Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Kulwinder Singh thanks to all

Kulwinder Singh thanks to all

Kulwinder Singh · 04 Feb 2005

Dear all thanks for taking time and contributing in the discussion. The topic of the discussion was “ Sarabloh Fanatic Brahmin of Sikhs ? The last thing in the text is ? and it was their for a reason and that reason was that I am asking question, I had my opinions about Sarbloh which is clear as anything, I do not have anything against Sarbloh, I know many great Sikhs have fallowed it and their Jeveen is admirable, I just issued statement that fanatical use of it does need clarification/ reasoning or investigating, I am interested in knowing other opinions. Although this debate is not new in any sense but internet does give chance to everybody who is on the net to say what ever they want to say in much more relaxed way then you can do in private discussions. Although most of the people who do follow Sarbloh does not show anger when discussed in private about the sarbloh, of course they disagree but they do not get frustrated as some people got on the form, that can be for two reasons, first they do not know who the hell am I, as they do not know me in person like other singhs know me in personal circle, Second what my intentions are, am I hear asking question or putting people off the Rehet. It is my firm belief that those who have choose to follow the rehet of Sarbloh will not be put off from it, as that is they choose to do, it is not done by pressure but rather choice. I was shocked to learn that some people actually questioned my intentions, which was the most disturbing part, I felt really sadden by this and thought to my self that have I done something really bad, then Guru Sahib answered my doubt that if, I did something intentionally to hurt somebody and my aim is to make somebody give up their Rehet then I am wrong, but as my intentions is to make sure that we do not end up like being Brahmins, just clinging to Rituals and outlook then real religion and inner look of our beliefs, then I have nothing to fear or be sad. I raised the question fundamentality about the Fanatical Element in the Sikhism. My Mistake that I used the Sarbloh as topic front, this was my mistake and I unconditionally accept that, this is because many people felt that I was targeting the Sarbloh or AKJ which is absolutely wrong and completely the opposite of what my intentions was although I do accept it was not presented in most favourable way. Then I had replies from Vir Kulbir Singh Ji and Gaini Jarnail Singh, they criticised me well with their knowledge and information even MK Khalsa, gave some fantastic volume to the debate, I even sent email to Bhai Kulbir Singh Ji and Mk Khalsa to reply more with their comment as I wanted to know their opinion in genuine way. Both Vir Kulbir Singh and Jarnail Singh gave solid replies, Nearly everybody reply was impressive some came to support me but mostly shared the opinions of the Vir Kulbir Singh ji, it shows that What is the difference between the Voice of Good Gurmukh Like Vir Kulbir Singh and Stupid git like me. I said in my post that I am not stubborn and I will change my mind providing I am convinced. One Vir Bhupinder Sing have labelled accused me me of Blasphemy , I do not know since when asking questions is Blasphemy? But I will send this vir personal email rather then communicating with him on the form because form should not become the focused on individuals. Most Form replies were against my view and I have to accept that. I have learned some useful facts for myself and I like to share with other so if somebody else think like me then they can at least browse though that. 1 It is wrong to critisise something which you have not done yourself or had first hand experience for yourself. 2 It was wrong to pick sarbloh as front end for fanatical element debate. 3 One must make mega additional efforts to express one’s intention when dealing with sensitive topic. 4 Be very sensitive when dealing with people over the form as some people behind the form are very relaxed and some are additional sensitive and you never know you may end up hurting somebody. So take extreme care. I am quite interested in giving a trail to Sarbloh rehit, but I will only do when I feel that I am doing because of love not because I want to experiment like some kind of lab setup because that is against Sikhi to my knowledge. Also I want to express what my intentions was to bring out of the Greatness of Sikhism which I feel some time we eclipse with our narrow mindedness and our behaviour. 1 Sikhism have lot more to offer to the rest of the world then we most of the Punjabi Sikhs realise. We are narrow minded in grasping the comprehensiveness of Gurbani. When Guru Nanak imagine he Imagine like this: gagan mai thhaal rav cha(n)dh dheepak banae thaarikaa ma(n)ddal janak mothee || Upon that cosmic plate of the sky, the sun and the moon are the lamps. The stars and their orbs are the studded pearls. And what we end up imagining is just our self and that circle of ours, we are Just Frog of a pond. Khoo de Dadoo. 2 Guru Nanak went far-far away to bring people together, Guru Granth Sahib Ji is Guru of the Whole world. No body who have little knowledge, after knowing even basic chracterstics of Guru Granth Sahib Ji can be dismissive of the Glory of Guru Granth Sahib Ji. What we want to do is make very difficult for ourselves and for other to have a glimpse of Guru, and without Guru it is all dark. ( that is Brahmins did kept the world in the dark, it served their purpose for many centuries). World deserve better, world deserver Guru Granth Sahib Ji’s communication, that is how we going to last as human race other wise in the changing world we will end up killing each other. 3 Even just with the historical links, we can provide Haleemee Raj all over Asia. If we just stick to the teaching of our Guru then we can reform the whole world. Imagine Khalsa Raj all over the globe. What we are bothered about just some kind of Khalistan ( Not Khalsa Haleemee Raj) which will end up in the hands of some Corrupt Punjabi So Called Sikh Politiaion who know nothing about humanity never mind Sikhi. 4 The language of Guru, Gurmukhi is on decline in the world, Many people in Punjab are not bothered about Punjabi reading and writing skills, those people who are suppose to be defenders of Sikhi are the Butcher of It. Nearly all So Called Sikh Politition are beyond comprehension selfish and stupid. Average Sikh love to think all the damage done to Sikhs is Via third party rather then ourselves. We can not stick together, we find it hard to agree to disagree, Everybody want to be a leader rather then follower. We hate each other so much that we do not even want to see each other growing. We deliberately make efforts to show others down. 5 We look for our difference to stay away from each other, we love to make comparisons and generalisation on the basis of A. Caste B. Pind C. District D. Region E. Political affiliations F. Religious affiliations G. Social Affiliations H. Education I. Modernisation J. Financial Affiliation K. Colour L. Nationality M. Ethnicity N. Language O. Family Background And god knows what else. Basically what ever we do we are fare more destructive then constructive in our contribution. I just wanted to make point that we should concentrating on building links and Love rather then crating walls and forts around us, which does not server any purpose to Sikhi in General. I made mistake in bringing sarbloh as front end of much more complex debate. I am sorry about that. I want to categorically declare that my intentions was never to bring anybody out of rehit or show AKJ down. My presentation of Topic fell well below the standard, I would like it to be, and I am sorry about that to everybody. Please forgive me. Vir Kulbir Singh Ji have said “Veer Kulwinder Singh jee. We need you on our side and not against us.” And my Answer to that is with folded hand and lowered head is Vir Jee I regret that I gave you even 1 micro second to think that I am not on your side or any other Guru Sikh’s side. I do not have any other side so the question to be against you or any Guru Sikh is completely out of question. I am moorakh and Papi so please find a space in your heart to forgive me. Please never ever think that I am on any other side then Guru Gobind Singh Ji’s side, I do fall extremely short of expectation of my Real Father Guru Gobind Singh Ji, But What ever I am, a really bad, Stupid, papi but I only belong to Guru Gobind Singh Ji. One more time I am sorry if I hurted anybody’s sentiments that was not my intention so please forgive me. I love you all and hopefully we will have many more interesting discussions. Thanks to all of you from the bottom of my heart. Aap Ji da Moorkh Kulwinder Singh [%sig%]

