Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Dancing

Dancing

Dancing · 20 Mar 2005

I know its wrong to dance at parties and what not. BUt what about dancing for exercise by yourself . You might say look to other sports for exercising. but dancing is avery simple exercise? Is it wrong?

Re: Dancing

RoopKaur · 21 Mar 2005

Why not practice some gatka paintrey instead?

Re: Dancing

singhji · 21 Mar 2005

why is it wrong to dance at a party, dancing can be seen as a art if u enjoy it and are good at it why not dance at a party

Re: Dancing

Sohagani · 21 Mar 2005

Why not just dance? (but make sure your dancing to the right tune ;)

Re: Dancing

KHALISTANI · 21 Mar 2005

WJKK WJKF doing pentra a few times is excelent exersie. also it helps u in your pentra and shaster vidyia in general. i belive there are tuks in Guru Granth Sahib Ji that are agaisnt dancing but i think i may be taking them out of context Bhull Chuk Mauff WJKK WJKF

Re: Dancing

singhji · 22 Mar 2005

i think u r wrong dere mate@khalistani

Re: Dancing

KHALISTANI · 22 Mar 2005

Why be at a party in the first place. if its a part at someone home where theres no alchohal our anything else that sinh's need to stay away from its understandable but a banquet hall party is no place for a gursikh to be. and i think the tuk is: Nach Nach hasea, chalea sahb roe I'm not sure though Bhull Chuk Mauff WJKK WJKF

Re: Dancing

Tarrandeep Kaur · 22 Mar 2005

nic nic hsih clih sy roie ] nach nach hasehi chalehi sae roe || Those who dance and dance and laugh, shall weep on their ultimate departure [%sig%]

Re: Dancing

Rain drop · 22 Mar 2005

Naach re man Gur ke aage

Re: Dancing

Amritpal Singh · 22 Mar 2005

I agree with Khalistani. Why be at a party in the first place? Next time you are at a party...look around...see what is being done around you. Take notice, and then think to yourself would Guru Gobind Singh Jee fit in here? What would Guru Sahib be doing at this party? CAn you see him their interacting with people and diong the same party things that other ppl are doing? Guru Gobind Singh jee would consider this a waste of time and taking away from this time to do Bhagti. We should avoid all distractions that take us away from Bhagti. Dancing is just a useless thing. Bhagti isnt the easiest thing to do in the world. IN reality its pretty hard. so why would u waste precious time dancing and going to parties? You could spend that time doing sewa or some other spirtually uplifting things.... think about it.

Re: Dancing

amanpreet · 22 Mar 2005

i totally agree. u r right it is just some sort of exercise

Re: Dancing

singhji · 22 Mar 2005

i still disagree on da grounds dat if u go 2 a non alchohol party its ok 2 dance- " Those who dance and dance and laugh, shall weep on their ultimate departure" i think this is a metaphor unless u think that if a sikh laughs they are going against sikhi, fair enough if you feel uneasy dancing dats cool, but i dnt think u can justify its wrong on that thuk.

Re: Dancing

KHALISTANI · 22 Mar 2005

Fine u can go and dance if u really want to. Find a song that doesnt talk about maya or kaam ful stuff or fighting or girls or guys or any of that sutpid stuff. But i garuntee u that your not gonna find that at a party. But why dance when u can do pentra or plain practise gatka. even running on a treadmill is better u can do simran while doing so. dancing even listening to music in my opinion distracts u from your goal is a Sikh. In my opinion it seems very manmukh thing to do. Bhull chuk Mauff WJKK WJKF

Re: Dancing

gaiani · 22 Mar 2005

see its this liberal bs that is eroding Sikh. why do u need to dance is it absolutely imperative that you must dance? Also is there a such thing as non-alcoholic party or are you just abstaining from alcohol? Even if there is no alcohol there is a kaam infused atmosphere. And the biggest question of them all, what would Guru Sahib say, that dancing o.k.?

Re: Dancing

wondering · 22 Mar 2005

yo dancing didnt SAY that it wasnt WRONG to dance at parties. Dancing knows its wrong to dance at parties. Dancing was just asking: You might say look to other sports for exercising. but dancing is avery simple exercise?

Re: Dancing

hm · 23 Mar 2005

hi khalistani i disagree that dancing will make a person lusty. but agree that some forms of dancing and clubbing with opposite genders very much can. how about giddah? punjabi women harmless clapping of hands and one or two moves folk dance. how is that lusty? the bhangra we see today is different to what it was. olden day men would gather on vasakh and do one or two shoulder moves to celebrate a good harvest while women did giddah in their own space. that is not lusty. what is lusty is westernisation, perversion of lyrics, slowing gorafied tones slowing dances down with opposite genders dressed in salwaar kamees. look at salwaar kameez 30 years ago. look at it today, sleeveless, shows curves off. so obviously that will create lust. No one dared sang matiyaar songs in my grandad days. It happened when we move outside punjab, these new western raised singers started singing crap. the bani tuks you talk about need to be studied in depth with the whole page.what kind of dance is being talked about? if we cant dance at all, then why do we feel like going in a body rytham when we at a rensbhai? if we are supposed to drop vasakh traditions then we need to re analyse.

