Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Takht Patna Sahib calls meeting on Nanakshahi calendar

Takht Patna Sahib calls meeting on Nanakshahi calendar

Rashminder Singh · 08 Feb 2005

Takht convenes meeting on Nanakshahi calendar Tribune News Service Amritsar, February 7 The Takht Patna Sahib Management Committee has convened a joint meeting of all the Sikh high priests, presidents of the SGPC and the Delhi Sikh Gurdwara Management Committee and representatives of all the Panthic organisations at Patna Sahib for March 13 to discuss the Nanakshahi calendar. The invitation regarding the proposed meeting was received by the Panthic organisations today. Though the SGPC had implemented the Nanakshahi calendar last year, the same was not endorsed by Takht Hazoor Sahib and Patna Sahib. These two Takhts had been observing Gurpurbs as per traditional Bikrami calendar.

Re: Takht Patna Sahib calls meeting on Nanakshahi calendar

S Singh · 08 Feb 2005

Too right as well. The Nanakshahi calendar is not accepted and was forced on to the Sikh quam by the SGPC. For centuries we have followed the Bikrami calendar and all of a sudden some Canadian thinks he has a better Caledar. He can keep his calendar and I continue to use the BK calendar.

Re: Takht Patna Sahib calls meeting on Nanakshahi calendar

gkd · 09 Feb 2005

for know every1 should accept the akaal takhts decission till they decide to go reconisder etc. the akaal takht is right even if wrong.

Re: Takht Patna Sahib calls meeting on Nanakshahi calendar

S Singh · 09 Feb 2005

Ha ha that is a funny statement. I will rspect the decisions of the Akal Takht once a proper Jathedar is appointed by the Sikh Panth and not by the SGPC. You can do what you wish but I have no intention of following the SGPC sposored half cooked Canadian calendar.

Re: Takht Patna Sahib calls meeting on Nanakshahi calendar

so true · 09 Feb 2005

Agree S SINGH, its sad that Akal Takht is ran by a SGPC man, not not some the Panth appointed. Bikrami calendar all the way.

Re: Takht Patna Sahib calls meeting on Nanakshahi calendar

sarcastic · 10 Feb 2005

yeh akhal takht is always rite they say eat meat so lets all meat, i mean ther neva rong r they? ;) so lets all start eaten meat!

Re: Takht Patna Sahib calls meeting on Nanakshahi calendar

Kulbir Singh · 10 Feb 2005

It is sad that the Hindu-minded pujaaris of Takhat Siri Patna Sahib and Takhat Siri Hazoor Sahib are insisting that Sikhs retain the Brahmin calender – Bikrami Calender. It was such a piteous situation before the introduction of Nanakshahi calender. SGPC used to wait for Pandits of Hardwar to come up with the new year calender before they were able to announce the dates for Gurpurabs. We used to depend on Pandits of Hardwar to tell us what day our Gurpurabs would fall. How can a faith that is so much dependent on other faith stay independent? Thanks to Jathedar Tohra's Gurmat stand in accepting this Nanakshahi calender and thanks to Bibi Jagir Kaur for implementing this calender despite furocious opposition from Hindu-minded Sikhs like Pooran Singh and Sant Samaj. It is hurting the Hindu-minded pujaaris of the above stated Takhats to see Sikhs coming out of the clutches of Brahmins. I think under every circumstances, Sikhs should free Takhat Siri Patna Sahib and Takhat Siri Hazoor Sahib from the Hindu-minded Sikhs. These Takhats must come under the control of Guru Khalsa Panth. SGPC should move to take control of these shrines. We recently visited Takhat Siri Hazoor Sahib and Takhat Siri Patna Sahib. Hazoor Sahib is controlled by very Hindu-minded Sikhs. They even wear bindi (a dot or a mark) that Hindu women wear after marriage. I think this bindi that they are wearing now will soon become a tilak in the future. Their practices and maryada is very dubious and it hurts the heart of every Sikh to just helplessly watch them abuse Guru Sahib’s darbar. They have so much audacity that they even placed a bindi on Mata Bhaag Kaur jee’s picture. What a beautiful picture that is but they ruined it by putting a bindi on the forehead of Mata jee’s portrait. While we were having darshan of Nageena Ghaat Gurdwara Sahib, we met a gursikh there who told us that he lives permanently in Naded (city where Hazoor Sahib is). Narrating his story he told us how he had came to get darshan of Hazoor Sahib about 5-6 years ago from UK and could never go back. He fell in love with Hazoor Sahib. He sold his property in UK and permanently moved to Hazoor Sahib. Upon his arrival he discovered that he had a uphill struggle living in Hazoor Sahib. The local Sikhs, who are very Hindu-minded don’t welcome Punjabi Sikhs. They only want them to come for a visit and not to live permanently. Pujaaris should be replaced with SGPC accepted Granthis. Sikhs can never go back to the old Hindu calendar and I request the Hindu-minded Sikhs to give up this futile fight. Please let the Sikhs stay free from the clutches of Brahminvaad. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: Takht Patna Sahib calls meeting on Nanakshahi calendar

S Singh · 10 Feb 2005

>>Sikhs can never go back to the old Hindu calendar and I request the Hindu-minded Sikhs to give up this futile fight. Please let the Sikhs stay free from the clutches of Brahminvaad. There is no logic to your point above. I am not Hindu minded but I am not giving up on a calander we have used for centuries in favour of one designed by some Canadian. You think our Guru would not have left us with a calander if they felt the BK one was wrong ? You, the SGPC and co obviously know more than our Guru.

