Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Corporate lawyer?? - right or wrong?

Corporate lawyer?? - right or wrong?

SJ · 23 Feb 2005

i have finished my legal training and am looking for work to qualify as a lawyer. My financial position is such that in order to pay off debts etc I need a high paying position. The only positions which offer this kind of pay are corporate firms (e.g. big american lawfirms that make millions and millions of pounds, by mostly working for big companies). I also plan to take my amrit soon (gurukirpa). Does anyone have any views on whether it is 'wrong' for me to work for a corporate firm which is perhaps not morally or socially responsible???? Very much appreciate some reasoned views on this. Many thanks in advance SJ New York

Re: Corporate lawyer?? - right or wrong?

Singhstah · 23 Feb 2005

truth is high but higher still is truthful living, u shud only earn u'r living truthfully, if the company is doin anything wrong in my opinion its not good to work there, however i'm a moorakh and u will get the best answer from guroo sahib.

Re: Corporate lawyer?? - right or wrong?

khoji · 23 Feb 2005

Dear SJ, You shouldn't worry about company's moral or social stance. One thing is for sure if it is a big company ... it has to be socially responsible. And as far as morality is concerned .. look big companies means they do business and business morals are somewhat different from human morals. Unless you are asked to do what you think is not morally right ... your heart and mind can not justify your work .. then better switch the company ... Just have faith in Him and He knows what is better for you and where to put you. Why you forget that you do not do what you do. You do what He wants you to do. Just make sure that mind doesn't play games with you and everything wrong that you do ... thinking that its His wish ... "man day agay majboor nahin hona hai ..." Logically ... you won't stop using an american car just because their war on iraq was unjustified ... in your terms immoral and socially irresponsible.... khoji

Re: Corporate lawyer?? - right or wrong?

an opinion · 23 Feb 2005

Working for a big firm doesn't mean that the firm will be doing anything morally corrupt. In fact, given that it is a big firm, there is even greater scrutiny as to its practice and regardless of the lawyer jokes that abound, professional conduct puts a pretty heavy onus on lawyers and is monitered (to some degree) by the law societies. As to social responsiblity, most larger firms have pro bono programs. While you may not be able to get involved in such programs in your first year (while you're learning the ropes), you will be able to do so soon. SJ wrote: > i have finished my legal training and am looking for work to > qualify as a lawyer. My financial position is such that in > order to pay off debts etc I need a high paying position. The > only positions which offer this kind of pay are corporate firms > (e.g. big american lawfirms that make millions and millions of > pounds, by mostly working for big companies). I also plan to > take my amrit soon (gurukirpa). > > Does anyone have any views on whether it is 'wrong' for me to > work for a corporate firm which is perhaps not morally or > socially responsible???? > > Very much appreciate some reasoned views on this. > > Many thanks in advance > > SJ > New York

Re: Corporate lawyer?? - right or wrong?

