Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Bhindranwale

Bhindranwale

in need of clarification · 21 Mar 2005

ok first off im gonna say i respect bhindranwala .. but lets point out couple of things..one he was not a santh...he never said he is he actually told people nto to call him that..(THE DEF..OF SANTH IS SOMEONE WHO MET GOD...OR WAS RNLIGHTENED SPIRTUALLY BY GOD AND is A PATH TO GOD)bhindranwala was great but he was nto a santh./another thing ya the gorverment shouldnt have attacked the temple.that was pure tryign to knock our religionbut remeber one thing to this day bhindranwala was the first singh to bring the battle into golden temple...in all of history hes the first singh to do that..noone took the battle there before..even when thye kill killed massa rangh..the muslim guy who put whores in the darbar sahib..two singhs went to kill him...JUS TWo..they chopped hiim liek a goat...if u guys dont know what im talking about..this during muslim rule..and a lot of singhs were in hiding..like bhindrawala could have went anywhere..but he chose two make a stand at the darbar sahib..so in a way i do blame him for what happened.he could have went anywhere else..like ya there are theroies that goverment was gonna attack golden temple anyways..but whats provoking them more gonna help???BHindran wala was a great man and i love his speeches they go str8 to your heart but i jus think that people know that thiers gonna be consequences..maybe he thouguth it was for the better only he knows.who knows if goverment was goonna do it anywyass.but that was a pure cheat shot for them to do..things like that make me want to seperate punjab..btu who knows what if the peoplegevcerning the punjab will do the same stuff to hundus..or muslims...unless it was true singhs who know what sutpid people do with power..its nothing to do with muslim christian bush biladen indra gandhi blabhlah hitler...nothign to dow ith religion..all about power...they jus use the religion a way to gather the masses....u think they care about religion and still kill gods children>>

Re: Bhindranwale

KHALISTANI · 22 Mar 2005

Sant Baba Jarnail Singh ji Khalsa Bhindrawale is a real sant. Telling ppl not to call him a sant that doesnt mean he wasnt. He also told ppl that he wasnt a mahapurkh. Its a singn of humility. He wasnt hiding in Sri Darbar Sahib. He was there for a long time. But the GOI was plannign this atack for a long time it jsut worked out tha Sant ji was there so they had an excuse. If the government says they wanted to arrest him how come they ddint send out an arrest warrant. or how come a few months earlier they realsed Sant ji from prison after arresting him at Mehta Chowk were the police fired shots at the pyaraa gursikh's there. ANd dotn worry about the punjabi government after its serperated. Sant JI will Return and head it so that no one has to be attacked and no oen has to be under opression WJKK WJKF

Re: Bhindranwale

Jarnail Singh gyani "Arshi" · 22 Mar 2005

Jarnail Singh is on record for having said this: A reporter once asked him" Sant Ji, How are you ? Jarnail Singh Ji's reply: I DONT KNOW about the SANT...but I am FINE. ( read between the lines ans Jarnail Singh Ji is telling us he is NOT interested in being called sant ji) Secondly He is also on record as having always kept a stick with him whcih he used to avoid people matha teking to his feet or touching his feet. Jarnail Singh

Re: Bhindranwale

Premi · 22 Mar 2005

I agree with the first poster. Bhai Jarnail Singh Bhindranwale was a great man because he bravely spoke up against the Indian Government's abuse of Sikh rights. BUT, to then take that to the Nth degree and start saying that he was a great warrior or a great Saint is typical of us Punjabis! Let's be honest with ourselves. Bhai Jarnail Singh Bhindranwale was a regular Sikh (by his own admission). Even if his spiritual state was great, we have no way of knowing and those who insist that he was a Sant are oblivious to Gurbani. The Indian Government's attack on Darbar Sahib was the greatest sin and those who are responsible will not be spared in the next world. BUT, here again it must be noted that Bhai Jarnail Singh Bhindranwale AND the Babbars were WRONG to baracade themselves inside the complex as this provided the Indian Government with the perfect excuse to demolish our sacred shrines and burn down our nation's library. It can be argued that this is obvious in retrospect, but just as we wouldn't barracade ourselves inside our children's school (because they a reprecious to us) the same should have been the case with Darbar Sahib - it is obvious. The fact that this mistake was made by Bhai Jarnail Singh Bhindranwale and others indicates that their state may not have been as high as we like to think.

Re: Bhindranwale

how do we no? · 22 Mar 2005

how do we no hu is a sant? how can we say baba jarnail singh ji was a sant, we dnt no, we cant pass that judgement, better to just call him bhai sahib, we cant be sure of anythink, only vahiguru ji knows.

Re: Bhindranwale

singh · 22 Mar 2005

i think ibhindrwale was the best thing that ever happend to taksaal thats why they class him soooo high, same way akj think bhai randhir singh was a mahapurash... all im saying is only guru ji and akaal purakh him self know who the mahapurrash and sants are we are nobodys! nobodys man we got to under stand that and make a gursikhi jeevan for our selves, who cares who calls who a sants lets just try and look at our jeevan 1st, wjkk wjkf

Re: Bhindranwale

amrik singh · 22 Mar 2005

VaheGuru Ji Ka Khalsa, VaheGuru Ji Ki Fateh. ....and here we go again..... he was a Saint - Soldier!! as brother/sister Khalistani stated Sant Ji was arrested and released from prison. they could have simply arrested him again!!! (and for that matter again and again and again) but they wanted to cause maximum humiliation, grief and damage thus the '84 attack. the other thing is that nobody actually see's the pictures of Sant Ji teaching Gurbani or doing Santhiya. They never see the pictures of the spiritual side of Sant Ji, they only see the warrior side. should we not use a full name when talking about somebody (you dont have to include Sant) if you dont want to, but just using Bhindrenwale seems so disrespectful - just my opinion. please forgive my mistakes. VaheGuru Ji Ka Khalsa, VaheGuru Ji Ki Fateh.

Re: Bhindranwale

.. · 22 Mar 2005

i think we should find something else to argue about, we already argue about this issue so many times already!