Re: Dancing

Jarnail Singh gyani "Arshi" · 23 Mar 2005

Waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh. Dear Tarandeep kaur Bhen Ji, THAT TUK is to WARN us not to be "TOO HAPPY".... imho..at a BIRTH/wedding/etc people are "so happy" they almost die of happiness...BUT let a person get sick/die/ in the family and they wail horrendously...BUT accordign to GURBANI/GURMATT Both happiness and Sadness are HUKM.....so if one laughs too much...they will surely cry louder..that is just what is warning from guru ji...MODERATION in EVERYTHING. Jarnail Singh

Re: Dancing

Rain drop · 23 Mar 2005

HAR JAN NACHO HAR HAR DHAYE

Re: Dancing

raj karega khalsa · 23 Mar 2005

Nach Nach tapae bohut dukh pavae

Re: Dancing

ji · 23 Mar 2005

ok why do you not post the whole page so we can understand what is being talked about in detail?

Re: Dancing

Dancing · 23 Mar 2005

I was ONLY talkng about DANCING for EXERCISE by MYSELF ALONE. Not any social events. You guys are ridiculous. I JUST WANTED TO KNOW if it was WRONG to DANCE FOR EXERCISE.

Re: Dancing

GURNAM · 24 Mar 2005

I personally think its fine for exercise on your own. Have fun!! (but not too much, as some of the previous posts suggest!!)

Re: Dancing

tinku · 24 Mar 2005

what about the two second happy dance we do when we get excited good news like new baby, relatives comin from overseas, or new car gift etc from mommy dadda?

Re: Dancing

:::::::: · 25 Mar 2005

clapping hands, goots swinging, harmless little gurls playing on swings singing songs is part of life. Even in one of the camps where the children of shaheeds are bought up aplha tv showed they were taught gurmat and wore dastars and some of the girls seen dancing in circles holding each others hands i think they look about 10 11. This can only lead us to believe the gurbani tuks given are specifically reffering to some kind of dance maybe. I would be grateful if the posters would be kind enough to provide the exact page number. bad thoughts arise dependant upon bad things.

Re: Dancing

ya · 25 Mar 2005

i dont know about page number its ang

Re: Dancing

JI · 25 Mar 2005

what will you dance to while "exercising"?

Re: Dancing

:::::::: · 26 Mar 2005

"ya" ji i acknowledge my mistake, may Waheguru, sangat ji, forgive and do kirpa on this maha moorakh i have made a mistake by saying page number. This is an unforesoon insult, sometimes we type in a rush, i apologise whole heartedly to Waheguru first and then to sangat ji. Benti bhai sahib rain drop and raj karega khalsa ji can we have the ang please?

Re: Dancing

etka · 26 Mar 2005

its fun, every1 has a different definition of "fun". i know ppl are gonnac ome up be like simiran is fun, which it is, but.......... think logicaly

Re: Dancing

Gopi · 27 Mar 2005

Why can't you live and let live? If someone wants to dance - their decision. I'm sure Sikhi has room for people to use their own brains - or are we all to be brainwashed automatons.

Re: Dancing

Redwhiteandblue Kaur · 27 Mar 2005

No, dancing for exercise is not wrong. It is an excellent workout that focuses on the most important muscle in your body - your heart. Plus, if done alone, one has the benefit where...it doesn't matter if one looks silly or not. The body doesn't care...as long as it is burning oxygen. For a Sikh (or anyone else, for that matter) to be at his/her strongest, both mentally and physically, regular exercise is mandatory. If you reasearch the writings of exercise physiologists, you will find that they will all agree that the best sort of exercise routine is one that a person can MAINTAIN. Dancing ji, a good form of exercise is one that you will stick with. It is your body and your mind that will experience the benefit from doing so...or the degredation from not doing so.

Re: Dancing

ponderer · 27 Mar 2005

why dance when you can do simran?

Re: Dancing

singh · 28 Mar 2005

"ponderer Date: 03-27-05 14:57 why dance when you can do simran?" the original post is asking if its ok to dance as a means for excercise. why do you assume the original poster does not do simran? nam japoh vand shakoh kirt karoh. naam is one aspect of life. in the old days we would keep fit through kirt karni as it involved labourous work. is there anything wrong in doing simran? excercise and dancing for excercise purpose in the confines of your own home? and btw we are still waiting for the ang of the bani tuks. why has the ang not been put up?