Tragedy smeared all Sikh-Canadians
Bhopinder singh · 21 Mar 2005
Tragedy smeared all Sikh-Canadians
For 20 years my immediate community unfairly bore the cross of innuendo, by T. Sher Singh
Toronto Star -- March 18th, 2005
During the two decades between the horrendous crime and tragedy of the downing of Air-India Flight 182 in 1985 and this week's verdict on the trial of the two accused of the outrage, my beard has gone from jet black to snow white.
Part of it, of course, is due to age, in my case, 55.
Some of the silver undoubtedly stems from the vagaries of the practice of law which, coincidentally, began for me in 1985.
A good portion of it also relates to the tragedy, from watching helplessly from the sidelines as several close friends have struggled with the loss of dear ones — a son and daughter, a spouse, a sister.
And some of the salt, inevitably replacing the pepper, is from watching my immediate community — almost 500,000 Sikh-Canadians — unfairly bear the cross of innuendo and broad brush-strokes.
All because the background and context of the tragedy lies in India, in accusations of dire human rights violations by the Indian government against its Sikh minority and the Khalistani separatist movement spawned as a result.
Yesterday's front-page headlines in one Toronto newspaper unabashedly refer to two "Sikh" militants who were found "Not guilty."
Sikh? True, their religion is Sikh. But this moniker is shared by me and my daughter, 500,000 Sikh-Canadians, and 25 million others around the world, only a handful of whom condone or support either the crime or the criminals, whoever they may be.
But, why not "Khalistani," instead of Sikh, which would make it relevant and accurate?
I have never seen — and thank God for it — Nazis referred to as "Christian" terrorists. We have Palestinian suicide-bombers and we have Israeli raids. IRA militants. But, why Sikh militants?
My daughter was 6 years old in June, 1985.
I was and am a single parent and my primary challenge ever since has been to prevent, or at least lessen, the collateral damage caused by the carelessness of the media.
I remember a Sikh-Canadian friend bringing over a newspaper one day to show me how his 12-year-old had come home one evening, spotted the headlines on an Air-India story, pored over the article and, taking a black marker, slashed a huge X across the page, and inscribed "Lies! Lies! Lies!" across the page. My friend found the page crumpled and thrown in the wastebasket.
I remember meeting with a number of CSIS and RCMP operatives in 1987 to assist them in understanding the basics about Indian and Punjabi politics and their spillover into Canada.
My advice was being sought, free, because neither institution had any Sikh or Indian or Punjabi or South Asian personnel on their staff who were equipped to assist them in the Air-India matter. Imagine, this with respect to a Canadian community a million strong and a century old.
Their question was: "Why does every Sikh household in this country sport the Khalistani flag? See: Here's the separatist symbol! "
I looked at the sample one of them had pulled from a briefcase. It was the saffron triangle flown outside every gurdwara (Sikh church) in the world, and the icon (the Khanda) displayed in homes, on necklaces, and T-shirts, on bumper-stickers ... just like the Christian Cross and the Jewish Star of David.
I explained. Their jaws dropped collectively, as if I had just clarified quantum physics.
They cited huge numbers of separatists in this country and provided the evidence: Tens of thousands of them, maybe even hundreds of thousands, refrained from clipping their beards or doffing their turbans. Are they potential terrorists, they asked?
They were genuinely puzzled when I told them that these were the basic requirements for those who have taken on the full discipline of the Sikh spiritual path, and had nothing to do with any political stance. And I added that I was one of them, pointing to my turban and untrimmed beard. I never heard from them again.
But I have heard of erased tapes, of bunglings, of missed opportunities, and ah yes, of broad public references to "Sikh terrorists."
It helped me decide on the route I would take with my daughter. I chose to encourage her to watch and hear and read the news with me, and to discuss its contents.
As a result, I believe, she has learned to discern right from wrong in a way clearer than most people I know.
As she grew up, I noted she had begun to nurture a deep sense of justice and fairness, and sport the ability to quickly cut through onion layers of obfuscation. We often talked about what we saw going on around the Air-India situation.
We quickly learned that there was a pattern emerging in the way the RCMP and CSIS were handling the case and anything else even vaguely related to it.
It has been long forgotten, but there were two trials, one in Hamilton, the other in Montreal, several years ago. Both purportedly related to the Khalistani movement.