Re: Bhindranwale

Kulbir Singh · 22 Mar 2005

Sant Jarnail Singh jee Bhindranwalay was in Darbar Sahib because Darbar Sahib belonged to his father. What business did Indira have in telling Sant jee where he should stay? Sant jee did nothing wrong when he stayed in his father’s house – Siri Akal Takhat Sahib. And Sant jee did great sewa of Panth by bringing awareness in Sikh Panth. He belonged to the whole Panth and not just one organisation. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: Bhindranwale

..................... · 22 Mar 2005

can i just say that sant jarnail singh bhindrawale was the greatest saint in this time as he not only preached sikhi but also practiced it , ****Admin Cut - Whether Sant Bhindranwale is alive or not is not the subject of this thread*****

Re: Bhindranwale

Kabadi · 22 Mar 2005

SANT JI had every right to be in darbar sahib complex... Telling people not to touch his feet, call him sant is a sign of humility... Sant ji use to clean the singhs kashera's at nite with 'neela' like bleach in india, and do jorian (shoe) di sewa, while all the singhs at taksal would be sleeping, so that know one would find out he was doing this sewa. that is how humble sant ji was... Guru Hargobind Ji assembled his army from Amritsar... There is so much history of Singhs gathering at Akal Takht Sahib... Sant Ji was defending his fathers home just as Bhai Kulbir Singh stated... The government could have issued an arrest warrant if they wanted Sant Ji, just like they had in the past when Sant Ji turned himself in and was later released because no charges could be brought against him... The Government attacked so many gurdwaras in punjab estimates range from 30 to 80, during blue star... was SANT JI or the BABBARS in those gurdwaras too???? Singhs dont run away from battle, they stand up and make a stand, they fight for their rights, for their dharm... They have no problem in giving their head, because they know that when they leave the phsycial body they will be rewarded... GURU GOBIND SINGH JI said, 'sava lakh sai ek ladaoo' ... Thats what being a Khalsa is about... standing for your rights, and others, and standing for the truth, and living without fear... and SANT JI was a perfect example of this... and through all of this he remained so humble, and was always at the sangats feet.

Re: Bhindranwale

amrik singh · 22 Mar 2005

Bole So Nihaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaal, Sat Sri Akaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaal!! the jakaira was with regards to kulbir singh jee's post. VaheGuru Ji Ka Khalsa, VaheGuru Ji Ki Fateh.

Re: Bhindranwale

ns · 22 Mar 2005

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ke Fateh Beautifully mentioned by Kulbir Singh Jee.. agree 110%.. read and reread your history before you make quick conculsions on Jarnail Singh Ji.. OH and Don't forget it is a known fact that the Indian secret police/army had prepared a replica of Darbar Sahib a couple of years earlier and were practising attacking it...it was in their agenda to attack no matter who was there.

Re: Bhindranwale

Harkirankaur · 22 Mar 2005

Waheguru jee kaa khalsa!Waheguru jee kee fateh! Gurbani called gursikhs sants. I do benti to sangat please refrain from saying anything bad for gurmukhs who have given their lives for panth. Sant jee is a great shaheed of our khalsa panth and he did a lot of seva. *****admin cut for deviating from the subject*******

Re: Bhindranwale

amrik singh · 22 Mar 2005

penji i dont know whether i should laugh or cry.... what are you on?? - nothing personal!

Re: Bhindranwale

Kabadi · 22 Mar 2005

harkiran kaur... im sure sant ji wouldnt wanna be apart of the jatha which baba deep singh was jathedar of, sant kartaar singh who sant jarnail singh looked up to so muchh, sant gurbachan singh, etc... and a jatha that gave so much shaheedi for the panth and has such a proud tradition... Taksal mite be at a low point rite now, ITS EASY TO BASH PEOPLE WHEN THEY ARE DOWN... its much harder to help them rise up again (which is what Sikhs do)... BUT I GUARANTEE THEY WILL ONCE AGAIN RISE ONE DAY... and by the way, all panthic jathebandi;s have been infiltrated by GOI agents, including TAKSAL and AKJ, if u dont think so, than refer to amrik singhs post.. 'what are u on?'

Re: Bhindranwale

Pardeep Singh Bilga · 23 Mar 2005

I was wondering if someone may be able to clarify something for me. I have read extensively about SANT Bhindranwale and I have so much respect and look up to this great Gursikh of modern times (how many of the recent babay can we say are even worthy of being called "Sant"?). From my readings regarding Sant ji, I have found it hard to find anybody against him, or criticise him for something he did wrong (apart from Hindus in disguise such as Khushwant singh?). However, the one thing that nobody has really clarified and I've wanted to know the reasons for is, is the fact that Sant ji resided for a time on the upper floors of sri Akal Takhat sahib, apparently directly above a room where Guru Granth Sahib ji Maharaj are were kept. This apparently caused part of the rift with the Babbars who were totally opposed to this. As sant ji was such a good Gursikh and was always humble- why would he live in a room above Guru Sahib? This is something which is universally unaccepted, with most Gurdwaras not building anything above the main hall where Guru Sahib stays. Does anyone have more knowledge surrounding this issue? Bhai Kulbir Singh? Jarnail Singh Arshi? Bhul chuk maaf karni

Re: Bhindranwale

Premi · 23 Mar 2005

I disagree with Bhai Kulbir Singh. I don't think its our right to be at Darbar Sahib - I think its a privilege. Darbar Sahib belongs to our father, not to us. When we visit our father's home, we must respect it. If we know that an army is coming with tanks to apprehend us, would it not be better to take the fight outside of our father's home rather than see it destroyed? If you know somebody is going to bomb you, do you go into your own families home? No. So why go into Darbar Sahib? Finally, why call him "Sant" against his wishes?

Re: Bhindranwale

Lakhvir Singh · 23 Mar 2005

WaheguruJi Ka Khalsa. WaheguruJi Ki Fateh. I too believe that Kulbir Singh Ji ended the whole argument by making the world's simplest statement. No matter how much we argue, this or that, is all meaningless. Sant Jarnail Singh Ji Khalsa Bhindranwale will remain a true Sant-Sipahi in the hearts of those Sikhs who have truly been awakened to the truths about the Sikh plight in India. Kulbir Singh Ji, thank you for your simple answer. The next time someone accosts me with the same question, it will be answered exactly how you put it. For the faithless cynics, they will not believe anything anyway. It beats me to think how we go on and on 20 years later, asking the same question over and over and yet all we have done is question SantJi who laid down his life in defence of Sikh integrity. He showed us that we will die fighting. As a respected leader of the Panth, he made his choices and I respect them. I'm the greatest moorakh, what would I know what he should have done or not done? Had Guru Gobind Singh Ji lived in our times, we would be throwing the same questions against him. People will deny it, but that is the truth. Some might have even gone on to say, 'O why did he have to send his elder Sahibzaade to war?' This is only a comparative scenario. Sant Jarnail Singh Ji was a true Sikh in flesh and spirit. Let's see how we will face adversity when our time comes to defend the Panth. That is when we will remember SantJi's teachings and exemplary life. WaheguruJi Ka Khalsa. WaheguruJi Ki Fateh.

