Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

brahym gyani aap parmeshar

brahym gyani aap parmeshar

harpreet · 01 May 2005

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh What is the sangats views on the intepretation of the tuk 'brahym gyani aap parmeshar'? I have noticed that people look at it in different ways and i wanted to make an educated decision on how I look at it. Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh

Re: brahym gyani aap parmeshar

Jarnail Singh Gyani Arshi · 02 May 2005

The One and ONLY BRAHMGIANI is AAP PARMESHAR HIMSELF...this word is specifically used for our GURU SAHIBAANS and now refers to GURU GRANTH JI...simply because NO LIVING HUMAN can attain the HEIGHTS mentioned...in the Sukhmani sahib Ashtpadees on Brahmgianis. THROUGHOUT SIKH HISTORY....NO ONE is called or referred to as BRAHMGIANI.....from 1930's onwards this title EXPLODED....and today we have more "BG" than Sikhs.. Take care...you dont follow the wrong one...because the RIGHT ONE is GURU GRANTH JI.

Re: brahym gyani aap parmeshar

too much ego for me · 02 May 2005

brahm giyani is god him self... what else to discuss? when the person whose achived supreme divine -glory gets merged with akaal purakh then he is god him self. it is the person with braham giyaan- not every 1 has braham giyaan!

Re: brahym gyani aap parmeshar

Sikh · 02 May 2005

Jarnail Singh Ji, why do u not place SAHIB after GURU GRANTH SAHIB JI? INSTEAD OF JUST GURU GRANTH JI?

Re: brahym gyani aap parmeshar

Jarnail Singh Gyani Arshi · 02 May 2005

OK veer "Sikh" Ji. My apologies. NO WORD can convey the Greatness of Guru Granth Sahib JI.....still SAHIB is beteer than none. Thanks for your advice. Sincerest apologies to you and to GURU JI.

Re: brahym gyani aap parmeshar

Dogma · 02 May 2005

Although I respect Jarnail Singh's position, I think that a brahmgyani is "comparable" to Akal Purakh. I don't think an actual Brahmgyani will go around portraying himself/herself as equal to Akal Purakh though. My reason for thinking like this is that there is many times in Gurbani when Guru Sahib says that God and His TRUE devotees are so much like God that there is no difference between them. Har Harjun doee ek hai, bib bichaar kich nahi.. However, I suggest you hear the suggestions of Jarnail Singh and others who contrast my thoughts to get both sides of the coin.

Re: brahym gyani aap parmeshar

Akali Gupt Fauj · 03 May 2005

Only Guru Mahraj Ji and Akaal are brahmgianis. No one else. No sant or mahant or tant or jant. Brahmgiani is someone who knows everything. I don't see anyone who knows everything and is perfect except Guru Ji and Akaal.

Re: brahym gyani aap parmeshar

Question Bhai · 03 May 2005

"Brahym Gyani" translated means "one who has knowledge of Brahma ( i.e. God )" It is pointless to say that "God" is "one who has knowledge of Brahma ( i.e. God )" Brahym Gyani therefore is any person who achieves further than Karam, Dharam, Gian and Saram Khands.

Re: brahym gyani aap parmeshar

Akali Gupt Fauj · 03 May 2005

Brahm comes from the brahmand, the whole creation. Brahmgiani is thus someone who has knowledge of the whole creation.

Re: brahym gyani aap parmeshar

khalistani · 03 May 2005

yoooooo WTH IS THIS i dont give 2 cents about our petty fights, and our arguments, but dont mess with guru jes banee dont change its aarths to suit ure own manmath sooraj kiran milai jal ka jal hoaa raam har harjan due aik hai bib beechar kacchh nahe i dont kno y these STUPID debates keep popoin off, not tot he person who started this topic, but by some people who posted i aint no santhia master nor do i claim to be im just learnin but guru jes taught me enough to know tha dont mean guru is vaheguru it cud mean in one perspective u cud say guru je is the ultiamte brahm giani ok fine ure choice butttttt all aarths of banee r true banee can haveMORE than 1 aarth dont say the other is wrong a brahm giani in some peopels mind can be guru je i guess that can make sence but that dont mean a person cannot becme to thelevel of god thas how amazing god is he takes u to his own level sooraj kiran milai jal ka jal hoaa raam just like the rays of light blend just likme water blends into one so does vaheguru jes daas and vaheguru there is no diffe4rence har harjan due aik hai bib beechar kacch nahe vaheguru and vahegurus slaves are one, there is no difference, THERE IS NO ARUGMENT OR DISCUSSION ON THIS THIS IS THE TRUTH u cannot deny it or twist it around man if guru je wanted me to post banee thuks suppoorting how guruu je, vaheguru, sants are all one power then i wud be herre for days many times bhagats say by sayung thu thu, i have become U so many places brahm giani is someone who has complelte knowledge of brahm, someone who has blended into akaaal this means once u blend in, u ARE AKAAAL no difference i dont kno when people will relaize this bhula chuka maf

Re: brahym gyani aap parmeshar

khalistani · 03 May 2005

btw, please put nanak brahm giani aap paremesuar bhula chuka maf

Re: brahym gyani aap parmeshar

singh · 03 May 2005

>this means once u blend in, u ARE AKAAAL no difference< Im confused how can someone be akaal. I believe in brahm gyanis but how can ther be no difference in them and akaal. Why not just start worshipping every brahm gyani that we know of (the very few that ther are) if he is akal.

Re: brahym gyani aap parmeshar

khalistani · 03 May 2005

because its still vaheguru je who brings them to that level he creates them even if there is no difference like water he is stillt he creator of the brahm giani bhula chuka maf

Re: brahym gyani aap parmeshar

Jarnail Singh Gyani Arshi · 03 May 2005

Waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh. singh jio, ONLY "AKAAL" is "AKAAL".... a drop of water can make it to the Ocean BUT that "drop" CANNOT be the OCEAN..... same problem with the jal ka jal hooa raam ? is there a "difference" between the different waters...the "water" in my body, in your body, in the jhelum, in the mississippi, in the fields at Kartarpur, in the fields of Ontario, the water in the Indian ocean and the one in the atlantic.... Bani qouted by Khalsiatani veer is confusing the issue...this just means everything is from Akaal and GOES back into Akaal...it DOES NOT "PROVE" that WATER in Mississippi is of a HIGHER LEVEL ( BG) than say the water in the village POND Chhapparr of Orrissa Village...I agree AKAAL is in EVERYONE and EVERYTHING..me, you, the village dog....but one human a Brahmgiani and the other just a ??? makes no sense..a human is a human. Period. A HUMAN's SEWA BIRTHEE JAAN..says Guru Ji..meaning ONLY SEWA of the SHABAD can achieve Muktee/Sach khand..and the Shabad Guru is Brahmgiani Guru Granth Ji sahib. Then another Tuk always quoted is Gur-Parmeshar EKO Jaan....this DOESNT MEAN that GURU and Parmeshar = 2 people who are to be known as ONE=SAME. The TUK actually means....GURPARMESHAR...EKO....JAAN....Know ye that GURPARMESHAR is ONE....the Central theme of the entire GURU GRANTH JI SAHIB....that AKAALPURAKH is ONE and not many. Sometimes we hear..Patee Parmeshar..is any Patee automatically PARMESHAR ?? or are parmeshar and Patee the SAME person ?? Of course NOT...a criminal patee cannot be parmeshar..this is just a saying ametaphor. All of us have ehard the Tuk..Waho waho Guru Gobind Singh aape gur chela..does the word AAPE here means GUR and Chela are two different people? BOTH are GURU GOBIND SINGH.....Same Application of "AAP" in Bragmgiani AAP Parmeshar.... Guru Ji EMPHASISING that ONLY the PAREMESHAR HIMSELF IS BRAHMGIANI....the TWO are NOT separate entetities..one is definitely not a human being.... so NO HUMAN ever can be a BG. All opinions on aarths are mine and open to correction....i am also learning..folks..so dont take my writing as soemthign it is not.