santbirsingh · 24 Feb 2005

vaahe guru jee ka khalsa vaahe guru jee kee fateh i find the previous answers to this question fairly disturbing. khoji said "And as far as morality is concerned .. look big companies means they do business and business morals are somewhat different from human morals. " what does that mean? the pure drive for profit that drives today's world economy is a not something that we, as sikhs of guru gobind singh sahib jee, should blindly follow. is such a model of world economics healthy? is it good for the poor and for the enviornment? the blind pursuit of profit is not something laudable. it makes me laugh, and cry, when sikhs justify working for sketchy companies, or law firms, etc, by using guru nanak sahib jee's comman of "kirt karnee" as an execuse. no aspect of one's life should be divorced from sikhi. a sikh can not get up in the morning and go to work and say, now my morals and my sikhyia mean nothing. now i must work and everything else is secondary. that is a pretty bleak and cynical world view and one that does not keep in line with the sikh ethic. guru jee teaches us that all aspects of our life should be lived in maryada and with guru jee in mind. just because we can not see the end results of the harms that large corporations commit, or we can not view the end results of our own governments' policy decisions on less fortunate people in the world is not execuse enough to turn away and say, "this is our life, we have to take care of our families and thats all that matters." consider that the over 6 million people killed in the holocaust were not killed just by nazi troops but also by ordinary german citizens that went about their days doing "their job" "following orders" and "not asking questions". does that mean they are not guilty for their crimes???? seva and simran are not something to do once a day, at amritvela, or on the weekend or when you "feel like it". they are something to make a part of very self, to weave into one's soul, to make yourself a true emobidement of the guru. one's kirt should be, as much as possible, a form of seva. work for a non-for profit ngo. or a charitable organization. you might not be able to make a HUGE salary, but you'll have enough for a simple life, enough for your family and children. what more can a sikh ask for??? read bhagat dhanna's shabad in gurbani, bhagat jee doesn't ask for the world, just the basics so he can continue to do bhagtee and remember akal purkh. the logic that one uses to work for a corporation with dubious practices, which would be most of the world's major corporations since they care for profit first and society second (remember, its all about keeping the share holders happy!) can quickly be used for any number of moraly comrpising situations. look at all the "sikhs" who worked for, and continue to work for the indian government and army. all throughout the late 80's and early 90's when our sisters, daughters and mothers were being gang raped and our brothers and fathers were being slaughtered by the punjab police and the indian army, it was sikhs, people wearing dastars and with beards that were commiting these crimes! how? they used the same logic. "we have to provide for our family", "we're just following orders" etc. well, thats just not good enough. a sikh is held to a higher standard than other human beings. we, more than anyone else, should strive always to be socialy conscious and aware of what we are doing. are we giving "dukh" to some other being, are we a positive force in the world or are we part of the problem? ask yourself that and then ask yourself what your guru would want you to be? in bhai nand lal singh's tankhanama, which i believe has been quoted on this site in the past and is also available in a small book written by dr. ganda singh and still in print (bhai nand lal granthavli is its title), guru gobind singh sahib jee gives bhai sahib the rehit of the khalsa. in one of the lines guru jee says that those who support the oppresive, tyranical governments can not call themselves sikhs. now we know that we have to take the larger meaning of the rehit and apply it our lives. what does this line mean. it is not only governments, but also anything that we may support in our lives that we should try and ensure that they are not oppresive or tyranical, that they do not take away the human rights and dignity of other people wherever they may be on the planet. there is an amazing book that i recomend everyone to read for it is filled with incredible sikhyia. it was written by shaheed bhai mani singh. there are a few editions floating around out there, one is edited by bhai vir singh. the granth is called "sikhan dee bhagat mala" and is sometimes reffered to as "gursikhan dee bhagat mala". there is some minor things in it that are obvious later insertions by brahminical writers (as is the case with all old rehitnamas and granths) but on the whole its full of amazing lessons in gursikhi. the book is a an explanation by bhai mani singh of bhai gurdas's 11th vaar. bhai gurdas's eleventh vaar is a long list of some notable gursikhs from the time of guru nanak to guru hargobind sahib jee all listed by guru. the story goes that once bhai mani singh asked guru gobind singh sahib jee why those specific sikhs were chosen by bhai gurdas for inclusion in his vaar and guru gobind singh sahib jee proceeded to detail all of those sikhs and the stories assocaited with them. bhai mani singh later wrote these down at the request of the sangat. one of these sikhs, at the time of guru arjun and guru hargobind, is an offical in the mughal government. now, this is the time BEFORE the mughals have gone after the sikhs, BEFORE guru arjun sahib's shaheedi. when the mughals were still on fairly good terms with the gurus. this offical comes to guru jee and says to guru jee that he works for the mughal government. he knows the govenrment does evil things and takes away peoples rights, BUT he has a young family to support and he does not know what to do. even though he is not directly involved in the inhumane treatments (he's just some minor bureacratic offical) he knows what his bosses are a party to. guru arjun sahib jee responds that working for that government in any capacity makes his as guilty as the soldiers doing the killing. he tells the sikh to put his faith in the guru and to give up that lifestyle and come and serve the guru and everything will be taken care of as long as he has faith in vaaheguru. the sikh does just that right away upon hearing guru jee's hukam and he in fact becomes a trusted sikh of guru hargobind sahib jee and ends up fighting for the guru in the very first battles of the sikhs. this is the main problem. we are all so obsessed with making money and we desire so strongly the trappings of success to show off in our materialistic culture (not just western culture but also punjabi culture) that we will go to any end. we don't think of the consequences of our daily actions. i remember i met a sikh in america once who worked for a company that designed rockets for the us army. she had no problem with her work because she was "just doing her job" and she felt no guilt for what those rockets might be used for. why not??? if it wasn't for people like her there would be no such rockets! when you become a part of that system you are just as guilty for anything that your company or government does, regardless of what you might tell yourself. a simple, happy life with our basics provided is all we really need. we waste our lives trying to make huge profits and we end up stepping all over our fellow human beings in the process. is it really worth it? can we look our guru in the eye after doing such acts? is this in keeping with the concept of "sarbat da bhalla"??? i personaly don't believe so. i think you should use your training and your skills for some other organizations. they need your help, they may not be able to pay you a lot, but you will live a simpler and happier life and know that even in your WORK you are providing seva to the world. what more could a sikh ask for??? gurFateh santbir singh

Re: Corporate lawyer?? - right or wrong?

