Re: Narendra Modi denied US visa because of being responsible for Gujarat riots
Indian Express · 18 Mar 2005
Indian Express
Modi may get another shot in the arm
Harish Dugh
Posted online: Friday, March 18, 2005 at 1539 hours IST
Updated: Friday, March 18, 2005 at 1754 hours IST
The US may well have given Gujarat Chief Minister, the controversial Narendra Modi a stick to beat the secular forces in India by withholding visa and denying him entry.
The near term history is rife with examples of Modi taking advantage of events that are not in his control or were not unleashed by him, for his selfish aggrandisement.
The US has a history of denying visas to those it considers have violated or otherwise acted in a manner predisposed to harm the interests of any particular religious group. It had denied the same to Austria’s Freedom Party leader Joerg Haider who had built up his reputation by espousing hatred against foreigners in the late 1990s. In fact, US had gone further by reducing diplomatic ties with that nation when in response to Chancellor Wolfgang Schuessel forming a government coalition with his party.
Modi’s elevation to the top job in Gujarat, put in place by the BJP bosses with the intention of having a ‘yes’ man in the state, while the local leaders were fighting amongst themselves for power, was leveraged by Modi to such an extent that today there is no one to challenge his suzerainty even at the national level.
The genius of Modi is to recognise opportunities in events that others would think of as dead ends or even pronouncement of political demise. He revels in strife and controversies wherein even angels would fear to tread. US could turn out to be an unwilling but helpless pawn in Modi’s power game.
His role or inaction, in the Gujarat riots in 2002, in which more than 2000 Muslim men, women, and children were massacred actually paved the way for his re-election. That he sat like Nero and fiddled while Gujarat was burning is the least of it. That he leveraged the Godhra train tragedy wherein 58 Ram sevaks were burned allegedly by Muslims, to paint himself the savior of Hindus is again the least that he did. That he was able to fire up the people’s parochial feelings and convert them into rage against other communities was sheer propaganda at its best, or worst, depending on your proclivity. It kept him in power – a man that no one can defy or touch.
Now, after the US visa imbroglio he can again whip up a hate campaign directed against the opposition parties and keep his Gujarat cauldron boiling. It may well keep him in power for the next decade. Here’s how:
Modi has put the ball in the Centre’s court (with a Congress-led UPA government at the helm) virtually forcing them to approach the United States’ government on his behalf for denying him entry. But the Centre will not be able to solve the case in his favour given US intransigence in matters visa.
Since the US is unlikely to listen and the ban on Modi will stay, he may well whip up sectarian passions saying other communities have launched an anti-Hindu campaign by targeting him in the national and international fora.
Considering that he is a self crowned king of Hindus, it won’t take too much of an argument to indicate that Hindus in India are in danger from forces within and outside the borders.
In fact, he has already put in motion a campaign that is saying the US has insulted India by denying him visa. He has equated India with himself and at one fell stroke destroyed all and every last vestige of the foundation that a free republic stands on. It reminds one of the argument that Indira is India and India is Indira, referring to the omnipresent and omniscience of former Prime Minister Indira Gandhi at the height of Emergency.
The final step would be to raise the pitch of politics in Gujarat and if possible in the northern states. They will be sowing the wind to reap a whirlwind.
That violence is bound to happen, a la the L.K. Advani-led Rath Yatra not so long ago, is a foregone conclusion. But disorder will strengthen his case even further. After all it would prove that Modi is in danger, no matter what.
As a byplay, Modi, who is increasingly in danger of being unseated by Gujarat partymen, will get a shot in the arm and he will be able to beat the opposition within the ranks of the BJP into submission.
Modi is master tactician who has martialled his forces like a general readying for battle. With the enemy identified he is looking to unleash the dogs of war and try to fuse the difference between the earthly founding of Indian republic and things spiritual.
Modi’s intention is to sneak his agenda on the national platform in through the exit door, since India has shown in the recent elections that it is not really interested in a sectarian, hate mongering personalities or their programmes.
Re: Narendra Modi denied US visa because of being responsible for Gujarat riots
Indo-Asian News Service · 18 Mar 2005
US visa denial follows anti-Modi campaign:
[World News]: New York, March 18 : The denial of a US visa to Chief Minister Narendra Modi Friday follows a relentless campaign by a coalition of American and Indian American religious leaders and rights activists who accused him of persecuting religion minorities in Gujarat.
Barely a month after the coalition demanded that Modi be stopped from entering the US for his "campaign of extremism", the chief minister has indeed been denied the visa.