Re: Takht Patna Sahib calls meeting on Nanakshahi calendar

S. Singh · 10 Feb 2005

I agree with Kulbir Singh Jee. I remember when I visited Nander Sahib. The pujaris of Nander have no nimrata and no manners on how to talk to Punjabi Sikhs. They discriminate against Punjabi Sikhs and do not employ them. After much struggle, one Punjabi Taksali Singh managed to get employed there as a Granthi. I remember when I was about to Matha-Taik to Guru Jee at Hazoor Sahib, I first stood infront of GUru Jee doing a short ardaas for about 30 seconds. I had my eyes closed, then all of a sudden I was interupted by one pujari with a pink coloured dot on his forehead who started to scream at me for taking so long. I was furious, and gave him an angry look for rudely disrupting my ardaas. It seems like they have no concept of Nimrata or even manners for that matter. and it wasn't just me, but I observed that they did this to almost anyone who stood infront of Guru Jee for a few seconds long. My experiences in Patna Sahib were similar. The Bihari 'sevaks' are very rude and need to learn how to talk to visiting sangat. My experiences in Punjab Gurdwaras was not disappointing at all. The sevadars in SGPC run gurdwara treat the Sangat with the respect and dignity they deserve. Same thing with the DSGMC run Gurdwaras.

Re: Takht Patna Sahib calls meeting on Nanakshahi calendar

Premi · 10 Feb 2005

---- agree with Kulbir Singh Jee. I remember when I visited Nander Sahib. The pujaris of Nander have no nimrata and no manners on how to talk to Punjabi Sikhs. They discriminate against Punjabi Sikhs and do not employ them. After much struggle, one Punjabi Taksali Singh managed to get employed there as a Granthi. =----- And you think the SGPC ones are any different.Running around in there cholas and drinking alcohol on the premises of Harmander SAahib and Keshgarh Sahib? -------Thanks to Jathedar Tohra's Gurmat stand in accepting this Nanakshahi calender and thanks to Bibi Jagir Kaur =------ Come on Kulbir Singh I expect more Giaan out of you? The kuree maar and Tohra sell-out of the panth is now worth thanks. These are the biggest thugs in the panth, good thing one finally kicked the bucket. Hey maybe you should thank Badal to because he got alote of funding for the 400 th Gurpurb?Of which he funelled alote to RSS, his right hand. Have you actually read your post? It is all applicable to all Gurdawaras both hear and in India. They have jots in Harmander Sahib, Akal Takht etc aswell. But SPGC says they are not allowed?They do not apply there own maryada in there run gurdwaras? Don't you think The Guru would have changed the Calendar during there tenure on earth?I would have thought so?Did they not make the Khalsa perfect before they left. In the end all of our Granthis etc need to be re-trained and given a renewed light and faith in banee. Which is what they are lacking. No offence to anyone, but lets be a bit more sensible.

Re: Takht Patna Sahib calls meeting on Nanakshahi calendar

SINGH · 10 Feb 2005

Guru Saahib didn't make a different calendar. The Bikrami calendar was used. So does this mean that this calendar should be used by sikhs forever and anything else is manmat? The gurus didn't make a different set of measurements (ie, length, weights, etc.). Should we use the same one they used? Are we indulging in manmat by using different systems? Systems of time measurement used by our gurus was different. Are we indulging in manmat when we use different systems? If the gurus set something down as a rule or as a unique system for us, then we should follow that without hesitation or question. If the gurus told us to avoid something, we should follow that. That is gurmat. If something affects the status of the panth or the guru or our own avastha, then it can be classified as gurmat or manmat. If it is something to do with a sikhee principle, then it can also be classified as gurmat or manmat. Things such as dates, measurements, etc, that were in common use by all of society, but which had little effect on their own on the panth, were left alone, and have nothing to do with gurmat or manmat. When a gurpurab is celebrated, we are celebrating the event. Many gurdvaras will have the akhand paat sahib on the weekend and not on the exact day. This isn't manmat. No gurmat principle is being broken. Similarly, the panth has seen a need for a new calendar. This need didn't exist at the time of the guru's, but now exists. The guru's didn't create the bikramee calendar and didn't tie us to it in any way. They used it because it was useful at the time, but no gurmat principle is tied to it. If so, please explain what principles are tied to using that calendar. The panth (and yes, love 'em or hate 'em, the SGPC and Akal Takht sevadaars are more representative of the panth than any single jatha or smaaj out there) has decided to implement this calendar, no gurmat principles have been broken and this decision should be respected.

Re: Takht Patna Sahib calls meeting on Nanakshahi calendar

kaur 156 · 10 Feb 2005

Waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh I had a different experience at Sri Hazur Sahib (nader). My dad had an accident and my mum told me to call the head Granthi whoe name was?? and in the shock she gave me the wrong name, so I ran to Hazur sahib and in front of Guru Ji I started shouting at the Gyani ji and giving him attitude as he could not think of a person of that name. So the sangat is looking at me as i am stressed but then he came with me and was really helpful when talking to the doc to make sure my dad got better. Waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh

Re: Takht Patna Sahib calls meeting on Nanakshahi calendar

khalsa · 10 Feb 2005

so for the people who support the bikrama calendar, would you rather have our gurpurbs and events dictated by some Pandit jee every year?

