Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

PANTHIC ALERT: Bhangra & Namdhari in Nagar Kirtan

PANTHIC ALERT: Bhangra & Namdhari in Nagar Kirtan

Manvir Singh · 27 Apr 2005

Vaahiguroo ji ka khalsa, vaahiguroo ji ki fateh Daas has written a letter to Sri Guru Singh Sabha Gurdwara Southall. Benti to others, please take a stand for Gurmat and also send letters to the Gurdwara Sahib. Please free to use daas' letter as a template (remember to change the date and the name at the end of letter). Thanks Daas, Manvir Singh ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------25/04/2005 SRI GURU SINGH SABHA GURDWARA 2 PARK AVENUE, SOUTHALL, MIDDLESEX UB2 4NP CC: Panthic Weekly, The Sikh Times, Panjab Radio Dear Sri Guru Singh Sabha Southall Gurdwara Parbandhak Committee, I would like to wish all the Gurdwara Committee a happy Vaisakhi. May Vaheguru keep you all in Chardikala and shower His blessings and bestow the gifts of Gursikhi Jeevan and Naam Di Daat. The Gurdwara Parbandhak Committee are the caretakers of the Gurdwara. They ensure that the Sikh Rehat Maryada is enforced and that all ceremonies, functions and events are in accordance to the Guru’s Maryada. However, more importantly the Parbandhak Committee give guidance, inspiration and provide the Sangat with a role model of how to be good responsible Gursikhs who respect the Guru and the Guru’s instructions. I visited Southall Vaisakhi Nagar Kirtan on 3rd April 2005 to mark the 306 year celebrations of the Khalsa Panth. I was disappointed to see in the Nagar Kirtan procession Naamdharis (Kooke) being part of the procession and holding a big banner saying “Naamdhari Sikhs”. In sangat-roop, anyone can join the Vaisakhi Nagar procession, however when anti-gurmat groups are holding big banners in the Khalsa’s Nagar Kirtan, then it becomes worrying! Naamdhari don’t believe in Khande-Pahul Da Amrit, and nor do they believe in Guru Granth Sahib Ji as the Guru, so with what ground where the Naamdhari allowed to carry their big banner and be part of the procession? Maaf Karnaa Ji, today we allow Naamdhari to be part of the Nagar Kirtan and hold big banners, tomorrow will we allow Radha Soamis and Narakdhari’s to do the same and join in the Khalsa’s Nagar Kirtan? Secondly, I was shocked as well as everyone I spoke to, to seeing Bhangra dancing part of the Nagar Kirtan procession. Dancers were part of the Desi Radio float. Is it Gurmat to dance to songs about Guru Gobind Singh Ji sacrificing his children for the Khalsa? Are Dhaarmik songs sung and played for people to hear so that they can dance or is it so that people can listen, reflect, learn and take action upon the message? The dancers said that they had permission for the Singh Sabha Parbandhak Committee to dance and that the Gurdwara Committee has not stopped them from dancing in previous years. My humble benti, request, to Sri Guru Singh Sabha Gurdwara Southall Prabandhak Committee is that as the representative of Guru Gobind Singh Ji’s House, you should be role models and leading the Sangat towards Guru Jee. It seems that it would be difficult to do so if the Parbandhak give permission to anti-gurmat groups like Naamdharis to be part of the Vaisakhi procession, and give permission to Bhangra dancers to dance in the Guru’s procession. How will we inspire the youth to Gursikhi when the elders are not enforcing Gurmat on Gurpurb celebrations? I hope this letter is taken seriously and action is taken upon it. I would appreciate a reply back from the Gurdwara Parbandhak Committee within two weeks please. Thanks Humble Daas, Manvir Singh Khalsa ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ [%sig%]

Re: PANTHIC ALERT: Bhangra & Namdhari in Nagar Kirtan

Jarnail Singh Gyani Arshi · 28 Apr 2005

well done. have sent them a copy myself.