Re: brahym gyani aap parmeshar

cybersingh · 04 May 2005

according to Gurbani; BHULAN ANDAR SABH KO ABHUL GUROO KARTAR this means that everyone is subject to faults EXCEPT GURU JI in regards to Nanak Brahm giani aap parmesar... well only Waheguru ji can be parmesar...this is obvious. so you can use the first tuk i mentioned and you can conclude that it means: Says Nanak, the one who has true brahm gian IS Parm-Ishwar. truely, who else could no about God but God himself?

Re: brahym gyani aap parmeshar

khalistani · 04 May 2005

man a sant and vaheguru has no difference i dunt kno y u cant see this SO MAN times in banee it says by saying u u, ive become U u BECOME ONE ONE URE SOUL MERGES INTO AKAAAL LIKE water from a cup poured into the ocean MERGES INTO THE OCEAN MAKING NO DIFFERENCE DO u kno wat no difference means??? HAR HARJAN DUEEEE AIIIIIIIK HAAAAAI BIB BEEEEEECHAR KACHHHH NAHEEEEE no beechars on this man there ONE ONEEEEEE IKKKKKK not 2 not 5 1 bhula chuka maf

Re: brahym gyani aap parmeshar

... · 04 May 2005

waheguru ji kakhalsa waheguru jiki fateh i can't say who is and who is not Bhramgiayni..cuz only Bhramgiyani knows his/herself!:) anyhow as hapreet veer ji has asked us to give our view.... ... for today my view is...a bhramgiyani is him/her self parmershvar.. i'll have to read Sukhmani sahib again to get the meaning for the tuk:D but i thought reading these shabds(and tuks) might help! http://www.sikhitothemax.com/page.asp?ShabadID=355 nd (1353-13, shsik®qI, mÚ 1) ayk krisanN ta sarab dayvaa dayv dayvaa ta aatmah. aatmaN saree baasavdaivas-y jay ko-ee jaanas bhayv. The One Lord is the Divinity of all divinities. He is the Divinity of the soul. (1353-14, shsik®qI, mÚ 1) naanak taa ko daas hai so-ee niranjan dayv. ||4|| Nanak is the slave of that one who knows the Secrets of the soul and the Supreme Lord God. He is the Divine Immaculate Lord Himself. ||4|| (1353-18, shsik®qI, mÚ 5) rahant sang bhagvaan simran naanak labDha-yaN achut tanah. ||1|| Only the meditative remembrance of God remains with us. O Nanak, it brings the blessings of the Saints, the sons of the Imperishable Lord. ||1|| for sure as we all grow inour sprituality(more kammayiye) we will have different perspective and this same tuk will/mght mean something different. [%sig%]

Re: brahym gyani aap parmeshar

singh · 04 May 2005

how do you define "brahm giani say jan bhaey; nanak jin prabh aap karaey" then?

Re: brahym gyani aap parmeshar

avidya · 05 May 2005

Gurfateh Jarnail Singh ji, if no one can acquire brahm gyan (knowledge of God) then what is the goal of Sikhi according to your understanding?

Re: brahym gyani aap parmeshar

singh uk · 05 May 2005

kirtn sohila: iho sanasar bekar susay meh tario bramgiani explain that giani maha gian singh ji arshi ji

Re: brahym gyani aap parmeshar

ssingh · 05 May 2005

Again I address the question to Jarnail Singh and akali gupt fauj - how do you interpret "brahm giani say jan bhaey; nanak jin prabh aap karaey" then?

Re: brahym gyani aap parmeshar

... · 05 May 2005

with guru shaib ji skirpa i read the astpadhi "Braham Gyani Sada Nirlep Jaisey Jal Mahi Kamal Alep" Braham Gyani Sada Nirdokh Jaisey Suru Sarab Kau Sokh Braham Gyani Ka Ihey Gunau Nanak Jiu Paavak Ka Sahajsubhau!1! Braham Gyani Kay Mani Hoi Pragasu Jaisey Dhar Upri Akasu Braham Gyani Kay Mitra Sutra Saman Braham Gyani Kay Nahi Abhimaan Braham Gyani Ooch Te Oocha Mani Apne Hai Sabh Te Neecha Braham Gyani Se Jan Bhaye Nanak Jin Prabhu Aapi Karei----2 Braham Gyani Jisu Karey Prabhu Aap Braham Gyani Ka Bad Partaap i can put more but seriously if ur read them....by ur self woul dbe better if we say that Waheguru Him self is Bhragiyani and that there is no one out in the world could become bhramgiyani then what would be the meaning of these panktis?

Re: brahym gyani aap parmeshar

Jarnail Singh Gyani Arshi · 06 May 2005

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa waheguru Ji ki fateh. This is my final take on the subject. The ULTIMATE BRAHMGIANI.....WAHEGURU HIMSELF as HE is the ONLY oen who has the Ultimate GYAN about HIMSELF.. Our GURU SAHIBAANS ( and now the GURU GRANTH JI SAHIB as the repository of their Shabad Guru Jyot) comes NEXT as the HIGHEST LEVEL of Brahmgian that we can get in Human Form/in human language etc. ALL others brahmgianis/brahmdhianis/brahmins/ just KNOW...have KNOWLEDGE of certain aspects of BRAHM...the WAHEGURU..NO ONE IN HUMAN FORM KNOWS the ENTIRE BRAHMGIAN.... Rememeber even BRAHMA who knew all the Vedas by heart FAILED to achieve ultimate ALL 100% Knowledge or Brahmgian of WAHEGURU....even Brahma could NOT achieve Brahmgiani status Gurbani is telling us by DESCRIBING the "Brahmgiani" qualities that a HUMAN CANNOT attain such status. Everybody who feels a mere HUMAN can be a "brahmgiani" ( ON PAR with GURU SAHIBAANS....and we cannot escape from this becasue GURUS were BRahmgianis...and so whoever callas himself a brahmgiani is CHALLENGING GURU JI ) is welcome to hold on to his/her views. To me this view is seriously FLAWED. PERIOD.

Re: brahym gyani aap parmeshar

ssingh · 06 May 2005

It is only legitimate when one uses bani to frame the discussion, use shabads and directly address the selections rather than ignoring it. otherwise it is indeed merely a humans take, and we already know such views can be seriously flawed. especially those that try to limit and restrict the intellectually ineffable with periods [%sig%]

Re: brahym gyani aap parmeshar

Dogma · 06 May 2005

Jarnail Singh Jee, Please answer ssingh's question he posed to you directly. I have read your final take on the subject but I think it's important for everyone to hear your response or interpretation of the thukh provided by ssingh. "Rememeber even BRAHMA who knew all the Vedas by heart FAILED to achieve ultimate ALL 100% Knowledge or Brahmgian of WAHEGURU....even Brahma could NOT achieve Brahmgiani status" ...Veerji, I was always led to believe that Sikhi puts Gursikhs at a distinct advantage over other dharams as it is the only one that leads people to Sachkhand. Bhai Sahib Kulbir Singh Jee also supports this position as well. Therefore, is it fair to compare Brahma to a devoted Gursikh of Guru Sahib? My point is that if Sikhi takes a person to Sachkhand, the HIGHEST of the HIGH, then how can one even compare Brahma to that of someone who has acheived muktee as they are not even on the same level? "Gurbani is telling us by DESCRIBING the "Brahmgiani" qualities that a HUMAN CANNOT attain such status." ...Why would Guru Sahib tell His Gursikhs what they CANNOT be? This point confuses me jeeo (?) Please answer back quickly, I think the sangat would appreciate your response veerji.. Waheguru Jee Ka Khalsa Waheguru Jee Kee Fateh!

