Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Valaiti Customs and Punjabiat

Valaiti Customs and Punjabiat

kaka · 16 Feb 2005

Being sikhs a lot of us are also natives from our homeland panjab. As soon as something is taken as anti sikh its usually associated with "punjabi culture" . This then takes on a whole new negative meaning as if are we ment to cut off with our punjabi roots? what about all the good from it? where our language comes from? our folk traditions? ( dhadi vara, cultural dress salwaar kameez, rehni behni in parivars, basic values to develop ourselves culture and specifically punjabi history ). The sikh books i read seem to come to the conclusion that we were nothing but slaves before sikhi, this kind of makes me feel ashamed in some ways that we were nothing just conquered dejected, dormant lost confused people till we were uplifted in 1699. But when you independantl look into history theres punjabi legends who fought like robin hoods such as dulla bhattis rebellion against the moghuls, and others from the 10th century onwards various punjabi quama have rebelled and fought against the moghul raj. Punjabis have created kingdoms long before islam, added to civilisations, with our own poetry, warriors so on in their long history. So then why do we always put anything to do with punjabi nationalism down? My point is even if they were not successful the spirit lived on, and if we were to understand punjabi history better would that not make our roots more stronger? less confused youth as to who they are? and this would also put us on a platform for punjabi nationality and one step towards our sovereign goal. pakistani punjabis to this day proudly keep punjabi heritage salwaar kameez, not ashamed to use punjabi as their language, and know their koo on their history. But when it comes to sikhs our sisters are ashamed of wearing punjabi suits, even the mundey and sisters do not like talking in punjabi in case they get mistaken for being immigrants. Wherever i look sikh punjabis biggest problem is their trying to become like gorei, the heart of it is loosing their true heritage of endless love and sacrifice standing up for one another. And obviously im not saying go and drink 6 packs of beer but at least cherish what we are and i do not believe that would conflict with sikhism if one takes amrit they have half the brain to decipher what is right and wrong. and why do we always bow down to pressure from other converted sikhs that the manmade barriers are punjabi culture? this is trying to force us to falsely accept that our roots are a hindrance when in fact the real disputes lie in conflicts about rehit because gorei just happoen to be in one group called 3ho and punjabi sikhs outside in akj taksal and sants. But akj and taksal are the same punjabis we still have a little friendly tiff on the odd occasion so its nothing to do with being punjabi or culture. One question should settle this if all sikhs were one rehit and many colours would they have a problem? Then you get some disgruntled people who feel they are neglected because they were gorei and take every shot they can at punjabiat/ look at anyone without their roots, they are confused. i do not want my sisters walking down the streets in gora clothes acting like gorei. so by losing what we are where do we intend to go? Nearly every chardi kala sikh past and present upholds their true punjabi values mother tongue, respect, izzat and rehni behni in peoples homes and wherever they go. So if we are devoid of everything that is punjabiat then what would we have left??

Re: Valaiti Customs and Punjabiat

Admin · 16 Feb 2005

This post by Kaka was under another thread. We are moving it here, where it belongs. Admin. Author: kaka Date: 02-16-05 04:06 i would appreciate no negative responses like female feotocide, drinking bhangra, caste. I am talking about the good of punjabiat and our long proud history and without out what we got?

Re: Valaiti Customs and Punjabiat

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 16 Feb 2005

Waheguru Ji ka Khalsa Waheguru ji kI fateh. you wrote: <<

Re: Valaiti Customs and Punjabiat

kaka · 16 Feb 2005

thank you admin ji for that. some of the non obvious reasons sparked me to write this is the creeping effects of westernising like: holding hands kissing hugging in public places the types of clothes being adopted to wear which in stark contrast to the past were simple without showing curves off (now girls get hit on much more by guys than ever before ) families no longer functioning as each others extension wife and husband want to leave the family and have their own new house leaving their old parents behind all alone. speaking in english to their children instead of punjabi (which allows us to express in a much better way)

