Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Headbangin and screamin in Keertan!

Headbangin and screamin in Keertan!

Gurus Son · 22 Apr 2005

Wjkk Wjkf Your younger brother, My brother and sisters I have come up with a disscution of in our simran and keertan should we headbang (shaking head side to side)and scream when saying the gurmanthar Waheguroo! A kid from Australia came up to me and told me that he aint to happy in the way the akj do there simran, I had told my personal reasons to him but I think this is a issue that people should talk about! We as sikhs love and get anand from the style of the keertan and some times we can get emotional other sangat might not know the reason for this and may talk bad about the jatha! Also he told me that in Australia the akjs there stik together and dont socialise with other singhs, I dont have a clue if this is corect but i would like to do a benthi that if it is please stop as we are all brothers akj, taksali or the sangat! sorry if this is not corret, We shouldnt think to high of our selves! Please can my brothers and sisters give there views on this post, Thank You! Wjkk Wjkf

Re: Headbangin and screamin in Keertan!

loner singh · 22 Apr 2005

i think ur right 100% that we shudnt think of our selves higher and not to talk to other jathas. the khalsa panth is complete with love for every 1 not just for 1 jatha... dont know about u but i love head banging lol

Re: Headbangin and screamin in Keertan!

Bored Boy · 22 Apr 2005

Sometimes it feels like the screaming is a put on.

Re: Headbangin and screamin in Keertan!

Whiplash Accident · 22 Apr 2005

i use to do the headbanging and i got a very bad whiplash. I went to the physiotherapist and he told me this headbanging is not good for my health and you might have to get a collar. So i Quit the head banging, i think it gets you dizzy and you think you are on a high.

Re: Headbangin and screamin in Keertan!

Anon Singh · 22 Apr 2005

Headbanging is not correct because firstly the Shabad moves up and down not left and right in the body. Unless you have your Dasam Duar and Navel Point located in your left and right ears respectively, I can't see how you are going to be forced to hit your head against an imaginary wall. Headbanging is not good for your brain either - from a scientific viewpoint it is very unhealthy. With regards to screaming, etc, I don't think you are in a position to judge whether that is coming from the heart or not. To claim a Singh/Singhni is "faking it" when infact he/she isn't, would not be good for your Karma. But I can say that very spiritual Gurmukhs will stay completely still in all Keertan and Simran because everything is occuring internally and they do not want it to be shown outside.

Re: Headbangin and screamin in Keertan!

hello · 22 Apr 2005

i like akj style kirtan n y cant we show our emotions on the outside

Re: Headbangin and screamin in Keertan!

Singh · 22 Apr 2005

"hello" how exactly are you going to concentrate or focus on the Shabad when you are swinging your head around madly? It's not possible. You are not expressing your emotions when you headbang, you are just making yourself look silly and damaging your brain when you could be focussing on the Shabad. I am not surprised someone got whiplash from headbanging, I hope this teaches a lesson. Ask old Singhs - the old time Jatha members never used to do it and don't do it now.

Re: Headbangin and screamin in Keertan!

Kulbir Singh · 22 Apr 2005

My personal opinion on this is as follows: 1) If one is getting Rass or Anand from Kirtan or Naam, it should be contained inside as much as possible. If it becomes uncontrollable, then it is fine but such a state comes on rare Gursikhs. 2) There is nothing wrong in saying out Naam as loud as possible. Saying Naam Swaas Swaas loudly during Naam Abhyaas time is perfectly fine. There is no restriction in saying out Naam loudly. “Kabir Kesho Kesho kookiye” clearly proves that saying Naam loudly is not wrong. 3) First of all swinging head should be avoided but if it happens inadvertatly it it should be up and down as opposed to left and right. Fortunate ones who know about the Gurmat Technique of Japping Naam know this very well that Naam vibrations or Naam Gurmanter travels up and down in our body. 4) As for not mixing up with Taksali Singhs and other Singhs, I think we should have love for all and socialise with all Gursikhs who keep maryada. We should socialise with anyone who keeps Rehit and is a Gurmat seeker of Vaheguru regardless of their affiliations. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: Headbangin and screamin in Keertan!

Dogma · 22 Apr 2005

Kulbir Singh, the translation of the thukh that you provided 'Kabir Kesho Kesho Kookiye' is as follows on sikhitothemax. kabeer kaeso kaeso kookeeai n soeeai asaar || Kabeer, chant the Name of the Beautifully-haired Lord; do not sleep unaware. raath dhivas kae kookanae kabehoo kae sunai pukaar ||223|| Chanting His Name night and day, the Lord will eventually hear your call. ||223|| Is this the proper translation in your opinion? Because it does not go along with your argument of doing Simran loudly.

