Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

HISTORICAL TASK BEFORE DALITS (Save SIKHISM from BRAHMINISM)

HISTORICAL TASK BEFORE DALITS (Save SIKHISM from BRAHMINISM)

Nanak Singh Bhatti · 02 Feb 2005

http://www.dalitvoice.org/Templates/feb2005/editorial.htm HISTORICAL TASK BEFORE DALITS If Sikhism is not saved from sure death, Brahminism will run riot & kill every protest movement What is happening in Punjab today is a fantastic experiment unprecedented in "independent" India Ñ a seriously sick patient, kept in a hospital ICU, is awaiting death any moment the life support is withdrawn. The patient is none other than the powerful Sikhism, a military religion that made mince-meat of Brahminism and gave new hope to the millions of people liberating them from the slavery in the 16th century in the North-Western part of India. If this vaidik experiment succeeds in Punjab it will be extended to rest of India. Brahminism will then run riot and kill every egalitarian movement. Today, the revolutionary religion of Sikhism, which came to save the slaves, is itself reeling under a three-way attack and lying seriously ill. Precarious condition. IN CHANDIGARH JAIL: As one deeply impressed by the socio-cultural revolution of Sikhism, we naturally got attracted to it. But the ruling Brahminical Social Order punished us by arresting us under the dreaded Terrorist Act (1986) and thrown us into the Chandigarh jail. All this is history. (Jagjit Singh, The Sikh Revolution, 1981, Bahri Publications). Ever since then we have been close to Sikhs and particularly the Dalit Sikhs. We have a fairly good circulation in Punjab and we even have a Punjabi edition of Dalit Voice. And many Sikh admirers all over India and the world. We have done our best to support Sikhism. But the great religion that came to save Dalits and other victims of Brahminism is itself facing slow death. Dalit Voice had a long Debate on this subject but the upper caste Sikhs, the principal beneficiaries of Sikhism, are not interested in heeding our warnings. Punjab today has become a unique socio-cultural laboratory where the BSO is conducting a crucial experiment. Once it succeeds there, it wants to extend it to other parts of India. The experiment is like this Sikhism is undergoing a unique type of painless, bloodless surgery at the hands of the Brahmin surgeon and surprisingly the patient is enjoying it too. This surgery is called hinduisation (enslavement) of the Sikhs. BRAHMINICAL MESMERISM: Such a Brahminical surgery is being experimented in other parts of India also ÑÊmainly on Dalits. And even other sections including Christians and Muslims. But all of them are protesting, resisting and fighting back. But in Punjab, the Sikhs have willingly subjected themselves to the operation and are enjoying it. Such is the power of Brahminical mesmerism. The ruling upper caste Sikhs (Jats and Khatris) have been divided into Akali Sikhs and Congress Sikhs (today the Congress is ruling Punjab) but both are slaves under the BSO. SLAVES ENJOYING SLAVERY: So much so, not only the Sikhs have become slaves but slaves enjoying their slavery. They are not even aware of their slavery. Even when they are called monkeys and donkeys by the Brahminical people they laugh and enjoy the insulting remark. (DV Nov.16, 2004 p.8 "Sikhs depicted as monkeys in Hindu films, TV serials & media Ñ enslavement of a great martial race"). How such a living death of Sikhism is made possible? The Brahminical experiment to kill Sikhism is very ancient. Arya Samaj did a thorough job. The vaidik trick is they allowed the upper caste Sikhs to make money and prosper. Today the Sikhs of Punjab and Delhi are a prosperous lot. So, when we raise the question of Sikhism facing a slow death, the hinduised Sikh, who has been made unconscious by the Brahminical drug, hits back saying " Why talk of religion when economically we are so strong and we are on the top? We have made money and money decides everything Ñ religion, caste, politics everything". GAINING WHOLE WORLD BUT LOSING SOUL: This is the stock answer of the hinduised (enslaved) upper caste Sikhs. Of course, they have the turban, the beard, the gurudwara Ñ all the outward show. But the content is zero. What is the use of Sikhs gaining the whole world but losing their soul? The typical Brahmin trick is to allow a caste or community to make money by hook or by crook and then catch the culprit and see that his ill-gotten wealth is used as per vaidik dictates. Two important articles are following this Editorial Ñboth written by upper caste Sikhs supporting our argument on "Slow death of Sikhism". On one side the vaidiks have almost succeeded in infiltrating the Sikh religious order ÑÊtheir very Golden Temple itself Ñ and the reports are they are on the verge of replacing the all-out anti-Brahminical Guru Granth with the Brahmin-manufactured Dasam Granth. DALIT SIKH CLASHES: On another side, the vaidiks are instigating some Dalits and Dalit Sikhs to fight the upper caste Sikhs and encouraging the Jat Sikhs to hit back. So much so Dalit-Sikh clashes are increasing in Punjab. Though Sikhism was born as a result of the long Dalit struggle and the philosophical inspiration of Dalit saints (the Guru Granth itself admits this in black and white), the vaidiks are instigating the "Sikh scholars" to refute the historical truth. (DV Edit July 1, 2004 "Chamar power rescues Sikhism"). SOCIO-CULTURAL-MORAL DECAY: The upper caste Sikhs are thus involved in a three-cornered fight (1) they are fighting between themselves and also (2) fighting with Dalit Sikhs and (3) some conscious upper caste Sikhs are fighting with their unconscious brothers. And the vaidiks are silently watching and enjoying the fun as Punjab, once the granary of the whole country, is facing all-round crisis Ñ spiritual, political, socio-cultural and also moral. The poor patient (Sikhism) is lying on the death bed. Some thinking upper caste Sikhs are deeply worried as we can make out from the "Communication" from the respected Editor of the Sikh Review, Brother Saran Singh. DV's RESCUE MISSION: Many Sardars like him admit that Dalit saints gave birth to Sikhism, then the Khatri Sikhs groomed the baby and brought it up. Finally the Jat Sikhs took over from the Khatri Sikhs. But today as the Jat Sikhs are consciously or unconsciously allowing the vaidiks to kill Sikhism, it is the duty of its founding fathers, the Dalits, to rescue it from the ICU and rejuvenate it. This major experiment is now going on in Punjab and DV and its family are seriously involved in this sacred rescue mission. We are aware that we have the good wishes and blessings of all the Great Gurus and particularly the 10th Guru Govind Singh Ji. Many concerned Jat and Khatri Sikhs as well as the entire Dalit Sikhs and Dalits in Punjab and outside want us to expedite this rescue mission. And then save the patient on the death bed. Such a rescue mission is also in the interest of Dalits who are the born enemies of Brahminism.

Re: HISTORICAL TASK BEFORE DALITS (Save SIKHISM from BRAHMINISM)

chinky · 02 Feb 2005

some good bits here but some bad, there is no caste of a sikh and you can only be a sikh if you believe and follow what bani says. so that means using terms like jat sikh khatri sikh chamar sikh have no significance as far as meditation and sikhi go. when you take amrit you have no jaat paat, these people should take amrit and be counted as sikhs and stop whinging about everyone else.

Re: HISTORICAL TASK BEFORE DALITS (Save SIKHISM from BRAHMINISM)

chinky · 02 Feb 2005

but the article is right on what hindus are doing to sikhism and sikhs should be smart and realise that.

Re: HISTORICAL TASK BEFORE DALITS (Save SIKHISM from BRAHMINISM)

jaidev singh · 03 Feb 2005

veer ji their is no such thing as high caste sikhs as jats are grouped with shudras by brahmin theirfore jats are low caste according to brahmin but look how guru ji lifted them and you are calling them high caste in the same way chamar word used by brahmin but remmember how proudly we talk about BEANT SINGH who killed bahmani theirfore guru is even lifting sikhs whome brahmin is calling chamar if only you people understand and own it and sing wars of beant sing and be proud . their can be no high low in all low

Re: HISTORICAL TASK BEFORE DALITS (Save SIKHISM from BRAHMINISM)

sikhadaraj · 03 Feb 2005

i disagree jaidev that all jatts are low. South panjabi jatts are descendants of 70% royal blood whos chaudhar was already established, and created kingdoms like dhar, malva, etc before sikhism came. the western branches also had military rule and warriors such as the kharral mirza and nikkai khom which is entirely west punjabi muslim. Brahmins had hardly any weight over punjab that is why their kateba say the people in punjab are sinners and have low habits. The truth was north western tribes never accepted brahmins order. But jatts being such a large nomadic group from different tribes broke off into different groups guptas, maurs, rajputs who are in fact hinduised jatts. I would appreciate it if people stop saying jatts were low before sikhism. That was the case ONLY for some because of their situation not because a jatt was a jatt it had nothing to do with caste. Rai Bhullar was a big jagirdaar before he even came near sikhi. but anyways sikhs should have no caste and thats final. But then why are these dalits bashing jatts for? i know plenty of chammars who are also westernised. So rightly they should stop looking at a jatt as a jatt and take amrit and say they are casteless then.