Re: PANTHIC ALERT: Bhangra & Namdhari in Nagar Kirtan

pyara · 28 Apr 2005

There's no harm in writing letters. But Sangat ji, we sit on our backsides too much. How did we end up in the situation where Bhangra dancers and namdharis hijak our SIKH events!!!! It is uplifting to see Manvir Singh take time out to make a stand. It is even more unfortunate that he is on his own. Let's stop looking the part and actually do somethin. We all know the problems, it's time to kick anti-gurmat Gurdwara Committees out and take over. Wake up Guys, it's not anyone elses problem. It's ours!!! Stop arguing about Ragmala or the bata. Look at the bigger picture. Our enemies are not muslims or western culture. The panths enemies lie within our own community. We need to turn up at Park Ave Gurdwara and confront the committee. Sorry to say letters only go in the bin. Actions speak louder than words.

Re: PANTHIC ALERT: Bhangra & Namdhari in Nagar Kirtan

Question Bhai · 28 Apr 2005

Hmm. I wonder whether these were the views of Guru Gobind Singh Ji back in 1699. Did he go around the "sangat", throwing out all of the people that didn't look like "Khalsa" potentials ? Many thousands, from various backgrounds [ including those that didn't even know a fig leaf about Sikhism ] took the Pahul that day. None of them were banished from the sangat!

