Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Who is Satguru?

Who is Satguru?

khoji · 24 Feb 2005

I would like to know the responses from the sangat as to who is satguru as mentioned in Gurbani

Re: Who is Satguru?

Kulbir Singh · 25 Feb 2005

Vaheguru’s created his own Guru-form and this Guru-form is called Satguru. According to Gurbani this word “Satguru” has been used as an adjective with only Siri Guru Nanak Dev jee (and his successors up to Siri Guru Gobind Singh jee Maharaaj). Gurbani does not recognise any other entity to be Guru. Only Guru Nanak Dev jee is Satguru: SABH TEY VADDA SATGUR NANAK, JIN, KAL RAAKHI MERI|| (Greatest of all is Satguru Nanak who has kept my honour in this dark age of Kalyug). JIN NANAK SATGUR BHETIYA, TINA MILIYA HAR SOYEE|| (Only those ones whom Satguru Sachay Paatshah Guru Nanak Dev jee has met, meet Vaheguru) Only Vaheguru is capable of having someone meet him or reach him. In order to accomplish this huge task he formed his own Guru-form and from the beginning of this creation kept the honour of Bhagats, through his Guru-form. When we read Bhataan de Saviyyay, we become surprised reading that Satguru jee kept the honour of Panchaali (Drupadi), Sudaama, Prahlaad and Ganika. Physically, these personalities existed long time before the advent of Siri Guru Nanak Dev jee but still Bhatts insist that they were delivered by Satguru jee. Read the following pankiti: AB RAAKHO DAAS BHAAT KEE LAAJ|| JAISI RAAKHI LAAJ BHAGAT PRAHLAAD KEE, HARNAKHASH MARAY KAR AAJ|| FUNN, DROPADI-LAAJ RAKHI HAR PRABH JEE, CHHENAT BASTR DEEN BAHU SAAJ|| SODAMA APDA TAY RAKHIYA, GANIKA PARHAT POORAY THEH KAAJ|| SIRI SATGUR, SUPRASAN KALYUG HOYE, RAKHO DAAS BHAAT KEE LAAJ|| O Satguru Raamdaas Sahib jee, right now save my honour. Save my honour as you saved Bhagat Prahlaad jee’s honour by killing Harnakash with your sharp nails. Then you kept the honour of Dropati and did not let the evil Kauravs strip her naked. You saved Sodaama from great difficulty he was embroiled in and also fulfilled all wishes of Ganika. O Satguru jee, now I implore upon you to get pleased on me and save my honour in this dark age of Kalyug. The whole of Saviyye Mahalle Pehlay ke show us how the bhagats who existed before Satguru Nanak Dev jee are now singing praises of Guru Sahib. Before 1469 Satguru jee – the Guru form of Vaheguru – kept honour of selected bhagats in all ages but in Kalyug he appeared physically to restore bhagats to Sach Khand. In this dark age, it was a must for Satguru to come in physical form and this physical form of Satguru is called Guru Nanak Dev jee. Satguru jee being the Guru-form of Vaheguru himself is totally one with Vaheguru. This is why there are pankitis in Gurbani that instruct us to see no difference in Vaheguru and Satguru. Whatever is the power if Vaheguru, same is the power of Satguru. There is no difference. They are same. His Guru-Form is merged in him. All other gurus are fake except for the Guru-form of Vaheguru – Siri Guru Nanak Dev jee and his ten forms up to Siri Guru Gobind Singh jee Maharaaj. All ten paatshaahees (Gurus) became Gurus because of presence of the Guru-Jyot in them. When Guru Jyot passed on to Guru Angad Dev jee or when Guru Jyot became active in Guru Angad Dev jee, Guru Nanak Dev jee who too was full of Guru Jyot, still matha-tekked to Guru Angad Dev jee. The sangat followed suit. Presently the Guru Jyot resides in Siri Guru Granth Sahib jee and Guru Khalsa Panth as a whole. Where ever Five Tyaar Bar Tyaar Khalsa jan Gursikhs assemble in the presence of Siri Guru Granth Sahib jee, this Guru Jyot becames active in them. The fake dehdhaari gurus of our times are nothing more than mortal beings. They are only deceiving themselves. One of the fake gurus was a professional working in Europe when he found out that he had been declared a Guru. He used to trim his beard and was just a worldly person. All of sudden he became a guru. Charan Singh Grewal one of previous gurus of Radhasoamis writes that when he was selected for the role of Guru, he was not at all aware of it. He was a lawyer who used to tie his beard at that time. He was very reluctant to become a Guru but he had no choice but was declared a Guru by Jagat Singh. If they had been real Gurus they would have experienced the presence of the Guru-Jyot within them. After becoming the so-called guru of Radhasoamis he opened up his beard to get a holy countenance. Many of these gurus including Gurinder Singh Dhillon did not start giving Naam for long time after they became guru. If Guru Jyoti had come in them, they would have started giving Naam right away. When Siri Guru Harkishan Sahib jee left his physical body, according to the will of Vaheguru, the Guru-Jyoti passed on to Siri Guru Tegh Bahadur Sahib jee. Siri Guru Harkishan Sahib jee himself said Baba Bakale i.e. he was referring to Siri Guru Tegh Bahadur Sahib jee. At amritvela, after the Guru jyot had become active in Siri Guru Tegh Bahadur Sahib jee, a special glow came on his face. His mother, Mata Nanaki jee immediately recognised the glow and knew without saying that he had become the Satguru. Modern fake gurus are lost. They have no Guru-Jyoti in them and are misleading their chelas. May Vaheguru give them Bibek-Budh and they may stop misleading people. I urge you Khoji jee to give up this bhambal-bhoosa of Bhamvar Gufa and Sahansar-Dal-Kanwal. Come to Satguru jee and these Bhanwar Gufaas and Sahansar-Dal-Kanwals will be licking your feet. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: Who is Satguru?

ks · 25 Feb 2005

well said kulbir singh jee, couldn't have put it better myself SABH TEY VADDA SATGUR NANAK, JIN, KAL RAAKHI MERI|| (Greatest of all is Satguru Nanak who has kept my honour in this dark age of Kalyug). dhan sri guru granth sahib jee!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Re: Who is Satguru?

sajjan · 25 Feb 2005

i would request khoji to come and visit tapoban sahib and discuss about satguru. he would be given all the honour of a seeker and i am sure will be satisfied in his quest

Re: Who is Satguru?

khoji · 25 Feb 2005

This question was never posted by me but I like people defending sikhi

Re: Who is Satguru?

Singh- · 25 Feb 2005

"Before 1469 Satguru jee – the Guru form of Vaheguru – kept honour of selected bhagats in all ages but in Kalyug he appeared physically to restore bhagats to Sach Khand. In this dark age, it was a must for Satguru to come in physical form and this physical form of Satguru is called Guru Nanak Dev jee. " Bhai Sahib I did not understand this part. Obviously the Bhagats were Brahmgyani so they were Vaheguru Themselves also (Brahmgyani Aap Parmesar) and Bhagat Bani is in Dasam Granth. What did you mean by Kept honour" and before Guru Ji came were the Bhagats not already in Sach Khand? I didn't understand this part please could you expand a little more. Everything else made perfect sense.

Re: Who is Satguru?

Kulbir Singh · 25 Feb 2005

-------------------- "Before 1469 Satguru jee – the Guru form of Vaheguru – kept honour of selected bhagats in all ages but in Kalyug he appeared physically to restore bhagats to Sach Khand. In this dark age, it was a must for Satguru to come in physical form and this physical form of Satguru is called Guru Nanak Dev jee. " Bhai Sahib I did not understand this part. Obviously the Bhagats were Brahmgyani so they were Vaheguru Themselves also (Brahmgyani Aap Parmesar) and Bhagat Bani is in Dasam Granth. What did you mean by Kept honour" and before Guru Ji came were the Bhagats not already in Sach Khand? I didn't understand this part please could you expand a little more. Everything else made perfect sense. ---------------------- When Dropadi who was being stripped naked by the evil Dushasana at the behest of his evil brother Duryodhna, she cried out to everyone in the court for help. The blind kind Dhrishtrashter kept quiet and so did the mighty and righteous Bheesham. Dronacharya had eaten salt of Kauravs and could not utter a word other than sympathise and Kripacharya just lowered his eyes. Yudhishter her husband was looking down with an extreme guilt for what he had brought upon his family. Bheem was so furious that he wanted to kill with his sight but was helpless as he was a slave to Duryodhna who had won over him in the game of Chaupar (a kind of gambling game). Arjun was composed but there was a tempest going on in his heart. Nakul And Sehdev were angry but were helpless like their brothers. Amidst all of these good men but helpless men, Dropadi who is also called Panchali was wailing and crying for help. Duryodhna had ordered that she be stripped naked in the court. Dushasana his brother was carrying out the orders. He had brought her down from her palace by dragging her by her hair. Other Kauravs were celebrating including Karna. When Panchali was left with just one cloth on her body she pleaded to the almighty Vaheguru. Gurbani writes that as per the will of Vaheguru, she realised Raam-Naam at that instance (Panchali ko Raaj Sabha mein, Raam Naam sudh aayee). In a split second she was saved. They kept pulling the cloth but the cloth did not uncover her body. They were tired pulling and pulled hundreds of meters of cloth but her body stayed covered with that last piece of cloth. According to Mahabharata, it was Siri Krishna who kept her honour but according to Gurbani it was Vaheguru or more precisely his Guru-form – the Guru Jyoti – that kept her honour. Whether this Guru-Jyoti worked through Krishna or directly is a different subject and not relevant here. The bottomline is that according to Gurbani her honour was kept by Satguru jee. Her honour was kept in the sense that she was saved from this worldly problem. This does not mean that she ascended to Sach Khand. This happened only when Guru Sahib gave them Naam. Previously it is possible that Guru Sahib may have given this Naam to selected individuals in a gupt form but only in Kalyug did Guru Sahib openly give Satnaam (the true Naam) in order to deliver people from Kalyug, into Sach Khand. According to Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh jee, Bhagats who were reciting Kirtam Naam (qualitative Naam) and not the true Naam reached up to Karam Khand. No one can reach Sach Khand without the true Guru who bestows the true Naam to his gursikhs. Now with modern research Giani Gurdit Singh jee has proved beyond doubt that all Bhagats physically met Guru Nanak Dev jee Maharaaj. Baba Farid whose baani is in Siri Guru Granth Sahib jee was actually Farid Sani who was sitting on the gaddi of original Farid Shakarganj of the 13th century. Guru Sahib met Farid Sani whose real name was Sheikh Brahm and he was greatly affected by Guru Sahib’s presence. Guru Sahib blessed him with Naam and enabled him to write Gurbani. If you look at the language he has written, it does not seem to be any different from Siri Guru Nanak Dev jee’s language. 300 years is a lot of time and language changes a lot in this time but there is no difference in Baba Farid jee’s Punjabi and Siri Guru Nanak Dev jee’s Punjabi. The use of “Saadh” word in Baba Farid jee’s baani is only because he met Guru Sahib. He himself writes that “Kar kirpa Prabh Saadh Sang meli|| Jaa phir dekha taan mera Allah Beli|| (Allah did kirpa and I met Saadh. Then I realised that Allah had become my friend) It is unlikely for a Muslim to use the word “Saadh”. Later Sufi Sants did use Hindi words but no one from that time as 12th and 13th century has used such words unless they met someone as Guru Nanak Sahib. They would have used Murshid or other such words but never Saadh. In any case, only those jeevs who came to the sharan of Siri Guru Nanak Dev jee Maharaaj got into Sach Khand. Only Satguru can enable one to go to Sach Khand. No one else. Bin Satgur kinai na paaiyo, bin Satgur kinai na paaiya. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: Who is Satguru?

