to lose to my brothers and sister there is no other better defeat then to be defected by those who you love most.
You said “I am trying to open your mind to the possibilities.”
You think I am trying to close my mind or anybody else mind ? Strange , very strange.
You have written “I used to think like you and rant and rave about brahmin sarblohi pundit hindus that are making up rehats--I can prove it to you in posts. But then guru sahib did kirpa and showed me what a true rehat it is.”
May Guru Ji Do Rehmet on my stupid head and make me understand things. I admit I am moorakh but I am saying even moorakh have right to debate and ask questions.
I repeat my intentions are not to hurt anybody but to raise an issue and learn. I am not Stuban, though I am moorakh and Papi.
Thanks
Bul Chuk Maf.
[%sig%]
Re: Sarabloh Fanatic Brahmin of Sikhs ?
Mkhalsa · 01 Feb 2005
singho, gangu brahmin has been covered so many times on this forum its not even funny..
also, you misinterpreted my comments on malik bhago. I said guru sahib rejected him and rather ate at a gursikhs house.
Regarding above accusations of twisting bani. I apologize. Yes, there are many metaphors, but it is rather obvious i think where there metaphors and where it is actually talking about something, at least in a lot of bani.
Re: Sarabloh Fanatic Brahmin of Sikhs ?
Tony Singhprano · 01 Feb 2005
anon singh, you are quite right when you describe sardar attar singh as an agent of the british, though he was employed by the british i see no evidence of a bias slant in his sau sakhee translation.
the british were becoming increasingly un-nerved by rapid rise of the kuka movement, and felt the sau sakhee was the underlining cause.
i think their is a difference in attar singh's translation and the tapoban one, "special favorite" verus "recognise him as the guru's sikh"
also, your quote on cunningham is incorrect, the "top knot" quote is actually from a 1834 book by Alexander Burnes.... cunningham was just quoting him. ( i have 1st. editions of both books.)
the cunningham quote has been a particular thorn in my side for years, if your trying to prove a point for your side why not properly research it first. Just cause someone says it's so.... doesn't mean it's so.
my passion is collecting 1st, edition books on the Sikhs
here is the full title of the work(1st. and only edition 1873)
SAKHEE
or
The Description of
GOOROO GOBIND SINGH'S
RELIGION AND DOCTRINES
Translated From Gooroo Mukhi into Hindi
and Afterwards Into English
By
Sardar Attar Singh
1873
---------------------------------------------------
Tony Singhprano
[%sig%]
Re: Sarabloh Fanatic Brahmin of Sikhs ?
chinky · 02 Feb 2005
eating from sarbloh does not make you a brahmin, its called rehat. Just like some prominent singhs outside jatha will not even touch pani unless it comes from an underground well, which is far more stricter than sarboh.
Re: Sarabloh Fanatic Brahmin of Sikhs ?
Jarnail Singh Gyani · 02 Feb 2005
Waheguru Ji ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki fateh.
We must learn to distinguish between "baiters" and "genuine learners". The baiters are those who purposely raise argumentative questions to provoke and spoil the atmosphere....genuine learners may sound and look like baiters but they arent......and since there is no "reliable meter" to check this out....lets not press the accelerator so much from the word GO I I am also equally guilty of "speeding" and deserve many speeding tickets !!)
Here I cannot but say ( may Guru Ji forgive me) that Veer Kulbir Singh ji seems to be the "really cool one"..I have yet to come across a post of his that he has lost his cool..Guru Ji's Apaar Kirpa !!....shows through..
Veer Kulwinder singh has rasied many relevant points..i have learnt a few things and considered a few things.....and from all this made my rehat resolve even stronger.... so all these discussions do help us all irregarde less of our status -level of rehat etc...there is always a next level..
To all those of my veers and bhens..i have learnt from all of you..May Guur Ji have Kirpa on all of Us as we are all his OWN. I think everyoen has got through to the actual meaning of fanatic/Brahmin...
jarnail singh
Re: Sarabloh Fanatic Brahmin of Sikhs ?
