Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Five Important Questions – At least Read

Five Important Questions – At least Read

Kulwinder Singh · 19 Feb 2005

Five Important Questions – At least Read This tread is created to debate how we treat others, some other questions are side effects but still very important indeed. To be clear what other's definition in the above question is : people of other religion, people of non similar practices but those who declare themselves as Sikhs, people who are non amrit dharies , people who are amrit dharies but do not have rehit similar to us, people who have not defined themselves to anything. In a another thread I was raising questions how it is that some Sikhs treat others like untouchables as one Sikh said that it was ok to Prepared Degh Again if it was touched from outside by some non rehtie Sikh,( He confirmed it happened and he is pleased by that.) When I heard this, I could not stay quite as I thought it was an insult of my religion and this action was done under my community name, as Sikhs acted in this way was enough for me to raise the alarm that, we are having same symptoms of Brahmins, that a degh which this Sikh claim to be prepaid by amritdahri Sikhs was polluted ( Brishted ) enough just mere touch of some Non rehti Sikh that they have to make the degh again. It is a the greatest danger to Sikhism that somebody take and reduce us from the being Greatest Religion in the world to The haven of The Great Manu Ji Maharaja of Hinduism In that debate I gave many example of how Sikhism show highest tolerance. I did not argued that some seva’s in the temples should be done by the Amritdharis but the point I was raising was that, there is no need to treat others with the mind of unsociability. The debate developed further and I gave my points and raised the question that many other bhagats and saints who’s bani is included in the Shri Guru Granth Sahib Ji are from the pre-Guru Nanak era and how beautifully these Bhagats and Saints bani is included in the Shri Guru Granth Sahib Ji and for us Sikhs their Bani is not different from any other Bani in Guru Granth Sahib Ji in Fact there is no other Gurubani then Shri Guru Granth Sahib Ji Gurbani never the less we do accept the contribution of these most dear highly respected Bhagats, that is how I understand and that is how it is for any Sikh. But this cardi kala wala Sikh ( I have no doubt that he is in far more chardi Kala then me – but on certain thing I have difference of opinion with him) said that all bhagats are from post Guru Nanak era , which is incorrect to say the least, ( I am aware that there are some questions about some Bhagat’s life times dates but most of them are clear. Below is the chart of Bhagats life time. Bhagat Ji Name Year of Birth Date they left the world Kabir Ji 1398 1448 Jai Dev Ji 1142 1200 Sheikh Farid Ji 1173 1266 Navdev Ji 1270 1350 Ravidas Ji 1378 1529 Pipa Ji 1425 Bhikhan 1480 1573 Ravidas Ji 1399 Ramanad Ji 1366 Sadhana Ji Same time span as Namdev Ji Bhagat Sain Ji Ramanad Ji Time Bhagat Surdas Ji 1529, Trilochan Ji 1267 Guru Nanak Dev Ji was born in 1469. Even when some bhagts was clearly born in times of Gurus there is no indication that they met Sikh Guru otherwise their Bani will have word Wheguru, which is not the case as we know it. On Vir has said that if these bhagats was Muslims or Hindus then they must be doing their own rituals and as sikhi is against the rituals, their Bani would have been rejected, -- this is a good point to think. Reply to this vir is that Even Hindu and Muslim both have people who have Gian (Knowledge) and many of them do not do all the useless rituals but they still call themselves Hindu or Muslims, for instance there are Sufi sect in Muslims which sing fantastic song of praises to God and Mohammed, but according to Islamic laws singing is Haram and prohibited, Some Sufies Dance in the Pure Amazement of God because the love in them become so uncontrollable that they have to do physical expression of love via dance- As Bullia Shah say that even dancing is a method of meditating but if you know how to dance in delight and amazement of HIS(GOD’s) love. Bhagat Nam Dev Ji wanted to go to Hindu temple Why ? because he wanted to create problem ? no because he wanted to pray and Pundits would not let him to come and pray and kicked him out, he went at the back of the temple and started praying and God moved the face of the temple towards him it is not me saying it is in Shri Guru Granth Sahib Ji . now the Pundits who claim to be the Key holder of everything in Hinduism is kicking Nam Dev Ji out, if Nam Dev Ji did not believe in that temple of God he would not have gone to pray in it, as it caused