Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Why do we hate M. K. Gandhi

Why do we hate M. K. Gandhi

Singh · 02 Feb 2005

Could some learned Gursikhs summarize for me why we don't like Gandhi. I've asked this question to a number of my family members and they just tell me that he sold us out, but didn't he die shortly after India was "liberated." They've also said other things but I don't know how factual they are. Apparently he didn't declare Sikh Freedom fighters to be freed from jails or something. I have to be honest, if someone asked me why I don't like Gandhi I don't really have a proper answer, infact I don't have one. So please someone educate me on this issue. [%sig%]

Re: Why do we hate M. K. Gandhi

Bhainji.. · 02 Feb 2005

I totally agree. I remember at school when we had "Ghandi day" to celebrate his approach of non-violence, I told my friends how he was betrayed Sikhs..yada yada..but when they asked for specifics, I kinda had no real evidence based answer..I would like some clarification too..What did he say or do?? [%sig%]

Re: Why do we hate M. K. Gandhi

Jarnail Singh Gyani "arshi" · 03 Feb 2005

Waheguru Ji ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji ki fateh. Read some of the past Issues of the INTJSA..International Journal of Sikh Affairs....published in Edmonton Canada under the able Chief Editorship of Dr. Awatar Singh Ji Sekhon Machaki. There is a lot of factual stuff in there that will clear ALL your doubts. For Subscription and past issues enquiry please contact. Address: Sikh Educational trust Box 60246, University fo Alberta Postal Outlet, Edmonton, Alberta T6G 2S5. Email: [address removed] Gyani Jarnail Singh Dhillon "arshi" Guest Editor INTJSA. As a short course on MK Gandhi.. He HIJACKED the Swadeshi Movement initiated by Ram Singh namdharee.. He HIJACKED the NON-VIOLENT MOvement of the Sikh Akali Lehr He called Guru Gobind Singh a BHULLAR DESH BHAGAT.... as compard to national HERO Shivaji.... this is agreat INSULT and msirepresenttaion of Sikhi and Guru Ji. He was the main Architect by having a fast unto Death stunt TO SABOTAGE the move by Dr Amdekar and his millions of Dalitsto convert to Sikhi He wrote a lot of Untruths and lies about Sikhi and the Gurus in his monthly magazines He was also one of those who lied to the Siksh about NO PAKISTAN..and thus the Sikhs got the worst end of the stick when Partition ocurred...even the Sarhadi gandhi got cheated by MK Gandhi...etc etc

Re: Why do we hate M. K. Gandhi

AnotherSingh · 03 Feb 2005

Gandhi: Behind the Mask of Divinity http://www.sikhspectrum.com/082004/gandhi_mask.htm Gandhi Branded Racist as Johannesburg Honours Freedom Fighter http://www.sikhspectrum.com/082004/gandhi_south_africa.htm

Re: Why do we hate M. K. Gandhi

Search For Tat · 03 Feb 2005

The best book on this subject on how Hindus have systematically destroyed Punjab, and Sikh, was written by Sangat singh. It is called Sikhs In History. It clearly has every speech, and time, and news ereport of events, and what MK Gandhi has siad about SiKhs. You will be shocked. Sangat Singh worked as policy maker in India, so had access to alot more info than most. A definate read.

Re: Why do we hate M. K. Gandhi

.................... · 03 Feb 2005

he was anti sikhi Juts like the RSS of today.

Re: Why do we hate M. K. Gandhi

Singh · 03 Feb 2005

Mohandas Gandhi was no friend of the Sikhs. He disrespected Sikhism repeatedly and flagrantly. He reffered to Guru Gobind Singh as a misguided patriot because he used the sword to defend himself. He insisted that Sikhs were Hindus. Once he said something along the lines of "I've read your Guru Granth Sahib and nowhere does it say anything about wearing Kirpans..."and thus that Sikhs should give up their kakaars. When Ambedkar, leader of the Dalits, expressed his desire to convert to Sikhism, Gandhi told him he shouldn't as there was not point since as a Sikh he'd still be a Hindu. Once, in a prayer meeting, Gandhi recounted what he had seen in Delhi. He said, "A Muslim brother fell on a banana peal. It must have been thrown by a Sikh". All this is from Sangat Singh's book. He overall was very anti-Sikh.

Re: Why do we hate M. K. Gandhi

sikhadaraj · 03 Feb 2005

well what has ghandi done for india? what did he do for punjab? if you or me go on a hunger strike and say peace peace peace will that free a country? common this is not fairyland.