Re: Bhindranwale

sikh · 23 Mar 2005

premi ji where else would bhai jarnail singh go? darbar sahib is our home? so naturally those and any other singhs/kaurs can go there and stay...... please stop thinking of darbar sahib as some place which is separate fromt he people it belongs to our father and his children will naturally stay there. waheguru

Re: Bhindranwale

KHALISTANI · 23 Mar 2005

WJKK WJKF i dont no how ppl can say sant ji was not a sant. there are so many stories about all the sewa and all the pyaar he had. I have heard of a story where Bhai Amrik Singh JI was speakign with him. Sant ji said that when he takes shaheedi, to do autumn sanskaar in the entrance of mehta chowk. this was so his ashes would have the chance to touch the feet of all the pyaara gusikh's and all the sangat at goes to Mehta Chowk. Another story was when he was resting late at night. and sangat was rushing in to do dharshan. one lady was making a wish that she wouldnt have a daughter. sant ji got up and almost hit her with his teer. why because she didnt want a daughter. lots of people in india still do this, asking for sons. Sant ji most have had some powers to here wat she was wishing for. He must be a bramgyaini the previous jathedar tells the next to be jathedar. we all know that baba deep singh ji was a brahmgyini. so he wouldnt only nominate another brahmgyaini as jathedar and so on. sant ji did alot for the panth not just for taksal. he wasnt the greatest thign to happen to taksal all taksal mukti's should be classified as the same. he did awaken a sleeping nation. he taught alot of students and did so much sewa for them and the panth and people still try and bad mouth him. as for taksal being in a bad state now its the truth. the whole acting jathedar thing is stupid. we all know who the real jathedar is. these guys are just doing some sewa until his return WJKK WJKF

Re: Bhindranwale

Premi · 23 Mar 2005

KHALISTANI Ji, your post shows your age. A few stories do not prove much at all, never mind whether somebody is a saint or not. Stories are nothing more than hearsay. SIKH you said "where else would bhai jarnail singh go? darbar sahib is our home? so naturally those and any other singhs/kaurs can go there and stay......" This is a very weak argument that doesn't go one iota of the way to explain the desecration and huge loss of innocent life. SIKH you said "please stop thinking of darbar sahib as some place which is separate fromt he people it belongs to our father and his children will naturally stay there." We all know that nobody really lives at Darbar Sahib - nobody raises his/her family there. If everyone did that then there would be chaos. The fact is that Bhai Jarnail Singh Bhindranwale and the Babbars made a big mistake by staying at Darbar Sahib. We are Sikhs of the Guru, we should be honest with ourselves.

Re: Bhindranwale

Kulbir Singh · 23 Mar 2005

---------- I don't think its our right to be at Darbar Sahib - I think its a privilege. Darbar Sahib belongs to our father, not to us. When we visit our father's home, we must respect it. ----------- Whether it was wrong or right was not for Indira to decide. Did SGPC or Akali Dal of that time even once asked Sant jee to move out of there? No official statement from anyone, requesting Sant jee to move. Sant jee would have obeyed any hukam of Guru Panth Khalsa. ------ If we know that an army is coming with tanks to apprehend us, would it not be better to take the fight outside of our father's home rather than see it destroyed? --------- Again the issue was that Indira was not the one to decide whether Sikhs should stay in Darbar Sahib complex or not. --------- If you know somebody is going to bomb you, do you go into your own families home? No. So why go into Darbar Sahib? ----------- If I have nowhere else to go, I don’t see what would be wrong in going to my family’s home. Same way, what better refuge than the house of Siri Guru Raam Daas jee Maharaaj? Did Bidhi Chand not come here when he was a bandit? He sat in Siri Guru Arjun Dev jee’s sangat while police were looking for him. Kulbir Singh

Re: Bhindranwale

Premi · 23 Mar 2005

>>> Whether it was wrong or right was not for Indira to decide. <<< Of course it wasn't up to Indira. But I'm talking about somebody telling you what to do, I'm talking about common sense. The Singhs were not children that need to be told what to do. It is fairly obvious that the Darbar Sahib complex would be desecrated when army tanks are on their way. Its common sense to think of the greater good and move out of the complex where thousands of innocents were attending. Of course indira and her dogs had no respect for Guru Ji or human life, but the Singhs should have had more common sense than what they displayed. >>> If I have nowhere else to go, I don’t see what would be wrong in going to my family’s home. <<< I think if you were wanted by the army of any country (especially one that had no qualms in using brute force and hated you and your people) you would not place yourself in that place which you value the most, as it is common sense that it will be damaged along with innocent people from your family who have no idea what is going on. >>> Did Bidhi Chand not come here when he was a bandit? He sat in Siri Guru Arjun Dev jee’s sangat while police were looking for him. <<< This is a weak comparison as it doesn't compare to all-out war, which was obviously about to happen - both Bhindranwale and the Babbars knew this days in advance. The Singhs died bravely, but there is no doubt that their war strategy was a tragic mistake.

Re: Bhindranwale

amrik singh · 23 Mar 2005

oh man.... now these Singh's had no common sense. what are you on?? - nothing personal!

Re: Bhindranwale

sikh · 23 Mar 2005

premi ji how is my argument weak? the singhs who were staying there were staying at there fathers house waheguru/guru ram dass ji (as kulbir singh ji says in another post)....where exactly would a rehitwale singh go? i think you need to give up the politically correct thought base which you have developed..... the singhs were standing upto oppression and upholding the pillars of honesty, intergrity etc...... what exactly does darbad sahib stand for! so naturally they would be based there......... i doubt any of the sangat if you asked them now or even before the attack took place would say they didn't want to leave there human form at wahegurus house, what a blessing i feel it must have been for them....... yes nobody lives at dabar sahib but that is not because they can't but becasue the current management have made darbar sahib into an attraction rather than the home of god and guru which it was and always will be.........during guru-jis time people did stay there.... premi ji please enlighten me as to where the singhs should have stayed and fought the oppressing army? do you really think they were only after bhai jarnail singh? they wanted to teach us the sikhs a lesson, indira need to improve and increase her vote bank and what better way than to silence those anti-bharat sikhs who wanted independence from mother india, what better way to show the hindu vote bank who was indian through and through........... think about it............

Re: Bhindranwale

Gurpreet Singh · 23 Mar 2005

akaal takhat sahib is the political head of sikhi, and whther you like or not, whether they were elected or not, Sant Baba Jarnail Singh Ji Khalsa was the political head of sikhi at the time, and so they belonged at Akaal Takhat Sahib

Re: Bhindranwale

Simran · 24 Mar 2005

Premi Ji is right. If we look at the matter with open eyes, then we must agree that staying at Akal Takhat Sahib was a mistake. There are so many other places to go, why are people suggesting that Akal Takhat Sahib was the ONLY place? It is worth remembering that the Singhs of old didn't stay anywhere, but lived on the backs of horses. They didn't feel that Akal Takhat Sahib was their "natural" place. If we are Sikhs then we should be honest, even if it is hard for us.

