Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Sikh Fundraising-using alcohol & meat!!!

Sikh Fundraising-using alcohol & meat!!!

Singh · 16 Mar 2005

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh!! Please can all read the below discussion I have been having with so-called community leaders, the attitude they portray towards Sikhi is very worrying; --------------------------------------- Mr Ranger’s email: Dear All, I am pleased to inform you that the Slough Sikh School is organising a function on the 18th March 2005 at Haveli Banqueting Hall Slough. Details attached. Telephone Numbers for cotact are also there. Please support the school and also at the same time enjoy the evening with good food and people Tickets are only £30 each. Regards, Rami Ranger ---- My reply: Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh! Why couldnt your think tank devise a more honourable way of collecting monies for a Sikh School? Unless I am missing the plot a Sikh School will teach Gurmat. Guru Nanak Dev Ji taught us to raise & earn monies in an honest manner (krit kamaie). If we are going to raise money in a banqueting hall surrounded by alcohol & animal carcasses then we are not abiding by Guru Nanak Dev Ji's hukam. Monies raised in an anti Gurmat way cannot be used to promote Gurmat, this is hypocrisy. Is this the best example you can set to the younger generation? Please rethink your strategy before offending other Sikhs. Personally, as a young Sikh, I would rather wait for the donations to slowly trickle in than collect large sums of dirty cash. ---- Mr Ranger’s reply: Lets see how you will serve the Sikh community. By attacking fellow Sikhs you are making the job of anti Sikhs easier. We lost an empire because Sikhs betrayed Sikhs. Is your job to support Sikhs or discredit them? I hope you achieve something good with your actions. As far as I am concerned I sustained employment of 2000 people in Britain in line with our Guru's teachings of hard work and honest living. Do visit my websites below for an education. Fanatic are tarnishing our religion and I hope you are not one of those who hate all those who do not act according to narrow interpretation of Sikh religion. Regards, Rami Ranger Sun Oil Ltd Sun House, 428 Long Drive Greenford, Middlesex UB6 8UH ---- Mr Gidar’s reply: Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh I have read you mail to Rami Ranger. Let me clarify some issues. This school is going to be a VA school which will have 20% other faith children. We are not doing anything dishonest, and it is the choice of the people to drink alcohol if they so please. Please can you let me know how you distinguish between the money we give to the gurdawara, some people who own off-licences and restaurants which have meat on the menu donate. I have not seen that money being identified and rejected. Sikhism is about equality and choice and respect for all. Please can you tell me more about Guru Nanak Dev Ji's hukam ( for your kind information Guru Nanak Dev Ji did not make any HUKAMS, he preached)and where it says we cannot raise money for a building to be used as a Sikh School by having a function. Extremism of any kind is dangerous whether they be Muslims or Sikhs. I can assure we will not be pouring alcohol into people’s mouths and putting meat in the dall. The function is not being held in a gurdawara. Kind regards Ravi Gidar ---- My reply: Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji ki Fateh! You are blatantly organising an event that is against Sikhi. How more obvious can it be? If you cant see it then you are blind. Its a sorry state of affairs to have people like yourself who are clueless promoting your own blend of Sikhism where everything goes. The School is focused on promoting Sikhi, you are so far from understanding what this means its amasing. Please tell me one sakhi where Guruji said that your kind of function is acceptable. You really have no respect for Guruji and the status Gur Nanak Dev Ji has for Sikhs. Sikhi is based upon Gurmat and for Sikhs this is hukam, there is no two ways about it, its not what you & your other egoist friends want to do. You are creating the anti sikh environment within your function, this is as good as pouring alcohol in peoples mouths. You are very quick to use terms such as extremist. What I have highlighted is the basics of Sikhi, hopefully this is what you will be teaching in the Sikh School. That means that every pupil in this school will become an extremist. If you wish them to be taught wierd Sikhi that you seem to practice then its best to remove "Sikh" from the name and open a normal state school. Reflect on your actions. Promote a Sikh School by actions that promote Guru Nanak Dev Ji. ---- Mr Gidar’s reply: These days it has become fashionable to apply two litmus tests to the definition of a Sikh. One is that of political correctness. We have all been to Sikh gatherings where, if your views fall even a hair short of an independent Sikh homeland, you are quickly branded "anti-Sikh." This also applies to meat and alcohol. I don't want to argue with you guys but let us help in the way we think is best. If you disagree with me then don't participate but don't give complaints about being anti - sikh etc. Ravi Gidar ---- Mr Ranger’s reply: Dear Ravi, Please do not waste your time with a "Bad Mechanic who will always blame his tools" I can easily tell you that this man is neither educated nor successful in his life and being a fanatic is the only credit to his fame. Please let him at least feel superior even though he is not. Regards, Rami Ranger ---- My reply: Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh! This is the final resort for you to treat me as some little kid and fob me off. I have presented and arguement with substance & truth and its