khoji_2 · 25 Feb 2005

jn nwnk auqm pdu pwieAw siqgur kI ilv lwie jan naanak outham padh paaeiaa sathigur kee liv laae here dhan dhan guru nanak sahib ji says that 'Nanak has found the top most level and has got the 'liv' of satguru how can satguru be guru nanak sahib when guru nanak sahib is refering that he has himslef got the 'liv' with satguru

Re: Who is Satguru?

.. · 25 Feb 2005

Jis Milay Man Hoi Anand So Satgur Kaheeyai

Re: Who is Satguru?

Singh- · 25 Feb 2005

Thanks Bhai Sahib. But it is not possible all the Bhagats were all blessed with Gurmantar by Akal Purakh/Satguru himself at the time? When you say Satguru blessed them and took them to Saach Khand, does this mean after his avtar in 1469? For those such as Bhagat Kabeer couldn't Satguru have given them Gurmantar straight away since he is beyond time? I just have problems believing no one achieved Mukti between the start of Kaljug and Guru Nanak's coming to this earth. Apologies. If the Bhagats were only reciting Kirtam Naam then they could not have been Brahmgyani, for what reason is their Bani in Guru Granth Sahib Ji then? Please do not be offended by my questions I am just confused.

Re: Who is Satguru?

dass · 25 Feb 2005

If in Gurbani Satguru is used in two ways. 1 Ik Onkar satguru Prasad( for In Onkar) 2 For ten guru's We read in gurbani where Guru Nanak very humbly praises his satguru and so does kabir and ravidass in gurbani. If read the slock guru nanak dev ji which says. when God created himself and then he created his Name(Ik Onkar-Anhand dhun) and second thing created "Kudrat" that is maya(universe and it beings) SHABAD GURU SURAT DHUN CHEELA( WORDS OF GURUNANAK) WHEN YOGIS ASKED HIM WHO IS HIS GURU) That shabad Ik Onkar( beause this anhand shabad no tongue can pronounce it and that is always called SATNAM) SABH TEY VADDA SATGUR NANAK, JIN, KAL RAAKHI MERI|| When guru Arjun dev ji said Sabh Tey vadda Satgur and pause then understand Nanak jin Kal Raakhi Meri All gurus used nanak in there bani . So to me this slok means: Threre is no one greater than Satguru Ik Onkar(Satnam) who is the guru of nannak and all guru's. Also there is only one pura satguru that is Ik Onkar(Satnam) Satguru. But anybody can understand this in their own views dass Only

Re: Who is Satguru?

Kulbir Singh · 25 Feb 2005

----------- here dhan dhan guru nanak sahib ji says that 'Nanak has found the top most level and has got the 'liv' of satguru how can satguru be guru nanak sahib when guru nanak sahib is refering that he has himslef got the 'liv' with satguru --------------- First of all, for your kind information, this shabad is by Siri Guru Raamdaas jee Maharaaj and not by Siri Guru Nanak Dev jee Maharaaj. Second thing is that only Satguru Nanak Dev jee Maharaaj adopted Vaheguru as his Satguru: Aprampar Parbraham Parmeshar, Nanak Gur miliya soyee|| (Sorath Mahalla Pehla) Siri Guru Nanak Dev jee Maharaaj states that he met The Aprampar Parbraham Parmeshar as his Guru. The word “Nanak” here is a singular noun in Sampradaan Karak. In Sampradaan Karak the aunkad of even singular noun gets removed. There is no doubt that Guru Nanak Dev jee Maharaaj adopted Vaheguru as his Guru. No one else in this universe has adopted Vaheguru as his Guru. Everyone else had a Guru. Your present Guru Gurinder Singh had a Guru and his Guru had a Guru. Jaimal Singh the founder of Beas branch of Radhasoami Matt had a Guru i.e. Swami Shiv Dyaal of Agra and even Shiv Dyaal had a guru – Tulsi jee. But Siri Guru Nanak Dev jee maharaaj had no physical or worldly Guru. His Guru was Vaheguru himself. Guru Nanak Dev jee is the Guru-form of Vaheguru. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: Who is Satguru?

Singhnee · 25 Feb 2005

sireeraag mehalaa 4 || naam milai man thripatheeai bin naamai dhhrig jeevaas || koee guramukh sajan jae milai mai dhasae prabh gunathaas || ho this vittahu cho kha(n)neeai mai naam karae paragaas ||1|| maerae preethamaa ho jeevaa naam dhhiaae || bin naavai jeevan naa thheeai maerae sathigur naam dhrirraae ||1|| rehaao || naam amolak rathan hai poorae sathigur paas || sathigur saevai lagiaa kadt rathan dhaevai paragaas || dhha(n)n vaddabhaagee vadd bhaageeaa jo aae milae gur paas ||2|| jinaa sathigur purakh n bhaettiou sae bhaageheen vas kaal || oue fir fir jon bhavaaeeahi vich visattaa kar vikaraal || ounaa paas dhuaas n bhitteeai jin a(n)thar krodhh cha(n)ddaal ||3|| sathigur purakh a(n)mrith sar vaddabhaagee naavehi aae || oun janam janam kee mail outharai niramal naam dhrirraae || jan naanak outham padh paaeiaa sathigur kee liv laae ||4||2||66|| Last pankti of above shabad is mentioned by khoji2 jee. Above shabad is by our fourth Guru sahib jee not by Siri Guru Nanak Dev jee and Nanak word is used as a mohar(stamp)only. It does not have ounkaR(-) under kakka of 'Nanak'. Guru Ramdas jee's Guru was Siri Guru Amardas jee(third Guru Nanak) not Vaheguru. So, siri Guru Ramdas jee talking about his satguru.

Re: Who is Satguru?

bhopinder singh · 25 Feb 2005

very good answer here dhan dhan guru nanak sahib ji says that 'Nanak has found the top most level and has got the 'liv' of satguru how can satguru be guru nanak sahib when guru nanak sahib is refering that he has himslef got the 'liv' with satguru --------------- First of all, for your kind information, this shabad is by Siri Guru Raamdaas jee Maharaaj and not by Siri Guru Nanak Dev jee Maharaaj. aidan thappar maro innan de

Re: Who is Satguru?

WAIT ONE MINUTE! · 25 Feb 2005

page 308 Satgur Kee Banni Sat Sat Kar Jaann Gursikhh, Har Karta Aap Muho Kada-ai....

Re: Who is Satguru?

Kulbir Singh · 25 Feb 2005

----------- If the Bhagats were only reciting Kirtam Naam then they could not have been Brahmgyani, for what reason is their Bani in Guru Granth Sahib Ji then? -------------- This is precisely my point. If bhagats had been reciting kirtam Naam, they could not have become Brahmgiyanis and could not have written Baani. And you cannot get Sat-Naam (true Naam) without the true Guru. True Guru is Guru Nanak as this is written in Gurbani and explained in the posts above this. So unless one meets Siri Guru Nanak Dev jee Maharaaj, how can one get Satnaam and how without Satnaam can one reach Sachkhand? How they met Siri Guru Nanak Dev jee, only Guru Sahib knows. History can be altered but not Gurbani. History can be wrong but not Gurbani. Gurbani says Guru Nanak is Satguru and he alone can give Satnaam. He must have met bhagats somehow to give them Naam. Read Giani Gurdit Singh jee's book on this subject. It is an eye-opener. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: Who is Satguru?

khoji_2 · 26 Feb 2005

**************************** Author: bhopinder singh Date: 02-25-05 15:54 very good answer here dhan dhan guru nanak sahib ji says that 'Nanak has found the top most level and has got the 'liv' of satguru how can satguru be guru nanak sahib when guru nanak sahib is refering that he has himslef got the 'liv' with satguru --------------- First of all, for your kind information, this shabad is by Siri Guru Raamdaas jee Maharaaj and not by Siri Guru Nanak Dev jee Maharaaj. ******************* aidan thappar maro innan de ***************************** fareedhaa jo thai maaran mukeeaaa(n) thinhaa n maarae ghu(n)m || aapanarrai ghar jaaeeai pair thinhaa dhae chu(n)m ||7|| Neednt say anything more because I believe in MY GURU Veer Kulbir Singh Ji you are bhramgyani that you consider me Radhasowami???????????? Or did you get a vision???????? Did WE not have 10 Nanaks and then Jugo Jug Atal Dhan Siri Guru Granth Sahib Ji? So what point are you trying to prove by saying that it is by 4th Nanak Sahib?????????????????? Eh???????????? Still waiting for a definitive one liner as to who is SATGURU in your opinion?