Re: HISTORICAL TASK BEFORE DALITS (Save SIKHISM from BRAHMINISM)

lachivalichai · 03 Feb 2005

if these supposed low caste grew their hair partaked in amrit sinchar talkd about sikhi instead of their own caste fought for the panth kept with gurmat and lead by example that we should not have caste then i would read that article in a different way. But so far though the content is good the dalits just seem to want their own piece out of sikhi instead of working with sikhs. It does not work like that, sikhi is about self surrender. How many of us, our forefathers lived as second rate citizens in a white mans land? we remained the butt end of jokes, " paki turbanators". the gorey teachers would at one time differentiate between asian and white students. the police would treat racist attcks on minorities with their own form of banter as near as the mid 1980s. We were made to feel like crap in every way just 10 years back. How worse were the dalits of punjab treated than we were treated in england in the 1970s 1980s and west canadians in the 1900s and east canadians in 1960s? In order to get out of this, we worked double hard, 16 hour shifts a day, sent the kids to colleges unis, where they spent long hours creating their futures, saved money to get where we have come today. This was through hard work. The dalits have to stop being jelous of others success and build their own path upwards and wish others well and i wish them well. But there is also a lot of valuable thought into that essay, it just gets spoiled by bringing anothers caste into it, then the cause they argue for their doing the same thing. I can see they are not prideful of caste but they seem to be cold and envious in the way they come out with jatt sikh khattri sikh.

Re: HISTORICAL TASK BEFORE DALITS (Save SIKHISM from BRAHMINISM)

jaidev singh · 03 Feb 2005

i disagree with sikhan the raj how come you link jats with all the self made history.Krukshetra is not far from punjab and jatts thier show the proof of shodra word and classification of brahmin they are not sikhs but associate themselves with rajputs and use the word singh as used by hindu rajputs long before the sikhs i have lived and worked with jatts of haryana and after long discussions with them came to the conclusion as they could not associate with all the history u made but they did mention MAHABHARAT but their is no historical evidence of the fact even happened and also pandavs and kaurvs were kashtrias

Re: HISTORICAL TASK BEFORE DALITS (Save SIKHISM from BRAHMINISM)

sikhadaraj · 04 Feb 2005

singh i am basing that upon renowned historians which i can list for you right now if you ask. what does kurukshetra have to do with this? the largest jatt tribal groupings refused to bow to brahmin order, thats a fact proven by history and artifacts. But the hinduised jatts that did, became known as rajput, and the rest while branching out to other areas. in fact i will bring up the essays for your clarification just give me a little time. central and west punjabi jatts never bowed to brahmins so whether the brahmin calls jatts shudras has no bearing upon punjabis. It is the brahmin who sat on his backside and did no work and asked for alms, it is the brahmin who is looked upon as inferior because of the way the way they believed others were, so in punjab it works the other way round, the brahmin gets his backside ripped. who are not sikhs? so what if rajputs used singh before? the rehbab also comes from the middle east, and is prescribed to use with bani, big deal that doesnt mean only arabs can use it! rajput is just a title that was used to bring jatts into hindu through agnikula ceremonies. Maurs are also jatt, and now the jatts that converted into hindus are looked upon as high as brahminlike status. jaidev on your last paragraph i will now qoute from historical works instead of speaking.

Re: HISTORICAL TASK BEFORE DALITS (Save SIKHISM from BRAHMINISM)

PART 1 · 04 Feb 2005

The Scythians inhabiting Central Asia at the time of Herodotus (5th century B.C.) consisted of 4 main branches known as the MassaGatae, Sacae, Alani, and Sarmatians, sharing a common language, ethnicity and culture. Ancient Greek (e.g. Herodotus, Pliny, Plotemy, Arrian) and Persian sources (Darius's historians) from the 5th century place the MassaGatea as the most southerly group in the Central Asian steppe. The earliest Scythians who entered the northern regions of South Asia were from this group. Historians derive "Jat" fom "Gatae", "Ahir" from "Avar", "Saka" from "Scythii", , "Thakur" from "Tukharian", "Saurashtra" from "Saura Matii" or "Sarmatians", "Sessodia" (a Rajput clan) from "Sassanian", "Madra" from "Medes", "Trigartta" from "Tyri Getae" and "Sulika" from "Seleucids". "Massa" means "grand" or "big" in old Iranian - the language of the Scythians. The early Sakas or Scythians are remembered by Greek (e.g. Herodotus, Megatheses, Pliny, Ptolemy) and Persian historians of antiquity as tall, large framed and fierce warriors who were unrivalled on the horse. Herodotus from the 5th century BC writes in an eye-witness account of the Scythians: "they were the most manly and law-abiding of the Thracian tribes. If they could combine under one ruler, they would be the most powerful nation on earth." According to their origin myth recorded by Herodotus, the Sakas arose when three things fell from the sky: the i) plough, ii) sword and iii) cup. The progenitor of the Sakas picked them up and hence the Saka race began its long history of conquering lands, releasing its bounties and enjoying the fruits of their labor (the cup has a ceremonial-spiritual-festive symbolism). The relevance of these symbols and codes of life and culture to the traditional Punjabi and northwest society are tantalizingly obvious. A branch of the Sakas kown as the Alani reached regions of Europe, Asia Minor and the Middle East. They have been connected to the Goths of France/Spain, Saxons and the Juts of Denmark. Entry into India Some of these Saka tribes entered northwest India through the Khyber pass, others through the more southerly Bolan pass which opens into Dera Ismail Khan in Sindh -- an entry point into Rajasthan. From here some invading groups went north (Punjab), others went south (Maharasthra), and others further east (UP, MP). This explains why some Jat, Gujjar and Rajput clans claim descent from Rajasthan (Chauhan, Powar, Rathi, Sial etc.) while others from Afghanistan (e.g. Mann, Her, Bhullar, Gill, Bajwa, Sandhu, etc.). This is supported by the fact that the oldest Rajput geneologies (10th centuries) do not extend into the northwest's Gandharan Buddhist period (400 B.C. - 900 AD). JATTS WERE SHUDRAS??????????? Sir Cunningham (former Director General of Indian Archeological survey) writes: "the different races of the Scythians which succesively appeared as conquerors in the border provinces of Persian and India are the following in the order of arrival: Sakas or Sacae (the Su or Sai of the Chinese - B.C. ?), Kushans (the great Yue-Chi (Yuti) of the Chinese - B.C. 163), Kiddarite or later Kushans (the little Yue-chi of the Chinese - A.D. 450) and Epthalites or White Huns (the Yetha of the Chinese - 470 A.D.). Cunningham further notes that ". . . the successive Scythian invasions of the Sakas, the Kushans, and the White Huns, were followed by permanent settlements of large bodies of their countrymen . . ". Cunningham and Tod regard the Huns to be the last Scythian wave to have entered India. Herodotus reveals that the Scythians as far back as the 5th century B.C. had political control over Central Asia and the northern subcontinent up to the river Ganges. Later Indo-Scythic clans and dynasties (e.g. Mauryas, Rajputs) extended their control to other tracts of the northern subcontinent. The largest Saka imperial dynasties of Sakasthan include the Satraps (204 BC to 78 AD), Kushanas (50 AD - 380), Virkas (420 AD - 640) while others like the Mauryas (324 - 232 BC) and Dharan-Guptas (320 AD - 515) expanded their empires towards the east. According to Ethnographers and historians like Cunningham, Todd, Ibbetson, Elliot, Ephilstone, Dahiya, Dhillon, Banerjea, etc., the agrarian and artisan communities (e.g. Jats, Gujars, Ahirs, Rajputs, Lohars, Tarkhans etc.) of the entire west are derived from the war-like Scythians who settled north-western and western South Asia in successive waves between 500 B.C. to 500 AD. The oldest Rajputs clans found in southern and western Rajasthan arose much later from earlier Scythic groups; or are of Hun origin (5-6th century AD); and many are no doubt of mixed Scythic-Hun origin. Virtually all are of Scythic descent. Sakastan : The Saka States Uptil the advent of Mohammed Ghori in the 13th century, the west and northwest was politically unified with the subcontinent for only 92 years under the Mauryas since the start of Saptha Sindhva's Vedic period (1500 BC). For most of its independant history it was under the rule of Saka kings. The west was also independant from the rest of India, existing under its Saka dynasties for virtually the entire period of history. The largest Saka imperial dynasties of Sakasthana include the Satraps (204 BC to 78 AD), Kushanas (50 AD - 380), Virkas (420 AD - 640) while others like the Mauryas (324 - 232 BC) and Dharan-Guptas (320 AD - 515) expanded their empires towards the east. A brief selected list of Saka rulers of Punjab and the northwest spanning 16 centuries includes Porus (4th century BC), Mauryas (3rd century BC), Rudradaman, Azes, Maues, Soter Megas (2nd century BC), Azilises, Wima Kadphises (1st century AD), Kanishka I, Haviska (2nd century), Vasudeva (3rd century), Vyaghra rata and Yasovardhana. Mauryas "For Chandragupta' s times, the evidences are more numerous and more detailed, and indicate a following of Persian customs all along the line - in public works, in ceremonial, in penal institutions, everything". The theory of a Scythic descent of the Mauryas is supported by the following pieces of evidence : Mauryan coins have the symbol of the sun, a branch, a humped bull and mountain (Dehiya, p.155). All these are pre-eminently Scythian MassaGetae icons who were Sun worshippers with the high mount symbolizing earth and the irregular curving lines alongside it symbolizing water. The tree branch is a symbol of productivity of the earth - agriculture and soldiering were the traditional noble occupations of Sakas. The historians of Darius record that when he attempted to attack the Scythian MassaGetae (an old-Iranian culture of Central Asia) along the Black sea in the 5th century BC, "the Saka kings swore by the sun god and refused to surrender earth and water". The clan name of Toramana and Mahirgula, viz Jauvla, is still available among Indian Jats who are now called Jauhl. Jat/Gujar clans and villages named Maur and Dharan exist even today in Punjab, Haryana, Bihar and western MP. The Puranas do not even refer to the largest imperial dynasties of the north such as the Mauryas (324 - 232 BC) and Dharan Guptas (320 AD - 515) as "Kshatriyas". Regarding the Mauryas, Dehiya [p.147] states "Another indication of the foreign origin [ ie. Saka ] of these people is . . . The Vishnu Purana calls them [ Gupta rulers ] Sudras. The Markandeya Purana brands the Mauryas as Asura. The Yuga Purana called them `utterly irreligious, though posing as religious'. The Mudra Rakshasa calls these people as Mlecchas and Chandragupta himself is called 'Kulahina', an upstart of unknown family".