Anon Singh · 02 Feb 2005
Tony Singhprano I have personally seen the topknot quote in a copy of Cunningham's book. This is why I also make a mention of Sarbloh, since I seem to remember mention of this also within it.
The original author of this quote is to me personally irrelevant since I see it only as a first hand account from a foreigner of Sikh women without any bias.
Next time I have this book at hand I will take a photograph of the page if you have any doubts.
"Special favourite" and "Guru's Sikh" to me has very little difference. They both reflect positive attributes in the follower of this Rehat. If you want to be picky about language in English yes, but if you study all old Rehatnamae you will see exactly why there is no difference between the two. Rehatnamae like Daya Singh and Tanakhahnama will express my point perfectly. My quote was not from the Tapoban site BTW.
Anyway please elaborate a little more about Sau Sakhi. Are there any other sections of the text you are particularly interested in and would like to enlighten us about?
Re: Sarabloh Fanatic Brahmin of Sikhs ?
J Singh · 02 Feb 2005
"????" I don't know what to say about your post. What does sarbloh kara and wearing chunnie not kesgi has to do with cooking and eating out of sarbloh? I am talking about asking old amritdhari sikhs from Punjab not anybody. My remarks regarding singhs sleeping in jungles on horsebacks was a sarcastic remark on us who live in all these western luxuries and pretend to emulate puratan singhs. Being fascinated by great gursikhs is wonderful as it inspires us in our sikhi-jeevan but getting few like-minded people to say yes to something we strongly believe doesn't make it a rehit that everyone must follow. We should follow the hukam of our Guru ji and should refrain from asking other singhs to comply with what we follow (I have seen it happen). Let them get inspired from out jeevans instead. I too was fortunate enough to accompany few singhs in the 80s and we too occasionally had to sleep in ganney de
khet and in bait de areas.
VJKK VJKF
[%sig%]
Re: Sarabloh Fanatic Brahmin of Sikhs ?
Singh · 02 Feb 2005
To people who keep bringing up horses and living in jungles as tradition and try to equate this to sarbloh rehit.... people don't keep sarbloh rehit simply because this was the traditional way of doing things. They do it because it is a rehit... which is different than a tradition. Bhai Daya Singh jee mentions sarbloh rehit many times in his writings. Similarly, a sarbloh bata isn't used in amrit sanchars simply due to tradition. Grinding a khanda on the bata is an important part of the amrit sinchar ceremony and using a steel bata won't do the trick. Lastly, most of you are arguing this without actually tasting the power of sarbloh rehit. I was once like this. Then I tried it. That ended the questions for me.
Re: Sarabloh Fanatic Brahmin of Sikhs ?
Anon Singh · 02 Feb 2005
"Singh" has raised a good point.
Sikhism unlike Islam is a religion distinct from culture; it does not require it's adherants to move back into the mindset and culture of the society where it was first conceived. It is not damaging to a Singh's Rehat to drive a car, for example.
When we define what Rehat actually is it, we see it as the code of conduct a Singh or Singhni should follow. The point of Rehat is not to "uphold a tradition" but rather aid Naam Kamai and bring the Seeker closer to God. This is after all the number one aim in a Gursikh(ni)'s life.
Sarbloh Bibek is not a tradition, but rather an integral part of Rehat which will aid Bhagti. This is where people's viewpoints seem to diverge; many fail to see the spiritual significance in a Gurmukh japping Naam whilst preparing food, as opposed to an angry young man in McDonalds frying french fries. If you are unable to realise the spiritual significance of Sarbloh and Bibek then it is unlikely you will ever consider Sarbloh Bibek as part of Guru Sahib's Rehat or helpful for a Sikh.
Re: Sarabloh Fanatic Brahmin of Sikhs ?