Re: brahym gyani aap parmeshar

... · 06 May 2005

"Braham Gyani Ka Ihey Gunau Nanak Jiu Paavak Ka Sahajsubhau!1!" explain this jio... can Brahm gyiani(as we say is only Waheguru) do a Guna(do something thz wrong)? all the qulitiesz that are described of bhram gyiyani....are of a person who is livin in a human form.... we know that Waheguru ji never takes birth etc...so how can we say that Akal purakh waheguru is the only one who has the bhramgiyan... also read what they have written ( "avidya" and "singh from uk") ________________ but now i have a question if someone could answer it for me:( There is no difference between God and our soul ...is there? umm i was reading "bhagvat gitaa" jus some parts of it to know what my other people think and believe (ofcoruse traslation and not the real sanskrit, would be wonderful if i could). anyhow in that Krishn says that the highest place in this world for a soul to reach is God(Him) and become his servents or devotie... did Guru sahib ji say that to us; his sikhs? i dont really know much ....jus what ever i know is with Guru sahib jis kirpa! so do we actually merge with Waheguru (if we are jevvan mukt) after this body is done with or do we Go to his dargah? its the mergin with WAHEGURU, being one with Him, that Guru sahib ji tells us the Ultimate goal is right or is it that we jus become his servent adn never become one? or am i jus askin a wrong question?(it could be that my question itself is wrong...so plz help if u can) i guess then we can talk about if its a Human, person, that Guru sahib ji is talking about that can become Bhramgiyani....or he is jus describing the qualities of Akal purakh? this is interesting, because our Guru sahib ji talks about jiivvan mukht(i), where as most of the religions talk about people being mukat only after they are dead!(something to think about dont u think?) or is this jus my dillusion?lol that u can never be mukat while livinnn...bhrama and other devtays... are they ever mukat? they want this human body don't they? but why??? hmmmm...lets see i dont know!!!(sorry for being sarchastic at the end of this post...:( ) bhul chuk muaff karni

Re: brahym gyani aap parmeshar

Jarnail Singh Gyani Arshi · 07 May 2005

Waheguru Ji ka khalsa Waheguru Ji ki fateh. To all those who beleive every "sant" out there is a Brahmgiani...and Sukhmani Sahib proves it.... Guur Gobind Singh ji says: KHALSA mera ROOP hai KHAAS, KHALSA mehn hoon karon NIWAAS Does this mean EVERY "KHALSA" out there is GURU GOBIND SINGH JI ?? Just as Brahmgiani is AAP PARMESHAR..a KHALSA is GURU GOBIND SINGH JI. Possible..YES..in the MILLIONS ?? NO...the REALITY of MILLIONS of Brahmgianis/Sants/Sadhs....is FALSE..and this GURBANI cannot be used to back them up. Guur Gobind Singh Ji is SAYING EXACTLY what GURU ARJUN JI is saying in the SADH/SANT/BRAHMGIANI/PANDIT etc Pankatees.. ALL these "positions" are the ULTIMATE PEAK ....

Re: brahym gyani aap parmeshar

ssingh · 07 May 2005

it has been admitted that it is possible, yet very rare - another reality that bani already alerts us to many times (please do search using, for example, "ivrly" on sikhitothemax.com) A reversal from the earler "seriously flawed view" that "Gurbani is telling us by DESCRIBING the "Brahmgiani" qualities that a HUMAN CANNOT attain such status" THe acknowledgement of this possibility by one man is unimportant. However, the act of denying this possibility, essentially refuting gurbani, in order to advance a seemingly more significant argument/view needs to be highlighted and noted. The message that people follow false spiritual guides is familiar, however, add that ardent, well-meaning spokesmen of this message engage in falsification. [%sig%]

Re: brahym gyani aap parmeshar

* · 08 May 2005

iehu sMswru ibkwru sMsy mih qirE bRhm igAwnI ] eihu sa(n)saar bikaar sa(n)sae mehi thariou breham giaanee || This world is engrossed in corruption and cynicism. Only those who know God are saved. ijsih jgwie pIAwvY iehu rsu AkQ kQw iqin jwnI ]2] jisehi jagaae peeaavai eihu ras akathh kathhaa thin jaanee ||2|| Only those who are awakened by the Lord to drink in this Sublime Essence, come to know the Unspoken Speech of the Lord. ||2||

Re: brahym gyani aap parmeshar

Manjit kaur Sidhu · 08 May 2005

just a personal take....imho "too much" is being read into the message by ssingh ji. the "ultimate Brahmgiani....WAHEGURU"...SECOND come the "human Brahmgianis..THE TEN GURU SAHIBAANS and the BHAGAT JIS in GURU GRANTH SAHIB JI MAHARAJ....and NOW FINALLY their JYOT in collective form in the GURU GRANTH SAHIB JI MAHARAJ JUGO JUG ATTALL...: THIS is the MESSAGE on this BOARD all along.....and imho it REMAINS this...at least that is what i "read"...NOT the so called "admission" that ssingh ji "reads"....isnt this a case of Saon da annah hara hee disda eh. To reiterate THERE ARE NO HUMAN BRAHMGIANIS/GURUS/SATGURUS/SADHUS/whatever...OUTSIDE GURU GRANTH SAHIB JI MAHARAJ. The One in a million/million miniscule gintee of "human brahmgiani" has already been FULFILLED by the coming here in HUMAN FORM by the GURU SAHIBAANS and the Bhagats whose GURBANI is with us. ANYONE else who has NOT written any GURBANI...fails this test. I was just reading the later part of Guru Granth Sahib Ji..and the WORD GUR-GURU is used by GURU JI to describe what is a "brahmgiani" in other places....NO wonder that many DEHDHAREE GURUS-GURS-SATGURS....also find consolation in these Panktees that GURU JI is ENDORSING their Claims to being those GUR-GURU-SATGUR...just like the myriads of so called Brahmgianis all around us point to Gurbani as the PROOF of their brahmgian. sorry to disappoint ssingh jis and others...no more HUman GURUS as well and no Gurs, or Satgurs either.... MK

Re: brahym gyani aap parmeshar

P Singh · 08 May 2005

Brahmgyani is one who isn't caught up in any duality, Brahmgyani has united with its own essence and is one with all there is.

Re: brahym gyani aap parmeshar

khalistani · 08 May 2005

a true khalsa is guru gobind singh jes roop a TRUE KHALSA thas not just taking amrit and chillin very hard thing to become bhula chuka maf

Re: brahym gyani aap parmeshar

ssingh · 09 May 2005

: "THERE ARE NO HUMAN BRAHMGIANIS" You are "prabh" then? If God so pleases that ramanand ji, the bhats, even bhai mardana ji (whose "shortcomings" are described, and did not become the second guru) had bani included and therefore are "brahm gianis" according to your criteria why could not a Sikh be made so. "brahm giani say jan bhaey; nanak jin prabh aap karaey" You're self-set limitation is merely a delusion. As for concluding with the assumption that the truth has dissapointed, it only reveals that the effort is not a search for reality (there is no gurbani mentioned), but a crack at someone or another. [%sig%]

Re: brahym gyani aap parmeshar

Princess · 09 May 2005

Author: cybersingh Date: 05-04-05 00:22 according to Gurbani; BHULAN ANDAR SABH KO ABHUL GUROO KARTAR this means that everyone is subject to faults EXCEPT GURU JI //////////////////////////////////////////// and Vaheguru jee. In above punkiti 'Guru' means Guru Sahib jee and 'kartar' means Vaheguru.

Re: brahym gyani aap parmeshar

Manjit kaur Sidhu · 10 May 2005

dear Princess ji, and that is bottom line answer as to why no human is a brahmgiani equal to Guru Ji/Waheguru Ji. This question is settled.....Brahmgiani AAP PARMESHAR is WAHEGURU/GURU JI.