Re: Who is Satguru?

gourree || · 26 Feb 2005

raam japo jeea aisae aisae || dhhroo prehilaadh japiou har jaisae ||1|| Just as Dhroo and Prahlaad meditated on the Lord, so should you meditate on the Lord, O my soul. ||1|| Who was the guru of Dhroo, Prehlaadh?

Re: Who is Satguru?

khoji_2 · 26 Feb 2005

************* Author: WAIT ONE MINUTE! Date: 02-25-05 16:04 page 308 Satgur Kee Banni Sat Sat Kar Jaann Gursikhh, Har Karta Aap Muho Kada-ai.... ********************* Yes I agree that it is satguru's bani 4th guru nanak sahib tells us this he could have said guru nanak kee bani? This proves that guru nanak sahib was delivering the bani of SATGURU to the mortals?? Am i wrong?

Re: Who is Satguru?

Gurdaspuria · 26 Feb 2005

Waheguru Jee ka Khasa Waheguru jee kee Fateh In Sikhism there is no place for adampresti(Human worship) or boutpresti(idol worship). Therefore "who is Sateguru" is vital to understand. Following translation is from Gurbani of SGGS and Guru Gobind Singh jee which shed light on the subject. Worship only one God through one SateGuru who is common for all. In all one Joot is pervading. Recognize all human equal Guru Gobind Singh Amrit Keertan 154 My SateGuru, forever and ever, does not come and go. SateGuru is the Imperishable Creator Lord; SateGuru is permeating and pervading among all. Guru Raam Daas Ji Raag Soohee 759 The SateGuru is the ship of Shabad which carries the Gursikhs across. Guru Nanak Dev Ji Raag Maaroo 1009 The SateGuru is spiritual knowledge/wisdom. Guru Raam Daas Ji Raag Maaroo 1069 The SateGuru is the Word, and the Word is the SateGuru, who teaches the Path of Liberation.| Guru Raam Daas Ji Raag Kaanraa 1309 Waaho! Waaho! Blessed and Great is the Formless SateGuru, who has no end or limitation. Guru Raam Daas Ji Salok Vaaraan Thay Vadheek 1421 The Guru is the Primal Being, which is beyond birth or incarnation. Guru Raam Daas Ji Raag Gauree 172 Let that mouth be burnt, which says that our God/SateGuru is subject to birth. Guru Arjan Dev Ji Raag Bhairao 1136 Waheguru Jee ka Khasa Waheguru jee kee Fateh

Re: Who is Satguru?

khoji_2 · 26 Feb 2005

thanks gurdaspuria ji for that compilation it really is helpful veer kulbir singh ji dhan guru nanak dev ji is our guru but not satguru if i am wrong then please get some pangtian which prove baba nanak sahib to be satguru

Re: Who is Satguru?

Kulbir Singh · 26 Feb 2005

--------- veer kulbir singh ji dhan guru nanak dev ji is our guru but not satguru if i am wrong then please get some pangtian which prove baba nanak sahib to be satguru -------------- Here are some pankitis where Siri Guru Nanak Dev jee has been called Satguru: SABH TEY VADDA SATGUR NANAK, JIN KAL RAAKHI MERI|| and SATGUR NANAK PARGATIYA, MITEE DHUNDH JAG CHAANAN HOYA|| One benti to Gurdaspuria and his other friends. We are dealing with Radhasoamis here who are trying to prove that Satguru should be dehdhaari guru. I know what your stand is on this i.e. same as SDO Mahinder Singh. We have discussed this before and very well know that you don't consider Ten Guru Sahibaan to be Satguru but just gurus. I ask you, and perhaps you can respond to this by giving a shabad where difference between Guru and Satguru is shown. Our stand is that in Gurbani there is no difference between the word "Guru" and "Satguru"; and there are not different categories of Gurus and Satgurus. Guru-form of Vaheguru is called Satguru. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: Who is Satguru?

.. · 26 Feb 2005

Aagiyaa Bhei Akal Kee Tabee Chalayo Panth Sabh Sikhan Ko Hukam Hai Guru Maniyo Granth Guru Granth Jee Maniyo PARGAT GURA KEE DEH Just as Baba Nand Singh said in reference to Guru Granth Sahib: "Eh Jeunda Jagda Bolda Guru Nanak Hai!" Yes, Guru Granth Sahib does speak and YES, there are people that can listen to Guru Granth Sahib speak. Radhasoamis agree that Guru Nanak is the SatGuru-Avtar for Kaljug. Then, all we have to do is show them the truth by telling them that 11th Gurgaddi is eternally given to Guru Granth Sahib Maharaj.

Re: Who is Satguru?

khoji_2 · 27 Feb 2005

no where in this thread any one has tried to take it to the route of proving that you require a dehdhari guru? i dont know why sikhs of today have such a phobia about everything including radhasowamis naanak mailaa oojal thaa thheeai jaa sathigur maahi samaae guru amardas sahib ji nanak without aunkad kulbir singh ji how will you 'samaae' into guru nanak sahib? as per my understanding you have to get 'lean' into akalpurakh who is also kartapurakh saas saas har gaavai naanak sathigur dhaak leeaa maeraa parradhaa jeeo guru arjan dev sahib ji nanak with aunkad is guru nanak sahib dhakining the purdha here or is satguru dhaking the purdha here? kahu naanak maeraa sathigur pooraa guru arjan dev sahib without aunkad is guru arjan dev sahib ji talking about himslef that he himself is pura or 5th nanak sahib ji talking about their satguru? har sathigur maelahu dhaeiaa kar jan naanak dhhovai paae guru ram daas sahib ji with aunkad is guru ramdas sahib here asking to meet himself? or is he asking for the 'har satguru' satguru of all? i hope the replies which i get for this post will be enlightning and help me in understand the gurbani more as there are much more learned guru ke sikh on this message board PS : a request please donot label me as radhasowami

Re: Who is Satguru?

jugroop singh · 27 Feb 2005

VahiGuruJiKaKhalsa,VahiGuruJiKiFateh! Veer/Bhain '..' Ji wrote: 'Radhasoamis agree that Guru Nanak is the SatGuru-Avtar for Kaljug. Then, all we have to do is show them the truth by telling them that 11th Gurgaddi is eternally given to Guru Granth Sahib Maharaj'. This 'belief' is, if one is to judge their Mat by the ocean of literature they produce, nothing but lipservice. Remember, the very basis of their concept is that without a physical body, there can be no Sat Guru. So, even if they pretend to believe the above, they are either lying or have been confused by their own Mat i.e. how can Siree Guru Sahib Ji (in the 1st form) be the Avtar for KalJug when they have another 'Guru' currently in place, who came into place during this very same KalYug...will they claim he has received the VahiGuru-Jyot which once 'walked this earth' as Siree Nanak Sahib Ji? Their stupidity knows no bounds because, despite their worshipping their human 'Guru', they still try to push their concept of 'Shabad Guru' as of 'more importance' than the 'physical body of their living Guru' but then ofcourse, have to carry on defending the 'need for the physical body of their Guru'!. Are you confused...well, i don't blame you! Their official stance is that Siree Guru Sahib Ji is simply a 'book' - to believe this notion is a sign of seriously maree kismat..however to go out and propogate this to others in an attempt to pull them away from Siree Guru Sahib Ji, which many of them do, is a whole other matter - just imagine the effects of such karams!!! Boy, do i feel sorry for them...and for that matter, the NamDharees who despite what they say, would agree with the Radha Soami's views regarding this 'book'. To be frank, Radh Soami Mat is simply an attempt to cash-in on many of the treasures of GurMat and Siree Guru Sahib Ji (Siree Guru Granth Sahib Ji), whilst establishing a 'GurGaddi', diluted Maryada and body of followers. Also notable is the fact that they steer clear, rather conspicuously, of mentioning Siree Guru Gobind Singh Sahib Ji as much as possible...why?...because therein lies the one factor that debunks ALL of their beliefs i.e. He has DIRECTLY taught: - No need for HUMAN BEING as denoting physical Guru ('Guru Mannioh Granth...') - No need for ONE PERSON as Guru to 'link' with Shabad Guru (in fact Sikhs have been told affirmatively not to do so...instead we are told to find 10th Maharaaj, and the othe 9 Maharaajs in the Angs of Siree Guru Granth Sahib Ji and within the Khalsa Panth as a whole) So, if they want to 'debunk' the views of Sikhs, let them prove that Siree Guru Gobind Singh Ji was 'misguided' or that He never gave GurGaddi to Siree Guru Granth Sahib Ji. Now, how will they do that? The Truth is, however unpalatable some people may find it, that Radha Soami is a Kacha Marag primarily for Punjabis and others who don't have the blessed Kismat of identifying who is The SatGuru and who is a pakhand 'Guru' during this KalYug... Furthermore, the unfortunate followers have their 'nominal attachments to basic Sikhi concepts' exploited by their newfound 'Guru' who will keep Kesh, wear a Kara and come across as a 'bit of a Sikh'. When setting a trap of falsehood, why not smear the bait with a small amount of Truth... If you encounter any 'confused' Radha Soamis, or are someone who is confused yourself, i beg you to make a choice, as opposed to further misguiding yourself into thinking you can have 'two masters' which itself is derided in GurBani. Please take this from someone who before finding Sikhi was close to taking on board their rubbish... Choose: The Master of KalYug and Every Age Forever More Eternal Shabad Guru, SatGuru, Siree Guru Granth Sahib Ji (given GuruGaddi DIRECTLY by 10th Mehl Siree Guru Gobind Singh Sahib Ji) or 'Guru Gurinder' (given 'GurGaddi' by 'Guru Charan') VahiGuruJiKaKhalsa,VahiGuruJiKiFateh!