Re: PANTHIC ALERT: Bhangra & Namdhari in Nagar Kirtan

kaur_uk · 28 Apr 2005

manvir singhji, vaheguru bless you with more and more seva for the panth

Re: PANTHIC ALERT: Bhangra & Namdhari in Nagar Kirtan

Manvir Singh · 28 Apr 2005

-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Hmm. I wonder whether these were the views of Guru Gobind Singh Ji back in 1699. -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- >>>Dear sister/brother, a very good question! We are blessed that Guru Gobind Singh ji is still with us in the form of the Shabad Guru, for us to ask Guru Ji's advice. [i]Satguru Amar Daas Ji, the Third Nanak, explains to ”Raas-dhaaree’e“, to people who dance depicting the early life of the Hindu deity Krishan. They dance about with their hair loose and call themselves “Bhagats” (devotees of the Lord). Guru Sahib addressing those who dance as an act of “Dharam” or who believe dancing will get the closer to Vaheguru, says on in goojari raag (a raag which communicates the feelings of Satisfaction, softness of heart, sadness) on ang 506 (For viakhiya of shabad in panjabi by Prof. Sahib Singh please visit: http://www.gurugranthdarpan.com/0506.html):[/i] ik ounkaar sathigur prasaadh One Universal Creator God. By The Grace Of The True Guru: nirat karee eihu man nachaaee || I dance as well, (but instead of making by body dance) I make this mind dance. gur parsaadee aap gavaaee || By Guru's Grace (within myself) I eliminate my self-conceit. chith thir raakhai so mukat hovai, jo ichhee soee fal paaee ||1|| (Bydancing one is not liberated, nor does one become a Bhagat this way) one who keeps his/her consciousness focused on the Lord is liberated; he/she obtains the fruits of their desires. ||1|| naach re man gur kai aagai || So dance, O mind, before your Guru (i.e. walk in the Guru’s Will). gur kai bhaanai naachehi taa sukh paavehi, antae jam bho bhaagai. || Rahaa’o || If you dance according to the Guru's Will, you shall obtain peace, and in the end, the fear of death shall leave you. ||Pause|| aap nachaa’e so bhagat keheeai, aapnaa piaar aap laa’e || One whom the Lord Himself causes to dance, is (in essence) called a devotee. He Himself links us to His Love. aape gaavai aap sunaavai, eis man andhae ko maarag paa’e ||2|| (For that human) Vaheguru Himself sings (the songs of how to walk in the Will), Vaheguru Himself causes (the human) to listen, and He puts this blind mind on the right path. ||2|| an-din naachai sakat nivaarai, siv ghar nee(n)d na hoee || One who dances (walks in the Will) night and day, banishes (within himself the influence of ) Maya, enters the House of (Kaliyaan-saroop) the image of good fortune, Vaheguru, where there is no sleep. saktee ghar jagat sootaa, naachai ttaapai avuro gaavai, manmukh bhagat na hoee ||3|| The world is asleep in the attachment of Maya; ( and on the hands of Maya) it dances, jumps and sings in duality. The self-willed manmukh, who follows his own mind, is unable to do devotion of the Lord. ||3|| sur nar virat pakh karmee naachae mun jan giaan beechaaree || The angels, mortals, renunciates, ritualists, silent sages and beings of spiritual wisdom dance. sidh saadhik liv laagee naachae jin gurmukh budh veechaaree ||4|| The Siddhas and seekers, lovingly focused on the Lord, dance, as do the Gurmukhs, whose minds dwell in reflective meditation. ||4|| khandd brahmandd trai gun naachae, jin laagee har liv tumaaree || The planets and solar systems dance in the three qualities, as do those who bear love for You, Lord. jeea jant subhae hee naachae, naachehi khaanee chaaree ||5|| The beings and creatures all dance, and the four sources of creation dance. ||5|| jo thudh bhaavehi saeee naachehi jin gurumukh subadh liv laaeae || They alone dance, who are pleasing to You, and who, as Gurmukhs, embrace love for the Word of the Shabad. se bhagat se thath giaanee, jin ko hukam manaa’e ||6|| They are devotees, with the essence of spiritual wisdom, who obey the Hukam of His Command. ||6|| e’haa bhagat sachae sio liv laagai, bin sevaa bhagat na hoee || This is devotional worship, that one loves the True Lord; without service, one cannot be a devotee. jeevat marai taa shabad beechaarai, taa sach paavai koee ||7|| If one remains dead while yet alive, he reflects upon the Shabad, and then, he obtains the True Lord. ||7|| maaeiaa kai arath buhat lok naachae, ko virlaa thath beechaaree || So many people dance for the sake of Maya; how rare are those who contemplate reality. gur parsaadee soee jan paa’e, jin ko kirpaa tumaaree ||8|| By Guru's Grace, that humble being obtains You, Lord, upon whom You show Mercy. ||8|| eik dam saachaa veesrai, saa velaa birthaa jaa’e || If I forget the True Lord, even for an instant, that time passes in vain. saahi saahi sadaa samaaleeai aapae bakshae karae rajaae ||9|| With each and every breath, constantly remember the Lord; He Himself shall forgive you, according to His Will. ||9|| se’ee naachehi jo tudh bhaavehi, je gurmukh shabad veechaaree || They alone dance, who are pleasing to Your Will, and who, as Gurmukhs, contemplate the Word of the Shabad. kuho naanak se sehaj sukh paavehi, jin ko nadar tumaaree ||10||1||6|| Says Nanak, they alone find celestial peace, whom You bless with Your Grace. ||10||1||6||

Re: PANTHIC ALERT: Bhangra & Namdhari in Nagar Kirtan

Manvir Singh · 28 Apr 2005

-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Did he go around the "sangat", throwing out all of the people that didn't look like "Khalsa" potentials ? -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- No-one has said that anyone who doesn't like "Khalsa" should be part of the Gurpurb celebrations. Anyone in "Sangat-roop" can participate and join in. The issue was with anti-Khalsa groups displaying large banners in the Nagar Kirtan and not being part of the Sangat, rather being distinct and publicising their group in the Nagar Kirtan "procession". -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Many thousands, from various backgrounds [ including those that didn't even know a fig leaf about Sikhism ] took the Pahul that day. -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Yes. That's great! As Sikhs we have a duty to open our arms to all Sangat. We should raise awareness and be exemplary Sikhs so that others are inspired. -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- None of them were banished from the sangat! -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- In no Sikh event has anyone been "banished" nor would we want to. The issue is about banners and people who are part of the Nagar Kirtan procession (not in sangat-roop), who are doing non-Sikhi things in the Sikhi event. Do you think that a group of 20 GurSikhs dressed in full Bana could go to a Radha Soami Satsang and hold banners saying "Raj Karega khalsa"? Do you think that a group of 20 BNP (white facist racist) supporters could join a black afro-carribean carnival procession and hold a banner saying "British National Party"? Are the people doing Bhangra in the Nagar Kirtan doing Bhangra because they love the Guru or is it for show? So what is the difference of the same dancing happening in a Mehfil/ club/ pub and the dancing in the Nagar Kirtan? Being Sikhs should we allow anyone and everyone to hold whatever banner they wish, to do whatever activity they want and to publicise as they please in an event which is supposed to marking 306 years of the Khalsa Panth? bhul chuk maaf. Daas, Manvir Singh