Re: Takht Patna Sahib calls meeting on Nanakshahi calendar

S Singh · 10 Feb 2005

To Khalsa So what if a pandit calculates on what day an event falls on. If you have a problem get some Singh trained up and get them to do it but dont start using a mickey mouse Canadian calander. Frankly I could not give two hoots if a pandit, budhist monk, christian priest or muslim mullah worked out the days for events. They are just doing a job rather than making up the dates (like the Canadian behind the new calander according to what they think is right) To SINGH If the Bikrami calander was good enough for our Guru then what makes it wrong now ? There was no need to change to a new calander. Tomorrow a German or UK Singh may design another new calander for Sikhs, you going to change it again ?

Re: Takht Patna Sahib calls meeting on Nanakshahi calendar

Kulbir Singh · 10 Feb 2005

------------------ -------Thanks to Jathedar Tohra's Gurmat stand in accepting this Nanakshahi calender and thanks to Bibi Jagir Kaur =------ Come on Kulbir Singh I expect more Giaan out of you? The kuree maar and Tohra sell-out of the panth is now worth thanks. These are the biggest thugs in the panth, good thing one finally kicked the bucket. Hey maybe you should thank Badal to because he got alote of funding for the 400 th Gurpurb?Of which he funelled alote to RSS, his right hand. ---------------- So you are saying that Jathedar Tohra did nothing good at all? Well, one thing he did good was that in the early nineties Sant Samaj came up with a parallel Rehit Maryada which changed Mool Mantr, and took away reference to Guru Panth Khalsa. Surprisingly they allowed Sikhs to eat meat. Jathedar Tohra took a very tough stand against this so-called Panthak maryada and the so-called sants had to back off. I am not an advocate of Bibi Jagir Kaur or Jathedar Tohra and know that they are no saints but this does not mean that we should ignore any good deed did by them. If it had not been for Jathedar Tohra we would have been begging Pandits of Hardwar for our Gurpurab dates. Good or bad, Bibi Jagir Kaur has taken some very impressive stands while in office. Just yesterday, she took a strong stand against unauthorised translations of Siri Guru Granth Sahib jee and installing the translated version on the throne of Guru Sahib. It was during her tenure that SGPC took a strong stand against the same-sex marriage and it was she who took up the courage and declare Sant Bhindranwalae shaheed. ----------- Have you actually read your post? It is all applicable to all Gurdawaras both hear and in India. They have jots in Harmander Sahib, Akal Takht etc aswell. But SPGC says they are not allowed?They do not apply there own maryada in there run gurdwaras? ------------ You should go and check out SGPC run Gurdwara Sahibaan. I personally found them in much better shape than Patna Sahib. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: Takht Patna Sahib calls meeting on Nanakshahi calendar

SINGH · 10 Feb 2005

S Singh, to find out why there was a need to change, first read explanations put up by the guy who made the calendar and then the explanations offered by the SGPC. And what does the fact that the guy was from Canada have to do with anything? Would it make you feel better if he was from Punjab? Or Hardwar? Have you looked at the reasons behind him picking dates? You seem to be suggesting that he just randomly picked dates. There was a lot of thought behind the calendar and it was before the SGPC and Akal Takht for several years before it was implemented. It may not be perfect, but definitely better than the older one. If you have a reason based on Gurmat for not accepting it, then please share that. By the way, if the system of measurement used during the guru's time was good enough for them, what is wrong with it now? Why do we use a different system? If tomorrow some other guy brings a new calendar (regardless of of where he's from - Germany, UK, Iceland or Mongolia) and it isn't against gurmat and the panth accepts it, yes, I'll accept it. I don't have that much ego that if something isn't against gurmat and is accepted by the panth, that I'd fight it.

Re: Takht Patna Sahib calls meeting on Nanakshahi calendar

A Singh · 10 Feb 2005

From Ang 923, Ramkali Sadd: raamadhaas sodtee thilak dheeaa gur sabadh sach neesaan jeeo ||5|| The Guru then blessed the Sodhi Ram Das with the ceremonial tilak mark, the insignia of the True Word of the Shabad. ||5||

Re: Takht Patna Sahib calls meeting on Nanakshahi calendar

SINGH · 10 Feb 2005

A Singh, are you saying that tilak is a sikh tradition?

