Patna Sahib Jathedaar - 2 wifes
Rashminder Singh · 02 Mar 2005
Polygamy acceptable, says Jathedar
Varinder Walia
Tribune News Service
Amritsar, March 2
The charges of polygamy put Giani Iqbal Singh, Jathedar, Patna Sahib, in a fix yesterday when the Jathedar, Akal Takht, Giani Joginder Singh Vedanti, announced that without divorce, second marriage by a Sikh is violation of the ‘Sikh rehat maryada’, approved by the SGPC and Akal Takht.
Jathedar Vedanti refused to accept the plea of the Jathedar, Patna Sahib, that polygamy was prevalent in the past and acceptable in Sikhism. Giani Iqbal Singh had pleaded that Maharaja Ranjit Singh who is called ‘Singh Sahib’ had more than one wife. He also quoted revered Sikh religious personalities having more than one wife to justify his second marriage.
Jathedar Vedanti said the matter of polygamy, in general, and case of the Jathedar, Patna Sahib, in particular, would be taken up in the next meeting of the Sikh clergy. He, however, clarified that Jathedar Iqbal Singh won’t be invited in this meeting.
Giani Iqbal Singh, however, claimed that he had married a Jammu resident with the consent of his first wife and in-laws, which was endorsed by the sangat from Patna Sahib. He claimed that his first wife had left the house without telling the family. Now she was living with her parents at Ganganagar (Rajasthan). “Had they (first wife and in-laws) any objection, they would have moved the court.”
Re: Patna Sahib Jathedaar - 2 wifes
Jarnail Singh gyani "Arshi" · 02 Mar 2005
BABA daljit Singh Ji of Chicago will be next on this polygamy Hall of Fame...and He is a Iqbal Supporter too..??
jarnail Singh
Re: Patna Sahib Jathedaar - 2 wifes
Kulbir Singh · 03 Mar 2005
I am not a big fan of Bhai Iqbal Singh. He has done great damage to Sikh Panth by questioning just about every decision of Siri Akal Takhat. Whether the issue was of Nanakshahi calendar or of Mundavani, he always was there to cause problems.
His predecessor too was anti-SGPC and during the Blue Star Operation on Siri Akal Takhat Sahib he along with the Hazoor Sahib Jathedar supported the action against Sant Bhindranwalay.
It would be interesting to see what Siri Akal Takhat Sahib decides after meeting about polygamy. I hope they don't let him off the hook and hold him accountable for his wrongdoing. If this man succeeds in keeping both wives at the same time he will set a very wrong precedent. It may even trigger polygamy in Sikh faith. There are many so-called Sikhs like Dharminder who would love to have two marriages.
Daas,
Kulbir Singh
Re: Patna Sahib Jathedaar - 2 wifes
Jarnail Singh gyani "Arshi" · 03 Mar 2005
Waheguru Ji ka Khalsa Waheguru ji kI fateh.
we are oh "so quick" to point out that Guru Gobind Singh Ji had "four" wives.....( AND SO THAT PROVES WE CAN TOO !!!)....BUT we are not so quick ( in fact NEVER do it)....to point out that...this same GURU GOBIND SINGH JI sacrificed His Father at age NINE, He Fought so many Battles, endured so much, SAW his eldest Sons shaheed in front of His eyes, His two youngest sons also shaheed..AND SO WE SHOULD BE PREAPRED to DO all this as well ??? How many of us can send his father off to have his head cut off for someone elses right to religious freedom ?? How many of us can see our FOUR fantastic sons die in front of our eyes....and still say THANK YOU WAHEGURU for this Boon....
Shame on us....any tom dick and harry can "marry" as many wives as he wishes...Guru nanak ji in Sri raag already told us...Je Lakh Isteriaan ..even if one "marries" a LAKH wives..it is of NO SUBSTANCE/use at all...its all lust.