Re: HISTORICAL TASK BEFORE DALITS (Save SIKHISM from BRAHMINISM)

PART 2 · 04 Feb 2005

It has also been suggested that this Scythic influence was occasioned by the immigration of Iranic Scyhtians fleeing the Greek conquest. Be that as it may, the fact remains that the main civilizing impetus behind the Mauryan empire was Scythic. Dateless revisionist Brahmanist monkey tales with reincarnating imaginary devtas may lie BUT inscriptions/coins texts do not - unless read by crooked and bigoted Brahmin and Bania historians like Majumdar and Bhevelkar turning "Jarta" (Sanskrit for "Jata") into "Guptas" and "Gartas" into "Guha" (cave)! Only unbiased non-Brahminist research can help uncover the true past of the Scythians of India. The Saka states and its civlizations were destroyed not by external forces, but by a deadly poison seeping from within. This deadly disease is none other than the Brahminists, who infilitrated the Saka states. By means of the dogma of jati (professional caste) the Brahmins divided and destroyed the unity of the Saka peoples, pitting brother against brother and son against father. The Brahmin inventions of dowry, female infanticide, and sati further debilitated the base of Saka civilization. Under the weight of Brahminist imperialism the glorious civilization of the Scythics was crushed and the Sakas ground into lower caste labourers serving their Aryan Brahminist masters. Finally, the alien Gupta kings from Kannauj destroyed the internally weakened Saka empires during the renewal of Brahmanist fascism. The glorious faith of the Sakas - the Saura religion, was fully destroyed and the crushed remnants absorbed into Brahminism.

Re: HISTORICAL TASK BEFORE DALITS (Save SIKHISM from BRAHMINISM)

PART 3 · 04 Feb 2005

Brahmanisation of Sakas During the 8-11th century religious transition, with Buddhist institutions and universities gone, the earlier Buddhist and Saka texts and literature of Sakasthan (and other regions of South Asia) went through Brahmanical censorship in which literature on earlier religions, social orders, history and rulers not conducive to their socio-political agenda was either destroyed, altered or interpolated to advance their caste ideology and claims of superiority. For example, the Deva Samhita of Gorakh Sinha from the early medieval period states "They are, like gods, firm of determination and of all the Kshatriyas the Jats are the prime rulers of the earth . . . Their history is extremely wonderful and their antiquity glorious. The Pundits of history did not record their annals lest it should injure and impair their false pride and of the vipras and gods". In revisionist post-11th century Brahmanical accounts even the grandest Saka-Buddhist emporer Ashoka Maurya (Maur clan) is maligned, slandered, mocked and all but erased from history as "insignificant king", "mlecha", "shudra" and "not generous to Brahmins". It is amazing and disquieting that most of the 1500 year history of Sakasthana and Buddhism in the subcontinent has been reconstructed from archeology and foreign sources (e.g. Greek, Chinese, Tibetan) rather than Indian materials. The thoroghness with which the Brahminists destroyed Saka civilization is indeed amazing. Whilst Greek and Scythic languages are recorded as spoken languages in various linguistic treatises, these languages were soon destroyed by the Brahmins. Few traces of the Saka civilization survived Brahmanic vandalism. Like the Panchalas, Carvakas and Latas, the Sakas joined the long line of races annihilated by Brahmins. Gangetic Brahmanical literature has gone through continual modification, interpolation and revision and was in earlier times were maintained solely in the oral tradition. The oldest Gangetic texts date to the 11th century AD and are written in Devnagari - a new script developed in that century (also the oldest Brahmanical temples and ruins are all post Buddhist, 9th century A.D.). To further this Brahmin monopoly over literature and Sanskrit, the new script was subsequently taught only to the Brahmin's obedient "twice born" orthodox castes. The rest of the population, including the Sakas, were maintained in enforced mental blindness. Under the increased professional rigidity and foreign caste prejudices propagated by Brahmanism in the west and north-west in the post-10th century era, Sakas engaged in artisan pursuits (e.g. Tarkhans, Lohars) were edged downward in Brahmanical "caste standing" while other Saka groups lost their tribal and clan identity altogethor to emerge only as occupational jatis. The Sufis and Sikh Gurus of the Punjab (11-17th century) rose to counter and arrest this process of social denigration and caste division and re-unify society along its traditional Saka ideals of brotherhood, equality and spiritual humanism. Interestingly, among the Puranic tirades the Gangetic caste-bigots unfurl against the Saka civilization and people of the West and North-West, one more term used to denounce them (besides "mlechas", "sudra" and "vahikas") is "vratyas" meaning "brotherhood". The concept of a casteless society and democratic republican polity propounded by the Saka tradition in which no segment among them was acknowledged as "superior" and where political leaders were elected (e.g Panchayat, Sarpanch, Sarva Khaap, Thok, etc.) was an abomination to the Aryan priesthood from Gangasthan (Kannauj or Brahmavarta).