Terrorists were being tried, we were forewarned. Swat teams visibly stood coiled around the "specially barricaded" facilities.
"Terrorists! Terrorists!" echoed every preparatory press conference. It was high drama, neatly orchestrated to meet every news deadline.
Well, both matters were finally heard, one by one, in separate cities.
The judge found that the bases of the charges were fraudulent: false affidavits, sworn by "investigative" personnel, were the mainstay.
There was no other real evidence. The charges were dismissed. In each case.
A similar case took place in New York State. Same scenario, swat teams and all. On the eve of the trial, it was discovered that the prosecutor had been penning threatening letters to the judge and signing them with the names of the accused.
The charges were dropped and the prosecutor taken away, reportedly for psychiatric treatment.
My daughter and I learned the following: If the prosecution protests loudly and repeatedly that $100 million has been spent on the case, that there are 10 truckloads of evidence, there are 100 witnesses, that there were 300 victims — and never, ever claims that there are X number of solid witnesses, and X number of damaging documents, and oodles, no some, no, even one piece of impeccable evidence connecting the accused with the crimes, then you know there isn't a case.
Not just a weak case. Simply, no case. And then, when you hear the word "terrorists" bandied about freely and with full-throated ease, you know it is a smokescreen to hide the absence of substance.
Were we surprised by the verdict?
Yes, we were. We are always surprised — pleasantly — at how our judicial system ultimately rises to the occasion, and does what it is supposed to do, albeit belatedly.
Now, just wait and see how loudly and how often the authorities use the word "terrorists" henceforth.
Here's my grey-haired conclusion:
There is good news and there is bad news. The good news: Ours is the best justice system in the world. The bad news: Ours is the best justice system in the world!
We do need an inquiry. It is a must. The truth behind why it took 20 years to get to this unsatisfactory juncture has to be outed.
And, we simply can't let the real criminals go free.
One more thing. My daughter grew up to choose journalism as a career: The pursuit of truth ...
T. Sher Singh is a Guelph lawyer who is a Member of the Order of Canada.
Re: Tragedy smeared all Sikh-Canadians
Bhopinder singh · 21 Mar 2005
sahajdhari
By that scale IRA should be called christian fighters.
Palestie fighters as muslims
Israeli reaction as Jewish
Kashmiri fighters as Muslims
Assam fighters as HINDUS
I think people fighting for Sikh homeland should be called Khalistanis
Re: Tragedy smeared all Sikh-Canadians
Jarnail Singh gyani "Arshi" · 22 Mar 2005
this smeared ALL SIKHS. Period.
Why should a Khalsitani be a "militant" or "terrorist". There are 20 MILLION Khalsitanis in the World and 99.9% of them are peacedul law abiding citizens of world countries...the ONLY militant CRIMINALS are KPGill, types in PUNJAB/INDIA...RSS types, RAW agents in sikh disguise..etc etc.
Werent ALL NAZIS under HITLER CHRISTIANS ?? So how come we never see the word "Christian" next to Hitler's name or any NAZI names ??
IRA are never categorised as Christians either..??? funny eh.
Jarnail Singh
Re: Tragedy smeared all Sikh-Canadians
The Toronto Star · 23 Mar 2005
Fake Democracy, Real Terrorism
By SAN GREWAL
The Toronto Star, Mar. 20, 2005
Turning a blind eye to a nation's anti-democratic ways can have a high cost. The Air-India disaster is the proof
The public reaction to Wednesday's acquittal in the Air-India case has overlooked an important question: Was the terrorism exported to Canada from India a direct by-product of that state's long-standing anti-democratic policies?
And, perhaps more importantly, does the title 'democratic' give countries that are anything but a licence to operate darkly in the background while using the propped-up ideals of freedom as a veil?
A month before the Air-India verdict, which found the two men accused in the 1985 bombing of flight 182, Ripudaman Singh Malik and Ajaib Singh Bagri, not guilty, a disturbing report was released in India, the world's largest democracy.
It was called the Nanavati report, named after former Indian Supreme Court judge G.T. Nanavati, who presided over a commission convened in 2000 to find out how thousands of Sikhs were systematically targeted and killed in the streets of New Delhi immediately after Prime Minister Indira Gandhi was murdered by her Sikh bodyguards in 1984.
