Niddar vs Uptej Singh 1998 Hola Mohalla
.................. · 02 Apr 2005
The much awaited film of the fight between Niddar vs Uptej Singh at 1998 Hola Mohalla
http://www.sikhiserver.com/UptejSinghvsNihangNiddarSingh.htm
Uptej singh knock Niddar stick out of his hands, Niddar, starts wrestling, and Uptej singh gets on top. Everyone rushes in.......
Re: Niddar vs Uptej Singh 1998 Hola Mohalla
kar kirpaa sabh rayN thheevaa · 02 Apr 2005
the link doesn't work
and when you go to the main site, the webmaster has linked a file on his own computer
and the file is not uploaded onto the website
Re: Niddar vs Uptej Singh 1998 Hola Mohalla
BirRaas Singh · 02 Apr 2005
I personally thought that Niddar Singh won the "fight" (if thats wat it was), Uptej Singhs hands are checked on a number of occasions, a hooj to the head, and a clear strike to the head is seen (although not fully executed for whatever reason), the stick is still in the hands of Niddar Singh as he rushes Uptej Singh, which he then delivers several "katari hath" to his collar bone & neck, Uptej is choked, and then Uptej Singh does a reversal to break the choke but Niddar Singh shows no resistance and flows over with the pull allowing him to gain top position when on the ground, then the fight is stopped.
Respect to both fighters however.
Re: Niddar vs Uptej Singh 1998 Hola Mohalla
Waheguroo! Network · 02 Apr 2005
Waheguroo Ji Ka Khalsa
Waheguroo Ji Ki Fateh
We have uploaded the video on http://www.khalsa.tv as the orginal link went down. We want to make it clear that all the credits for uploading and making this video belong to www.SikhiServer.com and we are only hosting the video for the Sikh Sangat. The quality on the video is low so if SikhiServer sevadaars want to do the seva of encoding the video again we will be more than happy to host that file aswell.
Waheguroo Ji Ka Khalsa
Waheguroo Ji Ki Fateh
Re: Niddar vs Uptej Singh 1998 Hola Mohalla
BirRaas Singh · 03 Apr 2005
hmm, whino could you please elaborate on what "special circumstances" are are reffering to, because i have no idea on what your on about. Dont be shy, you can say what you think. :)
Re: Niddar vs Uptej Singh 1998 Hola Mohalla
can't think of a name.. · 03 Apr 2005
Author: whino
Date: 04-02-05 20:18
I think Bir Ras Singh was facing some of those 'special' circumstances that Niddar and gang refer to, before watching this video. Only in such an inebriated state could one think that Niddar 'won.'
*****
Hmm ok, BirRaas Singh has given his ‘analysis’ on what happened, why don't you give us what you see (i.e. go through the moves and clarify how Uptej Singh won)..
Thanks.
Re: Niddar vs Uptej Singh 1998 Hola Mohalla
mrsinghsahib · 03 Apr 2005
Link does work - u have to do "save as" for it to work.
Waheguroo
Re: Niddar vs Uptej Singh 1998 Hola Mohalla
jaspal singh · 03 Apr 2005
the link doesnt work - can someone pls provide specific instructions to watch this movie clip.
many thanks
jaspal
Re: Niddar vs Uptej Singh 1998 Hola Mohalla
Ravinder Singh · 03 Apr 2005
This is how I saw it..
Uptej singh starts off with a rapid multiple and accurate attack.. Niddar singh is on the back foot and gets hit several times.
Niddar seems a bit dazzled by the attack and seems to then loose his cool.
He drops(or its hit out of his hand) his stick and goes to grab Uptej.
A scuffle ensues and Niddar ends up behind Uptej, holding him in a choke. Uptej then drops Niddar with an over-shoulder throw.
They both quickly scramble to their feet and seem to hold each other by the neck before it is broken up(may have been some strikes but is hard to tell).
Overall Niddar looks slow and cumbersome whereas Uptej looks superior in skill and speed.
At the end Niddar looks really angry and somewhat embarrassed.
Both fighters had a lot of spirit.
Chardi Kalaa!!
Re: Niddar vs Uptej Singh 1998 Hola Mohalla
Search For Tat · 04 Apr 2005
Did Niddar ever accept that challenge from the kickboxer singh from east London?
Re: Niddar vs Uptej Singh 1998 Hola Mohalla
jugroop singh · 04 Apr 2005
VahiGuruJiKaKhalsa,VahiGuruJiKiFateh!
