Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

SGPC’s no to descendents of Mian Mir

SGPC’s no to descendents of Mian Mir

Tribune News Service · 27 Feb 2005

SGPC’s no to descendents of Mian Mir Amritsar, February 27 The Shiromani Gurudwara Prabandhak Committee (SGPC) has refused to give permission to Nasin Maqdoom Sayeed Chan Pir Quadri, a descendant of Muslim saint Hazrat Mian Mir of Pakistan, to perform religious hymns in the sanctum sanctorum of the Golden Temple here. Quadri, the 19th descendant of Hazrat Mia, who is believed to have laid the foundation stone of the temple in 1589 on the request of fifth Sikh Guru Arjan Dev, had arrived here from Pakistan two days ago through the Wagah route with the desire to perform kirtans (hymns) at the Golden Temple. “We don’t have any problem with their religion but the SGPC and Sikh religion have certain set criteria for anybody who wants to sing kirtans inside the Golden Temple which is lacking in the team lead by Quadri,” SGPC President Bibi Jagir Kaur told reporters here today. “As per Sikh religion norms, only those people can perform kirtan inside the temple who adopt Sikh religion in letter and spirit. One should be well-versed to sing kirtan as per Sikh rituals for which one has to go through the mandatory training imparted by the SGPC and other Sikh religious and spiritual institutes,” she said. — PTI

Re: SGPC’s no to descendents of Mian Mir

etka · 27 Feb 2005

they're good enuff 2 lay the foundation stone but not to sing his praises?

Re: SGPC’s no to descendents of Mian Mir

S Singh · 28 Feb 2005

Strange but the Sikh religion is very much against people who kill their daughters yet Jagir Kaur is heading the SGPC. Maybe whe should delve into sikhi a bit more and resign.

Re: SGPC’s no to descendents of Mian Mir

khalsa · 28 Feb 2005

I think tihs is a Great Stand by SGPC. Rules are rules, and Only amritdari's should be allowed to do keertan IN sangat at gurdwaras. Great work SGPC!

Re: SGPC’s no to descendents of Mian Mir

Jarnail Singh Gyani · 28 Feb 2005

Guru nanak Ji went to Mecca....will any SIKH be allowed to go there today...Guru nanak Ji performed Nimaaz in Sultanpur Lodhi...can any sikh perform nimaaz at any mosque...and still remain a sikh That was then and now is NOW.... we have Maryada to follow.IF we allow every.1,2,3,...to take centre stage in our holiest Gurdwara....wont a "bedi" baba insist on sitting on Guru Ji's Throne..after all it is the throne of his blood ancestor.....dito sodhi baabas, whatever...( one already tried years ago but the Singhs took care of that)....Guru Ji and Mian Mir ahd a special relationship....do his descendants have the "same" relationship with the Sikhs`Rules are rules...no exceptions Jarnail singh

Re: SGPC’s no to descendents of Mian Mir

bingo · 28 Feb 2005

Why always Khalsa panth of Guru Gobind Singh proves heavier than Sikhs (Shishya) of first five Gurus? If then they did not find it objectionable to have laying of foundation stone by a muslim then which rehat are we talking about? Just the "Roop" that Guru Gobind Singh has given us is more important to us? Can't we be magnanimous enough to respect the decision then taken by Guru Sahib? SGPC knows only of politics and how to play with emotions on the name of sikhi.

Re: SGPC’s no to descendents of Mian Mir

Bundha · 28 Feb 2005

Chuffin' eck Gyani Ji, for once I agree with you !!!!! [%sig%]

Re: SGPC’s no to descendents of Mian Mir

S Singh · 28 Feb 2005

Some people claim that Mian Mir did not lay the foundation stone and that this story was concotted in the 1800s.