The report documented the commission's main finding that the widespread rioting and massacres were 'organized' and instigated by members of the assassinated prime minister's ruling Congress party to 'target the Sikh community' without any 'meaningful intervention' by the police.
The Delhi riots carried on for three days while fires lit the city. Government reports estimate 2,000 Sikhs were killed. The death toll, according to various articles in the Indian press, was as high as 10,000.
'My own two houses were burned down in broad daylight,' said Patwant Singh, a prominent Indian author who testified in front of the Nanavati Commission and was interviewed two years ago at his home in New Delhi.
'I went to see the president twice and the home minister while the riots were taking place. I urged them to send out military forces, the usual procedure during a period of civil unrest. It became clear that it was not civilians leading the massacring of Sikhs.
'It was an eye-opener, the degree to which a constitutional government, a state, can allow and endorse crimes against its own people.'
No charges have been laid, but five former Congress party members were named in the report for their involvement in the riots, including the former home minister, the former lieutenant-governor and a current Congress party M.P.
'Whatever happened in India and elsewhere has to be seen against this backdrop,' said Patwant Singh.
It's a backdrop that presents a disturbing sight in a country held up as an example of how democracy can succeed.
In 1975, when tension about Sikh autonomy mounted between Mrs. Gandhi and Sikh leaders, the Indian High Court handed down a decision upholding an earlier petition that had charged the prime minister with campaign fraud during the 1971 election.
Instead of stepping down from office, as she had been ordered to do, Mrs. Gandhi, in an unconstitutional move, declared a state of emergency, threw 100,000 political opponents in jail (a disproportionate number were Sikhs), censored the press, banned political parties and suspended all elections for nearly two years.
It was a foreshadowing of how things would unravel.
'Sikhs were, and still are, second-class citizens,' said Patwant Singh. 'If there was even the faintest suspicion that a Sikh had anything to do with the independence movement, they and their families were killed with impunity. Close to 200,000 were murdered by government security forces (according to the National Human Rights Organization) and police during the decade following Mrs. Gandhi's death. The government won't even let Amnesty International in to investigate the claims.'
In 1994, the U.S. State Department reported that the Indian government paid out over 41,000 cash bounties to police officers for killing Sikhs in the northwestern state of Punjab, where Sikhs still make up a slight majority and where many have agitated for an independent Sikh state.
Last April, the European Parliament called for a 'Commission of Truth and Justice' under the auspices of the U.N. The call was to 'comprehensively investigate whether the slaughter to which Indian Sikhs were subjected in 1984 constitutes genocide as defined in the Genocide Convention and the relevant international law.'
The point here is that the Air-India disaster did not occur in a vacuum. There is no justification for acts of mass murder, but that applies to governments as much as it does to terrorists. The slaughter and unlawful imprisonment of Sikhs in India during the 1970s and 1980s was at the very least condoned by a democratic government, if not outright instigated by it. Yet the world turned a blind eye to the killings, seeing the issue as an internal matter - until it landed on foreign shores.
This is the cost to the international community of not acting when a so-called democracy ignores the rule of law or enforces democratic principles in a selective manner.
The Canadian government welcomes immigrants into this country. But with the law-abiding come people such as Talwinder Singh Parmar, the suspected mastermind of the Air-India bombings, who in 1992 was killed by police in Punjab.
Parmar saw Canada as a safe haven from which he could foment hatred of the Indian government within this country's Sikh community.
It was a hatred Patwant Singh and many others believe led directly to the Air-India bombing.
Not one person has yet been convicted for the worst mass murder in Canadian history.
And, as Singh said two years ago, 'Not one chap has been charged for the deaths of thousands of Sikhs during the 1984 riots.'
[%sig%]
Re: Tragedy smeared all Sikh-Canadians
The Globe and Mail · 23 Mar 2005
Khalistan Alive In Sikh-Canadian Hearts and Minds
By ROBERT MATAS
A December 29, 2000 report in The Vancouver Sun by Kim Bolan described Balkar Singh Heir as "one of the leaders of the newly formed United Defence Council, which held a dinner Tuesday that raised tens of thousands of dollars for the legal expenses of Air India suspects Ripudaman Singh Malik of Vancouver and Ajaib Singh Bagri of Kamloops."