Re: HISTORICAL TASK BEFORE DALITS (Save SIKHISM from BRAHMINISM)

PART 4 · 04 Feb 2005

In many ways the Sufi and Sikh traditions of Punjab represent a renaissance, continuity and revival of the earlier egalitarian and humanistic spiritual and cultural traditions/heritage of the region's preceding Gandharan Saka-Buddhist civilization (500 BC - 900 AD). Therefore, one should not be surprised upon finding many Sufi and Sikh saints between 12-18th centuries with names like "Buddha Singh", "Gandha Singh", "Buddha Shah", "Buddeh Shah", "Bulle Shah", etc; or that many of the Gurmukhi letters were in use in earlier Gandharan scripts; or that many important historical Gurdwaras ("Guru's house") connected with the Gurus are situated on historical Gandharan Buddhist shrines (e.g. Panja Sahib); or that the institutionalization and very high regard given to socio-religious concepts of "sangat meh pangat" in Sikhi also exists in the Buddhist notion of enlightened society ("sanga"); or that the institution of Guruship found in Sikhism (and Sufism) has its parallel in the Buddhist tradition of "lammas" who were believed to inherit the sacredness, piety and divine inspiration of their predecessor. Nanak never presented himself as a Brahmanic Messenger or Avtar and believed that just as a candle is able to depart light to another without diminishing its own light, similarly a Guru could enlighten the soul and impart divine wisdom to the sangat and his successors and bring them to be his spiritual equals. Moreover, the religio-political institution of the Khalsa established by the last Guru Gobind Singh (with 5 elected "pyaras" and elected Jathedar) in 1699 and the 12 misls (republics) to arise in the middle of the 18th century are based on the traditional Saka republican democratic political system and insitutions (panchayat, sarpanch, sarva khaap, thok, etc.) found throughout the history of Sakasthan and which survive to this day.

Re: HISTORICAL TASK BEFORE DALITS (Save SIKHISM from BRAHMINISM)

PART 5 · 04 Feb 2005

Based on coins, inscriptions, archeology and early Indian/Buddhist/Chinese/Greek/Persian manuscripts dating back to 500 BC, historians and ethnographers since the 19th century (e.g. Cunningham, Tod, Rapson, Ibbetson, Elliot, Ephilstone, Dahiya, Dhillon, Banerjea, Sharma, Sinha, Puniya etc.) have shown that the traditional agrarian and artisan communities of the entire northwest (e.g. Jats, Gujars, Tarkhans, Khatris, Ghakkars, Rajputs, Awans, Khambos, Lohars, Yadavs, Ahirs, Meos, etc. including various BC groups) are descended from Scythian (or Saka) tribes of central Asia (an aggressive and expansionist old Iranian speaking culture) who settled western and north-western South Asia in successive waves between 5th century B.C. and 1st century AD. The capital-lion Saka inscriptions at Peshawar and Mathura state "Sarvasa Sakasthanasa puyae" (for the merit of the people of Sakasthana). Inscriptions and coins mentioning `Sakastan' are found all over the Saka core region of Rajasthan and surrounding tracts. Ethnological information collected in colonial censuses shows that the majority (+65%) of the population of the west ("Sakasthan" including Rajasthan, Punjab and western UP) is of Saka origin. Terms like "Sakasthana" and "Saka" appear on ancient Saka inscriptions and coins found as far as western UP (former United Provinces), (Malwa) and respectively. Other major Saka cities and centers include Jodhpur, Jaipur, Sialkot, Jalandar, Taxila, Moga, Ropar, Patiala, Batinda. Saka Descent of Rajputs The earliest Rajput genealogies of the northwest date only to the 9-10th century AD (post-Buddhist period) and arise from Saka (e.g. Jats/Gujars) and Hun (5-6th century invaders) clans who formally accepted Shankarcharya's revived Brahmanism (9th century) after the demise of Buddhism. Cunningham and Tod consider the Hunas to be the "last Scythian wave". Conditions of formal conversion: i) use only Brahmin as priest, ii) ban on widow remarriage and iii) burning of widows (sati). Converted clans/villages who relapsed on these conditions, rejoined "Jathood" or "Gujarhood". Despite popular conceptions of caste rigidity and permanence promoted in modern historical education, a high level of social and occupational mobility existed in Sakasthan even in post Buddhist times as attested by the Director General of the 1881 Indian Census, Sir Ibbetson [p. 8] : "The Sahnsars of Hushyarpur were admittedly Rajput till only a few generations ago, when they took to growing vegetables and now rank with the Arains. Some of the Tarkhans, Lohars and Nais of Sirsa are known to have been Jats or Rajputs who within quite recent times have taken to the hereditary occupations of these castes; and some of the Chauhans of Karnal whose fathers were born Rajputs, have taken to weaving and become Shekhs. . . . The process is going on around us, and it is certain that what is now taking place is only what has always taken place during the long ages". Political control over the western and northwestern subcontinent post 500 BC (Gandharan period) was primarily in the hands of Sakas (Scythians) and their descendents who mainly patronized Buddhism and Solar cults prior to 9th century AD. Based on analysis of coins, inscriptions, archeological finds and early Indian/Buddhist/Chinese/Greek/Persian manuscripts dating back to 500 BC, historians and ethnographers (e.g. Cunningham, Tod, Rapson, Ibbetson, Elliot, Ephilstone, Dahiya, Dhillon, Banerjea, Sharma, Sinha, Shrava, Puniya etc.) have shown that the traditional agrarian and artisan communities (e.g. Jats/Gujars/Tarkhans/Khatris/Rajputs. While the plains facts of history clearly contradict the supremacist and hegemonic claims Poorbia Brahmanists began making on southasia during the 19th century, this historical quackery and the elitist neo-Brahmanist identity (the "superior Aryans") and chauvinistic socio-political doctrines derived from it have been the founding ideology and the "historical consciousness" of the new Indian Brahmanist Order

Re: HISTORICAL TASK BEFORE DALITS (Save SIKHISM from BRAHMINISM)

PART 7 · 04 Feb 2005

The Sakas of the northwest did not accept the supremacy of the Brahmins, did not practise the chaturvarna caste system advocated by their "law givers" like Manu, had their own Saka priests (Magas), and mainly patronized Buddhism mixed with their own religion prior to 9th century AD. ill-disposition to Brahmanism earned them an unending hostility of the frustrated Gangetic priesthood. The post-Buddhist transmission of Brahmanism into Sakasthan required adaption to fit it into the Saka social and political order prevailing in the northwest where Sakas continued to wield political power, run their villages and own the land. The Brahmin livelihood depended on the goodwill and generosity of their Saka employers and patrons. In the Saka social order, zamindari, cultivation, artisanship and soldiering were considered the "noblest" and "highest" professions and way of life. These social ideals and cultural heritage are diametric opposites of eastern Brahmanical social dogma in which those who worked the land and worked for their living were designated "polluted" and "sudras" while those following non-Brahmanical religions were "mlechas" (barbarians). In return, the Sakas considered the Gangetic priests to be little more than soothsayers and palm-readers who begged for their food. With the rise of Sufism by the 11th century, the bulk of the population in Punjab had formally moved away from Brahmanism and the remaining employed Brahmins for ritual and ceremonial purposes while also patronizing Sufis, Fakirs, Yogis and Naths who followed the local secular and unorthodox spiritual traditions.

Re: HISTORICAL TASK BEFORE DALITS (Save SIKHISM from BRAHMINISM)

PART 8 · 04 Feb 2005

the Sakasthan country was politically separate from the subcontinent over 97% of its 2500 years known history - even this "3% togethorness" of 92 years occurred under the eastward expanding Saka empire of the Mauryas. The Sakasthan core region was almost never under the occupation of Brahminists in the pre-Gupta age. To the Brahmins, the west and northwest Saka country has always been historically a "foreign land of Barbarians" ("Vahika-desa" populated by "vahikas", "vratyas", "mlechas" and "sudras") as written in their own holy shastras. The Mahabharta, Puranas and Brahmin Law Givers repeatedly "forbid Brahmins" from traveling to these foreign lands where, in turn, their alien religion, priesthood, gods and caste creed was spurned and rejected by the Saka people population. For example, the Mahabharta, verses 2063-2068, Karna Parva, states "one should not go to Vahika-desa in which the five rivers and the Indus . . . where the mlechas live . . ". Saka priests were known as "Magas" (Sun priests who prayed to the sun for bountiful harvests) who, along with Buddhist masters of Sakasthan, found themselves out of work when Buddhism and its institutions declined during 8-10th century. Many of them eventually became recruited into the "Brahmin" fold (e.g. Saraswat, Dakaut divisions) while Gangetic emigrants form the "Gaur" division of Brahmins

Re: HISTORICAL TASK BEFORE DALITS (Save SIKHISM from BRAHMINISM)