I read in a history book that a very beautiful virgin Pathaan Woman came to see Gen Hari Singh nalwa in his camp and on seeing how handsome and brave he was she wanted to seduce him...she pleaded with him that she wanted a "son" just like him...finally when she wouldnt leave..Gen hari Singh nalwa knelt down before her and told her...You want a son like me...from This moment I AM YOUR SON...O MOTHER of mine. Just compare the IKHLAAK and UCha Jiwan of puratan Sikhs and the likes of our Jathedars ( dharam de Thekedaars actually)..why do i say this..because just this morning a mail has been circulated on all mailing lists that says so much about this sordid affair..those interested can go read all this stuff there.( this Forum is too pure to have such stuff printed here)....sad..very sad.
Jarnail Singh
Re: Patna Sahib Jathedaar - 2 wifes
Ranjeet Singh · 03 Mar 2005
Kulbir Singh who is Dharminder?
The idea of polygamy is not possible according to "Ek Jot Doey Murti..." unless I am mistaken in my understanding of that line.
Re: Patna Sahib Jathedaar - 2 wifes
Harpreet Singh · 04 Mar 2005
Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa
Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh
Although I don't have any such intentions personally nor do I see anyone of fellow gursikhs doing this ever, but just wanted to bring in one more point here as it is related to situations somewhat similar to this one.
As per gurmat maryada, only two amritdhari souls can have anand kaaraj in presence of Sahib Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji Maharaaj. I personally believe that registration of marriage is a wordly thing and it has nothing to do with Gurmat. Specially registering our anand karaj marriage in India is much worse as it registers and recognises our marriage as Hindu Marriage which is completely wrong.
So lets say 2 gursikhs have anand kaaraj and start living as husband and wife. If they r perfect souls no issues should arise ever. But in modern times so many cases are there where marriages break. People seperate. Concept of Divorce comes into picture in such circumstances.
I personally feel Divorce concept has no place in sikhism. But I get confused what happens in such case where one marriage breaks and couple seperates.
Today if two gursikhs go to court, apply for divorce and once granted both of them go again and remarry none of the singhs today raises any voice about there remarriage. Everyone in sangat, families accepts such remarriages. But on other hand if a person who does not believe in registration of marriages, why the hell he needs to apply for divorce? Once they have seperated and agreed that they never want to live together as couple this is something similar to divorce itself. In such circumstances if they remarry people start making lot of noise.
I have put forward two cases here. Can sangat on the forum please discuss and post views which option is ok:
1. Getting divorce and remarrrying
2. Not believing in registration and divorce concept so mutually agreeing to seperate and remarry
3. If unable to live together, separate but none of the partner remarries
The true anand kaaraj can never fail that's my faith as its blessed by Guru Sahib and meant for gursikh souls. But at end of day as human beings everyone is prone to commiting mistakes and people end up seperating. What should be the norm as per gurmat?
Please discuss.
Bhul chuk di khima
Dass,
Harpreet Singh
Re: Patna Sahib Jathedaar - 2 wifes
quick to jump... · 04 Mar 2005
Veer Jarnail Singh,
Lets not be so quick to jump to the extreme side, someone has brought up the FACT that Siri Guru Hargobind, Siri Guru Har Rai and Siri Guru Gobind singh all had more than noe wife, more than one life partner...Why? we will never know the real reasons, but why throw the typical/usual response of Siri Guru Gobind Singh sacrificed his father @ ninie, sacrificed his beloved four sons, his sikh's (the list goes on...) Are you saying that the payment/reward for there valour/giving to the world through Sacrifice, is the oportunity of having more than one wife...? Do you see were this is going...?
As i mentioned earlier, Why they decided to marry more than once is not known, and we can all try and justify it.
As far as the 'story' of Sardar Hari Singh Uppal (Nalwa) being approachd by the youngest wife of a pathan ruler, this may well be true, but it is also a known fact that Hari Singh Nalwa had two wifes and also an illegitimate son....
Polygamy is wrong, period. I personally feel that is undermines the equality and values of our sisters, which my beautiful sikhi holds so dearly...
Gurfateh,
Kulbir Singh dhillon UK wala
Re: Patna Sahib Jathedaar - 2 wifes
truth hurts · 04 Mar 2005
GuruFateh
For any amritdhari to get a divorce and then remarry is totally anti-gurmat.
Thats just the way it is...........
