Re: Sukhmani Sahib Gutka errors
Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 19 Feb 2005
waheguru Ji ka Khalsa Waheguru ji Ki fateh.
And in relation to ALL SROOPS of Guru Granth Ji Sahib, you might notice that sometimes the Moolmantar isplaced AFTER the bani and soemtimes BEFORE. Now that is a INCONSISTENCY....and Guru ji NEVER has any "inconsistency" ??
Prof sahib Singh ji has written a very khoj bharpoor lekh on how this "mistake" has ocurred.
According to him, GURU JI Gave the UTMOST RESPECT to the MOOLMANTAR and as such this is ALWAYS written at the TOP RIGHT HAND SIDE of EACH AANG...but when the "printers" printed their commercial sroops for sale, they neglected to notice this very important aspect and have mixed it all up...
SO make it a point to ALWAYS reda out the Moolmantar..EK Onkaar Satnam.... or EK Onkaar Satgur Parsaad...as it is written BEFORE you read out the bani title. The bani title is SECONDARY and should be read later.
Wherever the Bani Tilte has been placed BEFORE the Moolmantar..it is mistake of the printers.
The SGPC tried to make AMENDS..but as usual the SANT/BABAY group raised OBJECTIONS like the SGPC are trying to "change bani" etc and killed the idea. ( Just like in the Raagmaala controversy the sant/babay group has no basis while Prof sahib Singh Ji has shown conclusively that the way Moolmantar is always written Top Right Hand side of each AAng in the Kartarpuri Bir is proof eneough that this is the way it should be..PLUS the added Proof that Moolmantar is definitely MORE IMPORTANT than the Bani Title and should logically be READ FIRST.
Jarnail Singh
Jarnail Singh
Re: Sukhmani Sahib Gutka errors
Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 21 Feb 2005
Waheguru Ji ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki fateh.
Dear pali ji,
THATS exactly the point i am trying to make. It should be... Ik Onkaar satgur Parsaad... GAUREE SUKHMANI MH 5.... SLOK.....AAd Gurey nameh. According to Prof sahib Singh Ji..this is the way Guru Ji wrote it in the Original handwritten sroop..and it makes Perfect sense because EK Onkaar Satgur parsaad is the MOOLMANTAR and should be read First. The next pankitis are the SLOK... and naturally follow after the Title "SLOK"...and then the Title says: ASHTPADI..and asshtpadi pankitis follow...AFTER that there is NO "EK onkaar satgur parsaad BEFORE the SLOK anymore....just Title "SLOK" and bani follows.
In the Preceedign Bani Bavan Akhree...the Ek Onkaar satgur Parsaad COMES FIRST even before the Title of the Bani...Here it begins Thus:..
EK ONKAAR SATGUR PARSAAD...GAURREE BAVAN AKHREE MH 5..Slok..Gudev maata Gurdev Pita..
SO here isa clear example of INCONSISTENCY between two Banis by the Same Guru Ji, written one after the other....did GURU JI make this inconsistency....the answer is NO..the PRINTERS DID. Guur Ji ALWAYS gives PRECEDENCE to The MOOLMANTAR...and wherever the Printers have mistakenly placed it in SECOND or THIRD position..we must correct the mistake...when we read out the Paath...otherwise we are committing the same mistake of putting moolmantar in second/third place.
Jarnail Singh