the problem, second why then God moved the temple if that was not desired by Bhagat Nam Dev ji ? Does this episode show us that the Bhagat Nam Dev Ji was trouble maker and went to Temple to cause problem or he believed in that temple of God and God was unable to tolerate his beloved Bhagat’s suffering and came to assist him in open (partakh) way. But my dear Gurusikh vir jis do not want to think about this ? they want to portrait Bhagat Nam Dev who was born in 1270 and left the earth physically 1350 that he was Sikh, Even when Guru Nanak Dev Ji was born in 1469 about 119 years before this bhagat’s Farwell from this earth in physical form. I also gave example of Pir Budhu Shah that how he gave his sons to Guru Gobind Singh Ji, even when he was sure that they will be shaheed in the war against Muslims, and I doubt if he had thought that Guru Ji would not eat anything which he had touched then he would have offered his sons to Guru Ji, this vir’s reply is that Pir Budhu Shah was Sikh even when his Samad is their for everybody view and Sikh very lovingly go to see Samad of Guru’s friend –(Not metha Take but Just looking at the Samadh is ok for Sikhs as a reminder that a how close the relationship was between a Sikh Guru and a Muslim Pir), now Let’s take my dear friends view that Pir Budhu Shah was a Sikh for one min, then why on earth he had Samadh I can understand that he may have done things before he became Sikh according to Islamic traditions, when he became Sikh how on earth there is Samadh (Muslim type ) for him. And very strangely another( calling him second to reduce confusion) Guru Sikh also endorsed the View of First Sikh who was claiming that Pir Budhu Shah was Sikh, I have now discovered that this Second Sikh have openly admitted in the past that Pir Budhu Shah was Muslim, and More amazingly The first vir also have not said a thing against the second Sikh to point out as he pointed out to me that Pir Budhu Shah was Sikh. NOW I HAVE MORAL DILAMA WHAT TO SAY TO THESE TWO SIKHS ???? I am not saying the above line in any sarcastic way or anything else, that is my genuine concern what I am suppose to say to these two Gurusikhs ? Another strange thing One Gurusikh said that No body else apart form Sikh have the capability to reach the Such Khand ! He categorically said that Hindus and Muslims do not have the capability to do so. I was gob smacked when I read the above views. I though is their must be a Special GOD Who have signed the Legal Contract that he will Only accept Sikhs and everybody can not reach him regardless of their good deeds and clean hearts. Strangely that God does not seems like GOD My real father Guru Gobind Singh Ji pointing me towards. First Question: how we should treat others ( others as defined in the start of post) Second : should we claim all the bhagats are Sikh ? without them saying anything else apart from Kabir who say he is Allah Ram’s pind pran. Third Question: All the non Sikhs who was friends with our Gurus should they be claimed to be Sikhs without themselves accepting Sikhism ? ( Think how our own non Sikh friends will feel if we call all of them as Sikhs or they called you what ever religion they are as how come you be friend with somebody without being as same as them , as this is the intention of some Sikhs ). Fourth Question: Do we believe that God have exclusive legal binding with Sikhs that nobody who ever they are regardless of their true life as non Sikh and clean heart they can not achieve him and never ever will be allowed in SachKhand ? Fifth Question: Should we present Sikhi to others as Guru Granth Sahib Ji want Sikhi to be or should we do as non tolerable, Mega Ultra Strict , non practical, Obstructive in other walks of life, which isolate Sikhs and portray that Sikh have nothing to offer to the world and life in sikhi is completely incompatible with current world practices ? I have done my best not to offend anybody in this post, even if somebody feel I have done that then I am sorry, very sorry that is not my intention and I apologies for the offence caused even unintentionally, we are spending time to make our life better and progress in real form and take knowledge and introduce the world to Sikhism as we have lot to offer for the betterment of the whole humanity, my intentions are not to decrease the glory of my real Father Guru Gobind Singh Ji, But Loudly Say how proud I am for his vision, his creation, his contribution and his path which is defiantly the Most Direct path to THE GOD. I love you all and respect you all, regardless of our differences we are still One Family let’s not stop talking we can progress faster if we learn faster. Many Thanks Aap Ji da Moorakh Kulwinder Singh [%sig%]

