Re: String Instruments Vs Vaaja
harminder singh · 22 Feb 2005
This has been a very productive topic,
I was talking to bhai baldeep singh (grandnephew of bhai avtaar singh), and he stated that, from his knowledge, 90% of guru granth sahib should be sung in "dhrupadh" (a form of devotional singing)....then he started singing.....my friend who is not "sabaat surat" was sitting 5 feet away and
his eyes welled up!....
If the sangat were listen to bhai avtar singh ji's kirtan....and then compare what we listen to now...you'll see/feel the difference.
Guruji's court (guru ka darbar) was a place where the presence of the true-king was sung and the music of the (worldly kings)...was actually taken and developed further. Guruji's court was one of truth and excellence.
Personally, I feel that that eminence has been lost with tacky lights around palki sahib, weird rammallay, vaaja, and filmy tunes. I do not, under any circumstance, condemn those gurmukhs who singh with utmost pyaar..no ones bhagtee and pyaar is being challenged here.
please listen to the following shabads....by bhai avtar singh ji, and then imagine how kirtan was (as bhai avtar singh is known to have shabad reets from guruji's times)
1) man jaapo raam gopal (raag kanra) listen to it between 9-12pm ( a composition kept in its true form from guru arjun devji's time)
2)main banjaran raam ki (raag gauri bairaagan) listen to this between 3pm-6pm
3) meray greh ayayay, raaja raam bhutaar (proud to be sikh.com)...listen to this at amritvela as it is in raag asavari (3am-6am)....
listen to the precision, the devotion, the beauty of the sound, and the pukaar of bhai avtar singh ji...
(ps. I am not making him into a sant, so please refrain from going off on that tangent)
maharaaj kirpa karray and we should all do ardaas that kirtan in its puratan maryada be restored to guruji's darbar....otherwise it'll be washed out.
waheguru ji ka khalsa, waheguru ji ki fateh
Re: String Instruments Vs Vaaja
BirRaas Singh · 22 Feb 2005
The first time i listened to a shabad by Bhai Avtar Singh, it was "tohee mohee mohee tohee antar kaisaa" and i fell in love with this style of kirtan, it was soemthing id never heard before and as explained above "it pulls on the strings of your heart", i got hold of their set 31 raags and it never left my cd player since :)
I met Bhai Baldeep Singh when he was in the UK a lil while ago and i applaud his efforts in trying to carry on the revival of puratan kirtan maryada, and the buetiful instruments he has created, i hope people like him encourage more youth to take time out to learn classical instruments.
Re: String Instruments Vs Vaaja
jugroop singh · 25 Feb 2005
VahiGuruJiKaKhalsa,VahiGuruJiKiFateh!
For what it's worth...
When i got interested in Sikhi about 5 years ago, i heard alot of Raag-based Kirtan on Astra TV stations and some cd's. i enjoyed it but PERSONALLY there wasn't a really deep connection - i think it was just kismat; what other explanation can there be for the feelings and intimations that arise, making us depart from one path to another, from one place to another, from one mat to another...it is VahiGuru HimSelf who leads us to the kind of Sikhi He wants us to experience.
Then i experienced 'AKJ Keertan' in the UK - it was an amazing revelation...i felt deep inside that many of the people singing Keertan were really 'up for it' and somehow i could feel this inside...but there was still something about the style and mood, which i first couldn't put my finger on, which made me lose my initial intense reactions.
Then i started to listen pretty much only to Tapoban's Keertan Section which i have found is the Keertan style/convention which touches me the most - simply because it suits my preferences...no other reason aside from that...it creates feelings inside me which feel as though my love for the Guru is increasing...i think the style, the love, the fact that Keertanis are not named, there is no Dhunni etc. has led to these feelings. PLEASE DO NOT TAKE THIS TO MEAN THAT I WANT TO START A Pratan AKJ/Modern AKJ Keertan Maryada debate!
i guess the only truly relevant and USEFUL question i asked was:
Which kind of Keertan singing/listening really moves me and allows my heart to sing/listen, drenched with love?
i think this is the way we should perhaps frame the question to ourselves - to OURSELVES!!!
When reading Bhai Sahib's account, this was confirmed even more.
VahiGuruJiKaKhalsa,VahiGuruJiKiFateh!
Re: String Instruments Vs Vaaja
sanatan santra · 25 Feb 2005
if you sing bani from your heart thats what counts whether it be with vaja or string instrument.
It is also vital to preserve string instruments as this is prescribed in bani.
So Both are right.
The essence is true love for God, what use is singing in beautiful raags using rehbaab if the heart is full of bad things?
