Re: Is this what Guru ji envisioned for Khalsa?
dust of the rust · 17 Feb 2005
sheesh man i got a big ted so what? i can still put up a ruck!
Re: Is this what Guru ji envisioned for Khalsa?
Redwhiteandblue Kaur · 17 Feb 2005
J Singh ji,
I have a similar concern.
I don't believe that alap ahaar should be mandated because I don't believe that much in banning things. Instead, I believe in the discipline of moderation. We are not to live in isolation like the Sadhus, we are to live in the dirty water and shine with our stregth, like the lotus.
A bit of junk food from time to time will not do harm to most people. Where the issue lies is when something that is supposed to be a treat becomes a habit.
Another problem is when a younger Sikh gets used to eating junk food, and then doesn't drop the habit as one's metabolism starts to slowly fade.
I do not want to go as far as demonizing people that are overweight...as there are medical conditions that can lead to weight gain, and sometimes medicines that stave off more serious health conditions can lead to weight gain. As J. Singh ji rightly says, there are illnesses that can cause such things.
I do not think we should be querying our fellow Sikhs as to our medical history for the purposes of passing judgement on them, and I absolutely abhor the demonization of those that are handicapped or have some sort of condition that would deem one to be imperfect in the eyes of another mortal.
What I do wish for...
More initiative in our gurdwaras to keep ourselves healthy...particularly at langar.
The breakfast in my gurdwara is typically pakooras or samosas, gelebis, doughnuts, and fruit juice/soda. I am diabetic so eating those does not suit me at all (esp. if I want to eat langar afterwards) but even for the vast majority that do not have diabetes...that is a lot of food that is hard on the body. For the main langar...I'd really like to see more fresh fruits and vegetables, in addition to the traditional sabzis and other dishes.
This to me is not a place for disdain...but an area of opportunity.
Re: Is this what Guru ji envisioned for Khalsa?
Kulbir Singh · 17 Feb 2005
J Singh jeeo,
-----------
I also know a few who proudly wear full banna with dumalla and long shree-sahib but are also extremely over weight. Please forgive me for saying this but what is the point of dressing up and carrying a three footie teg if you don't have the strength, skill and stamina to use it. Some of the singhs I know have "baby hands", not a sign of real hard work. Some are just too weak and too out of shape to be in any kind of combat situation. Is this what we call tyar bar tyaar khalsa fauj? Is this what Guru Gobind Singh ji envisioned for us? Can you IMAGINE puraatan singhs being this way? A single Singh was enough for sava-lakh dushman.
-----------
The points you have raised are quite valid. We all should get in shape and be fully skilled in martial arts. Having said that, I don’t think it is fair to say that one should carry kirpan only if one is fully skilled in using it. Kirpan is one of the five kakaars and all gursikhs have to carry it. But your point too is well taken. Singhs should know how to use kirpaan and be physically fit.
----------------
We can all understand if it's due to some physical or mental illness but being obese and out of shape due to laziness and procrastination shouldn't be acceptible for Khalsa. What happened to the "Sipahi" part?
-------------
True again. We should strive to stay in shape.
-----------
I also know a few who eat really unhealthy foods. Fried stuff, pizzas, pakauras, sweets are pretty common. What do we think would happen if we stuff ourself with a batta full of rassgullae? Is it really the right food for a naam abhiyasi singh? Shouldn't we only have light food ("alap ahaar")?
------------
I myself am guilty of indulging in the kind of food you have mentioned above. As such I am not in position to do updesh to others about this.
Daas,
Kulbir Singh
Re: Is this what Guru ji envisioned for Khalsa?
Kulbir Singh · 18 Feb 2005
J. Singh jeeo,
You say that your post was aimed at those gursikhs who are intolerant towards ones who don't follow strict rehit. Perhaps you are talking about us. If you are talking about us then I have already admitted to you in my previous email that we should take care of our body and keep it fit. And yes we should keep kirpaan and be fully expert in fighting with kirpaan.
Pyariyo, I already agree with you. Some of us are guilty of ignoring this aspect of Rehit i.e. not keeping as physically fit as we should be. Do kirpa on us so that we may fix this dhil in our rehit and become fully fit, physically and mentally and spiritually.
We will make a solid effort this summer (if Guru Sahib wills) to get fit. Thanks to you for your suggestions. Dhanvaad hai tuhaada.
Daas,
Kulbir Singh