Re: PANTHIC ALERT: Bhangra & Namdhari in Nagar Kirtan

J R · 28 Apr 2005

w.j.k.k, w.j..f. stop being extremists, we all need to stop this, this is whats bringing sikhi down. People thinking there it, saying that there shouldn't be namadharis holding flags up etc in the nagar kirtan. Nobody is perfect, we should respect all beleifs and movements eg. akhand kirtan jatha, damdami taksal namdhari etc. If there shouldn't be namdhari, there shouldn't be seperate jathas, everyone has got there own ways of reaching god. please stop being a hero, if you didn't like what you saw at the nagar kirtan, then the simple solution is not to go, and stay at home w.j.k.k, w.j.k.f.

Re: PANTHIC ALERT: Bhangra & Namdhari in Nagar Kirtan

mugadh · 28 Apr 2005

You are 100% correct veer Manvir Singhji. Bhangra dance is meant for being done while saakat naad and geets (pop songs) are being sung, so the people who were dancing in the Nagar Keertan didn't have any intention of pleasing the Guroo or had any spiritual motive. Guroo Arjan Devjee tells us that no one can achieve santokh(contentment/inner peace) by dancing or watching teaters/movies: natt naattik aakhaarae gaaeiaa || actors in dramas, singing in theaters thaa mehi man sa(n)thokh n paaeiaa ||2|| - but even with them, the mind does not find contentment. ||2||

Re: PANTHIC ALERT: Bhangra & Namdhari in Nagar Kirtan

someone · 28 Apr 2005

J R, Staying at home is not a solution, creating awareness as this Singh is doing is the solution, its not about Jathebandis, it about what's right according to Gurmat!

Re: PANTHIC ALERT: Bhangra & Namdhari in Nagar Kirtan

J R · 28 Apr 2005

SOMEONE, SORRY IF I UPSET YOU, BUT IF YOU DID SIMRAN AT HOME, IT DOESN'T MATTER PEACE

Re: PANTHIC ALERT: Bhangra & Namdhari in Nagar Kirtan

someone · 28 Apr 2005

you are right, I didn' t look at it in that light!

Re: PANTHIC ALERT: Bhangra & Namdhari in Nagar Kirtan

Roopkaur · 28 Apr 2005

>Nobody is perfect, we should respect all beleifs and movements eg. akhand kirtan jatha, damdami taksal namdhari etc. If there shouldn't be namdhari, there shouldn't be seperate jathas, everyone has got there own ways of reaching god.< Although there might be different jathas, there is only one panth, or path. You have done a blasphemy by putting the naamdharees with panthic jathabandees like AKJ and Taksal. I suggest you educate yourself more on the gurudom of naamdharees before you place them in the same groups as panthic jathabandees. THere is one panth, therefore there is one of reaching god, through satguru Sri Guru Nanak Dev Ji, not a living guru. >please stop being a hero, if you didn't like what you saw at the nagar kirtan, then the simple solution is not to go, and stay at home< What kind of kaaeyar (coward) would sit there while Sikhi or guru ji is being insulted? Why should Sikhs sit at home while their celebration is being hijacked by virodhis of the Sikhs. Are you suggesting the shaheedi jathas during the singh sabha movement were wrong to fight for the rights to Gurdvaras and should have stayed home instead? Or are you saying Bhai Fauja Singh and the 13 shaheeds of the 178 Vaisakhi saka were wrong? I do not think people fight for Sikhi to be heros, they are genuinely hurt by the beadbi that is done to Sikhi these days. If fighting to perserve Guru Ji's Sikhi is called being extremist, I would rather be an extremist than just sit there and watch guru jis beadbi going on. It is a nagar keertan, where Sikhs should be singing KEERTAN, as the name implies, not singing, doing bhangra, and letting anti panthic groups sabatoge the keertan. I suggest you research Sikh history and educate yourself a bit more.

