Skip to content
ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥
Forum
Harimandir Sahib to Be Controlled by Govt: UNESCO
Harimandir Sahib to Be Controlled by Govt: UNESCO
news · 23 Mar 2005
Golden Temple upkeep lies with state: UNESCO
Tribune News Service
Amritsar, March 23
The communication of Ms J. Okahashi, a senior official of UNESCO, has confirmed that after according the world heritage status to the Golden Temple, the primary responsibility of its management and protection would be with the state.
With this, the proposed status to the Golden Temple may run into rough weather even as the SGPC chief, Bibi Jagir Kaur, had urged UNESCO to hold the process in abeyance.
A communication addressed to Dr Jasdev Singh Rai, Director, Sikh Human Rights Group (SHRG), Ms Okahashi stated that “the World Heritage Convention is an intergovernmental instrument ratified by states. According to this convention the responsibility for protecting heritage sites within a certain country belongs primarily to the state authorities. As for how, within the various levels of the government, non-government or local communities, this protection is actually operated, this is an internal matter. What matters, with respect to the WH Convention, is that this protection be effective in safeguarding universal values claimed by the nominating state when submitting a file for inscription on the world heritage list”.
The UNESCO official also stated that “a particular approach and wide consultation of all stakeholders is of course always recommended to ensure that the conservation objectives proposed in the nomination are shared by the local communities and are therefore sustainable”.
Re: Harimandir Sahib to Be Controlled by Govt: UNESCO
a singh · 23 Mar 2005
"...the primary responsibility of its management and protection would be with the state..."
the state!!
does that mean with the goi??
Re: Harimandir Sahib to Be Controlled by Govt: UNESCO
Singh · 23 Mar 2005
we've become a community of eunuchs. The "state" ie. the govt. first attacked Sri Darbar Sahib and massacred thousands of Sikhs, now we happily offer them control. Great! Akal Takhat Sahib, our seat of Temporal Authority, will be controlled from Delhi.
Re: Harimandir Sahib to Be Controlled by Govt: UNESCO
S Singh · 24 Mar 2005
This is all spin. "As for how, within the various levels of the government, non-government or local communities, this protection is actually operated, this is an internal matter."
In Punjab Haryana and Himachal the SGPC is vested with looking after the Gurdwara. There will be no change to this. The SGPC cannot do anything without the DCs consent anyway so nothing will change.
The only thing that will change is that the ongoing bodge ups by kar seva wale will come to an end. No longer will they be able to whitewash centuries old wall paintings or cover them with bathroom tiles.
Re: Harimandir Sahib to Be Controlled by Govt: UNESCO
sikh · 24 Mar 2005
finally you lot will wake up and do something and all those sikhs who said darbar sahib would not be controlled by the government it will be.....we shall have no control sat sangat ji i beg at ur feet please start to speak up and stop this process dead in its tracks this is not good for us............
Re: Harimandir Sahib to Be Controlled by Govt: UNESCO
sikh · 24 Mar 2005
s singh
are u blind? u must be bilnd if you can't see what this unesco status means for darbar sahib and the kaum as a whole
Re: Harimandir Sahib to Be Controlled by Govt: UNESCO
Bhopinder · 24 Mar 2005
The SGPC cannot do anything without the DCs consent anyway so nothing will change.
-------------------------------------___________________________
That is right so as it is ,it is already being run by GOI.
I guess their is no choice
Re: Harimandir Sahib to Be Controlled by Govt: UNESCO
S Singh · 24 Mar 2005
sikh
No I am not blind. I have seen how the Guru Ghar in the Harmandir Sahib complex have been destroyed by kar seva wale. Those who cannot see the damage done and the benefits of WHS are blind. I would rather have WHS and our heritage protected than having the continued destruction of our precious heritage !
WHS will at last offer some protection to our heritage before it is too late and as Bhopinder paaji has written the DC can do what he wants currently. To date the DCs have not interfered despite the legal authority to over rule the SGPC. What will change with WHS ? The GOI will not change the situation on the ground.
Re: Harimandir Sahib to Be Controlled by Govt: UNESCO
Bhopinder · 25 Mar 2005
the main thing is to finish the control of dc
as they dont control mandirs and churchs