Re: String Instruments Vs Vaaja
BirRaas Singh · 25 Feb 2005
I dont mean to offend anyone, but sometimes people show allot of hypocrisy in their beliefs, on one side Tapobans articles heavily stress the need to have all Guru Granth Sahib Saroops in larivar format, to this I 100% agree, no doubt., if we apply the same arguements to the format of kirtan then no one wants to know.
sanatan santra said
"The essence is true love for God, what use is singing in beautiful raags using rehbaab if the heart is full of bad things?"
your first comment is correct, but your 2nd comment is baseless, if all sikhs strive to love god, jin prem kio tin hi prabh paiyo, then why would we have a heart full of bad things?
Many people on this site esspecially stress the need for sarbloh bibek, the aspect of bana, if we can stress the need for these maryadas then why not kirtan maryada? I agree that learning strings/raag is hard work and takes many years of study, but when has rehit ever been easy? keeping sarbloh bibek is hard, keeping bana is hard in western world, keeping amrivela is hard, keeping concentration in simran is hard, if we can put in the effort to keep these rehits why not put in the same to learning raag and strings?
sarbloh bibeks say "give it a try, i guarentee you will fall in love with it", my benti to the sangat here is give learning raag and strings a go, you will fall in love with it
Re: String Instruments Vs Vaaja
Kulbir Singh · 25 Feb 2005
BirRaas Singh Veer jeeo, asee paindoo vaaja masaa vajaunday haan, rabaab kithon vajaavaangay?
Saanu 18 saal vich hajay takk vaaja chalauna nahi aaiya. Tu yaar sathon Rabaab dee aas rakhda hain? hehe!!
I will discuss the kirtan maryada with Singhs over this weekend and see what they say. I personally am not against Nirdhaarat Raag Kirtan and actually love it. If it is determined that it is maryada to sing only in Nirdhaarat Raags, then we should surely follow this maryada.
Daas,
Kulbir Singh
Re: String Instruments Vs Vaaja
sanatan santra · 27 Feb 2005
mere birraas singh
the point you have taken as "baseless" is assuming that ALL sikhs strive to love God.
That practically is the case for real rehetvan sikhs, BUT not too sure bout others if you get ma dreffffft!!
Re: String Instruments Vs Vaaja
Redwhiteandblue Kaur · 27 Feb 2005
Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa, Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh
I have only heard keertan performed on traditional stringed instruments once. It was an amazing experience.
I hold a B.Mus. degree and performed professionally using four different instruments (including voice). But - there in front of me were these beautiful instruments that I had never seen before in my life! When the ragis were finished, I was so tempted to reach over and try playing one myself.
At the same time - it was heartbreaking. These beautiful, precious instruments...who can play them now? Where is this part of our history going? Where could one even go to find such a beautiful instrument, let alone learn how to play it - or to master it?
Music is a living language. Certainly, there can be value to putting shabads to music using a popular tune, that perhaps more of the sangat knows.
Certainly, there can be value to performing them on an intstrument that is easier for the entire sangat to learn.
Music is also a discipline. It is something that is learned over years, not hours. It would be cruel to insist that a sangat member learn an instrument that s/he has no desire to play.
But - please - it is so important to rediscover this precious part of our history. Let's find a way to remember it and celebrate it in some way, instead of letting it get lost to the sands of time.
Daas,
Redwhiteandblue Kaur
Re: String Instruments Vs Vaaja
harminder singh · 02 Mar 2005
no offence to anyone here again,
but how can one really be sure they are hearing something from within someone else?
isn't assuming that you are at a point where you can judge another..man-mat?
gurusahib doesn't give us ijaazaat to "indulge" in that type of discriminatory thinking...for rehit and us, yes...but judging another isn't good.
As per the earlier days in the jatha, bhai sahib bhai randhir singh met jawala singh (father of bhai avtar singh) 3 times, listened to him sing shabads in raag, in 4taal...and joined in with his karray. bhai sahib requested jawala singh to come back again. This is taken from the book about raags written by gurcharan singh (Son of jawala singh).
Anything in maryada is better than not being in maryada...agreed?
Re: String Instruments Vs Vaaja
Ranjit Singh · 02 Mar 2005
I personally find raag keertan to be very moving. When at Tapoban Saahib, I hear singhs or singhneaa doing raag keertan, it is incredibly uplifting and beautiful. I am firmly of the belief that we should promote the learning of raag keertan as much as we can.
