Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Confusion? future of sikhi?past?

Confusion? future of sikhi?past?

confused · 30 Jul 2003

i have a question. akhand kirtani jatha though very gud at reciting bani in gurughars and prmoting bani has done gud and helped bring youth into sikhi. but y do the jatha not vand shak with the whole community what are they doing for humanity? what kind of projects do they have? guru sahib fed clothed the hungry the poor, no matter what religion or creed they were and opened gurdwara with 4 doors for everyone. seva for the wider sikh community besides kirtan progs? and y not do actively in gurdwaras as part of the wider community? about 6 years ago when i first came into sikhi jatha was very very big. but there are so many people just drifting away forming a dozen new groups,that do similar stuff such as rensbhais, katha, etc y is this happening? i have seen so many people go away from jatha but still remain in sikhi i am worried on one hand that jatha numbers mite go down but on the other hand jatha has done very gud as sikhs have built upon foundations from jatha and moved on.

Re: Confusion? future of sikhi?past?

daas · 30 Jul 2003

i agree... Jatha's got to do more - got to not only do keertan, but practice what's in it

Re: Confusion? future of sikhi?past?

UK Singh · 31 Jul 2003

'about 6 years ago when i first came into sikhi jatha was very very big. but there are so many people just drifting away forming a dozen new groups' Just this w/e gone I attended a rainsbhai [Southall (UK)] in remembrance of Bhai Rama Singh. I'm not Jatha and do not frequent these Kirtan Programs -not like I used to anyway. The numbers of youth in the Jatha seemed to have dwindled dramatically. Many youngsters when they first enter Sikhi after attending a camp must be confused by what group(s) to associate with. Why not just associate with the 'Panth'? What good has come from distinct Jathebandhis and further subdivisions within these? Why not just view a Singh as a Singh? Khalsa seem to complain about the myriads of cults that are destroying Sikhi. Ironically, splitting into various groups - like it or not is having the same affect. The recent Nihang fad has attracted many of the youth and is dangerous in that it preaches some anti Gurmat ideals. For instance, marrying hindu's seems to be OK all of a sudden? However, if some Singhs follow people like Nidar Singh, does that mean that we should stop communicating with these individuals?? The 'Jatha' have many views that are deemed as controversial by many other Sikh groups - have Taksalis fallen out with them, have the Nihangs or anyone else? In the UK camps at least I can see Unity between the various groups - even if it is for one week! We should place our differences aside and practice Gurmat only. In the past the multiple Sampardas all had respect for each other and all had specialist knowledge to share ie Nirmalas, Udasis, Taksalis, Nihangs and so forth. Now all we share are slanging matches over the net and Ninda of others! A question to the audience - how can we combat these numerous splits in Sikhi at the youth stage so that we do not end up following the footsteps of our previous generation?

Re: Confusion? future of sikhi?past?

faarfnoogle · 31 Jul 2003

I think ur right Its very hard for the jatha to practice unity i mean there been some efforts... smagams and rainsabais here and there ... but all in all most people in the jatha are very much attached to the jatha and could not see themselves at a smagam held by another jatha ... or even if there was a world khalsa conference they'd come as the jatha, not as nishkam sevaks... tough situation