Tony Singhprano · 02 Feb 2005
anon singh, i beg to differ
by continuing to quote Cunningham for the "top knot" reference you do a disservice in proving your point, due to the fact that the quote is out of context.
the following is the full quote
TRAVELS INTO BOKHARA .......(super long title)
Lieut. Alexander Burnes
1834
Vol. 3 page 146
"We had now an opportunity of seeing the Seik ladies, who are not less peculiar in their appearance than their husbands. They knot the hair at the crown, and throw a white robe over it, which entirely envelopes the body, and gives a conical shape to the head. They pull up the hair so tight to form this knot, that the skin of the forehead is drawn with it, and the eyebrows are considerably removed from the visual organ. As may be imagined, this fashion does not improve their personal appearance, yet it is general amoung all classes of the females. The Seik ladies are not so handsome as their husbands; their features are sharp and regular. They are not confined to their houses as stricly as the Mahommedan women; for the Seiks, in matrimony as well as religion, differ widely from the followers of the prophet."
after reading this passage, i'm sure you will agree that cunningham's use of the quote is quite lacking.
my point is, if your going to do something.... do it right
the following is from the sau sakhee (1873 attar singh translation)
Sakhee Eight
# 40
He should eat from and give food to his fellow Shiek, no matter if he belongs to any of the four Hindoo castes
anon singh, if you want to inquire about a particular issue, maybe i can look it up. it has been a while since i read the whole sau sakhee.
Tony Singhprano
Re: Sarabloh Fanatic Brahmin of Sikhs ?
Anon Singh · 02 Feb 2005
Tony Singh Ji,
Perhaps I am missing the point here but Burnes's quotation still seems to portray the same meaning as Cunningham's widely quoted description. Looking at paintings and photos of Praatan Bibis we can clearly see how the description fits fine.
With regards to Sau Sakhi, your quote again does not seem to conflict with the concept of Bibek (Rehatvaan Amritdhari Singhs are allowed to share food) but in my version which is based on that of Gurbachan Singh Naiar's translation, seems to have no such reference in couplet 40. In my version Sau Sakhi finishes at couplet 42.
Re: Sarabloh Fanatic Brahmin of Sikhs ?
Kulwinder Singh · 02 Feb 2005
I will reply to all the messages soon, I am also waiting for my Dear Vir Ji Kulbir Singh Ji and Dear Vir MK Khalsa Ji's Comments to my last post.
Re: Sarabloh Fanatic Brahmin of Sikhs ?
Jarnail Singh Gyani "arshi" · 03 Feb 2005
has anyone heard of the Saggi...soe kind of ornament that women wore at the top of the head to look like a top knot ( after they started making gutt/joora t the back)..I have an old phoot of my great grandfather's fmaily where all the women are wearingthese saggis making them look like they have top knots under the chunnis.. sorry to sidetrack..but to me this saggi thing looks like a "way" of looking that one ahs a top knot when one really doesnt.
Jarnail singh
Re: Sarabloh Fanatic Brahmin of Sikhs ?
Tony Singhprano · 03 Feb 2005
anon singh, cunningham's quote is a simple 2 lines
HISTORY OF THE SIKHS (1918 ED.) 3rd OR 4th edition
page 349
"The Sikh women are distinguished from Hindus of their sex by some variety of dress, but chiefly by a higher topknot of hair."
surely you can see that Cunningham's quote is lacking
the Attar Singh translated Sau Sakhee has 64 couplets within the 8th sakhee.
Tony Singhprano
Re: Sarabloh Fanatic Brahmin of Sikhs ?
Singhani · 03 Feb 2005
Why does this so called Gyani always bring Sants into every topic? Does the Admin not realise this can hurt the sentiments of some people? Or are they not as neutral as they portray to others?
Re: Sarabloh Fanatic Brahmin of Sikhs ?
Jhooth naa bol panday.... · 03 Feb 2005
singhani what are you talking about?. I couldn't find any sant word in Gyani jee's post in this thread.
Re: Sarabloh Fanatic Brahmin of Sikhs ?
Kulbir Singh · 03 Feb 2005
Vaheguru jee ka Khalsa Vaheguru jee kee fateh!
