Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Having Hindu Friends

Having Hindu Friends

Maninder Singh · 26 Feb 2005

WGKK WGKF Is it OK to keep freindship with Hindus? My chacha said that we should not have too much contact with hindus because: a) They are idol worshippers b) They are constantly trying to undermime Sikhi c) They are untrustworthy However I met a Hindu Guy at university who is quite religious and he is porbably the most honest, nicest guy I have ever met. Is my chacha talking rubbish? Maninder

Re: Having Hindu Friends

Redwhiteandblue Kaur · 26 Feb 2005

Broad statements about any religion are wrong. "All Sikhs are drunkards..."

Re: Having Hindu Friends

akj_for_eva_and_eva_amen · 26 Feb 2005

vjkk vjkf 2 b honest u shudnt speak to ny 1 part from gursikhs, or at least ppl hu r headin tht way vjkk vjkf

Re: Having Hindu Friends

Singh · 26 Feb 2005

I would avoid talking to punjabi's if anything, they are the worse ppl living on this planet.. They are so selfish and are conjussee .. Plus they make Sikhs look bad.. [%sig%]

Re: Having Hindu Friends

jugroop singh · 26 Feb 2005

VahiGuruJiKaKhalsa,VahiGuruJiKiFateh! Veer/Bhain 'akj_for_eva_and_eva_amen' ji wrote: '2 b honest u shudnt speak to ny 1 part from gursikhs, or at least ppl hu r headin tht way' That's a bit strong isn't it... ? VahiGuruJiKaKhalsa,VahiGuruJiKiFateh!

Re: Having Hindu Friends

Kulwinder Singh · 26 Feb 2005

Your question: Is my chacha talking rubbish? My answer: Yes.

Re: Having Hindu Friends

Singh J · 26 Feb 2005

"akj_for_eva_and_eva_amen" please dont spoil the good name of AKJ with your rubbish. Obviously you are NOT an AKJ Sikh, and are just out to falsely pose as one so you can show how narrow minded Jatha Singhs are. To every one, please dont listen to this person, he does not represent the AKJ views. AKJ does not forbid one from talking to non-Sikhs. I took Amrit from the Jatha, and I do not beleive in the crap he is writing. Maninder SIngh Jee, yes you can talk to Hindus/Muslims/Christians/Jews etc, and you are not going against Sikhism by doing so.

Re: Having Hindu Friends

AnotherSingh · 26 Feb 2005

Judge people as individuals, not by their religion. although if this person has anti-Sikhi views I would naturally stay away from him.

Re: Having Hindu Friends

Inderjit Singh · 26 Feb 2005

Speak to whom ever you want, but try to do sangat with Gursikhs... Sangat is really important!

Re: Having Hindu Friends

troubled · 26 Feb 2005

of course it's ok...we're all Waheguru's children

Re: Having Hindu Friends

MKaur · 26 Feb 2005

Thinking about it more logically. Thinking that we live in a world where not EVERYONE is a GurSikh. I persoanlly feel there is nothing wrong with talking to non-sikh people or people of other beliefs/faiths. As long as you don't make any close relationships with them. Don't ignore them...but at the same time, don't be soo close that they have any influence on you. Get what I mean?

Re: Having Hindu Friends

Redwhiteandblue Kaur · 26 Feb 2005

"" there is nothing wrong with talking to non-sikh people or people of other beliefs/faiths. As long as you don't make any close relationships with them. Don't ignore them...but at the same time, don't be soo close that they have any influence on you. Get what I mean? "" ------------------------------------------------------------- MKaur ji, I do get what you mean. You are saying that a Gursikh's faith is so fragile that it can be corrupted if a Gursikh happens to get "too close to them". Is this the stance of the AKJ? That we tell each other to run away in defeat from everyone that is "different" because we are too weak to handle the influence of anyone but ourselves? Why are Gursikhs not encouraging one another to be strong? Are saint-soldiers supposed to shy away from battles? Or FIGHT THEM TO WIN?? In my opionion, a true Gursikh does not FEAR the influence of others, a true Gursikh IS the influence of others. Are my opinions out of place? Please forgive me, and correct me, if they are.

