Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Sant Singh Ji Maskeen

Sant Singh Ji Maskeen

Pardeep Singh Bilga · 22 Feb 2005

I was reading on this forum yesterday, some views on the death of Sant Singh ji Maskeen and I noticed that Admin had cut a question raised by one person relating to some controversy about Maskeen ji. Admin put the reason somewhere along the lines of "Everybody makes mistakes, so we should not go into this now he is dead". Does one escape criticism after passing away? Just because a person is no longer on this earth, does that mean we only remember their good points? I think Sants in general have to put up with being closely watched as their status and position is to guide and teach the panth, therefore they do need to be more "perfect" than others. I do not know much about Maskeen ji, but I get the feeling he was widely respected and had vast knowledge of Gurbani. A question to Admin- following the huge controversy regarding Sant Maan Singh Pehowa Wale (and a lot of derogatory comments posted on this site) are we going to allow ONLY praising comments when he passes away? Deg Teg Fateh, Panth Ki Jeet

Re: Sant Singh Ji Maskeen

dodu · 22 Feb 2005

Pardeep Singh Bilga , It is not that anyone is above critisism, but there is a time and place for it. At this difficult time for the family and friends of Maskeen Ji it would be inappropriate to start discussions on his mistakes ( we all make mistakes don't we?). This is a time to remember Maskeen Ji in a positive light and not be so insensitive. In time, as the grieving period is over I am sure you can critizise him as much as you like, but please have a little sensitivity at this sad time.

Re: Sant Singh Ji Maskeen

..... · 22 Feb 2005

Yes we should only remember their good points. Can I just ask are you perfect?? Only God is perfect, we are human beings and are bound to make mistakes this is the way God has created us humans. I don't agree with your point that only Sants have to keep an eye on their status and position - every human being has a duty to that so that they can ultimately unite with Waheguru Jee. I don't understand why Sant Maan Singh has been brought amongst the comments regarding Gyani Sant Singh Jee Maskeen. It is very sad that Nindia is being done of Sants when they have passed away and are in Sachkhand.

Re: Sant Singh Ji Maskeen

uk singh · 22 Feb 2005

think Sants in general have to put up with being closely watched as their status and position is to guide and teach the panth, therefore they do need to be more "perfect" than others. Pardeep Singh - I have a feeling that you are confused about the title of Maskeen Ji. He was not a Sant in the contemporary sense. I believe his name was Sant Singh

Re: Sant Singh Ji Maskeen

Guldeep Singh · 22 Feb 2005

Administration does allow a pretty fair flow of ideas that also include criticism of some important people. It has been our tradition that upon someone’s Akal Chalana criticism is brought to a minimum. Administration rightly cut whatever this writer was going to write since by his or her own admission was unsubstantiated. I also think it was probably not true. I knew when I read that ½ line on the thread that the administration cut, it would spark more interest than the 25 other positive messages about Maskeen Ji. The writer themselves said that he “heard” something negative. Isn’t this the definition of NINDA? It isn’t difficult to find Ninda written about any great person. Take your pick Guru Nanak Sahib thru our present Guru Granth Sahib Ji Maharaj. Ninda has been written by Arya Samaj, Nirankaris, Radha Soamis, Namdharis and a host of other people. I have heard w/ my own ears Ninda being done of Bhai Jiwan Singh Ji! It isn’t difficult just to say something you “heard.” Maskeen Ji spoke tirelessly since the 1970’s against Nirankaris and Radha Soami’s. If any one is interested in Maskeen Ji’s Ninda, the Radha Soamis have already published a book against him with no substance only personal attacks. The book is called “Ik Vadhe Dhol Da Pol Khol Dita” (loosely translated: Exposing a Big Mouth) In his 50 years doing Katha, Maskeen Ji has touched countless people and has changed their lives. His personal life was beyond compare. The Panth has lost their Kohinoor. He was irreplaceable.

Re: Sant Singh Ji Maskeen

..... · 22 Feb 2005

Just comment to dodu - You should not critcise anyone at any time not just during the time when Maskeen jee's family is grieving Gurbani teaches us: "Hum Nahi Change Bura Nahi Koi"

Re: Sant Singh Ji Maskeen

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 22 Feb 2005

waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh. Veero...His NAME is "SANT SINGH"......and He is NOT a SANT ..( the ones who get dissed anyway) Just like most of us he may have made some mistakes..major and minor..so what ?? ( I know he is implicated in the "fraudelent" way Giani bhag Singh was excommunicated for his writings on Bachittar natak Granth (dasam granth) BUT No way can his "errors and omissions" be 'compared" to the likes of mann singh pehowa....the two are miles apart. Jarnail Singh.

Re: Sant Singh Ji Maskeen

dodu · 22 Feb 2005

<<<< You should not critcise anyone at any time not just during the time when Maskeen jee's family is grieving >>>> Sorry , what I meant to say was : You should not critcise him at a time when Maskeen jee's family is grieving .......