Veer Kulwinder Singh jeeo,
About Sarbloh Bibek, we have had so many debates already. While there is no pankiti in Siri Guru Granth Sahib jee to substantiate Sarbloh but for Bibek there are several references to in Gurbani. Gurbani clearly gives us hukam to associate with Gurmukhs and not with Manmukhs. There are several pankitis that tell us to do friendship only with Gursikhs and not with manmukhs. If Guru Sahib is stopping us from associating with non-devotees, how can their food be good?
SANTAN KA DAANA ROOKHA, SO SARB NIDHAN||
GREH SAKAT CHHATEEH PARKAR, SO BIKHOO SAMAAN||
(Ordinary food of Gursikhs is like a treasure whereas delicious 36 kinds of dishes of manmukh or saakat are like poison).
Indeed, food prepared without Gurbani Paath or Naam is like poison. Food made from income derived from sinful means is like poison. Food made from income that is without bhagti is like poison.
Coming back to Sarbloh Bibek, it is a tradition not only in Akhand Kirtani Jatha but amongst Nihungs and Taksal as well. Puraatan Singhs used to eat from Sarbloh only.
Recently we went to get darshan of Hazoor Sahib and there is a Gurdwara run by Buddha Dal (Nihung Singhs), called Mata Sundri daa Gurdwara. This gurdwara was founded by great Mahapurakh, Brahm-bethaa – Baba Mitt Singh jee. They keep strict pehraa of Sarbloh and Bibek there. Two kinds of langars are prepared there (originally there was only one kind) currently and one of them is Sarbloh Langar. The sewadaars who do sewa in Sarbloh Langar have absolutely magnificent jeevans. We met those 5 Singhs who are in-charge of the Sarbloh Langar and found out the following from them:
1) They always get up at midnight and are never late in getting up.
2) They do paath, which includes at least nitnem plus Siri Sukhmani Sahib, Siri Asa kee Vaar, Siri Akal Ustat, Chandi kee Vaar and one more baani, I can’t remember now.
3) The sewadaars consider only 4 kakaars and don’t consider kesh as kakaar, since they are part of the body anyway.
4) They never separate keski from their body and if it gets separated, they get pesh for that.
5) They never eat from non-sarblohi and bibeki.
6) Mostly they eat food cooked by them alone.
They had a glow on their face. One Singh was so pyaara that I cannot describe his beauty that descended on his face due to his rehit.
Such rehit of Sarbloh is not only limited to one jatha but it was and still is widely accepted in Panth. Most of the rehit of Khalsa is unwritten and is seena-baseena passed on to the next generation. Rehitnamas contain some references to Sarbloh and I request Balpreet Singh or some other Singh to quote references to Sarbloh.
-----------
You also saying “here may be God in every kitchen but every rasoyee does not have Naam. Without the presence of Naam no rasoyee (kitchen) can be worthy of making food for Gursikhs. If we use the argument that every kitchen has God in there so we should eat from there, then one can say that since God is present in tobacco too, therefore, we should be allowed to consume tobacco too.”
What kind of argument is that ? I would not dream of you presenting this kind of argument, you must have been in hurry to write this. Not well thought at all so I am going to ignore this.
-------------
Bhain jee Redwhiteblue Kaur had mentioned that since Vaheguru is present in everything and everywhere, so we can eat from any rasooyee. I don’t see why you don’t consider this as a good argument.
--------------
You say “We follow the Sarbloh Rehit only and only because it is Guru Sahib’s rehit. “
how about having a horse too. That was very crucial to puratan singhs ?
--------------
Horse was not a rehit for puraatan Singhs.
--------------
you also saying “As for Brahmanism, a Gursikh who follows the rehit of Guru Sahib and japps Naam as per hukam of Guru Sahib is the real Brahmin.”
I my opinion wrong, Real Brahmin is the one who think about the god and analysis him and try to understand his hukam rather then just being stuck to words as words.