Re: Takht Patna Sahib calls meeting on Nanakshahi calendar

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 10 Feb 2005

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki fateh. This is a very real dilemma we face when we discuss the SGPC/Akal Takhat/Jathedars/Tohra/Bibi jagir Kaur/badal etc..... the Bad is misxed up with the GOOD...some like Badal are MORE BAD 95-05 than good..some like Tohra and Jagir kaur are 50-50...and the jathedars are "appointees" I personally heard one Jathedar telling us in Selayang that one of his ears was held by Badal and the other by Tohra...so please refrain from lodging any complaints with him !!!!...but go straight to Tohra/Badal instead....and this from a jathedar who wants to be treated as equal to the Pope !!!. I can sympathise with veer Kulbir Singh... I feel exactly the way he feels...I have no love lost for most of the leaders in sgpc/jathedars etc in Amrtisar today because they are not following Maryada...but at the very least they are MUCH BETTER than the Hindu controlled Takhats patna and Hazoor sahib..where the Maryada is more Hidnu than Sikh...there we have "MONI" sewaks..when Gurmatt and Gurbani says Waheguru is NOT PLEASED by being Moni ( silent), there we have praying to PHOTOS of Guurs etc, tilaks being put to photos etc...aartees of Hindu types being performed to Guru Granth ji, Jyots and conches etc etc. The nanaksahi Calendar ( although NOT the BEST as it has many many khameean shortcomings..but never the lesss MUCH BETTER than the Hindu based Bikrami calendar) is a good step in the right direction..THIS is why the Hindu lobby/Sant samaj etc are having a fire under their seats..and they fought tooth and nail to kill the NC at birth..and still continue this fight to kill it...in MALAYSIA the SANT SAMAJ followers refuse to Follow the NC and continue to celebrate their Gurpurabs separately from the MAINSTREAM. The Muslims have their own calendar, the Christains have TWO, Hindus have their own, The Buddhists also have their own, the Jewish have their own....WHY shouldnt SIKHS have their own ?? WHY should we accept the "Slavery" of the Hindu pandits in this regard ?? Why settle for "Gurpurab dates not out yet...jantri not yet come... can anybody call Amrtisar please ?? and the answer from Amrtisar is we are waiting for a phone call from HARDWAAR...and then having TWO Gurpurabs in ONE year and NOT any in the NEXT ??..Vasakhi on 13th and then 14th ?? Why cant we settle for the SINGLE date that we set and the Entire Panth celebrates on world wide scale.?? WHAT is the SIGNIFICANCE of the changing dates ?? On a PERSONAL LEVEL why dont we also INSIST on using the Bikrami calendar for our own Birthdays/wedding Anniversaries etc ?? THAT would be WONDERFUL !!! ask the Pandits of Hardwaar which day is MY WEDDING ANNIVERSARY ?? MY BIRTHDAY ?? isnt that a "double standard" ?? WE have OUR OWN Lipi ( which the GURUs designed), we have Our Own GURU, we have our own GURMATT, we have our own GURBANI, we have our own BANNA, our AMRIT, our own GURPURABS...and WE should DECIDE when to CELEBRATE our own GURPURABS. The "TILAK" in the Gurbani Tuk above is the SACHA NEESAAN of GUR SHABAD in the POTHI SAHIB that was passed on from GURU AMARDASS JI to GURU RAMDASS JI to signify that HE was the nEXT GURU. This same POTHI was passed on from GURU NANAK to GURU ANGAD..to GURU AMARDASS JI. The "tilak" mark is a FALSE NISHAAN as opposed to the SACHA NISHAN of GURU SHABAD !!!! MARKS on the forehead have NO SIGNIFICANCE in GURMATT/GURBANI. This Bani also tells the SIKHS to DO NIRBAAN KIRTAN, CALL the "pandits ( sikhs) of GOPAL KESO ( WAHEGURU) and read GURBANI ( instead of the PURAANS) . People have been wrongly translating these tuks as GURU JI instructing His SIKHS to call the PANDIT adn read the PURAAN ??? IF PURAANS and PANDITS are still Necessary then what is GURBANI for ?? Jarnail Singh

Re: Takht Patna Sahib calls meeting on Nanakshahi calendar

S Singh · 11 Feb 2005

SINGH Good to see that you respect the Sikh Guru who also used the BK calander to mark events. You, the SGPC etc obviously have more trust in a Canadian and are wiser than our Guru if you think you know better than them when it comes to calanders.