PART 9 · 04 Feb 2005

the Sakasthan country was politically separate from the subcontinent over 97% of its 2500 years known history - even this "3% togethorness" of 92 years occurred under the eastward expanding Saka empire of the Mauryas. The Sakasthan core region was almost never under the occupation of Brahminists in the pre-Gupta age. To the Brahmins, the west and northwest Saka country has always been historically a "foreign land of Barbarians" ("Vahika-desa" populated by "vahikas", "vratyas", "mlechas" and "sudras") as written in their own holy shastras. The Mahabharta, Puranas and Brahmin Law Givers repeatedly "forbid Brahmins" from traveling to these foreign lands where, in turn, their alien religion, priesthood, gods and caste creed was spurned and rejected by the Saka people population. For example, the Mahabharta, verses 2063-2068, Karna Parva, states "one should not go to Vahika-desa in which the five rivers and the Indus . . . where the mlechas live . . ". Saka priests were known as "Magas" (Sun priests who prayed to the sun for bountiful harvests) who, along with Buddhist masters of Sakasthan, found themselves out of work when Buddhism and its institutions declined during 8-10th century. Many of them eventually became recruited into the "Brahmin" fold (e.g. Saraswat, Dakaut divisions) while Gangetic emigrants form the "Gaur" division of Brahmins

Re: HISTORICAL TASK BEFORE DALITS (Save SIKHISM from BRAHMINISM)

PART 10 · 04 Feb 2005

While plains and verifiable facts of history clearly contradict the supremacist, hegemonic and quack claims Brahmanist idealogues and organizations began making over historically separate and independent nations of South Asia during the late 19th century, Brahmanist historical fraud and the elitist neo-Brahmanist identity (the "superior Vedic Aryans") and socio-political doctrines derived from it are the founding ideology and "historical consciousness" of the new post-1947 Brahmanist Order in India Question for Brahmin Historians How did Jats come out of Shiva's hair? Banerjea, J.N. (1987), `The Scythians and Parthians in India' , in a `Comprehensive History of India' , edited by K.A.N. Sastri, Vol. 2, Peoples Publishing House, New Delhi, India, 1987, pp 186-309, pp 830-838. Banerji, R.D. (1909), `The Scythian Period in Indian History', Indian Antiquary, Vol. XXXVII, pp 25-74. Bhattacharya, J.N. (1896), `Hindu Castes and Sects', Editions Indian Calcutta, 1st ed. 1896 (1968 reprint), p.398-9. Bingley, A.H. (1978), `History, Caste & Culture of the Jats and Gujars', Ess Ess Publications, New Delhi, India (first published in 1899). Cunningham, A. (1971), `Coins of the Indo-Scythians, Sakas, and Kushanas' , Reprinted by Indological Book House, Varanasi, India (first published 1888). -------(1979), `Later Indo-Scythians (Coins)', No. 11, Reprinted by Indological Book House, varanasi, India (first published 1893-94). -------(1963), `Coins of Ancient India: from the earliest times down to the seventh century A.D.', reprinted by Indological Book House, Varanasi, India. Dhillon, B.S. (1994), `History and Study of the Jats', Beta Publishers Inc., Ottawa, Canada Dahiya, B.S. (1980), `Jats: The Ancient Rulers', Sterling Publishers Pvt. Ltd., New Delhi, India. Eggmont, P.H.L. (1970), `Alexander's Campaign in Gandhara and Ptolemy's List of Indo-Scythian Towns', Orientalis Lavaniensia Periodica I, pp 3-123. Gupta, P.L. (1988), `Coins', National Book Trust, New Delhi, India, pp 51-52. Hewitt, J.F. (1894), `The Ruling Races of Prehistorical Times in India', South-Western Asia, and Southern Europe, Archibald Constable & Co., London, pp. 481-487. Herodotus (B.C. 490-425): `The Histories', translated by de Selincourt, Penguin Books, New York, 1988. Ibbetson, Denzil (1916), `Punjab Castes: Races, Castes and Tribes of the People of Panjab', Cosmos Punblications, New Delhi (1981). `Jats' , The New Encylopaedia Britannica, Vol. Encyclopedia Britannica, Inc., Chicago, pp. 510. Kosambi, D.D. (1953), "The Study of Indian Tradition", Indica, Silver Jubilee Issue. Pawar, H.S. (1993), `The Jats: their Origin, Antiquity and Migrations', Manthan Publications, Rohtak, India The Getae and the Dacians, and Sarmatae and Parthians, in The Cambridge Ancient History, edited by S.A. Cook, F.E. Adcock, M.P. Charlesworth, Vol. II, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, 1954. Pradhan, M.C. (1966), `The Political System of the Jats of Northern India', Oxford University Press, London. Ptolemy (90-168 A.D.), `Geography of Claudius Ptolemy', translated and edited by E.L. Stevenson, The New York Public Library, New York, 1932. Mahil, U.S. (1955), `Antiquity of Jat Race', Atma Ram & Sons, Delhi, India. McCrindle, J.W. (1987), `Ancient India as Described in Classical Literature', reprinted by Eastern Book House, Patna, India, pp 164-165 (first published 1901). Mc Govern, W.N. (1939), `The early Empires of Central Asia', The University of North Carolina Press, Chapel Hill, North Carolina, pp 419-21. Pliny, (A.D. 23-79): `Natural History' , translated by H. Rackham, Harvard University Press, Cambridge, Massachusetts, 1947. Rolle, R. (1989), `The World of the Scythians', University of California Press, Berkeley. Sara, I. (1978), `The Scythian Origin of the Jat-Sikh', (Part 1 & 2), The Sikh Review, pp. 15-27, pp. 214-233. Sinha, B.P., Journal of Bihar Research Society, XXXVII, parts 3-4, pp 142. Smith, V. A. (1903), `The Kushana or Indo-Scythian Period in Indian History (165 B.C.-320 A.D.)', Journal of the Royal Asiatic Society of Great Britain and Ireland, pp. 1-64. Tod, J.(1972), `Annals and Antiquities of Rajasthan', Vol. 1, Routledge & Kegan Paul Ltd., London, (first published in 1829), pp. 623.

Re: HISTORICAL TASK BEFORE DALITS (Save SIKHISM from BRAHMINISM)

PART 11 · 04 Feb 2005

Brahmanist history and canards attempt to i) erase the history of Sakas and Sakasthan altogethor, as mentioned above, ii) replace the real history of Rajput origins (post-10th century casteized Sakas) with fanciful lunar/solar Brahmanical tales and iii) manipulate and pit Rajput Sakas against uncasteized Sakas like Jats and Gujars who did not accepted Brahmanical supremacy/orthodoxy and held on to their ancient Vedic-Saka social customs, cultural roots and political institutions ( widow remarraige, elected Panchayat, Sarpanch, Khaap, Thok, and Sarva Khaap). Once again, the Brahmin maxim of `Divide and Rule' which was invented by the Brahmin Kautilya ! There is a systematic and bigoted attempt to denigrate non-casteized Sakas (e.g. Jats, Gujars, Ahirs, Yadavs, Tarkhans, Lohars, etc.) as "Sudras" (lower caste Negroes) and "Mlecchas" in revisionist shastras and in modern Brahmanist history and social engineering (through Brahmanist produced Hindi films, state-run television, press, education system, etc.). s attested directly by the 11th century historian of Mahmud Ghazni. He clearly states in the Tarikh-i-Ferishta (Ferishta, English Translation by Briggs) that the Afghan war in Punjab was "against the Jats" and goes on to describe the engagements, which involved naval warfare, that resulted in the defeat of Jat forces under Raja JaiPala near Attock in 1027. (SORRY MATE PURE FACTS, NO SANATAN TALES, AND I HOPE PEOPLE LEARN AS TO WHAT IS BEING TALKED ABOUT IS NOTHING TO DO WITH SNOBBERY OF CASTE. JATTS JUST HAPPENED TO MAKE A MAJORITY IN THE NORTH WEST FRONTIER, JATTS WERE NEVER PART OF THE HINDU CASTE SYSTEM FOR IT TO BE INTERPRETED AS MEANING NO OTHER CASTES FOUGHT, JATTS ARE NOT A CASTE BUT A SEPERATE ETHNIC RACE THAT INHABITED A CERTAIN PART, BUT UPON TAKING AMRIT THEY ARE NOT EVEN THAT, BUT PLEASE DO NOT MIX FACTS OR GET CONSUSED. jUST BECAUSE A JATT WENT FORWARD DOESNT MEAN A TERKHAN DID NOT, IN THOSE DAYS ALL PUNJABIS WERE PRETTY MUCH THE SAME THING. )

