Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

1960-Bhai Sahib

1960-Bhai Sahib

Singh · 15 Apr 2005

i have heard the recordings from akj.org - 1960 old spools, delhi smaagam....as i am aware, bhai sahib randhir singh was alive then and passed away the year after. they do simran in the keertan there, i know bhai randhir singh didnt do it. my question is if whether anybody knows if bhai randhir singh ji was actually present at the smaagam there? anyone know?

Re: 1960-Bhai Sahib

Khalsa · 15 Apr 2005

I aware of the fact that Singhs in Bhai Sahibs time did not do simran in their kirtan. There are exceptions though. Those singhs that have hit their highest state of avasta while doing kirtan would stop playing the vaja and just start doing simran. This simran is differeent from the simran that is being done today. Todays kirtanees do simran in their kirtan to show off. From what i have heard Singhs from Bhai Sahibs time never did simran in their kirtan.

Re: 1960-Bhai Sahib

Jarnail Singh Gyani Arshi · 16 Apr 2005

and also the newly emerging trend of "MIXING" lines from various shabads all together in one new shabad... Prof Darshan Singh Raagi Jathedar Akal Takhat i beleive started this trend..but then he does a lot of KATHA in his kirtan...and taking lines from different shabads to explain a line in a certian shabad may be OK...but then the other day i heard a famous Raagi doing this in PURE KIRTAN....one line from one shabad, then the enxt line from a different shabad ( but simialr emaning)...then a third line fourth line from a different shabad..etc etc mixing about five different shabads with ONE RAHAO from the main shabad...I realsied this was happening when the person manning the computer was seen putting up all the "wrong" lines becasue he had to search the new lines in new shabads every two minutes...and then RETURN to the Original shabad for teh Rahao pangktee... This may be "new" way of doing kirtan to a Raagi..BUT i find it is INSULTING GURU JI...GURBANI should be sung as it is written....how can one start off with Raag Asa Mh 1..then go on to Majh mah 5 shabad line, then a Sri raag Mh 1 line etc...even though A:LL the shabads share a common meaning/lesson/etc. What do the readers think about this ?? Jarnail Singh

Re: 1960-Bhai Sahib

Singh · 16 Apr 2005

yes but was bhai randhir singh ji also there at that particular smaagam?

Re: 1960-Bhai Sahib

Jagjit Singh · 16 Apr 2005

waheguru ji kekhalsa, waheguru ji ke fateh Pyare jio, when I asked Giani Amolak singh many years ago, he said he knew of no recording of bhai sahibs kirtan, but had known that All India radio recorded one of his speeches once. However at this years AKJ UK smagam, when i spoke to Bibi Harjit kaur, she said she had heard of a recording of bhai sahib keertan. So one does exist. It is just about finding it.... waheguru ji kekhalsa, waheguru ji ke fateh

Re: 1960-Bhai Sahib

singh · 16 Apr 2005

Bhai sahiabs recording is out there, I have heard it, but the singh who has it said to me exact words "i will give a copy when the jatha does the same kam as Bhai sahiab, he is avery old singh and not jatha. He promised to leave me a copy

Re: 1960-Bhai Sahib

keertan · 16 Apr 2005

singh, what was the keertan like? was it totally out of this world?

Re: 1960-Bhai Sahib

... · 17 Apr 2005

yes , Jarnail Singh Gyani Arshi ji bibi harjeet kaur does this too, keep swappin sabads all the time, she did this frequently at the west bromich keertan programmes in the uk.

Re: 1960-Bhai Sahib

Singh · 17 Apr 2005

wowwwwwwwwwwwwwwww wat was the keertan like singhhhhhhh??????? be kind and share it with the sangat... pleaseee

Re: 1960-Bhai Sahib

singh · 18 Apr 2005

Giani Jarnail Singh Jee - Bhai Manpreet Singh Jee does this as well, as well as Bibi Harjit Kaur. I do not think there is anything wrong with it at all. It helps to consolidate the meaning of the shabad in your mind and exposes you to new Bani. Most of the Panth doesn't do Keertan in the Raags prescribed by Guru Jee. Isn't this insulting Guru Jee? Why do we always pick faults in others? The fact that the person using the projector was incompetent is not the Raagi's problem.