Re: brahym gyani aap parmeshar

ssingh0 · 10 May 2005

this has become really ridiculous. Can you directly respond to these questions, because if you continue conjecturing, you're evading gurbani, and implying that you're veechar are more significant. "man sacha mukh sach soay" ("avar na pekhay ekas bin koay, nanak eh lachan brahm giani hoay". Does Waheguru have a man and mukh? No - "barn chihan nahi mukh na maasara" (~746) let's leave it specifically at that, as I doubt this will be answered as the previous never was. [%sig%]

Re: brahym gyani aap parmeshar

khalistani · 10 May 2005

in sukhmanee sahib it alsos ays only the one who god makes a brahm giani become a brahm giani so then how can god be a brahm giani? i dont know tomuch to say trufthfully but banee can teach u everything sure, u can call guru je a brahm giani if u want but that doesnt mean a brahm gianis isnt a human also and like is aid, abhull guru kartaar, one u become that level, u become guru kartaaar u become one with vaheguru THERE IS NO DIFFFFERENCEEEE har HARJAN DUE AIK HAI bib beechar kacch nahe end of discusiion y the heck is beechar going on about this THERE ONE thers a shaabd that says by saying u u u, i have BECOME U har harjandue aik hai remeber this but vaheguru is the ulltiamte power cause hes the one who BRINGS THE BRAHM GIANI to that level HE MAKES THE BRAHM GIANI HE MAKES THE SANT thas y vaheguru je the greatest he himself has no beginning or end but vaheguru je takes people and brings them t him and makes them one with him there becomes no difference between akaal and his true bhagaths banee is crystal clear on this i dont kno y these debates always arise bhula chuka maf

Re: brahym gyani aap parmeshar

Dogma · 10 May 2005

"let's leave it specifically at that, as I doubt this will be answered as the previous never was" ssingh jee, you have very strong an logical arguements. I honestly hope that your questions will be answered. Simply for the sake of knowledge and discussion. Anyone? Waheguru Jee Ka Khalsa Waheguru Jee Kee Fateh!

Re: brahym gyani aap parmeshar

Manjit kaur Sidhu · 10 May 2005

Haar harjan EK HAI.... Gurbani is simply saying..the TRUTH...See also...Khalak Khalak Main....Khalak mein Khalak..meaning WAHEGURU is IN the KHALAK ( HUMANITY) and HUMANITY is IN WAHEGURU. Does this emean every Tom Dick and Harry is WAHEGURU ?? In a way YES but NOT in the Way that every "brahmgiani" who is called such or calls himslef..is WAHEGURU...and quote Brahmgiani aap parmeshar to prove it. In that case every Tom dick and harry can quote the Khalak Khalk panktee and prove he is WAHEGURU. Just READ JAPJI SAHIB.... our Most SUPREME BRAHMGIANI/GURU/SATGURU/ if there can be one...is TELLING US..that ONLY WAHEGURU ALONE KNOWS...the time, the date, the day, the year this WORLD was BEGUN..NO ONE ELSE KNOWS THIS....and there are many many many more SUCH EXAMPLES.... GURU JI also doesnt claim to Have "ALL the BRAHMGIAN" ....This is end of STORY folks..... ONLY WAHEGURU Has complete BRAHMGIAN...and ONLY HE is the supreme Brahmgiani...and those that came CLOSE to that are our GURU JI SAHIBAANS...and NOW ONLY GURU GRANTH SAHIB JEE MAHARAJ....no more...NONE. ALL the BRAHMGIAN you ever want or can take it is IN the GURU GRANTH JI SAHIB MAHARAJ JEE...with a VAST OCEAN before YOU, who wants to swim in a TEA CUP ??...those "human brahmgiani" followers !!! lols...i am not in that league..I prefer to sink deep into the OCEAN of BRAHMGIAN that i ahve Parkash at my humble home..and leave the Tea Cups to the Chah Wallahs. Mk

Re: brahym gyani aap parmeshar

khalistani · 11 May 2005

the thuk u posted has nothing to do with this that saying vaheguru je is IN U we have to find him har harjan due aik hai says THEY ARE ONE AND SAME i can give nough shabads the brahm giani asthpadi in sukhmanee sahib refers not to guru je but to singhs who have been madde brahm giani by guru je sukhmanee sahib clearly states that a brahm giani is made by god only by gods kirpa u become brahm giani this sint a thing that shud even be debated banee is crystal clear in this when banee says by saying u u u, i hAVE BECOME U tha is literall u become vaheguru je one and same no difference people dont see sants, guru je, vaheguru je, all one perhaps were all blind like me, cant see wats going on even in banee bhagat namdev je is called a sant people say they follow guru granth sahib je but have no idea what guru je is telling us i know a singh who has taken hukamnama on this he needed help, he was gettin messed him and the whole shabad was about vahegurus slaves, and sants, and how about their praises and telling the singht o go to them i agree we shud watch our for the fake diamonds but these days people are so full of bharam we cannot see a true diamind right in front of our face bhula chuka maf

Re: brahym gyani aap parmeshar

... · 11 May 2005

Waheguru ji kakhalsa waheguru jiki fateh!!! harpreet veer ji plz now tell us what ur take was on this tuk!:) i been waitin for u to post jio or are u still gona wait untill everyone hit walls( metphor)

Re: brahym gyani aap parmeshar

Harpreet · 11 May 2005

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh Haha sorry for not responding but I was reading the posts on this thread frequently and with a lot of interest. I cannot honestly say I have made a real opinion because their does seem to be valid arguments on both sides. But one thing I know for sure their are those in this worldy body who are at a higher avastha than normal people, and if they have merged with Waheguru and the drop of water has merged with the ocean than how can you not call this person a Brahm Gyani? They have achieved the ultimate goal and we should try to stay in the company of the few that are left. Glorifying sants and brahm gyanis can be a problem because how can you ever really be sure. Like Baba Ranjit Singh is doing great things for the panth but I doubt 'Sant' Ranjit Singh is a sant (I could be wrong) and the title sant has just been abused too many times that its getting rediclous. Calling all these fakes out their 'Sants' and 'Brahm Gyanis' has to be wrong. Your giving them a title reserved for the greatest of gursikhs who have merged with Akal Purakh. In the time that were in people should be REALLY cautious of who they claim to be a sant or brahm gyani because the title is thrown around more times than Steve Nash throwing up allys to Amare Stoudamire. Steve Nash is usually accurate with his passes, the title sant isn't always accuratley given to the right person. Well i went a bit off topic but I would have to say the one part I am having trouble getting past is how can anybody actually be on the exact same level as akaal and be on the same level as our Guru Sahibaan. Isn't there always a difference between us and our Gurus and Akal Purakh. Brahm Gyanis or Sants should know everything but than why do we still have debates over ragmala, keski, meat and a lot of other things. That is one thing that just doesnt add up for me. Bhai Randhir Singh was obviously a brahm gyani who had merged with akal purakh, but if he believed ragmala wasnt bani and than another Brahm Gyani believes it was, than whos right? Brahm Gyani aap parmeshar, so shouldnt they know the answer to all these questions? But Khalistani's points are very good, saying how bani says many times over you merge with waheguru and become him, but than a brahm gyani should kno everything, so why do people still have conflicting views over things like ragmala etc. I think its been a good debate so far and hopefully will continue a bit longer. Nothing nasty has happened and admin didnt have to close it because it got out of control like other debates were people just start acting stupid. Thanks to everyone for spending their time trying to answer my question to the best of their ability. Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ke Fateh

