Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

English creeping into Punjabi

English creeping into Punjabi

Kulbir Singh · 18 Feb 2005

Arshee Gyani jee in another post (Your favourite name for God) raised a very important point that Punjabi is getting stained with Hindi words and Persian words are fast disappearing from Punjabi. Very important observation by Arshee Gyani jee. Indeed, we can't help notice Punjabi has been stained with too much Hindi now and Persian words are fast disappearing. The new generation cannot even pronounce the words correctly. Z has been replaced with J. In Western countries, the bigger problem is English creeping into Punjabi. Here are some examples: Instead of saying booha or Darwaaza they say door. Instead of baari they say window (or Bindow). Instead of pardaah or parday they say curtain or curtainaan (for plural). Instead of batee bujha do they say light band kar do. Instead of gaddee they say car. Instead of rasoyee they say kitchen. Instead of gusalkhaana they say washroom. Instead of maej they say table. Instead of kursee they say chair. Instead of bijlee they say light or electricity. Instead of sadak they say road. Instead of bazaar they say plaza or market. There are numerous other examples to show how Punjabi is getting undermined in Canada and America. I think we should try our best to not speak any word of English while conversing in Punjabi. Only when we can't help it, we should speak the English word e.g. there is no Punjabi word for Computer so it is okay to say computer in Punjabi. Any thoughts on this subject would be appreciated. And any more examples of English words in Punjabi would be appreciated. I call on to my brothers and sisters who are reading this post to make an effort to speak pure Punjabi, as much as possible without using Angrezi (English). Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: English creeping into Punjabi

g · 18 Feb 2005

um punjabi isnt sikhi... Gurmukhi is and Gurmukhi is a mix of alot of langauges includeing hindi and persain? from what I have been told. so what are you on about kulbir singh

Re: English creeping into Punjabi

Gerk · 19 Feb 2005

Languages that don't adapt and change with time die. We should be happy that Punjabi is borrowing words from other languages and it's lexicon is growing, it shows that Punjabi is still live and vibrant. If you want it to stop changing and stop incorporating new words, you want it to die. [%sig%]

Re: English creeping into Punjabi

.. · 19 Feb 2005

im quiet lucky there i grew up with my grandparents they taught me old school freshi punjabi but problem is a lot of people dont understand what im saying feels like im speaking my own language at times. Mould it and speak it when your young and it will stay with you. I think we should also make a concious effort to speak in punjabi more when we also converse with each other. Very important our nyaney learn it otherwise be subject to bollywood mafia film/gorafied culture. We should be proud of our language but nearly most youth i know feel ashamed of it as if their more concerned about society taking them as illegal immigrants. Punjabi is such a beautiful language the poetry expressed there is matchless english is dull and hindi well thats just a baby of urdu, and urdu as we know was a moghul court language. We should uphold our mother tongue very high, we stand to gain nothing by loosing part of what we are.