Re: 1960-Bhai Sahib

BULLQUACK · 18 Apr 2005

bootababe aka "mix and match" does the same. i think we should finish one shabad before we start the next - we might not use the puratan tune but how can we start simran halfway through a line of bani and not even finish a whole line!

Re: 1960-Bhai Sahib

Singh · 19 Apr 2005

what is bhai sahibs voice like then? why is no body replying. please reply, the sangat would like to know what out piaara gurmukh sriman bhai sahib ji sounds like!

Re: 1960-Bhai Sahib

vivek · 19 Apr 2005

Taking one line from each sabad and singing each line is like composing your own shabad, this is not orthodox and is definatly wrong. Actually it shows the spiritual state of the kirtanee, any kirtanee who has any ras would get absorbed into the shabad and wouldn't just do one line then swap to another shabad. I find bibi harjeet kaurs kirtan very dry, kirtan is not all about voice. Everyone knows Mohinder singh sdo has lost the plot, anyone whos seen that video of him will know what im on about.

Re: 1960-Bhai Sahib

singh · 19 Apr 2005

His keertan cannot be discribed, it was very grainy the voice, just awesome for some reason listening to bhai jeevan singh ji tapes i feel i go back to that day i heard bhai sahiabs how can i describe it i don't know, but that singh will not release the tape, he says jatha should be 1 and when there is 1 akj jatha then they will get the most prized possesion a glimse of bhai sahiabs voice. Buttt i could never see that happening

Re: 1960-Bhai Sahib

curious · 19 Apr 2005

No I haven't seen that video of Mohinder Singh SDO, could you please share with me the details of this video.

Re: 1960-Bhai Sahib

guruguru · 20 Apr 2005

what was is keertan style like? raag or anything? whos keertan is it most similar to who ouve heard nowadays?

Re: 1960-Bhai Sahib

Truth · 20 Apr 2005

Oh my Waheguru, but no offence, please people instead of wanting to know about how and what etc etc, PLEASE think about the essence of Gurbani. Follow Gurbani with all your hearts. If you want to know more, then either ask the pratan gursikhs of Bhai Sahib's time or ask the family members. Other than that, please lets not go into idolism. Bhai Sahib certainly would not want people to have a thirst about the way and how their vioce sounded.

Re: 1960-Bhai Sahib

- · 21 Apr 2005

In response to vivek - Please stop mentioning names, no one needs to know who's Kirtan u find dry...and who are you to say whose avasta is high or not?? Or have you reached such a state of chardi kala that you find time to talk about other people on the net in between ur bagti? Vaheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Vaheguru Ji Ki Fateh! [%sig%]

Re: 1960-Bhai Sahib

ns · 26 Apr 2005

Waheguru Je Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ke Fateh I 'm quite surprised at learned indiviuals such as Bhai Sahib Jarnail Singh Ji or anyone else for that matter find it insulting kirtaneeas mixing shabads. If Darshan Singh Jee started the trend to exlpain the relvenace of various shabads and Gurbani in detail and he sure does an excellent job, then what's wrong with Kirtaneeas singing relevant shabads or shabads with close meaning and near enough same topic. We should never ever criticize any keertanes, raag or non raag, and I mean Gurbani Kirtanees not dharne e waleeas. Why you may ask , your Guru Ji Siri Guru Granth Sahib Je mentions clearly: " bahloo bhaloo reh kirtaneaa " can't remember all this line but it entirely means that Guru Ji's is pleased with the keertana which only sings Gurbani and naam only. You are more than welcome to correct me if I'm wrong