Statues and IDOLS in Sikhi
Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 16 Feb 2005
Waheguru ji ka khalsa Wahguru ji ki fateh.
reproduced below a mail from another forum..
Sister Parminder writes:
As more and more so called Sikhs are worshipping Sri Guru Granth Sahib ji as an Idol, without reading the contents or understanding them, some enterpreneurs have come up with the idea of selling small statues of Guru Nanak Dev Ji.
Many merchants have them in their shops along with the statues of other Hindu gods and goddesses. What I was surprised about was, that a Sikh family chose to give these statues of Guru Nanak Dev ji, as a party favor at a New Years Eve Party. From what I heard, some of the guests did not even realise what they had received, till the next morning. Some of them were quite horrified, they did not know what to do, some were even afraid of throwing them away as they did not want to be disrespectful. One family's little two year old would not let go of it, he kept saying " this is my Guru Nanak" and insisted on taking it to the Gurdwara on Sunday. The parents had to hide the statue, let the kid go through a tantrum.
My question is, where are our Religious bodies ? Shabd Guru is slowly being replaced, first by pictures of the Gurus, now by statues. Slowly, we are losing it!
On my part, I intend to have a polite dialogue with this family who gave out the statues. Maybe, they do not understand the consequence of their actions, it is our duty to explain the reasons for refraining from such activity.
Charhdi Kalaa
parminder kaur
Re: Statues and IDOLS in Sikhi
Kulbir Singh · 17 Feb 2005
Good point raised by Bibi Parminder Kaur jee. There should not be any kind of portraits of Guru Sahib. Idols are totally out of question. Sikhs don't believe in portraits and idols of Guru Sahib.
Siri Guru Granth Sahib jee is the "Aatmak saroop" of Guru Sahib. Guru Khalsa Panth is the physical form of Guru Sahib. This is why it takes both - Siri Guru Granth Sahib jee and Punj Pyaaray (Guru Khalsa Panth) to give Naam to Gursikhs. Of course, there have been some odd cases where after amrit chhak, Sikhs received divine inspiration from Siri Guru Granth Sahib jee as in the case of Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh jee but for the most part, Guru Khalsa Panth and Siri Guru Granth Sahib jee both together give Naam to seekers of Vaheguru. This samagam is called Amrit Sinchaar Samagam.
So called sants are very apprehensive of calling Khalsa Panth their Guru. This is why they took out the reference to Khalsa Panth being their Guru from the fake Sikh Rehit Maryada that they published illegally in the early nineties. They know that if Khalsa Panth is Guru, then who would recognise them. So they always oppose guruship of Khalsa Panth.
In the Rehit Maryada published by SGPC it clearly states that Khalsa Panth is Guru Khalsa Panth. Deedaar Khalsay kaa is Deedaar Guru Sahib ka.
Daas,
Kulbir Singh
Re: Statues and IDOLS in Sikhi
Redwhiteandblue Kaur · 17 Feb 2005
--- I suggest that before my learned colleages remove all the pictures of their eternal father that they remove all pictures of thier darling wives from their wallets and from the picture frames that adorn living rooms. ---
Very Well, Bundha ji,
You have thrown down the gauntlet...
...consider it done!!
I have no picture of my darling wife in my living room...
I have no picture of my darling wife in my wallet...
I have no picture of my darling wife anywhere!
I believe this completely fulfills the parameters of your challenge!
Therefore, I will counter.
A likeness is just a likeness, right? It's just a picture. Right now I have a picture of Chicago up on my wall. When I get bored with that...I take it down, drag it over to the storage area, wrap it up and lean it against the chicken wire, and grab another image to put up. Perhaps a picture of the eagle...or the arial shot of the ocean.
Ah, heck. Let's toss a guru in to the mix. Hmmm...what do I feel like looking at today? Guru...ocean....guru...ocean...nope, no guru likeness for me today, I want to look at the ocean today.
Am I being disrespectful? Why? A picture is just a picture, right? I mean, the picture of the eagle certainly isn't very insulted by having to lean against the chicken wire for a bit more. The eagle is America's national symbol...but I hardly think many people would see me unpatriotic for not dragging the picture of the eagle out instead.
You know...there was that time when my phone rang just as I was emerging from the shower. Yep...with wet, uncovered kesh hanging down my back...wet uncovered me went charging in to the living room to grab the phone. I was expecting a call from a friend about to return from India, so I was quite anxious to answer it. Got the phone. It wasn't who I was thinking of...it was another friend wanting to know if she can "just drop by".
Well, you know...that picture of the ocean didn't mind at all that both me and my hair was wet and uncovered and standing in front of it making off-color remarks. Neither did my houseplants...or my housepet.
I mean...that wouldn't be disrespectful to stand buck naked with uncovered kesh in front of a likeness of guru, would it? It's just a picture.