Re: Who is Satguru?

singh · 28 Feb 2005

vaheguru jee kaa khalsa vaheguru jee kee fateh to veer gurdaspuria as kulbir singh has said your views are exactly that, YOURS, do not try to brainwash the sangat by mistranslating gurbani tuks as given by your ustad sdo. i did not want to respond to this thread but it digusts and hurts me when anti-guru sahib parchaar is given a platform as guru jee beatifully puts it that sometimes it is better not to argue with moorakhs/fools. you do not have a monopoly on who is satguru. kulbir singh has answered very well that the true satguru is dhan sri guru nanak dev ji and jot of guru sahib is now in guru granth sahib ji for eternity. please remember what happened to ramrai when he changed one word of gurbani, guru jee turned his face from him and told him not too come back. here we are in this day and age changing as many words and meanings because of the say so of an individual who has led less of a exemplary life this is not nindia but fact, i do not wish to publish details but his kartoota are/were not gurmat inclined in any way and if you knew you wouldn't follow him(if you had any sense). if guru sahib turned his face to ramarai what do you think will happen to people who are distorting and mistranslating for their own needs. only by thgrace of guru sahib and blessing can we get anywhere spiritually, and IF guru sahib does kirpa only then we will receive the ultimate spiritual stage. doing a bit of simran and achieving a few ridhi sidhis is a low achievement and if that brings haumai you lose all focus and go on the wrong path(please remeber yogis can also achieve ridhis sidhi by their technique which shows it is how long the gurmat path is). distorting history, rehat, amrit gurbani,speaking against shaheeds of 78,harmandir sahib, brahmgyanis of guru sahib times, creating your own amrit sanchaar......the list could go on forever (by the way there is proof of all of this) if this not blasphemmy of guru sahib i dont know what is. you can do as much simran as you like but bhai sahib randhir singh clearly states that doing it without the grace of satguru guru granth sahib ji (who is naam dha dhatha) you will not receive the true blessings. and if we dont have full faith in guru sahib in the first place what chance have we got!!!! on many threads you try to put your viewpoint forward hopefuuly it will go unnoticed by the sangat, you also spell satguru incorrectly, as you spell it the way your ustad pronounces it which in itself is unforgivable. jae ko gur thae vaemukh hovai bin sathgur mukath n paavai || One who turns away from the Guru, and becomes baymukh - without the True Guru, he shall not find liberation. paavai mukath n hor thhai koee pushhahu bibaekeeaa jaaeae || He shall not find liberation anywhere else either; go and ask the wise ones about this. anaek joonee bharam aavai vin sathgur mukath n paaeae || He shall wander through countless incarnations; without the True Guru, he shall not find liberation. fir mukath paaeae laag charanee sathguroo sabadh sunaaeae || But liberation is attained, when one is attached to the feet of the True Guru, chanting the Word of the Shabad. kehai naanak veechaar dhaekhahu vin sathgur mukath n paaeae ||22|| Says Nanak, contemplate this and see, that without the True Guru, there is no liberation. | if still in doubt then you go your way and we will stay on this firm stand that DHAN DHAN SATGURU GURU GRANTH SAHIB MAHARAAJ is the true , living satguru for eternity, and for the misguided ones, only with full faith, prem, pyaar and sharda will this be realized. if not as a gurmukh writes many will come and go but only the true gurmukhs will be remembered. to admin this is not an attack on an individual, but the views given which are anti gurmat and do not help the youth of today who already being attacked by kalyug daily, we need to guide them the right way not put doubts of every little in there minds just beacuse someone decides theywant re-translate everything according to there matt. all above info is factual so hopefully you will put this up. vaheguru jee kaa khalsa vaheguru jee kee fateh

Re: Who is Satguru?

justin · 28 Feb 2005

Hello dear friends... I need to remove some misconceptions that have been arising here ... Jugroop mentioned that RS worship their Guru ... if worshipping means they love their guru and have faith in Him then you can say that they worship .. but if it means that they do "dhoop agarbatti" then you have been misled. If RS say that you can see light within then if no body has seen it in the past 100 years ... then it would not have been in existence now .... RS never considered Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji as mere book ... that still remains Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji. So ... no point of discussion on rumours. Let me know of one single saint who does not have a guru .... Kabir Sahib did not take naam dan from Guru Nanak Dev ...... he took it from Ramanand Sahib..... why do we have his bani in Guru Granth Sahib because he talked about santmat that Guru Sahibaan were preaching ... as simple as that ... I am not a history student ... so I do not know what Guru Sahibaan's lifestyle was or what they did for their living before they were bestowed with gurugaddi ... but the fact is after 500 years you won't believe all the present saints to live the same lifestyle ... the important thing is "hak halaal ki kamai" ... if any Saint is dependent on others for his living then he is not a saint at all ... God cannot be unfair to so many human beings who are not Sikhs, that they would not be able to reach Him unless and until they all adopt Sikhism ... by this I am not saying that RS is a separate identity than Sikhism ... Ultimately the thing is ... if you are able to see light within during abhyaas then the path you are taking is correct ... else you have to search. Why we are so particular about RS ..... I can tell you that an RS friend if he has taken naam daan and has some spiritual progress will never come down to a level as stating that SGGS is mere a book ... he will have full faith in Guru Sahibaan .... And this is also bitter truth that not all RS friends who have taken naam dan are able to see light because they lack concentration and love for God ... or you can say that God still does not want that because of some karmas. Any human being no matter to which religion, caste he belongs ... no matter who his guru is ... if he is able to see lotuses and is making spiritual progress ... NOTHING ELSE MATTERS ... I remember reading bhai bala's janam sakhi of Guru Nanak Dev ji where he asks Him that when would he come next in Deh Swaroop ... Guru Nanak Dev ji answers that He will come back in deh swaroop and he will have 14 gaddis then ... now only thing is when He comes back ... will we be able to identify Him .... I am not saying that RS Gurus are the ones that He was talking about ... it could be or it may be somewhere else or yet to come ... but only thing to ponder is Guru gaddi of Guru Nanak Dev Ji and Kabir Sahib co-existed....that means you can have more than one true saint at a time .... But again this should not matter to us because if He comes back that will not lessen the importance of SGGS .... the only thing that matters is .. "Do we see light within ...?"

Re: Who is Satguru?

Kulbir Singh · 28 Feb 2005

Our Radhasoami Friend – Justin, ------------ Jugroop mentioned that RS worship their Guru ... if worshipping means they love their guru and have faith in Him then you can say that they worship .. but if it means that they do "dhoop agarbatti" then you have been misled. ------------ I agree that Radhasoamis don’t do this kind of stuff i.e. agar-batee Dhoop jyot etc. They use Varnatmak Naam to get to Dhunatmak Naam. This Dhunatmak Naam they try to get to is not achievable by their Aalti-palti aasan. Only Gurmat Naam can get one to the jyot-vigaasi form of Naam i.e. that form of Naam that is holding the whole universe together. ----------- RS never considered Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji as mere book ... that still remains Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji. So ... no point of discussion on rumours. ------------ Over here you are wrong. There are several references in several of the books published by Radhasoami Beas in which they have written that “a book cannot be Guru”. Who are they targeting when they say that a book cannot be Guru? Charan Singh himself said in one of his cassettes when doing translation of sunaiya pauris of Siri Jap jee Sahib. He said something along the lines that a book or pothi cannot be Guru. ------------ Let me know of one single saint who does not have a guru .... Kabir Sahib did not take naam dan from Guru Nanak Dev ...... he took it from Ramanand Sahib..... why do we have his bani in Guru Granth Sahib because he talked about santmat that Guru Sahibaan were preaching ... as simple as that ... -------------- You ask if any saint had no Guru. The answer is that Siri Guru Nanak Dev jee had no human Guru. His Guru was Vaheguru himself and Siri Guru Nanak Dev jee himself has written this. Ponder upon this pankiti: APRAMPAR PARBRAHAM PARMESHAR, NANAK GUR MILIYA SOYEE|| ------------ God cannot be unfair to so many human beings who are not Sikhs, that they would not be able to reach Him unless and until they all adopt Sikhism ... by this I am not saying that RS is a separate identity than Sikhism ... ------------ Then why do you, O Radhasomis believe that only if one comes to your Guru one can reach Anami Lok, Satlok and Radhasoami Dhaam? Do you believe that anyone can reach the top level i.e. the Radhasoami Dhaam without your Guru? I have read in your books where you have written very clearly that all religions are within the realms of “kaal” and only your faith i.e. the Radhasoami faith can take you to Radhasoami Dhaam. ----------- Ultimately the thing is ... if you are able to see light within during abhyaas then the path you are taking is correct ... else you have to search. --------------- What is so hard about seeing the light? This fake light can be seen by anyone who thinks that he wants to see the light and does paath? Anyone can hear those so called mystical sounds like bell, flute etc if your mind wants to listen to it. The real thing is if you hear Anhad Shabad – the real ones and not some flute, dhol, bell or water fall etc. as you guys preach. --------------- I can tell you that an RS friend if he has taken naam daan and has some spiritual progress will never come down to a level as stating that SGGS is mere a book ... he will have full faith in Guru Sahibaan .... ------------ No they don’t have faith in Ten Guru Sahibaan. Then how dare they say that Kabir was the Guru of Guru Nanak Dev jee? According to Siri Guru Granth Sahib jee Kabir is called a Bhagat while Guru Sahibaan are called “Mahalla”. There is a difference. Guru Sahibaan are above everyone else. ------------- Any human being no matter to which religion, caste he belongs ... no matter who his guru is ... if he is able to see lotuses and is making spiritual progress ... NOTHING ELSE MATTERS ... ------------ Gurmat is greatest of all. This Sahansar-Dal-Kanwal i.e. the lotus with 1000 petals is nothing at all and nor is Bhanwar Gufaa anything for Khalsa. Khalsa does not go this route. This is the route of the Jogis. Who wants to see Sahansar-Dal-Kanwal? I don’t. This is a much lower state. Gursikhs aim from Vaheguru and that is it. Anything short of Vaheguru himself is not acceptable to Gursikhs. ------------ I remember reading bhai bala's janam sakhi of Guru Nanak Dev ji where he asks Him that when would he come next in Deh Swaroop ... Guru Nanak Dev ji answers that He will come back in deh swaroop and he will have 14 gaddis then ... now only thing is when He comes back ... will we be able to identify Him .... ------------- Impossible!!!!! This is a blatant lie. Bhai Bala’s Janamsaakhi that you are reading is distorted and also this janamsaakhi is not a book of authority in Sikh Panth. ------------ I am not saying that RS Gurus are the ones that He was talking about ... it could be or it may be somewhere else or yet to come ... but only thing to ponder is Guru gaddi of Guru Nanak Dev Ji and Kabir Sahib co-existed....that means you can have more than one true saint at a time .... ----------- Siri Guru Nanak Dev jee is the Satguru while Kabir jee is a Bhagat. This makes it clear. Bhagat jee is great but he is not a Guru and he never claimed to be one either. He never gave Naam. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: Who is Satguru?