Re: Having Hindu Friends

Kulbir Singh · 26 Feb 2005

One thing is for sure that we cannot escape the influence we get from our sangat. Bhai Gurdas has written a masterpiece stanza to prove this point: kaahoo dhasaakae pavan gavan kai barakhaa hai; kaahoo dhasaakae pavan baadhar bilaath hai || (There is such wind that brings clouds and causes rain; and there is such wind that just blows sand in people's face) kaahoo jal paan keeeae rehath arog dhohee; kaahoo jal paan biaapae brithhaa bilalaath hai || (Some places have such water that keeps the body always free from disease and then there is such water that causes pain and suffering to the body) kaahoo grih kee agan paak saak sidhh karai; kaahoo grih kee agan bhavan jagath hai || (Same thing with fire. Fire in some houses is pure and helps in many ways but in some cases fire is such that burns and does great damages) kaahoo kee sa(n)gath mil jeevan mukath huei; kaahoo kee sa(n)gath mil jamupur jaath hai ||aaa|| After giving examples of good and bad kinds of air, water and fire, Bhai Sahib jee finally moves to do the master stroke. He writes that there is such sangat that helps one become a jeevan-mukat i.e. toplevel Gursikh who attains salvation while living; and there is such sangat too that takes one to Jampur i.e. hell where one gets great punishments. This shabad is enough to prove that we should be discriminatory when selecting friends. The best company is to have company or sangat of Gursikhs who are eager to meet their beloved Vaheguru or who have already attained their beloved one - Vaheguru. In school if need be one should only hang out with such people who are loathe to the evil ways of Kalyug. To hang out with such people who smoke, drink, talk about opposite sex and do other acts like fornication etc. is a sure remedy to get in the bad books of Guru Sahib. I can tell an incident from my school time. When I was studying in a college in Toronto, I used to hang out mostly alone busy in reading Gurmat related books and school books or I had couple of school friends who were serious about their studies. Once our teacher assigned all of us to groups and we had to present an assignment that required group work. In my group there were three girls and three more guys apart from me. We used to meet everyday to do our assignment. While sitting in this group, I realised how easily they used to end up talking bad stuff. I used to sit there mostly silent and used to participate only if they spoke about the assignment, some philosophical stuff or politics (one of my favourite subjects). Anyway, one day they started talking about adult stuff and asked me too if I had any such experience too. By the kirpa of Guru Sahib I had self-confidence and believed that they were wrong and Guru Sahib's teachings were right. I did not have any urge to fit in their crowd nor by Guru Sahib's kirpa I had any inferiority complex. Other guys bragged about their big accomplishments with girls and when my turn came I just told them that I never had such experience before and I would wait for this experience till I get married. They all started laughing at me. We started having debate on this subject and I told them flatly that my Guru has taught me to keep my body pure of such activities because I had come to this world with a very sacred goal i.e. attainment of Vaheguru. One of the guys was a Muslim guy who had joined others in laughing at me but hearing my answer he started pondering and kept quiet. Then one of the girls stoop up for me and said that she respected my stand and felt that which ever girl marries me would be a lucky girl. I don't know how lucky my wife is but in any case I was glad that Guru Sahib did not give me inferiority complex and I never tried to fit in this Western crowd. That Muslim guy later on confided in me that he too had no experience with girls and that he had been bragging about his so called accomplishments to fit in the crowd. Anyway, the point I am trying to make is that we should not do such sangat or company that is detrimental to our spiritual well-being. If we do happen to be in such company that is not in accordance to Gurmat, we should firmly hold on to Gurmat, japp Naam inside for protection and never try to please them by trying to be like them. Khalsa is never alone. Khalsa is always Sava Lakh (125,000) and above all Guru Sahib is always with his Khalsa. Babbar Shers (Lions) don't try to mingle with Bhedaan Bakriyaan (goats and lambs). Babbar Shers rather stay alone than mix with goats and lambs. Khalsa avoids the sangat of Lallee Shallee, Aira Gaira Nathoo Khaira, Dhilla Missa and Kacha Pilla person. Khalsa strives to do sangat of Khalsa. It is possible that some religious Hindu friends may be okay to hang out with but the best sangat is to do sangat of Gursikhs who are serious of their aim to meet Vaheguru. And there is no such maryada of not talking to non-Sikhs or hating them. All are children of Vaheguru and we should love them all but we must only hang out with those individuals who don't cause us to drift away from out goal of meeting Vaheguru. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: Having Hindu Friends