So...I get dressed, call my friend back, apologize for my boorish behaviour and invite her over. She drops by and says that her husband had a strange week. She shares the story as we laugh in delight and screech in horror over what she encountered. We talk for awhile, then her husband stops by. I tell him that I heard the problem...and he starts laughing and then lets loose a string of obscenities when reliving the part of the week that angered him.
After all...it's not disrespectful to laugh and scream and cuss and otherwise carry on in front of a likeness of guru, right? And it's not disrespectful to have non-Sikhs with uncovered hair in front of the likeness, right? I mean...it really is just an image. My picture of the ocean didn't mind one bit. Heck, my houseplants didn't even mind. My picture of the ocean doesn't mind when the cat pukes a hairball right in front of it.
So...between the two of us, we quite the husband down...and the remainder of the evening is a bit more civil. We chat for a bit over coffee, munch on some munchies, and then call it a night. My friend gives me a bear hug, kisses me on the cheek, and thanks me for my hospitality. Her husband slaps my back and puts a hand on my shoulder and tells me that I'm a helluva good listener.
I mean...it's not offensive to hug and kiss and backslap and that kind of thing in front of the image of guru, right? It's just a likeness.
Or...is it?
If so...then the image is more than just an image.
Bol Chuk Maaf
Re: Statues and IDOLS in Sikhi
Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 17 Feb 2005
Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki fateh.
Veer Bundha Ji....ahhh good idea BUT you "forgot" one very important point... the PHOTOS of wives and girlfriends people carry in their Wallets are the TRUE LIKENESS of their wives. girlfriends, sons, family etc....No one in his right mind would carry a photo of Aishvaria rai and say it is his wife..after all BOTH are women, Indian etc... ??? dont you agree ??
I am sure you wouldnt be too glad to carry around a portrait of BUSH in your wallet and claim it is your father would you...only George BUSH would carry a photo of His dad BUSH SR in his wallet...
SO..carrying around a "so called photo of Guru Gobind Singh ji" and calling it a likeness of your father ( remember the image is produced from the FERTILE IMAGINATION of artists like Sobha Singh..and I am MORE INCLINED to think that IF Sobha Singh paints a picture it is more likely to look like his father...or some one he "imagines"...just last month at a Gurmatt samelan in Malaysia a Young man from Indonesia attended and everybody was saying HE LOOKED EXACTLY LIKE GURU GOBIND SINGH ??? Now do you "understand" where these false pictures and statues are leading to ?? Where did everybody get the idea of what Guru Ji "looks" like....you guessed it....from all those numerous pocket calendars with photos of Guru Ji ???.....I used to have a large Portrait of Guru Nanak ji by Sobha Singh on my Hall Wall....and one day a Chinese Contractor I engaged to do some painting came to my house..and the First thing he said to me was.. EH Singh, is that "Ghumaar Singh" your relative ?? He drinks too much you know. I was surprised and said WHO Ghummaar Singh..>??? I dont know any such person....Then why you having his PHOTO on your wall ?? Thats the last day any such photos were ever placed on my walls.
We ahve "progressed" from mere calendar portraits to bulk wallet calendar photos distributed by the thousands at gurdawras all over, to STATUES...and IDOLS..and the day is not far away when some film maker is going to have a LIVE "GURU GOBIND SINGH/GURU NANAK.." ( probabaly somebody like Sunnydeol/amitabh bachan etc in a FAKE BEARD KALGEE DASTAAR etc) on the bollywood screen and...HALF will SUPPORT it ( probably excuses just like the ones YOU Gave..whats wrong really ?? it reminds me of my pita ji..blah blah.. the other HALF like myself will oppose..and that will be the floodgates open to more such films. TECHNICALLY speaking the BOLLYWOOD IMAGE is also just a SCREEN IMAGE and the One on PAPER is a PRINTED IMAGE..so if we find nothign wrong with a paper image..we CANNOT oppose a Film Image..and then we will have films like...??? those we have on Jesus..
Lets STOP the ROT NOW before it gets out of Hand and spreads like a Forest Fire which no one can control.
Jarnail Singh
Re: Statues and IDOLS in Sikhi
Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 18 Feb 2005
Waheguru ji ka Khalsa Waheguru ji ki fateh.
Veer Bundha Ji, you wrote
<>
IMHO..couldnt be more distant from what Guru Ji looks like....doesnt inspirte nay love/etc in me at all...in fact Sobha Sinhg's Guru nank looked much better and "inspired" more...until I got wise to the emptyness of such "inspirations" and removed it from my sight. Now I get more Love and deeper inspiration from the Shabad Guru. Just try it and see...picture love is like sachrin....shabad Guru love is like..Gunggeh mithaee khayee (gurbani).
Bhul Chuk maaf.
jarnail Singh.
