Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

heritage status of darbar sahib

heritage status of darbar sahib

sikh · 13 Mar 2005

why is nobody talking about probably the biggest probelm of all to face the panth the heritage status of darbar sahib? does sangat even realise the enormity of what can and will happen here if darbar sahib is given heritage status under unesco? the indian government will have total control over the whole complex and akal takhat sahib shall lose its sovereignty......... we will have no voice left at all........... sat sangat wake up and and see what is happening and make your voice heard........ please read the following website and make your voices heard, darbar sahib is the reposibility of each and every sikh! www.witness84.com

Re: heritage status of darbar sahib

S Singh · 13 Mar 2005

This is utter tripe. What has happed to in the Darbar Sahib complex without WHS. Lets see...... bodge up gold plating job that is not casing damage to the inner structure of the Harmandir Sahib so what they could not do during Bluestar the kar seva wale have started. The use of disgusting bathroom tiles to decorate the interior of Gurdwara Baba Atal. Whitewashing old wall paintings again at Gurdwara Baba Atal. Again all thanks to kar seva wale. The turning of the Ramgharia bungas into muslim style minarets....again kar seva wale. We have had enough heritage destroyed by kar seva wale, it is time to protect our heritage and get WHS. If you think the GOI will take over then you are living in cloud cuckoo land. All that will happen is that any kar seva wale have to meet strict standards so your good hearted kar seva wale will not be able to use bathroom tiles to decorate and white wash centuries old paintings. The only people causing the fuss are doing for their own self interests. Have they come up with alternatives to save our heritage......NO ! I think they are linked to kar seva wale, once WHS is granted the work of kar seva wale will diminish unless they get hertiage specialists on board. There is the counter argument that we should not be bothered about our heritage but once you start losing your heritage you are nothing.

Re: heritage status of darbar sahib

sikh · 13 Mar 2005

s singh people like are a complete and utter joke........... have you even bothered to read the facts? nobody is hiding anything.....go read and enlighten yourself.......... and i not only urge you but the rest of sangat............

Re: heritage status of darbar sahib

Balji Kaur Toor · 13 Mar 2005

It is a big problem In our hands it is not only golden temple is in danger every single historical gurdwara been demolished not by Aurungzed or any other mogul ruler but by our own SGPCand re built by Kar seva peole. We got to do something to free the gurdwaras from greedy beasts.

Re: heritage status of darbar sahib

S Singh · 14 Mar 2005

Sikh I may be a joke but at least I am not getting my kachare in a twist over a trivial matter like WHS. The SGPC can not do anything without the Deputy Commissioners giving the nod anyway so nothing will change. I am concerned about our heritage. Its obvious people like you are not. I have read the facts and they do not back your statements. The Akal Takht will remain independent (not that it is with the interference from SGPC and Akalis).

Re: heritage status of darbar sahib

sikh · 14 Mar 2005

s singh thank you for your informed comments.

Re: heritage status of darbar sahib

sarjitsinghkhalsa · 14 Mar 2005

everything is under indian cpontrol the sikhs you see are not sikhs they are goverments puppats any way dont worry khalsa raj coming in 2008

Re: heritage status of darbar sahib

@zero · 14 Mar 2005

where did 2008 come from?

Re: heritage status of darbar sahib

S Singh · 14 Mar 2005

2008.....another made up year. Just like that Gumtee wala "baba" was claiming that Khalsa Raj was coming in a few years (that was several years ago).