The Globe and Mail, Mississauga, Ontario, Mar. 17, 2005
The burning passion for revenge against the Indian government, allegedly the motive for the 1985 Air-India terrorist attack, has cooled over the years.
However, the dream of an independent Sikh state called Khalistan that accompanied the cries for revenge lives on.
'We love Khalistan,' proudly proclaims the message on the wall at the front of a prayer room in the Ontario Khalsa Darbar, a Sikh temple in Mississauga. The temple attracts about 15,000 people each week, up to 80,000 on religious holidays.
'Sikh Homeland Khalistan,' echoes a sign hanging prominently on the walls of another prayer room in the temple.
'It may take a generation or more, but we still support Khalistan,' Amanpreet Singh Bal, an activist in the Ontario Sikh community, said in an interview at the temple as dozens of people listened to religious chanting on a Saturday evening.
Temple president Jasjit Singh Bhullar said no one advocates violence to achieve Khalistan or to avenge past injustices.
'No one liked what happened in 1985,' he said, referring to the Air-India disaster. 'It was not very good for the community. It was very sad for the families of those who died.'
Cries for revenge were made after thousands of Sikhs who came to pray at the Golden Temple in Amritsar, Sikhism's most sacred shrine, were killed by Indian government troops in June, 1984, during gunfights with insurgents. Thousands more were killed in anti-Sikh riots in Delhi in November, 1984, after prime minister Indira Gandhi was assassinated.
Many people at that time said the killings should not have happened, Mr. Bhullar said. But the twin bombings in the Air-India attack, which left 331 people dead, achieved nothing, he added. 'I don't think you accomplish anything by killing someone.'
The Sikh community in Canada is very different now, he continued; those who remember the massacres of 1984 commemorate that event by donating blood. Several Sikh communities hold donor drives for the Canadian Blood Service each November.
The 'drive to save lives,' in its sixth year across North America, reflects a dramatic reversal in attitudes in the Sikh community, he said.
Twenty years ago, some Sikhs in Canada advocated violence to avenge the deaths of those killed in India during military attacks against insurgents fighting for a separate Sikh state.
Mr. Bal said public reaction to the Air-India disaster made the community in Canada realize that it had to be more aggressive in letting Canadians know who they are, and after the attack, many in the Sikh community felt they had been branded as terrorists by the Indian government.
Mr. Bal and Mr. Bhullar list several 'products of 1984,' including the election of several Sikhs to the House of Commons and provincial legislatures, the acceptance of turbans in the R.C.M.P. and the recognition of religious symbols in mainstream culture.
Balkar Singh [Heir], a spokesman for a group called the Sikh Liberation Organization, said he continues to work for the independence of Khalistan.
The Ontario resident, who immigrated to Canada in 1972, was picked up during a visit to India in 1987, held in jail under the country's anti-terrorist laws and tortured. He told Canadian officials at the time that among other things, he was repeatedly asked by police what he knew about the Air-India disaster. He was also questioned by the R.C.M.P. while in the Indian jail.
He was released without being charged and returned to Canada in October, 1988, after a year in detention.
Mr. Singh condemns the use of violence to achieve independence, but he remains convinced that Sikhs need their own state. 'It may not happen today or in 10 years or 50 years. But it will happen.'
[%sig%]
Re: Tragedy smeared all Sikh-Canadians
kar kirpaa sabh rayN thheevaa · 23 Mar 2005
"saachae mail n laagee man niramal har dhhiaae ||"
my Gursikh family can't be smeared.
"sach sampooran nirmalaa this vich kooR na raldaa raee"
only those get smeared who do not do naam simran.
" chahu jug mailae mal bharae jin mukh naam n hoe ||"
[%sig%]
WSC-AR Statement - Re: Tragedy smeared all Sikh-Canadians
World Sikh Council - AR · 24 Mar 2005
WSC-AR Statement on Verdict in Canada Declaring Two Sikhs Innocent
World Sikh Council - America Region (WSC-AR)
P.O. Box 3635, Columbus, Ohio 43210, USA
Phone: 614-210-0591, Fax: 419-535-6794
E-mail: [address removed], Website: www.worldsikhcouncil.org
FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE
March 23, 2005
Contact: Dr. Tarunjit Singh, Secretary General, 614-210-0591, [address removed]
Nearly twenty years after the June 1985 tragic bombing of an Air India Flight and after more than a four year long judicial probe, Justice Ian
Bruce Josephson of the Supreme Court of British Columbia (Canada) declared on March 16, 2005 that Ripudaman Singh Malik and Ajaib Singh Bagri, two Sikhs charged with the crime, are innocent.