Re: HISTORICAL TASK BEFORE DALITS (Save SIKHISM from BRAHMINISM)

sikhadaraj · 04 Feb 2005

JATTS ARE SUDRAS??? WHERE DO THE MONKEY TALES ORIGINATE FROM? Colonel A.L.H. Polier (died in A.D. 1795) [9] wrote, "Originally and in general the Siques (Sikhs) are zemindars (landowners) or cultivators of land, and of that tribe called Jatts (Jats) which, in this part of India, are reckoned the best and most laborious tillers, though at the same time they are also noted for being of an unquiet and turbulent disposition. This tribe of Jatts (Jats) is very numerous and dispersed in all the country from the Sind (presently, a province of Pakistan or river Indus) to the southward far beyond Agra (a city in northern India). In another document Polier [9] said, "But what is more to be admitted is that those Seik (Sikh) Sirdars (Chiefs), whose territories border on the King's were but very lately of the Jauts (Jats) and of their caste and tribe ---- they have put on their iron bracelet, fifty of them are enough to keep at bay a whole battalion of the king's forces, such as they are". Griffiths, J. (his document dated February 17, 1794 A.D.) [10] said, "The Jaats (Jats) are said to observe some institutions similar to the Seiks (Sikhs), wear their hair and beards in the same manner, and are part of the same people, who under Swrudge Mul (Suraj Mal----consult Chapter 5 for more information on this powerful king of the Jats), etc., formerly POSSESSED MANY OF THE COUNTRIES IN THE NORTH INDIA---".

Re: HISTORICAL TASK BEFORE DALITS (Save SIKHISM from BRAHMINISM)

jaidev singh · 04 Feb 2005

does it make sense you just wasted your time and energy trying to proove one part of humanity is better then the other i wonder if you are brahmin they make so much mythology endless lies to proove themselves superior, now dont tell me you were not trying to do the same it is all ballony in the same manner hitler gave so many historical facts or shall i say lies to proove the superiorty of whites or aryans can they match blacks in strength or for that matter any aryans .strength in terms of physical after the victory of second world war same feeling came to the whites,but chinese gave them a good lesson in 1950 and 1968 ie korea and vietnan then they started saying only christians can fight ,but afghanistan prooved otherwise (1978) so you can see i am better and you are not does not work reason being everyone is created equal by the god so please keep your fake and ballony history to yoursef and please dont quote those who always divide and rule the history was made by shaeed beant singh and that was no human is better than other by birth or history . if guru does kirpa even shudra can become high class you are like phari rajay who refused to take amrit because of fake and ballony history

Re: HISTORICAL TASK BEFORE DALITS (Save SIKHISM from BRAHMINISM)

sikhadaraj · 04 Feb 2005

supremacy? you are the one whos saying jatts are sudras not me. by you saying this is ballony theory, can you explain to us then where do jatts originate from? this is not about caste, you are confused veereh, if jatts are a caste of farmers or sudras, then why are other sudras not known as jatts? why are other indian farmers not known as jatts? can you please elaborate how the above information is false? i have only given here what respected historians have found. Please do not attack the person posting dear brother, i apologise if i offended you, you are welcome to attack the message just proove its false tell us where jatts came from? i want to see how you put this brahmin jhatka pie together that says jatts are part of their 4th tier system. And i am the brahmin? you are the one classing jatts into sudras not me, when punjabis were pretty much hostile to brahminism in most of history. I am sorry if i upset you and i do believe in equality in sikhism. I was trying to say do not mix up facts of history. I have stated before in my last post if you cared to read that upon becoming a sikh the jatt has no caste/race. I do not see what your so gussa about when most punjabis were probably from the same place anyway at the time. Anyways last question is jatts were so low and downtrodden then how comes rai bhullar had loadsa land before he came into sikhi????? more examples for you if you wish.

Re: HISTORICAL TASK BEFORE DALITS (Save SIKHISM from BRAHMINISM)

? · 04 Feb 2005

what happen to 'PART 6'?

Re: HISTORICAL TASK BEFORE DALITS (Save SIKHISM from BRAHMINISM)

jaidev singh · 05 Feb 2005

veer i never said jats are sudras , but was quoting brahmins to which a single line answer i reject brahmin and his theory is sufficient just outrightly reject it by writing 11 posts what were you trying to proove ie jatts are not low see thats the catch you were trying to proove the superiorty you should talk about baba budha ji , dhana bagat baba deep singh ji , bhai jeevan singh ji, bhai sangat singh ji , bhai beant singh ji and so many thats our high and low and guess who is low iether all low or none

Re: HISTORICAL TASK BEFORE DALITS (Save SIKHISM from BRAHMINISM)

Kulwinder Singh · 05 Feb 2005

People calling them self Sikhs and providing long evidence to prove what? that some body is upper or lower ? Well, it is fine to discuss the problems of oppressed people but why would you want to prove something that you claim that you do not believe in ( caste system / Uper or Lower), If you want to deal with racism then you will have to use the word Black and white (If dealing with caste you will use the caste names)but If someone start producing evidence that a particular tribes of white is superior then others, then their intentions are at least tinted with some of this belief in them self. Or if somebody say that your tribe is lower and you get really heated about it and try to prove that they are not lower but actually higher then what it shows is that your attempts are fake and up to some extent you are fake too, sorry for the strong words. [%sig%]

Re: HISTORICAL TASK BEFORE DALITS (Save SIKHISM from BRAHMINISM)

sikhadaraj · 06 Feb 2005

jaidev we sikhs have no interest in what brahmins say about punjabis for their influence never hardly touched upon the lands that were run specifically by punjabis for most of punjabs history. But if a fellow sikh echoes what the gangu lalas say then we will respond with strong facts. There are many attempts by sanatanists trying to proove sikhs are part of this sanatan hindu web from the start, some even wear the bana and do other tricks, so we are constantly vigilant against them. By bringing jatts into this hindu caste system makes some of our youth believe we were sanatan hindus coming from shiv jis hair . However scientific, historical and scriptual proof speaks otherwise. I apologise for those who misttok the essay to make it look i think jatts are high, the point was much larger in one hit that jatts not only were a different ethnic grouping, but had their own raj and political power away from brahmins and hindus for them to be put in one group as sudras. i am not bothered argueing with you looking for little moral cracks over me, 1 post, 11 or 21. You make what you want. If you feel i am trying to say jatts are superior thats your own misinterpretation i couldnt care if jatts were slaves, if that was a fact i would categorically state that using historical accounts and artifacts to show that in response if a FALSE claim was made that jatts were kings if they were not. Some jatts were downtrodden and being such a large group some were warriors, rulers and landowners well before sikhism. Now why do you both have a problem with this when the facts are above? Veereh you do not know what my intentions are please ask before you accuse someone of making superior claims. I too can claim you are being narrow minded, and judgemental but i have not attacked any of you. So if brahmins believe jatts are low let them carry on, no one cares much for brahmins, or their sanatan dharm monkey tales. They are the real low ones for extracting peoples lives, wealth, and faith from them, so it is them who are the low ones. kulwinder singh over to you mr singh. I NOT KNOW HOW MANY TIMES I HAVE TO REPEAT, THE POINT I WAS MAKING WAS IF YOUR GONNA QOUTE FROM HISTORY THEN LET IT BE FACT AND USING ACCOUNTS. If its brahmin SANATAN DHARM LIES that contradicts what is written in black and white by historians, famous people and invaders then obviously im gonna stand up and point that out and i think most would. I do not understand why you both are attacking me for this detailed article its not mine but proffesional people who have spent their time researching using their skills. I would rather look at that than listen to a monkey brahmin fantasy tale. I have already stated at the time most punjabis were more or less the same ethnic grouping regardless of what cast they are now hence this is nothing to do with high or low if we were the same thing seperate bakhari quam from brahmins and sanatan hindu dharm from the start. I do not need to proove anyones caste is higher or lower i only stated what historians qouted if you can counter that you are welcome buddy. Kulwinder thank you i am fake, please add more attacks to your list. So no reasoning on the debate itself so lets attack the poster instead. Take a peep into your inner self before you point fingers at others.