Re: Bhindranwale

santbir singh · 24 Mar 2005

this topic seems to come up again and again. i wrote this as a response to a similar post on sikhe.com four years ago concerning the issue of the legitimacy of baba jarnail singh fortifying the darbar sahib complex. these are my thoughts on the subject. it was written a few years ago so forgive me for all mistakes. concernign the question put forward by "Pardeep Singh Bilga", it was a common practice for the jathedar of the akal takht to reside in the rooms of akal takht sahib located on the higher floors. jarnail singh was simply following panthic convention when he stayed in those rooms. those rooms are also commonly used for panthic meetings of the singh sahiban, etc. if it's disrespectful to use any of those rooms because the main floor of akal takht has guru granth sahib jee on it then the entire top five stories should be locked up and we should question what the point of building the entire building was. jarnail singh also countered these critcisms in his own speeches by pointing out that "sant" fateh singh and others stayed at akal takht sahib and nobody in the panth had any problems with their stay there. in addition, those men used to sleep on mattresses and beds when at akal takht. baba jarnail singh pointed out that he slept on the floor, on a sheet, without a mattress, out of respect for guru granth sahib jee and for the akal takht. here's the essay: Journey of Sovereignty Over the last few days a debate has been going on Sikhe.com concerning the role of Jarnail Singh in the destruction of the Akal Takht and the army action against the Darbar Sahib Complex in 1984. For the last seventeen years the constant claim of some Sikhs, that somehow Shaheed Baba Jarnail Singh was to blame for the destruction of the Akal Takhat and how it would have been much better had he not been in the complex and that by being there he invited the army action, makes two things clear to me. One, we are a people with a slave mentality. We blame ourselves for the crimes committed against us by the State. And two, our knowledge of Sikh history is narrow and lacks an intelligent understanding of our history and traditions. The belief that the sanctity of a place, especially the Darbar Sahib complex, must be kept at all costs and that Jarnail Singh should have done everything in his power to ensure it was not defiled in any way is an argument that flies in the face of Sikh ideology and tradition. The Akaal Takht Sahib (properly called Takht Akaal Bunga Sahib) is a building: brick and mortar, marble and gold. What is more important than the actual building, is the sovereignty of the Khalsa Panth; is the freedom of the Akal Takht. When given a choice between letting a government control the Takht or defending it, and thus perhaps then brining about its destruction, the Nation of the Sikh would rather have it destroyed than come under government control. If to keep its independence the building is destroyed, then that is of no consequence to the Panth. If, after its destruction, the government still takes over, then at least the Khalsa Nation can say we tried our hardest to ensure that the "Throne of the Infinite" remained sovereign. Let us look at some key examples in Sikh history that should help prove this point. In 1764, Bhai Gurbakhsh Singh and his twenty-nine sathees were the caretakers of the Akal Takht Sahib and the adjoining gurdwaras. Bhai Sahib was one of the top students of Baba Deep Singh and was from the Damdami Taksaal / Shaheedi Misl. At the time, the majority of the Khalsa were in the jungles to the north of Punjab and the deserts in the Rajasthan area. The Sikhs were under heavy persecution from the governments of the time and the Khalsa was regrouping in these wild lands. Very few Sikhs were left in Punjab and these thirty Sikhs had volunteered for the seva of up keeping the Darbar Sahib Complex, especially the Akal Takht and Darbar Sahib. Bhai Gurbakhsh Singh was what we would now call the Jathedar of the Akal Takht Sahib, though that position was not called so until much later in Sikh history. When the Afghanis under Ahmed Shah Duranni came through Punjab on one of their many invasions of the sub-continent, they found Amritsar deserted (at that time Amritsar was called Chak Guru, Chak Ramdaspur, Guru ka Chak, or just Chak). They came to Darbar Sahib, which they had planned to occupy. Now, if there were no Sikhs there, they would have just occupied the buildings and left. And Sikhs today, would probably say, let them, because then the buildings will be saved. But no. The Khalsa cannot allow any power to have control over the throne given to it by Akal Purakh. This is a timeless throne, one that the Khalsa rules from, answerable only to God. Its independence must be maintained. So, those thirty brave Sikhs came out and took on a large Afghani army. The odds were hugely stacked against them (like they were in 1984), but the thirty Singhs fought extremely bravely. They destroyed many Afghani troops and, ultimately, they were all killed. For them, dying there and doing everything they could do to protect the sovereignty of the institutions of the Khalsa was much more important and dear to them than their lives. So long as Sikhs were in the Akal Takht, they would not voluntarily let it be taken over by a foreign power. Now let us look back ten years earlier, to 1757. Baba Deep Singh is considered one of the giants of Sikh history, and rightly so. The first Jathedar of the Damdami Taksaal, his accomplishments are many. He was taught directly by Bhai Mani Singh in intellectual, philosophical and martial traditions. He prepared the first copies of the Guru Granth Sahib from Bhai Mani Singh's original Damdami Bir, the one Guru Gobind Singh had transcribed to Bhai Mani Singh in 1703 at Damdama. Baba Deep Singh fought in battles under Guru Gobind Singh. He fought with Shaheed Baba Banda Singh Bahadur in those early campaigns of the Khalsa Panth after Guru Jee's passing. He was the leader of one of the five Jathas of the Taruna Dal. He was the founding Jathedar of the Shaheed Misl. He fought in the lesser holocaust, the chota Ghallughara, and in all major Sikh battles up to his martyrdom. In 1757, the Durrani Afghanis were again on an invasion into the sub-continent. They came to Darbar Sahib and occupied the buildings. There were no Sikhs to stop them, or the Sikhs that were there thought they could do nothing to stop the occupation. Baba Deep Singh was at Damdama Sahib at the time and received news of the occupation of the buildings only a few weeks later. When he found out, what did he do? The key question is, what did he do that was any different from what Jarnail Singh did. Sikhs today would have had him sit back and allow the buildings to have been occupied. The Afghanis would use and abuse the buildings and, when it came time to leave, they would, leaving the buildings to be taken over again by the Khalsa. Sikhs today would say, fine, let them, as long as the complex is not destroyed. They would have Baba Deep Singh sit back and say to himself, "Hmmmm, maybe I should let them have it, if we cause problems, maybe some "beyadbee" will come to the buildings." But of course, he did not. The greater "beyadbee" is for the gurdwaras and the Takht of the Khalsa Panth to be under the control of anyone but the nation founded by Guru Nanak. Upon learning of the Afghani occupation, Baba Deep Singh set out with his students from the Taksaal at Damdama Sahib in southern Punjab. He was well into his seventies, an age when most would have left their warrior days behind. Of