J Singh · 28 Feb 2005

justin wrote: RS never considered Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji as mere book ... that still remains Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji. So ... no point of discussion on rumours.>> In the above line, you say "Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji". Just ask your RS friends whether they consider "Guru" Granth Sahib ji as their "guru" or mere "granth sahib". If they don't consider him as their Guru than how is "Guru ji" not just a spiritual book to them!! Truth is hard to swallow. I am sticking my head out by going against the majority here and saying that the pankati "SABHTEYVADDA SATGURNANAKJINKALRAAKHIMERI|| to me means,"Nanak, Satguru (Vaheguru) is above all ( sabh te vadda) and He does my "raakhi" in Kalyug. In my limited samjh the word Nanak here is a stamp. Guru Nanak Dev ji has also directly addressed Vaheguru in JapJi Sahib many times and called himself "neech" in humility. VJKK VJKF

Re: Who is Satguru?

Kulbir Singh · 28 Feb 2005

It is one of the fundamental Sikhi principle that Siri Guru Nanak Dev jee is our Satguru and before coming to this world in human form, he existed in jyot form and has been merged in Vaheguru. In essence, Siri Guru Nanak Dev jee is the Guru form of Vaheguru himself. Vaheguru himself takes the form of worshipper, what is being worshipped and Naam that is used to worship him. JYOT ROOP HAR AAP, GURU NANAK KAHAAIYO|| (The jyot-roop Vaheguru himself took form of Guru Nanak). Here “Jyot roop Har” is Karta kaarak noun of Kiriya vaachi shabad – kaahaiyo. “Guru Nanak” in this pankiti appears as Karam Kaarak. Some may argue that it is Sampradaan Kaarak but I think it is Karam Kaarak. Either way, the meanings don't change much as there is a very fine line between "Karam Kaarak" and "Sampradaan Kaarak". >>>>>> I am sticking my head out by going against the majority here and saying that the pankati "SABHTEYVADDA SATGURNANAKJINKALRAAKHIMERI|| to me means,"Nanak, Satguru (Vaheguru) is above all ( sabh te vadda) and He does my "raakhi" in Kalyug. In my limited samjh the word Nanak here is a stamp. >>>>>>>>>> I am not sure how you arrived at these meanings. In this pankiti you cannot separate “Nanak” and “Satguru” as they both appear in “Karta Kaarak” form of noun. Jin is the pronoun used for “Satgur Nanak” and appears in karta kaarak form as well. “kal” is an istree-ling naav used in the form of “karam kaarak. “meri” is a pronoun used in form of “Sampradaan Kaarak”. “Satgur Nanak” is the karta kaarak of kiriya-vaachi shabad – “raakhi”. The meanings are very straight-forward that “Satgur Nanak is the greatest of all who has kept my honour”. The master of Gurbani viyaakaran, Professor Sahib Singh too has interpreted this as I have written above i.e. Satgur Nanak is the greatest of all. I humbly suggest that you read more about Kaaraks. Following are the eight kaaraks used in Gurbani: 1) Karta Kaarak 2) Karam Kaarak 3) Karan Kaarak 4) Sampradaan Karak 5) Apaadaan Kaarak 6) Adhikaran Kaarak 7) Sambodhan Kaarak 8) Sambandh Kaarak. Every noun and pronoun that appears in Gurbani appear in one of these eight kaaraks. Depending on what kind of lag-maatars the word has, we can determine which kaarak it is in. Please refer to Professor Sahib Singh jee’s Gurbani Viyaakaran for more details. You can also refer to Giani Harbans Singh jee’s Naveen Gurbani Viyaakaran. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: Who is Satguru?

justin · 28 Feb 2005

Kulbir Singh, I agree that Radhasoamis don’t do this kind of stuff i.e. agar-batee Dhoop jyot etc. They use Varnatmak Naam to get to Dhunatmak Naam. This Dhunatmak Naam they try to get to is not achievable by their Aalti-palti aasan. Only Gurmat Naam can get one to the jyot-vigaasi form of Naam i.e. that form of Naam that is holding the whole universe together. ----------- How can you be so sure if you haven't seen the other side of the coin ... by your reason all people before Guru Nanak Dev Ji for 1500 years and more could not realize God ... because they could not be Sikhs ... logic is lacking here as God can not be so unfair and biased towards our Sikhism. ----------------------------------------------------------- Over here you are wrong. There are several references in several of the books published by Radhasoami Beas in which they have written that “a book cannot be Guru”. Who are they targeting when they say that a book cannot be Guru? Charan Singh himself said in one of his cassettes when doing translation of sunaiya pauris of Siri Jap jee Sahib. He said something along the lines that a book or pothi cannot be Guru. ------------------- I do not agree with you here .... what He has suggested that just by mere reading it you shouldn't think that you can realize God ----------------------------------------------------------- You ask if any saint had no Guru. The answer is that Siri Guru Nanak Dev jee had no human Guru. His Guru was Vaheguru himself and Siri Guru Nanak Dev jee himself has written this. Ponder upon this pankiti: APRAMPAR PARBRAHAM PARMESHAR, NANAK GUR MILIYA SOYEE|| ---------- This is your understanding of the bani ... nothing has been documented in any books of that time ... that He did not have any guru. Sant either directly come from God but still they need a spark or if tru sant bestows his daya mehar on somebody and uplifts and make him a sant or a person becomes one through abhyaas and daya mehar of a sant/guru. Jesus was a Saint directly from God but still he needed baptism from St John. -------------------------------------------------------- Then why do you, O Radhasomis believe that only if one comes to your Guru one can reach Anami Lok, Satlok and Radhasoami Dhaam? Do you believe that anyone can reach the top level i.e. the Radhasoami Dhaam without your Guru? I have read in your books where you have written very clearly that all religions are within the realms of “kaal” and only your faith i.e. the Radhasoami faith can take you to Radhasoami Dhaam. ----------- This is your misconception. Anyone who does abhyaas and can concentrate and wants to be one with God can make spiritual progress. I definitely believe that if a person takes naam daan of any true saint/guru, he can reach sachkhand. I do not have any idea of any such book that you have mentioned. I am talking of RSS Beas, of others I can not comment. ------------------------------------------- What is so hard about seeing the light? This fake light can be seen by anyone who thinks that he wants to see the light and does paath? Anyone can hear those so called mystical sounds like bell, flute etc if your mind wants to listen to it. The real thing is if you hear Anhad Shabad – the real ones and not some flute, dhol, bell or water fall etc. as you guys preach. ----------------- I am again saying "If RS say that you can see light within then if no body has seen it in the past 100 years ... then it would not have been in existence now .... " Jesus said .. "If thy eye be single..your body shall be full of light" .. Can you try to explain this statement? "This fake light can be seen by anyone who thinks that he wants to see the light and does paath?" ... I am not talking here of imagination .. it does not remain for long. I bet that once you have darshan of your guru inside then you can have darshan of any of the guru sahibaan within who can take you to the almighty because they are one with Him and then once you have settled your karmas you can be one with Him for ever. I can quote many vaaks from gurbani where guru sahibaans have mentioned about such sounds ... they have not mentioned just for the sake of it. I do not have it now as I do not have strong memory like yours. The bells that we have in church, bells we have in mandirs, the candles we have in church, the jyot we have in religious places, the instruments that we have found for ourselves ... like shankh, mridang, sarangi are nothing but the reflections of inner spiritual heights into day to day life. Hindus started idol worship only in that way ... initially that was made for their concentration for meditation but over the ages they were happy only with aarti and puja ... meditation all forgotten. Do you ever wonder why we have guru sahibaans photos on calendars doing meditation ....(if we leave the historical depictions)? I remember, one hindu saint has said ... naam ki mahima main kya karun ... naam ki mahim to raam bhi nahin kar saktay ... how can such a statement come from a hindu ...because he knows that sants are above devi\devta\avtaar .... he does not follow sikhism then how could he talk about Naam .... why bible starts with "Word is God". Bible also speaks about such sounds. ------------------------------------------------------ No they don’t have faith in Ten Guru Sahibaan. Then how dare they say that Kabir was the Guru of Guru Nanak Dev jee? According to Siri Guru Granth Sahib jee Kabir is called a Bhagat while Guru Sahibaan are called “Mahalla”. There is a difference. Guru Sahibaan are above everyone else. ------------------------ Nobody has said Kabir Sahib was guru of Guru Nanak. Tell me one book where this is mentioned. Kabir sahib was a saint and preached what Guru Sahibaans were preaching .. its only because of that His vaani is present in SGGS. ------------------------------------------------------ Gurmat is greatest of all. This Sahansar-Dal-Kanwal i.e. the lotus with 1000 petals is nothing at all and nor is Bhanwar Gufaa anything for Khalsa. Khalsa does not go this route. This is the route of the Jogis. Who wants to see Sahansar-Dal-Kanwal? I don’t. This is a much lower state. Gursikhs aim from Vaheguru and that is it. Anything short of Vaheguru himself is not acceptable to Gursikhs. ----------------------------- RS does not say that the aim is to see lotus .. the aim is to see God/Waheguru. Lotuses just falls in the route. Somebody mentioned that Bhai Randhir Singh has mentioned about this ... why he mentioned the route of yogis .. Just that below dasham dwar these lotuses are inverted and pale and above it they are straight and bright. I again say that any abhyasi can make spiritual progress under a true guru ... if you have found a true guru and you believe Him and do abhyaas .. you can make spiritual progress .. no need to affiliate to RS then. ---------------------------------------------- Impossible!!!!! This is a blatant lie. Bhai Bala’s Janamsaakhi that you are reading is distorted and also this janamsaakhi is not a book of authority in Sikh Panth. ----------------------- Giving an authority to a book in current era can also be due to pressures and political motives. Try getting the oldest manuscripts that existed before RS foundation was laid .. then you will be able to see it without bias. I just read it in a public library in Jalandhar. ------------------------------------------------ Siri Guru Nanak Dev jee is the Satguru while Kabir jee is a Bhagat. This makes it clear. Bhagat jee is great but he is not a Guru and he never claimed to be one either. He never gave Naam. ---------------------------- Bhagat is due to the fact that India had a Bhakti movement during Kabir Sahib's time. Kabir Saheb never gave naam ...then you are mistaken ... he gave naam to Ibrahim Adham - King of bukhara, Dharamdas to name a few ... Dharamdas was the one who got the guru gaddi after kabir sahib. Kabir sahib also had 21 gaddis after him. Sant Ravidaas whose baani is in SGGS gave naam to Sant Peepa who was a rajput king. Sant Peepa's few couplets are there in SGGS. Any saint can give naam IF AND ONLY IF he has a hukm from God/waheguru because by giving naam dan he has to take the responsibility of making him one with God. ---------------------------------------------- By all this discussion I am not in any way trying to say that to be one with God you have to be an affiliate of RSSB.. just that you need to have a true guru and do abhyas with the will to be one with God .. Rest all depends on His daya mehar. If you find that Guru in SGGS ..you can go ahead. Why a jew who does not see guru or saint in SGGS can not be one with God? Everybody, irrespective of religion (may be a hindu or a jew) , if he sees SGGS as his/her Guru then he/she can continue with that and do nit nem and abhyaas. Rest all is in the hands of God. We can just pray for His daya mehar.