Re: Valaiti Customs and Punjabiat

bagri kalan · 16 Feb 2005

need to correct you jarnail singh the salwar kameej has been worn in punjab by punjabi women long before prophet mohammed and his deen of islam existed. The muslim dress prescribed by Peer Mohammed is jiljaab (long overcoat type black covering everything from top to downards similar to what taliban imposed on afghan women) and hijaab. Salwar kameej however does come from persian traditions for the chief reason that early day punjabis were persian migrants ( NON hindu NON islamic scythian) Gupta, P.L. (1988), `Coins', National Book Trust, New Delhi, India, pp 51-52. P. L. Gupta writes "the standing pose of the Gupta kings at the altar is almost identical to that of the Kushan kings, as is their dress - Kushan long coats and trousers (uchkin, salwar/kameez). The Kushana or Kasvan tribe of the Sakas had ruled over Sakasthan (west and northwest) in the period from 1st century to 4rd century AD. Regarding the Guptas, Dehiya [p.181] states "The coins of SamudraGupta, Chandragupta I, Kacha, Chandragupta II Vikramaditya, Kumaragupta I, Skandagupta, etc. all have the central asian long coat and trousers." Cunningham, A. (1971), `Coins of the Indo-Scythians, Sakas, and Kushanas' , Reprinted by Indological Book House, Varanasi, India (first published 1888). Tod, J.(1972), `Annals and Antiquities of Rajasthan', Vol. 1, Routledge & Kegan Paul Ltd., London, (first published in 1829), pp. 623. Banerjea, J.N. (1987), `The Scythians and Parthians in India' , in a `Comprehensive History of India' , edited by K.A.N. Sastri, Vol. 2, Peoples Publishing House, New Delhi, India, 1987, pp 186-309, pp 830-838. "The Sakas have left their deep imprint on the ethnic composition, ethos, cultural heritage, political institutions, social customs, dress, kinship patterns, folk dances and cuisine of the Punjab and other provinces of Sakasthan. These include : democratic-republican political systems and institutions, elected panchayat, sarpanch, thok, khaap, sarva khaap; kurta-pajama, uchkin, turban, salwar-kameez, ghagra" Now it has been factfully established the salwaar kameej was not introduced by "muslim invaders" but an original tradition by punjabis. [%sig%]

Re: Valaiti Customs and Punjabiat

bagri kalan · 16 Feb 2005

According to Herodotus [8] "Sacae" is the name, the Persians give to all Scythian tribes and they wore trousers and long coat (even today Punjabi ladies wear baggy trousers and their men folk used to or still wear trousers especially during the winter months called "Churidar Pajama") The archeological findings witness [10] that the Scythians carried swords as long as two and half feet as well as short double sided daggers called "akinae". Furthermore, Scythians and their cousins Sarmatians worshipped the iron sword called "scimitar" ("Samchhir" in modern Punjabi?), in fact, as late as fourth century A.D. Historical Accounts of Scythians in Central Asia, Customs and Characteristics) Dr B.S. Dhillon

Re: Valaiti Customs and Punjabiat

bagri kalan · 16 Feb 2005

the evidence provided is purely a related answer to the subject of salwaar kameej and not meant for the wider scope mentioned in the original post.

Re: Valaiti Customs and Punjabiat

M. Singh · 16 Feb 2005

<<

Re: Valaiti Customs and Punjabiat

` · 16 Feb 2005

Punjabi dress is different from Sikhi dress, which is A cholaa and churidaar pajami, so these two things should not be mixed in together.

Re: Valaiti Customs and Punjabiat

sikh · 16 Feb 2005

true say you can go to new york berminghoom leeds gravejunt chandigarh delhi amritsar jullanthar and what you find is people changing fast its shocking. i would say thats because they are now faced in dog eat dog environment where money means everything, and conforming to society. Compare what your grandads were what they said they did, and if they couldnt do it their heads would remain low until they mustered enough to accomplish what they set out to do. Look at us we are conditioned by temporary gora thinking. all i hear from sikhs nowdays is "tough luck" "i tried" "i dont care" " i want the fittest girl, the best house" " i will use my academic knowledge to show i am the best one here" instead of the sher toot ee nang culture that doesnt care about wealth, jeona maur, walking headless tradition, ik dojai di satt, chardi kala spirit, never say drop off, fight to the end. the sad thing is the bulk of sikhs in punjab are the ones changing too fast more than us outside due to multinational corporations moving into cities and affecting rural life dg, ck, wimpies, macci ds, kfc, fashion shows, pubs, bars, clubs, films. We should not blame our brethren but seek help and create panthic projects gather funds and work for uplifting decaying society. Having met some of the "fresh of the boats" i am surprised to learn they are now more gorey than us in the way they are. i was expecting the lion sher spirit, like when our grandads first came from punjab in the 1940s.

Re: Valaiti Customs and Punjabiat

unknown · 16 Feb 2005

Why do Akj's accept the kurta pujama as Bana?

Re: Valaiti Customs and Punjabiat

dekeyah · 16 Feb 2005

"unknown Date: 02-16-05 10:50 Why do Akj's accept the kurta pujama as Bana?" what is bana? can it be defined just to mean chola? then that must be universal then why not let your sister wear it?