Re: English creeping into Punjabi

Jarnail Singh Gyani · 19 Feb 2005

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji ki Fateh. Gurmukhi is the "ALPHABET" and NOT a "Language". Secondly the "language/spellings/usage..." in the GURBANI of the GURU GRANTH JI Sahib is "STATIC"...meaning no one can change anything in any way whatsoever. Yes it is absolutely right that Living Languages do change with USAGE..the more we use, the more they change....in MALAYSIA a lot of Local MALAY words have also crept in..Here Punjabis call "rooms" - bileh, "knife" peeso, "kitchen" dappar, "bath" mandi, "Clothes" baju...so much so that when those staying here sometimes call home to talk to their relatives, they use locally adapted words and the punjabi frequently goes :ah...kee kiha tun..and the local will then substitute BAJU with Jhaggha !!! This is going to occur all around the world where-ever we settle fro long periods..French words will creep into French-Punjabi, Russin Punjabis will speak a mix of Rusiian-Punjabi..Punjabis in China/Japan will have Chinese'Japanese words.. How did FARSEE/ARABIC words come into Punjabi....the SAME WAY. English is also changing this way..the Offical English language Dictionary... the Oxford Dictionary regulalrly UPDATES with Foreign words that have become "ENGLISH" due to wide usage....How many know that "Bungalow" is not an original English Word but from India..so is "Verandah" ( off hand these are the only oens i can recall but there are many many such "borrowed" words that English ahs adopted as its own. BUT in the PUNJAB..this whole POLICY is DELIBERATE and OFFICIAL....totally REPLACE PUNJABI to make it sound like a Bastard Version of HINDI..and also KILL the GURMUKHI ALPHABET by having it replaced by DEVNAGREE. A few months ago Ajit jalandhar carried a series of very well written articles on how this campaign is being orchestrated. IMHO..our DEFENCE to this should be EDUCATION of EACH CHILD in GURMUKHI ALPHABET. The "words" as such dont matter much and are not dangerous....as long as our next generation is well versed in the GURMUKHI ALPHABET, they can Communicate with GURBANI ( Our living GURU)...and SPOKEN PUNJABI.....it is up to the teachers, the Parents to Speak it at home environment so that ALL the children know ALL the Words. This is the Formula I use in my home...my children "know" that THaali/Plate/Pingan..mean what we eat in....Shirt..Jhaggha...Baju means what we wear. In soem homes this is not the case..so in the Gurdwara when you tell the chikld..Beta thalli liah..he stares at you until you say bring the plate.....in the home where BRING THE PLATE is the ONLY thing the children understand..is a goner as far as Punjabi is concerned...This si the Situation we MUST NOT Let Happen at any cost...and it is in the Parent's Court. Jarnail Singh

Re: English creeping into Punjabi

Singh_meharban · 19 Feb 2005

Dear Veer Ji Your concern for Panjabi, the mother tongue, is nice. I agree. Panjabi word should be preferred "till we fail to find one" in our conversation. Purity of a language in conversation, is a good mental exercise. (Similarly Hindi or English should not be mixed with Panjabi, for the similar reason and logic.) But how you handle, Gurbani words, of no Punjabi origin. There are many and many. Should not those be used or preferred in our speech or writting. Certainly Gurbani is not all Panjabi. Guru Sahib Ji in Jaap Sahib mixes two words of different languages to form one. Bhai Nand Lal Ji writes in Persian. Bhai Gurdas Ji also uses Non Panjabi terms. Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh Ji in his grand poem "Jot Wigas", uses non Panjabi words mixed with Panjabi. And that looks marvelous. He also mixes english words with Panjabi, at some points. Interestingly, that earns appreciation, from the "forward writer". Readers also appreciate hios style. Kindly, define the dividing line.

Re: English creeping into Punjabi

... · 19 Feb 2005

Little own these Punjabi words, look at punjabi in itself! From Sat Sri Akaal to Sasikal!

Re: English creeping into Punjabi

Sohangani · 19 Feb 2005

I am Canadian born. My parents never spoke to me in Punjabi very often, so as a natural result, I murder the language when it comes out of my mouth. I've tried over the past few years, but it's been difficult. My Punjabi has a quite a few English words, which I try to exclude once I learn the appropriate Punjabi replacement. The worst part is, 85% of youth in Canada are like me. The 10% above us, are just mid-field speakers. Very few, a handful, can speak Tayt Punjabi. As Sikhi continues to flourish in Canada, and other English speaking countries, Punjabi will slowly decline. Sad but True. Living in English speaking countries, we speak and hear more English than any other language, leaving the next generations vocabulary significantly weaker. Even if Parents do an excellent job of teaching thier children to speak Punjabi, the children will never have a vocab like that of the parents, and there will be a general decline as time passes. I seriously hope this won't be the case in the future, but the reality of it seem painfully real. [%sig%]

Re: English creeping into Punjabi

sikh · 19 Feb 2005

bindow :)

Re: English creeping into Punjabi

Redwhiteandblue Kaur · 19 Feb 2005

I agree that it is a sign that the language (and the speakers of the language) are growing...and spreading...and thriving. Anyone that has referred to a tidal wave as a "tsunami", a spicy sauce as a "curry", a conversation as a "dialogue", or the internet as "cyberspace" has done the same thing in English. Dialects of Latin-American Spanish show heavy influence of English words. The Japanese language, after WWII, instituded a third alphabet to be exclusively used for Western words that were adopted in to the Japanese language. Its a natural part of change. Although...change does not excuse the need for proper education.