Re: HISTORICAL TASK BEFORE DALITS (Save SIKHISM from BRAHMINISM)

daljit singh · 06 Feb 2005

where i live the ramgharias are doing more damage to sikhi than a so called "jatt sikh from punjab" through 1)opening caste gurdwaras 2)seperating sikhs on caste lines and sending their children to go to ramgharia gurdwara 3)those children growing up then keep their caste beliefs to themselves from public view unlike their parents and still pretend to be casteless and then take shots at others behind their backs. 4)creating gurdwara constituitions that bar sikhs from other castes to be on the commitete panel 5)allowing hindu vishwakarmis ( parralel turkaan caste of hindus) on their panel to participate in gurdwara affairs 6)signatory oath that the sevedar declares they are owing allegience and committed to welfare for upliftment of ramgharia community ( as opposed to sikh community) hence sangat and pangat taken a new road in a ramgharia gurdwara. 7)wearing starch paghs, that easily fly off after being smacked up, and look like stick on hats. 8)creating friction between sikhs and muslims by doing a nagar kirtan with panj pyarey after the babri masjid 1992 demolition and calling the london news team to show that we sikhs are behind the hindus. This in effect led to gurdwaras being attacked elsewhere in england as well as tension simmering between muslims and sikhs. 9)close liaison between namdhari and darshan dasis ( inter relations who are known to be hobby nobby with indian gov) 10)Most of the sant deras are run by turkanns with turkaan majority and start as off shoots from ramgharia gurdwara. 11)With this new ramgharia tag They ridicule sikhs who are not the same as them by reffering to their castes as though they are superior, sophisticated the super educated from their second homeland africa. Within their own majority they throw their weight on others to show them here the turkan rules the roost and play devious clever games to make it look like everyone else are bad. 12) and then after diluting their own form of sikhi they want inter caste marriages with daughters from other castes and specifically target jats for this. at least the chumars are honest and say jatt sikh, the ramgharia have the balls to hide behind sikhi, nishan sahib, adopt the pagh and then shape it their own way and try to change sikhism to their own whims. Then criticise jats and play games while hiding behind behind the name of sikhi. The truth is they are not as oppressed as they make out to justify their own caste biases. They want to carry on where their forefathers left off, and if they want to build a society that is based on sikh principles then it is upto them to at least implement what the Gurus gave.

Re: HISTORICAL TASK BEFORE DALITS (Save SIKHISM from BRAHMINISM)

?? · 06 Feb 2005

what have dalits done to save sikhi so far in the last 25 years? Be that in punjab India or outside? dalits in punjab are most hindu how will they save sikhi from brahminism? The title of this sub thread is puzzling me

Re: HISTORICAL TASK BEFORE DALITS (Save SIKHISM from BRAHMINISM)

brahminbhootmurdabad · 06 Feb 2005

if jats were sudras then how comes they had all these north west empires and kingdoms while the brahmins walked around begging for money from the ruler? so who is the real sudra? the one who rules?? or the priest who begs for money? brahmins should reassess their holy books their conciousness seems to have failed logic when they penned their caste system down. Maurya empire : 324 - 232 BC Chandragupta Maurya - 324 - 301 Bindusara - 301 - 269 Ashoka - 269 - 232 Gupta empire : 320 AD - 515 Chandragupta I - 320 - 335 Samudragupta - 335 - 375 Chandragupta II - 375 - 415 Kumaragupta - 415-455 Skanda Gupta - 455 - 467 The Rulers of Bharatpur ( a jat kingdom ruled by jats) Badan Singh, 1724-1756 Maharaja Suraj Mal, 1756 - 1767 Maharaja Jawahar Singh, 1767 - 1768 Maharaja Ratan Singh, 1768 - 1769 Maharaja Kesri Singh, 1769 - 1771 Maharaja Newal Singh, 1771 - 1776 Maharaja Ranjit Singh, 1776 - 1806 Maharaja Randhir Singh, 1805 - 1823 Maharaja Baldeo Singh, 1823 - 1825 Maharaja Balwant Singh, 1825 - 1853 Maharaja Jaswant Singh, 1853 - 1893 Maharaja Ram Singh, 1893 - 1900 (Exiled) Maharani Girraj Kaur, regent 1900-1918 Maharaja Sir Vrijendra Sawai Kishan Singh, 1900 - 1928 (Exiled) Maharaja Brijendra Singh, 1929-1947 (Joined the Indian Union)

Re: HISTORICAL TASK BEFORE DALITS (Save SIKHISM from BRAHMINISM)

Kulwinder Singh · 06 Feb 2005

Sikhadaraj Ji, I said "up to some extent you are fake too" I am not saying you are 100% fake but the topic you are addressing with that much passion what you are trying to achieve, I did not say you made the evidence but "providing long evidence to prove what". Could you be more clear in black and white in small sentence what you are trying to prove. Just 1-2 sentences will do please answer the question. Thanks Kulwinder Singh

Re: HISTORICAL TASK BEFORE DALITS (Save SIKHISM from BRAHMINISM)

Thakur kaur Taksali · 06 Feb 2005

Guru Nanak Ji questioned ?? nay made fun of this shudra ruler vs brahmin superior thing in asa ki waar.. Guru Ji asks..how is it possible that the donor ( ruler shudra jatt sardar whatever0 goes to hell but the receiver of this donation ( brahmin superior high class) goes to heaven ??isnt it a joke ? bebe

Re: HISTORICAL TASK BEFORE DALITS (Save SIKHISM from BRAHMINISM)

brahminbhootmurdabad · 07 Feb 2005

Here are some negations and rebuttals to the false claim that Jatt is a so called "Caste". These rebuttals have not been and cannot be negated and the truth lies in the fact that Jatt is a Race and not a Caste as traditionally thought. Here are five rebuttals that will prove this point. 1) ETHNIC NATURE: If you look at the Nature of a "Caste", you will notice that its spread throughout India. Eg Caste consists of professions divided into four Categories called Varnas. The Caste System, in its present form, is further based solely upon birth. Thus, as per Caste Rules, Farmer Profession is categorized under Vaisya Category (Varna). And Remember that as per Caste SYSTEM in its present form, this is to be based upon Birth i.e. Farmer's son MUST ONLY be Farmer if Caste System has to be maintained. This point will further be used as a rebuttal in proving how Jatt is not a Caste. Now talking about Ethnicity, you will notice that Caste is not Ethnic in nature at all. Eg a Priest living in North of India will belong to a Brahmin Caste and a Priest living in South of India will also belong to Brahmin Caste. THERE IS NO ETHNIC SIMILARITY HERE. In the same way, NOTE VERY CAREFULLY that a Farmer of North India will be a Vaish and a Farmer of South of India will also be a Vaish. This Logic leads us to conclude that IF Jatt is a Caste (assuming the proposition that Jatts are Farmers) then Jatts must also be Present uniformly throughout India, (just like Brahmins) the land where Caste System is present. But observation tells us that Jatts are only present in Punjab, Haryana and parts of Uttar Pardesh. This gives an Ethnic Nature to Jatt Identity strongly proving the case that assumption "Jatt means Farmer" is false and thereby further concluding assumption that Jatt is a Caste is False too. 2) RACE PRESENCE: It should be noted that this discussion is yet not concerned with Historical viewpoint and raciological and archaeological study of Jatt History. Its just about rebuttals to how Jatt is not a "Caste". What it is then, is a matter of study that will be made in further papers. Caste is present in different Races. Eg Priestly Caste Brahmins are present in South Indian Dravidian Race as well as in North Indian Races. If its assumed that Jatt is a caste, why then are there no Jatts in, lets say, Dravidian Races? Again, the Ethnic Nature Rebuttal further strengthens this point and further helps this rebuttal in making yet another point in how Jatt is not a Caste. 3) FUNDAMENTALS OF CASTES: All the fundamentals, rules and regulations of Castes are goverened by Religious Law Books such as Manusmriti written by a man called Manu. All of these books are part of Hinduism, written by Hindu Mystics. Two thirds of Jatt Community does not follow Hinduism and thereby Manusmriti, that defines and regulates the basic backbone of Caste System holds no relevance for this two thirds of Jatt Community who are not Hindus but are Jatts. Yet another strong rebuttal as how Jatt is not a Caste. 4) PROFESSIONAL NATURE OF CASTES: Castes are professional in nature. Though Caste System further makes it a compulsion to make it based upon birth. But Jatts can be found in just any profession: Business, Politics, Sports and so on. Proving further Jatt is Not a Caste. 5)CASTE-EXCOMMUNICATION: This is yet another important point. As a punitive measure, the Caste of a person can be degraded if some pre-defined rules are not set i.e. a person who is a Brahmin can be degraded to a Shudra Caste and so on. Thus Caste follows the rule of Ex-Communication. But a Jatt born among the Jatts can, under no condition, be ex-communicated. Together, the above five points of rebuttals thereby confirm the fact without doubt that Jatt is not a Caste. Captain Bingley [3] quoted Thomason in 1899, "they are manly without false pride; undemonstrative; independent without insolence; reserved in manner, but good-natured, light-hearted, and industrious. No one could be associated with them for any time without conceiving both respect and liking for them".