Re: brahym gyani aap parmeshar

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 12 May 2005

Khalistani veer writes: even in banee bhagat namdev je is called a sant...<<< YES YOU ARE RIGHT 110%...Bhagat Kabir Ji is also called a SANT....GURU NANAK JI is also called a SANT/SATGUR....and so are many others... BUT.....BUT... ALL these are in the SHIROMANI SANT....SRI GURU GRANTH SAHIB JEE MAHARAJ...so when we BOW our heads to GURU JI GRANTH SAHIB JEE we BOW our heads to ALL the Sants/Satgurs/Brahmgianis/Gurus...INSIDE SHABAD GURU. A lot of GURMUKS/BHAI/MAI/BHAGAT are also mentioned... BUT quote GURBANI TUK..about ANY OTHER "SANT'/BRAHMGIANI/SATGUR/GURU.....OUTSIDE of GURU GRANTH SAHIB JEE..and who Didnt write any GURBANI. Quote any SIKH TEXT....any SIKH GRANTHS..anything.....that mentions any SANT/BRAHMGIANI/SATGUR/GURU....GURU KAAL/POST GURU KAAL...Baba banda Singh bahadur Kaal...Sikh Misl Kaal...Maharaja ranjit Singh Ji kaal...British Period....until..1930's....then from ONE SANT...the BHAKRA DAM of SANTS BURSTS....and we see sants and Brahmgianis floating all over..like pieces of floatsam in a FLOOD... ONLY one BABA "budha Ji"....and then ALL BHAI only...then FOUR BABAS..who gave thir lives on the field of Chamkaur and two in the walls of Sirhind.....then another one BABA called "Deep Singh Ji"....NOT a SINGLE SANT/BRAHMGIANI/SATGUR whatever.... I wonder WHY no SANTS/BRAHMGIANIS during these YEARS..when a SINGH WAS REQUIRED TO GIVE HIS HEAD/get torn from limb to limb/get his scalp removed/get sawed into half/relax on a CHARRKHRREE, get his maaas pulled by hot pincers, get his eyeballs pierced with hot rods...NOT get to RIDE on ELEPHANTS and MERCEDES CARS.... The First "sant" that appears on Sikh History is sant attar singh mastuana in the 1930's...whose PATRONS were the Maharajas of Jind/Nabha/patiala...and who almost ALWAYS rode on an ELEPHANT... just like the "modern sants" who ride in Mercedes cars( talk about going BAREFOOT ).....careful this is not sant bashing just info... "SANT" Niranjan Singh ... the FAMOUS RAAGI.....DROPPED the title of SANT and changed to BHAI...his "following" dropped, his kirtan "LOST RAAS"..and of course his INCOME also dropped drastically..... THATS WHY all the other SANT JIs/BABA JIS/BRAHMGIANIS DONT WANT TO DROP the TITLES. What more PROOF of BRAINWASHING when just the Title of "SANT" makes KIRTAN have MORE RAASS ??? He is the SAME raagi..but now not "sant" but just BHAI in the TRUE GURBANI GURMATT TRADITION. ???? where did the Raass go ??

Re: brahym gyani aap parmeshar

... · 12 May 2005

waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru jiki fateh thanks harpreet veer jio u brought out a great point. its really something to think about!

Re: brahym gyani aap parmeshar

Me · 12 May 2005

I wonder how its possible for someone to have so much hatred towards sants. Hmm.

Re: brahym gyani aap parmeshar

khalistani · 12 May 2005

veer je i am not saying guru granth sahib je is not guru the are our guru je banee guru guru hai banee vich banee amrit saraii i comepletly agree 100 % singh sahib vaaho vaaaho banee nirankar hai i am stupid, but guru jes banee tells u everything kbIr qUM qUM krqw qU hUAw muJ mih rhw n hUM ] kabeer thoo(n) thoo(n) karathaa thoo hooaa mujh mehi rehaa n hoo(n) || Kabeer, repeating, ""You, You"", I have become You. Nothing of me remains in myself by saying u u, we BECOE HIM thas how GREAT vaheguru je is they have NO hankaar there amazing theyll take u tot heir own level bRhm igAwnI bRhm kw byqw ] breham giaanee breham kaa baethaa || The God-conscious being knows God. bRhm igAwnI eyk sMig hyqw ] breham giaanee eaek sa(n)g haethaa || The God-conscious being is in love with the One alone. bRhm igAwnI kY hoie AicMq ] breham giaanee kai hoe achi(n)th || The God-conscious being is carefree. bRhm igAwnI kw inrml mMq ] breham giaanee kaa niramal ma(n)th || Pure are the Teachings of the God-conscious being. bRhm igAwnI ijsu krY pRBu Awip ] breham giaanee jis karai prabh aap || The God-conscious being is made so by God Himself. bRhm igAwnI kw bf prqwp ] breham giaanee kaa badd parathaap || The God-conscious being is gloriously great. bRhm igAwnI kw drsu bfBwgI pweIAY ] breham giaanee kaa dharas baddabhaagee paaeeai || The Darshan, the Blessed Vision of the God-conscious being, is obtained by great good fortune. bRhm igAwnI kau bil bil jweIAY ] breham giaanee ko bal bal jaaeeai || To the God-conscious being, I make my life a sacrifice. bRhm igAwnI kau Kojih mhysur ] breham giaanee ko khojehi mehaesur || The God-conscious being is sought by the great god Shiva. nwnk bRhm igAwnI Awip prmysur ]6] naanak breham giaanee aap paramaesur ||6|| O Nanak, the God-conscious being is Himself the Supreme Lord God. ||6|| only he is a brahm giani who is made by vaheguru jehimself gauVI mhlw 5 ] gourree mehalaa 5 || Gauree, Fifth Mehl: hau qw kY bilhwrI ] ho thaa kai balihaaree || I am a sacrifice to those jw kY kyvl nwmu ADwrI ]1] rhwau ] jaa kai kaeval naam adhhaaree ||1|| rehaao || who take the Support of the Naam. ||1||Pause|| mihmw qw kI kyqk gnIAY jn pwrbRhm rMig rwqy ] mehimaa thaa kee kaethak ganeeai jan paarabreham ra(n)g raathae || How can I recount the praises of those humble beings who are attuned to the Love of the Supreme Lord God? sUK shj Awnµd iqnw sMig aun smsir Avr n dwqy ]1] sookh sehaj aana(n)dh thinaa sa(n)g oun samasar avar n dhaathae ||1|| Peace, intuitive poise and bliss are with them. There are no other givers equal to them. ||1|| jgq auDwrx syeI Awey jo jn drs ipAwsw ] jagath oudhhaaran saeee aaeae jo jan dharas piaasaa || They have come to save the world - those humble beings who thirst for His Blessed Vision. aun kI srix prY so qirAw sMqsMig pUrn Awsw ]2] oun kee saran parai so thariaa sa(n)thasa(n)g pooran aasaa ||2|| Those who seek their Sanctuary are carried across; in the Society of the Saints, their hopes are fulfilled. ||2|| qw kY crix prau qw jIvw jn kY sMig inhwlw ] thaa kai charan paro thaa jeevaa jan kai sa(n)g nihaalaa || If I fall at their Feet, then I live; associating with those humble beings, I remain happy. Bgqn kI ryxu hoie mnu myrw hohu pRBU ikrpwlw ]3] bhagathan kee raen hoe man maeraa hohu prabhoo kirapaalaa ||3|| O God, please be merciful to me, that my mind might become the dust of the feet of Your devotees. ||3|| rwju jobnu AvD jo dIsY sBu ikCu jug mih GwitAw ] raaj joban avadhh jo dheesai sabh kishh jug mehi ghaattiaa || Power and authority, youth and age - whatever is seen in this world, all of it shall fade away. nwmu inDwnu sd nvqnu inrmlu iehu nwnk hir Dnu KwitAw ]4]10]131] naam nidhhaan sadh navathan niramal eihu naanak har dhhan khaattiaa ||4||10||131|| The treasure of the Naam, the Name of the Lord, is forever new and immaculate. Nanak has earned this wealth of the Lord. ||4||10||131|| sants have come to help us escape kaljug, to help us beat this fire they have come to save the world y do we despise them so much when vaheguru je sends them? u can call someone baba or bhai, u can call baba buddha je a sant, or baba, but it doesnt change the fact they are a sant ill callbaba je sant buddha je ok.. in banee sometimes guru jes names is only written as nanak sometimes in bhai gurdas jes vaars its only nanak does that mean everyone called guru je only nanak no wat weere doing now is making asssumption and not fillowing banee of course we wud know who sants and brahm gianis are otherwise guru je didnt need to write so much about them if we dont know whot hey are, then how will they save this earth? a sant cannot remainhidden everyone knows this this is even told in sukhmanee shaiub, the true servant of god cannot remain hidden guru je MAKES PEOPLE DO POOOJA, WORSHIP, OF THOSE THAT WORSHIP GURU JE ijn@ nwnku siqguru pUijAw iqn hir pUj krwvw ]2] jinh naanak sathigur poojiaa thin har pooj karaavaa ||2|| Those who worship the True Guru, O Nanak - the Lord causes them to be worshipped in turn. guru je makes those who worship him, in return, hell make people worship that person its all love man a brahm giani knows everything sukmanee sahib is clear on this he knows wat is kaakar, wat is banee, wtc. etc. the reason we have fights is one person might be extremly high avastha and the othermight be a real brahm giani ure choice to see but with bhram in ure mind about banee, weather u belive or not, without ot bhaorasa someone who even gets darshan cannot become brahm giani a brahm giani is without any bharm but pleease please PLEASE DONT turn this into some messe dup debate now anyways respect sants, even do pooja of them nothing wrong BUT guru granth sahib je is GURU THEY MAKE THE BRAHM GIANI SUKHAMNEE SAHIB SAYS THIS os guru je is the greatest of all they MAKE THE BRAHM GIANI they were ALWAYS antarjamee however a brahm giani is not always antarjamee so guru je is the greatest cause even sukhamnee sahib says only he is a brahm giani who god makes so so dont have beef wit sants man listen to ure GURU JE please be careful of fake sants too there thugs, in the bad meaning bhagath kabeer jes banee is famous for talkjing about fake sants like radhaswami these guys are pakhandis no one can take place of guru je NO ONE bhula chuka maf

