Re: why are hindi movies always disgracing us?
Redwhiteandblue Kaur · 24 Apr 2005
Perhaps for the same reason that Panjabi Sikhs say the word "western" like it is a bad thing: ignoring the concerns of a minority in exchange for making a point.
Re: why are hindi movies always disgracing us?
kunjarwood murdabad · 25 Apr 2005
a lot of people should do a lot of things but the simple answer is key influential groups will not do anything because they know better than anyone to hold onto power their actions have to resonate alongside with the wants of the people. If sikhs themselves pay for a movie ticket to watch tamashey made out of themselves what will sgpc do?
Re: why are hindi movies always disgracing us?
can't think of a name.. · 25 Apr 2005
I agree with what most of you are saying about the portrayal of Sikhi in Bollywood..
One thing I have to bring up though is, how many people do you personally know who refer to themselves as a Sikh yet they do not follow the path laid down by our Guru’s?
I bet you all know a number of people who cut their hair yet call themselves a Sikh, that you know a number of people who happily get drunk but refer to themselves as Sikhs, and that you also know of people who dress in ways we class as inappropriate yet there are people who dress like that who class themselves as Sikh..
When there are so many examples of what we see on screen in front of us claiming to be Sikhs then how can we say Bollywood is showing an incorrect picture? At the end of the day even if these people are not what WE think of as being ‘Sikhs’, that’s what they class themselves as and that’s what’s being shown on the big screen in Bollywood. Like it or loath it, the fact of the matter is there are people who we all know who are like those portrayed by Bollywood.
Now I’m not saying it is right, but its not like Bollywood is making up what they show on screen, is it?
If tomorrow they were to show a Amritdhari doing something wrong (incorrect portrayal) then yea I’d have reason to be concerned..
[%sig%]
Re: why are hindi movies always disgracing us?
Pardeep Singh Bilga · 26 Apr 2005
All these films are the same, they don't care for any sentiments or religion they offend- I raised this issue a few months ago (see: http://www.tapoban.org/phorum/read.php
f=1&i=21702&t=21619#reply_21702).. they will even take the mick out of their own religion (hindu) just to roll out another crappy "movie". If you remember, quite a large proportion of India's population is illiterate, so complex storylines are not an option...just cheap, tacky rubbish will make money time and time again.