Joesph K. Grieboski, president of the International Institute on Religion and Public Policy who was the prime mover of a petition to Secretary of State Condoleezza Rice, had told IANS earlier: "Under the International Religious Freedom Act (IRFA) of 1998, the US can deny visas to those involved in religious persecution."
Incidentally, the denial of a visa to Modi came close on the heels of Rice's visit to India.
Asked if he believed that given the strong bilateral relations between the US and India, Washington would actually heed his request, Grieboski had said: "That is precisely the reason why it is more possible now to do so."
Modi was scheduled to visit the US in the last week of March to attend the annual convention of the Asian American Hotel Owners Association (AAHOA) at Fort Lauderdale in Florida March 24.
Hindu groups across the US began a counter-campaign soon after the coalition lined up several liberal and Christian, Muslim and Sikh religious groups in support of its petition.
Local Indian American newspapers took out full-page advertisements from Modi's supporters, mainly sympathisers of the Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) and Hindu groups, in Modi's favour. One advertisement described him as the "lion of Gujarat."
But the coalition had written to Rice "to encourage the denial of a visa or, should he already have a visa, bar entrance into the country".
"Since taking office as chief minister of Gujarat Oct 7, 2001, Modi has pursued a campaign of extremism targeting religious minorities in Gujarat."
"The most egregious violation of religious freedom engaged by Modi - the orchestrated attacks in Gujarat in 2002 in which more than 2,000 Muslims were killed during government condoned riots - unfortunately falls outside the consideration of the International Religious Freedom Act (IRFA). The aftermath of the riots, however, has demonstrated that Modi and his BJP government are not in compliance with the spirit and standards of IRFA."
"The International Religious Freedom Act of 1998 was established as a tool to advance freedom of religion globally on the one hand and to punish those individuals and regimes responsible for reprehensible acts of persecution and discrimination on the other," Grieboski said.
The Council on American Islamic Relations (CAIR), which claims to be the largest advocacy group for Muslims in the US, also sent out an "Action Alert" urging members to send letters to the State Department to block Modi's entry into the US.
Those opposed to Modi's entry into the US formed a group, the Coalition Against Genocide (CAG), to press for action by the AAHOA and by US government officials.
The AAHOA, consisting predominantly of entrepreneurs of Gujarati origin, had stood by its invitation saying Modi was their guest and it was unlikely to change. With the convention less than a week away the association will have to alter its programme.
Chris Mathews, the popular host of the current affairs show "Hardball", who was scheduled to be among the star speakers, pulled out because of some prior commitments but it was clear to many that he was doing so because of the controversy around Modi. Such speakers are typically paid thousands of dollars as a speaking fee.
--Indo-Asian News Service
Re: Narendra Modi denied US visa because of being responsible for Gujarat riots
Indo-Asian News Service · 18 Mar 2005
Rights groups hail visa denial to Modi:
[India News]: Ahmedabad, March 18 : Human rights groups and activists welcomed Friday the US move to deny visa to Gujarat Chief Minister Narendra Modi over the 2002 sectarian violence in the state.
"It is a step in the right direction. We were asking for it for a long time," Father Cedric Prakash of Prashant, a rights advocacy group, told IANS.
The city-based group was part of organisations that sought to create people's awareness on human rights issues in Gujarat ahead of Modi's visit to the US that was to begin Saturday.
"This is also for the first time the US government is not indulging in double-talk," he added.
The US government refused to grant diplomatic visa to Modi citing his government's handling of the sectarian violence in the state in 2002 that claimed at least 1,000 lives.
Dwarikanath Rath, convenor of the Movement for Secular Democracy, said: "Secular activists in the state are pleasantly surprised.
"(US President) George W. Bush could do what (British Prime Minister) Tony Blair could not do," he said.
Modi had visited Britain last year amid protests and demsotrations by human rights activists.
Rath added that the reasons cited by the US, including suppression of religious freedom, were well considered.
Mukhtar Mohammed, a lawyer fighting cases related to communal violence, said the US move was a victory for human rights organisations.
He, however, did not praise the US Government for the decision. "Any right-minded government would have acted that way."
Added Samon C. Christian, joint secretary of the All India Christian Council: "It is a victory for the secular world. We highly appreciate and congratulate the US government for taking a wise and strong decision."
--Indo-Asian News Service
Re: Narendra Modi denied US visa because of being responsible for Gujarat riots
Indo-Asian News Service · 18 Mar 2005
An insult for Modi, not for India: Congress:
[India News]: Ahmedabad, March 18 : The opposition Congress in Gujarat Friday dismissed Chief Minister Narendra Modi's criticism of the denial of a US visa to him and said it was certainly not an insult to India but was "an individual matter".