course, a Sikh warrior's days are never behind them. On the way to Amritsar up to five thousand Sikhs joined him. They met the Afghanis at Tarn Taran, about fifteen kilometers from Amritsar, where the battle began. There were at least twenty thousand Afghanis. Baba jee and all the other Sikhs fought bravely. We all know what happened to Baba Deep Singh. He received a sword blow to his neck and his head left his body. Despite this he kept on fighting, fulfilling a promise he had earlier made in front of the Guru Granth Sahib. He made it close to the Darbar Sahib Complex and fell there, throwing his head to the parkarma of the Darbar Sahib. Like in 1984 and 1764, the battle of 1757 was lost by the Sikhs. It was an impossible battle to win, one where the question, "why bother", would be asked. Why bother fighting a losing battle? Why go out and be slaughtered if you know your chances of success are slim to none? Why go and fight, if by fighting you are brining more destruction to the very buildings you are dying to protect? Well, firstly, an unwinnable battle has never been an excuse to not fight for the Nation of the Infinite. In fact, the great Sikhs, like Baba Deep Singh, will travel far distances and pray to God for the chance to be able to partake in such a battle. Yes, ultimately the buildings were destroyed (the Akal Takht Sahib has been destroyed seven times, eight now, and the Darbar Sahib twice), but the Khalsa tried it's everything to keep it free. Jagmeet Singh has already countered my above points to some extent. He has written that the situation of Baba Jarnail Singh in 1984 is not comparable to Baba Deep Singh's situation of 1757 and Bhai Gurbaksh Singh in 1764. Let us look at the situation of 1984 a little closer. For a better understanding of the situation one should read Jarnail Singh's own speeches, as translated by Ranbir Singh, or better yet, hear the originals. In 1982, four young students of the Damdami Taksaal were arrested by the police on trumped up charges. The Taksaal was been targeted because of Jarnail Singh's rising popularity, the success of the campaign of getting Sikhs to take Amrit, and the fast growing strength of the All India Sikh Students Federation (AISSF). Jarnail Singh had been head of the Damdami Taksaal, jatha Bhindran-Metha, since 1978 when Bhai Kartar Singh was killed in a supposed car accident. He deputed Kartar Singh's eldest son, Bhai Amrik Singh, to deal with the situation. Bhai Amrik Singh was also the President of the AISSF. The AISSF is an organization set up in the 1920's that had grown stagnant and useless over the years. After the emergency that Indira Gandhi had called in 1975 ended, largely due to the non-violent protest of the Sikhs, Bhai Amrik Singh was elected president in 1978 and he revitalized the foundering organization, the numbers of members in the Indian wide organization went up from ten thousand in 1978 to one hundred thousand by 1980. Those federation activists became the backbone of the movement that Baba Jarnail Singh and Bhai Amrik Singh were to lead. Bhai Amrik Singh, after going to make enquiries, was also arrested, again on false charges and sent to jail. Jarnail Singh then sent Baba Thara Singh to find out why these innocent Sikhs had been arrested, on what charges and for what reasons. Baba Thara Singh was one of the older members of the Damdami Taksaal, a respected Sikh, whose advice was sought after. He too was arrested. (On a side note, as prisoners, Bhai Amrik Singh and Baba Thara Singh caused the prison officials a lot of problems. All of the Sikh prisoners, who were in jail with them, would quickly renounce alcohol and drugs and to start keeping their hair. They would take amrit, and within a few weeks, the entire Sikh population of a jail would have become religious. They had to be moved from prison to prison. In one jail, where Amrik Singh and Thara Singh had a gurdwara built for the Sikhs, the Hindu inmates asked Baba Thara Singh for him to build something where they too could worship. Baba Thara Singh, of the Damdami Taksaal that the government has claimed again and again was anti-Hindu, then had a Mandir built in the prison for the Hindus.) Baba Jarnail Singh surveyed the situation and decided on a course of action. Six of the members of his Jatha had been arrested on false charges and were being tortured in jail. Two of them were the top Sikhs of the Taksaal. In mid-July 1982, he went to Akal Takht Sahib and there did an ardaas and launched a morcha against the government to secure the freedom of these six innocent Sikhs. Jarnail Singh was already hugely popular and many thousands had been administered amrit by the Damdami Taksaal in the previous few years, so the morcha quickly became a large-scale movement. Traditional Sikh leaders, specifically the Big Three of the Akali Dal, Chief Minister Parkash Singh (Badal), President of the SGPC Gurcharan Singh (Tohra) and President of the Akali Dal, Harchand Singh (Longowal), decided to start a panthic wide morcha and merge it with Jarnail Singh's morcha. They thought they could feed off the popularity of Jarnail Singh, that he would be under their control and that they could use him as a figurehead, a pawn of theirs. They underestimated his morals and principals and his ability to understand the wider situation, to comprehend what was really on the line. They especially failed to understand how intelligent he really was, something that western commentators have also done, believing this was just a "simple rustic preacher". All of them also discounted the ability of his "lieutenants". Bhai Amrik Singh galvanized the Sikh youth around India and was seen as a pious and deeply religious man. Harminder Singh (Sandu) had a brilliant organizational mind and it was he who organized many of the morcha's actions. Bhai Manvir Singh (Chaheru) and Bhai Surinder Singh (Sodhi) were trained in the police and army and they carried and planned out many of the covert actions that later became necessary when the government began to target innocent Sikhs. And of course former army General, Sahbeg Singh, who organized the defenses to the army action of June 1984. All of these Sikhs and many more were at the disposal of Jarnail Singh during the two yearlong morcha. The Akali Dal leaders named their morcha the Dharam Yudh Morcha or, translated, the Holy War Morcha. What is a morcha? When and why did they come into popularity with the Sikhs as a tool for political change? Morchas literally means an armed position in a war. In the past century it has come to mean a non-violent mass protest. Morchas were first used to free historical Gurdwaras from the control of the corrupt Hindu mahants, who were backed by the British Government, and to secure specific demands from the government. The first morcha was the Rikab Ganj Morcha, which began when the British tore down a wall of the Rikab Ganj Gurdwara in New Delhi, where Guru Tegh Bahadur Sahib's body had been consigned to flames, to build a road. After that first morcha, more and more morchas began until the government finally allowed the Sikhs to set up their own central body to govern Gurdwaras, the SGPC. Famous morchas were the Guru ka Bagh Morcha, Jaito Morcha (when the British officials of Nabha state stopped an Akhand path of the Guru Granth Sahib midway), Chabian da Morcha (when the keys to the toshakhana of the Darbar Sahib complex were confiscated) and, of course, the massacre at the Nankana Sahib Morcha. Later, after the British left the sub-continent, morchas were taken out soon after so called independence. One of the early ones was a