What a Disgraceful and FALSE propoganda
Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 16 Feb 2005
Waheguru ji ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji ki fateh.
Veer Jagdeep Singh writes on another forum..
Vahiguru Ji Ki Khalsa Vahiguru Ji Ki Fateh!
I came across the following claim (amongst many accusations against the Singh Sabha) made by 'Nihung Niddar Singh' of UK and his associates, with regards to the death of Bhai Kahn Singh:
Giani Gurdev Singh, a veteran of Samparda Bhindra now residing in England, spoke of the ignominious death of Bhai Kahn Singh over the ‘Raagmala’ issue. Giani Ji contends that the King of Patiala had discovered Bhai Kahn Singh’s role in promoting the ‘Raagmala’ controversy, and summoned him to his court. Giani Ji continues:
‘He too became misled with regards to ‘Raagmala’. He [Kahn Singh] found out that the King had summoned him. [The King] summoned him, and he realized“I will be dishonored”. Then they say, at night he took an overdose of opium and committed suicide out of fear.’
Giani Gurdev Singh, transcript of interview on October 2001
Giani Ji’s account is contrary to what has been written in ‘Mahan Kosh’ which states that Bhai Kahn Singh passed away peacefully on 23rd November 1938. During the interview, the grandson of Sant Giani Baba Gurbachan Singh Khalsa ‘Bhindrawaley’, Giani Avtar Singh was also present and confirmed Giani Gurdev Singh’s story. They both contend that Kahn Singh’s suicide was common knowledge amongst the ‘Parcharaks’ (missionaries) and ‘Granthis’ (preachers and scholars) of Sikhism in Punjab at that time.
Can someone shed further light on this claim by the 'UK Nihungs' ?
Jagdeep Singh
Note by jarnail Singh:
Similar patently FALSE PROPOGANDA is also being spread about Bhai Sahib bhai Randheer Singh ji. Is there any DEPTH these bluffers will not descend to. MY entire family has NOT read raagmala for the past Five Generations and none suffered any such "lies"....I also Do NOt read raagmala and DONT regard it as bani or worthy of even the slightest respect ( none more than the covers of Guru Ji )....in fact it is mere trashy poem...and I am not afraid i will get whet these liars say.
Re: What a Disgraceful and FALSE propoganda
Rashminder Singh · 17 Feb 2005
veer ji is it the same giani gurdev singh ji now in australia?
Re: What a Disgraceful and FALSE propoganda
dust of the rust · 17 Feb 2005
the stuff they say is cheap publicity stunt like what mss bhatti did. cause offence, outrageous, get everyones attension then,
to this new list of "historical proofs". They just want numbers boosted up in the sanatan maryada and sadly they have chosen to attack every single sikh organisation that exists. anyone can make a line of ballony out of historical texts because i can say today i saw some singhs doing this on so and so date. How credible is it? and what would be more relevant what people do or what Guru sahib commands?
The only reason they have added in the caste sections is not because they believe in it but because ideologically they believe singh sabha is jat and ramgharia is run closer to their own sanatan tradition. This is far from the truth singh sabha has all kinds of people in its committees and sangat.
It looks to me their trying to say here we have different types of sikhs udasi nirmala nihung, and then bloster that claim up by saying we also have jat sikh terkaan sikh adding in the rest of the plural set. What they mess up on is 1699 itself Guru sahib made one equal sikh out of 5.
No spiritual seeking person would keep with that, no one wants to hear nindia no matter how good or bad the case, we come to this earth to do paat simran, who cares how akj damdami taksal singh sabha was started? Its the difference it made transformed people into sikhs, which is a lot more than i can say for the niddo gang.
I would not even bother with them.
Re: What a Disgraceful and FALSE propoganda
Gurpreet Singh · 17 Feb 2005
atleast have the nimirta to respect my beliefs and not an ang of my guru "trashy poietry"
Re: What a Disgraceful and FALSE propoganda
Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 17 Feb 2005
Waheguru Ji ka Khalsa Waheguru ji ki Fateh.
Dear Dogma Ji,
I agree....BUT how do i "respect" a poem i find in madhav nal's kaamkandal book..it is the same...WORD FOR WORD..with CORRECT NUMBERING/ SEQUENCES OF PANKITIAAN to boot....it FITS in there PERFECTLY like a GLOVE.
Just as a example....if someone's mother..works in a "p******** joint"....is she a "P*********" or "MOTHER". a "P" fits in perfectly in PJ..a Mother fits perfectly in a greshteee home....the two cannot interchange.