Re: Why do we hate M. K. Gandhi

Redwhiteandblue Kaur · 03 Feb 2005

What did Gandhi have to do with the creation of Pakistan and the exodus of Sikhs from that part of Panjab? I was on the phone with my uncleji, and he starts telling me of this long trip that he took with his mom at age 4...how he was on the train in only his kachheras, and how he remembers very little about the trip except the brutal hunger and thirst. He blamed Gandhi for much of it...but I was a bit too overcome with the emotion of the story to ask why he blamed Gandhi. Any ideas?

Re: Why do we hate M. K. Gandhi

AnotherSingh · 04 Feb 2005

The Hindus has said that they wanted a united India, with Muslims and Hindus together. However, during congress meetings they would often make anti-Muslim remarks. Muhammed Al-Jinna, once a very staunch supporter of a united India, realized that Muslims would never be given equality in a country with a Hindu majority and decided that the only solution was the creation of an independant Muslim state.

Re: Why do we hate M. K. Gandhi

Partition and Aftermath · 04 Feb 2005

Sat Sri Akal: When the British were leaving India, they chose the representatives of the three religious communities of India: The Hindus, the Muslims and the Sikhs. They met with the British representative Lord Mountbatten to broker the deals of how India would be split up after the British occupation ended. The Hindus were represented by Nehru, the Muslims by Jinnah, and the Sikhs by Master Tara Singh/Baldev Singh. In the beginning, it would have been easy for the Sikhs to get their own homeland if they wanted to...even easier than the Pakistan that the Muslims wanted. However, the foresight of the Sikh leadership was poor and gullible. At one meeting between the parties concerned, Mountbatten even asked the Sikh representative Baldev Singh if they wanted a Sikh homeland. In his infinite wisdom, he stated to the press publicly something along the lines of "If the Sikhs want an independent nation, they will ask their Hindu brethern for it". (My father explained that Baldev Singh was a leading industrialist in India and perhaps due to his not wanting his businesses to be affected by a partition, he put his own greed ahead of Sikh interests). Baldev Singh upon his deathbed reportedly cursed himself for this decision over and over. Jinnah was a very smart and shrewd man. Without having to send Muslims to violently or peacefully clash with the British, the man was able to broker a deal for an entire country. By far, the Sikh have and are still losing the most of this all. They lost the best farmlands (in spite of this, Guru Sahib's Kirpa is Beant...Indian Punjab, once a swampy marsh is now out-producing Pakistan Punjab), thousands of Sikhs and the current tragedies of recent history and present. We have nobody to curse but out own near-sightedness. People blame Tara Singh and Baldev Singh (and others in that time period)...but what were the rest of the Sikhs doing? They followed these people with full faith, demonstrating that there was a general lack of awareness of basic politics and reality. Clinging to the belief that their Hindu brethern would be ever amicable to them, they were awakened to a tragic reality right after independence, when Nehru and the entire Brahmin Regime bared its teeth at the Sikhs and commenced its siege against the Panth. Whether it be the dressed up politicians in immaculate Kurta Pajamas, the Khaki Chaddi RSS, the thug-goon Shiv Sena, the cerebrally poisoned Arya Samaj or others, the Brahmin onslaught has been attacking the Sikh Panth mind, body and soul since independence. Who can we blame then and now? Nobody but ourselves. Through this, a Sikh can only ask for the strength to follow the Almighty's Hukam through this tough time.