morcha to be able to say Punjabi Suba (the new so-called democratic Indian government had banned the slogan of "Punjabi Suba Zindabaad", or "Long live the Punjab state", and then of course the long hard fought fight for Punjabi Suba itself. The morchas against Indira Gandhi's false 'emergency', which she imposed when the Supreme Court found her guilty of election fraud, are also famous. How is a morcha conducted? They work on a principle of non-violence. Sikhs would go out to the Gurdwara they were trying to free, or just out into the streets, and court arrest. The idea being, that the mass arrests and civil disobedience would force the government to cede to the demands. Also, the mass arrests would bring the government's prison and justice systems to a halt. Against the British, who weren't interested in the complete destruction of the Sikhs, and who did not partake in extra-judicial killings, torturing of innocent citizens and other excesses, the morchas were successful. But as the Indian Government grew more and more blatant in its effort to destroy the Sikhs, these morchas grew inefficient. The Dharm Yudh Morcha was taken out in order to bring about the Anandpur Sahib Resolution (ASR). The ASR written in 1972 at Anandpur Sahib, hence the name, made a long list of demands of the government. Many were small simple demands, like having a radio broadcast from Darbar Sahib, attaining holy city status for the city of Amritsar, renaming a train after the Darbar Sahib and other such things. But the key demands were much more serious in nature. They demanded that Chandigarh be given to Punjab, along with other Punjabi speaking areas left out of the 'Punjabi speaking Punjab' whose boundaries were drawn up in 1968 on a linguistic basis. Water rights were also integral to the Resolution. The free right to carry arms and the recognition of the Sikhs as a distinct nation (much as the Quebec sovereignists demand that French Canadians be recognized as a distinct nation). The key demand was that India be reorganized so that the states would have more autonomy from the center. It was envisioned that the center would only have control over foreign affairs, defense, currency and internal trade. Every thing else would be under the provision of the individual states. This was a demand that would have begun to solve many of the problems of the Indian state that had been more than obvious after the British had left the sub-continent in 1947. Panthic wide morchas were taken out in a very specific way. The panthic leaders would all make an ardaas at the Akal Takht, promising that they would not stop the morcha until the panth's demands were met. Then, the panthic leaders would stay in the Darbar Sahib complex, usually at Guru Nanak Nivaas or in the Sarais. Living at the Akal Takht was not unheard of and Jarnail Singh was not the first to stay there (also, he was forcibly kicked out of Guru Nanak Nivaas by the Babbar Khalsa under Sukhdev Singh, who had been told to do so by Bibi Amarjit Kaur of the Akhand Kirtani Jatha and Harchand Singh Longowal). Fateh Singh had also stayed in the Akal Takht when he was taking his supposed fasts unto death in the 1960's. As Jarnail Singh pointed out, Fateh Singh stayed on a bed in the Takht, while Jarnail Singh slept on the floor. In addition, Bhai Gurbakhsh Singh and his twenty-nine sathee Singhs also stayed in the Akal Takht. Living in the Takht itself was not a unique thing. On a daily basis, volunteer Sikhs would come in large numbers, go to Darbar Sahib and then go on to listen to speeches of the Panthic leaders and to kathaas, tadis, poems and other speeches. The morcha participants would then go do ardaas at Akal Takht and then go to court arrest. These Sikhs would come organized in groups, with a Jathedar at their head. This had become the pattern of running a morcha. The Dharam Yudh Morcha was taken out in the same way. Jarnail Singh started his morcha only for the release of the Sikhs of his jatha who were unjustly arrested. After the Panthic leaders started their morcha and joined it with the one Jarnail Singh already had going, he threw himself in full force with the panthic wide morcha. At the Akal Takht, all the Panthic leaders and Jarnail Singh did ardaas, saying they would never stop the morcha until the Panth's demands were met. As a leader of the morcha, Jarnail Singh stayed in the Darbar Sahib complex, just as leaders had for the last forty years and just as the different Akali Dal leaders were doing at the same time. His staying in the Darbar Sahib complex was exactly in line with Panthic tradition. Harchand Singh (Longowal), Gurcharan Singh (Tohra), Balwant Singh (Ramoowalia) and other panthic leaders were all staying in the complex as well. Many thought that once the Sikhs of the Damdami Taksaal had been released, Jarnail Singh would then stop his morcha or take a back seat position. When it became clear that his personality was taking over the morcha and that the masses were following him and not the old Akali Dal leaders, those leaders were hoping for such a turn of events. But, Jarnail Singh maintained that he was not going to go back on the ardaas he had made at the Akal Takht. Now, for those who have no respect for the Guru Granth Sahib, or for the Guru Khalsa Panth, taking an ardaas in front of the Guru and making a promise in front of the Guru is no big deal. But for those Sikhs who have respect for the Granth Sahib and think of it as their true Guru, such a promise must be fulfilled. Come what may, that promise must be kept. Just as Baba Deep Singh had made a promise to fight and free Darbar Sahib, just as Bhai Gurbakhsh Singh had made a promise to defend the Darbar Sahib complex whatever the circumstances, Jarnail Singh made a promise that he would keep the morcha going until its demands would be fulfilled. There could be no going back on a promise made before the Guru. There can be no negations on terms that one has decided on in front of Guruji. The Akali Dal leaders had no problem with going back on promises made before the Guru, promises they had made to the sangat again and again. Those same leaders who had said they would fight to their death for the Anandpur Sahib Resolution, quickly sold out the Sikh people in negotiations with the Centre, ignoring many of the key demands of the Resolution. When Harchand Singh signed the Rajiv-Longowal accord in 1985, he had gone back on most of the promises he had made in front of the Guru. Except for Longowal, many of these Akali Dal politicians are now leaders in the Punjab Government and have not even tried to bring about one the demands of the Anandpur Sahib Resolution, forget the major demands, not even the minor ones. The number of promises that Chief Minister Parkash Singh himself has broken would be a mile long. But Jarnail Singh was no Badal. A promise that he made in front of the Guru Granth Sahib could never be broken. He had made a promise that he would bring about the demands of the Dharam Yudh Morcha, or die trying, and he did just that. As I stated earlier, Indira Gandhi's response to the Dharam Yudh Morcha, ensured that it would not be successful. In the old days they would arrest the Sikhs, thereby putting them into the justice system. What Gandhi began to do, was to release the morcha participants right away, without charging them. While they released the common Sikhs, the police would keep the leaders of the morchas in jail and torture or kill them. This served completely to nullify the tactics of the morcha. As the police, the Hindu right wing organizations and the Hindu governments of neighbouring