IF these Singhs want me to respect "raagmala" then they should GET it OUT of the kaamkandla book...OR make an EFFORT to get the Kaamkandla Book BANNED for disrespecting "gurbani". For 70 years there has been NO SUCH EFFORT..WHY ?? are they happy that raagmala is shereh aam in a sex book ?? Tomorrow some one may print a copy of Jaap Sahib in the kamasutra ?? WHY have we let a GURBANI be in a sex book all this while ??
Jarnail Singh
Jarnail Singh.
Re: What a Disgraceful and FALSE propoganda
jagroop singh · 19 Feb 2005
VahiGuruJiKaKhalsa,VahiGuruJiKiFateh!
Dogma ji,
Your stupidity is so unbelievable that it makes my mind boggle.
You need a good slapping for coming out with what you just said - any Singhs who personally know you should do your Seva and give you a good beating.
Make sure you ask for forgiveness during your next Ardaas.
ps - before you dismiss me as some sort of 'fanatic' really think about what you just said - how DARE you connect the name of our Siree Guru Sahib Ji with the Kama Sutra...especially for the extremely unimportant purposes of providing a simple analogy - and a pathetic one at that.
VahiGuruJiKaKhalsa,VahiGuruJiKiFateh!
Re: What a Disgraceful and FALSE propoganda
Rashminder Singh · 19 Feb 2005
veer dogma ji
bhai sahib jarnail singh ji point make sense to me...........
Why pro ragmaliaas have not banned that puratan sex book which has word to word same raagmaalaa, they consider it as guru ki baani then y dont they take any step for its satkaar....
Or they think a new question will rise in novice sikhs that what is this sri raagmaalaaa sahib doing in Sex book which was written b4 guru granth sahib ji was compiled by 5th guru ji
Plssssssssss Answer this question..... Why pro raagmaliyaas not doing anything to ban that book (kaam kandalaa) or take raagmaal out of it????????????????????
Re: What a Disgraceful and FALSE propoganda
Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 19 Feb 2005
Waheguru Ji ka Khalsa Waheguru ji Ki fateh.
Rashminder Singh ji,
OF course the Pro-Raagmallis DONT DARE to raise any sort of STORM or Hulla Gulla AGAINT this SEX BOOK because then that would be PROOF that raagmaala is indeed from that book...so they prefer to be "cool" about that !!!..
There have been NUMEROUS Morchas and Protests about suh mundane things like Guru Ji's "imaginary picture" on Cigarette calendars, alcohol calendars, etc etc..BUT NEVER a SINGLE PROTEST about Holy "GURBANI - Raagmaaala being in a SEX BOOK ???? WHY ???? reason is pretty obvious to anyone..raising such objection will bring out the sex book and any one with even rudimentary brain matter will realise this is NOT GURBANI at all...so much better to close both eyes to this "sacrilege"
Jarnail Singh.
NB Please be "careful" about 'supporting" me in any mail as you may be labelled as "another "arshi" supporting his own arguments under another ID. ha ha ha just joking. ( they love to "imagine" i am just ONE INSIGNIFICANT old man....so any mail supporting me just cant be anybody else !!!) Wahegurujikakhalsawahegurujikifateh..
Re: What a Disgraceful and FALSE propoganda
London Singh · 21 Feb 2005
WJKK WJKF
Having been to the lectures of Nidder Singh in my opinion his views are just rehashes of Arya Samaji propaganda from 100 years ago. I know we should not judge but frankly Nidder has ZILCH knowledge, his so-called 'lectures' which are supposedly organised because of 'tremendous demand' are just him reading off a script while one of his monkeys operates an overhead projector. Ask him any question which requires indepth knowledge and you get the nang version of vicky pollard ( character off 'little britain' ) ..yeah but..no but..yeah but..no but..lol .. to be honest seeing him trying to answer a basic question on Sikhi is embarrassing. I recall him trying to answer a question on the Five Khands which the Singhs sitting behind me had to correct. What is even more embarrassing is that he invites non-Sikhs to his lectures and they must go away from his lectures with very little respect for the Sikhs thinking that this joker is the best speaker that Sikhs can produce.
His monkeys Narsingha..aka Jagroop Singh, Yankee, Bahadur Singh are no better, just jokers who find the Sikhi of the Gurus too restrictive and 'fanatic' and would probably have been atheists or joined some other cult if nidder wasn't around.