time for you to reflect on what exactly you are promoting. If you cannot understand the damage you will cause then I urge you to stop involving yourself in Sikh Activities as it is beyond your limited capacity. ---- Dr Singh-Raud’s reply: Sat-Siri-Akal Veer Jees, Firstly please lets not get personal in these issues. However I would like to say that there are a number of ways one can help raise money. As far it is not in an illegal manner, is not stained, and is respectful of others views, in my opinion, it is fine. Since there is a wide spectrum of Sikhs, we have to watch that one group does not see itself as the only voice. It is a given fact for example that there are those Khalsa that eat meat (Jhatka)and those that don't eat meat. There is a whole debate on issues such as these, which scholars such as Sundeep Singh Brar(USA) have had an active input. Hence at the Oxford and Cambridge Sikh Alumni Association Dinner we had both vegetarian and meat dishes to cater for both. It was not a religious function, but rather a funding raising academic function for Sikh Scholars and parents of Sikh youths who wanted to support the organisation. The dangers of imposing one groups views on others is that we walk away from Guru Nanak Dev Jee's philosophy of tolerance. Gurfateh Harkirtan Dr H. Singh-Raud JP BSc(Hons), MRSC, CChem, GIBiol, PGCE, MCollP, MEd(Cantab), PhD, FRSA ---- My reply: Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh! Please answer me one question: Will you collect monies for a Gurdwara in the same manner? There is no difference in this School and a Gurdwara. In fact the potential of the School is massive. "The dangers of imposing one groups views on others is that we walk away from Guru Nanak Dev Jee's philosophy of tolerance". This point seems to be directed to my stance on the situation, its seems a nice way for you to label me as an Extremist again. Sikhi ethics is based upon morals rather than what the law sees as legal. This programme is morally wrong. You talk about Guruji's message of tolerence, is that all Guruji taught? Why do you selectively forget the remaining phylosophy? ---- Dr Singh-Raud’s reply: At no point was there any intention to label any one. Just because one takes a stance does not make anyone an extremist. "Yesterday's terrorists are today's freedom fighters". With regards to collection for a gurdwara, it is known that funds are just collected from Sikhs, just as much as this school is not just for the Sikhs but infact for 80% of the Sikhs and 20% other minorities. Veer Jee you say there is no difference between this school and a gurdwara, I beg to differ. The gurdwara is a place of worship (spritual). Finally are you saying that Sikhs are not allowed to eat meat? Gurfateh Harkirtan Dr H. Singh-Raud JP BSc(Hons), MRSC, CChem, GIBiol, PGCE, MCollP, MEd(Cantab), PhD, FRSA ---- My reply: Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh! Will this school not be promoting what is taught in Sadh Sangat in a Gurdwara? If not them please remove Sikh from the school's title. All things that relate to Sikhi should be treated with the same reasoning. Gurmat is not confirmed to a Gurdwara. Sikhs practice in their daily lives and need to remember what they stand for. If you want to attach Sikh to this School then you stick to Gurmat. Its simple. Meat is not served in langar, Akal Takht has issued a hukamnamma on this. Those who wish to disregard are acting out their our manmat. If you wish to feed people meat & alcohol for something promoting "Sikhi" then its hypocritical. Dont pick and choose we must regard Guruji bachan as hukam. And yes meat is not allowed in Sikhi. Everyone knows thats no matter what our learned scholars may think. ---- Mr Ranger’s reply: Dear Harkirtan, Do Sikhs want to move with the times like the rest of the world or do we want to go back to the days when we were fighting the Mughals? The next attack on Sikhs will come from the technological front and if we are not acting and behaving like modern and progressive Sikhs then help us God. Regards, Rami Ranger ---- Dr Singh-Raud’s reply: Dear Rami Veer Jee, I don't understand the root of your question. Sikhs can wear turbans, be amritari and be extremely progressive. Gurfateh Harkirtan Dr H. Singh-Raud JP BSc(Hons), MRSC, CChem, GIBiol, PGCE, MCollP, MEd(Cantab), PhD, FRSA ---- My reply: Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh! Just the answer I expected from Mr Ranger. For you to tarnish our history like this shows the respect you have for Guruji and the Puratan Sikhs WHO died for the Sikh Religion & for Sikh Ethics, they didnt die for you to throw parties. We owe them what we are today, the least we can do is to teach our history, the morals and above all Gurbani to the next generation. However you are instead teaching the next generation to turn their backs to their Forefathers and their sacrifices & principles. Is this the progression you wish to promote? How exactly does my suggestion of fund raising by better means (such as Kirtan Darbars and Sports Events) not make us modern & progressive Sikhs? ---- Mr Ranger’s reply: We also need to be of progressive thinking. I do not see Sikh Prime Minister or the Chief of Army Amrit Dhari. Regards, Rami Ranger Sun Oil Ltd Sun House, 428 Long Drive Greenford, Middlesex UB6 8UH ---- My reply: Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh! This discussion continues to amaze me and shows the bad attitude you have towards Sikhi, Mr Ranger. You have no value for Guruji. Just to reminder you, but I guess you dont even care, Guru Gobind Singh Ji requested the Panj Pyare himself for Amrit. For you to feel amrit affects a person's progressive thinking is a show of your narrow mindedness. The more I look into your thinking I feel more worried about what you actually stand for.