Re: SGPC’s no to descendents of Mian Mir

Kulbir Singh · 28 Feb 2005

This story of Hazrat Mian Meer laying the foundation stone of Sachkhand Siri Harmandir Sahib was first written by Giani Giyaan Singh in the late 1800s. Sooraj Parkash and other old accounts state that Siri Guru Arjun Dev jee himself laid the foundation stone of Siri Harmandir Sahib and Baba Buddha jee did ardaas for it. Since it seems very politically-correct thing, our scholars immediately adopted this saakhi, without doing any research in it. Why would Siri Guru jee ask Hazrat Mian Meer to lay the foundation stone of Siri Darbar Sahib? With the presence of gursikhs like Baba Buddha jee, Bhai Gurdas jee, Bhai Manjh jee, why was there need to look for a spiritually elevated person outside of Sikh faith? Above all, Siri Guru jee himself was the greatest Sant in human body at that time. What was the need for him to ask a Sufi saint to lay the foundation stone of Darbar Sahib. Is there any other old Granth except for Giani Giyan Singh’s book that says that Siri Guru jee asked Mian Meer to lay the foundation stone of Siri Darbar Sahib? If this is in fact true that he did lay the foundation stone of Siri Harmandir Sahib and if there is any proof of the same, then I would have no problem accepting this saakhi. Guru Sahib diyaan Guru Sahib jee hee jaanan. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: SGPC’s no to descendents of Mian Mir

bingo · 28 Feb 2005

In my view, believeing that this sakhi is true, He asked Miyan Mir to lay the foundation stone just to let "moorakh" people like us know that spirituality is above religions.

Re: SGPC’s no to descendents of Mian Mir

Kulwinder Singh · 28 Feb 2005

Very Well Said Dear Bingo Ji ! Dhan Teri Sikhi and Dhan Terai Sikh Guru Ji, who understand your sentiments even today. A big hug from me.

Re: SGPC’s no to descendents of Mian Mir

Kulbir Singh · 28 Feb 2005

Bhai Kulwinder Singh jeeo and Bingo jeeo, How is spirituality above religions? Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: SGPC’s no to descendents of Mian Mir

what have we learned? · 01 Mar 2005

Being given the status 'dharj' of being the youngest/newest of the world's main religions, I personally feel that we have not learnt from the obvious mistakes that have become inherent in other faiths, instead we have decided to match and justify there mistakes... 1, Restricting certain ceremonies, such as singing Waheguru's praises to those whom have been initiated into the khalsa panth, whether that individual has the jeevan or love for waheguru... 2, Assuming that if/when an individual takes amrit, please let not assume that he/she is a better, or more important, than ANY individual that chooses not too. Our rehit maryada is there as a guidance document, by no means is it waheguru's Law. (In my humble opinion) Just look around you, we are seeing the general state of amrit-tari sikhs, and there jeevan! 3. No one faith/religion has the monopoly on GOD. We are all his children, whether we are good/bad, we are all his children. (This is why spirituality is higher than religion... for an individual does not have to be apart of any faith to attain the truth. IMHO) 4. Instead of welcoming others into the Sikh faith, we have begun to push people further away. Darbar sahib is also known as Harmandhir sahib too (hari being GOD, mandhir be a place for god's worship) whom are we too prevent those whom wish to singh his praises? We are not saying that you allow a sodhi/bedi to sit there as if he/she is the 'guru' the topic is about allowing Muslims to sing his praises, in darbar sahib. Just because the Muslim faith may not allow any other person of another faith to sing in a mosque, does not make it right. imho. After visiting this forum for the past few years, imho, those whom may carry a large breath of knowledge not only about our SIRI Guru granth sahib, but also sikh history, seem to have placed on the 'blinkers', narrowing there vision. Lets spread the love and the WORD that is our beloved Eleventh Guru. Lets see if this is possible beyond our own small circles... Kulbir Singh Dhillon UK wala

Re: SGPC’s no to descendents of Mian Mir

RK · 01 Mar 2005

1. The fact that they have amrit shuck and are keeping the Sikhi roop should mean that they have love for guru ji, since they are following guru jis hukams. Note, you may argue that there are people who adopt the roop but do other stuff like drink, pluck kes etc. and I am of the opinion that these people cannot do keertan as they are misrepresenting SIkhi. 2. I do not know about the "better person" part, but they would certainly be a better Sikh since they are actually now a Sikh of Guru Nanak Dev JI, and can now start on the path towards Vaheguru. They actually have enough love for guru ji in their hearts to obey his first hukam. How can you say a person who chooses not to obey guru jis first hukam is better than one who does? 3. Although we are all his children, it has been said in Gurbani that Vaheguru can only be obtained through the satguru, and as has been proved in another thread that satguru is only Sri Guru Nanak Dev Ji, how can we as Sikhs go against what Sikhi is saying and say that anyone can obtain GOd? You yourself say that you beleive in Guru Granth Sahib Ji, then why do you argue with what has been written in Gurbani? 4. This topic of seva has also been discussed on this forum before. There are certain sevas in the panth that you must be qualified for, and keertan seva is one of them. How can a person sing the teachings of guru ji while not following those teachings? That would be hypocrisy. We are doing keertan for dhan dhan Satguru ji, how can anyone just walk in and start doing keertan for them? I have seen this trend of cheapening Sikhi just to fit into the universalist views that have developed throughout the years, and I think it is disgusting how people try to sell of their asools just to make Sikhi fit into the popular discourse of religion. I suggest people start trying to aspire to the high levels of SIkhi instead of always trying to bring Sikhi down to thier own level.

