Kulbir Singh - Double IDs
Kulbir Singh · 26 Feb 2005
Vaheguru jee ka Khalsa Vaheguru jee kee fateh!
I have received some emails asking me to clarify if I have been using double IDs posting on tapoban.org. Following is my Sapashteekaran.
This daas has 99.9 percent times only used "Kulbir Singh" id to post on this forum. .01% times I have used "Singh" ID which is a universal ID and using it does not amount to lying to sangat.
Yesterday while posting something under the thread "Who is Satguru" I signed off under my name but the name on the top stayed 'Singhnee". this was purely an error on my part and was not intentional or malicious act to deceive sangat.
"Singhnee" ID is used by my wife Harkiran Kaur who is just one of the person using our computer. Other gursikhs and my relatives come to our home and use this computer as well to post and surf the internet. The last ID used stays as default in the "Your Name" field of the message post area.
When posting, I almost always use "Kulbir Singh" to post and if I want to stay anonymous, I ensure that I don't use any other ID than "Singh" because otherwise it would amount to lying to sangat and I don't want to incur this sin on myself. To use any other name would be purely paap as deceiving sangat is punishable in Dargah of Vaheguru. The reason why I have used "Singh" ID is that sometimes I have felt the need to stay anonymous and plus it is not a lie to use this ID, since I am a Singh. To post under a bibi's name or any other name is purely against Gurmat and amounts to lying to Sangat.
I have written the above considering Siri Guru Gobind Singh jee maharaaj haazir-naazir with me. For you to believe or not to believe is up to you. I have told you my side of the story.
Daas,
Kulbir Singh
Re: Kulbir Singh - Double IDs
Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 26 Feb 2005
Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru ji ki Fateh.
This type of "accusation" is actually a variation of the " i will see you outside".....and "come to Gurdwara and see me" types..meaning the accuser has "lost" the argument and has nothing to say. ( although let me reiterate we are not here to "win or "lose" or score points..some people do feel that way and do come to do exactly that..just like they "are always wanting to see you outside..dekhlaangeh....gurdwaraeh ton bahar tan ake dekh..etc etc"..but when the gauntlet thrown is picked up..they disappear as fast as they can.
Just for info the only people i have seen behaving like louts and mini gangsters INSIDE the Gurdwaras are the young hotblood sant-babay followers..i saw an elderly gent having his turban knocked off for distributing his article opposing BARSIS of sant-babays..and another puch someone INSIDE a gurdwara on this same santbaba problem.( and what is more strange is the original "santbaba" himself is an epitome of Calm/sereness/gurbani reading/japping shanti dee moorat..but his chelas are another masaalla !!! I saw the Godfather starring Marlon Brando once and the "Godftaher" certainly never shot anyone..his mafia goons did all that dirty work....can anyone blame me if i analogise here.
imho, i have been getting the short side of this "stick" for so long now i have become totally "immunised". i dont even reply to these people.
An appeal to all readers...just read the ideas posted and dont look at the gift horse in the mouth to count his teeth.if you dont agree then post the counter arguments..and let everyone make his her own decision. Only a person whose ID is completlely transparent and well known and checkable by others..is entitled to ask others . Strangely i have NOT encountered this "problem" on any other forum. Maybe it is time for teh ADMIN to look into re-orgainisng this forum so that ONLY those whose ID's are Pre-registered are allowed to post..although this is not foolproof either..OR better still JUST IGNORE such people.
Jarnail Singh
Re: Kulbir Singh - Double IDs
Jatt Jandrah · 27 Feb 2005
kulbir singh i dont care. I love you and others like you ( me not bingah just expressing love for all true sikhs), i will not big you up but i see very good qualities inside you which is very scarce nowdays. I value the truth and love for gursikhi rehit inside you.
May Waheguru keep blessing wonderful sikhs like yourself.
Re: Kulbir Singh - Double IDs
jugroop singh · 27 Feb 2005
VahiGuruJiKaKhalsa,VahiGuruJiKiFateh!
Sadh Sangat Jio,
i would like to echo Bhai Jarnail Singh Ji's sentiments and mention something else.
Sadly, the quality of overall posts on this forum has gone down slightly due to some absolutely pointless posts being let through. These usually take the form of a sentence or two deriding someone, making silly accusations, adding nothing to the thread etc.
i think that should be stopped otherwise the overall qualty of this, the best cyber-forum by far, will slowly start going down.
i know that some people will say censorship, admin denying opinions, tapoban wants to brainwash everyone etc. but they are usually the people who want to post irrelevant stuff as opposed to really find out more abot GurMat, ask for opinions about GurShabads etc. - sorry if i sound harsh but the fact of the matter is that anyone who visits this foprum and posts and gets responses knows the score - its a Tat GurMat forum and not a 'chit-chat discuss anything forum as long as you put the word 'Sikh' into the sentence once' forum.
ps - sorry if i sound bossy...
pps - my id is no longer 'Jagroop Singh' because i realised that 'JUGroop Singh' would be a better way of spelling it - it makes pronunciation easier...lol.