Re: PANTHIC ALERT: Bhangra & Namdhari in Nagar Kirtan

pyara · 29 Apr 2005

Whoever wants to make the stand, make it! I want to make the stand. I don't want to see another Vasakhi where Sikhi is mashed up by BHANGRA dancer or NAAMDHARIS. Thanks for the complement of "being an extremist". If only I was that blessed to be an extremist I wouldn't be sitting behind a PC. Naamdharis, Nirankaris, Bhangra Dancers are welcome to have their own processions or carnivals. Stop infiltrating our Nagar Kirtans and portraying the wrong message.

Re: PANTHIC ALERT: Bhangra & Namdhari in Nagar Kirtan

Jarnail Singh Gyani Arshi · 29 Apr 2005

Pyara...i am "extremist" too...a PC arm-chair extremist. Sikh Nagar kirtan is for KIRTAN...of GURBANI...not namdharees, narakdharees, bhangrees whatever... i dont mind being called "extremist" if that is what i beleive in....

Re: PANTHIC ALERT: Bhangra & Namdhari in Nagar Kirtan

singh · 30 Apr 2005

naamdharees are anti khalsa they do not belong at nagar kirtans.

Re: PANTHIC ALERT: Bhangra & Namdhari in Nagar Kirtan

Question Bhai · 01 May 2005

Gyani Arshi did you ever read the line -- "Hum Nahin Changay, Boora Nahin Koy". Or do you skip that line every time ?

Re: PANTHIC ALERT: Bhangra & Namdhari in Nagar Kirtan

Jarnail Singh Gyani Arshi · 02 May 2005

Question Bhai jio, WHAT the heck has that line got to do with getting into *** with narakdharees and ANTI GURMAT GROUPS ?? Heck they can be Chunggay fro all i care..BUT stay away from a Nagar Kirtan meant for GURBANI and GURU GRANTH JI...of course my Chinese Muslim Neighbour is very very chunggah....so what should i do with him ?? shall i send him to you..as he is looking for a bride...i am sure you must have a lot of chunggian kurrian in mind who wouldnt mind getting married to a chunggah man ?? Chunggah aapne ghar mein raheh....Hum aapne ghar mein raehnge..

Re: PANTHIC ALERT: Bhangra & Namdhari in Nagar Kirtan

Pardeep Singh Bilga · 03 May 2005

Well done Manvir Singh ji- every little helps. We, the SIKH sangat cannot just stand by and allow silly so called "Parbandhak Committees" to allow our Gurdwaray and auspicious dates like Vaisakhi to hijacked by anti-panthic forces. I wrote a similar letter to my local Guru ghar recently, after a poster was plastered on the inside of the main door, advertising somebody's video/photography business. The poster had the usual picture of Sri Harmandir Sahib/calendar (the businessmen have learned to use the sacred place has an advertising tool- I've even seen "Golden Temple Atta"- WHERE will this end???) and also the contact details for their business. (One important point is that the businessman had recently had seva of Sri Akhand Path and is a well know and prominent person in the local area...the committee walay love this type and do a lot of "poocch pulling"...acting like beggars, even when somebody like this gets up to give money i.e. for the tsunami..you get the stage secretary blaring out the names of the "high rankers" even though they haven't even asked for them to do so!..."£20 falana singh walon, jo guru ghar di seva bahut karde han"...WHAT??? the guy is mona! and only comes to the Gurdwara once in a blue moon) In my letter, I asked, if this is allowed to continue, will we soon be seeing ads for pubs/clubs/wedding halls inside the Gurdwara? The next time I went, the poster had been removed. I felt a sense of relief that somebody had even bothered to read my letter and some action had been taken. If we just leave it be and don't say anything, things will get worse, so good on Manvir Singh Ji for taking time to make his voice heard. Bhaji- let us know what the reply is from the Gurdwara. Waheguru ji ka Khalsa, Waheguru ji ki fateh

Re: PANTHIC ALERT: Bhangra & Namdhari in Nagar Kirtan

raju · 03 May 2005

dear all, what will the people say when the music is so load that it drowns out all of the kirten.???????? turn the music up cos i want to dance? some one please have some sense, or will it be to late when most people want to hear rock and roll and not kirten.