Re: SGPC’s no to descendents of Mian Mir

noone in particular · 01 Mar 2005

What do the four dours of Harmander Sahib representing? Openness to persons from the 4 corners of the earth..These "universalist views" in my opinion, are what make Sikhi the most beautiful religion to follow. [%sig%]

Re: SGPC’s no to descendents of Mian Mir

blue · 01 Mar 2005

Waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh Interesting post RK, I have developed a serious and incurable dislike for those that complain non-amritdhaaris can be better than amrit-dhaaris because ''look at what amrit dhaaris are doing aj kal''! If a person shaks amrit and then removes hair, drinks aclohol, is he still an amrit-dhari? Without any offence intended I know some muslims prefer to sing ''Aval Allah noor uapaea kudrat ke sab bande''. some of them do try to bring their own views in (not accusing everyone though). Waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh

Re: SGPC’s no to descendents of Mian Mir

sikh · 01 Mar 2005

Darbar Saahib has four dours.... but only one pathway leading to those four doors. If someone happens to be a descendant of Mia Meer or anyone else... so what? Blood links mean nothing in sikhi. You don't get special priveleges just because you're related to someone.

Re: SGPC’s no to descendents of Mian Mir

fff · 01 Mar 2005

prove it...prove it all [%sig%]

Re: SGPC’s no to descendents of Mian Mir

Jarnail Singh gyani "Arshi" · 01 Mar 2005

Waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh. The FOUR DOORS..are for people of ALL Four Corners to COME IN....NOT DEMAND special rights and Privileges. Guru Arjun Ji might have "welcomed Mian Mir to sit on His Right hand side, Guru Ji might even have hugged him..etc etc...BUT how does that act of GURU JI translate into us giivng the "same" treatment to these blood relatives just ebcasue they are "blood relatives"..when Guru Ji Himself has NEGATED "BLOOD TIES" as not qualifying factor...these people have to BE QUALIFIED for the privileges they seek...through the same GURU JI ( Guru Granth Ji)....that is Follow what GURBANI says.....merely saying i am blood related to so and so doesnt cut any ice..and we need not "CUT and stretch Sikhi" asools to FIT that image of "universal sikhism"...no ji, "universal Sikhism" DOES NOT MEAN any Tom Dick and Harry can come DEMAND to sit CENTRE STAGE..just because his great grandfather also received that privilelge...it is a "PRIVILEGE" not a "RIGHT"....and we can give it to anyone we please...because we are the GURU KHALSA PANTH...and deny it to anyone we please. Tomorrow KPS Gill may demand that he be allowed to administer Amrit at Takhat Keshgarh Sahib..or even be appointed Jathedar Akal Takaht ??..because his great grandfather fought on Guru Ji's side in a a battle or something..or that he is blood related to Ganggu who "saved" the Chotteh sahibzadeh by taking them to his home !!! This may be FATFETCHED...but can happen nevertheless if we give in to such notions as blood relations and such..ad disregard our principles which we have forged. A person must show Genuine LOVE for the GURU, by adopting His Principles and Gurbani before he can "inquire/request" for any privilelegs. Jarnail Singh

Re: SGPC’s no to descendents of Mian Mir

london singh · 02 Mar 2005

WJKK WJKF I agree with RK, Blue and Sikh. It is interesting that people start to claim to be the descendents of so and so person from Sikh history and want special status just from their blood lineage. There is no proof that Mian Mir ever laid the foundation stone for the Harmandir Sahib. What has happened is that this unsubstantiated story has gained currency because Sikhs have become more concerned about showing our religion to be 'secular' than having faith in the truth. The special treatment demanded by so-called 'descendents' has been receiving a lot of coverage. The reason being is that Sikhs have become weaker and people see this as their best opportunity to gain a perch on the tree of Sikh society and perhaps get some Sikh followers and money. The Ganga Sagar which the descendent of Rai Kalha has been displaying has led to lots of Sikhs making offerings to it both in money and in the form of jewellery. What has happened to this money and items? Did Guru Gobind Singh gift the Ganga Sagar to Rai Kalha so that his Sikhs would make offerings to it instead of to Waheguru? No great emphesis was ever laid in Sikh history to descendents and lineage. Maharaja Ranjit Singh rather than give lands and riches to Rai Kalha's descendents actually did the opposite, he deposed them of their lands and only after the British signed a treaty limiting the Maharaja's rule to west of Satluj did the Rai's descendents get their lands back. So grateful were they for this that 50 years later they offered the sword of Guru Gobind Singh to Queen Victoria as a gift! Most Muslims try to sing 'Avval Allah' because they believe that is praise their Allah but some are so blinkered in their views that they fail to realise that the next lines describe Allah as being present in every being - something which is totally against Islam!! Sikhs need to be especially vigilant, we have become weakened by the events of the 80's and are now seen as gullible for all so-called descendents who want to use their lineage to try and fool us

