Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

DsGMC blamming others ...should take the blame

DsGMC blamming others ...should take the blame

Gurcharan Singh Kulim · 20 Mar 2005

Waheguru JI Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki fateh I am amused with this sudden culture of blame that has arisen from among the officers of the DsGPC. Instead of blaming the non Sikh person,the DsGPC should take the total blame.They authorized and appointed a person who they thought fit enough to do a translation, without really checking anything else.There are I am sure Sikhs who speak many other languages,but the Sikh institutions do not appoint such people based on their merits, but they will appoint someone who they have have expected personal favours from and who may do them favours at a personal level. Such is the corruption among Sikh institutions. The person in question was only doing what he understood.He is a non Punjabi speaker, and he could only do so much when he does not understand the language of the Guru Granth Sahib. Very neatly, the blame has been dropped upon someone else.They had Sikh advisors appointed for years, so did these so called advisors NOT seen anything amiss earlier?What have they been doing?Suddenly the cat seems to have jumped out of the bag...and they want to blame someone , who probably does not even understand to exactly what the words mean in the context of the Gurbani. Even on the net among the many Punjabi speakers it becomes apparent, many have difficulty understanding simple shabads and qoutes.They mix the words of Punjabi language with hindi or even with the hindu religion...!!So what do we expect from a non punjabi translator like this telegu writer.I feel there is something greater that has gone wrong, and they are now looking to deflect the issues and blame the small fish. They are many Sikhs born in the disapora,who are good Punjabi speakers as well as of the languages of their new mother countries.Why are services and sewa not sought from such Sikhs to help in translations of the Guru Granth Sahib?I am sure the SGPC and DsGPC is not blind to this fact, when their leaders go on unnecessary "phorun tours". The DsGMC as well as the SGPC is not interested in these Sikhs of the diaspora, but instead they have looked at paid translators, and hence quite rightly they have reaped the slap they deserve on their cheeks. I will not even be surprised, that there may be something larger of an issue lurking behind the scene, in the manner they are now shouting about punishing the person to hide their own misaapropriation of monies! To the DsGPC and SGPC the diaspora Sikhs are only there for one reason, and ONE reason alone-they are a source of financial tapping.That is as simple as I can put it.The diaspora Sikhs may think otherwise, but that is all you, sirs. If we were to be seen as anything more, dont you think, they will seek to appoint a respresentative from a number of countires where there are substantial Sikh populations on to the SGPC and DsGPC, and tap in the skills and resources we have in the disapora?Esspecially so for translation and developement of preaching Sikhi in the latest techniques. I can see a representative each from Malaysia, Singapore,Thailand,Australia,Fiji,Pacific Region, Canada and USA, UK,Europe, Italy, Kenya/Tanzania and the Middle East enhancing the skills and knowledge pool of the SGPC and DsGPC- this could also mean a uniformed and standard practice of the maryada as well as a quick response to problems faced by Sikhs outside and within India. But, as the DsPGC and SGPC are only interested in the monies from abroad and nothing else, the vast pool of resources we have matters not at all. The diaspora too keeps living in the false hope as if we matter greatly to them...so we live in the hope..........that we can change the issues these Sikh bodies are infested with. That is just a hope, and please let us not blame the telegu writer.

Re: DsGMC blamming others ...should take the blame

S Singh · 21 Mar 2005

I agree whole heartidly with your idea of having representative from Malaysia, Singapore,Thailand,Australia,Fiji,Pacific Region, Canada and USA, UK,Europe, Italy, Kenya/Tanzania and the Middle East on the SGPC and DGPC. It is good to see that the Pakistan GPC have taken representatives from abroad and the only people upset are the SGPC as they wanted their own reps.

Re: DsGMC blamming others ...should take the blame

Jarnail Singh gyani "Arshi" · 22 Mar 2005

kash.... je kar aseenh aapnii peehree hath sota ferna jandeh hundeh taan eh "doosre ko blame" karna na sochdeh. Why should the SGPC and DGPC..and all others ( YES ALL of them) have any interest in bringing aboard "Diaspora reps" ?? as that would DILUTE their POWER..maybe one or two here and there may be brought in to "eye wash"..but SERIOUS REPS..NO WAY...that is just not going to happen. Just look how the Badal Group has been the Primary SABOTAGER of the All India Gurwara Act all these years while hoodwinking the entire Sikh nation that the GOI was NOT giving this. This was the main reason behind the Akali Rejection of Amdekar and his harijan Millions from SIKHI.... EVERYTHING is about RETENTION of their OWN KURSEE...at ALL COSTS...250,000 DEAD SIKHS cannot shake this KURSEE LOVE of Badal/and his cohorts...Baaba SARBJIT SINGH JI BEDI is TELLING the PRESS that HE ATTENDED the RSSS meetings with DAMDAMI TAKSAAL under Baba Thakur Singh..and the REST of the SANT SAMAAJ......but there are still sant followers who want to HOODWINK us into beleiving this is all GOI "PROPOGANDA" to malign the DDT/Thakur Singh Ji etc etc. SO WHO is telling the TRUTH ?? Isnt baba BEDI President of the Sant Samaaj..is he a LIAR or were those who have died LIARS ??...THESE people are also ONLy intersted in the DIASPORA MONEY...nothing else...otherwise there is a lot of Parchaar for these SANTS in PUNJAB itself....no need to come to UK/Canada/USA/etc etc. SAADIAN peehreean heth bahut koorra jammah hai ji.....it is almost impossible to sota pherna there. jarnail Singh