Re: Who is Satguru?

khoji_2 · 28 Feb 2005

dear veer kulbir singh ji i will wait for your reply on some of the questions i had typed above along with the pangtian

Re: Who is Satguru?

bhopinder singh · 28 Feb 2005

Over here you are wrong. There are several references in several of the books published by Radhasoami Beas in which they have written that “a book cannot be Guru”. Who are they targeting when they say that a book cannot be Guru? Charan Singh himself said in one of his cassettes when doing translation of sunaiya pauris of Siri Jap jee Sahib. He said something along the lines that a book or pothi cannot be Guru. ------------------- I do not agree with you here .... what He has suggested that just by mere reading it you shouldn't think that you can realize God ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ first of all are you justn or khoji or direct from raw or ib POTHI PARMESHWAR KA THAN we are the first people who were told by prophet that shabad is guru SHABAD GURU SURAT DHUN CHELA Their is no ummat that can say that before nanak their was someone who said that

Re: Who is Satguru?

KAUR · 28 Feb 2005

>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> This Message Board is designed to discuss issues concerning Gurmat, Gurbani, issues related to the Sikh Panth and Sikh history. Any type of posts that contain vulgar language, personal attacks, flame wars, and content against the teachings of Gurmat are STRICTLY PROHIBITED. Constructive, respectful debates with the aim to learn about Gurmat are encouraged. Arguments simply for the sake of argument will not be tolerated. Moderators and Administrators have authority to delete/edit such posts. Administrators and moderators only interest is to maintain a constructive, well run Message Board which promotes learning and Gurmat inspiration. www.tapoban.org does not necessarily endorse the views and opinions voiced on these forums, and cannot be held responsible for the content of sites linked from these pages or the views of the members posting here. <<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<< I don't understand why we allow these above anti-Sataguru Nanak people to use our resources to promote their sects. If someone does not believe in Guru nanak to be Satguru, one can't be a sikh. Gurubani says: "Sab te vaddaa Sarguru Nanak jen kal rakhi meri" A true sikh can't challege Gurbani. These anti-sikh people are arguing for the sake of argument and guidelines of this forum does not allow it. Why still we allow all this??? We can't change them by telling them truth because they didn't start this thread innocently or to gain knowledge. They started it to argue and to promote their gurudum's principles. Let them go to their deraas and do this worthless parchaar over there.

Re: Who is Satguru?

Kulbir Singh · 28 Feb 2005

Khoji2, -------- i dont know why sikhs of today have such a phobia about everything including radhasowamis ----------- And I don’t know why Radhasoamis are so obsessed with Sikhs. If they don’t believe that hair have anything to do with spirituality, then why are their gurus always sporting uncut hair and turban? What was the reason why Gurinder Singh who used to trim beard before becoming a guru and even had his hair cut, kept beard and turban? The reason is obvious. They know that if they don’t dress up like Sikhs and don’t look like Sikhs, then they will not be able to trap innocent Sikhs and convert them to Radhasoamis. ----------- naanak mailaa oojal thaa thheeai jaa sathigur maahi samaae guru amardas sahib ji nanak without aunkad kulbir singh ji how will you 'samaae' into guru nanak sahib? as per my understanding you have to get 'lean' into akalpurakh who is also kartapurakh ----------------- The word Nanak over here is without aunkad because it is a singular noun in Sambodhan kaarak. Whenever a singular noun comes in sambodhan kaarak its aunkad gets removed. I stated earlier that Satguru is the Guru-form of Vaheguru. Here is a pankiti you should ponder upon: JYOT ROOP HAR AAP, GURU NANAK KAHAIYO|| (The jyot roop Vaheguru himself came to this world and was known as Guru Nanak Dev jee). There are no difficult words in this pankiti and it clearly proves that the Guru-form of Vaheguru came to this world to deliver people from this darkness of ignorance. Now for your question how does one “samaa” or merge in Satguru. As stated before Guruform of Vaheguru is called Satguru. Satguru is essentially Vaheguru himself. Getting merged in Satguru is same as getting merged in Vaheguru. Vaheguru and Satguru are one and totally merged with each other. ------------ saas saas har gaavai naanak sathigur dhaak leeaa maeraa parradhaa jeeo guru arjan dev sahib ji nanak with aunkad is guru nanak sahib dhakining the purdha here or is satguru dhaking the purdha here? ----------------- Siri Guru Arjun Dev jee is talking about Siri Guru Raamdaas jee or more precisely the Guru-form of Vaheguru which is also called Siri Guru Nanak Dev jee. Satguru Nanak Dev jee Satguru Raamdaas Sahib jee is dhakking pardaah here. ------------- kahu naanak maeraa sathigur pooraa guru arjan dev sahib without aunkad is guru arjan dev sahib ji talking about himslef that he himself is pura or 5th nanak sahib ji talking about their satguru? ------------- O Bhai, Guru Sahib is talking about his Satguru i.e. Siri Guru Raamdaas Sahib jee. He also talks about “Guru” which also means “Satguru’’. Main bin Gur dekhay, neend na aavay. Here Guru Sahib is again talking about his Satguru or Guru – Siri Guru Amardaas jee. ------------ har sathigur maelahu dhaeiaa kar jan naanak dhhovai paae guru ram daas sahib ji with aunkad is guru ramdas sahib here asking to meet himself? or is he asking for the 'har satguru' satguru of all? ------------- We should realise that Guru Sahib has written Gurbani with extreme humility and has always presented himself with extreme humility. When Siri Guru Nanak Dev jee says “Nanak neech” it does not mean that we should start thinking that he was Neech or a bad person. We all know that Guru Sahib has written in extreme humility. Second thing we need to realise is that Gurbani has been written for gursikhs of all spiritual levels. He did not need to meet Satguru as mentioned in this pankiti because he was already one with Satguru and had met him. Then who is he referring to here? The answer is clear. He has written this pankiti for us moorakhs so that we may use this pankiti to do benti or imploring to Vaheguru to let us meet our Satguru. --------- PS : a request please donot label me as radhasowami ----------- Ok Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: Who is Satguru?

khoji_2 · 28 Feb 2005

Dear Veer Jee KS thanks for your reply and agreeing to my request By your reasoning when the GuruJot passed from Guru Nanak Sahib to Guru Angad Sahib then Guru Angad Sahib is the Satguru and Guru Nanak Sahib did matha tek to Guru Angad Sahib as mentioned earlier on in this thread. ******************** ---------------------- saas saas har gaavai naanak sathigur dhaak leeaa maeraa parradhaa jeeo guru arjan dev sahib ji nanak with aunkad is guru nanak sahib dhakining the purdha here or is satguru dhaking the purdha here? ----------------- Siri Guru Arjun Dev jee is talking about Siri Guru Raamdaas jee or more precisely the Guru-form of Vaheguru which is also called Siri Guru Nanak Dev jee. Satguru Nanak Dev jee Satguru Raamdaas Sahib jee is dhakking pardaah here. *********************************** Now you say that Guru Arjan Dev Sahib Ji is refering to Guru Ramdaas Sahib and Guru Nanak Sahib. But by your earlier reasoning the Satguru here is Guru Arjan Dev Sahib Ji as the Guru Jot had PASSED to him? So is he asking himself to dhaking purda? I am hope to have more insight into gurbani by your replies

Re: Who is Satguru?

gurbaksh singh · 28 Feb 2005

i was a radhasoami but i am no more of that and i want to tell people about these people i was way up in their high command their is a regular meeting with the joint commisioner of raw and two different agencies of government of india on 7th and 24th of every month first i thought it was just a normal thing , but later on i came to know as literature written by different hindu fundamentlist intelectuals was given to us i told the respected officer that we have a guru so i dont need books written by you as he can write for us. first he told me nothing but as i became adamant he started abusing me what he said is as follows even guru so called was their your guru is nothing but created by us on this i said no than he kicked guru in the face salo sikhon ke khilaf khade kia tha tum ko we spent so much money and resourses on you this is why we moved you away from agra to beas , we always want your guru to look like sikhs our and your sole aim is to distroy sikhism on this i said guru ji is it true and the so called guru fell upon the knees of the officer and with a abuse told me bh............ ehi sade guru aa and told me to touch the feets of the officer which i refused after this i went to darbar sahib and i started walking in the parkirama and did a ardas in front of guru sahib to forgive me THE WAAK WAS BHULE MARG JINE BATIYA AS GUR WADBHANGI PAYA from thst day onwards i never went back to beas indian police and different agencies have threatened me so many times but to this day guru has protected me GURU GURUNANAK

Re: Who is Satguru?