Re: SGPC’s no to descendents of Mian Mir

Jarnail Singh gyani "Arshi" · 02 Mar 2005

waheguru Ji ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji ki fateh. London Singh Ji, You are so right....we are now WEAK..and right for the KILL...that is why these hordes of "blood relatives", bearing "nishanis" of Gurus and their mehils..are rushing forward to claim their positions...why no body ever heard of these people in the past 100 years ?? were they sleeping ?? or have they wqken up to see the iron is hot for striking...the ganga sagar thingy is proof of how gullible we are...MILLIONS of chharrawa has been matha teked to this vessel..what a bunch of fools we are ??? All this is result of the mind numbing carried out by the sant baba brigade..suddenly anything any object that has "touched" the Guru Ji's body is DIVINE/HOLY/..we dont question it..but matha tek to it. IF GURU JI's body was so precious they could have PRESERVED them..IF "Blood relatives" were so important GUru Ji would have TOLD US...instead GURU JI made us Hold to GURU GRANTH JI...doesnt that count for anything ?? Obviously not as the mad rush to matha tek, drink from the holy water coming out of ganga sagar etc shows.. When will be ever let GURBANI light up our DARK LIVES ?? Jarnail Singh

Re: SGPC’s no to descendents of Mian Mir

Toronto Singh · 03 Jan 2006

WGJK WGJF Are we fighting to prove who is wrong? Doesn't gurbani carry hymes from Muslim and hindu sufis. Isn't the word "Allah" and "Rab" has been directly taken from Quran. we must read other religion and respect other. religion so we get same respect

Re: SGPC’s no to descendents of Mian Mir

Jagjit Singh · 04 Jan 2006

waheguru ji ka khalsa, waheguru ji ke fateh Pyare jio, since when is doing the seva of keertan higher than listening to keertan? Nobody has ever stopped anyone listening to keertan in Darbar sahib. Why do descendants insist on only doing it and walk off in a huff and puff if they are not allowed. This shows an alterior motive, possibly to use it build on their own personal fame. If Sian Mian Mir was alive today. He would come to Darbar sahib. Praise the Guru for the Drashan of his Gursikhs. Matta tek in front of Guru ji. Then sit there and Listen to the bani and join the sangat in singing the praises of Akaal. He would never walk of in a huff and puff just because he was not allowed to do keertan. This is the behaviour of a very low avaastha. One which reeks of ego in itself. One who has a high avvastha enjoys listening and joining in singing the praises with the sangat. He does not care if he is leading the sangat, or just part of the sangat. he just feels blessed to be in a sangat. Today we have descendants popping up left, right and center. Clearly there is alot of money in religion. The rules of only Amritdharis is Gurmat and should always remain. How do we know Sian Mian Mir did not take Charan pahul and was not a Gursikh? We do not know. Maybe he was. But these people are not. Plus one point made by one veer about Amritdahris, saying look at what some are doing now. The only ones who are behaving badly are those who have never appreciated the high value of Amrit. This does not mean we de-value it further. In kalyug, just the darja of being a Amritdharis is a huge thing. waheguru ji ka khalsa, waheguru ji ke fateh

Re: SGPC’s no to descendents of Mian Mir

A Singh · 04 Jan 2006

SGPC can ceratinly have separate arrangements within the Harmindar Sahib premises for people to wish to sing Gurbani belonging to different cultures. They can also work out schedules accordingly.

Re: SGPC’s no to descendents of Mian Mir

indy · 04 Jan 2006

were arguin about some muslim not being able 2 do religious hymns in the golden temple when bibiz arent even allowed 2.... we got bigger fish (vegeterian 1z) 2 fry!!!!! DEGH TEGH..............................