Re: Takht Patna Sahib calls meeting on Nanakshahi calendar

Harpreet Singh · 11 Feb 2005

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh Daas has been reading posts on this thread. Although the thread started with discussion about Takht Patna Sahib decision to convene a meeting on Nankshahi calendar, some posts have changed the track to issue of management of gurdwaras and the behaviour of management/granthis. Daas had the opportunity of living and studying at Guru Nanak Dev Engineering College, Bidar which is around 160 miles from Nanded. Guru sahib blessed us with frequent darshan of Takht Sri Hajoor Sahib. It might have been around 7-8 month period out of 5 years that I spent at Nanded. Very often we used to sneak out of college, and get laaha of seva and sangat at the Takht sahib. Bhai Kulbir Singh has mentioned that the pujaris are brahmins and these takhts are under control of the government. I would like to share my experiences about the management of Nanded/Bidar gurdwaras. I know there are many practices which are followed in the gurdwaras there and these are against gurmat e.g. During keertan of Aarti every evening they light the jyot and in morning they prepare the chandan tilak while keertan of Sri Asa Ki Var is being sung. But which gurdwaras these days are 100% free of these sort of manmats/kamarkaands. Go to Gurdwara Baba Deep Singh Ji in Amritsar, I remember my mother in law (who follows such karam kands just like any other old bibi even after lot of arguments) to take a box of Desi ghee and pour that into the jyot. I was surprised to see the queue of people doing this during my first visit to the gurughar. To my surprise people from all corners of world come to this gurughar just to perform this ritual. There are so many shops outside the gurdwara sahib just for selling desi ghee at high cost. I can give numerous examples of itihasik gurasthaan who are being managed by SGPC where so many karam kaand are followed. Bhai Kulbir Singh ji has said that these two takhts are controlled by government. I would like to ask a simple question. Who controls our main takht today? Is it the panth or Baadal? Is badal panth? Unfortunately we cannot close our eyes when such things are hapenning under our own nose. Anytime one of these two takhts takes a stand we shout at peak to oppose them. I can agree that they are wrong if others were right. But that's not the case. We have as panth never tried to go and join ourselves with the sikhs of these two places. Only once Bhai Fauja Singh tried but the pujaris at that time were not willing to discuss. But did we tried ever again. These karamkaands are being followed at these places from over 100 years. Do you think just by telling them once or twice they will stop? It takes ages to make a wrong right. Patience is the key to success. Guru sahib is looking over everyone. The day he decided this practice should stop it will stop. Out duty is to keep trying. Dass had the opportunity of looking/observing/participating in lot of the issues at these two places. Although there were some unfriendly people but not everyone. Some of the granthi singhs and even the Jathedar of Takht Sahib was very gurmukh. I am no one to judge but his jeevan was 1000 times better then likes of Badal/Tohra. At Gurdwara Nanak Jhira sahib, the head granthi was so gurmukh. Dass had great admiration of Bhai sahib. He left for sachkhand in front of my eyes. His jeevan was that of a true gurmukh. There were some granthi singhs at these places who got in our sangat and slowly started joining our programmes of Sri Akhand Paath/Rensabais. Slowly they came to understand lot of things about gurmat which they had never heard of or had no chance of understanding. REASON: Most of these sikhs have been sikhs from long times just because there forefathers were. They come from hindu background. They are very small community. They still end up marrying women from hindu families who then become amritdhari. But due to lack of gurmat knowledge keep on following lot of hindu rituals. Daas knows singhni of Bhai Hari Singh (laangri singh there), who was amritdhari bibi, she did so much seva and there was so much pyaar for the sangat, but she weared a BINDI and her dress was Saari. This was not because she liked it, it was because she was never ever told that it was wrong to wear this. I have seen gurughars here in west where granthi singh will do parkaash only on a Sunday at 10AM. Will not even bother to do his nitnem. But we will still proudly say that our gurdwara follows Akal Takht rehat maryada. One more very important contribution of sikhs of Nanded/Bidar. During movement so many juhaaroo singhs used to come and stay at these places when it was very difficult for them to find any safe place in punjab. There were numerous occasions that sangat helped them out. A sikh boy was shot dead by DCP of police in my presence when sikhs were protesting against the construction of unauthorised mandir by Shiv sena activists in gurdwara land at Nanded. Sikhs there ended up teaching them a lesson. I still remember that it was only that community of Sikhs. None of the members of SGPC, Akal Takht, no punjab media highlighted this issue. Just because that takht is not under OUR control. I feel pity when we proudly say that Akal Takht is under OUR control and Nanded Takht under government control. Unfortunately we forget that takht can come under nobody 's control because it is takht of Sri Akal Purakh. Yes what is under control is the golak/power for these places and unfortunately to me it feels like Takhts in punjab are under worse management control. Let us talk of unity of all the takhts. Let us talk of unity of Sikh sangat all over world and most important let us talk about dispersing gurmat knowledge to people all over world. Bhai Kulbir Singh, daas has a benti, I read ur posts with great admiration, but this post made me feel that it was biased. As a Gursikh we need to learn as much as we can and also try and distribute this knowledge to others. Your expereince might not have been very good this time but next time it might be better. There are all sorts of people in this world. Its our luck at what time what type of people we end up meeting. But based on these we should not make judgement about a community of which those people are part of in general. No one community if good/bad. Individuals have their own karam, their own thinking. At end of day our motto is to share gurmat. Lets not critisize those who did not liked or followed gurmat, may be its there karam which are stopping them from doing so. Bhul chuk di khima da jaachak Daas Harpreet Singh [%sig%]

Re: Takht Patna Sahib calls meeting on Nanakshahi calendar

Kulbir Singh · 11 Feb 2005

Veer Harpreet Singh jeeo, thanks for pointing out possible judgemental errors in my previous email. You are right that Siri Akal Takhat Sahib indirectly is controlled by Akali Dal Badal but I think they are mostly worried about political stuff. I don’t think Badal cares whether you read Raagmala or not and whether you light jyot or not. He only cares that his political career stays up. For this reason I don’t think he interferes in matters that are totally religious in nature. When I was referring to Panthak, I meant that the maryada followed by Gurdwaras under the control of SGPC is much closer to Gurmat than other Gurdwaras that are run by private institutions. I know that SGPC is not perfect but we are fortunate to have a central committee that governs and safeguards the interests of Sikhs. Just take an example of Hindus. How iniquitously their religious chief Shankracharya was treated recently by police but Hindus were unable to do anything. During the eighties and early nineties government was able to commit excesses but now I cannot imagine they arresting and humiliating Jathedar Vedanti jee the way they did to Shankracharya. Yes SGPC is not perfect but it is doing a lot of good work too and I have noticed that they are not getting credit for it. It has become a fashion to bash and badmouth SGPC. I think we do great disservice to Panth by bashing and undermining SGPC in public. Everytime SGPC and Siri Akal Takhat Sahib takes initiative to do anything good, they almost always face opposition from either Iqbal Singh of Patna Sahib or by Hazoor Sahib management. They violated maryada and created a rift in Panth by issuing a decree against great book Mundawani written by eminent scholar Giani Gurdit Singh jee Chandigarh. They don’t understand that they are playing into the hands of government by making tamasha of Sikhs like this. If a book can be published in favour of Raagmala (“Raagmala Bani hai” by Taksal) then I see nothing wrong in publishing a book against Raagmala. If they say that their sentiments were hurt by Mundawani, I say that our sentiments were hurt by trying (but failing in this purpose) to prove extracts of a love story to be Gurbani. I agree with you that perhaps we have not tried to do parchaar amongst the Sikhs of Hazoor Sahib and Bihar. As for taking laaha at Hazoor Sahib, which Sikh’s heart would not cry out for Siri Guru Gobind Singh jee maharaaj when visiting it. This is the place where Choji Preetam Siri Guru Gobind Singh jee Maharaaj spent so much time and this is where he shed his human body. One good thing about Hazoor Sahib is the availability of good rooms to stay but this is because of efforts of Punjabi Sikhs under Baba Nidhaan Singh jee. They built very good residential rooms for pilgrims to stay. I apologise for implying that all South India Sikhs are bad. This is not the case at all and as you mentioned in your email, there are some really good South Indian Sikhs. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: Takht Patna Sahib calls meeting on Nanakshahi calendar