Re: brahym gyani aap parmeshar

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 12 May 2005

Khalistani veeer writes: be careful of fake sants too there thugs, in the bad meaning bhagath kabeer jes banee is famous for talkjing about fake sants like radhaswami these guys are pakhandis no one can take place of guru je NO ONE Absolutley right again veer. Thats what i beleive in too...just that too much "sant floatsam" floating in a flood..and every sinking man tries to grab a piece of that floatsam..thinking it will save him from drowning....turns out to be false hope as THAT wood is NOT HEAVY ENOUGH to save anyone..Thats all I am trying to say..NOT project "hate" for every piece of floatsam ( even a STONE can get across an ocean IF it is on a HEAVY piece of wood/Boat....BUT IF that stone is placed on an "unworthy" wood, the wood also will sink.. The HEAVIEST and BIGGEST BOAT ever constructed is Shabad Guru GURU JI SRI GURU GRANTH SAHIB JI MAHARAJ,,,capable of saving even the biggest MOUNTAIN....if anyone ( example being "Me" in one message above) wants to exercise his right to grab hold of a TEELA....he is welcome too as the constitution guarantees it.

Re: brahym gyani aap parmeshar

avidya · 13 May 2005

Jarnail Singh, You asked for a Sant who didn't write gurbani, you forget Sant Sadharan named by Guru Amar Das because of his devotion. It is in Mehima Prakash by Sarup Das Bhalla, reprinted by Bhasha Vibhag. Hope this helps.

Re: brahym gyani aap parmeshar

Question Bhai · 13 May 2005

Actually on the topic of Sants -- there are loads of marble tiles in the vicinity of Harmandir Sahib which says, "donated by Sant . . ." Also, in the museum there is a couple of room fulls of galleries of photos of Sants. Surely someone should "clean up" these !!!

Re: brahym gyani aap parmeshar

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 14 May 2005

Avidya jio, There are actually three SADHARANS in Sikh history.....one was a atamgiani sikh of Guru nanak ji sahib, another the sewak of Guru Amardass Ji who built a ladder of wood for the Baoli Sahib and another Sikh of Guru Arjun Ji Sahib who built Guru Ji's House. ALL these were in GURU JI's time and "recgnised" by Guur Ji as His sewaks. MY point if you care to read my mails ...is I am ECHOING Bhagat kabir Ji when he says with Danke dee chot naal.... "Rahio "SANT" me toll, SADH bhuthereh dithheh...and of course the panktees on BENARAS KE THUGG who "look and behave" like SANTS..but are NOT. My POINT is IF BHAGAT KABIR who is a BRAHMGIANI BHAGAT , at the peak of his bhagtee who could write GURBANI at Par of Shabad GURU Standard, finds it so difficult to see any SANTS....well just read the mails...so many YOUTH can see so many SANTS and BRAHMGIANIS all over...how can 10 year olds and 18 years olds who cant even read Gurbani properly be able to "recognsie" so many SANTS and BRAHMGIANIS...not only are they able to do that..BUT they are willing to CONFRONT you and threaten to break your teeth, Knock off your DASTAAR in a GURDWARA, ..just because you "FAIL" to SEE their SANT/BRAHMGIANI in the same light !!!.. TO me it is JUST A BHEEAD CHAAL....one Brahmgiani breeds many others...a sort of NETWORKING....one SANT proliferates into thousands..like amoebas..AND THATS WHY WE HAVE MORE SANTS than GURSIKHS...unlike "sant sadaharan" of Guru Jis' time !!! And in GURU AMARDASS JI's time when a TAPAA, who was also exactly like a BRAHMGIANI and all that Sant stuff. came on..GURU JI EXPOSED HIM as a MAYADHAREE/CHEAT/THUGGH...and EVERY SIKH beleived GURU JI..but NOW try and EXPOSE such a Mayadharee sant brahmgiani/even RAPIST and MOLESTOR..and see/hear the howls of protest from his loyal supporters..SANT KI NINDA...Sri SUKHMANI SAHIB....Man do you want to become a Keerra !!!??? they ask in awe..the Sants know their hold on people..koii birla bani vicharsee..most just follow the lead..to the slaughter( just see a documntary on how they slaughter sheep and cows...a VERY WELL BEHAVED/DOCILE and CALM...bull or ram is TRAINED to LEAD all the others up a RAMP...He leads and all follow....at the last minute..this "SANT" follows one ramp and the gate shuts behind him asap..and all the rest go down another RAMP that leads to the slaughtering machines..This is the JOB of this docile calm ram/bull over and over again....BELIVE it or NOT. This "trick" was just performed live in front of world audience by a famous "**********"...and all his die hard followers are waiting for the answer to the riddle..which he left unanswered... After all this time and research you have come up with one NAME..i can get you a LIST off the WEB that will take you DAYS to DOWNLOAD....and MOST of them Have WEB SITES and overworking SEWADAARS who work tirelessly day and night promoting their own sants and brahmgianis. Has there been SUCH a HUGE LEAP IN SPIRITUALITY..since sant Sadharan Ji's time ?? I think NOT..I think it is bahgat kabeer jis'; time all over again''Rahio SANT me toll SAD bhautereh ditthheh...again Beleive it or NOT.

