Re: Why only Hinduism and Islam mentioned in Gurbani?
sarjitsinghkhalsa · 14 Mar 2005
hundu is not a religion it is tradition hold together
Re: Why only Hinduism and Islam mentioned in Gurbani?
Kulbir Singh · 14 Mar 2005
Gurbani has mentioned Islam, Hindusism, Buddhism and Jainism but has not mentioned Judaism and Christianity. It would be worthy of mentioning here that Bhai Gurdas jee has mentioned Jews and Christians in his baani and Siri Guru Nanak Dev jee Maharaaj must have met them when he travelled in his four udaasis but Guru Sahib has deliberately omitted any reference to them. In my humble here are some points related to this:
1) Since Bhai Gurdas jee has mentioned Jews and Christians in his baani one cannot say that Guru Sahib had not heard of them. Our Guru Sahib know about the whole universe and about past, present and future. So this is not even an option that Guru Sahib had not heard of them.
2) Guru Sahib mentioned Islam and we should note that the basic philosophy of all three Katebi (there are four katebs – Koran, Anjeel i.e. Bible, Torah and Old Testament) religions is same. The mention of Islam has covered all of them.
3) Guru Sahib mentioned only those religions which were significant in the next world. It seems like the Sidhas were the most significant and spiritually elevated people after the Bhagti Maarag Bhagats like Bhagat Kabir jee and Bhagat Naamdev jee. It may seem like in this world, Christianity and Judaism are very significant but perhaps in the next world, they are nothing at all. That’s why they have not been mentioned in Gurbani.
4) Guru Sahib had harshest words for Jains because of their atheist nature and nonsense rituals. Guru Sahib calls them “Sirr Khuthai Shaitaani” i.e. Extreme Devils.
5) Guru Sahib diyaan Guru Sahib hee jaanan. We can only speculate.
Daas,
Kulbir Singh
Re: Why only Hinduism and Islam mentioned in Gurbani?
Harnek Singh · 14 Sep 2005
Veer Kulbir Singh,
You said above that Gurbani mentions Buddhism, but I haven't been able to find any specific Gurbani quotes on Buddhism. Could you please find and post them here?
I'm researching various other paths and want to see what Guru Ji said about Buddhism.
Re: Why only Hinduism and Islam mentioned in Gurbani?
Harjas Kaur · 14 Sep 2005
[quote]You said above that Gurbani mentions Buddhism, but I haven't been able to find any specific Gurbani quotes on Buddhism. Could you please find and post them here?[/quote]
aakhahi vayd paath puraan.
The Vedas and the Puraanas speak.
aakhahi parhay karahi vakhi-aan.
The scholars speak and lecture.
aakhahi barmay aakhahi ind.
Brahma speaks, Indra speaks.
aakhahi gopee tai govind.
The Gopis and Krishna speak.
aakhahi eesar aakhahi siDh.
Shiva speaks, the Siddhas speak.
aakhahi kaytay keetay buDh.
The many created Buddhas speak. -SGGS p.5/6
Not only are buddhas mentioned in Gurbani, but Buddhist tradition teaches Guru Nanak Devji's earlier incarnation was the legendary Indian mystic Guru Padmasambhava who first introduced Buddhism from India to Tibet. To Tibetan Buddhist's Guru Nanak Devji is revered as a root Guru of the Nyingma lineage. Interestingly, because buddhas and gurus are depicted as clean-shaven, Guru Padmasambhava is usually shown wearing beard. He is also said to have taught the monks martial arts. If this is true, Gatka is the basis for all karate.
http://www.sikhspectrum.com/062002/tibet.htm
http://www.sikhphilosophy.net/sikhphilosophy/interfaith-dialogues/670-guru-nanak-tibbet.html
[img]http://pema.free.fr/images/padmah1.gif[/img]
Guru Padmasambhava
[%sig%]
Re: Why only Hinduism and Islam mentioned in Gurbani?
The Khalsa Fauj · 14 Sep 2005
Gurbani does mention these religions. Ktaib is 4 books. Including bible and the jewish book.
Re: Why only Hinduism and Islam mentioned in Gurbani?
Harnek Singh · 15 Sep 2005
Siddharath said:
"Excellent. That is what we need more of in this phorum. Another expert on Hinduism. Nice going Sarjit Singh."
Actually, it is true that Hinuism is not a religion, even Hindus admit to this. The term hindu is an umbrella-term which refers to people in the geographic location of what is now India.
Hinduism is a collection of very different pagan & ritualistic practices, most which have no founder or scripture. Some of the practices that come under the term Hinuism are fundamentally contradictory to one another, e.g. some are atheist practices, other believe in millions of Gods, others believe in one God, etc etc.
Re: Why only Hinduism and Islam mentioned in Gurbani?