Kulbir Singh · 28 Feb 2005

----- But by your earlier reasoning the Satguru here is Guru Arjan Dev Sahib Ji as the Guru Jot had PASSED to him? So is he asking himself to dhaking purda? ------- When a lamp lights other lamp it does not have to extinguish itself to do so. Same way Siri Guru Nanak Dev jee did not cease to be Satguru the instance he passed on the jyot to Siri Guru Angad Dev jee Maharaaj. I think you should read Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh jee's books to get a better understanding of these very mystical things. Guru-jyot is not a small thing that can't stay in two physical beings. As the matter of fact, Guru-jyot resides in everyone in this world but became active only Ten Guru Sahibaan. Satgur mera sada sada hai, na avai na jaaye|| Oh Abinaashi Purakh hai sabh mein rahiya samaaye|| Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: Who is Satguru?

justin · 28 Feb 2005

Gurbaksh Singh Ji, Do not mislead with this fiction ... the better example I can give you which is more relevant here I read on internet where a guy took naam daan but couldn't see light within and couldn't mae spiritual progress though he said that he tried hard on meditation.. This is the bitter truth not all people who get naam daan are able to progress spiritually as they lack faith and concentration. But there are people who do make spiritual progress. In this case also I am not against that guy. Whatever he felt right.. he did. Regards

Re: Who is Satguru?

justin · 28 Feb 2005

Kaur Ji, With due respect ... no one here is to convert or do a prachaar .... just that bhai kulbir singh ji has his point of views and wherever I felt that I need to clarify I did. If you see from my comments I am not at all against having SGGS as guru sahib. Actually I like the explanations of baani on this forum and thats the reason I come here. As you know baani says that "naam di kirpa taan dhuron likhi aayee hai" then who are we to convert .... and why should one get converted by just reading comments ... I remember a couplet on this woh dar hi kya jahan koi sar na jhukay woh sar hi kya jo har dar pe jhuk jaayay Dar - darwaja Sar - head And for the baani ... "sab te vadda satgur nanak" ... here it speaks of a mureed's love/devotion for his murshid ... I completely agree with you and all that Guru Nanak Sahib is a satguru and is God Himself.

Re: Who is Satguru?

justin · 28 Feb 2005

Bhopinder Singh Ji, I do not think you have read Bible and that is why you are biased Bible starts with "Word is God" ... Word here is the "Shabd" that you are talking about "But the Word of the Lord endureth for ever. And this is the Word which by the gospel is preached unto you." Bible ... "And take the helmet of salvation, and the sword of the Spirit, which is the word of God" ....here Spirit is your "Surat" Bible ... "The words that I speak unto you, they are spirit, and they are life" "And the Word was made flesh, and dwelt among us" that means the saint was "Shabd Swaroop" and had come as human being. Bible ... "Know ye not that you are the temple of God, and that the Spirit of God dwelleth in you?" Guru Nanak Ji says "kaaya mahalu mandiru ghar hari ka, tis mahi rakhi jyot apaar" Bible ... "He hath given us of his spirit" Guru Nanak Dev Ji .. "Aatam mein raam, raam mein aatam" Kabir Sahib .. "Kehu kabir ih ram ki ans" Light Within ... guru nanak sahib says... "Antar jyot sabad dhun, jagai satgur jhagaru nibaire" ------------------------------------------------------ I am not saying that there are things in SGGS that have already mentioned in Bible 2000 years ago ... what I mean is all saints come from the almighty and their innner spiritual experiences are same and hence they speak similar things ... just the way changes a little due to language and era. you will see similar kalaam from many sufi saints .... Guru Nanak Dev Ji .. "ghar mahi ghar dekhai dayee, so satgur purakh sujan" Sultan Bahu "naam faqeer tis da bahu, ghar vich yaar vikhalay hu" ---- Kabir Sahib "Bin satgur pawaye nahin, kotin karay upaaye" Guru Nanak Dev Ji "Satgur bajhau ghor andhara, dubi muaye binu paani" Tulsidas "Gur binu bhav nidhi tarai na koi" ------------------ Again I am saying ... it does not matter whether you find your guru in SGGS, RSSB or anywhere else ... without a true guru you can not have spiritual progress and we should not compare saints ... peer milay tay peed na jaaway, taan us peer ki dharna hu murshid milya rushad na man nu, oh murshid ki karna hu jis hadi thi nahin hadayat, oh haadi ki fadna hu I have many gursikh friends but we never crossed each others ideology and we respect each others path. And most of the time I am on with them for various events.

Re: Who is Satguru?

J Singh · 28 Feb 2005

Veer Kulbir Singh ji, I knew you would come back to me with your superior explanation of gurbani viyaakaran :-). I will not pretend to understand all the uses of kaaraks in Gurbani. I will go back and refer to Professor Sahib Singh jee’s book. It may seem too simplified but here is one of the reason for my interpretation. We all agree that all Guru Sahibaan had the same saachi jaagdi jyot of Vaheguru residing in them (Kal taaran Guru Nanak aiya). I just couldn't see why Guru ji would address themselves (their own jyot) to be "sabh te vadde". I can see bhagats saying that but not Guru Sahib themselves. They were picture of humility and came to show us the way to meditate Vaheguru's "naam". Guru sahibaan used the word "Nanak" in many shabads as their stamp. Didn't quite understand what yo meant by, "Vaheguru himself takes the form of worshipper, what is being worshipped and Naam that is used to worship him." Anyway, I am a gursikh and Guru Granth Sahib ji is my Satguru as well :-) VJKK VJKF

Re: Who is Satguru?

AnotherSingh · 28 Feb 2005

The Guru is a special form of the True One. Remember we talked about how the True One is carefree; well, there is a part of theTrue One that is intensely caring - that is the Guru. The Guru wants us to merge with the True One . When we start the journey towards the True One, we focus on the Guru - the Guru is easier to understand because the True One has crystallized into a form that is familiar to us.; but when the Sun of knowledge rises, we see that there is no difference between the two. In fact, if the Sun rises enough, we see there is no difference between us and the True One either!" -from Naamnet

Re: Who is Satguru?

khoji_2 · 28 Feb 2005

---------- they didn't start this thread innocently or to gain knowledge. They started it to argue and to promote their gurudum's principles. Let them go to their deraas and do this worthless parchaar over there. ---------- this thread was started with the best of intentions by some one who is trying to follow the path shown by satguru dhan guru granth sahib ji (satguru because its the bani of the satguru) dhur ki bani coming through our GURU sahibaan and blessed bhagats to have a understanding as to what gurbani tells us about SATGURU. there are prani out here who cannot stick to the topic and brought this radhasowami stuff in. It is upto the admins to keep the topic in tracks and not allow any unwanted radhasowami stories and discussions in this particular thread.

Re: Who is Satguru?

Gurdaspuria · 28 Feb 2005

Waheguru Jee Ka Khalsa Waheguru jee kee Fateh I am no position to write that Guru Baba Nanak Dev jee is not Sateguru, for me Guru jee more than that. I will write what Gurbani especially Guru Nanak Dev jee’s is to say about Sateguru according to my understanding Pooran Joot of the Sateguru, which one and only one, which is not subject to birth and death, in which God has placed self, came in our Gurus and Bhagats and then as a result they revealed Gurbani which is called “Sateguru ke Bani”. They never claimed the Bani is their own Gyain/Knowledge/wisdom but they declared the Bani came to them from the Khasm/Karta(karan karaven sagal bid Sateguru hamra). Most of the places in Gurbani, there is no difference SateGuru and Guru: Because word Guru, Gur, Gur(u), Gurdev are also used for SateGuru, without the preface “Sate”. Real meaning of “Sate” is more than “true”, which is “Forever”. Therefore, the real meaning of SateGuru is “Forever Guru”. As indicated in the following tuks of Gurbani. aadh gureae nameh || jugaadh gureae nameh || sathigureae nameh || sree guradhaeveae nameh ||1|| I bow to the Primal Guru. I bow to the Guru of the ages. I bow to the Forever Guru. I bow to the Great, Divine Guru. ||1|| Guru Arjan Dev Ji Raag Gauree 262 sathigur maeraa sadhaa sadhaa naa aavai n jaae || ouhu abinaasee purakh hai sabh mehi rehiaa samaae ||13|| My SateGuru, forever and ever, does not come and go. SateGuru is the Imperishable Creator Lord; SateGuru is permeating and pervading among all. ||13|| Guru Raam Daas Ji Raag Soohee 759 In Following Gurbani Tuks Guru Baba Nanak Dev jee establish relationship between “Nanak” and “SateGuru” Eko Naam hukam ha Nanak SateGur(i) dea Bujhae jeo. Nanak says, The one “Naam” is the Command of God, the Sateguru has revealed me(Nanak) the understanding. Guru Nanak Dev Ji Siree Raag 72 Nanak SateGuru(i) Breham dhikhaaeiaa ||5||20|| O Nanak, the SateGuru has shown me(Nanak) the Lord God. ||5||20|| Guru Nanak Dev Ji Raag Aasaa 355 Note to Veer Kulbir Singh: I am not asking my friends for posting to the subject. I donot who is posting. My writings are not based on any person or book's view. I simply follow Sri Guru Granth Sabib jee & Guru Gobind Singh jee bani and base on that. I do agree with you to comdmn dehdhari so called Sategurus especially Radhaswamies and Naam daries. Waheguru Jee Ka Khalsa Waheguru jee kee Fateh

Re: Who is Satguru?

rsingh · 28 Feb 2005

khoji2, are you just simply going to ignore, 'sabh te vadha satgur nanak'? It doesn't fit your thinking to call Guru Nanak Dev Jee a Satguru so you just ignore the whole tuk? Or try changing its meanings around? So if you're saying Guru Nanak Dev Jee wasn't sat guru, then that means you're calling them a false guru. But you try to claim that their banee, was sat and Guru Granth Saahib Jee is satguru for containing this banee. Well, gurgaddi was given to Guru Granth Saahib Jee by Guru Gobind Singh Jee. How could an un-sat guru give a gur gaddi to a satguru? And how could an un-sat guru give us this banee and put it in the form of a satguru? Look, stop trying to play with words. There is a guru. Either the guru is true or false. Either the guru is sat, or the guru is choot. It's a pretty simple concept. You're trying to create different levels of gurus, by having satgurus and neutral gurus who aren't false, but aren't true either. No such thing exists. Gurbani is quite clear on this. Either a guru is false or is true (sat). Guru Nanak Dev Jee is Sat. Period.

