Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Other religions and Sikhism

Other religions and Sikhism

TUF · 26 Apr 2005

What are your thoughts on studying other world religions? I have found that by reading about other relgions, I have gained a new appreciation for how great Sikhism really is. I feel that if more people knew about Sikhism we wouldn't always be made so obscure and grouped with smaller religions. Some other relgions are very closed minded and don't allow thought outside of their own dogmatic beliefs. I've found this especially with some christian/catholics and some muslims. I don't mean to be filled with 'hoame' but after reading about Christianity, Judaism, and Islam, I've realized how truly shallow they really are and how deep SIkhi truly is. On the other hand, I've found that reading about hinduism and buddhism has helped me in learning more and deeper appreciation for Sikhism. Let me know what you all think. Is it harmful to study other religions or is it beneficial? And is it narrowmindedness to just concentrate on SIkhi and ignore other forms of religious thought.

Re: Other religions and Sikhism

Putt Sehmi da · 26 Apr 2005

yeh but wouldnt you say its a about a matter of interpretation?

Re: Other religions and Sikhism

TUF · 26 Apr 2005

Yes, definitely, its all about interpretation. But when researching other religions (and even when reading about ours) its beneficial to make ones approach critical. I guess, for example, one person could read about Jesus and say 'wow, he's the son of god and maybe I should worship him', while another person would ask 'they say he's the son of god but how do I know this is true.' I guess different people approach things from different angles. I prefer the critical approach rather than blind faith. Its not good to be gullible, rather its better to understand something fully and then make one's own decision. And I've noticed most people on this board are quite intelligent and fall into the latter category, while others may need to think a bit more critically. Nothings worse than a brainwashed fanatic who has not fodder to support an argument. And all religions have these, whether muslim, christian or Sikh.

Re: Other religions and Sikhism

- · 26 Apr 2005

I agree, before I was first coming into Sikhi I did a comparison of different faiths - partly for interest, partly to see what gian I could get. I looked at the religion and how good it was as a reflection of the original founder's spiritual height. I did take into account changes made by selfish persons for political reasons etc. But still, looking at things this way, Sikhi is head and shoulders above the crowd. The only thing that comes close is Buddhism(imo), but even that falls short by quite a bit. Why worry about other religion's meditation methods etc. when Guru Nanak ji knew them all and told us to do Naam Simran? This comparison really made my faith in Sikhi stronger.

Re: Other religions and Sikhism

Jarnail Singh Gyani Arshi · 26 Apr 2005

STUDY all other RELIGIONS.....then only will you REALISE what a Diamond SIKHE is.

Re: Other religions and Sikhism

Kulbir Singh · 27 Apr 2005

--------------------- What are your thoughts on studying other world religions? ----------------- There is nothing wrong in studying other world religions but a Sikh should first understand and read Gurmat Dharam before reading about other religions. If one does not have proper knowledge about one’s own religion and starts to read other religions, that person stays confused for rest of his or her life. Foremost thing to do before attempting to study other religions is to get thorough understanding of Sikh Dharam. Here is what I think one should study in Sikhi before studying other religions: 1) Do at least 2 Sehaj Paaths of Siri Guru Granth Sahib jee 2) Do some paath of Bhai Gurdaas jee’s baani and understand the meanings as well. 3) Read all books of Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh jee. This is a must to understand Gurbani and Gurmat. No other author has covered the topics that Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh jee has covered. Without reading Bhai Sahib's books it is hard to get clear understanding of Gurmat. 4) Read books of Bhai Vir Singh jee especially history our 10 Gurus written by him. 5) Read life sketches of prominent Gursikhs Mahapurakhs of Sikh Panth including Baba Buddha jee, Bhai Gurdaas jee, Baba Deep Singh jee, Bhai Mani Singh jee, Sikh heroes of 18th Century, Baba Karam Singh Hothi Mardaan, Sant Attar Singh Mastuana, and other Gursikhs of all times. Once you have good understanding of Sikh Dharam, then go ahead and read whatever you want and you will never get confused. I know some gursikhs who had great potential to grow spiritually but because they started reading other religions ahead of time, they got stuck and confused. Now God knows how long they will stay stuck and confused. Our mind is like a “Kora Kaaghaz” i.e .blank paper. The first thing that we should write over it is Sikh Dharam and then other Dharams. --------------- I have found that by reading about other relgions, I have gained a new appreciation for how great Sikhism really is. I feel that if more people knew about Sikhism we wouldn't always be made so obscure and grouped with smaller religions. --------------- Yes you are right but your suggestion is only for those people who have good understanding of Sikh Faith. ------------- Some other relgions are very closed minded and don't allow thought outside of their own dogmatic beliefs. I've found this especially with some christian/catholics and some muslims. ---------------- My personal opinion is that the difference between Sikhi and Judeo-Christian-Islam religions is as great as the difference between a Chiraagh (an oil lamp) and Sun. Kithay Raam Raam, Kithay Tain Tain. Kithay Raja Bhoj, Kithay Gangu Teli. There is no comparison. Buddhism and Jainism are totally bankrupt anyways because they don’t believe in Akal Purakh. They have good concepts but what good is their goodness when they don't believe in our creator Vaheguru? What we are left with is Hinduism. Most of the Hindu world is totally lost but philosophically they are better than other religions. This is why Guru Sahib in his Baani has given most importance to the Hindu sects like Yogis and followers of Bhagti lehar. Rest of the Hindus are lost in idol worshipping. Khalsa Parmo-Dharmang. (Khalsa is the greatest Dharam). ------------------ I don't mean to be filled with 'hoame' but after reading about Christianity, Judaism, and Islam, I've realized how truly shallow they really are and how deep SIkhi truly is. On the other hand, I've found that reading about hinduism and buddhism has helped me in learning more and deeper appreciation for Sikhism. --------------- I totally agree with your opinion. Buddhism has some good concepts but the fact that they don’t believe in Akal Purakh is not a small thing. This one thing totally kills this religion. And yes Bhagvad Geeta and Upanishads contain great spiritual matter that is interesting to read. But after reading all that and then comparing it to Sikhi, you realise the greatness of Sikhi. Thanks for your post. It was a good and informative post. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: Other religions and Sikhism

TUF · 27 Apr 2005

Thank you Kulbir Singh bhaji for your insight.