The World Sikh Council - America Region (WSC-AR) is pleased with the verdict upholding the innocence of the two Sikhs charged with this crime.
WSC-AR is concerned, however, that those who are really responsible for the murder of 329 innocent victims (many of whom were Sikhs) of this tragedy are still free. Many news sources have repeatedly cited the notorious operations of India's intelligence agencies in Canada for masterminding this state-supported terrorism to defame Sikhs in Canada and all over the world.
We hold the families of the victims of this tragedy in our thoughts and prayers and, once again, we extend our unqualified support in pursuing their quest for justice through the identification, arrest, and conviction of the real perpetrators of this crime.
We call upon the Canadian government to establish a Royal Commission of Inquiry that will investigate all facts pertaining to this tragedy. We also request the International Civil Aviation Organization (ICAO) in Montreal, to call upon the Governments of India, Canada, USA, Ireland, Britain, and Japan -- who were involved in the initial probe -- for their full cooperation for the sake of transparency and accountability, leading to the arrest and conviction of the real perpetrators.
Our thoughts go to Ripudaman Singh Malik and Ajaib Singh Bagri and their families, who have needlessly suffered this prolonged pain, agony, and confinement. This has caused a tremendous drain on their health, family life, and financial situation. We pray to the Almighty God for bestowing upon them the courage and determination to stand up against injustice and falsehood, and seek restitution.
Eminent investigate journalists, Zuhair Kashmeri and Brian McAndrew, of the Globe and Mail and The Toronto Star, concluded in their book titled "Soft Target" published in 1989 that "For several years, India has been engaged in a devious and ruthless operation to manipulate and destabilize Canada's Sikh population. The operation has been orchestrated by India's intelligence service and has left the Sikh community estranged from Canadian Society… To its credit, CSIS [Canadian Security Intelligence Service] eventually woke up just before the tragic Air-India bombing that left 329 people, mostly Canadians, dead in June 1985. It chased the
culprits right to the Indian embassy and consulates. But what it then faced was political interference."
For Sikhs across the world, the verdict in Canada is a sigh of relief, but the struggle for transparency and accountability continues. As it were, the Sikhs all over the world also suffered the agony of defamation and distortion, particularly because many media experts rushed to the conclusion by blaming the Sikhs for this tragedy-which reflects, rather poorly, on their professional integrity and their commitment for objective and informed reporting.
For Sikhs, this verdict is a renewed call for reaffirmation of our faith in divine grace for the ultimate victory of truth and justice. We sincerely thank all those people of good will, who have provided moral support, despite the official campaign of misinformation and falsification.
We take this opportunity to express our sincere gratitude to Justice Ian Bruce Josephson, who has demonstrated great courage and integrity of character and deep commitment for justice, despite overwhelming financial and diplomatic resources of the Indian intelligence agencies in providing fabricated evidence to confuse the situation in order to implicate the two innocent Sikhs.
We also take this opportunity to urge media experts to search their soul and provide their readers and viewers the truth in partial restitution of the injury of defamation, wittingly or unwittingly, inflicted upon two innocent Sikhs and the entire Sikh community.
The WSC-AR is a representative and elected body of Sikh Gurdwaras and institutions in the United States. Its members include 36 Gurdwaras (Sikh places of worship) and other Sikh institutions across the nation.