Jatt Jandrah · 27 Feb 2005

i tell you three thing yeh - its better if you keep to gurmat sangat cos sangat does change a person. However at the same time its not a sin to have a friend who is not a sikh, but ideally it would help you to stick to sikh when you have taken the gurmat way. Adopting gurmat means a very very chunk of your life being Waheguru centred. If i spend 5 days a week, 9 hours a day with muslims, punjabis, or gangsters, and no sikhs i am not sure how i would end up. or a mix of all 4 would be a different result to sticking to gursikhs as much as i could. N when we mean sikhs we mean sikhs with rehit or at least agree and aim towards it. But a random thought comes into my brain too, i cant help but think what kind of effect some gursikhs on this board could have on non sikhs. But thats a different thing anyway.

Re: Having Hindu Friends

akj_for_eva_and_eva_amen · 27 Feb 2005

vjkk vjkf sagal ti-aagai dusat kaa sang. He forsakes the company of all wicked people i didnt say tht akj forbid it, i jus sed tht we shudnt mix with bad sangat, mabye i put it across to harshly, forgive me if i did but mixing with manmukhs isnt gonna help ur sikhi, it isnt a major paap if u do, just try to limit it and not get to attched with them. obviusly u cant follow evrything in gurbani, if u cud ur a brahmgyani, but u cud at least try a bit. freinds are not goin to accomapny u in the end so y bother 2 much bout them kis naal keechai dostee sabh jag chalanhaar. With whom should I become friends, if all the world shall pass away? vjkk vjkf