Re: Sikh Fundraising-using alcohol & meat!!!

Rocky · 16 Mar 2005

Rami Rangar ? Is he by any chance linked to Pritam Ranger ? I don't know why they even bother linking themselves to Sikh events, they are political/corporate entertainers. All the do is organise big dinner and dances for the Asian Conservatives or Hindu socieities. What are they doing raising money for the Sikh school. Morever, why are they doing such an anti Sikh way of raising money. It's pretty sick and upsetting that people are using the label Sikh to spread their manmat. They will be pouring alcohol and meat down people throats in the name of raising funds for a Sikh school. How disgusting!! They will invite various VIPs to attend this dinner/dance. All they will get is the wrong message about our Guru's teachings.

Re: Sikh Fundraising-using alcohol & meat!!!

jugroop singh · 17 Mar 2005

VahiGuruJiKaKhalsa,VahiGuruJiKiFateh! Sadh Sangat Jio, The Slough Sikh School is a GurMat project - it will be excellent for Slough and Sikhs in general. However the majority of the Trust members, who i know personally, do not have the kind of GurSikhi Jeevan and Sochni which would make them understand why this should not be happening. They have good intentions at heart but do not understand why this is so inappropriate. What i am writing sounds harsh but it is the truth. Such situations as this are sad; however, please let us not think 'we will not support this project and will not donate'. i intend to continue supporting the Trust when it does things positively and not supporting the Trust when i think it is doing something negatively - as in this case. Sadly, we must accept that many people who attempt to do Seva do not have unflingching faith in Siree Guru Sahib Ji - to the point where they worry about 'how will we raise all the money'. It is this which leads to 'compromises' such as this. VahiGuruJiKaKhalsa,VahiGuruJiKiFateh!

Re: Sikh Fundraising-using alcohol & meat!!!

Mani · 17 Mar 2005

Do we really think that we have the backing of our Guru when we raise money in this inapproriate way? Are we not all part of the anti Gurmat act of serving alcohol and meat if we still support this trust? What good can we get out of the school if the foundations are weak? Sorry for the pessamistic view, but I feel that the money raised in this way must not be linked with a Gurmat school. It is a paap!!

Re: Sikh Fundraising-using alcohol & meat!!!

Rocky · 17 Mar 2005

I agree. What good are we really doing for the Sikh Kaum if we compromise our Sikhi inorder to raise money. We might as well serve alcohol and meat in the school!!!!!! Will the TRUST start thinking along these lines when they want to increase pupil numbers.

Re: Sikh Fundraising-using alcohol & meat!!!

GurSa Singh · 18 Mar 2005

Jagroop Singh Ji, This compromise is dangerous. How cheap is our Sikhi? Can we throw it away in order to raise a few thousand pounds? Can we put a price on what the Gurus, Saheeds and Puratan Sikhs have done for us? For some people it is that easy to throw away their Sikhi. There is no "majboori" in serving alcohol or meat, it is a personal preference, people do this out of choice. Will Guru Gobind Singh approve of booze being served in the name of Sikh progression? I don't think so. So what right do we have to allow this to happen!! What's the point of a SIKH school if we can't even follow our Guru's Hukam properly? These funds will not benefit the Sikh Kaum, we will reap what we sow!

Re: Sikh Fundraising-using alcohol & meat!!!

jugroop singh · 18 Mar 2005

VahiGuruJiKaKhalsa,VahiGuruJiKiFateh! Veer Gursa Singh Ji, i couldn't agree more with EVERYTHING you say. It is just sad that the majority of the people who get to have the say about how money will or will not be raised regarding Panthik Projects' do not have this level of thinking. i wish they did but they don't. Please understand that i too am totally opposed to money being raised via a 'dead animal dinner and alcohol' scenario. It would have been nice if the restaurant said that for that evening, they would only serve vegetarian dishes and serve non-alocholic drinks... To be honest, i am not sure whether money made from food/drinks will go to the Trust or whether just money 'pledged' during the evening by individuals will go to the Trust. VahiGuruJiKaKhalsa,VahiGuruJiKiFateh!

