Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Gurdwara BANS Mona Marriages!

Gurdwara BANS Mona Marriages!

news · 14 Mar 2005

Gurdwara ban on short-hair marriage http://www.telegraphindia.com/1050314/asp/jamshedpur/story_4490455.asp PARVINDER BHATIA Jamshedpur, March 13: Buoyed by the success of the ban imposed on jeans-clad women from entering the Gurdwara premises, the Central Gurdwara Prabhandhak Committee (CGPC) here has decided to ban Sikhs with trimmed hair from getting married at gurdwaras. According to CGPC officials, the step has been taken to uphold the religious customs of the community. They said the decision was taken after consulting senior members of the community. CGPC has written to the heads of 23 Gurdwara prabandhak committees in the city to implement the decision. It has also warned the committees of strict action if they were found flouting the orders. "The holy books have some directives on hair in our religion but it is sad that people, especially the youths, are shaving their beards and heads and disowning the sacred beliefs. It is essential to create an awareness among them," said Sardar Shailendar Singh, a senior official of the CGPC. Members, men or women, with trimmed hair will not be allowed to perform "Anand Kharaj" (a religious marriage ceremony) on the Gurdwara premises. Senior CGPC vice-president Harbhajan Singh said the decision would work as a pressure tactic on youths so that they will learn to respect their hair. "Hair is the identity of a Sikh but it is sad that trimming of hair has become a sort of fashion among youths. We have to make them realise the importance of our beliefs. The ban will also serve an eye opener for parents," he said. Singh, who is also the president of Sonari Gurdwara Prabhandhak Committee said the Gurdwaras have already started implementing the decision. However, the decision taken by the central body is set to snowball into a controversy as some members have started voicing their protest. "The decision is unjustified. At a time when other religions are becoming liberal, how can the religious heads of our community be so rigid? We would protest the decision," said Avatar Singh Nagi, a resident of Baridih. However, Sardar Shailendra Singh, president of CGPC, said only a small section of people are protesting the decision and they are ready to face any type of challenge.

Re: Gurdwara BANS Mona Marriages!

Question · 14 Mar 2005

Great news, just wanted to know where is Central Gurdwara Prabhandhak Committee (CGPC) based ?

Re: Gurdwara BANS Mona Marriages!

Sohagani · 14 Mar 2005

It's about time.

Re: Gurdwara BANS Mona Marriages!

@zero · 14 Mar 2005

having checked the link on article seems to be based in calcutta.

Re: Gurdwara BANS Mona Marriages!

Kulbir Singh · 14 Mar 2005

Wonderful news. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: Gurdwara BANS Mona Marriages!

Jagdish singh CA · 14 Mar 2005

Nonsikhs marriages......... Guru jee gave wonderful Amritvela this morning (march14th) and seeing this article makes my day...............

Re: Gurdwara BANS Mona Marriages!

s. singh · 14 Mar 2005

great news!!

Re: Gurdwara BANS Mona Marriages!

Jarnail Singh gyani "Arshi" · 14 Mar 2005

a lot of wailings and protests will be heard..from various quarters with imposing titles like Dr. Sahab, Prof sahab etc that this will drive away 'sikhs", "reduce sikhs numbers" etc etc etc...but i say kudos to the brave parbhandaks who took this stand as per Sikh rehat maryada...about time too....at first it was just a "mona SIKH descendants" who wanted to carry our anand karajs in Gurdwaras..then it progressed to NON-SIKHS as well...here and there a few of these Non_Sikhs tried to wishy washy things by "becoming part time sikhs" by taking "Japji Sahib Panj paurree AMRIT ???"..and there were Granthis and Parbhandaks doing all this for money sake..one Secretary of a local gurdwara even got hold of a Guru Granth Ji sahib Bir at his home to perform such Amrit chhakking ceremonies and anand karajs at his home as the gurdwaras banned them..His "excuse"..oh Sikhi is LIBERAL, Manas ki Jaat , Na Ko Beri nahi Begana etc etc etc we must LOVE all... ??? WHAT A WARPED SENSE OF GURMATT...Another Teacher Sahab Ji.(sect follower whose sect will be kept anonymous as this Forum has disallowed it..but i will just call it "D") also went this way...but he had no choice as his own son-in-law was MONA and this Mona SIL was the one used by him to "transport" Guru Ji here and there ( SO MUCH for "respect" these people allegedly have for GURU JI)... AT one time it was MANDATORY for the Granthi Ji performing the Anand Karaj to make sure BOTH were AMRITDHAREE.....then this was reduced to a mere ritual of just ASKING IF the Bride and groom were AMRITDHAREE and IF NOT, then PLEASE become Amrtidharee as sooon as possible.....THEN even this ASKING was regarded as an INSULT and STOPPED ( MOST of the Grooms had FRESHLY TRIMMED BEARDS but insisted on carrying three foot sri sahibs !!!)...once a very rich groom created a huge fuss when he removed his starched pugg from his head due to sweating !!! right in the gurdwara....the Granthi stopped the Kirtan and walked out....BUT Another Kirtani jatha ( Nanaksari of all people) sat straight down and carried out the anand karaj for a hefty fee !! ( these people also allegedly LOVE the GURU JI sooooMUCH...) So lets hope things improve....they seem to be moving in the right direction.. jarnail Singh