Sadh Sangat Jio,
All i know of practical martial arts is a few judo lessons donkey's years ago, a short period of Wing-Tsun Gung Fu not so long ago and about 4-5 lessons of Niddar's Shastarvidiya...finding the time to stick to martial arts is a nightmare for me because of current committments but i will definitely be going back to Wing-Tsun lessons soon which, in my limited opinion, is easily the most practical and effective when it comes to unarmed/armed (but thats a seperate discussion).
What has most interested me in terms of reading over the years is the honour/discipline/spiritual element of martial arts.
Veer Ravinder Singh Ji writes:
'Uptej singh starts off with a rapid multiple and accurate attack.. Niddar singh is on the back foot and gets hit several times.
Niddar seems a bit dazzled by the attack and seems to then loose his cool. He drops(or its hit out of his hand) his stick and goes to grab Uptej. A scuffle ensues and Niddar ends up behind Uptej, holding him in a choke. Uptej then drops Niddar with an over-shoulder throw.
They both quickly scramble to their feet and seem to hold each other by the neck before it is broken up(may have been some strikes but is hard to tell)'.
That is a decent description of events. However, althought the clip is only 1:13 in duration, there are a no. of elements present within the bout which are worth deconstructing and analysing. i view the encounter as a series of stages:
- pre-battle
- initial stick-play
- charge
- grapple
- end of bout
- post-battle
>Pre-battle
Both display their pre-battle display and are on the same footing, albeit Niddar has a long whilst Uptej Singh has a short stick. Both, with one stick in hand, face-off.
>Initial stick-play
Niddar makes the first approach although he does not wish to make contact at this point; then, and i don't think anyone can argue with this point, Uptej Singh advances very speedily with a series of blows (which may have made accurate and effective contact). Whilst doing so, he spins around once, showing Niddar his back...
>Charge
Noting Uptej Singh's first spin, Niddar decides to wait for Uptej Singh to do this again...Uptej Singh does so and gives Niddar the opportunity to utilise this relatively short amount of time, where Uptej Singh is spinning around, in order to charge him.
It becomes obvious at this point that Niddar does not want this bout to continue via stick-play but rather wants to grapple; perhaps noting Uptej Singh's speed and the initial flurry, he decides that the most effective way he can influence this bout is by charging and then relying upon his close quarter combat techniques and sheer strength. Uptej Singh's second spin gives him this opprotunity.
>Grapple
It is possible that Niddar felt Uptej Singh did not have the same level of strength as him nor knowledge of grappling; therefore according to this rationale, by subverting the bout to a grappling match, he may have felt this would leave him with a distinct adavantage.
Both sticks are dropped/knocked and Niddar then makes his major move - he manages to place Uptej Singh in a choke hold, squarely from behind, with himself in an ideal position. My opinion is that he definitely wanted it to end with a complete and physically unconditional submission on Uptej Singh's part - the fact that Niddar goes for a chokehold is indicative of this.
However, and this is what struck me as most noticeable during the grapple, Uptej Singh in a very calm and controlled manner, readies himself, raises his arms and obtaining a good grip behind Niddar's neck, throws him straight over. Please remember, this is no easy thing to do; staying calm during a firmly established choke-hold is very difficult. Niddar seemingly decides to 'roll with it'; technically a good idea and the right decision in such a situation...
However, the ideal outcome for him would have been to take control of the ensuing conditions and strengthen his reins. He doesn't manage to do this and in fact, only manages to get up AFTER Uptej Singh has not only got up but also placed both his hands on Niddar's neck thereby assuming the dominant position.
This presents the crucial moment at which Niddar is most vunerable to anything Uptej Singh may have chosen to do i.e. strikes to the eyes, elbows to the upper/mid region, knees to the lower/mid region etc. If Uptej Singh had wanted to, and this is strictly my opinion, he could have inflcited somes serious damage at this point. For whatever reasons, Uptej Singh decided not to do so; instead he is content with holding Niddar's neck.
Niddar then reciprocates by also placing both hands on Uptej Singh's neck. Sadly, from the video, it is not possible to see what kind of strikes, grips are being delivered to the face/neck/upper bodies of the fighters as the framing does not give us an opportunity. All that can be seen, just before they are seperated, is that Niddar's face is being firmly pushed away to his right hand side; we cannot assess in what manner Niddar may or may not have subdued Uptej Singh because this is not visible (camera is behind Niddar).
>End of bout
Some Singhs step-in and slowly but surely manage to seperate the two. It is not obvious during this who is maintaining or lessening their grip amongst the two fighters.