SJ · 24 Feb 2005

Thank you for your time to respond to this. My instincts and my heart tell me that I would be a hypocrit to pursue my career with a corporate firms. Although the pro bono schemes are good, they do not cancel out the harm the firms do in the first place. And thinking about it, do I want to think about my guru night and day or do I want to be thinking about how best to earn my fees.......I know what I want now and what I should do now, with help from my brothers and sisters who have posted on here. I would be interested to know where I could purchase the book which Santbir Singh mentioned if anyone knows. Thank you. [%sig%]

Re: Corporate lawyer?? - right or wrong?

? · 25 Feb 2005

> Does anyone have any views on whether it is 'wrong' for me to work for a > corporate firm which is perhaps not morally or socially responsible???? What do you mean by moraly or socially responsible?

Re: Corporate lawyer?? - right or wrong?

santbirsingh · 25 Feb 2005

vaahe guru jee ka khalsa vaahe guru jee kee fateh www.singhbrothers.com should have the sikhan dee bhagat mala. gurFateh santbirsingh

Re: Corporate lawyer?? - right or wrong?

mexican gangster girl · 25 Feb 2005

don't be a lawyer, cuz u hv to lie defending yr clients, don't be a doctor, cuz then u hv to charge patients money, doctors are rich usuually! don't be an accountant, cuz tthen hv to cook the books like Enron & Worldcomm saga don't be a engineer, cuz contractors will tempt you with bribes$$ to close one or two eyes, don't be a pilot, cuz terrorists may force u to crash into the Twin Towers don't go near fashion industry, cuz to deal with the human(women) shapes don't do this....don't do thatt...don't do blahh...blahh... don't be a farmer cuz then you hv to use pesticide instecticide to grow vege don't be a sant and go into the mountains cuz that against sikhi don't be a stockbroker n play equities cuz thats gambling so..bottomline wat to do? so whtever profession u are in, there's bound to be moral or ethical challenges, ultimately, if your conscious is clear its ok....... example no.1 : if you a farmer, you can grow organic vegetables instead of pesticide filled ones, or grow use pesticides within known environment limits example no.2: if you are stockbroker, don't do insider trading, don't follow Martha Stewart ethics, you can invest in Ethical funds (many available on NYSE) example no3: if you are accountant, follow GAAP (generally accepted world-wide) rules example no.4: if you are anengineer, never shut your two or one eyes. example no.5: if you are a lawyer, open your own firm!!!! choose your own corporate clients, follow your you wil definitely make more money!!! the end from the little phooots in mexico Note:if you want proper advice, we will have to charge you for it (juz a small fee, not the millions lawyers usu charge!! Satnam [%sig%]

Re: Corporate lawyer?? - right or wrong?

khoji · 25 Feb 2005

I like the very practical answer from mexican gangster girl This is what I meant in my answer but people like to write long essays quoting from here and there . :-) ... laughs out loud

Re: Corporate lawyer?? - right or wrong?

Redwhiteandblue Kaur · 26 Feb 2005

SJ ji, I'm surprised at your question. Earning a Juris Doctorate degree in the US is US$100,000+ in tuition alone. However, nearly every ABA-accredited law school offers programs (many require registration when one is a 2L) where the student's tuition is forgiven, providing they pursue a career in the public or non-profit sector. Certainly, the administrators of law schools are not fools, and have heard many a tale from students that are looking to take a free ride. So...at the risk of sounding horribly rude...why are you asking this question NOW, instead of when you were a 1L or 2L? I'm not seeking to flame you...I'm just very curious. Personally, I don't see anything immoral or unethical working for corporations. Many lawyers join biBigLaw (assuming one has the pedegree of class rank, academic rigor, and leadership history to do so), get a few years of "big firm" experience, pay off your bills, and then bail out to do what they really wanted to do. Do you see anything wrong with that?

Re: Corporate lawyer?? - right or wrong?

Mandeep Singh · 26 Feb 2005

wjkk wjkf short message: i will be doing the same thing in the UK...though i have always been interested in working for a big 'magic circle' firm like clifford chance llp and the likes...i will with guru ji's kirpa go into Corporate law with an interest in Human Rights (the corporate law im interested in necessitates good human rights as i want to go into developing markets etc..). Go for it with full force if your heart wants to be their...Maharaj, if its in his hukam, will aide you. I dont personally believe you should enter a profession of the high calibre as law JUST (or majorly influenced by) paying off debts, high pay etc.... however i do live in an 'idealistic' world.... Bhul chuk maaf karni, Daas, Mandeep Singh