Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Are Sikhs A Race?

Are Sikhs A Race?

enquiry karni ah · 09 Feb 2005

can someone define if quam means race? if it does then to my thread question are sikhs a race? what makes a race? im not too clued up but from what i understand its like blacks, europeans, gypsies, germanic, nordic, turkish, then india with loads of its own different races. But how do sikhs become a race if sikhs are meant to be universal? like i heard theres sikhs in south india, sikhs in punjab, afghanistan, america whites, bengal, and UP (pahari type sikhs). These are all different races with their own disctinctness. so how can sikhs be a race if they are many races? Then if sikhs do qualify as a race biologically are they meant to be a race according to any sikh scripture? i recall someone saying that guru jis were against caste and race pride so being a sikh race would not be contradictory?

Re: Are Sikhs A Race?

Gurcharan Singh Kulim · 09 Feb 2005

The short answer to your enquiry is ...YES Sikhs have been defined as a race,in todays terms.That is eactly the same type of question i once asked-in 1982 of jathedar Gurcharan Singh Tohra,when he visited my home in ancestral village. His answer was not convincing, and I pointed this out to him at that time.The issue of "Sikh kaum han yaan nahi" was raging then, and all the Panth was divided-another point I pointed out to him that it was not healthy to create such divisonal issues with the Panth-such issues were unproductive any way. But I beleive having understood their point, I realised their concern was to keep the divison from the Hindus and keep an independent sikh identity-therefore it became an apparent that they had misused the tranlated meaning from the word kaum. However all these changed with the ruling of the mandla case.The three appeal judgesof the High court pointed out that given todays interpretation a race cannot be defined only on the basic biological definitions or one single geographical area.It had to encompass more, like the common geographical area,customs, traditions and language and biological features.Within that wider definition Sikhs qualified to be a race of people-kaum. This amy be argued to be a tecnical interpretation, but it is a legal interpretation, and part of the law now afecting Sikhs in this country. Hence it is based upon this definition that Sikhs are asking for a separate monitoring of the Sikhs-legally they have a a sound case. I dont have the time now,but I can expand soundly upon this.For yourother argument, as to what happens to a Black or white or even a chinese Sikh-well legally they belong to the Sikh kaum-but their ethnic origin may not be so.Ethnically their (Nasal) may be Chinese ,Thai or white.Nasal is the nearest Punjabi word for the ethnic origins. May I aslo point out that often the word kaum has been wrongly used to define the diferent races,the correct word used should have been "nasal" ,however some far more well versed Punjabi writers may disagree with me. The other final point is that as most of the operational language in those days was urdu,the punjabi language though highly developed,was not spoken accurately.There was not much emphasis in the Punjabi grammer-which only came about very much later, after much of the spoken Punjabi(which was spoken very poorly and crudely in the majority) language had firmly made its base in the Punjabi homes. Examples of such can be seen even today, when people address each other in the word ..."Tun" instead of "tusin".The word "tusin" is see by many to mean plural, which is wrong.It is a more polite, respectful and correct way of addressing an older person or speaking politely. There are many other instances...like "tusin ki karde ho?", is never said ,but one may mostlyhear "tun ki karda yaan?"Sadly, attempts have never been made to correct when people speak wrongly,rudely and crudely,therefore the mistakes carry on.The situation becomes more complicated when such Punjabi is spoken abroad, as the younger generation model it and dilute it wrongly further. It is in the light of such poor language practice,often the word kaum has been wrongly used. Now we often get similar in the English language, for example like the word Gurduara,translated into english,it is said to be a temple.Then the word jathedar- is often refered to as the "pope" of the Sikhs!! In the chardhi kala of the Panth Gurcharan Singh Kulim

Re: Are Sikhs A Race?

Kulwinder Singh · 09 Feb 2005

if you look for the definition, how world describe race then Absolutely Not , 100 % not, It never was , It is not and It never will be.