Note: side topic..I heard that you maintain a website..can you email me the address. Thanks.
Re: Statues and IDOLS in Sikhi
Bijla Singh · 18 Feb 2005
Guru is Shabad not a body so what significance does a picture of a body hold? none. pictures of Guru Ji should not exist because Shabad Guru has no human form. and i don't think Baba Nand Singh Ji needed to have a picture of Guru Ji as he could always have darshan of Guru Ji. he was a true gursikh and well aware of a fact that pictures don't have any place in Sikhi. sakhis of shaheed gursikhs are more than enough to inspire us. i prefer having pictures of shaheeds on the wall. just my opinion. Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh
Re: Statues and IDOLS in Sikhi
Kulwinder Singh · 19 Feb 2005
Dear Bundha,
Redwhiteandblue Kaur is saying that a picture is a picture nothing more then that and if you have picture and understand that it is just a picture and should not go to the point where you believe in it anything apart from Printed / Painted picture.
In plan English just do not think a picture may have feelings, eyes and emotions, then it is a picture and it must be just a picture in your clear head, so you can carry on what ever you doing in front of that picture, if you have picture of your father or mother in your bedroom and then think you should not change your cloths in that room then it is bit worrying.
Sorry I intervened as Redwhiteandblue Kaur is Very bright and much more then capable of explaining in detail.
In further nutshell, Picture is Picture, no Sikh should believe in worshiping anything else apart from THE GOD. Anything else depend on your own needs /understanding/stage in spirituality and state of mind. Sikhi is clear picture are not for worshiping in Sikhi at all.
Thanks
Kulwinder Singh
Re: Statues and IDOLS in Sikhi
Rajesh Lulla · 26 Feb 2005
I was wondering if you could tell me what the picture of nanaksar looks like as someone had told me to getr it and hang it at home but I have no idea which picture they were talking about
Thanks
Re: Statues and IDOLS in Sikhi
Anil Kapoor · 14 Dec 2005
I agree with Bundha ji.
One should always have picture as it helps .Bundha ji try a statue it realy helps your focus and concentration and you always feel guru is here with me.Chawla ji from RAW always told me how they permoted Shobha singh ji and offcourse Nanaksar is child of IB and Raw.
Re: Statues and IDOLS in Sikhi
Harcharan Singh · 14 Dec 2005
Waheguru ji ka Khalsa Waheguru ji ki Fateh,
Dear picture lovers:
Questions, our Guru's adopted and made divine some of the rawaj of the their period i.e. Using Raags, shastar etc...
If pintings were ok, why did they not adopt this practice? There are no paintings of our Guru's, so we must then ask the question why?
Only 1 feasible answer, they never allowed. Not so hard to understand, only shakeen and proud royalty of the time had paitings commissioned to preserve their images in time and to show status and importance, how would that have ever fitted with Guru ji.
In addition please read Gurbani, there are numerous references to teh evil of Idol worship.
Where do you think Idol worship began?
By someone trying to replicate their divine/spiritual leaders.
I have seen many, many Sikhs from all different backgrounds doing ardaas to false pics of Guru's. Idol worship has already taken root.
Pics first appeared during Maharaj Ranjit Singhs time, he commissioned many paitings of Hindu Gods and Gurus, and both...
Another one of Ranjit Singhs lasting legacies...
After Singh Sabha got in power they became vogue, with national paiting competitions being held in 1920's onwards which is where 99% of the famous paintings we see today were imagined.
A prime example is the one of Sardaar Jassa Singh Ramghaira when he captured Red Fort, he is shown in jewellery and a modern punjabi Paag!
I have seen old paitings of Sarsaar Jassa Singh and his 2 sons which I think are held by his descendants , which show a completely different image..
Shawl, neela durmalla, white katchera, shastar, bare foot, the very simple bana, well armed and undercover image you would have expeted from Gursikhs during the fighting years. The painting style is also representative of the mid to late 1700s.
I personally find paintings the biggest insult to Guru Nanak Dev ji who preached against idol worship, there is no difference between a paitning and a metal idol of Guru Ji, both have the potential to be (and they are by most people) worshipped in some form or another.
I have had many arguements with Giani who allow pics in their Gurdwara, esp the popular one of Guru Gobind Singh Ji Maharaj with gold and and jewellry over his Dastaar, why make him look like Malkit Singh. This infuriates me.
We should take a lesson from Mussalmaan, who have to this day never drawn the face of their Prophet.
We think we are the saved ones, yeah right, start listening to your Guru and then you might be!
Being born into a Sikh family, having a beard and Pag, taking amrit doesn't save you alone, listening to, understanding and obeying Guru Ji does.
Paitings/statues are idols, no one can deny it, they lead to people putting there hands together and asking for things 0 WORSHIP.
Simple.
The biggest insult is that we dare to imagine and portray what Guru Sahiban looked like.