Re: English creeping into Punjabi

ji · 19 Feb 2005

wat pees me off more than language is punjabi girls and some mundai selling their history off by wearing tight western clothes instead of traditional dress. i dont care if some sanatan comes back and accuses me of bein taliban.

Re: English creeping into Punjabi

Kirtan Kaur · 19 Feb 2005

Instead of saying chamcha, they say spoon. Instead of saying jootee or jooteyan, they say shoe or shoes. Instead of saying pizza, they say peeza. This is fun.

Re: English creeping into Punjabi

Kirtan Kaur · 19 Feb 2005

Also it is very common to say "No" instead of saying "Nain. Also, Kulbir Singh, nobody says Gussalkhanna for bathroom--not even in Punjab. They just that they're going to the "koo" (well). Gussalkhanna just sounds plain weird. It sounds like some sort of Muslim word.

Re: English creeping into Punjabi

g · 19 Feb 2005

ok excuse me gurmukhi is the alphabet but Gurbani is in many diffrent langauges so then how can you complain about english creeping into punjabi when its not sikhi

Re: English creeping into Punjabi

hey · 19 Feb 2005

my punjabi-english dictionary said that bathroom was "jungle janna" hahaha

Re: English creeping into Punjabi

Kulbir Singh · 19 Feb 2005

-------- Also, Kulbir Singh, nobody says Gussalkhanna for bathroom--not even in Punjab. They just that they're going to the "koo" (well). Gussalkhanna just sounds plain weird. It sounds like some sort of Muslim word. -------- Bibi Kirtan Kaur jeeo, I am not sure if Gussalkhana is not a common word but I have used this all life and I have heard many others saying it. I guess it depends on the family tradition. There are some words that are unique to some families. My wife sitting next to me is now telling me that she too thinks that Gussalkhana is a common word in Punjabi. But yes you are right that this is a Persian/Urdu word. More Punjabi word for this is Maidaan jaana or Jungle Paani jaana. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: English creeping into Punjabi

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 19 Feb 2005

and here is a joke that i know personally happened to a friend. When my friend got married his wife would always complain to her mother whenever she came to visit....eh ( husband) koonda nahin..koonda nahin.. ( doesnt say much )....but my friedn thought she was asking for a KOONDA ( mortar for raggrring masalla etc)..so he went out and bought a brand new koonda....but still the wife complained eh koonda nahin..and he finally got the answer koonda is to "speak" as well as koonda is mortar... So yes..language and words are family sensitive..area sensitive... what the majhails call booha, we malwaiis call baar..when they say Booha Dhoh de...we say baar band kar de... Once a Punjabi jatt challenged the Englishman to tell him in English..the word to describe the action of a buffalo urinating while walking along... the Englishman thought hard and said there is NO such Word....but there is a punjabi word for it repleid the punjabi jatt..so my language is far superior. What that word is for you all to guess and for me to know...ha ha ha Punjabi is a very very rich language....dont lose it. jarnail singh

Re: English creeping into Punjabi

... · 19 Feb 2005

jungle jaana hehehe thats funny but isnt 'jungle' an english word

Re: English creeping into Punjabi

singh · 20 Feb 2005

kirtan kaur i have grown up in the uk and i use ghuosalkhana for toilet. thing is in punjab every 12 miles the slangs of punjabi change, the words r slightly diff. The part i come from the punjabi is more masculine with more persian and lahori descent than other parts. Thats why its easier for me to understand lahori punjabi than diff slangs just 40 mins past jullanthar. I picked this up from my grandparents when i was a bacha. punjabi language is not affected by persian because of muslims. Punjabis themselves have persian history coming from persia before islam began that is why many persian words exist in the punjabi dictorionary. However some sikhs from hindus towards delhi speak hinduised versions thats purely to do with where they came from. However we should stick to basic punjabi and try to use punjabi equivelent words where we can.