Having said that, I also have to say that there is place for non classical raag keertan as well. If we go by what the veers above are saying, many people who are not proficient musically will never be able to perform keertan. Our guru's told everyone to sing the praises of vaahiguru, and to sing them daily. It would be best if these were sung in gurmat raags and we should strive for that. However, if I am unable to sing in raag, for whatever reason, it doesn't mean I should simply stop singing vaahiguru's praises. If I can't pronounce gurbanee correctly and haven't been able to get proper santhiya, it doesn't mean that I stop doing my nitnem and reading banee. I do my best with what I know.
The fact of the matter is, that there are few people with the knowledge and ability to teach proper gurbanee raag. Most people that I know would love to learn proper raag, but they are unable to, due to the lack of teachers. Additionally, learning raag isn't easy. Of course, sikhee isn't easy and we still have to try. However, if we look at the many great gursikhs who did keertan, but not necessarily always in the correct raag (although many did at times due raag keertan), we can deduce why. Many of these gursikhs were simple people, who may have been farming many hours a day or doing other services (military) and they didn't have access to proper raag schools. They may also have lacked money and time. They still wanted to sing the guru's banee, and they did so. They did it with great love and devotion and moved many souls with their keertan. This doesn't mean they were against raag vidiyaa or raag keertan, simply that they were unable to get that training and made due with what they had.
Historically, there is also a precedent for this. It's commonly said that when sata and balvand left, the sikh sangat did keertan in simple tunes. It's also said that when Guru Hargobind Sahib Jee were imprisoned, gursikhs did chownkees in pinds throughout punjab, singing gurbanee. Many of these gursikhs weren't trained in any raag vidiyaa and used simple folk tunes. I don't know how accurate these stories are, but they seem plausible.
Also, raag keertan doesn't mean going crazy doing vocal gymnastics with all the alaaps, etc. Giani Amolak Singh Jee, Bhai Dharm Singh Zakmee and others do amazing keertan in raag, but with the emphasis clearly on the shabad and not on their musical talents. I've heard gursikhs do amazing keertan in seemingly simple tunes that everyone can sing along with and later learnt that they it was performed in the correct raag.
We should strive to learn keertan in the correct raags and should promote this as much as possible. In my humble opinion, raag vidiya should become more of a focus at Gurdvara Tapoban saahib as well. My saying it may be a little hypocritical, since I'm about the least musically talented person around and will be lucky if I can do keertan in simple tunes in this lifetime, let alone raag. At the end of the day however, people are going to sing gurbanee, and sing it in the best way they know how. Instead of constantly complaining about this, the veers who are learnt in classical raag keertan, should teach as many people as they can and go to as many keertans as they can and let the sangat hear the beauty of gurbanee sung in the correct raag.
Re: String Instruments Vs Vaaja
string singh · 03 Mar 2005
looking at it from a musical perspective....the vaaja is insufficient for performing raag. indian classical music, and raag is based on a system of "shrutis" or microtones. whereas a vaja is fixed scale
to cut a long story short....say raag x has a "sa" note in it.....well that "sa" note may not be the same "sa" as the one in raag y. there could be a different of a microtone or two.
so how can raag be played on a vaaja when the vaaja can only play one sa?
Re: String Instruments Vs Vaaja
Jeewan Singh · 20 Apr 2006
Everyone is talking about how the tunes keertanees use theses days are from bollywood or pop "music." If you never listen that pop "music", how do you know where they came from? I never listen to that "music", so I have no idea where the tune comes from, to me its new and therefore everytime I listen to the kirtan I only think of the Gurbani, nothing else. The best thing to do is to stop listening to that bollywood stuff, it only helps you more.
Also, the Guru's did use popular tunes of their times for Gurbani, such as Asa Di Vaar, its supposed to be sung to the tune of 'Tunda-Asraajaa.' Which was a tune used to praise a raja of the times. Was it wrong for them to use that pop tune? What does everyone think?
Re: String Instruments Vs Vaaja
Jeewan Singh · 20 Apr 2006
Please do not call me a wonderful soul, I am nothing of the sort.
I never said Raags were not to be followed, I was just commenting on those who keep on talking about pop "music."
I was curious so I looked up Raag on Wikipedia [http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Raag] and in the article it mentions how some Indian Pop "music" resemble raags. Also after reading the article above and noting that many tunes [even those that are not classical] could be in raag; maybe we are just pointing fingers at Kirtanis just because their kirtan doesn't sound classical and they aren't telling the whole world that they do all their kirtan in Raags.
I also fail to understand why the Harmonium is a lesser instrument when compared to Indian string instruments. Could someone explain that?
Re: String Instruments Vs Vaaja
gurmatsangeetkar · 25 Apr 2006
what is your question in regards to
[%sig%]