Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Nagar kirtan + dhols?

Nagar kirtan + dhols?

. · 11 Apr 2005

Are Dhols at Nagar kirtans right?

Re: Nagar kirtan + dhols?

ms · 11 Apr 2005

dhol is just like the tabla whats wrong with it just louder

Re: Nagar kirtan + dhols?

singh · 11 Apr 2005

Yes its fine

Re: Nagar kirtan + dhols?

Pardeep Singh Bilga · 12 Apr 2005

Dhol nagara

Re: Nagar kirtan + dhols?

RosEEE · 12 Apr 2005

The Dhols have been exploited. No one focuses on Gurbani when the 30 dhols are banging together. All people associate with Dhols is Bhangra dancing.

Re: Nagar kirtan + dhols?

Singhni · 12 Apr 2005

The dhol is not needed when there is a Nagara showing the coming of the sikhs. Dhols are just to pull girls and to look good. shame on them!

Re: Nagar kirtan + dhols?

hs · 13 Apr 2005

Sorry but "author singhni said dhols are just to pull grils", that is your point of view, but think again it's instrument like tabla or nagar. As far for pulling girls if you thinking this kind of stuff at nagar kirtan than shame on you.

Re: Nagar kirtan + dhols?

lol · 14 Apr 2005

a drum banging isnt going to pull a gurl, i think it looks disguisting a trim singh or mona with earings and sweaty foreheads banging a dhol people outside just laugh empty shells. thats all the noise one can make on a religious proccession bang bang bang stupid.

Re: Nagar kirtan + dhols?

khalsey da footdust · 14 Apr 2005

it does look so damn gay earings dangling side to side, sweat dripping down their faces, beer guts and double chins bouncing up and down, nodding and moving their heads forward as if their full of ego "yes i have a dhol in my hands all eyes on me" hardly a kirtan is it? while pakistanis and hindus walk on the outer strip smoking, using cam shots to study nagar kirtan, checking kuria out and god knows what else. Girls and boys are as bad as each other. on positive note perhaps this is the right place to start parchar to sikh youth , give more leaflets on sikhi, invitations to kirtan programmes, and workshops. Or even questionaires to the youth hand em out and ask them as a comunnity what would they like? their opinions and send back centrally in their own time to a reg po box. someone told me the present dhol tamasha is a corrupted form of real dhol vidia that was around in Guru jis time is this right or wrong? if it is right then who does dhol vidia now?

Re: Nagar kirtan + dhols?

G Singh · 14 Apr 2005

I think that their is nothing wrong with a Dhol. In Sri Chandi Di Vaar, it is written that when the Devtas and Rakshas armies faught one another, they first made alot of noise using Dhols, conch shells, and Nagaras (Dhol, Shank, Nagarai Bajai).