Re: Gurdwara BANS Mona Marriages!

ms · 14 Mar 2005

i dont think it is right that they are basically being forced...as sikhs we are supposed to have respect for everyone so whats wrong with mona's i feel liek sometimes we are putting out an all out war against monays. even when i go to the gurdwara there are all these people telling me DONT CUT YOUR HAIR ANY MORE, WEAR A DASTAR, WEAR YOUR KAKKARS, i cant do it till im ready for it...but it isnt right that people should be forced i understand that kids need to realize what the hair means to us but this way just isnt the way...they should be taught why we keep the hair and people who have sacrificed to keep their hair...people should be out there explaining things like Ardas, i never knew what the words in ardas meant until i got a translating Nitnem book, i think kids just need an eye opener thats more understanding to them Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh

Re: Gurdwara BANS Mona Marriages!

Gurpreet Singh · 14 Mar 2005

In sri Dasam Guru di granth, guru gobind singh ji says nisani sikhi ki panj harf asat so to be a sikh you must have all 5 kakkars. WHy would a non-sikh want a sikh wedding?

Re: Gurdwara BANS Mona Marriages!

MKaur · 14 Mar 2005

When I started learning more about Sikhi and went to a few weddings around that time (im still learning) I always thought in my head that...wow all these people come here infront of Guru Sahib ji all dressed up and looking sharp for what? What is the point of dressing up infront of your Guru. I always thought that its become like a ritual. Which bride has the nicest lenga. Who's jewellery looked better. How the other girls hair was done. Was her lipstick matching her lenga? oh and not to mention...the monay munday that wear a red dastaar in the morning with a foot long KIRPAN in their hands and then a few hours later are clean shaven and drunk at the celebration party? It just seems like people are forgetting about the real meaning of a Sikh anand karaj. I just recently learned of the deep meaning behind the BaNi that is read during the wedding. It is really deep stuff and to most couples today IT MEANS NOTHING. As soon as the anand karaj are done, people are up and about running around in the divaan hall putting haaRs on the bride n groom and giving them money anddd in my opinion what has become of most Sikh anand karajs today is ridiculous. This step that the Sonari Gurdwara Prabhandhak has taken is GREEAAAT! It gives a sense of HOPE. A Hope to uphold the significance of our Sikh anand karaj.

Re: Gurdwara BANS Mona Marriages!

sahajdhari · 14 Mar 2005

you guys got one mona here saying that CPGC did a great job :D

Re: Gurdwara BANS Mona Marriages!

etka · 15 Mar 2005

another monah ion the same boat as sahajdhari....... u can't use guru ji...

Re: Gurdwara BANS Mona Marriages!

Lakhvir Singh · 15 Mar 2005

WaheguruJi Ka Khalsa. WaheguruJi Ki Fateh. Sometime last year, a Namdhari family booked the hall at a local Nairobi Gurudwara for a wedding. But when the time grew nearer to the day, the Gurudwara committee realised their error that they had allowed the hall to be hired out to a family that would conduct the marriage rites in the Namdhari tradition, which would be a clear mockery of the Sikh Rehat Maryada. Upon the withdrawal of the permission, the Namdhari family picked up a storm and even treatened to sue the Gurudwara committee. Even when the committee apologised that it was their mistake and that we were sorry about it, the Namdhari family was up in arms. The committee's decision, and that of the Sikh sangat, was final and they stuck to it. The threats to sue never materialised. Now there is a sign placed in the Gurudwara that no marriages would take place in the premises unless it was conformed to the Sikh Rehat Maryada. It was good to see that those people who 'locked out' their Gurus and followed their own matt, were in turn 'locked out' of the Guru's house which would no longer tolerate an insult to the house of Nanak. Banning such issues from the house of Nanak are indeed important, just like it was for the Guru to lock out the Masands from further representing the Guru. Of course the Masands took offence. It will be nothing new now when those that mock the institution of Nanak are also forbidden to lay claim to anything that they themselves reject to follow - the instructions of the Guru. WaheguruJi Ka Khalsa. WaheguruJi Ki Fateh.