Harpreet Singh · 11 Feb 2005

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh Bhai Kulbir Singh Ji, Thanks for posting the last message. Daas does not in any case wants to undermine the importance of SGPC and Sri Akal Takht Sahib. The only thing I wanted to point out was that we need to compare like for like. Badal would have every interest in gurmat related issues as his links with RSS won't let him Sikhi principles flourish. Anyway I didn't wanted to start a new debate about Badal etc. My only concern was giving bad name to a group based on actions of certain people. Daas is very thankful that you have understood and corrected what was wrong. Just further on about my experience, dass along with many other singhs had studied at Bidar around the period 1992-1997. Guru sahib blessed us with too much chradhikala keertan akhaade and Gurbani paath parvaah. Initially there was opposition from gurdwara parbandhaks. There were people who used to make all sort of noises to throw us out. But as time passed with more and more keertan parvah many families started joining in these nearly every day samagams. We studied less and enjoyed keertan/bani more. We did not had any gurmat parchaar in my mind. We used to do it as we were some hungry souls dying for gurshabad. But it had such a positive effect on some Dakhni(south indian) sikhs there, they attended big samagams in punjab with us, became tyar bar tyaar and kept full sarabloh bibek rehat as well. I haven't gone back since 1997 and moved out of India but I still long to get darshan of both the gurasthaan and the singhs there provided they are still in that city. Another very good thing which I brough back for my life from nanded was the love for sarabloh shastars. Daas was able to make a big collection of sarabloh shastars inlcuding Tega, Khanda, Goliya and many others as Nanded provided best opportunity. Lot of sikhs there whose forefathers used to prepare these shastars for Guru sahib's fauj are still in the same profession and that's one of very good things about Nanded. Its our Arms factory. Its even possible to get some rare and puraatan shastars from these sikhs. I won't go any further else I may end up choking this thread with out of context messages. Bhul chuk di khima da jachak Daas, Harpreet Singh

Re: Takht Patna Sahib calls meeting on Nanakshahi calendar

SINGH · 11 Feb 2005

S Singh, you've obviously exhausted your arguments. You just keep repeating the same thing without answering anything.

Re: Takht Patna Sahib calls meeting on Nanakshahi calendar

S Singh · 11 Feb 2005

Well SINGH you have no answer do you. If our Guru could see no flaw in the BK calander and used it, what makes you think you and your pro Canadian calander buddies are wiser ? It would not have taken our Guru Ji long to devise our own calander if they saw it fit. Stop pretending you know more than our Guru !

Re: Takht Patna Sahib calls meeting on Nanakshahi calendar

Kulbir Singh · 11 Feb 2005

----------- If our Guru could see no flaw in the BK calander and used it, what makes you think you and your pro Canadian calander buddies are wiser ? It would not have taken our Guru Ji long to devise our own calander if they saw it fit. ---------- Veer S. Singh jeeo, Guru Sahib merely used the available calendar at their time. During the times of Siri Guru jee, Bikrami calendar was the best one and the most accurate one too. It was more accurate than the Lunar calendar followed by Muslims. But Guru Sahib have not approved or rejected any calendar. If Guru Sahib had written that Sikhs should use only Bikrami calendar then surely you can say that we are going against Guru Sahib’s hukam but Guru Sahib did not pass any comment on this calendar. During the times of Guru Sahib different measures of recording time were used i.e. Visuye, chassey, khin, Gharreeyaan and Pehar etc. but now we use seconds, minutes and hours. Does this mean we are disobeying Guru Sahib by doing so. All sants and mukhees of different deras have used modern measurement of time. Why are they so adamant about the new Nanakshahi calendar then? Guru Sahib used seyr, mann, and we used kilos, pounds and grams etc. Are we disobeying Guru Sahib by doing so? I don’t think so. Guru Sahib used horses, carts, and palkees to travel but we now use cars, buses, trucks and aeroplanes to travel. Are we going against Guru Sahib’s hukam by doing so? If we were to use your line of argument then we would have to be like Amish people who still don’t use cars, electricity or machinery. Guru Sahib used the best calendar those times and did not ordain anything on it. We are free to use the new calendar. If tomorrow we find out that there is a better way to record time, we should surely adopt it, so long as it does not affect the spiritual life of a Sikh. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: Takht Patna Sahib calls meeting on Nanakshahi calendar

Rashminder Singh · 11 Feb 2005

I totally agree with Bhai sahib kulbir singh ji May vaheguru bless his panth with aapsi pyaaar and show them right marag......... SGPC removed the Keski compulsion from Sri Akaal Takht Sahib and other deraas and sampardaas agreed with them in a minute Then Deraas & Sampardaas forcibly started Love Story from Kaam Kandlini (Raag maalaa) at Sri Akaal Takht Sahib and SGPC coudnt even stop them.......... Then Meat Eating Confusions were arised in panth by SGPC i.e Missionary Colleges :( How much more to come now.............. I agree with Bhai Sahib Harpreet Singh Ji that our takhts are not in care of gursikhs else why would we see jyots in darbaar sahib & why raag maalaaa was started again in Darbaar sahib and Sri Akaal Takht Sahib Vaheguru [%sig%]