Re: Are Sikhs A Race?

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 09 Feb 2005

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru ji Ki fateh. I agree with veer ji GSkulim that Punjabi language has not received the due attention...not from its own sons and daughters and not from the Punjab Govt and not from the Indian Govt. It has been portrayed as the Gawaar language of Jattboots types of rustics simpletons fools..look at how the "punjabi sikh" characters speak in Bollywood and also punjabi films made by punjabis. IN fact Punjabi is a much finer language, more polished than Urdu/Hindi. Our Gurus did not just choose Punjabi without any thought... it is worthy of Dhur Ki bani aiyee tin saglee chint mitayee...then it is worthy of worldy literature of the finest grade. Sikhs are a KAUM....which can be translated as NATION. A "Nation" can have as many ethnic - nasal permutations as one likes. So Just as the JEWS are a NATION and have Ethiopian Jews, Russian jews, etc..SIKHS can be a "NATION" that encompasses chinese sikhs, american sikhs, italian sikhs, jewish sikhs, punjabi sikhs etc. Hopefully we can stop further rot from setting in..speak Punjabi at home ..and make sure it is the correct punjabi. Sadly the so called Punjabi Papers and magazines..like Ajit Jalandhar etc are all using highly hindicised punjabi.....and our local Punjabi papers ( i am referring to malaysia which has the one and only Punjabi paper in the entire region)..have fallen on low times so much so that the people employed to translate english news to punjabi use dictionaries to translate word for word literally which ends up making no sense at all.These translators are imported from Punjab... ( Capable Editors that can actually write original pieces in punjabi are non existent....even those imported from PUNJAB cant write a single sentence in punjabi..??? Jarnail Singh

Re: Are Sikhs A Race?

$ÍÑGHZ "®" |<|ÑGZ · 09 Feb 2005

Doesn't quam mean nation though?

Re: Are Sikhs A Race?

Gurcharan Singh Kulim · 09 Feb 2005

My apologies in the rush to give an answer and complete before I left the house,I ommited to mention kaum may be translated more accurately as nation, as veer Jarnail Singh ji has pointed out. But then the issue also arises, when like one jathedar in the Punjab in 1982 said to me ,that the Sikhs are a kaum,and the kaumiat of Sikhs is Bharti or Indian!I am still to this day, trying to work that one out !Like wise trying to defend Tohra and Tota Singh he also tried to tell me ,that although the chinese embracing the Sikh religion becomes part of the Sikh kaum ,...his kaumiat will still be Chinese! May be someone with a good grasp of the language can help outin this.I am after all a product of home educated Punjabi-the only difference being I loved my mother tongue and went way out to learn it correctly under my own steam!!I am not a product of any college or university of of the Punjab in Punjabi language.But I also know that I do not need a dictionary like Veer jarnail Singh ji pointed out as is used by many so called editors from Punjab Gurcharan Singh Kulim

Re: Are Sikhs A Race?

pppreshie power!!! · 10 Feb 2005

well there are places where guru ji has mentioned certain tribes as quams ie the berar quam is mentioned for its bravery. Now berars were not a nation at the time so then what else can brar mean? today berar is a surname and not in the least a physical nation. So where does the word quam lead us? perhaps there are many meanings for its use which is possible.

Re: Are Sikhs A Race?

stupid · 10 Feb 2005

aaee panthhee sagaal jamaathee = this gurbani thuk proves that the entire creation is one race maanas kee jaath sabhai aykai pahchaanbo = this gurbani thuk proves that the caste and class of humans is one eik utham panthh sunio gur sangat = this gurbani thuk proves that there is one SUPREME path, and that is the path of gur sangat there is only one race, one caste, one class - these involve segregation and they discourage diversity - this is the human race, class, caste. however, there are different nations, cultures, and paths - these involve personal identity and they promote diversity - the highest of these is sikh kaum, gurmat, and gursikhi.