Re: heritage status of darbar sahib

Gurcharan Singh Kulim · 27 Mar 2005

In order for Sri Harimander Sahib Ji to be chosen as one of the new Seven Wonders of the World, WE ALL NEED TO VOTE. Recently I was selected as the UK Ambassador for the Wonder of World Project, which means I'm promoting the New Seven Wonders of The World Project in the UK.-----Bhai Harbans Lal------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- I am rather amused and would challenge who chose the gentleman who resides in Texas as the UK representative?Are there any Sikhs in UK who can vouch they voted or chose an american citizen to represent the UK Sikhs? Are there NO Sikhs to represent the UK Sikh view?I am sure we can represent our own views.Harmander Singh can do that very artriculately. Can Mr Harbans Lal ji also tell us who then was the american sikh representative,or was he representing BOTH?That is a little selfish is it not ?Or is this representative of the Punjab/Punjabi/Akali/SGPC/Congress/BJP ............da Kursi da kissa? Is Bhai Harbans Lal in league with Bibi Kiranjot Kaur and the SGPC mandli and was expected to carry out a rapid coup detat, and whitewash the UK/abroad based Sikhs into believing they have voted to choose in favour of the site being a World heritage?Or is there a greater unseen conspiracy involving the national state powers?Bhai sahib seems very keen on pushing this thriough veryu quickly. If the above is the case then it explains the poor manner and process the case was prepared, and the sneaky manner it was being rushed through ..... Can Hrabans Lal also tell us who is representing Malaysia, Singapore, Australia,Thailand, and Sikhs from Canada and other countries?OR IS HE AGAIN REPRESENTING ALL THESE COUNTRIES HIMSELF???Now , now, now...we want to know the names of the representatives.Who was representing Indian Sikhs? The interesting point and observation is how a sehajdhari Sikh has been nominated to represent the at least 70,000 thousand Khalsa in UK(plus the 500,000 sikhs in UK) I am not even asking why Bhai sahib has not chosen the path to amritpaan.Many have asked that before me.So I shall not wade into that arena yet again.That is his persoanl choice.Some have said that he is not even a sehajdhari, but intent on bringing the independent Sikh religion closer to hinduism. Who chose bhai sahib to represent the Sikhs in this ?Bibi Kiranjot Kaur?If indeed it was Bibi Kiranjot Kaur,that then explains why, what and who.... and the whole fiasco of this application-that should have been a non starter anyway in the first place.I shall not even waste my time over the dossier. Bhai sahib may have chosen the path of sehajdhari, which according to his understanding is an ongoing path....with the pooran Gursikh and khalsa roop NOT in sight at all.I can also bear to have no qualms with that. But should a sehajdhari be then even deciding upon the status of the Harimander sahib- when the SGPC has vetoed their right to elections and a role in the supreme religious matters of the Panth? Bhai Harbans lal may go on presenting his papers,there may be some who will buy their worth, when theory is compared to practice....karni atte kathni wich zameen asmaan da farak.... but his being on the committee of decison making of such an important dharmik issue will be signalling a wrong message to the Sikhs who have shed their required articles of faith; and also a very significant signal to the Indian Government,i.e. appoint a few more sehajdharis and the SRM of the Panth will be changed. ans Sikhs will differ no more from the hindu rashter. There are more serious suggestions emerging now.The SGPC did not even consult the Sikh masses and Sikh societies.They are quick to beg for monies from the Sikhs abroad, but very reluctant to allow the Sikhs living abroad to have any say in the SGPC.Very strange one sided democratic process at work. If Sikhs abroad are NOT allowed any say in the SGPC..should Sikhs abroad listen to SGPC opr seek any direction from SGPC at all in the affairs of Sikhi in their own lands.In fact for many Sikhs, 'abroad' is no longer a foreign country, it is the country of their birth.SGPC is based in a foreign country for many of them.Should they be then listening and taking heed from a foreign based organisation like SGPC? Being connected to Harimander sahib does NOT mean being connected to the SGPC, and taking orders from SGPC (Ltd company now, of badal) Gurcharan Singh Kulim

Re: heritage status of darbar sahib

Son of Guru Granth Maharaj · 27 Mar 2005

be ready for it will definitely coming soon!!!!!!!!!!! just like you know how they say ready or not here I come!!!!!!!