Re: PANTHIC ALERT: Bhangra & Namdhari in Nagar Kirtan

Manvir Singh · 03 May 2005

This is a fourth or fifth letter I have written to Gurdwaras regarding violation of Gurmat. No Gurdwara has ever replied.

Re: PANTHIC ALERT: Bhangra & Namdhari in Nagar Kirtan

Jarnail Singh Gyani Arshi · 03 May 2005

<<<<<<<<

Re: PANTHIC ALERT: Bhangra & Namdhari in Nagar Kirtan

Amar Singh · 04 May 2005

Gur Fateh! Manvir Singh and Gyani Arshi-Dhillon Sahib, I concur with your view that Vaisakhi nagar kirtans are fast being overridden by events (bhangra/dholis) which should be saved for 'cultural' melas for anyone interested in such items -not part of the jaloos or nagar kirtan. With respect to Namdharis you wrote the following: "Naamdhari don’t believe in Khande-Pahul Da Amrit, and nor do they believe in Guru Granth Sahib Ji as the Guru, so with what ground where the Naamdhari allowed to carry their big banner and be part of the procession? Maaf Karnaa Ji, today we allow Naamdhari to be part of the Nagar Kirtan and hold big banners, tomorrow will we allow Radha Soamis and Narakdhari’s to do the same and join in the Khalsa’s Nagar Kirtan?" Manvir Singh, before we allow emotion to guide us, let's ensure we have out facts straight. Namdharis DO believe in Khande-Pahul da Amrit of Guru Gobind Singh -in fact, this is the origins of their movement with Baba Ram Singh propagating mass initiation of Khalsa rites, please look into the history of the Namdhari Kooka movement under Baba Ram Singh, which I'm sure you'll agree was 100% Panthic, it was Namdhari Singhs under Baba Ram Singh who first opposed the creeping in of un-Sikh practices of ancestor, tomb worship etc, through their day-light parchar and actions, agreed later (after Baba Ram Singh’s passing) on the never-ending debate of Guruship began. Nonetheless, to suggest that Namdharis do not believe in the Pahul is simply ridiculous and hence comparing them to RadhoSoamis and Sant Nirankaris, who clearly are not-Sikh movements today, although headed up by predominantly ‘Sikh’ appearing leaders is a little flawed, as the latter indeed do not believe in the Pahul, the Kakkars or the Khalsa Rehit. Namdharis do not issue parchar of non-Gurbani or anti-Kakkars or use of Drink or Drugs, they are strict in these respects on Khalsa Rehit, moreover unlike Radhosoamis and NIrankaris, they do not prescribe self-concocted ideas of what constitutes meditiation. Namdharis, I agree differ on one main point concerning Guruship, however this is far too often misconstrued into accusing them of not respecting the Guru Granth Sahib, which is a mistaken belief given that Namdharis do in fact respect both the Guru Granth Sahib and Sri Dasam Granth Sahib without question, although their attitude towards the Guru Granth Sahib is simply identical to the attitude of most Sikhs today towards Dasam Granth, i.e. is it Gurbani and should be respected as such, but for them it is not Guru. I am in no way suggesting that this is acceptable belief for me personally, as I view Sat Guru Sahib as Guru Granth Sahib, however we must be certain that our arguments are indeed correct and not mistaken hype. I have no problem with Namdharis being part of the Nagar Kirtan, given their actual respect for Gurbani and treatment of Shabad Kirtan in a manner far superior to that of today’s Jathas singing and shouting kirtan to Bhangra Tunes and Jingle Bells. The Akal Thakt and Punj Pyare are quite clear on who are the 5 Mel, and when I took Amrit, it this was clarified to me as well in a list which included RadhoSoamis and Sant Nirankaris, but NOT Namdharis.