Re: Headbangin and screamin in Keertan!

singh · 22 Apr 2005

Is moving your body, or moving your head a bit side to side or up and down to the beat of simran or keertan wrong?? Ive always wondered this. NOt like insanely moving but simple movement to the beat of the kirtan or simran.

Re: Headbangin and screamin in Keertan!

Kulbir Singh · 22 Apr 2005

Dogma jeeo, I humbly disagree with the translation you provided. -------------- kabeer kaeso kaeso kookeeai n soeeai asaar || Kabeer, chant the Name of the Beautifully-haired Lord; do not sleep unaware. ---------- The word kookna means cheekhna i.e. to scream, to cry out. So the meaning is clear. Cry out Naam (kesho kesho is representative of Naam here) O Kabir and don't just sleep unconscious of Naam. ----------- raath dhivas kae kookanae kabehoo kae sunai pukaar ||223|| Chanting His Name night and day, the Lord will eventually hear your call. ||223|| ------------- Crying out Naam this way (as described above) day and night will bring fruit one day as Vaheguru will hear your pleas at some point in time. The word "Kookna" means cheekhna or to wail out or to cry out. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: Headbangin and screamin in Keertan!

bhola singh · 22 Apr 2005

when we are screaming on top of our voice there is hardly any chance of sleep for you as well as for those around you. One of my gursikh friends says he goes to keertan samgams just to scream aloud. And he screams naam and gurbaanee very well. Almost everybody can hear his loud voice. Screaming naam and baanee with force definitely cleans the mind. Its just opposite of "sehaj bilOvOh jaisay tatt naa jaaee" but works for very very dirty souls like me. In the protection of naam and baanee there is no chance for brain or body being affected by some bad thing. There is nothing in this universe which is more pleasure giving than Naam and Gurbaanee. and as for "Naam vibrations or Naam Gurmanter travels up and down in our body." kulbir singh jeeO waheguroo ji ka khalsa waheguroo ji ki fateh i suggest you study the last of chapter of book Naam Abhyaas Kammaaee by Bhai Randhir Singh jee. The shabad always has to go up and up, and strike the dasam duaar. The technique is well explained. waheguroo ji ka khalsa waheguroo ji ki fateh

Re: Headbangin and screamin in Keertan!

heyheyhey · 23 Apr 2005

we should not do gurmanter in keertan because it doesnt say so in that shabd and plus only 5 piare tell gurmanter so if ur doing naam and monas hears and starts doing naam like the 5 taught is not right

Re: Headbangin and screamin in Keertan!

yahoo · 24 Apr 2005

lol no offence heyheyhey but a lot of people already know the technique whether they are non akj or monnei for a few reasons, but because naam has not been revealed by the panj pyarey it will not be as productive for them till the naujwaan are ready to take amrit from the panj.

Re: Headbangin and screamin in Keertan!

Gur Ka Sikh · 24 Apr 2005

im from australia and would just like to say that the akj singhs and singhneea associate with everyone. we do not see ourselves as higher to them or anything like that. "Guru's Son" i know u did not mean it but u made it as if all australian akjs are like that. so in the future plz do not post up such comments because it is an insult to the Gursikhs here who r so chardi kala and have such humility. Unlike myself. thank you Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh

Re: Headbangin and screamin in Keertan!

dk · 24 Apr 2005

lol this is a funny post. if you dont agree with headbanging dnt do it. how dooes one actually KNOW whether headbanging or grooooin isnt helping someone get closer to mahraj.onli maharaj knows this. if you dont like it dont do it, and if you do like doing it assess why you are doing it, and if you think its for the right reasons that carry on. everyone has there own way of showing pyaar for mahraj, how can we critisise it. trust me i've learned this the hard way. we should jus concentrate on our own sikhi.

Re: Headbangin and screamin in Keertan!

Guru son · 24 Apr 2005

Wjkk Wjkf Brother, i did not mean to affend no one but if read properly i did not accuse no one, i was just telin u something that a singh told me I dont have a clue what is going on in australia, and I did say sorry if it is false, and I say sorry again. plz forgive a moorakh! Wjkk Wjkf

Re: Headbangin and screamin in Keertan!

J · 24 Apr 2005

yes your 100%, Headbanging is totally wrong. Bhai randhir Singh Ji never used to do it, or the old school AKJ (video proves this), so it shouldn't be done, its not the way you do simran or kirtan, and you can become very ill and may have to Paracetomal several times in a raensbai kirtan. Headbanging is just a show and an act. Headbanging should be done on a football pitch, not in a darbar w.j.k.k, w.j.k.f

Re: Headbangin and screamin in Keertan!