Re: Five Important Questions – At least Read

Good Questions · 19 Feb 2005

You pose some very good question Veer Kulwinder Singh Jee. :) [%sig%]

Re: Five Important Questions – At least Read

Rashminder Singh · 19 Feb 2005

I totally agree with Bhai Sahib... even though i believe keski as a kakkaar, dont regard raagmaalaa as a baani, agree that bibek and sarbhloh is an very inportant rehit BUT i dont agree with this concept that if non sarbhlohi Amritdhari Sikh even touch the utensil from outside by mistake makes its unsuitable to eat...... I feel upset when i hear from respectable sarbhlohi singhs that they dont consume the food even if the utensil is touched by mistake........... This is against gurmat...... this is Hindu Matt.... How can we call all those mahapurush and chardikala naam kamai wale gursikhs dheelai or unrehitwant only because they dont follow sarbhloh.... Bhai Sahib Bhai Jeevan Singh ji, Bhai Sahib Bhai Raamaa singh ji, Baba Attar Singh Ji Mastuwane wale and many other naam kamai wale gursikhs.... I love this website and respect these gursikhs (tapoban) a lot but I felt so upset after reading this post where a gursikh told they had to make degh again coz a non rehitwand amritdhari gursikh touched it (Non rehitwand = Non Sarbhlohi bibeki) :( May waheguru bless all Wahegurujikakhalsawahegurujikifateh [%sig%]

Re: Five Important Questions – At least Read

Singh · 19 Feb 2005

>>>>>>>> Even when some bhagts was clearly born in times of Gurus there is no indication that they met Sikh Guru otherwise their Bani will have word Wheguru, which is not the case as we know it. >>>>>>>> The list of birth dates you gave are not universally accepted. The Janamsakhis of Guru Nanak, like Meharban Janamsakhi say that he met all these bhagats. As for your point above that they didn't use "waheguru"; which Guru Sahib used this word in their bani? How common is it? Reflect on that question and you will have your answer to the above as well. To answer your questions: 1) Treat all with love. That doesn't mean that we have to do whatever they say or join them in whatever they do though. 2) This has been discussed 101 times. Please check an older thread on it 3) What's question?? All those that helped Guru Sahib or were his friends are to also be respected. What happens to them in the afterlife or where they went is no concern of ours. Ghani Khan and Nabi Khan, as far as I know, didn't become Ghani Singh and Nabi Singh, but I still have total admiration for what they did. 4) The Path to Vahiguru is naam. Gurmat Naam is available through Guru Nanak. If someone meditates on another naam, then they too will progress. Maybe come into Sikhi one day or in another life perhaps? I don't know. But what's the difference? Neither I nor you have any control on this, nor does it effect us, so why bother commenting? My belief is mubaarak to me, and yours to you. It makes no difference really. 5) We should of course present Sikhi as it is. "Khanio Tikhee, vaalo(n) nikee" sharper than the blade and finer than a hair. It's not easy and it is SUPER strict. I don't want to water Sikhi down for others. Yes, highlight that the base is love, but to love someone means sacrifice. Sacrificing our head means to give up our old way of thinking and acting. Means to give up EVERYTHING and ANYTHING Guru Sahib wants us to. That's not easy. If one day, they say that kesh and kirpan are obstructive, I won't budge. Same way, if they now are say bibek is intrusive, I won't move an inch.

Re: Five Important Questions – At least Read

.. · 19 Feb 2005

amazing.. i am left speachless

Re: Five Important Questions – At least Read

satnam · 20 Feb 2005

wjkk wjkfateh!! what i find amazing is that if i were to have something special which only a select few were to touch/eat then i would guard/ protect the sanctity of this 'sacrament' with utmost attention. The question of something being touched by another would then never, NEVER have to arise...but if it did then i would only see it as my own lack of attention. However in this case it seems to be a case of appeasing the mind and not God. wjkk wjkfateh.

Re: Five Important Questions – At least Read

Kulwinder Singh · 24 Feb 2005

Thanks Dear “Good Questions” Ji for your contribution, Thanks Dear Reshminder Singh Ji for your contribution, Firs of all, Dear Singh Ji Thanks for your contribution too, Dear Singh Ji, Thanks for your reply, On Ans of 1 question: I agree with you with love and yes we do not have to do what ever they say or join them in what ever they do. On Ans of 2 Question: I would have preferred your own version but never mind. On Ans of 3rd Question : The Question in relation to the post; explored Idea. All the non Sikhs who was friends with our Gurus should they be claimed to be Sikhs ? ON Ans of 4th : Again we agree that It does not make difference, I agree with your Line My belief is mubaarak to me, and yours to you. On the 5th Question : we agreed on that “the base is love “ and I am saying that if we move away love then we are not getting any closer to GOD. The point raised by me was “which isolate Sikhs and portray that Sikh have nothing to offer to the world and life in sikhi is completely incompatible with current world practices ?” What will that represent that Sikhism is out of date religion ? it is for some narrow minority of Isolated community or it has the path which universally suite everybody and Sikhism have solutions to worlds present and future problems. Think with the heart and mind of Guru Nanak, I mean big really Big. Dear .. JI please try to put few words to expand on your amazement. Dear Satnam Ji thanks for the post. Thanks Kulwinder Singh Ji. [%sig%]