Re: brahym gyani aap parmeshar

dil · 14 May 2005

VGKK,VJKF; Some where in this topic I came across sant and satguru for guru granth sahib. I differ at this point. Sant and Satguru are different worlds and cannot be used as synonyms. Sant is like attaining a stage, after doing naam simran and blessed with vaheguru ji.s kirpa. It is like attaining a bachelors or masters degree after studying in university. But at this stage he is not authorized impart knowledge or teaching to students. Satguru is specially blesseed by god to impart knowledge to students. Like professors in university. Both may have equal stage. But sant (degree holder) is not authorized to teach university students where as professor (guru) is authorised. So for all sikhs repeat sikhs only, sant kabeer, sant namdev ji, sant ravidas ji are saints and not gurus. where sri guru nanak dev ji to sri guru granth sahibs are gurus and not saints. (So as I think guru is above sant) Where as for kabeer panthis or followers of naam dev and ravidas ji, sants may be considered gurus but not for sikhs. Bhool chook muaf. VGKK,VJKF;

Re: brahym gyani aap parmeshar

? · 14 May 2005

Can someone translate: BidhiaAsheenaGuruKaSeena

Re: brahym gyani aap parmeshar

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 15 May 2005

dear dil jio, to carry your analogy a bit further.. to my three year old pre-school child...her Kindergarten "TEACHER" is the end all and be all..NOBODY in this world can KNOW anything that her "teacher" doesnt know ( it is pointless telling her that the kindergarten teacher is a grade four DROP OUT herself. This is where the "sants" and "brahmgianis" come in....to their "followers" they are everything.. To her friends at school... "DAD" knows absolutley EVERYTHING !!! To a Brahmgiani chela his brahmgiani knows everything...Gian of BRAHM !! thus a "person" can be anything to a certain group.... to KabirPanthis..Bhagat kabir is GURU... to Ravidassis Bhagt ravidass is GURU..to us ONLY their GURBANI is GURU. IT all depends on "how high" one is and how far and wide ones "eyesight" can roam... a person in a ditch can only see the sky right above him and maybe the walls of his ditch...a person on the top of Mount Everest can see the world below him..a person on the moon can see the entire Earth under him...and so on... The TRUTH of the Matter is GURBANI puts us all SO HIGH UP that we can see everything clearly... EACH SIKH is empowered by GURU JI to go as High as He can all by HIMSELF....but a lot of the lazy ones still want to clutch at some holyman's feet/chola/...or even worse still remain in the ditch and be satisfied with a tiny view of the sky..

Re: brahym gyani aap parmeshar

Dogma · 15 May 2005

Jarnail Singh Jee, You contend that 18 year olds are not capable of recognizing who a true sant is. What qualifies you in weeding out the " fake" sants? How is your avastha higher and what qualities do you possess that gives you the ability to recognize a real from a fake? " My POINT is IF BHAGAT KABIR who is a BRAHMGIANI BHAGAT " ...in another post you said that only Waheguru can be a brahmgiani. Now you claim that Bhagat Kabir is a brahmgiani bhagat as well. Which is it? I really hope that you're not changing your ideals from topic to topic just so that they can used as arguments for your philosophy. "And in GURU AMARDASS JI's time when a TAPAA, who was also exactly like a BRAHMGIANI and all that Sant stuff. came on..GURU JI EXPOSED HIM as a MAYADHAREE/CHEAT/THUGGH...and EVERY SIKH beleived GURU JI..but NOW try and EXPOSE such a Mayadharee sant brahmgiani/even RAPIST and MOLESTOR..and see/hear the howls of protest from his loyal supporters" ...That was Guru Sahib teaching his Sikhs. You're not Guru Sahib. I DO believe that you do a great service by making every cautious about who they regard as Sants or not, however your matt is not on the level of Guru Sahib. There is a VERY good chance that you at times MAY be doing Ninda of a Sant. There is a very good change that you may be wrong in some of your ideas of a particular Sant. " Rahio "SANT" me toll, SADH bhuthereh dithheh...and of course the panktees on BENARAS KE THUGG who "look and behave" like SANTS..but are NOT. " ...Veerji, you previously on other threads and on this one claim that Sant refers to Guru Sahib himself. This is your main argument as far as Sri Sukhmani Sahib is concerned as well. Then how can you use this thukh from Gurbani as a means of arguing that not even Bhagat Kabir Jee could recognize a true sant???? From your previous posts you say that the word Sant in Gurbani refers to Guru Sahib so isn't, by your logic, Bhgat Kabir Jee saying that he's looking for a True Guru? I don't understand Veerji, to an idiot like myself it seems your a using different interpretations of Gurbani to suit your arguments. Thanks for continuing the discussion veerji, I thought you took a holiday for awhile. :) Looking forward to your answers. Waheguru Jee Ka Khalsa Waheguru Jee kee Fateh!

Re: brahym gyani aap parmeshar

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 15 May 2005

Waheguru Ji ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji ki Fateh. I find no contradiction in my statements...Bhagat kabir Ji is INSIDE the SHABAD GURU which I have said many times is the Brahmgiani today..Read my maisl carefully..WAHEGURU is the Supreme Brahmgiania becasue ONLY HE KNOWS "everything" that is to be known...second to HIM come our GURU SAHIBAANS..and For TODAY it is SHABAD GURU....SRI GURU GRANTH SAHIB JI MAHARAJ....ALL the Brahmgian anyone cna absorb in this lifetime is IN the Shabad Guru....and ALL inside the Shabad Guru be they Kabir Ji or Ravidaass Ji or Bhatt ji or Sunder Ji...all are at the SAME SHABAD GURU LEVEL put there by GURU JI.....and when I bow my head to GURU JI..I dont "separate" ravidass from Guru nanak Ji or Kabir Ji from Guru Arjun Ji. Rahio Sant me Toll is in the Bhatt Sawiyahs ( sorry my mistake in saying this tuk is by Bhagat kabir Ji).... The Bhattas as we know are writing about the FIVE Guru sahibaans...who are the SANTS and the REST are all THUGGHS. I find it very distressing to say the least that you IMPLY that I think I am on the Level of GURU AMARDASS JI..and have this high avastha to distinguish thuggs from tapass and sants. GURU JI has WRITTEN DOWN his GURBANI as a LESSON to US..HIS SIKHS. By READING and VICHAARING HIS GURBANI we His students can LEARN....that doesnt mean we are also at that high avastha and pretending to be GURU JI. Guru Ji did ntowrite about the Taopaa and his TRICKS jsut as an ENTERTAINMENT PIECE for us to read and enjoy..IT is a Valuable LESSON for us to APPLY in our Daily LIFE and "see" the Tapaas that roam this world even today. I am an Amrtidharee Singh and as far as possible i follow Guru Ji's advise..Jhooth na bole PANDEH...SAACH KAHIYEH... You ask me about my vastha and how i recognise sants?? in the same vein may i know how high your avastha is that you can recognise Sants..maybe I can learn a few pointers from your avastha. You ahve obviously recognised many many SANTS and BRAHMGIANIS....may i know what criteria is used to pass them...the LITMUS TEST ?? Then we can continue thsi discussion. i find it very interesting so far. Yes I was away for a few days attending a Conference. Holidays taan karmaa naal he mildeean hein ji.

Re: brahym gyani aap parmeshar

avidya · 16 May 2005

Gurfateh Yet having said all this, when the discussion arose, you stated that the devotee becomes one with Waheguru without distinction. Is this not brahmgyan? You didn't at the time say, and this is only Guru Sahibaan. Secondly, if Waheguru is the only brahmgyani...what awaits us. If we cannot experientially know Waheguru, then where is waheguru? This is a dualism akin to some forms of Islam that God is unknowable. This means that aatma is a whole alternative category utterly seperate to Waheguru...so please tell me more of your new philosophy because this CERTAINLY is not gurmat!