Amaze me how come you still have these opinions!
-----------------
This is just one aspect of real Brahminism that you have mentioned. Yes to be a Brahmin you have to do what you have written above but to be a real Brahmin one has to be discriminating (positively) good from bad. There is good and bad food and a real Gursikh would discern good from bad. To eat just any food, without worrying about who made the food or what kind of income was used to fund food is not Gurmat.
-------------
You also saying “yes we are Brahmins but we are Brahmins by Karma”
Guru Nanak say
Dharm Karm Pakand Jo Disha Tin Jam Jagai lootay!
It is Brhaminwad of Suuch and Juudth, That I am not eating anything which is not prepared in the pure kitchen in sarbloh.
-----------
It is your opinion, and you are entitled to you opinion. We believing in cleaning and keeping the rasoyee suchee not only from dirt but also from Manmukhs. Loving people does not mean that you have to eat from their hands. To do so would amount to violating Gurbani Hukams of not associating with manmukhs.
----------
What is purity, earning with truthfulness and working for what you earn and being good law obeying citizen of Good contries is purity. Being helpful is purity, being humble is purity, standing against oppression is purity.
Accepting others as equal is purity.
---------
Is eating from people who don’t do bhagtee purity? Would you eat from a Bhaayeeya of UP or Bihar who has made food with the same hands that he uses to eat tobacco? Would you consider eating from a person who drinks liquor and consumes tobacco or commits adultery? Thinking of others as equals is one thing but this does not mean that Khalsa should eat from just any lalli-chhalee and kacha-pillaa.
---------------
Guru Nanak Dev Ji rejected Malik Bhago because he was exploiter of people, to the contrary he pretended to be very religious.
-----------
So what was wrong with his food then? Food is food and shouldn’t Guru Sahib have considered him as an equal. Perhaps if he had shown love to him and accepted his food, he may have mended his ways. No but Guru Sahib rejected his food.
This saakhi proves that food can be rejected if it is not coming from correct sources. Singhs do exactly the same thing. Food coming from non-devotees is like poison for Singhs and this is why Singhs like Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh jee who had reached high spiritual states, rejected food prepared by non-devotees. He endured unbearable tortures but kept his rehit of Sarbloh Bibek.
------------
I think if you pause for one minute then thin Guru Nanak Dev Ji did more travelling on feet then anybody else in the universe I believe, and he did not convert everybody he went to chat or see that was never his intention. You think a Guru who was so advance in his thinking that he dismissed all sort of ritual and loved everybody would have made fuss that he will only eat at his Sikh’s house ?
------------
Of course he would only eat from his Sikh’s house. Read old manuscripts like Janamsaakhis and you will find out how Guru Sahib used to stay hungry for days, without food. There were days when they ate only leaves and wild fruits and Bhai Mardana kept complaining incessantly for this. One day he gave ultimatum to Guru Sahib that he will only proceed if Guru Sahib quenched his thirst and hunger.
As for converting people, it is estimated that he converted 32 million people to Sikhi. Wherever he went, people begged him for his Sikhi and became his Sikhs. He never had eating problem because he established Dharamshaal where ever he went to.
-----------
For many years Mardana Stayed with Guru Nanak Dev Ji he was never pressured to convert to Sikhi, he indeed died as Guru Nanak’ Sikh so Guru Nanak Dev Ji and Mardana eaten together life time even when Mardana was not declared Sikh.
---------------
What are you talking about? Mardana jee became a Sikh early on in his association with Guru Sahib. He was given three orders including japping Naam and not cutting hair. Of course Guru Sahib then would have had no problem eating from his hands and even in the same plate as him.
-----------
How about Gangu Brahmin who worked in the Kithen of Guru Ghar there is no reference where Gangu Became Singh ?
----------
Gangu was a Khidaava and not a rasoyeeya. Principal Satbir Singh has written that he was called a rasoyeeya because he was a very short-tempered person. And he left Guru Sahib before 1699 Vasaakhi and he must have taken Charan Pahul from Guru Sahib before that.
