Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

PANJ PYARE

PANJ PYARE

GUPT · 23 Apr 2005

wjkk wjkf i thought the panj pyare are supposed to be where five singhs are present and guru gobind singh ji is standing in the missle of them. at bebe nanaki gurdwara the panj pyare sed to a singh receiving amrit that it was up to him what the fifth kakkar was was, keski or kesh. does this mean that guru gobind singh doesnt know either??? people say panj pyare are panj pyare yeh. but then some panj pyare say different things to others... wjkk wjkf

Re: PANJ PYARE

vivek · 23 Apr 2005

panj pyare are 5 amritdhari singhs who keep KHALSA REHIT, so if you believe keski is the 5th K and the panj do not keep keski on all the time then some say they are not true panj pyare because they dont keep khalsa rehit. Would guru gobind singh ji ever say.............'the 5th K can be keski or kesh its upto you'......................i dont think so, therefore i can safely say the panj pyare you are talking about are not panj pyare. As panj pyare and guru gobind singh are one.

Re: PANJ PYARE

GUPT · 23 Apr 2005

my mistake **middle**

Re: PANJ PYARE

kaur kurreh · 23 Apr 2005

my understanding is that the bebe nanaki panj pretty much say that both kes and keski are kakkars... u have to keep both kakkars anyway so why make it an issue as to which is the fifth. [%sig%]

Re: PANJ PYARE

Fateh jeeee · 23 Apr 2005

Why come to a phorum to discuss this??? if you think you are WORTHY enough to question the panj pyaray go to bebe nanake Gurudwara sahib and question them. Funny how everyone jumps up to start making accusations on phorums yet wont step up face to face. I personnally feel that Guru Gobind singh sahib jee was DEFFINTLY present in the panj pyaray in that amrit sanchaar. myself and many other gursikhs joined togther to do keertan with the sangat and panj payary after the amrit sanchaar! I have not felt such amazing chardikala in a long time! Those of you who are really concerned about the validity of the panj pyaray...try acting like real gursikhs yourself and go question the gursikhs to thier faces...dont hide behind your computers feeling all high and mighty pointing fingers at gursikhs, you never know wat amazing souls you may be slandering!

Re: PANJ PYARE

JKThind · 24 Apr 2005

Waheguru Ji ka Khalsa Waheguru ji KI fateh. I wouldnt question the PUNJ....if it was up to me ?? IF we start questioning..then it is NOT the PUNJ that matter but what "I" (WE) THINK ???? IN THAT case WHY EVEN BOTHER to go to the PUNJ..because I/WE have ALREADY DECIDED at home ?? Are we just going to the PUNJ so that they "confirm" what we have decided at home ?? What a height of Manmatt and Haumaii..we want the PUNJ to RUBBER STAMP what WE DECIDE ???..in that case WE/I are GREATER then the PUNJ .... we tell them what to do ....just like Badal told the PUNJ .....many many times...are we any better ??? IF GURU JI said HE is PRESENT in the PUNJ..then HE is....those who DOUBT will do that at their own peril....BEWARNED. Jasvir kaur

Re: PANJ PYARE

GUPT · 24 Apr 2005

who said we are slandering them? [%sig%]

Re: PANJ PYARE

confused · 24 Apr 2005

my understanding is that the bebe nanaki panj pretty much say that both kes and keski are kakkars... u have to keep both kakkars anyway so why make it an issue as to which is the fifth. So if both keski and kesh are kakkars theres are 6Ks?? If Kesh is a K does that mean you can cut your hair before amrit? If the panj pyareh say kesh or keski does that mean theyre not sure? If the panj say you dont have to do nitnem just moolmantre is that ok, i mean is it wrong to question them?

Re: PANJ PYARE

kaur kurreh · 24 Apr 2005

"my understanding is that the bebe nanaki panj pretty much say that both kes and keski are kakkars... u have to keep both kakkars anyway so why make it an issue as to which is the fifth. So if both keski and kesh are kakkars theres are 6Ks??" no, both are kakkars in the sense that both should be kept by a Gursikh. not that there are 6 kakkars. if the fifth kakkar is kes, then so be it, but keski should still be kept. and if keski is fifth kakkar, kes should still be kept. if keski is the fifth kakkar, does it mean that kes can be cut?! [%sig%]

Re: PANJ PYARE

Bored Boy · 25 Apr 2005

This is so logical. Use your common sense. Kes is a kakaar but a keski must always be worn by all. At least Punj Pyaray outside your "jatha" are thinking about the keski.

Re: PANJ PYARE

confused · 25 Apr 2005

If keski is the 5th kakkaar does it mean kes can be cut? Cutting hair is a kurehit, removing keski is not. Yes removing a kakkar is bad and ardas must be done to ask for forgiveness, its completely different from cutting your hair though. Im not amritdhari, so i dont wear 5 kakkars, but i still keep my hair......if you say kesh is a kakkar you are belittling its importance. Not wearing keski kangha kirpan kashera...is different from not wearing hair. Hair is more fundamental, and more important than the 5 kakkar. Wearing 5 Kakkars became compulsary for amritdharis, from when dasm patsah started the khalsa, keeping hair was compulsary from Sri Guru Nanak Dev Ji

Re: PANJ PYARE

hardip singh · 25 Apr 2005

if keski is the fifth kakkar, does it mean that kes can be cut?! if keski is fifth kakar, kes cannot be cut - due to the prohibition as one of the 4 bajjar kurehits as told by Guru Sahib. When people say 5th kakar is keski they are not belittling kes but rather showing that KES is even more important than the 5 Ks, Kes is the Gurus Mohr - identity, stamp,seal. Even the place of the the birth of the Khalsa is called KESGARH, to show the importance of KES to the Guru, the 5Ks were external gifts given to the Khalsa, Kes is already part of our natural form, which Guru Sahib wishes us to maintain - to live in the Will of God, tis is 1 among many reasons for the keeping of KES. Gurfateh