Re: PANTHIC ALERT: Bhangra & Namdhari in Nagar Kirtan

Singh*Ilford · 04 May 2005

Namdharis are in the same category as Radhasoamis & Sant Nirankaris. Use your logic. Living Guru, distorting history etc etc . I personally don't want anything to do with them. The ironic thing is that I come from a "Naamdhari" family. I would suggest that someone visit a naamdhari temple and see for themsleves the "respect" given to our living Guru, Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji Mahraj.

Re: PANTHIC ALERT: Bhangra & Namdhari in Nagar Kirtan

MS · 04 May 2005

Actually if you read the letters Baba Raam Singh wrote from when he was in jail (i think 13 he wrote) you will find that he was having to answer his so called followes accusing him of being the Guru when he himself in those letters openly critisized those who were calling him Guru and rejected the claim. So its not true to say only after his passing did this start - the movement was hijacked by the dirty bramhinical forces in his time. I think B. Randhir Singhs autobiography has also documented this.

Re: PANTHIC ALERT: Bhangra & Namdhari in Nagar Kirtan

UK Singh · 04 May 2005

Manvir Singh, if you want the sangat to go to Southall Gurdwara let us know and we will go with you. You know the UK Youth are willing to do seva any time. Just ask we will help. Letter are a waste of time you have to go to the Gurdwara and talk with them.

Re: PANTHIC ALERT: Bhangra & Namdhari in Nagar Kirtan

Amar Singh · 04 May 2005

I also have Namdhari Family members as well as AKJ and Taksali relatives and there is plenty I have seen in all camps whcih would make the Namdharis appear like saints in comparison and of the reverse is also true. I am well aware of historical distortions, but again this can be applied to AKJ, Taksal, SGPC and Nihangs (depending on which 'panthic' stance you take) so doesn't prove anything. The fact remains that the Akal Thakt hukamnamas and rehit as elucidated by the Punj Pyare, DID not include them in the same group as the 5 Mel or Radhasoamis and Sant (Jhoothe) Nirankaris. Let's move on and eradicate the real issues, such as Bhangra from the Nagar Kirtan (if people want to dance, do it at the mela which is a cultural and not religious event). At least we tend to hear some respectful kirtan from the Namdhari floats and not some shouting to the tune of Jingle-bells accompanied by shody dholki or dhol playing.

Re: PANTHIC ALERT: Bhangra & Namdhari in Nagar Kirtan

Bored Boy · 04 May 2005

Groups like AKJ, Taksal, SGPC and Nihangs still come under the banner of the khalsa. The focus is all on Shabad Guru. Just because naamdharis play some classic raags, don't mean they have the right to be put on a pedastal. They say that their present Guru is the 15th Nanak. Now, maybe it's me, but I don't agree with that at all and I can honestly say any GurSikh that I know will not believe in that. I believe that the Naamdharis should not be allowed to have a float or banners in our Nagar Kirtans. This goes hand in hand with the fact that I do not want Bhangra and Giddha at our Nagar Kirtans. I am equally offended and annoyed by a Naamdhari doing his parchaar about Guru Gobind Singh Ji going into hiding for 50 years as I am with a Bhangra dancers in a nagar kirtan. Let's face it would we allow a evangelist Christian preach at our Nagar Kirtan saying that Jesus is the only way and tjay. When we allow groups like Naamdharis to sneek their kirtan into our Gurdwarae/Nagar Kirtan or Akhand Jaaps (as they did on 1 May 05 in Hounslow) we show a lack of principles. Anything goes. In my eyes Naamdharis, Radhasoamis and Nirankaris are anti panthic groups just as the Ram Rais and Dhir Malia were.

Re: PANTHIC ALERT: Bhangra & Namdhari in Nagar Kirtan

Amar Singh · 05 May 2005

Those are your eyes, not the eyes of the Panth (i.e. Akal Thakt) or the Punj Pyare...

Re: PANTHIC ALERT: Bhangra & Namdhari in Nagar Kirtan

Bored Boy · 05 May 2005

Akal Takht say I can eat meat, but that doesn't mean I believe it's right. I follow Gurmat, which I feel is logical. I follow my shabad Guru, like millions of other fellow Sikhs.