Re: Having Hindu Friends

jugroop singh · 27 Feb 2005

VahiGuruJiKaKhalsa,VahiGuruJiKiFateh! Veer Kulbir Singh Ji wrote: 'It is possible that some religious Hindu friends may be okay to hang out with but the best sangat is to do sangat of Gursikhs who are serious of their aim to meet Vaheguru. And there is no such maryada of not talking to non-Sikhs or hating them. All are children of Vaheguru and we should love them all but we must only hang out with those individuals who don't cause us to drift away from out goal of meeting Vaheguru.' Just to humbly add to this, a GurMukh piyare once explained the concept of Sangat in an amazing way and it will always stay with me... If someone is striving to meet their Guru, they should always ensure that if they meet people who are not striving to meet the Guru then these people should do THEIR Sangat (i.e. the Sikh's Sangat) and NOT the other way round. To use our Veer Ji's anecdote...these other people tried to steer the conversation towards their worldly thoughts, pleasures, beliefs etc. Veer Kulbir Singh Ji ensured that by the time the conversation finished, they had done HIS Sangat (and not the other way round). This is because: - He did not agree with them and further assist them in establishing their spirtually negative views; both to themselves and within the others around them. - He didn't feel embarrased about his views - instead he presented GurMat and as a result ended-up inspiring at least two people...the Muslim who seems to have realised the errors he was making just so he could appear as an 'inconspicuous sheep' amongst the MunMukh flock and the girl who deep down inside knew that to remain a virgin until marriage is actually a very beautiful thing. So, they did HIS Sangat and not the other way round. He would have done THEIR Sangat if the influence had been in the other direction. i personally think that we should always strive to do Sangat of GurSikhs - the reasons are so obvious, and entrenched within GurBani, so no need to elaborate. However, (unlike 'akj_for_eva_and_eva_amen' who i also think is a charlatan trying to mock the Jatha), the idea of trying to actively never talk to people of other religions whatsoever is unneccesary and could potentially be spiritually detrimental - i.e. it could be motivated by, and generate, wrong beliefs about others and lead to ego, however subtle. The GurSikh is like the gardener, tending the crops. S/He lovingly waters and nurtures those crops which will offer the greatest yield (Meets with GurSikh Sangat in a humble, loving manner). However, there are also crops which don't offer as great a yield but are still worthy of being lovingly harvested (Sangat which isn't GurSikh but also isn't MunMukh i.e. religious Hindus, Muslims, Humanists etc). However, the weeds are cast out (the GurSikh always tries to steer clear of MunMukh Sangat). In terms of trying to avoid negative Sangat within the social scene, by simply refusing to attend pubs, clubs etc. you will end-up cutting-out perhaps over 90% of the bad Sangat that could influence you. After all, who wants to hang around with a 'boring person who just wants to say nice things, listen to Keertan and do Paath all day long'. Sometimes, because of the modern workplace environment, we must sometimes spend considerable amounts of time with people who are constantly angry, doing ninidyah etc. i guess if they don't heed our words, or simply don't care for our opinion, then we can simply do Simran which will mean that we close our ears to them and instead use the time in a positive manner to open our ears and expose our tongue to VahiGuru. This would also prevent us from being affected by their 'negative Sangat'. VahiGuruJiKaKhalsa,VahiGuruJiKiFateh!

Re: Having Hindu Friends

Redwhiteandblue Kaur · 27 Feb 2005

Jatt Jandrah, I don't think that is a random thought. Kulbir Singh ji enclosed a stunningly beautiful shabad about the influence of Sangat. At the same time, aren't the best ambassadors, the best representatives, the best faces for are faith...aren't they Gursikhs?

Re: Having Hindu Friends

so wat? · 27 Feb 2005

u ppl r jus being racist now!!!!

Re: Having Hindu Friends

Jagga Jatt · 27 Feb 2005

Veer ji He "Akaal Purak" is also in Hindus. we make anyone our friend.....its our choice .....guru ji teaches us what is Good or Bad........."Gurbani says " Sakat Sang Na Kijiye Dooronh Jayeeye Paag" . so I think All we need to know about Who is "Saakat".........Saakat can be a Person who write "singh" after his name ......Like me.....I write "Singh" After my Name & I am Saakat.... [%sig%]

Re: Having Hindu Friends

akj_for_eva_and_eva_amen · 27 Feb 2005

vjkk vjkf jugroop singh sorry for all and any offence intended, i agree with ur post. if i sounded 2 extreme i apologise i was jus tryin to emphasize tht we shudnt mix with bad sangat but ur post summed up most of my views nicely. im not tryin to degrade the jatha so dont say i am because that wud be lying and i wouldnt want you to lie ova a paapi like me, sorry again vjkk vjkf

Re: Having Hindu Friends

blue · 27 Feb 2005

Waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh I think we should keep sangat of Gursikhs and other good humans, spending time with muslims and hindus is NOT a BAD thing but it does mean you cant talk about sikhi as much in an inspiring way but more because you debate the views. Why cant we just be with a mix? But if someone says something against Sikhi I would put them straight first and then depart their company. Waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh

Re: Having Hindu Friends

Harsimrat Kaur · 27 Feb 2005

Gurfateh it doesn´t matter who you talk to as long as they do not lead you astry. as long as you are strict on what things you do and how close you get to certain people it doesn´t matter who you talk to. skihi tells us that everyone is equal no matter what colour, religion or culture. as long as you think you are strong enough to say NO to things that disagree with you then talk to as many people as you like. JUST RESPECT ALL!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Gurfateh