Re: Who is Satguru?

singhnee · 28 Feb 2005

Gurbani is full of word 'Satgur(u)' used for Guru Nanak jot. I tried to find few of them. bin sathigur sukh n paavee fir fir jonee paahi ||3|| bin sathigur kinai n paaeiou kar vaekhahu man veechaar || hor kithai bhagath n hovee bin sathigur kae oupadhaes ||1|| har kae jan sathigur sathapurakhaa bino karo gur paas || . sathigur saevee bhaao kar mai pir dhaehu milaae || sathigur dhaathaa har naam kaa prabh aap milaavai soe || bin naavai jeevan naa thheeai maerae sathigur naam dhrirraae ||1|| rehaao || jeh sathigur theh sathasa(n)gath banaaee || dhha(n)n dhha(n)n guroo gur sathigur paadhhaa jin har oupadhaes dhae keeeae siaanae ||1|| rehaao || kar kirapaa har maeliaa maeraa sathigur pooraa || jan naanak anadhin har gun gaavai mil sathigur gur vaecholee ||4||1||15||53|| ham moorr mugadhh asudhh math hothae gur sathigur kai bachan har ham jaanae ||1|| rehaao || raam ham sathigur laalae kaa(n)dtae ||1|| rehaao || har agam agochar paarabreham hai mil sathigur laag baseet(h)aa || sathigur dhaathai naam dhirraaeiaa mukh masathak bhaag sabhaagae ||1|| maeraa jeeo pi(n)dd sabh sathigur aagai jin vishhurriaa har gal laaeiaa ||2|| mai maelae mithra sathigur vaecholae jeeo || sathigur thae dhrirriaa eik eaekai || aapan naam sathigur thae paaeiou ||1|| rehaao || sathigur thae paaeiaa naam neesaan ||2|| sathigur dhaathaa sabadh sunaaeae || sathigur thae naam paaeeai karam milai prabh soe ||4|| sath purakh jin jaaniaa sathigur this kaa naao || sathigur sikh ko naam dhhan dhaee || so sathigur jis ridhai har naao || sathigur har prabh dhas naam dhhiaaee man haree || sathigur vich aap varathadhaa har aapae rakhanehaar || sathigur vich vaddee vaddiaaee jo anadhin har har naam dhhiaavai || jo ni(n)dhaa karae sathigur poorae kee this karathaa maar dhivaavai || gur sathigur kaa jo sikh akhaaeae s bhalakae out(h) har naam dhhiaavai || sabh nidhhaan sathiguroo vich jis a(n)dhar har our dhhaarae || sabh thae vaddaa sathigur naanak jin kal raakhee maeree ||4||10||57|| sathigur saevae sadhaa sukh paaeae sathigur alakh dhithaa lakhaaee ||3|| dhhan dhhan sathigur jin naam dhrirraaeiaa jan naanak this kurabaanaa ||4||3|| ho balihaaree sathigur apunae jin gupath naam paragaajhaa ||2|| har har sathigur purakh milaavahu gur miliai sukh hoee raam ||1|| bin sathigur naao n paaeeai bujhahu kar veechaar || bin sathigur kinai n paaeiou guramukh milai milaae || sathigur kaa sabadh sun n jaagiou a(n)thar n oupajiou chaao || har maelahu sathigur dhaeiaa kar gur ko balihaaree ||23|| bin sathigur naam n paaeeai bhaaee bin naamai bharam n jaaee || sathigur dhaathaa mael milaavahu har naam dhaevahu aadhhaarae || rehaao || ha(n)o sathigur apunae ka(n)o sadhaa namasakaaree jith miliai har naam mai jaathaa ||16|| dhhan dhhan sath purakh sathiguroo hamaaraa jith miliai ham har bhagath paaee || so sathigur dhaekhahu eik nimakh nimakh jin har kaa har pa(n)thh bathaaeiaa || ho balihaaree sathigur aapanae jin maeraa har alakh lakhaarae ||8|| sadhaa our dhhaarae naehu naal piaarae sathigur thae pir dhisai || so sathigur pooraa dhhan dhha(n)n hai jin har oupadhaes dhae sabh srist savaaree || naanak sathigur kee saevaa so karai jis no nadhar karai karathaar ||1|| so sathigur saevihu saadhh jan jin har har naam dhrirraaeiaa || dhhan dhhan sathigur purakh nira(n)jan jith mil har naam dhhiaaee || ham pooshheh ham pooshheh sathigur paas har baathaa raam || jinaa sathigur jin sathigur paaeiaa thin har prabh mael milaaeae raam || dhhur khasamai kaa hukam paeiaa vin sathigur chaethiaa n jaae || gur sathigur paasahu har gosatt pooshhaa(n) kar saa(n)jhee har gun gaavaa(n) || sabh jaae milahu sathiguroo ko maeree ji(n)dhurreeeae jo har har naam dhrirraavai raam || so sathigur vaahu vaahu jin har sio jorriaa || sathigur saranee jaae po maeree ji(n)dhurreeeae gun dhasae har prabh kaerae raam || naam nidhhaan sathiguroo dhrirraaeiaa binas n aavai jaaee ||1|| sathigur vittahu vaariaa jith miliai khasam samaaliaa || jithhai jaae behai maeraa sathiguroo so thhaan suhaavaa raam raajae || . jinh naanak sathigur poojiaa thin har pooj karaavaa ||2|| jinhaa naanak sathigur bhaettiaa thinhaa miliaa har soee ||2|| har keeaa kathhaa kehaaneeaa maerae piaarae sathiguroo sunaaeeaa || bin sathigur kinai n paaeiou bin sathigur kinai n paaeiaa || sathigur baajhahu gur nehee koee nigurae kaa hai naao buraa ||13|| sabhae kaaj suhaelarrae thheeeae gur naanak sathigur thut(h)aa ||1|| saa dhharathee bhee hareeaavalee jithhai maeraa sathigur bait(h)aa aae || All above Gubani punkitis have satgur(u) word used for Guru sahib jee not Waheguru. Please read and vichaaro. My veers/bhains who think 'Satgur(u) is used only for Waheguru, could please do kirpa to explain to sangat how this word means Waheguru in following punkiti: "satgur baajhahu gur nehee koee nigurae kaa hai naao buraa " Waheguru jee kaa khalsa! Waheguru jee kee fateh!

Re: Who is Satguru?

Admin · 28 Feb 2005

We have decided to close this thread because there is too much going on under this thread. We will open a debate for Radhasoamis under the thread "Who is Satguru - Debate with Radhasoamis" and if the other group i.e. Khoji2 group wants they can start a new thread to do so. Admin.

Re: Who is Satguru?

david frank · 09 Jun 2006

Hi I can give you the exact definition of Satguru. The definition is True spiritual teacher who has access to the fifth spiritual region called Sach Khand. A Satguru is a Saint who is ordained to take certain allotted souls back to God by initiating them into Surat Shabd Yoga. I do not care about Radha Soami or Sikh but I do care to understand the exact meaning of Satguru. Then no more confusion about WHO IS SATGURU????? Sat means true and Guru means teacher. Saint means HE reaches to the fifth inner region. Do not confuse Saint with saint. The small letter of "s" in the word of saint means saint does good things for his or her people who need help. Please pardon me that I am a deaf person and I am ignorant. thanks David Frank, IT IS HARD TO FIND A TRUE SATGURU EVERYWHERE. IN THE LAW OF GOD THERE MUST BE ONE OR MORE TRUE SATGURU AROUND THE WORLD. JESUS WAS A MYSTIC TEACHER AT HIS TIME. SIKH PEOPLE NEED TO STUDY ALL RELIGIONS IN ORDER TO UNDERSTAND THEM BETTER. RELIGION MEANS "GO BACK TO THE SOURCE FROM WHERE WE COME. RELIGION DEALS WITH SOUL ONLY. MYSTICISM MEANS EXPERINCE OF UNION OF GOD. THEY (RELIGION AND MYSTICISM)TELL US THAT WE NEED A LIVING SATGURU.

Re: Who is Satguru?

.... · 09 Jun 2006

Sat means sach means truth means God and Guru means Guru. If some body is attched to Sach nothing else, not even .000000000001% to jhooth, he is sat guru. Everything which God has created is aad sach, jugad such, habhi sach, Nanak hosi bhee sach. So God ceated satgurus in past, present and will produce in future also. For Gursikhs Satguru is Guru Granthsahib. Also if any Maha Purakh who has remembered all the Guru Granth Sahib by heart, can become Satguru too. But he will never say that he is satguru. IF Satgurus were only present in Kalyug, that does not make sense. Satguru is a saroop of akal, so he is present all the time.