Re: PANTHIC ALERT: Bhangra & Namdhari in Nagar Kirtan

Khalsa_Force · 11 May 2005

Sangat Jio, I jst wanted to ask if BHANGRA and dancing etc is allowed to Amritdhari sikhs?? ( 2nd case is on vulgar songs). whts answer in both cases?

Re: PANTHIC ALERT: Bhangra & Namdhari in Nagar Kirtan

Manvir Singh · 11 May 2005

There is nothing wrong with Bhangra in itself. However by doing Bhangra you will not get any closer to Vaheguru. (As some Hindu sects believe). Bhangra or dancing is not part of Sikh Dharam. Just as Yoga is not part of Sikh Dharam. However doing yoga for exercise and health is okay. If you say Bhangra is part of Sikhi or that we can join it to religion -- this is false. However, Bhangra in itself is fine. Unfortunately, Bhangra is nowadays linked to vulgar songs. There is nothing with songs whose lyrics are clean and modest. bhul chuk maaf daas, Manvir Singh

Re: PANTHIC ALERT: Bhangra & Namdhari in Nagar Kirtan

Khalsa_Force · 12 May 2005

Thanks Khalsa Ji

Re: PANTHIC ALERT: Bhangra & Namdhari in Nagar Kirtan

A Singh · 13 May 2005

Dear Bored Boy, So, we can "choose" to use OUR "logic" when WE feel like it against the Akal Thakt, but when someone questions the Khalistani Hukamnama or the Table & Chairs Hukamnama, then it's "oh no you're being anti-panthic". Make your minds up.

Re: PANTHIC ALERT: Bhangra & Namdhari in Nagar Kirtan

DUNNO · 13 May 2005

amrithdairs shoudl not lsiten to bhangra or dance , these are not the actions of a gurmukh, look at all the people of high avasta saints etc... have you ever heard of any of these participating in such actions ??? dancing is manmat not gurmat and listening to any music other than gurbani is pointless and a waste of life .

Re: PANTHIC ALERT: Bhangra & Namdhari in Nagar Kirtan

Bored Boy · 13 May 2005

Naamdharis are anti panthic, just like sitting on a dinning table and eating langer. It's logical and it makes sense. Khalistan is a personal opinion. You are either up for it or not. You don't need the Akal Takht to tell you these things. Just use your logic and commen sense (GURMAT). Using the title "Jo Bhole So Nihal" for a non-dharmic film is anti-panthic even though the Akal Takht think it's ok. GURMAT goes above the Akal Takht Hukunamas of today, it helps you make your daily decisions. Try it. ----------------------------------------------------------- Re: PANTHIC ALERT: Bhangra & Namdhari in Nagar Kirtan Author: A Singh Date: 05-13-05 02:48 Dear Bored Boy, So, we can "choose" to use OUR "logic" when WE feel like it against the Akal Thakt, but when someone questions the Khalistani Hukamnama or the Table & Chairs Hukamnama, then it's "oh no you're being anti-panthic". Make your minds up.

Re: PANTHIC ALERT: Bhangra & Namdhari in Nagar Kirtan

A Singh · 13 May 2005

Dear Bored Boy, I find it strange that you suggested the following: "Just use your logic and commen sense (GURMAT)" How exactly have you arrived that the conclusion that one's "Logic", moreover "common sense" is equivalent to "Gurmat". If that was the case, then everyone would have Gurmat, which I trust you agree is a lot more than common sense. As per trying it, I have no problem with exercising Gurmat, particularly when it comes to those who feel singing celestial Gurbani to tunes such as jingle bells, GT road te and other such nonsense as being acceptable because "it's the words that matter, and we're showing our love for Guru Jee" Shame that those who make big announcements about 'supporting' the Akal Thakt actually do not live up to the claim that is touted around. Gur Fateh!

Re: PANTHIC ALERT: Bhangra & Namdhari in Nagar Kirtan

Dogma · 13 May 2005

A singh Jee.. from bored boy's post I thought he was saying that we should our common sense which should be ROOTED within Gurmat. ..i dunno, just what I interpreted...