Harnek Singh · 15 Sep 2005
It seems to me that when Guru Sahib mentioned Islam, it was short for Islam, Judaism and Christianity. All these faith come from the same roots (i.e. Moses) and share the idea that their scripture lays down rules which they must follow.
In complete contrast to this, when Guru Shaib refers to Hindus, Guru Sahib is referring to Hinduism, Jainism, Buddhism, etc., which are more internally focussed paths which require meditation and various internally focussed practices.
Guru Nanak's statment that he is neither Hindu nor Muslim is a complete and utter rejection of all these faiths.
Instead, Guru nanak brought down the true way to get to God, which is Naam.
Re: Why only Hinduism and Islam mentioned in Gurbani?
Harnek Singh · 16 Sep 2005
khalistani Jee, you are very much mistaken in your understanding of "Hindu Dharam" - there is no such entity, it is a colelctive term for a wide range of conflictign practices. Therefore, by saying that "Hindu Dharam" is a beautiful Dharam, you may be referring to parts of it which other Hindus completely reject as cruel and blasphemous.
The caste system is strongly put forward by the brahmins throughout India. It is an extremely cruel way to control the masses.
The only good thing that seems to pop out from the "Hindu" practices were the handful of Bhagats who rejected Hindu mythology and focussed their minds on the universal God. They were the true Bhagats of God, far above the likes of Devi & Devtai such as Krishna.
These Bhagats reached SachKhand after receiving Amrit-Naam from Guru Sahib. Their status is very high indeed, but they were not Hindus, by their own admission.
Re: Why only Hinduism and Islam mentioned in Gurbani?
Harjas Kaur · 16 Sep 2005
[quote]Also, Harjas Kaur, why is a BUddhist incarnation of Guru Sahib so acceptable to us??? How is this any different from the claims that Guru sahib is an Avtar of Vishnu??? There is no need to read into these stories and much less to try and tie "Gatka" with Eastern Marital Arts, which are quite clearly superior to the Gatka forms we see today.[/quote]
Why would the respect other religions show our Guruji be unacceptable to us?
This is not the same as political Hindutva extremists trying to eradicate Sikh independance by making Sikhi a sect of Hinduism. This is just sharing the reality that other religions have respect for Guruji. Buddhists consider him a great Guru and sant. Why is that offensive? If it was important to know Guruji's past lives it would be in Gurbani. Maybe he has given martial arts to the world, who knows? Buddhists credit him out of respect. I though it was interesting.
Do you really believe Gatka is inferior as a martial art? Maybe the reason is that eastern martial artists spend lifetimes of dedication to their arts rather than any supposed inferiority of style. How many Singhs do you know spend a lifetime dedicating themselves to Gatka as a professional style? I imagine no one had more superior technique than Guru Gobind Singhji. No one!
I also imagine that Khalsa could do amazing things. They did after all defeat the Mughal empire. If you see Sikh shastars today, they seem to be of very poor craftsmnanship. If you see Mughal era and modern Muslim swords, they are amazing! Do you really think the Sikhs won the victories they did by practising inferior martial arts and using inferior equipment? I think stuff has been allowed to deteriorate.
For example, kirpans today are not even made from fighting quality metals. They certainly display no craftsmanship, detail, balance or love of the weapon. But that's just my opinion. I for one think maybe they should. The only thing that makes a samurai sword exeptional is that makers of samurai swords put exceptional love into their weapons. If we put that kind of love into our shastars and our gatka, the whole world would notice. If we really loved and honored our shastars, the ones we crafted would be world-class. The only inferiority is our half-heartedness. Are we the Khalsa fauj that we should be?
[img]http://www.clanleslietrust.org/pics/swd1.jpg[/img]
[img]http://arabiannights.ca/images/dagger1a.jpg[/img][img]http://www.joyyang.com/Special/mztp/images/0/image028.jpg[/img][img]http://www.thecityreview.com/mughal3.gif[/img][img]http://www.tribuneindia.com/2002/20021228/pun1.jpg[/img]
[%sig%]
Re: Why only Hinduism and Islam mentioned in Gurbani?
Harjas Kaur · 22 Sep 2005
[quote]In any event, your argument that these is no underlying threat from the Buddhist view of Guru Sahib being an incarnation is plain naïve.[/quote]
Perhaps. But if Sikhi is the Truth, then truth is it's own perfect defense and there can't be any threat against it. As far as I know Buddhists aren't murdering Sikhs or trying to change the words and history of Babaji like Hindutva fanatics. They do however make yearly pilgramages to Darbar Sahib to show respect.
Guru Nanak Devji traveled around the world. That some people still remember and respect him is a blessing. What have we to be offended and threatened by? They are Buddhists they do not have to understand Sikhi and can believe what they want. Obviously they don't have Guruji. And Guruji said nothing about incarnations so either its untrue or unimportant. But whatever happened to "our" tolerance and protection of other peoples faiths? I thought it was beautiful that people of other religion actually have this respect for our Guruji.
[%sig%]