states to Punjab, especially Haryana and Rajasthan, began to target Sikhs more and more, Jarnail Singh became increasingly the man that the Sikhs turned to for assistance and protection. What he did in that situation is also widely misunderstood, but to get into that right now would be going too far off the topic. Let us now look at another common criticism of Jarnail Singh concerning the destruction of Darbar Sahib. Many bring up the point of the carrying of arms by Jarnail Singh and other Sikhs who were with him. They also criticize the armed encampments and fortifications built into the Darbar Sahib complex by Shaheed General Sahbeg Singh. Some quotes of Guru Gobind Singh should help clear up the point. He should be the expert on what is and what is not allowed for the Khalsa. Guru Gobind Singh Sahib has said: "Panj hathiar bahn keh, darshan koh avana." "Wearing five arms then come and do my darshan." Many critics of the Khalsa say that a kirpan is a useless weapon in the modern world. That one cannot do anything with a kirpan. I hate to use this as an example, but the terrorists of September 11, 2001 did quite a lot with just box cutters. A kirpan, of a decent size and of good quality, is the bare minimum of personal defense. With one, a person can at least defend himself or herself or defend others who are in distress. In a choice between nothing and a kirpan, a kirpan can help in an emergency. It is the least the Khalsa should wear on themselves. If you are able, and if the situation thus requires, a Sikh of the Guru should wear more weapons on their person. Guru jee asks for at lest five. Guru Gobind Singh further writes: "Binaa shashtre keshang narang bhaid jannoh. Ghai kahn teh pakreh leh saidahnoh. Eh morh aagya sunoh meraih pyareh Bina tegangh keshang divoh nah deedareh" Which translates as, “Without weapons and uncut hair a person is but like a sheep. Held by the ear they can be taken anywhere. Listen to this command of mine, my beloved: Without a sword and uncut hair, do not come into my presence.” Weapons are integral for attaining sovereignty. As Mao said, "Power comes through the barrel of a gun." Guru jee made an incredibly astute statement on the role of politics, religion and weapons in the following quote. This quote is the central guiding principle of Sikh polity: "Tabh in bhinoh Gareeb navaj Shashtren keh adeehn heh raj Raj binah neh dharma chaleh heh Dharam binah sabh dhaleh maleh heh" The translation of which would be “The Protector of the Poor says Weapons are the key to sovereignty Without sovereignty religions cannot flourish Without religion all are completely destroyed." The above three quotes are of Guru Gobind Singh jee's hand. I wonder if those who criticize Jarnail Singh for arming himself and for putting up fortifications around Darbar Sahib would have it in them to criticize Guru Gobind Singh. In this ongoing debate, some one has also brought up the point that Guru Har Gobind made sure not to fight in the Darbar Sahib complex, that he first sent a small contingent of Sikhs out to fight at Lohgarh the night before the main battle and then the next day the battle took place at a village close to Amritsar. Guru Har Gobind had a strong fort built on the outskirts of the city. He had control of all of Amritsar and many of the adjoining villages. It is not comparable to draw a parallel between this and the 1984 situation. The Sikhs did not have control of all of Amritsar in 1984. If they did, they would have, for sure, ensured that the battle took place far from the Darbar Sahib complex, hopefully on the out skirts of the city. But how could a few hundred fighters ever hope to defend and fortify an entire city when they had no control of it? Remember also that the army made the first move. They surrounded the complex completely and then attacked. On the Sahaheedi Purb of Guru Arjun Sahib at that. A strange choice considering the huge number of devotees who always come and visit the Gurdwara on that day. The battlefield was not Jarnail Singh and Sahbeg Singh's to decide. Could the attack on the Darbar Sahib Complex and the Akal Takht been avoided. Yes, if the government had ceded to the legitimate and just demands of the Sikhs. If they had not started to kill hundreds of Sikhs in torture cells and false encounters (the number of innocent Sikhs killed from 1980 to 1984 was up to 300 by the time of Blue Star), if they did not set up riots in Hindu dominated States (read Haryana) that targeted Sikhs. If young Sikh women were not raped by police and armed forces. If Guru Granth Sahib's were not desecrated. Sikhs today blame Jarnail Singh for the escalating nature of the conflict. They blame him for brining about the attack on the Darbar Sahib when all he ever did was try and show the Sikhs that they were slaves in the Indian system and tried to defend the Sikhs against illegal killings and tortures. If the Operation BlueStar attack was truly done in order to stop the so-called terrorists that had holed themselves up in the Darbar Sahib Complex, then why attack on Guru Arjun Shaheedi purb. Why trap thousands of innocent Sikhs in the complex. Why pretend to be the Red Cross and when people come out for assistance, shoot them dead? Why enact a statewide curfew and a full media blackout? Why stop trains to and from Amritsar? And most importantly, why attack up to 80 other Gurdwaras on the same day? Was Jarnail Singh in all of them? Had he made fortifications in all of those Gurdwaras, over half of which were historical Gurdwaras? Why, after having killed thousands of Sikhs and destroying the Akal Takht, did the army burn down the Sikh reference library, which contained over 1,000 historical Guru Granth Sahib Birs and other texts, many of which were signed and authenticated by the Gurus? Which contained the writings of the Gurus, the arms and clothing of the Gurus and famous Sikhs. Which contained treaties and government orders of the Independent Khalsa Nation from hundreds of years ago. Why burn that down? Why attack all of those Gurdwaras? Those who say again and again that Jarnail Singh was a pawn in a larger game, or claim that he is to blame for the destruction of the Akal Takht and the death and misery that was to descend upon Punjab in 1984 and after, really do need carefully study the history of events before coming to conclusions. One of the biggest problems the panth faces today, and we do face many, is that we lack an ability to look at our history, put its events into context and learn from them so that we do not make the same mistakes again and again. Concerning the modern day situation, we need to take a step back and look at the policies of the Indian state in relation to the Sikhs. Learn about how the government has treated us, and is. See how much they respect us, how much care they have for our freedom, our liberty and our lives. Jarnail Singh is not the man who caused the destruction of the Akal Takht. He is the man who died defending it so that the Khalsa Nation could be woken from its century long slumber and again walk the path of personal sovereignty and independence for itself and for all the peoples of the world. He should not be blamed, but praised, as a shinning example of what a true Sikh is and how a true Sikh lives. Baba Deep Singh, Bhai Gurbakhsh Singh and now Jarnail Singh. These are some of the heroes of the Khalsa nation, who gave their heads to try and maintain the freedom of the Akal Takht, but never backed down on their principles. If only we had more Sikhs like them. We wouldn't be nearly as badly off as we are now. December 14th, 2001