The US revoked Modi's tourist visa and denied him a diplomatic visa, citing suppression of religious freedom in his state. Modi termed the US move as an insult not only to the 50 million people of Gujarat but also to India.
But Arjun Modhvadia, Congress member and opposition leader in the state assembly, told reporters: "We do not see it as an insult of people. It is an individual matter. It is Modi's old habit to label his insult as Gujarat's insult."
"While I personally believe that a chief minister must be issued visa, Modi was denied permission to visit the US because of his government's partial handling of the communal violence in the state in 2002," he said.
Modhvadia clarified that the Congress-led government at the centre had taken no objection to Modi's US visit. "Even Modi has acknowledged as much," he said.
"There were protests in the US against Modi's proposed visit. Though he was going to attend a function of the Asian American Hotels Owners' Association (AAHOA), a section of the association was opposed to his visit," he said.
"It should be pointed out that Modi took pride so far in equating his policies with those of (US President) George W. Bush. What does he have to say about that now?" Modhvadia asked.
Speaking in New Delhi, senior Congress leader and union Textile Minister Shankarsinh Vaghela, who hails from Gujarat, supported the US decision.
"I welcome the decision. Such violent people (as Modi) must not be given visa, even if they happen to be holding constitutional posts," he said.
"The people of Gujarat too are repenting their decision to re-elect him," he added.
--Indo-Asian News Service
Re: Narendra Modi denied US visa because of being responsible for Gujarat riots
Bhopinder singh · 22 Mar 2005
Guilt by any other name
By M.J. Akbar
So is Narendra Modi a hero then, thanks to George Bush and Condoleezza Rice? Of the many reasons for taking a position on the Gujarat chief minister and his adoring fans in the American Asian Motel Owners Association, who have been seeking his charismatic presence on their motel-soil for perhaps two years now, this has to be silliest. The relevant point is not whether Narendra Modi has become a hero. The point to note is that he is already a hero to those who hero-worship him.
It did not need Bush or Rice to persuade the motel owners, many of them fellow Gujaratis, to adore Modi or make him their star guest. They did not want Atal Behari Vajpayee or Lal Krishna Advani; and certainly not Dr Manmohan Singh or Sonia Gandhi. They wanted Narendra Modi and no one but him, which is why they were prepared to wait.
He became their hero when he supervised a pogrom against the Muslims of Gujarat after the Godhra incident three years ago. It was the kind of "revenge" that pleased the heart of hate-mongers. Since then Narendra Modi's problem has been to check similar heroism without losing his fan base.
Narendra Modi is a politician with both ambition and a strategy, which itself is unusual. All, well, most, politicians are ambitious, but rather than developing a strategy they wait for stars to bring them luck and joy.
Modi believes that the infamous riots have provided him with a cushion-vote of some 15 million Indians. This, apparently, is his estimate of the core "anti-Muslim" vote in India. He is building other vote blocs on that to become the most popular leader of his party and by virtue of that a future prime minister of India.
His strategy is cool and logical. Having taken command of the venom vote he does not need to spew venom anymore. He can now concentrate on proving that he is an excellent administrator, which he is.
His reputation as an effective chief minister is growing steadily. Moreover, his palm does not itch in the manner of, say, Pramod Mahajan, a contemporary with similar ambitions if less strategy. As politicians go, Modi is among the least corruptible. Money is not his weakness.
So there you are: a hero to minority haters, competent, honest, ambitious. It is the kind of biodata that can take you places. There are enough middle-roaders who would be happy to overlook the riots in exchange for competence and personal probity.
Liberals may loathe Modi, but they would be foolish to ignore him or his potential. The principal yardstick of public life is not justice, but success. Success tends to drown out accountability, while failure invites quick punishment. Modi's success in the assembly elections, when he brought the BJP back to life from a comatose state, exonerated his mischief.
This was not the mischief behind a curtain. This was not corruption ferreted out by either fearless or sleazy journalism. This was not a crime that needed too much investigation.
It was a macabre, brazen use of state power for political gain, in front of the world's television cameras and print media. It was a crime whose evidence lies in dozens of photo exhibitions, on Internet sites and archives, and most painfully, in the minds of a generation of young people who watched helplessly as a government abetted hooligans gone berserk, torching homes and killing their loved ones. If there is another definition of genocide I would be grateful for some education.
We in India did very little about Modi. His leader Vajpayee made some noises, which spluttered away and exposed the impotence of a prime minister. Nor have his adversaries done anything in particular.