Re: Gurdwara BANS Mona Marriages!

Premi · 15 Mar 2005

Maybe this so-called CGPC should be doing some parchar to gring those youth into Sikhi. That is were they seriously lack in doing good. They take all these decisions that are very easy to implement, but don't do the hard work of doing parchaar in there own homes to there own kids who for the most part are monas. I am fully for the decision, but what are the ramifications? Those that are confused is this not just one more step to alienate them from Sikhi? I mean todays everyday gurdwaras are not centres of parchar rather they are just places that have good singing, degh and langar. The granthis or prabadakhs can't motivate or swade the sangat to gursikhi. I mean do you see them holding youth classes? Youth camps?Bringing youth on the commitee's? Helping youth in the schools who are being ridiculed by Indians for there turbans? Tryig to show the Mona's the greatness of Sikhi and Kesh? Those kids need guidance and sangat. These commitee guys are just worried about there image and Kursee. Not all of these monas are stupid drunkards like you are making them out to be.They are learning like everyone else and need the chance to learn. Having important functions at the Gurdwara makes a connection inside you that holds and brings you back there. Which then translates into them becoming more and more and more closer to Sikhi.It could take many lives to do so but you have to start somewhere. If we look back at our lives or previous lives many of us were very similar to the monas, but those times we went to the gurdwara had an impact on out Karms which brought us into this "Sikhi Gift of Life to end anymore lives", whether we realize it or not, evertime we go to the gurdwara it brings us closer to God. I don't know I am not sure if I agree with it or not. There are so many angles to look at. We want to follow the Maryada but at the same time we do not want to alienate the most vulnerable within the Panth. I mean these guys are going to start going to churches, Mandirs, etc, etc. What a waste that we could not bring them into Sikhi? With everything we have? Premi

Re: Gurdwara BANS Mona Marriages!

Singh · 15 Mar 2005

Waheguru, so the gap deepens, when will people see sence.

Re: Gurdwara BANS Mona Marriages!

singh@to · 15 Mar 2005

******************** I mean these guys are going to start going to churches, Mandirs, etc, etc. What a waste that we could not bring them into Sikhi? With everything we have?*********************** quality matters not quantity...

Re: Gurdwara BANS Mona Marriages!

RK · 15 Mar 2005

I agree that it is important to do parchaar to introduce people to sikhi, but how is going against the puraatan maryada of Gurmat of only amritdharees able to perform the anand karaj and making a mockery out of this pavitr occasion doing parchaar? I mean, by going through this marriage, even though the bride usually looks like shes a hindu then a SIkh, and the guy wears a pug even though he has like half an inch of dhaari, does it all of a sudden inspire them to become Sikhs? I dont think so.

Re: Gurdwara BANS Mona Marriages!

craziness · 15 Mar 2005

all i can say is if dat is implemented all over the world that would mean the next step would probably lead to monnai dont come gurdwara. Most gurdwarey would then be lock and key shut down cos its monnai where charawah and funds come from that keep gurdwaras running. instead of making a point from sikhi view people r more stuck up themselves, what about positiveness out of it like educating people at weddings what anand karaj means? slide show thingy? helping to educate youth with resources? what does it answer by banning? jack squat! i think the only loosers to win out of this as usual are the ones who quietly squeek in the corner " we want quality over quantity". wheres your quality when its needed then the panth is dieing out what you doing to save it?

Re: Gurdwara BANS Mona Marriages!

jss · 15 Mar 2005

dear "craziness" you are taking things to an extreme.... nowhere has anyone said monas can't go to gurdwara....they are simply attemtping to rectify a problem that has become prevelant in india and abroad...people making a joke of anand karaj... i don't judge people for being monas...but i do ask them this "why go through anand karaj when you don't know what it means and nor do you care"....it's an insult to guru ji... your logic of moving to the next step to not letting them come to gurdwaras is totally flawed...lets' not make this rule more than it is... using your logic..i could say ...if we let monas have anand karaj..then we'll have to start monas take amrit withouth them having to follow rehit...that is utter nonsense.....

Re: Gurdwara BANS Mona Marriages!

ji · 23 Mar 2005

the real issue is gianis like sant singh maskeen are very rare. the organised priesthood in sikhi is failing to bring more people to the sikh fold. Having tried to bring punjabis closer to sikhi through prophecies, dates, etc they look at the grim reality around them. Their parchar methods need to be changed and contain genuine sikh flavour. Education is the key. banning will bring division. Besides its not like it will ever happen in punjab anyway when most of punjab are monnai. Its blown out to big than the issue is. education, love, respect and help make sikhs.