Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Worldly Law and Divine Law

Worldly Law and Divine Law

Kulbir Singh · 17 Mar 2005

If law punishes an offender for a crime that is also a sin according to Gurmat, does this offender still have an outstanding punishment from Vaheguru? In other words, say for example, a person commits murder and is sent to jail for 25 years. This person comes out of jail after 12-13 years, on bail. Does this punishment he got by law eliminate the need for divine punishment or will he still be held accountable for this punishment in the next world by Vaheguru or Dharam Rai? Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: Worldly Law and Divine Law

Premi · 17 Mar 2005

I would say yes. It may seem as if they are 2 seperate laws, but it is God on the inside sending those thought waves and doing the Hisaab of Karams. But the wordly punishement may not be enough to pay back the crime, in which case more would be needed. For ex: Someone who does bad work or somthing now may get fired and can't find a job, which is a financial punishement Premi

Re: Worldly Law and Divine Law

kar kirpaa sabh rayN thheevaa · 17 Mar 2005

Bhai Kulbir Singh ji, I know you ask questions to make manmukhs like me think and to engage our brains. I know you already have the answers. Thuhaaday vich einee nimarthaa kithahu aaee veerjee This is what I think... Since it is in Vaaheguroo's hukam whether the person who commits murder is found guilty or not guilty, then Vaaheguroo's hukam would advise about whether their punishment is a punishment valued in dargah. Sometimes, if somebody committed a crime, and they are sentenced to jail - the jail time might not be a punishment that is valued in dargah, because that worldly punishment may be paying for a different past karma. Likewise, it may not be accepted in dargah, because it is not harsh as the crime deserves. vaaheguroo jee kaa khaalsa vaaheguroo jee kee fatheh!!!! [%sig%]

Re: Worldly Law and Divine Law

Kulwinder Singh · 17 Mar 2005

Dear Vir Kulbir Singh Ji Crime and Sin are completely different things, both are different in definitions and in fundamentals, as they are different in nature they have different magnitude, in some strange case where it can be said that they both agree or have common ground on the physical level, the Scope of Sin is very different from Crime so the Punishment is given in one does not cover the other. As the punishment is based on one understanding it does not cover the other. The question of outstanding punishment from GOD is bit unfair, As God does not punish normally as he is the Most Kind ( do not forget he forgive humans day and night for unlimited sins), Humans punish themselves by digging deep holes for themselves. Although occasionally he does intervene to put some "Kala" according to his will. Although Sin is more serious then Crime in General, the punishment for the repenting being could be much lighter for sin in The Grace of God, only if the human being ask for forgiveness in true meaning. That is my understanding, if it make sense fine otherwise ignore it. Your Maha Moorakh, Kulwinder Singh [%sig%]

Re: Worldly Law and Divine Law

ms · 18 Mar 2005

I dont think its Vaheguru's hukam whether someone kills someone or not...thats obviously Haumai. Hukam would be doing Guru Jee's seva and much other things. Anything that Vaheguru would not want us to do wouldnt be included in His Hukam to us. That is clearly Haumai or our selfwill.

Re: Worldly Law and Divine Law

Bundha · 18 Mar 2005

ms, Everything is in wahegurus hukum, everthing. 'Hukmai unthar sab koe, bahar hukum naa koey...." Everthing is according to wahegurus will, this is a very simple statment but very difficult to understand and only people with high avasta can/may understand it. btw Kulbir Ji I agree with you. Sin and crime are separate. Crime is manmade thing and is punished by men, sin is punished (or forgiven) by waheguru. [%sig%]

