Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Sanatan Sikhism?

Sanatan Sikhism?

yo · 18 Feb 2005

I often hear that sanatanists saying that sikhs should regard themself as part of the hindu nation/hindus/sanatan sikhism. What does sanatan sikhism mean? a follow on from hindu religion? that means the hindu books would hold almost as dear ( or equivelent) to a sanatanist sikh. The Mahabharta, Puranas and Brahmin Law Givers repeatedly "forbid Brahmins" from traveling to these foreign lands (punjab north west) where, in turn, their alien religion, priesthood, gods and caste creed was spurned and rejected by the people . For example, the Mahabharta, verses 2063-2068, Karna Parva, states "one should not go to Vahika-desa ( punjab) in which the five rivers and the Indus . . . where the MALESH (BEASTS) live . . ". How do the sanatan sikhs feel about joining hands with the brahmin law givers who saw your forefathers as less than dirt? you are nothing but a beast according to hindu books. Who kept your forefathers in spiritual blindness by not allowing the mass of punjabis to study by using rajput (hinduised military) and later moghul arms to subdue punjab?

Re: Sanatan Sikhism?

.... · 18 Feb 2005

a challange to sanatan followers most sikhs were ex sufis, sultanis, rare cases muslims, and some hindus. So how do all sikhs become sanatan? punjab before sikhism was more sufi. how will sikhs be from hinduism? even if we take the argument all sikhs came from hinduism where did bramha vishnu mahes come from? Vaheguru, so we all come from God not from hindus. im fed up with hearing this we are the extension of hindus when we never were hindus to begin with.

Re: Sanatan Sikhism?

A Singh · 19 Feb 2005

Eka maeey jugat veaayee tin chelay parvaan Snatan means eternal and the word hindu is a arabic term for the geographical location east of the river indus i.e. hindustan Still to this day muslims from pakistan are sill sometimes referred to as hindus by their arab brothers. If Truth is eternal and has been there even before time, would you not agree that sikhi is eternal i.e. snatan? What about Shivji, Bhagat Prahalad, Dhru etc who area all referred to as Gurmukh in Gurbani? If Sikhi began in 1469, then who do these Bhagats of Maharaaj become Gursikhs?

Re: Sanatan Sikhism?

hera · 20 Feb 2005

my pakistani friends tell me they are certainy not called hindus by arabs, they are respected as muslim community. Please do not mislead a singh. a singh "If Truth is eternal and has been there even before time, would you not agree that sikhi is eternal i.e. snatan?" does such a word as "sanatan" exist in hindu holy books? hindu religion is actually made up by brahmins to serve their feet. That doesnt mean truth was not around the world. When sanatanists look at yugs ram krishan are made out to be the biggest icons. What about buddhism? Under buddhism, punjabis expanded empires all the way from arabia to burma quiet an achievement isnt it? No hindu gods even created empires on that scale. economic trade flourished, all man were put on same level. Buddhism was spread all over the far east. So why do sanatanists hide this? Sikhism has more connection with buddhism than hinduism, sangat pangat (sangah), guruship enlightened. How can sanatanists claim buddhism as hindu when buddhism opposes brahminism? and brahminism tried to wipe it out. We could also find an arabic, persian, christianised term for eternal, and apply that to sikhism but we do not. Sikhi is a third path on its own. a singh "What about Shivji, Bhagat Prahalad, Dhru etc who area all referred to as Gurmukh in Gurbani? If Sikhi began in 1469, then who do these Bhagats of Maharaaj become Gursikhs?" But sikhs are not sanatan, they are of persian descent. So sanatanism can only apply ethnically to hindus who became sikhs and not independant masses who make up sikhs.

Re: Sanatan Sikhism?

Niranjan Singh · 20 Feb 2005

A Singh Where is it mentioned in Gurbani that Shiv was a Gurmukh ? Please provide references before making such statements. Regarding the Bhagats, please refer to Bhai Randhir Singh Ji's book "Gurmat Parkash", esp. chapters 9, and 10 that deals with this very subject. You will be amazed at what will learn about our Baba Nanak who has been spreading "Satnaam-da-Chakkar" not just in 1469 for many many Yugs, and not only on this Earth. Read Bhai Gurdas Ji's Var 1, Pauri 36, and Bhattan-di-Banee for further details. Just because you don't understand Baba Nanak's Kalaa please don't declare the Free Khalsa Panth as Hindoos (Slaves, Theives). You "snatan" hindooism has only been around since yesterday but my Baba Nanak has existed forever. That is why he is our Yug-Yuh Avtaar ! [%sig%]

Re: Sanatan Sikhism?

singh-o-mania · 20 Feb 2005

could someone breifly explain what the word sanatan

Re: Sanatan Sikhism?

Anon · 20 Feb 2005

Sanatanism = Satanism :O