>Post battle
The following is interesting if we wish to look at it from a psychological perspective. Uptej Singh is the first to recover his weapon and perform neccesary Satkaar. Niddar does so himself only after noticing Uptej Singh doing so.
As a side-note, i can't tell if Niddar takes his Kirpaan out at this point as he turns away from Uptej Singh and then places it back into his gatra, or whether he picked it up off the floor and is now placing it into his gatra.
Niddar then turns away whilst Uptej Singh walks towards him in order to shake hands and, in true Sant-Sipahi tradition, to bring a civil climax to proceedings.
Anyway, based upon this simple analysis, i personally conclude the following, which is based upon what was achieved and who was 'physically dominant', or who displayed more 'spiritual discipline', at the end of that particular stage:
(- pre-battle > n/a)
- initial stick-play > Uptej Singh (dominance)
- charge > Niddar (dominance)
- grapple > Uptej Singh (dominance)
- end of bout > Uptej Singh (discipline)
- post-battle > Uptej Singh (discipline)
Niddar - 1/5
Uptej Singh - 4/5
I'm sure many may not agree with this way of looking at it but please feel free to respond. Indeed it would be interesting to discuss the finer points.
VahiGuruJiKaKhalsa,VahiGuruJiKiFateh!
Re: Niddar vs Uptej Singh 1998 Hola Mohalla
BirRaas Singh · 04 Apr 2005
Good analysis by Jagroop Singh, but i am more inclined to agree with "Singh" above, when sparring with non live weapons its very easy to not acknowledge strikes, when live knives, tulwars are used everything is super slow and each move has to be extremely calculated. The way Uptej Singh charged in with the short stick representing a tulwar would have been suicidal had it been real weapons.
I personally am pretty shocked at how relaxed Niddar Singhs approach to this "fight" actually was, it seems that they only got serious when Uptej Singh lands a strike to their bicep. I dont think the winner of this bout will ever be decided, my respects to both fighters and I hope that one day they can sqaure off in true Khalsa tradition and learn from each other.
Re: Niddar vs Uptej Singh 1998 Hola Mohalla
Search For Tat · 04 Apr 2005
Sorry!! but Singhs posts reeks of pure bias for Niddar.
I think he should watch the video again.
Also no one has answered whether Niddar has ever accepted the challenge by the kickboxer?
Re: Niddar vs Uptej Singh 1998 Hola Mohalla
can't think of a name.. · 04 Apr 2005
Oh come on, we all know any post that favours one Singh over the other is going to 'reek of pure bias’ to any supporters of the 'other side'.. :p
Peace.
[%sig%]
Re: Niddar vs Uptej Singh 1998 Hola Mohalla
AT the end... · 04 Apr 2005
it's clear from his expression that teji thought he had won the fight. nidar did'nt look happy at all.
it was obvious that this was a stick fight. nidar would'nt accept a fight with mock weapons. during the stick fight teji whacked nidar on the side of his dumalla (bad move, because it cushioned the blow). also, neither fighter had room to maneuvre, cos of the people standing way too close by. it seemed that nidar rushed teji when he himself could'nt move any further back without hurting the onlookers. got to admit that teji turned his back on nidar loads of times, and that nidar took a decision to go on defensive, probably to try and get a flavor of teji's skill level before committing himself to attack. when nidar rushed in, teji did'nt seem to know how to handle it, and could'nt retreat or block effectively. teji's attack routine was very flashy - would he have done that against someone he did'nt know who was intent on wounding/killing him?
nobody was hurt and the result was inconclusive, as it was broken up when neither of them was getting anywhere (grappling situation). someone said nidar went for a knife. that could explain why it was broken up so early. teji tried to chat and be nice to nidar after the fight, but it seems to me that his post-fight dialogue was premature and it would'nt be right for him to claim victory.
a lot of crap has happened because of this fight not being allowed to finish.
Re: Niddar vs Uptej Singh 1998 Hola Mohalla
Novtej Singh · 04 Apr 2005
So much for having your shaster accessible, but i think Niddar's kirpan was a bit too much; it was on the floor half of the time showing it was so easy to take out of the sheath.
Re: Niddar vs Uptej Singh 1998 Hola Mohalla
AT the end... · 04 Apr 2005
it was a distinctly unimpressive display all round. not up to the hype.
Re: Niddar vs Uptej Singh 1998 Hola Mohalla
Search For Tat · 05 Apr 2005
so clearly a case of the loin and elephant story. He only boasts and fiughts where he think he can win. Where he cannot, he just makes some silly ecuse to get out. All hype, no backbone!!