Dogma · 24 Apr 2005

thank you Kulbir Singh... I agree with your translation of the thukh you provided. Sikhtithemax is good, but even the older Singhs that I know tell me not to JUST rely on it 100%. Thanks for clearing up my doubts. Waheguru Jee Ka Khalsa Waheguru Jee Kee Fateh.

Re: Headbangin and screamin in Keertan!

Gurcharan Singh Kulim · 24 Apr 2005

Singho, some wrote above why are we Akj taksali etc, we must be friendly with all in the community. My question is WHY CANT YOU ALL BE SIMPLE GURU KE SINGH

Re: Headbangin and screamin in Keertan!

singh · 24 Apr 2005

One question, is it wrong to 'sway' to the beat of keertan or simran.

Re: Headbangin and screamin in Keertan!

singhnee · 24 Apr 2005

Im also from australia and would like to add by saying that such things do not happen here..with gurujees kirpa we have some amazing souls here and we only started holding akj smagams around the yr 2000. So its simply just an oppourtunity where sangat from all around aussie can get together once a yr to do simran and kirtan. Prior to that we had kirtan programs in our own cities. The sangat that attends is mostly amritdharis, we all stay together for the week at the gurdwara, it has never occured to us if one is akj or taksali. We dont have large number of sikhs here, but the ones we do have..just yea :o) gurujees kirpa. So basically we all know each other, we all know every single amritdhari and theres no distinction between jathas as we dont even have huge numbers, we just have all amritdharis getting together having a great time. 'Gurus son' hope thats clarrified some things for you, if you get time, come to one of the smagams and check it out yourself :o)

Re: Headbangin and screamin in Keertan!

can't think of a name.. · 25 Apr 2005

Author: Gurcharan Singh Kulim Date: 04-24-05 17:08 Singho, some wrote above why are we Akj taksali etc, we must be friendly with all in the community. My question is WHY CANT YOU ALL BE SIMPLE GURU KE SINGH

Re: Headbangin and screamin in Keertan!

harpreet singh · 25 Apr 2005

wjkk wjkf i m totally opposed to this kind of simran. if u want to do this u should do in ur home, not in public. guru fateh.

Re: Headbangin and screamin in Keertan!

ns · 26 Apr 2005

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ke Fateh Does it really matter what you do head bang, jump up and down, run , fly when you 're in love with Guru Ji? I can't see the general public ever complaing or ciritcizing the punk rockers or , rock singer or any other singers of their behaviour on stage, yet we Sikhs are so great at being observant and that's all nothing else.

Re: Headbangin and screamin in Keertan!

Gurcharan Singh Kulim, MBA Phd · 26 Apr 2005

I have not seen any HEAD BANGING in any Gurduara.But if you are referring to people getting engrossed into the shabad and do sway/move in tune or lyrics their head-what is it to another? They are in MAST with their faith, they are enjoying their Gurus shabad, let them get on ....you dont do it if you dont like dont do it......I have travelled to USA Canada, I have seen gurduaras in India, Burma Thailand, malasysia, Australia,France, etc ...some poele will get terribly engrossed into naam japna ..simran ....let them get on with it ..as long as they are not standing on stage and doing a show.....it is for Guru ji to judge ..if they fake ...let us all be the Sikhs of Guru ...in the way the Guru wanted ...not the way one likes or not likes or this taksaal or that jatha ...wants ....start with what you know , learn from others and do your best to follow that Gurbani that you hear and learn ....pointing fingers at another 's body movement is not one of the ways Guru would be interested to know.....

Re: Headbangin and screamin in Keertan!

Jarnail Singh Gyani Arshi · 26 Apr 2005

well said Gurcharan Singh jio, When we have the "time" or inclination to look around in Sangat..means OUR MIND IS WANDERING.....and that is BAD. Any one just looking around aimlessly at what this person is doing and what that bibi is wearing is NOT PAYING ATTENTION to KIRTAN/KATHA...etc etc is wasting his time.... IN SANGAT one must be really engrossed in Kirtan Katha....in TUNE with GURU JI....no looking around...

Re: Headbangin and screamin in Keertan!

atl_singh · 27 Apr 2005

Author: harpreet singh Date: 04-25-05 23:44 wjkk wjkf i m totally opposed to this kind of simran. if u want to do this u should do in ur home, not in public. guru fateh. harpreet singh, i do Not humbly disagree with your view. ure just wrong. havnt u ever heard of : saas saas har naam dhhiaaeeai and/or saas graas har naam samaal and/or jinaa saas giraas n visarai har naamaa man manth those tukaan basically mean that one should meditate and remember Waheguru for every breath, and every bite of food. Don't tell me you dont breath in public. guru fateh [%sig%]