Re: Bhindranwale

ns · 24 Mar 2005

Waheguru Ji ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji ke Fateh Santbir Singh Jeeo , excellent points exactly Sikhs and especially upcoming generations of Sikhs need to read and read history and the your points above before making any statements on Jarnail Singh Ji and other Shaheeds of 1984. Common sense , it was common sense to defend Darbar Sahib

Re: Bhindranwale

in need of clarification · 25 Mar 2005

beautiful

Re: Bhindranwale

etka · 26 Mar 2005

Sant Baba Jarnail Singh ji Khalsa Bhindrawalle was a Sant, a Mahapurkh, and a fauji siphai. He was the epidimy of what every sikh should want to be. He was perfect in every attribute, flaw less in character. Sant Jarnail Singh ji, is quite definatly a sant, his gian was wow. But this does not make him better or equal to Maharaj Sahib Siri Guru Granth Sahib ji the owner of the universe. This is where ppl who are against Sants (fake or just against the title sant) take advantage of the situation. Sant ji did not hide in Sahib Siri Akaal takht sahib or guru nanak niwaas. He went there 2 preach to the masses, so he could have a greater concentration of ppl to preach to. He had every right and hakh to be there. India planned this attack out for many yrs, and Sant ji has courted arrest on 2 occasions and released soon after on both events. If he was not a Sant then what was he? what attribute did he lack? maybe i agree (very slightly) that Sant may not be the correct title, if not then its quite definatly Baba Jarnail Singh ji, cause he was quite definatly up there wtih the likes of Baba Deep Singh ji, Baba Banda Bahadur Singh ji. His humility showed it, his love and devotion to Sahib Khalsa Panth showed it, his seva of Guru ji showed it..... Sant Jarnail Singh ji Khalsa ZINDABAAD.

Re: Bhindranwale

troubled · 26 Mar 2005

santbir singh bhaji your article was very long! BUT well worth the read. i for one can say that i learnt a lot from reading it. thankyou for taking the time out to post such an enlightening piece of work. nobody is gna get anything from debating whether anyone, not just Sant Jarnail Singh ji was a Sant or not, so why argue "yes he was" "no he wasnt" this brings no pyaar and unity between us. no true GurSikh wants to be called 'Sant' - that is not being humble. nimrata is one of the most important values of Sikhism and what is more humble than placing yourself at peoples feet never mind our Guru's? for a man of Jarnail Singh jis stature and spirituality to deny people from calling himself a Sant shows how humble he was thus showing that he was a PROPA GURSIKH. To all those people arguing, "why did he say not to call himself a Sant?" - if he was to say "YES i AM a sant!" the majority of u would say: a real Sant would never say that, a real Sant would be humble, etc etc...so claiming to be a Sant or not claiming to be a Sant is pointless becoz with you, he will not be able to win eitherway...you will swing the argument from one point to another contradicting yourselves. i am probably the poorest example of a Sikh i dont evn think that i can be called a Sikh, however, I am learning. i dont follow a jatha i see no difference between a Bubber, an AKJ or a Taksaali (probably becoz i dont know the differences between them), but i feel those people that keep shifting their argument and contradicting their opinions/principles to say Jarnail Singh ji wasn't a Sant are adament on saying it becoz they dont believe in and dont agree with Jarnail Singh ji's jatha. as for those who say he shouldn't have been in Harmandir Sahib, who are YOU to say who stays in Harmandir Sahib n who doesnt??? if during your time of need someone told you that you should leave Harmandir Sahib or any other Gurdwara how wud u feel?and more importantly how wud u reply??how many of you, when it comes to exams, tests, interviews, fights or any other time of need turn to your Guru???when our panth was in need thats exactly what Jarnail Singh ji n his other Shaheed Singhs did - no one has the right to condemn them. operation Bluestar was a terrible thing n i cant imagine how Indira Gandhi and her other perpretrators are gna suffer in the punsihment they will receive becoz it will be SEVERE BEYOND our imagination. but operation Bluestar woke up so many people, Sant ji woke up so many people, it was with the shaheedi of so many innocent victims in our spiritual home on a gurpurb of all days, that we as a people realised what kind of government we were under: those Sikhs who were opposed to the idea of Khalistaan become pro-Khalistaan; those "Sikhs" who were drinking smoking - "sessioning" tuk their amrit and became SIKHS; those so-called Sikhs like myself grew more of a love and desire for the religion i knew little about. if Sant Ji had left Darbaar Sahib n fought elsewhere with just his men who wouldve cared? would we as a nation wake up n say "hold on, we're Guru Gobind Singh Ji's children, we shouldnt be treated like this" n stand our ground? would the rest of the world (even though they forgot) think "that government is EVIL" "the indian government is wrong" "those people (Sikhs) were INNOCENT"??? the truth is NO nobody wud have thought that at all. we are the first ones to put each other down, never mind the rest of the world - we would all have thought "SIKH TERRORISTS!"causing trouble, giving us all a bad name, making our lives hell". even though that was what 84 led to...but it DIDNT LEAD to that - that treatment was always there. it was the events of 84 that highlighted it amongst us in a bid to unite us. but 20 years on are we united? we all say the events were terrible but are we united in making a difference in making a change? NO...all we focus is on debating about which jatha is right n which is wrong, who is a Sant n who isnt n who is to blame for 84...wen its plain n simple (for a bimbo like me) that "the Gandhi's n their disgusting,merried men" were in the wrong n they will suffer n pay the price for what they did - there is no point in arguing whether SANT JARNAIL SINGH JI should've been there or not it will not change anything it will not change the past it will not make the events of 84 disappear it will not change the way our brothers and sisters were treated all those factors still remain. there is no point in arguing if anyone is a Sant or not, we are not spiritual enough to see or decide that. the only thing we should be doing is try to be Sants ourselves, like Guru Ji told us to be, from there we'l be able to become True Warriors not just fighters, and maybe one day we'l be able to defend ourselves in a way that would make our father proud no matter whether we 'won' the battle or 'lost' it. lets learn from these threads - we are not doing ourselves any good arguing over things that have been debated many times over and over again - no1 ever wins. lets love and respect each other n class ourselves as Guru ke Sikh rather than taksaali, akjs, bubbers, akalis etc etc - we are our Guru's Sikhs first and foremost, every other label comes after that. sorry if i offended anyone - it was not my intention, please forgive your big mouthed overtly opinionated sister!! WAHEGURU JI KA KHALSA! WAHEGURU JI KI FATHEH! P.S it is rather long!sorry i alwys waffle, u shud see my essays! :P [%sig%]

Re: Bhindranwale

Sikhi · 27 Mar 2005

Sat Sri Akaal, You made a Good post "Troubled" All i got to say is that true Gurus Kirpa i found our great leader Sant Jarnail Singh Bhindranwale. Sometimes when i do things which i shouldn’t i pick my Gutka and try to understand my fault. Then i read about our great Shaheedis who died for our future which mostly is about '84. About how a Great Sikh, Sant Baba Jarnail Singh Bhindranwale. He inspires me a lot.

Re: Bhindranwale

afas · 31 Mar 2005

i nominate santbir singh's post as one of the best all time on this forum

Re: Bhindranwale

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 01 Apr 2005

I second Afas on that. Santbir Singh Ji veer has done a good job. Stay in Chardikalla. Jarnail Singh