The reason why he seems to be able to hoodwink so many youth is that he is able to provide a 'easy Sikhi' compared to what we are able to provide. The Gurdwaras are split on minor caste issues, most jathebandis are more geared towards attacking other jathebandis than doing anything to counter Nidder and his cronies. We can see all this on the net, look at the mass of articles and posts against or for Keski as Kakkar. Imagine you are a young Sikh who hasn't been taught his religion by his parents and you want to start to learn about your faith, given the amount of negative material available for and against each jathebandi is it any wonder that such youth end up as victims of Nidder? I am fortunate that I learnt about Sikhi when there was no such negative material and now when I read about one jathebandi's views about another I can make an informed decision but the youth who are new to Sikhi just get disheartened by all the inter-jathebandi bickering.
We Sikhs have a history of doing nothing against each manmat that rears it ugly head, we wait until it gets so strong and then we try and counter it. The case of the nakli-nirankaris is well known to us, if we had countered them when they first began in the 50's we wouldn't have needed to have taken them on when they were much stronger in the 70's.
This is a humble request to the Sikhs of the Gurus of whatever Jathebandi.. put you bickering on the backburner and know and recognise the harm that people like Nidder are doing to the Sikhi of the Gurus. Nidder's cult only consists of himself and a few of his close followers who would not change their views about snatan Sikhi even if Guruji came to them and told them that nidder was wrong. The whole mass of his other followers are just young Sikhs who have been misled by him and if the Jathebandis were stronger in countering Nidder they would be back to Sikhi in a flash.
Re: What a Disgraceful and FALSE propoganda
jugroop singh · 21 Feb 2005
VahiGuruJiKaKhalsa,VahiGuruJiKiFateh!
Veer/Bhain 'an opinion' ji,
You wrote:
'It was Jarnail Singh Arshi who made the analogy of Jaap Sahib in Kamasutra, NOT Dogma - Dogma simply replied to Jarnail Singh's post.
If you are going to be angry at anyone, direct that anger at the right individual.'
> Apologies for not noticing who mentioned it first - i didn't read the whole thread and so shot my mouth off without thinking...i have a serious habit of doing that!
It's not that i felt especially angry - just really offended. Generally speaking, may i humbly say that we should ALL (including me) be more careful in the 'way we speak about' GurBani.
Bhul chuk maaf karna ji.
ps - 'London Singh' mentioned a 'Jagroop Singh' who is one of Niddar's students...i think he's mistaken me for someone else.
VahiGuruJiKaKhalsa,VahiGuruJiKiFateh!
apologies
jugroop singh · 21 Feb 2005
VahiGuruJiKaKhalsa,VahiGuruJiKiFateh!
Veer/Bhain 'Dogma' ji,
Once again, apologies for not noticing who mentioned it first.
Nonetheless, i still think you, me, Veer Jarnal Singh Ji and everyone else should be careful when discussing GurBani...that's all.
Apologies for singling you out 'Dogma' ji.
VahiGuruJiKaKhalsa,VahiGuruJiKiFateh!
Re: What a Disgraceful and FALSE propoganda
Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 21 Feb 2005
Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru ji Ki fateh.
Blue ji,
Akal Takhat has already made a decision...READ or DONT READ the raagmala. So our duty is to OBEY. I DONT READ. ( but you may read and thats your right). BUT neither YOU or Me has the right to REMOVE anything from Dhan Guur Garnth ji Sroops or ADD anything.
Now it is every GURSIKH's GURU GIVEN RIGHT to propogate GURMATT. And all i am doing ( sitting on my bottom...i dont know how others do their typing) typing away is to "persuade" more people as to why they shoud STOP READING raagmala...
THATS ALL and that is also MY RIGHT. OF course people who hold a different view will be "offended"..I "offfend" people daily..because i tell them to stop worshipping babay and sants and concentrate on GURU GRANTH JI Gurbani ONLY instaed of beleiving in mere humans...I "offend" others who want to do this ritual and that ritual as Gurmatt..I "offend" monay who want to do akhand paath raols, prepare degh and langgar..I "offend"..."offend and offend...
Many "offend" me by telling me to close one eye, live and let live, after all monays are also sikhs, they love guru ji from inside..blah blah blah...what harm can a coconut ina red cloth do to gurmatt if left at a akhand paath...blah blah blah.
The way i look at it..life is like that..I cant stop "offending" people and people cant stop "offending" me.
Jarnail Singh