Re: Sikh Fundraising-using alcohol & meat!!!

Young Brit Singh · 19 Mar 2005

Bhai Jugroop Singh Ji, Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh! Whether funds are raised with money raised from food/drinks or pledges the fact of the matter is it is un-Sikh function. We can all make a party morally acceptable by labeling it as a fund raising event. Guru Nanak built Kartarpur from nothing, with Akal Purakh's grace a town was formed. Guru Sahib didn't need to do anything which was wrong. Similarly all Gurus were able to form institutes from nothing through moral means. In the last century various famous Sants/Sewadars formed Gurdwaras/Hospitals etc in the middle of jungles by moral means. Not one person needed to have a fund raising event serving meat & alcohol. Having a fund raising event serving alcohol and meat is regressive not progessive. It's a bad sign of what Sikhs actually now stand for in the 21st century. Veerji, as an amritdhari who has pledged his life to Guruji's Hukam, I would advise you to be careful about the sangat you associate with. The sangat should take us towards Guruji not further away. Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh!

Re: Sikh Fundraising-using alcohol & meat!!!

Jugroop Singh · 20 Mar 2005

VahiGuruJiKaKhalsa,VahiGuruJiKiFateh! Bhai 'Young Brit Singh' Ji, i think that i've caused a misunderstanding here. That's because eventhough i agree with you 110%, it seems that you think i don't. Veer Ji, i am sorry - let me clarify. - i do not think that any such 'evenings' are needed to raise money for Siree Guru Sahib Ji's cause. Complete Visah/Bharosa/Faith in Siree Guru Sahib Ji would make all maya come begging at the door of this project. - Personally, i would only feel that this event was respecting GurMat if this restaurant ALWAYS served vegetarian, non-alcoholic products and was a 100% non-smoking environment.Then i would say that them raising money via pledges would not be a bad thing...i am not sure if this is strictly GurMat so if others have thoughts please share. - Also, i can't bear the thought of someone thinking i've taken Amrit when i haven't been belssed with such a gift, so i must tell you that i have not been given Amrit yet. i hope that Siree Guru Sahib Ji always continues to bless me with Sangat that takes me close to Him...and the day i am blessed with The Gift of Gifts. Reflecting back over the posts i made, perhaps the comments that i made sounded as though i was 'chummy' with the Trust. The fact is that some Naujawan based in Slough have been contributing to the project, over the last several years, when we have felt it is progressing appropriately and we have distanced ourselves when we have felt it is progressing innappropriately. As to the above event, for the record, i spoke to the Trust Chairman over the phone a few days ago and told him that: - There was no need for this event despite the fact that money is 'taking longer to come-in' than anticipated - The situation is being discussed on forums - Ultimately, this event is anti-GurMat and the situation is simply sad. VahiGuruJiKaKhalsa,VahiGuruJiKiFateh!

Re: Sikh Fundraising-using alcohol & meat!!!

jugroop singh · 20 Mar 2005

Bhai 'Young Brit Singh' Ji, VahiGuruJiKaKhalsa,VahiGuruJiKiFateh! Bhai Tav Prasad Singh Ji, i think that i've caused a misunderstanding here. That's because eventhough i agree with you 110%, it seems that you think i don't. Veer Ji, i am sorry - let me clarify. - i do not think that any such 'evenings' are needed to raise money for Siree Guru Sahib Ji's cause. Complete Visah/Bharosa/Faith in Siree Guru Sahib Ji would make all maya come begging at the door of this project. - Personally, i would only feel that this event was respecting GurMat if this restaurant ALWAYS served vegetarian, non-alcoholic products and was a 100% non-smoking environment.Then i would say that them raising money via pledges would not be a bad thing...i am not sure if this is strictly GurMat so if others have thoughts please share. - Also, i can't bear the thought of someone thinking i've taken Amrit when i haven't been belssed with such a gift, so i must tell you that i have not been given Amrit yet. i hope that Siree Guru Sahib Ji always continues to bless me with Sangat that takes me close to Him...and the day i am blessed with The Gift of Gifts. Reflecting back over the posts i made, perhaps the comments that i made sounded as though i was 'chummy' with the Trust. The fact is that some Naujawan based in Slough have been contributing to the project, over the last several years, when we have felt it is progressing appropriately and we have distanced ourselves when we have felt it is progressing innappropriately. As to the above event, for the record, i spoke to the Trust Chairman over the phone a few days ago and told him that: - There was no need for this event despite the fact that money is 'taking longer to come-in' than anticipated - The situation is being discussed on forums - Ultimately, this event is anti-GurMat and the situation is simply sad. VahiGuruJiKaKhalsa,VahiGuruJiKiFateh!