Re: English creeping into Punjabi

Gulzar Singh · 20 Feb 2005

WJKK WJKF > >The new generation cannot even pronounce the words correctly. Z has been replaced with J. > This is very true! Many people at the gurdwara often pronounce my name as "Guljar" instead of GulZar. But then again, I dont think my name is a proper sikh name. :( WJKK WJKF [%sig%]

Re: English creeping into Punjabi

sikh · 20 Feb 2005

since being married my mum thinks i'm a chamcha!

Re: English creeping into Punjabi

singh · 20 Feb 2005

some people use "hehta" for down others "neechey" where i come from we say "thalley rakh". instead of saying "hajai" we say "hallai".

Re: English creeping into Punjabi

Jarnail Singh Gyani · 20 Feb 2005

Waheguru Ji ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji ki fateh. With all due "respect" he he he.... Gussalkhana is an ACTUAL ROOM..i.e.bathtroom..BUT the Punjabi equivalents..Maidaan jaana just means "doing your business in the field"...this is NOT a ROOM/PLACE..BUT the "ACTION"...and same goes for Jungle paani jana..means doing your business in the Jungle/out there ?? The TRUTH si that in PUNJAB there was No such thing as a "BATHROOM"...everybody went out to the FIELDS ?KHET to do their buisness...its only a few years ago that latrines and bathrooms began to be built in houses or NEAR houses. Even today some houses share a common latrine in the street meant for a few houses. Jarnail Singh

Re: English creeping into Punjabi

Singh · 20 Feb 2005

Arshee ji could you please let us know that word?

Re: English creeping into Punjabi

.. · 20 Feb 2005

Kuldeep means The lamp of the family Kuldev means The god-like person of the family What does Kulbir mean?

Re: English creeping into Punjabi

a singh · 21 Feb 2005

i had read your post earlier in the day, then speaking to an uncle ji i slipped in "ok ji" then i thought of your post veer ji and i smiled to myself..... i should have said hanji! another one to watch out for in the future! vaheguru ji ka khalsa, vaheguru ji ki fateh.

Re: English creeping into Punjabi

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 22 Feb 2005

Waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh. Singh Ji, there is no such word....please forgive if you misunderstood me. In a rail coach a pendu sat next to an engineer. the engineer was talking non stop and so the pendu thought of a way to shut him up. He told the angrezi babau....you ask me a question and if i cant answer ,you will give me 50 dollars..and then i will ask you a question adn if you cant answer me you must give me 100 dollars. This is fair as i am uneducated and you are an enjineer sahib. So the engineer asked a question....and the pendu thought for a while and said I give up..here is 50 dollars. Then the Pendu asked the Enjineer..what bird has four legs, but lays no eggs. The engineer thought and thought..and finally gave up and handed over 100 dollars. Then he told the pendu..please tell me the answer... the Pendu smiled and replied..I also DONT KNOW. SAME HERE JI...I also DONT KNOW !!! Jarnail singh

Re: English creeping into Punjabi

uk singh · 22 Feb 2005

Different regions in any country have slight variations in accent and vocabulary, but nonetheless we should try and preserve Punjabi as a language and teach it to forthcoming generations. I find that Pakistanis in old Punjab have managed to maintain the language far better than modern Punjabis. It is possible that they lag behind India by several years in the uptake of Western influences - satellite/magazines.

Re: English creeping into Punjabi

Harsimrat Kaur · 22 Feb 2005

Gurfateh, First, panjabi isn´t the mother toungue of skhi. Neither is gurmukhi. In actuially fact it´s a lanuage not a lot os peole have heard of it because peole are forgetting it and getting attached tophysical thing. The actual mother tongue of sikhi is Sant Script. This is the actual launguage the first four guru ji´s wrote but the fifth guru ji brought in Panjabi for the people who didn´t know sant script. At least this is what i have been told by many peple at my gurdwara. They all agree that sant script is the language. I hope i didn´t offend anyone or got anything wrong. If i did i´m sorry. Gurfateh

Re: English creeping into Punjabi

Kaur · 23 Feb 2005

I have been brought up in UK but my parents are both from punjab and therefore speak punjabi beautifully. However, I only know how to basically communicate in punjabi as my parents have been adamant that it is not punjabi that they want me to learn, but the words which coomonly come in Bani. Hence I have a basic understanding of bani, but if u ask me meanings of punjaabi words, im stuck""