Re: Takht Patna Sahib calls meeting on Nanakshahi calendar

avidya · 12 Feb 2005

Gurfateh No, there is a flaw in that argument Kulbir Singh ji. If the aim of the thing were to be knowing exactly HOW MUCH something weighs, and the old system is correct, then why change it if it were created by the Gurus? The analogy is flawed because the very aim of the calendar is to celebrate the correct date during the year, otherwise why not celebrate gurpurab everyday? When another calendar means we are no longer celebrating gurpurab on that historical occasion, doesn't that defeat the point of gurpurabs? Lets be a little more serious here - the motivation was, since Sikhi is a 'world religion' among others, why rely on another religion for the calendar? I would argue that Bikrami calendar is an Indian calendar, not owned by Hinduism. The motivation was probably not to actually worship gurpurabs correctly, but to cut Sikhi off a little bit more from 'hindu' links. But to my mind this is one more step toward Kala Afghana style self-mutilation whereby nothing is left. Surely if this is the issue of why Sikhi should rely on hindus for anything, you should also be removing the hindu terminology from Gurbani, or are we saying that such language was common parlance of the day among sadhus of all persuasion?

Re: Takht Patna Sahib calls meeting on Nanakshahi calendar

S Singh · 12 Feb 2005

>>Veer S. Singh jeeo, Guru Sahib merely used the available calendar at their time. During the times of Siri Guru jee, Bikrami calendar was the best one and the most accurate one too. Once again you manouvare away from the question and go on to make all sorts of unconnected remarks about other measures of time etc. By your above remarks are you trying to imply that our Guru were not capable of designing a calandar and so we had to wait centuries for some Canadian to do it ? I am of the opinion that our Guru were men of very high learning and if they had any qualms about the BK calander they themselves would have designed a Sikh calander. I say your arguement in favour of the new Canadian calaner is seriously flawed.

Re: Takht Patna Sahib calls meeting on Nanakshahi calendar

SINGH · 12 Feb 2005

"If the aim of the thing were to be knowing exactly HOW MUCH something weighs, and the old system is correct, then why change it if it were created by the Gurus? " avidya, what are you talking about? The point is that the guru's DIDN'T make it. Just like they didn't make the BK calendar and didn't ordain sikhs to use it. "When another calendar means we are no longer celebrating gurpurab on that historical occasion, doesn't that defeat the point of gurpurabs?" Actually, the vast majority of people would say that with the new calendar, we are finally able to celebrate gurpurabs on the actual day. It's not flucuating from year to year anymore. Makes much more sense. S Singh, you're just confused. It's clearly been shown that the BK calendar wasn't ordained by the guru's. That's the bottom line. There is nothing wrong or anti-gurmat in starting a new calendar. The panth has accepted it and panthic gursikhs will go with it. Confused and stubborn people like yourself will continue raising confused and stubborn arguments, but in the end, the new calendar will stay. It's already more widely accepted than the BK calendar.

Re: Takht Patna Sahib calls meeting on Nanakshahi calendar

blue · 13 Feb 2005

Waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh S Singh has made a point but I don't think anyone has answered him satisfactorily but given examples of the Gurus using horses and different measurements. Horses were not wrong to use, different ways to measure were not wrong, the BK was also not wrong else the Guru would have thought of something better, for example if the Gurus did not agree with something they would change it and invent something ot replace that. Sikh beliefs are a key example. If BK was celebrating Guru Nana Dev sahib Ji's gurpurbs at the wrong time then my simple question is: Would Guru Gobind Singh Ji allow this to happen? Waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh

Re: Takht Patna Sahib calls meeting on Nanakshahi calendar

S Singh · 14 Feb 2005

SINGH It is you and your Nanakshahi backers who are confused and in effect insulting those who have been using the BK calander for centuries. Our Great Guru Ji were OK with the BK calander. Also read my points I have not said it was made by our Guru but it was used by them. You still dodge the issue of why our Guru Sahib did not design a calander if they thought the BK one was not good.

Re: Takht Patna Sahib calls meeting on Nanakshahi calendar

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 14 Feb 2005

where did the idea that the "BK Calandar" is about celebrating gurpurabs at the "wrong" time spring out from ?? This si not the issue. The ISSUE is that we need a SIKH Calendar so that WE SIKHS decide when to celebrate our Gurpurabs. With the BK this is decided at KANSHI?BENARAS etc wherever the pandits sit.....and with the Nanakshahi Calendar AMRITSAR will decide this. BK/Janrees/...called KHALSA JANTREE....but 80% of the STUFF is like janam din vishkarma ji, janam ashtami gandhi ji, barsi of so and so SANT Ji, janam Namdharee baba jagjit singh ji...barsee of...barsee of barsee of.. durga ashtami, navratree.. mela beas, langgar beas, nanaksari nagar kirtans etc etc..I ask the BK's WHAT has all this got to do woth SIKHS ?? WHAT are these "days" doing in a SIKH CALENDAR called KHALSA JANTREE..??? WHY are puranmashis, sangrands, etc etc included...when any "special day" is ANTI GURMATT in Gurbani. DONT we have "ENOUGH" Sikh Guru's GURPURABS, shaheedee dins of SIKH SHaheeds, Martyrs, soldiers, great personalities etc..WHY is there no mention of any SIKH Women, Birthdays of Great Women Like Mai Bhago, Maata Khevee Ji, Mata Gujjar kaur Ji, Maharani jinda Ji, Mata Ganga Ji..etc etc etc in these so called KHALSA JANTREES prepard by Benaras Pandits Dont we have any self respect ?? You wont find Guru Gobind Singh ji's gurpurab in a Muslim calendar...so why is Eid etc in the Khalsa Calendar?? I find no mention of any Guur Ji gurpurabs in Hindu jantrees.. Christians DONT celebrate Jewish holydays...for the simple reason they are not jews...are we STILL HINDUS ?? WE want to decide on our Gurpurabs...any day any time BUT we decide not the pandits. jarnail Singh