The UPA government that succeeded the BJP-led coalition has not even bothered to worry about those riots, except to the extent that a Laloo Yadav wanted to derive his own quota of political mileage from Godhra.
It will soon be a year since it came to power, but the Congress, always ready to expend serious heavy firepower against Mulayam Singh Yadav, who destroyed the BJP in UP and effectively prevented its return to power, has not mounted any effective political campaign against Modi. To be fair, no one else has either.
Congress and non-BJP chief ministers gladly shake Modi's hand at ministerial conferences, while media lines up to seek the favours that he can offer from office. (By the way, notch up another Modi success: he has eliminated a great deal of corruption within media.) His party, which saved him from its prime minister, does not dare interfere with the rising trajectory of his star. It is sometimes whispered that BJP president Advani would like to remove Modi, but they remain mere whispers.
In any case, Advani, who retains a persistent memory of Delhi in the 1984 riots gets amnesia about Ahmedabad in 2002. If India did not bother, there was no reason why the rest of the world should. Britain, Switzerland, Australia and Singapore were happy to give Narendra Modi a visa when he asked for it.
It is extraordinary, then, that, quite out of the blue, Washington took a stand. It is of course symbolic. America can only exercise its right to deny a visa to a non-American. Most of us were unaware of the American law that "makes any government official who was responsible for, or directly carried out at any time, particularly severe violations of religious freedom, ineligible for a visa".
America cannot do anything more, because Modi does not need anything more from America. He has no desire for a green card, or even a holiday. If he was interested in the members of the motel association it was because many of them are of Gujarati origin, and their applause would have resonated well among some sections back home.
According to some knee-jerk analysis, this decision could even become counter-productive. Well, so what? Is justice to be weighed on the scales of popularity, or its not-very-distant relative, prejudice? I am certain that extremists and even terrorists often have popular support. That does not make them less culpable. If we make justice conditional, we erode the foundations of civilization and sap the life-energy of democracy.
A psychoanalyst would probably find much more in the sometimes overlapping and sometimes disparate layers of Modi's arguments against the American decision than a columnist.
There is a hint of self-incrimination in the plea that if others who have violated human rights can be permitted to visit America, and even welcomed, why should he be denied a visa?
At other moments, there are suggestions that India's sovereignty has been undermined. Er, not quite. It takes more than a denied visa to undermine our sovereignty. But Narendra Modi does provide one splendid suggestion. Should India refuse a visa to the United States chief of army staff because of the alleged violation of human rights in Iraq?
I don't know about others, but I consider this an absolutely splendid idea. Should Pranab Mukherjee, as our defence minister, lead the campaign to prevent any such visit? That might be over the top, but how about letting this idea loose among all the liberal NGOs and human rights activists whose combined efforts persuaded the United States establishment to stop Modi's visit. After all, the same yardstick must apply.
The evidence for the abuse is visible in hundreds of photographs, and we do not know how much abuse took place with those who were not photographed. There is serious evidence of culpability at the highest levels of the American military.
Jeff Jacoby, writing in the Boston Globe and the International Herald Tribune, says: "In August 2003, when he was commander of the military base at Guantanamo Bay, Major-General Geoffrey Miller visited Baghdad with some advice for US interrogators at Abu Ghraib prison.
As Brigadier-General Janis Karpinski, the military police commander in Iraq, later recalled it, Miller's bottom line was blunt: Abu Ghraib should be 'Gitmoized' - Iraqi detainees should be exposed to the same aggressive techniques being used to extract information from prisoners in Guantanamo. "You have to have full control," Karpinski quoted Miller as saying. There can be 'no mistake about who's in charge. You have to treat these detainees like dogs'."
Treat these detainees like dogs. Any more evidence needed? Here is some from Afghanistan. "A detainee in the 'Salt Pit' - a secret, CIA-funded prison north of Kabul - is stripped naked, dragged across a concrete floor, then chained in a cell and left overnight. By morning he has frozen to death."
What was his crime? "He was probably associated with people who were associated with Al Qaeda," a US official explained. Of course, the American military high command never accepted that they were guilty of what happened under their nose. Neither did Narendra Modi.
VFF leads Sikh community to secure US refusal to Indian CM Narendra Modi
VOICES FOR FREEDOM · 23 Mar 2005
VOICES FOR FREEDOM
18 March 2005
Press Release
VFF leads Sikh community to secure US refusal to Indian Chief Minister Narendra Modi
Washington DC – The US Department of State today refused a diplomatic visa to Indian Chief Minister Narendra Modi for his role in the 'serious violation of religious freedom' during riots in his home state of Gujerat 2 years ago. The Secretary of State Condoleeza Rice following a campaign led by the Institute on Religion and Policy and several organizations and US Congressmen has also withdrawn his tourist and business visas.