------------
Brahmin in terms of Hinduism is Prime, Top, Intelligent, Superior, Key holder of everything in the world
Brahmin in Indian Term: a Fraud
Brahmin in Sikhi Term: then one who try to understand the nature of GOD, the one who analysis HIM, the one who is wise to understand HIS will.
--------------
Very well said. You are a very intelligent man, Veer Kulwinder Singh jee. We need you on our side and not against us. We need intelligent people like yourself to do parchaar of Sikhi. Don’t oppose rehit. If you cannot keep it, then believe me you won’t do any good to Sikhi by having people give up Bibek rehit. Bibek Rehit immensely helps in doing bhagti. One has to experience to know.
Bhul chuk dee maafi.
Daas,
Kulbir Singh
Re: Sarabloh Fanatic Brahmin of Sikhs ?
Jarnail Singh Gyani "arshi" · 04 Feb 2005
Waheguru Ji ka Khalsa Waheguru ji kI fateh.
Kulbir Singh Ji writes:>>>
Very well said. You are a very intelligent man, Veer Kulwinder Singh jee. We need you on our side and not against us. We need intelligent people like yourself to do parchaar of Sikhi. Don’t oppose rehit. If you cannot keep it, then believe me you won’t do any good to Sikhi by having people give up Bibek rehit. Bibek Rehit immensely helps in doing bhagti. One has to experience to know. <<<
I couldnt agree more. This is one aspect of our life that we have to experience ourselves..lets not diss people who try something different from what we can do. I wasnt a bibeki/sarblohi..in fact i used to DISS it..diss it a lot.....and then i tried it for just a month ( in deference to my late dad's wish that i give it a try and if i still felt the same way i could drop it..)...it was terrible,,,like an addict getting cold turkey treatment..but i persevered..and i am glad i persevered. I am sorry i cant say any more than that. all i will say is just try it and see.
To those who like to diss the non-bibekis..i have the same answer..let them be...IF GURU JI wills it they will come around.
Jarnail Singh.
Note: To "Jhooth na bol pandey"..in answer to singhanee (aka..jka)..thank you Ji for coming to my aid !! May Guru Ji Bless You.
Re: Sarabloh Fanatic Brahmin of Sikhs ?
Anon Singh · 04 Feb 2005
Tony Singh Ji, With regards to Sau Sakhi, this is very interesting that your copy has 62 couplets. Although I know it would be a long task, it would be a massive seva for the Sangat to type up Sakhi #8. Many people are not aware of it's contents and many people believe in or reject Sau Sakhi without knowing it's contents. It is not a widely available text so I am sure many would benefit if you could make it available!
Yes I am aware that Cunningham's quote is very short but I do not see any contradiction between the two quotes, neither do I see any difference in the overall meaning between the two. I see that Burnes has also elaborated saying Singhanis wear a large "robe" ontop and pull the jurra very tight so their eyebrows are lifted. He also (very subjectively) claims the Singhanis are not quite as handsome as their Singh counterparts.
The overall jist of the two quotes is that ALL Praatan Singhnis were easily distinguished by a Joora on the top of the head, which was also covered.
Re: Sarabloh Fanatic Brahmin of Sikhs ?
bhopinder singh · 04 Feb 2005
first of all the admin should not allow such headings.please dont misunderstand me as i am not against the content of discssion
cause no sooner kulwinder singh chose the heading it was all over . he lost all the credibility as you can see he is not interested in discussion but slandering
you can never go to a muslim forum and start the discussion under the topic all muslims are infidels
cause you will loose all the cedibillity of a constructive debate
what this man is doing is blasphamy
he may discuss this in a better way ie under a better heading is sarbhloh a rehat
but the manner of his discusion shows arrogance
at the last he should be requested to choose another mode of discussion ie face to face
Re: Sarabloh Fanatic Brahmin of Sikhs ?
Admin · 04 Feb 2005
This discussion is exhausted. Thread closed.