Re: Why do we hate M. K. Gandhi

. · 04 Feb 2005

Even before Gandhi came to India in 1915, the Sikhs had been peacefully protesting for the right to run their Gurdwaras (after the Sikh kingdom had been annexed, the Gurdwaras had been turned over by the British to Brahmin Hindus to run). Gandhi was very critical of the 'Sikh way' of civil disobedience. He said: "The Akalis (Sikh Warriors) wear a black turban and a black band on one shoulder and also carry a big staff with a small axe on the top. Fifty or a hundred of such groups go and take possession of a gurdwara; they suffer violence themselves but do not use any. Nevertheless, a crowd of fifty or more men approaching a place in the way described is certainly a show of force and naturally the keeper of the Gurdwara would be intimidated by it." (Collected Works of Mahatma Gandhi, Vol. 19 pg. 401). This is where I do not understand Gandhi's teachings. On the one hand Gandhi did not believe non-violent resistance should be "passive," but rather that it should be, in essence, a "force". On the other hand, he criticized Sikhs for practicing non-violent civil disobedience in seeking control of their Gurdwaras. Their methods were even praised by British leaders. Reverend C. F. Andrews wrote: "The vow (of non-violence) they (the Sikhs) had made to God was kept to the letter. I saw no act, no look, of defiance." As far as the spirit of the suffering they endured, the Reverend said "It was very rarely that I witnessed any Akali Sikh, who went forward to suffer, flinch from a blow when it was struck. The blows were received one by one without resistance and without a sign of fear." Still, Gandhi could not reconcile this manner of civil disobedience, for he decided that the Sikhs participating in it harbored "hatred in their hearts" and thus never gave his blessings to such forms of agitation. Gandhi could not understand why Sikhs would peacefully protest while wearing arms. To him, this constituted cowardice, that one carries arms while walking in peace. I completely disagree. Gandhi failed to realize the differences between non-violence of the weak, and non-violence of the strong. The importance of carrying arms was to show that they were indeed brave enough and capable of using them, but that they were instead consciously choosing not to. It is a discipline that only a few select can conquer. A coward who is weak and scared will never wear arms and walk in peaceful protest because, as soon as the first signs of oppression arise, he will be scared and use his weapons in haste. Similarly, the weak and the scared will never have the capacity to make non-violence their way of life. To them it will only be something useful when they are helplessly bound in shackles. To be able to wear arms and to not retaliate or show the slightest bit of anger or attempt self-defence against someone who is attacking you is the highest form of non-violent protest. It implies a complete resignation to peaceful ways and an absolute belief in the power of non-violent protest despite the ability of the protestor to respond violently. It is one thing to walk in peaceful protest that is born out of a feeling of helplessness and quite another to walk peacefully, inviting oppression and suffering upon himself despite being fully armed, while totally being able to fight back. The first constitutes a cowardice, the second a force. I can't help but think that the sort of non-violence practiced by Gandhi's followers in India was that of the weak, that of the helpless. I believe that most did not truly understand the principles of non-violence in the manner in which Gandhi preached it. Rather they just thought they would be unable to win independence through other means. I come to this conclusion because of the history of Indians both before and after Gandhi. An obvious fact is that Indians as a race have been oppressed for the last several hundred years by the Moguls (and later on by the British). Many of them never uttered a word of protect against the atrocities that were committed against their kith and kin, atrocities which were much worse than those perpetrated by the British. Even fewer actually took up actions against the Moguls (the major exception of course being the Marathas in the south). It was quite common for invaders such as Abdali and Nadir Shah to invade India, take Indian jewelry and Indian women and head back to Afghanistan. Yet there were very few strong voices that opposed this. This was because of fear. This fear is what stopped them from participating in any course of action besides submitting to their oppressors. It seems like over time most Indians have developed a "learned helplessness". Following Gandhi's ideas arose from this feeling of helplessness. Indians followed Gandhi's beliefs not because they thought non-violence was a superior weapon in dealing with social problems, as Gandhi had preached, but rather because they felt they had no other alternative. This in itself defeats the whole purpose of non-violence. It was quite common for Indians to one day be peacefully protesting and the next day to form lynch mobs. The only conclusion I can come to in order to reconcile these two thoughts is that they had no idea what the real essence of non-violent agitation was. The simple fact that after Gandhi his philosophy of non-violence has been completely abandoned by the people of India at large seems to point toward this conclusion. To me, Gandhi came across as being an uncompromising extremist. A non-violent extremist, but an extremist nevertheless. His letters to the British people during World War Two encouraging them to "allow yourself, man, woman, and child, to be slaughtered" by "peacefully surrendering" to the Nazis in order to further his fanatic ideas of non-violence is a perfect example (CW Vol. 72 pg 229 231, CW Vol. 72 pg. 177). When pressed even further, he went to the extent of calling Guru Gobind Singh, the Maratha Shivaji and George Washington "misguided patriots" for taking up arms in defense of their people (CW Vol. 26 pg. 486-492). Had Gandhi lived under the likes of Aurangzeb, in almost all likelihood he would have been arrested and hanged for even showing the slightest bit of defiance to the Mogul Empire. His non-violent ways worked because the British were not total tyrants, rather just concerned with exploiting Indians for their own economic gain. The aim of the British was not to annihilate them, as Aurangzeb and Hitler had attempted to do to their subjects. Thus the situation was ideal for the implementation of non-violent agitation. According to Gandhi, only "evil and violence" came about from those who use violence. He seems to totally disregard the idea of a "noble cause", basing his ideas of whether a movement was right or wrong on his narrow view of whether or not non-violence was being used. No doubt history has shown that those who used violence for the sake of unworthy causes ultimately did perpetuate violence and evil upon themselves. But, at the same time, those who used violence because of noble causes (as in defense of their people), the rule did not apply. There is a certain undeniable beauty in watching or reading about others who are fighting for noble and legitimate causes. Perhaps one of the best examples I can bring up is reading about the American Revolution. There is a certain magnificence, a certain holiness, about those people fighting for their rights. The fact that they used arms to achieve their freedom did not discount the righteousness of what they did.