Voices For Freedom led the US Sikh community in a signature campaign urging the Department of State to reject Modi's visa under Section 604 of the US International Religious Freedom Act which makes any foreign official who has engaged in "particularly severe violations of religious freedom" inadmissible to the United States.
Within two days, more than twenty Sikh Gurdwaras, including the Sikh Gurdwara of Fremont (CA), San Jose (CA), Sacramento (CA), Stockton (CA), Washington DC, New York, Detroit (MI), Dallas (Tx) endorsed the signature campaign. Other Sikh organizations that supported the campaign were Khalistan Affairs Center (Washington DC), Sikh Youth Of America, Shiromani Akali Dal (Amritsar) and ENSAAF that endorsed the letter to deny Modi the visa. Twenty US Congressmen, led by Joseph Pitts, also supported the signature campaign.
The Department of State's deputy spokesman, Adam Ereli, said in his press briefing today, " The terms for issuing that (diplomatic) visa under U.S. law had not been met, and so we decided not to issue the visa, based on U.S. law and based on findings of fact by the Indian National Human Rights Commission pointing to comprehensive failure on the part of the state government of Gujarat to control persistent violations of rights. We determined that an existing visa that Mr. Modi had -- an existing tourist business visa -- should be revoked under Section 212(a)(2)(G) of the Immigration and Nationality Act, which says that any foreign government official who is responsible for or directly carried out at any time particularly severe violations of religious freedom should not be eligible for a visa."
Voices For Freedom Director, Ranjit Singh, said, "This is the right thing to do. The US State Department has expressed and has defended the rights of the minorities. All such oppressors need to be tried and punished. The original International Religious Freedom Bill only allowed consideration of acts committed in the previous 24 months, it was amended by the Intelligence Reform legislation passed in December 2004 to include violations that occurred at any time"
Yadwinder Singh, President of the American Gurdwara Prabhandak Committee, which represents US Sikh Gurdwaras, said, "This is a victory for human rights groups and organizations. This is a message to Mr. Modi and it should ring loud and clear to other human rights violators in India, such as K.P. Gill, that they cannot get away with what they have done. They are accountable for their actions."
Dr Amarjit, Director Khalistan Affairs Center said, "By denying Narendar Modi entry into the US, a right message has been sent across to Modi and to others like Tytler, Kamalnath, Bhajan Lal, KP Gill, etc., that genociders are not welcome in this land of Liberty. The Indian Government by defending Modi has shown its true colors as well "
Simranjit Singh Mann, President of Akali Dal Amritsar, in a telephonic interview to VFF congratulated the US Sikh community for this unique achievement.
Congressman Pitts said, "This decision tells people still suffering in Gujarat that we believe they all deserve the right to equal treatment under the law and we're willing to stand up to people who deny it to them. And it tells foreign leaders that we will not stand for religious persecution."
Ben Marsh, the resident fellow on South Asia at the Institute for Religion and Policy said, "This ban is against an individual. We are incredibly happy at the action of the US State Department. Other offenders of Human Rights should consider this as a message."
Mr. Modi was to be the chief guest at the 2005 Annual Convention and Trade Show of the Asian American Hotel Owners Association in Fort Lauderdale, FL to be held on March 24-26 and had a scheduled speech at Madison Square Garden on March 20th. The Coalition Against Genocide had planned a demonstration in front of Madison Square Garden, New York on March 20th, if his visit had materialized.
Since October 7, 2001, Mr Modi has pursued a campaign of extremism targeting religious minorities in Gujerat. The most egregious violation of religious freedom under Mr. Modi's stewardship of Gujerat was the orchestrated attacks in Gujerat in 2001 in which more than 2,000 Muslims were killed. The Indian Supreme Court in 2004 stated that trials in Gujerat would never be fairly held due to Mr. Modi's state leadership. Other than the carnage of Muslims during his leadership of Gujerat, Modi made derogatory remarks about Sikhs. He also cancelled the National public holidays of Sikhs and Christians: to mark the birthday of Sikh Guru Nanak Saheb and Good Friday respectively, in the state of Gujerat. He was forced under public pressure to reinstate these public holidays.
Contact: Ranjit Singh:Tel: 001 516-241-6760:Tel: 001 917-821-7368
[%sig%]