GuruFateh
Re: Patna Sahib Jathedaar - 2 wifes
Jarnail Singh gyani "Arshi" · 05 Mar 2005
Waheguru Ji ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji ki fateh.
It is blasphemy to say it is a "FACT" that Guru Ji had more than one wife. Guru Ji didnt preach what they didnt practise. We cannot ever equal the Gurus in anything we do.... I am 100% SURE the "reason" for quoting such dubious " facts"... about GURU JI..is to SANCTION it as RIGHT and therefore Right for us sikhs too..otherwise why dont we always cite Guru ji's sacrifice and say I WANT to DO THAT TOO...??
Veer S Singh Ji, you say that SGPC is "just a management" body and has no "right" to issue a Rehat maryada..etc etc. can you specify Which "jathebandi is the "Guru Khalsa Panth" ?? and WHY should that jathebandi be the PANTH and authorised to issue a Rehat maryada ?? And also please enlighten us as to WHICH REHAT MARYADA ??? AUTHORISES MORE THAN ONE WIFE ?? Apparently Jathedar Iqbal Singh is adherreing to THIS PARTICULAR Rehat maryada...is he ?? Any others also doing that by following that Rehat maryada ??. (baba Daljit Singh of Chivcago..maybe..many many more such babas ?? .I am sure many will love to "follow" the Rehat maryada that Iqbal singh follows..and it MUST be the Only One Authorised by the "PANTH"..whoever that is... Also a few Quotes from Gurbani on more than one wife would be fine with me...as the "authorised Rehat maryada" ( not sgpc DRAFT) MUST be following GURBANI and GURU JI's direct Orders ??
NO Sir..if you had One Anand Karaj.....and it "failed" thats it...it has failed. Learn to live with it...NO trying agaain and agaain...unless one partner DIES
Jarnail Singh
Re: Patna Sahib Jathedaar - 2 wifes
jagmeet singh · 06 Mar 2005
Waheguru ji ka khalsa
Waheguru ji ki fateh.
I am not an active participant of this group but i do read the posts.
Iam very disappointed that some readers on this group feel that our Guru's have more than one wives. If we take the case Guuru Gobind Singh ji. he married Mata Sundri ji. The thoughts of some writers is wrong that Guru ji also married Mata Jeeto ji. Actually Jeeto ji and Sundri ji are not different persons, one but with two different names. At those times it was a tradition when a newly wed girls arrives at her new home, a new name was given to her. That is why when Mata Jeeto ji married Guru Gobind Singh ji, she was given a new name by Mata Gujri ji and that was Sundri ji because she was so beautiful.
And in the case of Mata Sahib kaur ji. In those times there was not fast means of travel, a devote sikh decided to marry her daughter to Guru sahib because last time someone visited Guru sahib from his vallage, they only knew that Guru sahib is still single. So when he decided, he took the dola of Mata Sahib kaur ji to Anandpur Sahib just to know that Guru Sahib has already been married, he told Guru sahib to accept Mata Sahib kaur ji, but Guru sahib refused and told him that he cant because it is against gurmat. but the devout sikh told that now I have already announced the marriage of my daughter to you, and everybody in his village knew about it, if Guru sahib dont marry his daughter now then nobody will marry her thereafter.
then Guru sahib told him that her daughter can live here, stay here, and do seva of sangat.
thats the real story behind this. but some clever brahmins twisted this story so that to create confusions between sikhs, so that to leave sikhs to fight between each other forever. the story of Guru sahib having two wives was made during the reign of maharaja Ranjit singh, so that to let maharaja to have more than one marriage.
Waheguru ji ka khalsa
Waheguru ji ki fateh.
bhullan chukan di maafi.
sangatan da daas
Jagmeet Singh
Re: Patna Sahib Jathedaar - 2 wifes
Prabhjoyt singh · 24 Nov 2005
Iqbal su said the line "Sri Nankanna Sahib te hoor Sikh Gurdhama nu panth tou vichorea gaia una dey khulay darshan didar te sewa sambal khalsa panth hu bakshu" should be removed from the ardas. This was said on 19 november in a public meeting.