Re: Worldly Law and Divine Law

Kulbir Singh · 18 Mar 2005

Worldly law is man-made whereas Divine law as the name implies is Vaheguru’s law. Let us first take a general look at the worldly law: In my opinion, worldly law is based on Kanoon-e-shahadat. Even though the purpose of law is to provide justice, it does not always provide justice. The decision or verdict is based on Shahadat i.e. proof or witness. In essence this is Kanoon-e-Shahadat i.e. it is based on witness or some tangible proof. If a person commits a murder, he or she can be punished only if there is a proof against that person. If there is no proof, that person can walk free, without getting punished. Everyone is innocent until proven guilty. If we really look at Kanoon-e-Shahadat, the purpose of this law is twofold. Firstly, worldly law is to protect the society from offenders and secondly it is to seek revenge from the offender. Another purpose of the worldly law is to deter society from committing such offences. To fulfil the purpose of protecting the society from offenders, they are placed in seclusion, away from society, in jails. The victims naturally nurture the feelings of rage, revenge and anger against the offender. When the offender is punished, it helps to soothe the victims' minds filled with these feelings. Now let us take a look at the Kanoon of Sacha Munsif (Justice) Vaheguru. Vaheguru has in place the law of karma. Through this law of Karma, good deeds are rewarded and bad deeds beget similar reactions from nature and as such the offender feels the effect of his wrongdoing. In my humble opinion, the purpose of Vaheguru’s law is not to seek revenge or to protect the society from the offender. The purpose of Vaheguru is to bring the offender to realise his mistake and do paschataap (regretting) for his mistake. Until the offender realises his mistake and stops the repetition of it, the punishment goes on as opposed to the worldly law, whose punishment stops after sometime. As soon as the offender realises and with pure mind seeks pardon from Vaheguru, Vaheguru provides the person with means to clean himself of the dirt incurred from the offence. As the result of punishment by worldly law i.e. jail term or fine etc. it seldom makes the offender a better person but Vaheguru’s punishment is designed in such a way that eventually one gets purified through it. Another difference between the two laws is the definition of the offence. What is an offence in the eyes of the law may not be an offence in the eyes of Vaheguru and vice-versa. Committing adultery and fornication is not an offence under the worldly law but these are severe offences under the law of Vaheguru. The acts of fornication and adultery can have very severe retributions. What they covet leads them to years of misery and sorrow. As an example, say a person commits a murder under the influence of rage and gets caught by police. He is tried in the court of law for second degree murder. While in the jail, he reflects upon what he did and is very regretful of what he has done. He really wants a second chance in life. But law is going to ignore this aspect of his mental condition and will sentence him according to the precedence of law. And rightfully too. No one in the world really knows if he is regretting from his heart and even if he is regretting, it won’t satisfy the victims who have been hurt with this murder e.g. the dead persons family etc. To satisfy them, the law has to take its course. On the other hand, Vaheguru knows what’s going on in one’s heart. If this person really regrets from heart and wants a second chance, he will get it. The purpose of Vaheguru’s punishment is to reform a person and not revenge. If a person gets reformed before the punishment, he does not need get punishment from Vaheguru. If this person uses the detergent of Vaheguru’s Naam and Gurbani to clean his mann of the dirt incurred from killing a person, this person does not need any punishment. If a person does many murders but then regrets his mistake and japps Naam, all his sins get burned away like wood gets burned in fire: GHOR DUKHIYANG, ANIK HATIYANG, JANAM DARIDARNG, MAHA BIKHIYADNG || MITANT SAGAL, SIMRANT HAR NAAM NANAK JAISE PAAVAK KAASTH BHASMANG KAROT ||’ (If one has very acute and severe sorrows, has committed many murders, his life is pure poverty and he has several other problems; all this can be burned or erased like wood burns in fire, if he japps Naam.) There are several other pankitis that prove that through Naam, one can clear all one’s sins. The only condition is that one regrets committing the mistake from heart and makes an earnest effort to not repeat it. What is expressed above is per my meagre understanding of Gurbani and Gurmat. I could be wrong. Koi Daava-e-Haqq nahi. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: Worldly Law and Divine Law

. · 18 Mar 2005

well suppose yoiu kill someone u go in jail 10 years according to world law u payed with ur time and this served legal justice. but someone told me if u kill in sikhi you have to pay with 7 lifetimes with some bad disease. i think legal law in west is based on christianity level. law of middle east would be different where they cvhop your hands if you steal.

Re: Worldly Law and Divine Law

Gulzar Singh · 20 Mar 2005

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa, Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh What about killing people for the sake of sikhi? E.g. the singhs who killed Indira Ghandi did great seva for the panth, no? Worldly law would see this as a crime. But Divine law would not see this as a paap, would it? So I guess there would be cases in which worldly law sees certain actions as serious crimes whereas our rehit and devine law would see these actions as very honourable, e.g. becoming a shaheed, beating someone who does nindiya of our Gurus or of Guru Granth Sahib Ji etc... Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa, Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh

Re: Worldly Law and Divine Law

kaur · 20 Mar 2005

>> As the result of punishment by worldly law i.e. jail term or fine etc. it seldom makes the offender a better person << Is this fact or opinion?

Re: Worldly Law and Divine Law

. · 21 Mar 2005

this is s of topic sowwie, but its affecting a lot of areas prisons in england at least, are places where criminals get more heavily connected, build their names up, and when they come out they know no one will give them a job and end up under some gangsters wing or reoffend to get a roof over their head. In heavily populated desi areas this is even worse due to drugs epedemic, someone comes out of jail they cant get a job again and end up working for dangerous people. Its a bad circle. There may be seldom cases where people reform, but at what price? what prospects do they have in front of them? If the person cannot get a job what will they do after? its a dark tunnel. should have labour camps, to deter people from committing crime and 4 years should mean 4 years and not 2 counting the nights. labour camps run in conjunction with firms, in exchange for money for prisons to run itself releasing burden on tax payers money. So then a prison will become known as a labour camp hopefully dettering people from offending. I still think its unfair for someone to kill or rape and then just sit inside a jail, eating, moping around. If someone killed your family member would you want the offender to sit in a jail cosy and warm with a roof? or maybe do forced labour work throughout the sentance to serve as a punishment and build some morals int the person if you do that you must pay for it. The rehab centres they have if any, are not enough, what they need to do is evaluate that each criminal gone down heavy once, entering society will not stand a chance in employment. They need to set schemes and community projects up that helps criminals reform into society when they come out, and be able to change their lives and have a chance, perhaps in phases, like working under guided supervision and being monitored, then next step.