Re: Kulwinder Singh thanks to all

Kulbir Singh · 04 Feb 2005

Veer Kulwinder Singh jeeo, Whether you agree fully with us or not, one thing I have become convinced of is that you are a person with good intentions and are definitely on our side. Please accept my apologies for suspecting that you were not on our side. Baaki Veer jeeo, may Guru Sahib do kirpa on us and may we follow his hukams and keep his rehit. May Guru Sahib make our journey here a success. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: Kulwinder Singh thanks to all

Jarnail Singh Gyani "arshi" · 05 Feb 2005

Veer Kulwinder Singh ji, waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh. I second kulbir singh ji's views above. I assure you i took no offense at anything you may or might have said..we are all here on GURU's Side..Guru Arjun Ji Himself has said that MY Dharra is with WAHEGURU....unlike some who make dharras with their relatives, rich zamindaars, politicians, whatever... I only depend on WAHEGURU....and similalrly we all depedn on Waheguru Ji. I look forward to more questions and opinions from you. Jarnail Singh

Re: Kulwinder Singh thanks to all

bhopinder singh · 05 Feb 2005

veer kulwinder singh if you read my post i was not against the content of discussoin, but the heading you chose . it was dubious and above all no sikh and i repeat no sikh should ever be compared with brahmin or bipr cause you are either bipr or khalsa as for sarbloh i dont know much but was told by someone who taught me whatever sikhi i know to never make fun or mockery of the singhs who practise it ie are they fanactical brahmins cause by doing that i am not doing anything to the individual but making fun of the way of life many singhs shoose over death ie shaeed bhai anokh singh bhhai balbir singh aned so many so be very careful and respetful as i already mentioned i am not against the content of discussion but was merely trying to speak for the singhs who are no more in ters of physical body but while living they loved it

Re: Kulwinder Singh thanks to all

?? · 06 Feb 2005

no sikh of the Guru will ever sit back and allow shaheed singhs to be insulted like that. Countless Great SHaheed singhs fought were sarblohis. Besides who wants to eat from the hands of a drunk? someone whos been screwing around in clubs one night before? lack of hygeine? bad thoughts in their mind ie gossip? people who smoke? and prepare meat carcasses at home? nail varnish and lipstick somethered over their physical frames? Sarbloh rehat bibek are important.