Go to the Sikhnet art section, you will see new paintings of our Guru's with earings. that should comfort those of you who are seeking justification for mutulating your body i.e. peircing and tatooes.
Sat Sri Akaal.
Harcharan Singh
Re: Statues and IDOLS in Sikhi
Son of Akal · 14 Dec 2005
Wahiguru Ji Ka Khalsa Wahiguru Ji Ki Fateh
When Guru told us.
Puja Akal Ki,
Parch Sabad Ka,
Deedar Khalse Ke.
weneed to worship Akal.Go be Gurbani.
And to se Guru se a true Khalsa and if could not find one then se in mirror.
The very same Guru oppsoed idoltory called its worship Kur Kriya.
by the way Nanaksar etc has nothing to do with R&AW or IB,they have thier own idol worhsipping agenda.
Sahijdhari can worship picture but Amrtidhari has to worship Akal only and if worship any of Guru by thier pictures we know such person goes to the lake of hell.
Re: Statues and IDOLS in Sikhi
turbocharged · 15 Dec 2005
"One should always have picture as it helps .Bundha ji try a statue it realy helps your focus and concentration and you always feel guru is here with me."
Dont advise a sikh to always have a picture or a useless stone idol to help them pray to the infinite, formless God.
You will feel god, is here with you when you actualy recite naaam. at the endi of the day the guru spoke out fiercley against idols and picture worship. so dont do it period.
Sahijdhari can worship picture but Amrtidhari has to worship Akal only and if worship any of Guru by thier pictures we know such person goes to the lake of hell.
Sahijdhari is a sikh in the making.
SAHIJDHARIS CANOT WORHSIP PICTURES AS IT GOES AGAINST SIKH PRINCIPLES.
Re: Statues and IDOLS in Sikhi
Harcharan Singh · 15 Dec 2005
Waheguru ji ka Khalsa Waheguru ji ki Fateh,
Dear mr Turbo,
Sehajdhari is a historical term used to describe people who live by all Sikh principles but have not yet taken amrit.
That means they do nitnem, they do not drink, they do not go to clubs, they give dasvandh etc etc.
To be honest sehajdhari do not exist in this day and age.
What most people term as sehajdhari today are monai Punjabis who go to the Gurdwara, but also drink eat meat, live a normal life, but say they are Sikhs and belive in Guru.
They are not sikhs in teh making, they are Sikhs in the breaking.
The word sehajdhari can be seen in early European accounts of teh Punjab. One statistic that is seen is that by a missionery who in the late 1700's reflected there are 99% Khalsa dressed in blue and 1% sehajdharis in Punjab.
Sadly the statistic has now completely reversed.
Satnaam
Harcharan Singh
Re: Statues and IDOLS in Sikhi
turbocharged · 15 Dec 2005
"To be honest sehajdhari do not exist in this day and age."
i kno some sahejdharis, some cut haired some keep uncut kesh but they all do nitnem and they Dont drink alco or eat meat neither do they perform any sort of idol worshipery.
Re: Statues and IDOLS in Sikhi
son of Akal · 16 Dec 2005
Wahiguru Ji Ka Khalsa Wahiguru ji Ki Fateh
Sahijdhari is one who is on way to become Sikh from non Sikh.
a so called sikh who cuts hairs or mona is termed patit(fallen) and other name is sirgum,a sirder or head lossing headmanship.
Re: Statues and IDOLS in Sikhi
Concerned Singh · 18 Dec 2005
Sahijdhari is one who is on way to become Sikh from non Sikh.
a so called sikh who cuts hairs or mona is termed patit(fallen) and other name is sirgum,a sirder or head lossing headmanship.
Waaheguru Ji Ka Khalsa, Waaheguru Ji Ki Fateh
Sahej means a state of mind that a Gurmukh reaches when sukh and dukh, panj chore are dealt with. the so called terminology that one is on his/her way to become sikh from non-sikh is not what it means. it is thrown in by so called kaali's to get votes. Please read Gurbani before believing in what others say.
Waaheguru Ji Ka Khalsa, Waaheguru Ji Ki Fateh
Re: Statues and IDOLS in Sikhi
son of Akal · 19 Dec 2005
Wahiguru Ji Ka Khalsa Wahiguru Ji Ki Fateh
As per history(refer Amritworld.com) there were some Hindus who were not willing to share the bowl of Amrit with lower Castes in Delhi.
Guru did not give them Amrit till they make up there mind to have it from ther common bowl(books of Sikh missioanry Collage also have this writtan).
As they took some time so were slow to incorporate Panth so they were called Sahijdhari.
coming to the meaning of word Sahij.
It has two meaning.
Ease and Slow.
in the context of Sahijdhari(which so far not seen in Guru Granth Sahib Ji but in other books) it means slow incorporator.