Re: heritage status of darbar sahib

abc singh · 28 Mar 2005

The Illusion of World Heritage Status www.panthic.org Recent Developements on the Sri Harimandar Sahib-UNESCO matter Amritsar (KP) – For the past years, the so-called ’Parliament of the Sikhs’, Shiromani Gurdwara Parbandak Committee (SGPC) has been working with the UNESCO to make Sri Harimandar Sahib a place of world heritage. Such a status would mean that the heart of Sikhi would be enlisted in a cultural and natural heritage protocol maintained by the UNESCO. This means mass-tourism, international attention and financial benefits particularly for the city of Amritsar, but also Punjab in general. However, there is a catch! The World Heritage list contains names of around 730 sites in 125 countries, 26 of them in India. If Sri Harimandar Sahib is given the World Heritage Status (WHS), it will be the next site to be under the protection and management of the Government of India. For the past 80 years, the management of the complex has been the responsibility of the Shiromani Committee. What lies behind the codes of ’primary responsibility with the state’ is unclear. Even the SGPC operates within the structure of the Provincial Government, according to the Sikh Gurdwaras Act of 1925. Would the enlistment of Sri Harimandar Sahib in the World Heritage list have any impact on the internal management of Sikh Gurdwaras at all? Only the experts of Gurdwara legislation could answar this question, and there seems to be little agreement amongst them. Keeping in mind the fairly recent conflicts between the Sikh nation and the Indian state, one would conclude negatively about the whole issue. Seemingly unaware of the tensions between the state and the Sikh community, the SGPC submitted a dossier to UNESCO for inclusion of Sri Harimandar Sahib in the heritage list, through the Indian Government last year in February. In has been reported that the committee used Rs 20 lakh to get the dossier prepared by a private company. Surprisingly, the SGPC-leaders Giani Joginder Singh Vedanti, Bibi Jagir Kaur and Sukhdev Singh Bhaur made a statement months later in November 2004 saying that they did not read the dossier! And now various Sikh intellectuals and political factions have raised issues about the contents of the 500-page long dossier. In February 2005, the committee stalled the UNESCO proceedings on the matter and formed a panel to review the dossier. No firm reports about the asessments made by this panel have come out so far. However, there is a feeling in Sikh circles that scholars have found several anomalies. Scholars are unanimous that WHS would mean that the Sikh heritage would be preserved in a better way. Meanwhile, there is a debate whether the inclusion will enhance the chances of interference by the Indian Government or its security agencies in the management of Sri Harimandar Sahib. Panthic factions have made comments that non-Sikhs will get charge of Sikh shrines. However, those who support the WHS, argue that it would mean that it will be given greater security and immunity, as the state would not be allowed to send in police forces inside the Gurwara complex according to UNESCO conventions. In recent weeks, the SGPC leadership has tried to calm Sikh sentiments down saying that it will not tolerate any interference of UNESCO or the government in its administration and maryada of Sri Harimandar Sahib and might withdraw the case for seeking world heritage status if that is needed. Meanwhile speaking in a press conference on March 24, Bibi Kiranjot Kaur had reportedly said that comments made by the UK-based advisory to Akaal Takht, Dr Jasdev Singh Rai were incorrect. She claimed that under the rules of UNESCO, the management of Sri Harimandar Sahib would remain in the hands of the Shiromani Committee. After a shocking report that came out on March 23 from Ms J. Okahashi, a senior official of UNESCO, which confirmed that after according the world heritage status to Sri Harimandar Sahib, the primary responsibility of its management and protection would be with the Indian state, the SGPC leadership said that it would consider withdrawing the dossier. Meanwhile on Thursday, a statement released by the Press Information Bureau, under the Government of India said that Indian Minister of Information & Broadcasting and Culture, S. Jaipal Reddy had commented upon this issue in Lok Sabha. He said that the Archaeological Survey of India had submitted a proposal to the World Heritage Committee for inscription of world heritage status on Sri Harimandar Sahib. The heritage status of Sri Harimandar Sahib is very much in a state of illusion. The recent developments show the lack of communication and understanding between the SGPC, representatives of various Sikh socities and the Indian state. SGPC has been working for the welfare of the community, but without being fully aware of the sentiments of Sikhs, and neglecting the delicacy of this issue. http://panthic.org/news/131/ARTICLE/1168/2005-03-27.html?sid=98133a7d52f4c4c64ed2e34a928f284f