Re: In Need of Urgent Advice!!
Gurcharan Singh Kulim · 02 Apr 2005
The issue is really simple.Is your dharri flowing ?If it is flowing, then you must tied it up.You dont have to use a net.
According to the dress code of the Indian armed service the dharri must be tied up.
This code is also aplicable to the Sikh personnel in the Malaysian and Singaporean Armed forces.
This may the same code that is being used for UK.
The code was implemented from the time the British took over the Punjab.
The issue is now do you want to challenge the recognised code and get an exemption to allow Sikhs to have free flowing beards in the forces.You will have fight this through the courts.But rememeber there is legislation already there about the rights of Sikhs.Having a free flowing beard on duty is not one of them.
In fact a few years back two Sikh airmen of the Indian Airforce were disciplined for not having their beard according to the dress code regulations-i.e.tied up.They did not win their argument.The chair of the discipline committee was a Sikh himself.
I think for practical reasons it would not be advisable to have a free flowing beard in the services, unless it is very very short naturally.
I think we cannot have it all our way all the time,there is a dress code ..please follow it.It should not be hard.
You have the right to be amritdharri, and carry a small kirpan under your uniform.
I would not suggest at all you give up your job, in fact I would urge you to serve in the police earnestly like the Sikhs are known to all over the world.But follow the code.
All the best, and think rationally, but dont argue when you have no grounds to.
Gurcharan Singh Kulim
Re: In Need of Urgent Advice!!
Gurcharan Singh Kulim · 02 Apr 2005
The issue is really simple.Is your dharri flowing ?If it is flowing, then you must have it tied up.You dont have to use a net.
According to the dress code of the Indian armed service the dharri must be tied up.
Also, practically, it is advantageous for you, as in a confrontaional situation,a foe will head staright for the beard.And once with that in hand, it can not only cause you harm and injury, but also the mental embarrassment and pain.
This code is also applicable to the Sikh personnel in the Malaysian and Singaporean Armed forces.It is also applicable in Tahiland for their Sikh servicemen.
So you can see there is already a legistlation in force which is also recognised for the Sikh personnel serving in the United Nations Forces.My father in law was one of the first Sikh officers from Malaysia that served in the UN Forces in Katanga -Congo.He said he had this legislation booklet.This may the same code that is being used for UK for Sikh servicemen.It also allows the individual to appear well groomed.
(Some may argue this point, however, I am being practical,I am a practising Sikh myself, so I am s esitive to the issues)
The code was implemented from the time the British took over the Punjab, and Sikh enlisted in the army.Many Sikhs in the Maharajah Ranjit Singh army as well have been seen with beards tied up-for practical reasons.
The issue is now, do you want to challenge the recognised code and seek an exemption to allow Sikhs to have free flowing beards in the forces.You will have to fight this through the courts.
But rememeber there is legislation already existing about the rights of Sikhs. But having a free flowing beard on duty is not one of the rights.The issue for the Sikhs is NOT to cut the beard.The practice according to old paramparra is to keep the beard flowing.It is not enshrined in the rehat maryada(legislation that courts will use)that the beard of a Sikh HAS to be flowing.
In fact a few years back two Sikh airmen of the Indian Airforce were disciplined for not having their beard according to the dress code regulations-i.e.tied up.They did not win their argument.The chair of the discipline committee was a Sikh himself.They had to adhere to the dress code.
I think for practical reasons it would not be advisable to have a free flowing beard in the services, unless it is very very short naturally.
I think we cannot have it all our way all the time,there is a dress code ...please follow it.It should not be hard.
You have the right to be amritdharri, and carry a small kirpan under your uniform.That they cannot argue about.
I would not suggest at all you give up your job, in fact I would urge you to serve in the police earnestly like the Sikhs are known to all over the world.But follow the code.
All the best, and think rationally, but dont argue when you have no grounds to, listen, think, rationalise and suggest that you will have to go away and seek advice.
Yopu can also get advice from the METROPOLITAN SIKH ASSOCIATION,LONDON
Gurcharan Singh Kulim
Re: In Need of Urgent Advice!!
AT the end... · 04 Apr 2005
Gursikh don't make an issue of it. Be polite to the trainer. You have'nt even started the job yet, and yes it is likely to get yanked if you are assaulted. If that happens you could get in a headlock. Remember as a PCSO you don't have CS spray or baton or even restraint cuffs. If you have to defend yourself, it's up to you, your radio and your bare hands.
Put it in a net. You're just going to mark yourself out as a troublemaker if you go to the Sikh association, even if you win on this trivial point.
Re: In Need of Urgent Advice!!
Gurcharan Singh Kulim · 04 Apr 2005
This is amzing!A simple question was asked.It deserved a simple and practical solution and suggestions.
Instead we see as usual Sikhs making up their own rules.
Bhai sahib,the law is clear as I have explained.Just as I have said, if you want to be the centre of a controversy and make a scene, to demand you be allowed a flowing dharra, the choice is yours.
If you want to follow and agree there are certain regulations to neat keeping of the beard and represent the Sikh image positively, the choice is again yours.
Nobody is asking you remove your dharra,the health and safety officer has a duty to inform you of the regulations and rules ,and of health and safety.If you continue to flout them, the issue could become of a disciplinary nature.
That would be all together a different arena.You will not win because of the existing legislation about Sikh appearance in the services.
The references they will used against you, would be the armed forces existing legislation from all the countries where Sikhs serve as service men.
I would suggest you follow the legislation and represent the SIKH IMAGE POSITIVELY.
However if you seek to change that legislation,I also wish you good luck in your fight, an uphill fight.
Good Luck.GURFATEH
Gurcharan SiNGh KULIM
Re: In Need of Urgent Advice!!
Birmingham Singh · 07 Apr 2005
What area are you based in. What force are u training with?
because forces like met and west mids have good links with the communitties and this has never been mentioned in all the recruitment drives they have done at camps, sikh soc events and gurdwara diwans, so it would be interesting to find out if this is just the trainers interpretation or is infact police policy, if it is policy and you are based in West mids maybe i can help as through my previous employment a collegue of mine had to assess the polciies of the west mids police to see if they were all culturally sound and equal in policy etc.
hope this helps
Re: In Need of Urgent Advice!!
To Mr Policeman · 07 Apr 2005
I completely sympathise with your situation. I like you agree it is very important to have the dhari flowing. But at the same time there are problems with your work. I suggest you do as much research and talk to as many people as possible then come to a conclusion - I think either way your love for Sikhi will be recognised by Guru Ji. But do try to keep you dhari as it is. Have you considered, tucking it under your uniform or something? (dont laugh!) I'm sure theres some way to get round it.