Re: brahym gyani aap parmeshar

Dogma · 16 May 2005

lol... My avastha? HA! What avastha? I'm nowhere jeeo...As far as me recognizing someone a Sant. I can't. That's why I can't go around saying that Sant A is a fake and Sant B is the real deal. I'm sure there are people who take advantage of the title but I'm not capable of deciding who is the pretender and who is the real deal. I don't call everyone a Sant. Only a few jewels of this Panth who have shown themselves to be as such. Hence lies the difference between us...I can't call someone a fake, because there is no bigger fake than me. You speak of a litmus test. The only litmus test that I know of is Gurmat. Also veerji, earlier in this thread you said regarding Brahmgiani's "Possible..YES..in the MILLIONS ??". ...Are you contradicting this earlier statement you made with your last post? Also, just curious but you also implied a hierarchy of Brahmgian in your last post with Waheguru above all and then Guru Sahib. Can this hierarchy be continued with Sants or does it end with Guru Sahib? If it ends with Guru Sahib...why? waheguru jee ka khalsa waheguru jee kee fateh!

Re: brahym gyani aap parmeshar

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 17 May 2005

Waheguru Ji ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji ki fateh. you are being too modest....about your avastha... i understand..Gursikhi is about humility. To answer your last question...The Sant/Brahmgiani hierachy ENDS with GURU SAHIB....because this SHABAD GURU is there to answer all our questions. With a Light source shining as bright as a billion stars and suns..who needs a candle....anybody "trying to sell me a candle" in broad daylight has to be a fake...but someone "being a candle" is fine with me. Although a candle also produces "light"..the Exact same light as a SUN...there is simply no comparison of a modern day "sant-human" to GURU SAHIB. I am sorry no one can ever convince me to look elsewhere for light other than to GURU JI. A Blind man approached a brahmgiani to find out how he could avoid people KNOCKING into him. The Sant told him to always carry a LIGHTED LAMP with him and thus anyone seeing the light wouldnt knock into him...But you know what..the Blind man was knocked into the very next day...in BROAD DAYLIGHT !!!!...By another BLIND MAN carrying a lighted lamp in his hand Waheguru Ji ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji ki afteh.

Re: brahym gyani aap parmeshar

Dogma · 17 May 2005

"I am sorry no one can ever convince me to look elsewhere for light other than to GURU JI." ...waheguru. Gyani Jee, I have to say this line brought a smile to my face. I agree with you 100% on this. Unfortunately, I don't have the same destiny as you. You realized this probably without the help of any higher avastha, blessed soul. For me, someone had to point me to the direction of Guru Sahib and told me follow Him. As far as the hierarchy is concerned. I was wondering where do you put the likes of Gurmukh pyaaray like Bhai Sahib Bhai Randheer Singh, Bhai Vir Singh Jee, Sant Gurbachan Singh Jee etc. These wrote and spoke extensively on Gurbani and were Sants. Can you acknowledge that the writings and knowledge of these men can be and SHOULD be used by all Sikhs in order to understand Guru Sahib?

Re: brahym gyani aap parmeshar

Harjinder Singh · 17 May 2005

I must say "Very well said" respected Gyani Jarnail Singh "Arshi" Jeo. I am proud of your such a strong belief and affiliation to only Guru Sahib and Guru Khalsa Panth. I strongly believe that If we all SIKHS truly believe that any decision taken by Guru Khalsa Panth(Guru’s physical form) in accordance with the Guru Granth Sahib Jee (Guru Soul Form) to resolve our current/future issues/problems is clear and medatory Order of Guru Nanak Dev Jee/Guru Gobind Singh Jee for all of us, there will not be any divisions, contradictions, or outstanding issues. But hate to say that most of us do not feel Guru Khalsa Panth is actually Guru Sahib himself as actually entrusted by the tenth Nanak Guru Gobind Singh Sahib Jee. Most unfortunately, Most of us are locked with one or the other personalities most of them were of course(no doubt about it) great gursikhs (Candles) who got the light directly from the Guru Sahib (the Sun). Guru Sahib says [gurbani]gurmuK sau kir dosqI siqgur sau lwie icqu[/gurbani] guramukh so kar dhosathee sathigur so laae chith || Make friends with the Gurmukhs, but focus your consciousness on the True Guru Only. But i think most of us today believe and act in fact otherway around in the event of responding to Guru Khalsa Panth Jee and Guru Granth Sahib Jee as compared to a Gursikh we associate with. Guru Sahib Aap hee Kirpa Karkey Apney Khalsey noo Apney bhuley/bhatkey Khalsey Noo ehsaas den Ke Mai kitte challa Nahi giya Ajj vee tuhade vich hee Haa Guru Granth Sahib Dee Hazzoori andir Panj piyarian dey roop vich. Siraf, Vishvash ate mann lain dee hee baat hai, Sarey masley ajj he hal ho sakdey han ate agey noo vee hundey rehangey.

Re: brahym gyani aap parmeshar

Harjinder Singh · 17 May 2005

I must say "Very well said" respected Gyani Jarnail Singh "Arshi" Jeo. I am proud of your such a strong belief and affiliation to only Guru Sahib and Guru Khalsa Panth. I strongly believe that If we all SIKHS truly believe that any decision taken by Guru Khalsa Panth(Guru’s physical form) in accordance with the Guru Granth Sahib Jee (Guru Soul Form) to resolve our current/future issues/problems is clear and medatory Order of Guru Nanak Dev Jee/Guru Gobind Singh Jee for all of us, there will not be any divisions, contradictions, or outstanding issues. But hate to say that most of us do not feel Guru Khalsa Panth is actually Guru Sahib himself as actually entrusted by the tenth Nanak Guru Gobind Singh Sahib Jee. Most unfortunately, Most of us are locked with one or the other personalities most of them were of course(no doubt about it) great gursikhs (Candles) who got the light directly from the Guru Sahib (the Sun) by obeying the hukum of Guru Sahib to their best level. Guru Sahib says [gurbani]gurmuK sau kir dosqI siqgur sau lwie icqu[/gurbani] guramukh so kar dhosathee sathigur so laae chith || Make friends with the Gurmukhs, but focus your consciousness on the True Guru Only. But i think most of us today believe and act in fact otherway around in the event of responding to Guru Khalsa Panth Jee and Guru Granth Sahib Jee as compared to a Gursikh we associate with. Guru Sahib Aap hee Kirpa Karkey Apney Khalsey noo Apney bhuley/bhatkey Khalsey Noo ehsaas den Ke Mai kitte challa Nahi giya Ajj vee tuhade vich hee Haa Guru Granth Sahib Dee Hazzoori andir Panj piyarian dey roop vich. Siraf, Vishvash ate mann lain dee hee baat hai, Sarey masley ajj he hal ho sakdey han ate agey noo vee hundey rehangey. [%sig%]

Re: brahym gyani aap parmeshar

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 17 May 2005

Waheguru Ji ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji ki fateh. Guru swarey Dogma jio, you ask me: As far as the hierarchy is concerned. I was wondering where do you put the likes of Gurmukh pyaaray like Bhai Sahib Bhai Randheer Singh, Bhai Vir Singh Jee, Sant Gurbachan Singh Jee etc. These wrote and spoke extensively on Gurbani and were Sants. Can you acknowledge that the writings and knowledge of these men can be and SHOULD be used by all Sikhs in order to understand Guru Sahib?<<<< Gurbani as quoted above by my Veer Harjinder Singh ji provides the perfect answer. [gurbani]gurmuK sau kir dosqI siqgur sau lwie icqu[/gurbani] Suffice it to say that some of my most "valuable " possessions are books by these Gurmukhs.....and when I am not reading GUrbani....these are the books I turn to.... [%sig%]

Re: brahym gyani aap parmeshar

someone · 30 Dec 2005

BRHAM GYANI AAP NIRANKAAR dhan those have attained brham gyan and may they be an insperation for us [%sig%]