Re: HISTORICAL TASK BEFORE DALITS (Save SIKHISM from BRAHMINISM)

Mr T · 01 Mar 2006

sikhi has no caste race or tribe. God made humans. I am glad to see many mix race marriages take place today. It is a dissapointment sikhs became stuck on this between themselves. maybe its time sikhs do their bit now to totally abolish the false notions of race and caste

Re: HISTORICAL TASK BEFORE DALITS (Save SIKHISM from BRAHMINISM)

opinion · 01 Mar 2006

i do eternally sympathise with the stigma suffering of untouchables in india and punjab. In england they have worked hard to lift themselves and have got somewhere. In my generation no one cares whatever caste someone is . But because they had it bad in the past and still in some partsof in india some of our untouchable bhais have taken it to heart too much and feel aloof and alienated from sikhs and punjabis yet our bhais continue to have guru granth sahib maharaj in the places of worship , believe in its message and are just as loyal as anyone else. but its also a great loss these bhais and bhens who suffered so much in history with the guru championing their cause could have made such beautiful deeply imbued spiritual sikhs by taking amrit and keeping rehat given Guru ji. The core things lacking are kes, amrit, and rehat. The grove rd birmingham ravidasi place of worship anyone on tabia are amritdhari as far as i am aware and they have a notice not to have any sants something of that effect on stage. Other than that these bhais and bhens ( untouchables from punjab) in my experiences have a lot of piar for punjabis and sikhs, and they should be more part of the sikh qom and participate in panthic matters. For this to happen our bhais and bhens must break out of the hindu fold. The hindu untouchables outside punjab are like a different bunch, their aims and objectivs differ and they can totally hijack the picture wrongly to suit their own tune. What i have stated here reflects only on the england bhais and bhens i have met and experienced brotherly and sisterly piar with i do not know what the picture is in punjab today, but know this much that rest of indias untouchables are for some reason still stuck in hindu rituals, they need to save themself first. then when they save themselves maybe they will become very good sikh, become panthic and help evolve sikhism into a casteless era with every other sikh. We should always rejoice in what we share first. There are many who will keep pointing fingers at these bhais and bhens because the very word chammar is like bad. But let us not forget they are an ever growing part of punjab. Its an injury to our religion to see these people branch off into caste sects when Guru ji had the lowest of the low in mind to transform into saint soldiers. the lowest of the low meek in ardas everyday veers. my own grandparents would say marry who you want but not a chammari. But if i ever had the blessing this is something i would go against because it feels so right to break a hate filled system that is built on titles heirarchies that Guru Nanak dev ji had defeated. We should hold university college sikh talks on this kind of ekta too beyond the pale of jathebandis. and when these caste scheduled join the stream of sikhi to become part of sikh panth then the panth can face a lot more ahead in both punjab india and england where sikhs are divided not knowing where they belong too busy to be a false caste join a few brothers on weekend for 6 pack beer than sit back and devote their energies collectively to advance the panth forward. they must slowly decide whether they belong to a religion or a caste. When they decide they are part of a central united entity all these caste groups will then have to face the next challenges as sikhs ie sikh girls converting to islam so join up all these ramgharias singh sabhas ravidasis. this is to all punjabis they need to sort their act out fast or els another generation of youth will keep walking away from false customs, because those outdated customs, stereotypes are totally unjustified and can never fit into the world in which we evolve into today. why do we want to keep loosing more people? its birthright to guide our bhais and bhens to sikhi through piar and not preaching. the best way would be to lead by example and demonstrate equality and love for all oppressed peoples on this regard. [%sig%]

Re: HISTORICAL TASK BEFORE DALITS (Save SIKHISM from BRAHMINISM)

veggi powa · 01 Mar 2006

caste is past let go of it fast cos it wont last

Re: HISTORICAL TASK BEFORE DALITS (Save SIKHISM from BRAHMINISM)

Just a Singh · 01 Mar 2006

sikhadaraj jee, I think that Rai Bullar was a Muslim Rajput Zamindar. I think you are confusing 'bullar' with the Jat name 'Bullar'. Rai Bullar was a Bhatti Rajput.

Re: HISTORICAL TASK BEFORE DALITS (Save SIKHISM from BRAHMINISM)

Dogra · 02 Mar 2006

Oh dear, North India was clearly populated before any 'aryans' came, as proved by Indus valley civilisation and Mohen dajaro. Here is a quote from an article:http://www.geocities.com/neovedanta/acxxvi.html In Conclusion we can say: That the present day beliefs about ancient Indian history are factually incorrect. They are based on European perspective with gross distortions due to colonial bias and interests. Prior to Indus Valley Civilization of Mohenjo-Daro and Harappa, there flourished a much progressive culture and civilization, which we may label as Vedic Period of ancient India. Recent discoveries in archeology, astronomy, ancient mathematics, and satellite photography lend unequivocal support to this claim. Based on these new facts, it can be safely said that the 'Aryan Invasion' theory is but a myth" Beggars belief that tere are those who will use any evidence to justify themselves. So if a person is originally of no faith, then later his offspring become Hindu faith, then muslim faith, then next offspring become Sikh faith, that individual suddenly becomes a different race??? yeah right!! India sub continent was not easy to get into via the Khyber pass as it was closed for 9 months owing to the cold. Also Ghengis Khan has thousands of 'relatives' does that make them all Mongolian????

Re: HISTORICAL TASK BEFORE DALITS (Save SIKHISM from BRAHMINISM)

Sher.B.Singh (Brampton) · 02 Mar 2006

it not only Hindus fault or Government, its the SIKhs Faulltt as well.

Re: HISTORICAL TASK BEFORE DALITS (Save SIKHISM from BRAHMINISM)

Jatt Soorma · 10 Mar 2006

Most of the Pakistanis are just a bunch of Chamars who were forcibly converted to Islam. Later on these converted Muslim Chamars started to pass themselves off as Jatts. The real Jatts amongst Pakistanis are very few. The real ones are the Gakkars, Janjuas, Tarars, Kharals, Chathas, Khokhars and a few others who share common names with us. The rest of these people like to falsely claim arabic ancestry. As for the first article, it seems to have been written by some Dalit organization. Beware of such Dalit propaganda, these are not only anti-Brahman, but also very anti Jatt. Kanshi Ram, the Chamar leader of the Chamar Bahusamaj Party has nothing but hate for the Jatts. Dalit propaganda is just as dangerous as Brahman propaganda. In fact I would say it is even more dangerous than Brahman propaganda. At least the Brahmans have more to worry about other than Sikhs, such as Muslims, Christians, Babri Masjit, Kashmir and Dalits. But these Dalits are obsessed with hating Jatts. in UP they want to dislocate the hard working Jatts off of their farm lands. Kanshi Raam wants Jatts to give their hard earned land for free to the free loading chamars of UP. So dont fall for Kanshi Raam's Chamar propaganda.

Re: HISTORICAL TASK BEFORE DALITS (Save SIKHISM from BRAHMINISM)

Pardeep Singh Bilga · 11 Mar 2006

Jaidev Singh wrote: "in the same way chamar word used by brahmin but remmember how proudly we talk about BEANT SINGH who killed bahmani" Which caste was Beant Singh from? (not that his caste actually matters, as he is a Sikh martyr- period) but I don't know many chamaars who use the name "Singh" (unless they are amrit-dhari of course- which Beant Singh wasn't) - they usually go for names like Ram/Chand)Dass etc -- also- don't know many non-amrithdhari chamaars who wear a turban- unlike traditional Panjabi Jatts/Julahay/Tarkhaans who kept either trim beard or full and pagg, but hadn't taken amrit. Bhul chuk maaf.

Re: HISTORICAL TASK BEFORE DALITS (Save SIKHISM from BRAHMINISM)

... · 11 Mar 2006

Bhai Beant Singh WAS amritdhari. He received amrit a few weeks before killing Gandhi. Same with Bhai Satwant Singh. There's no doubt about these facts.