Re: Takht Patna Sahib calls meeting on Nanakshahi calendar

S Singh · 14 Feb 2005

I will state this till I am blue in the face. If our Guru thought it wrong for us to use the BK calander and though it was inaccurate etc they themselves would have created a calander. If our Guru can write our Guru Granth Sahib Ji do you not think they were capable of writing a calander ? This topic is now bordering on espousing hate against pandits of Benares and Kashi in the incorret belief that this will help justify the new Canadian calander. Frankly I could not care less if pandits, budhists, jains, jews or aliens, worked out the dates. It is possible to use a computer program to work out the dates so we could get some Sikh kid to work out dates according to the BK calander if this puts an end to this pandit tripe that some people keep mentioning. What has now happened is that instead of following the Bikrami Calendar the Nanakshahi has simply adopted the Christian Calendar, but of course the name Nanakshahi has been given to it. The names of the months like Chait, Baisakh etc. and names of the days like aykam, dwitia, Poornamaa, amaavas etc. come from the Bikrami and lunar calendars. Our Gurus lived on earth using these names also. In Gurbani one can find these names of the months and days.

Re: Takht Patna Sahib calls meeting on Nanakshahi calendar

sajjan singh · 23 Jun 2005

it shows that we want simply to change one master to another (who is unknown to us ). guru ji has given great imprtance to the motherland and asked us to be ready to sacrifice our life for the honour of our country. by adopting calender designed by a candian and the other country's calender simply changing the names without any research and facts - which is against the guru sahib's guidance. hence, i feel that instead of following the foriegner/malech calender we should follow khalsa jantree prepared by fellow country man. If you are so interested in starting a new calender make through research bring it to the notice of panth and after approval impliment it. we are already divide our self into deccani and punjabi sikhs. the way people live in the native state they speak the local language of the region. i request bhai kulbeer singh to come and visit any sikh houses in deccan and find out himself how the punjabi speaking sikhs and the deccani sikhs recite their gurbani and how they adhere to the sikhism. the fact is that, many punjabi speaking people recite gurbani nitname from hindi lipi whereas the deccani sikhs recite from gurmukhi lipi (not punjabi) . the deccano people are completely gurusikhs where as the so called punjabi sikhs most of them are patiit. these are the facts from hyderabad deccan area. hence so please don't create and offend the deccani sikhs now onwards. check your self before pointing finger towards others.

Re: Takht Patna Sahib calls meeting on Nanakshahi calendar

ssingh · 23 Jun 2005

there is a scholar on the Sikh calendar that stays around the north american west coast. I have heard his ideas of why he opposes the "nanakshahi" calendar. He has Many points, and he completely slams the pro-arguments. Those who are praising the Nanakshahi calendar as a savy move to dissociate from Hindu-thought are mistaken. I recommend you seek out this guys knowledge and address the issue in light of that before voicing your ignorance.

Re: Takht Patna Sahib calls meeting on Nanakshahi calendar

Kulbir Singh · 23 Jun 2005

Sajjan Singh ----------- by adopting calender designed by a candian and the other country's calender simply changing the names without any research and facts - which is against the guru sahib's guidance. -------------- Veer Sajjan Singh, the person who designed the Nanakshahi Calender is not an outsider but from a Sikh background. His name is Pal Singh Purewal. He is a resident of Canada but he still is from Sikh background. This calendar was presented to SGPC and it was reviewed by a committee of Sikh scholars who after making some amendments in it, approved it. -------- hence, i feel that instead of following the foriegner/malech calender we should follow khalsa jantree prepared by fellow country man. If you are so interested in starting a new calender make through research bring it to the notice of panth and after approval impliment it. we are already divide our self into deccani and punjabi sikhs. -------- The Deccani Sikhs have been cut off from the mainstream Khalsa for too long and for this reason they have developed some very dodgy practices, that are not in accordance with Gurmat. Siri Akal Takhat Sahib has approved this calendar and Deccani Sikhs must approve it. And again I repeat that this jantri has been prepared by a Sikh and not by a malech as you wrote. ------------ the way people live in the native state they speak the local language of the region. i request bhai kulbeer singh to come and visit any sikh houses in deccan and find out himself how the punjabi speaking sikhs and the deccani sikhs recite their gurbani and how they adhere to the sikhism. the fact is that, many punjabi speaking people recite gurbani nitname from hindi lipi whereas the deccani sikhs recite from gurmukhi lipi (not punjabi) . --------------- May I kiss the feet of Deccani Sikhs who recite baani from Gurmukhi lipi and by the same token shame on Punjabis who recite baani from Roman or Devnagri lipi. Gurbani was written in Gurmukhi lipi and as such must be recited in its original Gurmukhi lipi. ---------- the deccano people are completely gurusikhs where as the so called punjabi sikhs most of them are patiit. these are the facts from hyderabad deccan area. hence so please don't create and offend the deccani sikhs now onwards. check your self before pointing finger towards others. ----------- Deccani Sikhs should adopt the Nanakshahi calendar and should not break off from Panth by continuing to adopt the outdated Bikrami Calender. As the matter of fact, I appeal to our Hindu Brothers too to adopt the updated Nanakshahi calendar or create their own calendar on similar grounds as the new calendar. The new calendars are more accurate and there is nothing wrong in adopting it. Kulbir Singh