VahiGuruJiKaKhalsa,VahiGuruJiKiFateh!
Re: Kulbir Singh - Double IDs
ex-sikh sangat member · 27 Feb 2005
Bhai Kulbir Singh Jee, you do not have to justify yourself. The naive person who started the thread on Sikhsangat did it just to do NIndya of you and Tapoban. Some people have no shame doing Nindya of a decent rehetvaan Singh, after all... it is Kalyug isn't it? After his post some people just jumped in to the bandwagon of immaturity and saw this as an opportunity to start bashing tapoban.
Just dont worry about it. Some people still need a little bit of growing up.
Re: Kulbir Singh - Double IDs
sanatan santra · 27 Feb 2005
jugroop singh the mods here are chardi kala singhs they know how to do their job.
not everyone is as educated, well researched, or good at putting things into context or seeing everything like you see it. If you cant see that then God help you. However if someone does insult or use bad language then i do understand what you say.
Re: Kulbir Singh - Double IDs
sanatan santra · 28 Feb 2005
jugroop singh
"its a Tat GurMat forum and not a 'chit-chat discuss anything forum as long as you put the word 'Sikh' into the sentence once' forum."
You are right few posts as you have mentioned do get through. But then we are all at different ages, from different countires some just learnin basic english levels, and many just starting on sikhi while others advanced.
Not everyone knows how to use big posh words, so to express themselves what might look like "chit chat" to you may be the simple everyday language they use.
Just because you use the word "tat gurmat" its not right to put others down like that. "tat Gurmat" also requires a fine line of understanding and patience but obviously not letting people take the mick on here with personal insults and swearing. If the solution you suggest happens, a lot of kids who come here will be gone, with advanced uni boys like you with big constructing sentances left. Having said that i am all for filtering posts that contain swearing, filth, and insults. But you have no hakh over how others write, we are all independant in nature, you have to understand that.
Re: Kulbir Singh - Double IDs
jugroop singh · 28 Feb 2005
*** Admin Note: We are admitting this last post to this thread. Perhaps jugroop Singh jee, you can start this topic of kind of posts that should be allowed, under a new thread *****
VahiGuruJiKaKhalsa,VahiGuruJiKiFateh!
Veer/Bhain 'sanatan santra' ji,
Apologies - i didn't mean to belittle anyone. i wasn't trying to demean people and the 'way' they put their points across.
Just wanted to say that Admin should just try to ensure that junky responses (i.e. people cussing each other without making a point, trying to be sarcastic without making a point etc.) don't keep increasing.
i think Admin are doing an excellent job - moderating and organising a Gurmat messageboard isn't easy nowadays.
No offence intended to anyone.
Bhul chuk maaf karna ji.
VahiGuruJiKaKhalsa,VahiGuruJiKiFateh!
Re: Kulbir Singh - Double IDs
sanatan santra · 28 Feb 2005
jugroop singh i am sorry i took it the wrong way bul chug maaf karna veerji
Re: Kulbir Singh - Double IDs
kulwinder Singh · 28 Feb 2005
Vir Ji if you make trillion IDs even then you are not a 0.000000000000001% less or more better Sikh or human being. I say as this to you as I normally do debate with you as I have different way of looking at things then you, at the same time I respect you for your commitment to your ways and thinking. Would I be offended or feel any different if I figured it out you may have knowingly or unknowingly used different IDs the Answer is absolutely no.
So in future please ignore these kind of emails. Some People like to pinpoint on trivial points rather then serious issues
Re: Kulbir Singh - Double IDs
Jarnail Singh gyani "Arshi" · 01 Mar 2005
Waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh.
Dear irony ji,
i have come across people who "think" highly of you, praise you to the skies, "barra gurmukh", Bahut widvaan .... reahtwaan etc etc....BUT the moment they realise..you dont beleive "Raagmala" is bani. ( just one example...it can be they find out you dont beleive in sant babays, their brand of maryada jyots etc etc.)...all that "piyaar" goes out the window and you are lowest of the low..worse than a patit....
SO All that "gurmukhta..piyaar..etc " is all for their OWN KIND..only..just as Bush once said..Either you are WITH me or Against Me...he he he.
Jarnail Singh