---
Some excerpts from "Soft Target:
How the Indian Intelligence Service Penetrated Canada", Zuhair Kashmeri and Brian McAndrew, James Lorimer & Company Publishers, Toronto, 1989:
"For several years, India has been engaged in a devious and ruthless operation to manipulate and destabilize Canada's Sikh population. The operation has been orchestrated by India's intelligence service and has left the Sikh community estranged from Canadian Society…To its credit, CSIS [Canadian Security Intelligence Service] eventually woke up just before the tragic Air-India bombing that left 329 people, mostly Canadians, dead in June 1985. It chased the culprits right to the Indian embassy and consulates. But what it then faced was political interference." (page iii)
"Asking the Sikhs [in Canada] to forget about what was happening in Punjab was like demanding that Canadian Jews disregard the plight of the Jewish 'refuseniks' in the Soviet Union. If only because they all had families still living in Punjab, the Sikhs would not turn their backs on their homeland." (page 38) "The CSIS [Canadian Security Intelligence Service] investigators slowly became convinced that the Indian Intelligence service may have played a role in the [Air India] bombings. And the further they probed, the more their suspicions grew." (page 84)
"CSIS [Canadian Security Intelligence Service] had enough circumstantial material to reach the conclusion that agents of the government of India were linked to the Air-India and Narita bombings." (page 93)
"The record of the Indian government shows that it will use both legitimate and illegitimate means to strengthen its political hold on a country the Western media calls 'the world's largest democracy.' The disinformation campaign made the public look upon the Sikhs as a menace and the separatist groups as the obvious culprits responsible for the bombings." (page 94)
"It seemed that the interests of the Indian government superceded the rights of Canadian citizens of Sikh origin to freedom of _expression, and these 'irritants' were standing in the way of an improved relationship between Canada and India, with its growing demand for foreign technology, skills, and marketable goods." (page 139)
"The perception of the Sikhs held by Montrealers, and without doubt by other Canadians, are largely a result of the Indian government's campaign to slur the Sikh community in Canada. And, despite the already-entrenched negative impressions, the Indian government has not relented in its quest to interfere in the lives of the Canadian Sikhs." (page 150)
---
Member Gurdwaras of WSC-AR:
1. Gurdwara Sahib Fremont, Fremont, CA
2. Guru Nanak Sikh Mission, Livingston, CA
3. Sikh Gurdwara of LA, North Hollywood, CA
4. Sikh Gurdwara Riverside, Riverside, CA
5. Colorado Singh Sabha, Denver, CO
6. Guru Singh Sabha of Augusta, Augusta, GA
7. Sikh Study Circle of Atlanta, Atlanta, GA
8. Sikh Religious Society of Chicago, Palatine, IL
9. Sikh Society of South, New Orleans, LA
10. Sikh Gurdwara of Michigan, Rochester Hills, MI
11. Sikh Society of Michigan, Madison Heights, MI
12. Guru Nanak Foundation of Jackson, MS
13. Sikh Gurdwara of North Carolina, Durham, NC
14. Garden State Sikh Association, Bridgewater, NJ
15. Guru Nanak Sikh Society of Delaware Valley, Sewell, NJ
16. Siri Guru Singh Sabha, Glenrock, NJ
17. Sikh Cultural Society Inc., Richmond Hills, NY
18. Sikh Cultural & Edu. Society of Western NY, Buffalo, NY
19. Sikh Religious Society of Dayton, Dayton, OH
20. Guru Nanak Found. of Greater Cleveland, Richfield, OH
21. Guru Gobind Singh Sikh Society, Bedford, OH
22. Guru Nanak Religious Soc. of Central Ohio, Columbus, OH
23. Tristate Sikh Cultural Society, Monroeville, PA
24. Mid South Sikh Sabha, Memphis, TN
25. Sikh Center of Gulf Coast, Houston, TX
26. Siri Guru Singh Sabha, Richardson, TX
27. Sikh Gurdwara of North Texas, Garland, TX
28. Singh Sabha Gurdwara, Fairfax, VA
29. Sikh Association of Central Virginia, VA
30. Sikh Religious Society of Wisconsin, Brookfield, WI
Other Sikh Institution Members of WSC-AR:
1. Siri Guru Granth Sahib Found., Anaheim, CA
2. Sikhs Serving America, Topeka, KS
3. Sikh Youth Federation of North America, White Plains, NY
4. Sikh Educational & Religious Foundation, Dublin, OH
5. Sikh Youth Federation of USA, Toledo, OH
6. Academy of Guru Granth Studies, Arlington, TX
---
World Sikh Council - America Region (WSC-AR)
P.O. Box 3635, Columbus, Ohio 43210, USA
Phone: 614-210-0591, Fax: 419-535-6794
E-mail: [address removed], Website: www.worldsikhcouncil.org
[%sig%]
Re: Tragedy smeared all Sikh-Canadians
Gurpreet Singh · 26 Mar 2005
or it could mean he wasnt the smartest guy in the world and was used a pawn by the GOI